I don't think I know any other groups for which you often have to argue about some SOLO parts, even for the parts without strong bgvs impact or with strong bgvs but clear lead vocal separation
@@lukec2129i’m not saying is 100%, I’m still doubting, but for these video comparing the way Tzu and Jeong sing their other lines in this song for me is more identical to Tzuyu than Jeongyeon, but i’m not sure, for me is 75% and 25% respectively xd
This might be the most confusing line in Twice's line distributions, i had never seen so many people dissagreeing this much. personally i always heard jeongyeon, but idk what to believe in anymore lmao
I cannot hear tzuyu AT ALL, no matter how many times I try to... I didn't even know there was a discussion between people about this, in my opinion it's definitely Jeongyeon
This is so confusing So for some reason I hear it spilt right The first half sounds like Mina and than the second half sounds like Chaeyoung [ Mina ] jjochagagesseo jeo [ Chaeyoung ] kkeutkkaji But if it is a single person, I would have to lean to Tzuyu. The reason is that sometimes Tzuyu can sound more like Mina and Chaeyoung than Jeongyeon But that is just my 2 cents in the discussion, I just wanted to contributed something to see if I can help in some way 😭
Though Jeongyeon can sound like Mina so if it is spilt then it could be Jeongyeon -> Tzuyu I hope I did not make this more confusing 😭. It is just proposing ideas as Jeongyeon’s tone can be similar to Mina and same with Tzuyu to Chaeyoung
I noticed that my last filter still has a vocal from sophiya so I filtered her out and decided to just make a comparison/discussion with you guys. I'm still leaning more towards Tzuyu but if you hear Jeongyeon don't attack me just say it with respect 😅
I think the last -jiii- part is the only part that sounds like Tzuyu, the rest sounds completely like Jeongyeon to me 100%. Funny because I always thought this was Tzuyu's line but now I am more convinced than ever that is Jeonyeon.
I hope they sing this live or just for soundcheck. The opinion is really even so live is the only way to confirm 🤧
I don't think I know any other groups for which you often have to argue about some SOLO parts, even for the parts without strong bgvs impact or with strong bgvs but clear lead vocal separation
Me either, and the fact that it mostly involved JeongTzu
Plot twist: that line is Nayeon 😱😱😱
That would be crazy 😵
When you don’t know which member sing line, always say Nayeon LOL
At 0.5 speed, it only really sounds like Tzuyu
it really doesnt sound like her at all, it sounds more like mina than tzuyu (and its obv not mina), its very clearly jeongyeon’s tone
At 0.5 sounds even more like Jeongyeon imo lol
that mades clearly is Tzuyu, comparing with her other lines the voice sounds more like Tzuyu than Jeongyeon
i disagree, the “-ji” comparison part makes it pretty obvious in my opinion, the line is a lot fuller in tone than tzuyu’s voice
@@lukec2129i’m not saying is 100%,
I’m still doubting, but for these video comparing the way Tzu and Jeong sing their other lines in this song for me is more identical to Tzuyu than Jeongyeon, but i’m not sure, for me is 75% and 25% respectively xd
@@DDP121I agree, I made an analysis too if you’d care to watch
@@DDP121Right, it's the way how she ends her lines here. Very different from the bridge
@@lukec2129actually tzuyu has a full, velvety tone. Jeongyeon is full and loud.
This might be the most confusing line in Twice's line distributions, i had never seen so many people dissagreeing this much. personally i always heard jeongyeon, but idk what to believe in anymore lmao
sounds like jeongyeon to me
tzuyu
in my opinion it’s definitely jeongyeon
Yeah, no worries. I respect it
Sounds like jeongyeon for me
Even if it is Tzuyu, can't hear her voice at all
is jeongyeon my opinion
help i can't hear jeongyeon 😭
Me too 😭
Look at Raven Lam's filter
I cannot hear tzuyu AT ALL, no matter how many times I try to... I didn't even know there was a discussion between people about this, in my opinion it's definitely Jeongyeon
This is so confusing
So for some reason I hear it spilt right
The first half sounds like Mina and than the second half sounds like Chaeyoung
[ Mina ] jjochagagesseo jeo [ Chaeyoung ] kkeutkkaji
But if it is a single person, I would have to lean to Tzuyu. The reason is that sometimes Tzuyu can sound more like Mina and Chaeyoung than Jeongyeon
But that is just my 2 cents in the discussion, I just wanted to contributed something to see if I can help in some way 😭
Though Jeongyeon can sound like Mina so if it is spilt then it could be
Jeongyeon -> Tzuyu
I hope I did not make this more confusing 😭. It is just proposing ideas as Jeongyeon’s tone can be similar to Mina and same with Tzuyu to Chaeyoung
It's jeongyeon the pitch of the line shows exactly how it should sound considering jeongyeon's technique
Still hear Jeongyeon
byeeee i still hear jeongyeon 😭 she's is by bias and idk but i hear her voice
She is my bias too, but I just can't hear her 🤧
well obviously its jeongyeon for sure
Yeah, def Jeongyeon
i look up the lyrics at genius and it's actually jeongyeon who sang that part
@@ciananaiesthough i agree that jeongyeon sings this part, genius is not an official source, it is made by fans
Si, definitivamente ws Jeongyeon
I noticed that my last filter still has a vocal from sophiya so I filtered her out and decided to just make a comparison/discussion with you guys. I'm still leaning more towards Tzuyu but if you hear Jeongyeon don't attack me just say it with respect 😅
I made an analysis and I agree that it’s tzuyu
I just can heard Tzuyu here sorry
Please do Shadow, we need to know if it is Sophia, Dahyun or Chaeyoung.
This is even more confusing 😭
Is it Jeongyeon? Or Tzuyu?
Idk anymore 😩
@@AnDistribution I feel like the only way for this to be solved, is if they sing Bring It Back live 😭
I think the best way is to wait for them to sing this live 😂
And when is that?
I think the last -jiii- part is the only part that sounds like Tzuyu, the rest sounds completely like Jeongyeon to me 100%.
Funny because I always thought this was Tzuyu's line but now I am more convinced than ever that is Jeonyeon.
definitely jeongyeon, especially when you slow it down
It's funny that when you slow it down you hear Jeongyeon and the other comment is when they slow it down they hear Tzuyu 😭
@@AnDistribution haha yeah, i think especially listening to the “쫓아가겠어“ you can definitely hear jeongyeon’s tone
Would you make breakthrough filtered vocal, cus i can't hear any twice member in "say dont give up" and ending part