This one just makes me shake me head in amazement. What are your thoughts about this one? Buy The Warning Music Here: apple.co/3LN55KJ Merch Store: bobcieslinski.myspreadshop.com/ Donation: www.buymeacoffee.com/BobCiesl... Click here for Highfidelity ear protection for concerts and everyday life: bit.ly/highfidelityearplugs Join Channel Membership: bit.ly/BobCieslinskimembership Buy Apple Music Subscription Here: apple.co/3xl0Ey6 Ekster wallets, Bags and Cases: ekster.com?sca_ref=4171993.L0f4OQQsAl Click here to buy Music Gear:bit.ly/SweetwaterMusicStore Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/bobciesli...
Yea Bob, we share the same mind, music happens between the notes, and these ladies certainly have the chops to put it all together. I've been watching them since they were 8,10, and 12. What a fun ride.
Just got QOTMS from their merch store. The production is a bit flat, understandable considering it's an independent album, but it really is stunning musically. Lots of headphone ear candy that you don't get from the live version.
I still maintain that The Warning are one of the best live bands on the planet! They have such an amazing sense of detail while song writing and they put in the work to make sure everything translates to their live performances!
This one is spectacular. In particular, Pau's proficiency with her drumming and singing simultaneously is awe inspiring, live none the less. Especially at the end of the 2nd verse.
There are so many things I love about this particular video: 1. Dany and Pau sharing lead vocals. 2. Ale’s 2-3-Go! 3. During Pau’s interlude she lays her sticks on her snare to maximize her stage presence by her arm articulation. 4. The crowd work. When they are free playing and Dany turns to Pau to resume the click. 5. #NumberlyGarfs 6. The abrupt ending. That doesn’t take into account the driving beat of the song and the remarkable writing and vocals throughout.
Pau sing and drums at the same time since... she play drum. When she was 6 or 7 at the start of her drumming one of her first teacher encourage her to sing and drum because it'll help her to be on time
Well it sure made a difference cause she plays some tough stuff while she’s singing. I think that’s hard but if you’ve been doing it all of your life then it’s to be expected. Thanks!
To do what Pau does, pat your head, rub your stomach, jump up and down on one foot, then belt out a song in tune, on key, in rhythm with everything else you are doing keeping the legato notes from getting broken by your actions. Simple, right? Pau apparently sings while running or doing other exercise to keep up her lung capacity for her singing while drumming. She has talked about her drumming is automatic so she can focus on her singing.
This was the opening song when I saw them. Everyone in the crowd was so pumped and was singing along. When I saw them, Ale was playing through Ampeg, but a few months later at the MTV VMAs, she was playing through Orange. During one of Pau’s Instagram lives, she was asked how she can play and sing at the same time. Her only answer was “practice.” The first video on their channel is a much younger Pau playing a tiny kit and singing along with a Hannah Montana song. It’s just something she’s always done.
Also, there’s a video out there where Pau talks about how she doesn’t have perfect time. Ale, however, does have that natural sense of timing and gives Pau a look whenever those drums go off. Lastly, the look that Dany gives Pau at 7:19 is telling her to turn the click back on. Pau controls it on her laptop that’s next to her, and it was turned off for the audience participation section.
Oh, and I don’t know if The Warning has said they deliberately put in audience participation parts in their songs, but I know BAND-MAID has said they do. That’s the tour I want!
These fascinating ladies take you through a fantastic, beautiful musical and lyrical rollercoaster that amazes me every time. Saw them live about 3 weeks ago in Tijuana and as expected, they blew my head off as well as melted my face. DPA forever!
I know that the band feels bad if one of them is sick or if they are tired and feel as if they haven’t given the best of shows for their audience. There are always going to be gigs like that. All you can do is try your best. I was at the London show which was the last show of their European tour and I know that they were tired. They put on an amazing performance nonetheless and everyone in the crowd went home satisfied. Definitely one of the best shows that I’ve been to.
At the Pepsi Center all of them were a little under the weather but Pau still made the audience cry when she did Black Holes and went on to Breathe. Especially when she started crying at the end.
Nice reaction Bob, as always. Just got my ticket for The Warning concert in Paris, France on April 2024 (Europe tour : 19 concerts in 25 days all over Europe). I'm so excited. Can't wait... Greetings from France, Gilles 🤘🟦⬜🟥😉
Yes, Bob. Their live shows really are something. The energy in the room is off the charts. Recently they have been STARTING their live shows with this song. What a great way to get the crowd ampped up and engaged, eh? So glad you have found a similar attraction to this music that many of us old (and young) rocker fans have embraced.
Hey Bob, I love this song because you get lead vocals from all 3, Dany and Pau on co-lead, and the "2,3, Go!" is Ale's line. And , yes, that killer bass intro, and 1 of my favorite drum fills. Pau is very good at singing while drumming, there are a bunch of songs where she sings lead on the entire song. As for her stamina, she practices singing while running. To hear a song with Pau singing lead, try "Dust To Dust", "Narcisista"(1 of their 2 Spanish language songs), "23", or "Revenant". All were played at this same Teatro Metropolitan 2022 concert.
Exactly right - The Warning is the best rock band when it comes to the chanty sing-a-long bits, which are featured in many of their songs. It's arena rock at its best. Great analysis!
Fun to see how much Pau is pumped - you can clearly see it when she's pumping her chair (at the end of the audience involvement section) when Ale plays the 2 notes that restart the music - DOING DOING and here we go!
Nice reaction! Since I saw the intro of Disciple live, I understood Lzzy Hale when she said, after touring with them, The Warning attack the audience like no other younger rock band! 0 to 100 in 1 second... Can't wait to see them live again in April 2024, on their 2nd huge Euro tour! 👍🤘
The song begins so strongly, when I first heard it I wasn't sure I liked it because of how it slows down, before speeding up again. Of course this is intentional and is an element of the hook. Of course I love the song. They're an amazing band.
Bob I agree that adding the sing along parts is smart. But it has morphed over time. In their concerts now most of the crowd sings along with every word of every song. It is hard to hear in the recording sometimes but it is there.
I think you are completely correct - The Warning does like to put into songs parts that the audience can join in with, and makes it fun. I also think you right about their development and proficiency, they seem to be hitting an exponential growth curve where they are growing by leaps and bounds. They have had a decade of playing as a band and now are playing across the world at all sorts of venues, meeting other artists and industry types; it is all starting to pay off now (artistically).
I love this song. I think Pau can do all these incredible multi-tasking things because she had the passion and the drive to be doing it since she was 6. No one ever old her she couldn't except for her (ex)friends that told her she was wasting her time. But her family never told any of them that what they wanted to do was too hard. Nor did they push them, these young ladies are stubborn and determined and if they couldn't do something they worked at it until they could. I'll support these sisters Always, as professor Snape would say.
I'm convinced, The Warning is going to explode into superstardom any day . They might be there already, we just gotta catch up. They're moving fast..Yep .... 🤟🎶☮️
As always, you manage to generate a new pleasure in listening a song that I’ve heard tons of times. Thank you. A lot of people have argued with me that they play very simple parts that any decent musician could easily copy. That may be true, but the number of simple things well put together, mixed with top-notch lyrics, singing, and showmanship becomes something unique. I adore this ladies.
They are so brilliant. Some of the best live Rock I've seen in decades (up there with Band-Maid, who they recently met at a festival this year - lots of mutual love and respect there). Great analysis and thanks for pointing out so many fine points that I wouldn't have noticed otherwise.
Thanks Bob....incredible song, incredible Talent, incredible young ladies...absolutely LOVE this song, it's a banger and of course there is PAU...my favorite most talented Rock Trio in many many decades...Have been listening to Rock for 6 decades now myself...hands down, the best I have heard. Thanks to TW for giving me my Rock and Roll back again in my older age. Love their music, love who they are...this is the real deal right here. DPA/TW. ⚡⚡⚡⚡🤘🤘
Great reaction to the band that best presents their live performances... Their way is masterful. DPA... They have a formidable innate talent, each one of them. Innate but with practice taken to the sublime. Despite their youth, they already have a lot of experience on their path in addition to their great preparation since they were children. Their attitude, discipline and will to achieve their goals are leading them to great, well-deserved achievements. Daniela, Paulina y Alejandra… They are still on the road to the top, but with too much potential, enough to think it will be inevitable. Furthermore, the volume of quality that each of their creations implies is great… and the number of songs that carry said quality is enormous, which for me could be “The Warning label”. I’m sure that each of their creations is subjected to a meticulous quality process before finally seeing the light… And not only in the technical aspect, but we have also already proven that they have an exquisite taste for good music that emanates from them when they become inspired and creative. Added to all this is that they are surrounded by an excellent family and fraternal team totally committed to their project… And they have a fan base, “The Warning Army”, tremendously loyal to them that is decisively involved in supporting them because they have deservedly earned it for being incredible and surprising human beings. Knowing this will give you a much better perspective to better value Dany, Pau and Ale, and maybe you will understand that TW is not just a band of talented girls who make good songs… No, it's about music, really art with the brilliance of a "masterpiece" created and performed by three genius performers from an early age who have been developing and evolving by leaps and bounds. The beauty of their art lies in its simplicity. Each of these amazing rock masterpieces must be appreciated in all its dimensions and then be surprised again that they are creations of those who have wonderful talent but who, due to their age, still have much more talent to develop. They are already admirable but their potential increases exponentially as they achieve success. As long as all this continues to flow with this equation they will soon reach the top of the world where they deserve to be. We're always looking for more from our favorite band of all time. Thanks and regards from México!! 🇲🇽 🤘😁✌️
These sisters are overwhelmingly talented!! They are the best power trio of XXI century! EPIC live performance! They did a superb job! Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
*Disciple* is one of their songs about social media and how it affects people in ways they don't even know... *XXI Century Blood* , *Z* , and *Kool-Aid Kids* are three others that also speak about social media... the 1st one, XXICB, has an OMV that tells a story... it and the director were nominated for (and won?) several awards when it was released in 2017 when Dany was 17, Pau was 15, and Ale was 12 😹 TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
So there are lots of bands out there with maybe more technical flash, epic riffing, showoff playing...but NO band with better music. Just one great earworm song after another. And full of musical "moments", which you await...like, 2...3...GO! Everything the girls do is to serve the song, not their individual pkaying. This particular version of Disciple is the best. I love how Dany includes the crowd in the singing, then lashes into the second somple riff before "ohohoh hear my calling". She usually doesn't do that, but it is SO effective. She should always do that live! Por favor Dany!
@@bobcieslinski Oh certainly I could go on and on...like diving into songs, deconstructing and reconstructing them. Like Amour, a personal favorite, which I did once in recommending it...the lyric version of Amour is great, but misses the sweet sting of Dany's guitar in the prechorus, which stands out in live versions. But the lyric version emphasizes Ale's loping bass line in the chorus. And Dany's luscious French pronunciation in the bridge...like I said I could go on...
You asked how Pau can sing and play like she does. All three are treat their craft like professional athletes. They practice the music chops, study music, but all have hard core physical training regiments. However Pau is rumored to do wind sprints and sing as hard as she can at the same time. Dani jogs and sings at the same time.
Great performers 3 extremely talented sisters that are a threat to the world...... A Global Warning if you will! 🤘This is my favorite song because it was my first TW experience in reality every song I've heard since has been my fav. Thanks for reacting to TW. ⚡🔥⚡🔥⚡
@PaleHorseShabuShabu I said 'one of', not 'the greatest that's ever existed'. There exists a pretty comprehensive history of her playing, going back many years, that show that even when she was in elementary school, she could out play a lot of adult musicians.
@@RussInCanadaAle started young and received the right instruction and has worked very hard on her craft, and I adore her as I adore her sisters, but "hands down one of the all time great bassists"? As a 44 year old whose been playing bass nonstop and immersed in this instrument and seen bass players of many different genres since I was 14, I strongly disagree.
True limb independence on the drums is tricky on its own; then to throw in not just harmonizing, but full lead vocals, AND Pau also projects so much personality. Pau is really talented and has worked so very hard to do it as well as she does; it's such a joy to watch.
It`s so nice to see, how people/ reactors like you are raising up in their respect and joy for this band and their music. I looooooooove it! (Greetings from a 55 year old from Germany). 🤩🎸
@@bobcieslinski Thanks for your answer! 😀Yes, I saw that short! They are so lovely, especialy Danny. But I love them all. Just a sidenote: I`m also a great fan of the band Maneskin. They also make "hand made" music. And at one concert, the singer, Damiano David, also stopped the show in a quite similar situation. A nice generation I think! ☺
Pau sings while running on a treadmill to practice singing while playing the drums. It's amazing how steady she can keep her voice while bouncing around on a drum kit!
That ooo aah oo part is known as the "Millennial whoop" that was so popular and identifiable a few years back, It is psychologically memorable and relatable. This is a great band and they DO NOT rely on such schtick....but that is the whoop.
Ive been a fan for some time now. I cant say how many times a day that I listen to their music, but its a lot. Currently have an addiction to getting 'Warning' tattoos. My Fav Band. With each year they grow stronger & have a larger following.⚡️🤟 Good luck to them.❤️
They really know how to construct a rock song that sticks in your head, as they seem to do it consistently. Then they give a flawless live performance. Such a tight-knit unit, and the drummer is an absolute phenom. Holding a beat while singing is hard enough, let alone throwing in fast fills. It's almost scary that they are only going to get better.
Great, great reaction! Thank you! Lo has dicho bien, amo el rock y amo a The Warning. Imposible no hacerlo. Todo su increíble talento se luce en vivo. Son geniales!
Great reaction. Good live version. This whole live show is great. Am so lucky to see them live in April. Got the vip arrangement. So will meet them in person. Cannot wait. Thanks for this reaction.
I love The Warning(almost as much as Band Maid !) I love Dani's stage presence her charisma really comes across. We are lucky to be witnessing some great rock bands at the moment and The Warning are right up there. Great heavy riffs and very good song arrangements. The Error album lifted these sisters to a new level, Z, is my favourite song from it, I hope you check it out. Cheers Bob.
Yep, their live shows are fabulous , agree with everything you say , riffs, arrangement etc. Funny you mention Band Maid , I found them a few days ago after they got mentioned in comments about the warning. Can't stop watching the live video of Onset , mind blowing stiff.
So pleased you found Band Maid . I have been following them since 2020 and they have become my obsession. They just have no bad songs and they are all just super fun and talented too.@@brucejacquesStick
I appreciate a musicians insight. We dont get much of that on youtube. I find it amazing that 3 Mexican girls singing English and a crowd of 8,000 Mexicans singing along in English.
What's less obvious about that powerful intro is Ale once again making great use of her 5-string by dropping down an octave after Dani comes in. It's Ale waking up subwoofers. About that chord... the song modulates to Dm : Dm - G - Bb and then jumps up a tritone with what your ear hears and anticipates as a minor II-V cadence back to Dm ( Em7b5 - A7b9 - Dm). But instead it treats the Em7b5 as the V of A major and, presto, another backdoor modulation. Weird but effective. I may be wrong but i bet this song began as two or three hook ideas that Pau glued together to make a coherent piece. Lennon and McCartney were known for this kind of song construction. It brings a lot of unexpected color to a song. Lennon's son, Sean, does this as well with his Ghost of a Saber Toothed Tiger duo with Charlotte Kemp Muhl. It produces a song with lots of memorable hooks.
Hey Jeff! You really stepped out in a limb there but who knows you might be right. We will certainly see for sure and it sure is a possibility. Thanks!
Basically when Pau started playing drums she started singing while doing it. Same with Dany. If you look when they were small Pau sings an AC/DC song while playing and she sings lead. The recording isn’t great and she definitely has a child’s type voice but she is singing while playing drums. Ale can sing lead and has when Dany needs a break, but she hates it. She prefers to sing back up.
I swear Pau has a quad processor in her head. Not only can she sing while drumming, she has a laptop next to her and she runs the click track, any backing tracks and the lights and background videos from that laptop. She has a couple petals that she uses to start and stop the song and what is happening on the show.
right after what I guess would be considered a lead section, which was the repetitive part, I expected some fast rocking lead. It's always a bit amazing to me that the simple patterned riffs make for some of the best rock songs. I will say you are right about having a verse the crowd can get into, it is one of my complaints about Lovebites as usually their complexity negates a lot of crown responses (nothing really wrong about that, but it could be some fuel for the fire so to speak). A nice rocking song. Still not a big fan of the vocals but growing a bit on me.
Yeah those catchy parts are what can turn a great singer into a into a real crowd pleaser for a group. I think Lovebites is still doing great and I’m not sure their type of music would benefit from something like that. I feel like the audience already has those things with the music instead.
It seems all 3 girls have been able to tap into parts of their brain that an avg person doesnt have access too. Its been scientificly proven that normal everday people only use a small percentage of their brain. I think Pau especially has somehow accessed more of her brain to be able to drum and sing flawlessly. To do somthing different with all 4 limbs while singing complicated lyrics is almost like something that is super human. Dany does the same with difficult guitar riffs and complicated lyrics..its pretty amazing.
This one just makes me shake me head in amazement. What are your thoughts about this one?
Buy The Warning Music Here: apple.co/3LN55KJ
Merch Store: bobcieslinski.myspreadshop.com/
Donation: www.buymeacoffee.com/BobCiesl...
Click here for Highfidelity ear protection for concerts and everyday life: bit.ly/highfidelityearplugs
Join Channel Membership: bit.ly/BobCieslinskimembership
Buy Apple Music Subscription Here: apple.co/3xl0Ey6
Ekster wallets, Bags and Cases: ekster.com?sca_ref=4171993.L0f4OQQsAl
Click here to buy Music Gear:bit.ly/SweetwaterMusicStore
Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/bobciesli...
Yea Bob, we share the same mind, music happens between the notes, and these ladies certainly have the chops to put it all together. I've been watching them since they were 8,10, and 12. What a fun ride.
Just got QOTMS from their merch store. The production is a bit flat, understandable considering it's an independent album, but it really is stunning musically. Lots of headphone ear candy that you don't get from the live version.
The Warnings writing is musical genius 🤘🔥
I still maintain that The Warning are one of the best live bands on the planet! They have such an amazing sense of detail while song writing and they put in the work to make sure everything translates to their live performances!
It shows Robert! They are just getting so good. One a side note you have the same name as one of my favorite elementary band composers Robert W.Smith.
@@bobcieslinski That doesn't surprise me, I was in the Navy on a ship with about a 900 man crew, there were 3 Robert Smiths!
Yesterday (December 7th) I went to their concert in Toluca Mexico, it was such an amazing experience...
My favorite live act period. The biggest strengths song writing and playing live
The Warning and Nightwish
This one is spectacular. In particular, Pau's proficiency with her drumming and singing simultaneously is awe inspiring, live none the less. Especially at the end of the 2nd verse.
I totally agree with you. I was amazed at that same thing. I actually mentioned that in the video.
Also, the ease in which Dani plays that PRS, 👨🍳💋
There are so many things I love about this particular video:
1. Dany and Pau sharing lead vocals.
2. Ale’s 2-3-Go!
3. During Pau’s interlude she lays her sticks on her snare to maximize her stage presence by her arm articulation.
4. The crowd work. When they are free playing and Dany turns to Pau to resume the click.
5. #NumberlyGarfs
6. The abrupt ending.
That doesn’t take into account the driving beat of the song and the remarkable writing and vocals throughout.
Great comments thanks mjc!
Pau sing and drums at the same time since... she play drum. When she was 6 or 7 at the start of her drumming one of her first teacher encourage her to sing and drum because it'll help her to be on time
Well it sure made a difference cause she plays some tough stuff while she’s singing. I think that’s hard but if you’ve been doing it all of your life then it’s to be expected. Thanks!
To do what Pau does, pat your head, rub your stomach, jump up and down on one foot, then belt out a song in tune, on key, in rhythm with everything else you are doing keeping the legato notes from getting broken by your actions. Simple, right? Pau apparently sings while running or doing other exercise to keep up her lung capacity for her singing while drumming. She has talked about her drumming is automatic so she can focus on her singing.
Ale's bass line is the glue that holds this track together. Great bass playing. Listen to her groove here, it's deep.
Thank you for the awesome review! The Warning have become my favorite rock band!!
The Warning rule. Pau is a low key genius. They are ridiculously talented; it's breathtaking 🤯❤️⚡️🇲🇽👯♀️
This was the opening song when I saw them. Everyone in the crowd was so pumped and was singing along. When I saw them, Ale was playing through Ampeg, but a few months later at the MTV VMAs, she was playing through Orange.
During one of Pau’s Instagram lives, she was asked how she can play and sing at the same time. Her only answer was “practice.” The first video on their channel is a much younger Pau playing a tiny kit and singing along with a Hannah Montana song. It’s just something she’s always done.
Also, there’s a video out there where Pau talks about how she doesn’t have perfect time. Ale, however, does have that natural sense of timing and gives Pau a look whenever those drums go off.
Lastly, the look that Dany gives Pau at 7:19 is telling her to turn the click back on. Pau controls it on her laptop that’s next to her, and it was turned off for the audience participation section.
Oh, and I don’t know if The Warning has said they deliberately put in audience participation parts in their songs, but I know BAND-MAID has said they do. That’s the tour I want!
Best live band on the planet.
okay, I wanna hear that beginning again. Had me laughing Bob, and didn't hurt my feelings a bit to hear it again
Hey Ron! Man it’s so good you just want to listen over and over again.
These fascinating ladies take you through a fantastic, beautiful musical and lyrical rollercoaster that amazes me every time. Saw them live about 3 weeks ago in Tijuana and as expected, they blew my head off as well as melted my face. DPA forever!
They are anthem rock songwriters. They put everything they have on stage for sure!
They are amazing thanks for commenting!
I know that the band feels bad if one of them is sick or if they are tired and feel as if they haven’t given the best of shows for their audience. There are always going to be gigs like that. All you can do is try your best. I was at the London show which was the last show of their European tour and I know that they were tired. They put on an amazing performance nonetheless and everyone in the crowd went home satisfied. Definitely one of the best shows that I’ve been to.
At the Pepsi Center all of them were a little under the weather but Pau still made the audience cry when she did Black Holes and went on to Breathe. Especially when she started crying at the end.
From what I’ve seen from them they would always want to give a great show. So glad you saw them. I hope to see them someday too.
Nice reaction Bob, as always. Just got my ticket for The Warning concert in Paris, France on April 2024 (Europe tour : 19 concerts in 25 days all over Europe). I'm so excited. Can't wait... Greetings from France, Gilles 🤘🟦⬜🟥😉
Thanks for the kind words and enjoy that concert! It should be awesome!
I get chills.
Yes, Bob. Their live shows really are something. The energy in the room is off the charts. Recently they have been STARTING their live shows with this song. What a great way to get the crowd ampped up and engaged, eh? So glad you have found a similar attraction to this music that many of us old (and young) rocker fans have embraced.
Hey Bob, I love this song because you get lead vocals from all 3, Dany and Pau on co-lead, and the "2,3, Go!" is Ale's line. And , yes, that killer bass intro, and 1 of my favorite drum fills. Pau is very good at singing while drumming, there are a bunch of songs where she sings lead on the entire song. As for her stamina, she practices singing while running.
To hear a song with Pau singing lead, try "Dust To Dust", "Narcisista"(1 of their 2 Spanish language songs), "23", or "Revenant". All were played at this same Teatro Metropolitan 2022 concert.
Pau is smart for practicing that while running. Thanks for the suggestions Chris! Hope you are doing well!
Exactly right - The Warning is the best rock band when it comes to the chanty sing-a-long bits, which are featured in many of their songs. It's arena rock at its best. Great analysis!
Thanks for the kind words and comments!
They are the complete package, writing, arrangement, musicianship, stagecraft, everything is top level.
Yep you got it right Jason. All boxes checked.
Fun to see how much Pau is pumped - you can clearly see it when she's pumping her chair (at the end of the audience involvement section) when Ale plays the 2 notes that restart the music - DOING DOING and here we go!
Such an awesome song g by these relented ladies.
That little double bounce with her dual pony tales kills me every time. Just adorable.
Nice reaction! Since I saw the intro of Disciple live, I understood Lzzy Hale when she said, after touring with them, The Warning attack the audience like no other younger rock band! 0 to 100 in 1 second... Can't wait to see them live again in April 2024, on their 2nd huge Euro tour! 👍🤘
I'll be there too and bring along two new fans. Snowball effect.
Man you are lucky! I’d love to see them but they haven’t been close enough yet
The song begins so strongly, when I first heard it I wasn't sure I liked it because of how it slows down, before speeding up again. Of course this is intentional and is an element of the hook. Of course I love the song. They're an amazing band.
They sure are!
I think The Warning has the ability to do something out of the norm thats makes their sound unique. I think thats what makes them so popular.
Bob I agree that adding the sing along parts is smart. But it has morphed over time. In their concerts now most of the crowd sings along with every word of every song. It is hard to hear in the recording sometimes but it is there.
Yes sir Bob. We do love them, and why we always say... You must see them LIVE, and witness them on stage. ⚡Studio Quality Live Band ⚡
Thanks gman! I’ll hopefully get a chance soon.
Have you reacted to their song called "23"yet ? If not it's a must see ! Cheers fella .
I haven’t Anthony thanks for the suggestion!
I think you are completely correct - The Warning does like to put into songs parts that the audience can join in with, and makes it fun. I also think you right about their development and proficiency, they seem to be hitting an exponential growth curve where they are growing by leaps and bounds. They have had a decade of playing as a band and now are playing across the world at all sorts of venues, meeting other artists and industry types; it is all starting to pay off now (artistically).
Hey Jim! Hanks for watching and commenting. They are really growing musically and they are ready for that next step and it is coming. Can’t wait to
The best explanation I have heard is that they play Anthems! Yes! Anthems!
They are anthem like but there’s definitely more there too.
I love this song. I think Pau can do all these incredible multi-tasking things because she had the passion and the drive to be doing it since she was 6. No one ever old her she couldn't except for her (ex)friends that told her she was wasting her time. But her family never told any of them that what they wanted to do was too hard. Nor did they push them, these young ladies are stubborn and determined and if they couldn't do something they worked at it until they could. I'll support these sisters Always, as professor Snape would say.
That is the trick when you don’t realize how hard it is and you have that support. You just keep plugging along and having fun.
This is the very song that made me a fan of The Warning. I can never tire listening to it.
It’s a great one alright. I can see why it made you a fan.
I'm convinced, The Warning is going to explode into superstardom any day . They might be there already, we just gotta catch up. They're moving fast..Yep .... 🤟🎶☮️
Something about them is just mesmerizing.
It sure is
As always, you manage to generate a new pleasure in listening a song that I’ve heard tons of times. Thank you.
A lot of people have argued with me that they play very simple parts that any decent musician could easily copy. That may be true, but the number of simple things well put together, mixed with top-notch lyrics, singing, and showmanship becomes something unique.
I adore this ladies.
Thanks Juan!
They are so brilliant. Some of the best live Rock I've seen in decades (up there with Band-Maid, who they recently met at a festival this year - lots of mutual love and respect there). Great analysis and thanks for pointing out so many fine points that I wouldn't have noticed otherwise.
Hey Thanks Tony! Always good to hear from you! I could see these two bands getting along. They seem very similar in doing things the right way.
Thanks Bob....incredible song, incredible Talent, incredible young ladies...absolutely LOVE this song, it's a banger and of course there is PAU...my favorite most talented Rock Trio in many many decades...Have been listening to Rock for 6 decades now myself...hands down, the best I have heard. Thanks to TW for giving me my Rock and Roll back again in my older age. Love their music, love who they are...this is the real deal right here. DPA/TW. ⚡⚡⚡⚡🤘🤘
Great reaction to the band that best presents their live performances... Their way is masterful.
DPA...
They have a formidable innate talent, each one of them. Innate but with practice taken to the sublime.
Despite their youth, they already have a lot of experience on their path in addition to their great preparation since they were children.
Their attitude, discipline and will to achieve their goals are leading them to great, well-deserved achievements.
Daniela, Paulina y Alejandra…
They are still on the road to the top, but with too much potential, enough to think it will be inevitable.
Furthermore, the volume of quality that each of their creations implies is great… and the number of songs that carry said quality is enormous, which for me could be “The Warning label”.
I’m sure that each of their creations is subjected to a meticulous quality process before finally seeing the light…
And not only in the technical aspect, but we have also already proven that they have an exquisite taste for good music that emanates from them when they become inspired and creative.
Added to all this is that they are surrounded by an excellent family and fraternal team totally committed to their project…
And they have a fan base, “The Warning Army”, tremendously loyal to them that is decisively involved in supporting them because they have deservedly earned it for being incredible and surprising human beings.
Knowing this will give you a much better perspective to better value Dany, Pau and Ale, and maybe you will understand that TW is not just a band of talented girls who make good songs…
No, it's about music, really art with the brilliance of a "masterpiece" created and performed by three genius performers from an early age who have been developing and evolving by leaps and bounds.
The beauty of their art lies in its simplicity.
Each of these amazing rock masterpieces must be appreciated in all its dimensions and then be surprised again that they are creations of those who have wonderful talent but who, due to their age, still have much more talent to develop.
They are already admirable but their potential increases exponentially as they achieve success.
As long as all this continues to flow with this equation they will soon reach the top of the world where they deserve to be.
We're always looking for more from our favorite band of all time.
Thanks and regards from México!! 🇲🇽
🤘😁✌️
🤘⚡️🤘The Warning bring it every single time 🤘⚡️🤘
They sure do Gill.
Stadium rock. They’re just built for it. 80,000 people all singing along to every song. River Plate her they come.
Yep you said it. So catchy and so good.
These sisters are overwhelmingly talented!!
They are the best power trio of XXI century!
EPIC live performance!
They did a superb job!
Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
They sure are incredible Pablo.
Nice reaction, Bob. I remember having energy like that -- fifty years ago. 🤫
Hey Charlie! I feel the same way and thanks for thr kind words.
This song has it all. Just epic!!
It sure is Jeff.
*Disciple* is one of their songs about social media and how it affects people in ways they don't even know... *XXI Century Blood* , *Z* , and *Kool-Aid Kids* are three others that also speak about social media... the 1st one, XXICB, has an OMV that tells a story... it and the director were nominated for (and won?) several awards when it was released in 2017 when Dany was 17, Pau was 15, and Ale was 12 😹
TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
So there are lots of bands out there with maybe more technical flash, epic riffing, showoff playing...but NO band with better music. Just one great earworm song after another. And full of musical "moments", which you await...like, 2...3...GO! Everything the girls do is to serve the song, not their individual pkaying.
This particular version of Disciple is the best. I love how Dany includes the crowd in the singing, then lashes into the second somple riff before "ohohoh hear my calling". She usually doesn't do that, but it is SO effective. She should always do that live! Por favor Dany!
Great comments Tom! They are so good for all the reasons you mentioned and more.
@@bobcieslinski Oh certainly I could go on and on...like diving into songs, deconstructing and reconstructing them. Like Amour, a personal favorite, which I did once in recommending it...the lyric version of Amour is great, but misses the sweet sting of Dany's guitar in the prechorus, which stands out in live versions. But the lyric version emphasizes Ale's loping bass line in the chorus. And Dany's luscious French pronunciation in the bridge...like I said I could go on...
⚡The Warning⚡
🔥👸👸👸🔥
Rock🤘😎
I read somewhere that Pau practiced singing while she ran.
Someone told me the same thing that’s pretty smart.
4:50 Pau is just showing off here. It's effortless for her. Queen of the drum kit.
It really looks like it for her but man that’s crazy. Wow!
MAESTRO, REACCIONE A "23" O "DUST TO DUST", AMBAS CANCIONES LAS CANTA PAULINA EN SU TOTALIDAD. TOCA Y CANTA.
You asked how Pau can sing and play like she does. All three are treat their craft like professional athletes. They practice the music chops, study music, but all have hard core physical training regiments. However Pau is rumored to do wind sprints and sing as hard as she can at the same time. Dani jogs and sings at the same time.
Great performers 3 extremely talented sisters that are a threat to the world...... A Global Warning if you will! 🤘This is my favorite song because it was my first TW experience in reality every song I've heard since has been my fav. Thanks for reacting to TW. ⚡🔥⚡🔥⚡
Ale is hands down one of the all time great bassists.
She has a lot of great qualities as a musician, but no, no she's not. Stop with the hyperbole.
@PaleHorseShabuShabu
I said 'one of', not 'the greatest that's ever existed'. There exists a pretty comprehensive history of her playing, going back many years, that show that even when she was in elementary school, she could out play a lot of adult musicians.
@@RussInCanadaAle started young and received the right instruction and has worked very hard on her craft, and I adore her as I adore her sisters, but "hands down one of the all time great bassists"? As a 44 year old whose been playing bass nonstop and immersed in this instrument and seen bass players of many different genres since I was 14, I strongly disagree.
@@PaleHorseShabuShabu
So, the weaknesses in her playing are....?
!!!The Warning = 10 🔥¡¡¡ Greetings from Argentina
Best band on planet to me ..they are magical
They are incredible hard rockers.
Bob, you're right.
Thanks Francis! They are amazing.
Who had The Best Rock Drummer Wears A Dress on their bingo card?
This is my favortie The Warning video nice reaction
Thanks Mark! It’s an awesome song.
Yuv really nailed it ! I’m a 67 yo rocker and the Warning is the Best Rock Band out there today !
True limb independence on the drums is tricky on its own; then to throw in not just harmonizing, but full lead vocals, AND Pau also projects so much personality. Pau is really talented and has worked so very hard to do it as well as she does; it's such a joy to watch.
You said it lord. I don’t know how she does it so well.
It`s so nice to see, how people/ reactors like you are raising up in their respect and joy for this band and their music. I looooooooove it! (Greetings from a 55 year old from Germany). 🤩🎸
Hey Micky! They are amazing! Great people too. I saw a short where they stopped the show and was concerned for a fan in the audience.
@@bobcieslinski Thanks for your answer! 😀Yes, I saw that short! They are so lovely, especialy Danny. But I love them all. Just a sidenote: I`m also a great fan of the band Maneskin. They also make "hand made" music. And at one concert, the singer, Damiano David, also stopped the show in a quite similar situation. A nice generation I think! ☺
@@mickypescatore9656I’ve never heard them before. I know the name but just never listened.
⚡️⚡️Like # 6️⃣8️⃣8️⃣ The Warning Army 🪖🪖Texas División ⚡️⚡️
Pau sings while running on a treadmill to practice singing while playing the drums. It's amazing how steady she can keep her voice while bouncing around on a drum kit!
That’s crazy and incredible.
That ooo aah oo part is known as the "Millennial whoop" that was so popular and identifiable a few years back, It is psychologically memorable and relatable. This is a great band and they DO NOT rely on such schtick....but that is the whoop.
El mejor rock del 2023 ,The Warning y su tema Disciple un riff y un tema muy duro.como el rock de TW
Ive been a fan for some time now. I cant say how many times a day that I listen to their music, but its a lot. Currently have an addiction to getting 'Warning' tattoos. My Fav Band. With each year they grow stronger & have a larger following.⚡️🤟 Good luck to them.❤️
They are amazing and that tattoo sounds awesome!
Song makes me feel like I'm soaring through the air..... can't explain it exactly 🤔🤔🤔 love it and then👍❤️😎💯
They really know how to construct a rock song that sticks in your head, as they seem to do it consistently. Then they give a flawless live performance. Such a tight-knit unit, and the drummer is an absolute phenom. Holding a beat while singing is hard enough, let alone throwing in fast fills. It's almost scary that they are only going to get better.
Great comments and yeah they are so young and will only get better. Thats incredible.
Pau has come along way since she was 10
Great, great reaction! Thank you! Lo has dicho bien, amo el rock y amo a The Warning. Imposible no hacerlo. Todo su increíble talento se luce en vivo. Son geniales!
Thanks for the kind words!
You have been Warned! Resistance is futile! You will be assimilated!
Thanks, Locutus of Borg. You're doing good work. 😉
Yes we have been warned. Also glad to hear the Star Trek reference. In a big Star Trek fan.
Great reaction. Good live version. This whole live show is great. Am so lucky to see them live in April. Got the vip arrangement. So will meet them in person. Cannot wait. Thanks for this reaction.
Thanks for the kind words! You are lucky enjoy the show and meet and greet.
That is one of my favorite songs of theirs. #SisterPower Keep up the good work, Bob!
Thanks Greg!
You are seeing something special when you see The Warning. THEY ARE GOING TO BE A JUGGERNAUT IN ROCK
I love The Warning(almost as much as Band Maid !) I love Dani's stage presence her charisma really comes across. We are lucky to be witnessing some great rock bands at the moment and The Warning are right up there. Great heavy riffs and very good song arrangements. The Error album lifted these sisters to a new level, Z, is my favourite song from it, I hope you check it out. Cheers Bob.
Yep, their live shows are fabulous , agree with everything you say , riffs, arrangement etc. Funny you mention Band Maid , I found them a few days ago after they got mentioned in comments about the warning. Can't stop watching the live video of Onset , mind blowing stiff.
So pleased you found Band Maid . I have been following them since 2020 and they have become my obsession. They just have no bad songs and they are all just super fun and talented too.@@brucejacquesStick
Thanks Lewis!
Stunning mexican rock band. Chingonas chicas. El rock no ha muerto. Espersnza para la buena musica.
6:11 is a shame the camera don't get a close shot in that moment, the drummer expressions are amazing.
Gear master just released Ale and danys live rig break down if you're interested.
Thanks Matt!
🤘🤘🤘
Great video, thx
I appreciate a musicians insight. We dont get much of that on youtube. I find it amazing that 3 Mexican girls singing English and a crowd of 8,000 Mexicans singing along in English.
Thanks so much I appreciate the kind words and comments Darrin.
What's less obvious about that powerful intro is Ale once again making great use of her 5-string by dropping down an octave after Dani comes in. It's Ale waking up subwoofers.
About that chord... the song modulates to Dm : Dm - G - Bb and then jumps up a tritone with what your ear hears and anticipates as a minor II-V cadence back to Dm ( Em7b5 - A7b9 - Dm). But instead it treats the Em7b5 as the V of A major and, presto, another backdoor modulation. Weird but effective.
I may be wrong but i bet this song began as two or three hook ideas that Pau glued together to make a coherent piece. Lennon and McCartney were known for this kind of song construction. It brings a lot of unexpected color to a song. Lennon's son, Sean, does this as well with his Ghost of a Saber Toothed Tiger duo with Charlotte Kemp Muhl. It produces a song with lots of memorable hooks.
Thanks for the in-depth theory with this song.
I think they will go down in history as the best power trio, even better than Rush. (yes, I said it)
Great reaction Bob.
Hey Jeff! You really stepped out in a limb there but who knows you might be right. We will certainly see for sure and it sure is a possibility. Thanks!
Whoa whoa... let's see what else they do over the next couple decades :D .. even so, I don't hate the comparison.
“Best” in what way?
You should check out their song Dust To Dust
Great reaction!❤
Thanks Troy!
Basically when Pau started playing drums she started singing while doing it. Same with Dany. If you look when they were small Pau sings an AC/DC song while playing and she sings lead. The recording isn’t great and she definitely has a child’s type voice but she is singing while playing drums. Ale can sing lead and has when Dany needs a break, but she hates it. She prefers to sing back up.
I swear Pau has a quad processor in her head. Not only can she sing while drumming, she has a laptop next to her and she runs the click track, any backing tracks and the lights and background videos from that laptop. She has a couple petals that she uses to start and stop the song and what is happening on the show.
Incredible that she can do all of that James. She must be a robot. But she has too much passion for that.
I've read that Pau practices singing while running on a treadmill....
That’s a unique way to train. Smart too.
🤘🤘
❤❤❤
Good video, thanks. I just found them too and really dig it..
Thanks for watching!
Alejandra ❤❤❤❤❤
They bring it. Pau beats those drums like they owe her money.
🤣that’s a good one Randy.
Orgullo de México 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽
I LOVE this versión IS so femenine! But strong and elegant!
right after what I guess would be considered a lead section, which was the repetitive part, I expected some fast rocking lead. It's always a bit amazing to me that the simple patterned riffs make for some of the best rock songs. I will say you are right about having a verse the crowd can get into, it is one of my complaints about Lovebites as usually their complexity negates a lot of crown responses (nothing really wrong about that, but it could be some fuel for the fire so to speak). A nice rocking song. Still not a big fan of the vocals but growing a bit on me.
Yeah those catchy parts are what can turn a great singer into a into a real crowd pleaser for a group. I think Lovebites is still doing great and I’m not sure their type of music would benefit from something like that. I feel like the audience already has those things with the music instead.
🤘😎❤️⚠️
- You Shall Remain Inside Your Space of Ignorance -
🤷♂️
@@bobcieslinskiit's the last lyric of the song ;)
React to dust to dust from this concert
“You shall remain inside your place of ignorance”, a great way to end a song about the poisonous nature of tribalism.
It seems all 3 girls have been able to tap into parts of their brain that an avg person doesnt have access too.
Its been scientificly proven that normal everday people only use a small percentage of their brain.
I think Pau especially has somehow accessed more of her brain to be able to drum and sing flawlessly. To do somthing different with all 4 limbs while singing complicated lyrics is almost like something that is super human. Dany does the same with difficult guitar riffs and complicated lyrics..its pretty amazing.
You said it Mike!