I enjoyed your reaction, but I noticed that most of your discussion focused on the way the original speaker presented the topic rather than on the points he made about Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). Since the video title is 'Prophet Muhammad - The Greatest Man in History | Non-Muslim Reaction to Islam,' I was hoping to hear more of your thoughts on the actual content related to the Prophet’s character, achievements, and teachings. It would be great if you could balance your critique of the speaker with more of your reaction to what was shared about Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) himself. Thanks!
You can't find anyone in history his life recorded his actions and saying like Muhammad pbuh, sorry but you can't said if I do research I will find try to research first, do you think this man put him number 1 without research the life of others?
As a Muslim what he said obviously I don’t agree with him. But having said that we as a Muslims need to develop patience. Prophet message was to be kind and don’t judge other people. Understand his point coz I guess they don’t believe in any religion. Whatever we say to him about our religion or our prophet he won’t comprehend coz he doesn’t believe in anything. As a Muslim I can pray for him that may Allah guide them. Give them a credit to listen the video… yes they need to refrain about passing any comment without knowing but again their knowledge about religion is not enough.
@@sabrinalopez4714 they do not seek knowledge. They seek to deny knowledge that is provided to them. If they wanted knowledge they would do research on what they hear instead of flat out calling it “bulls**t” that’s where I see friction between what they say and what they actually portray. They still react to Islamics videos for the viewership, I don’t condone that personally
Life is not a Test, ISLAM is other name for intolerance, and probavly abbreviates to International Syndicate for Lies and Manipulation. You must watch the series, The Muhammad by Zafar for enlightening facts.
Jesus, Muhammad and Moses all three stood against oppression and taught us to support the opressed. May God almighty help our poor, oppressed and abused brothers and sisters in humanity, in Gaza.
@@TasinHussain your scriptures speak about it. The fact is you have been brainwashed to seek Muhammad and his Allah, which is not really different from the Old Testament. The sooner you realise the better. It seems you have not even completed the Tharjuma of the un-holy book.
I can relate to what Justin was saying about having religion and ideologies being forced upon you as a child. It puts a bad taste in your mouth and makes religion seem bad. It wasn’t until I was 14 and started to read the Qu’rān myself with an open mind that my belief became real. The Qu’rān actually addresses humans directly and tells them to question and use their intellect. This really appealed to my logical mind. I then learned about the life of Muhammad pbuh when I was 19 and started to read the Qu’rān again. I had a brand new experience this time because I had more context. May Allah guide us all. insha’Allah. ♥️😊
@stayspiritual You know what just don't listen to all comments and continue doing what you are doing right now but if you are truly seeking the truth and knowledge trust me you'll find it no matter how much time it takes from you and you don't know how your life will be inext years only Allah knows best It takes time but as long as your heart and mind is open to learn and seek knowledge and find the truth you'll find it
The truth doesn't care about your or anyone opinion the truth will remain the truth whatever the case so it's not a choice to have eternal life or not, the truth that there is eternal life the only choice we have if we will go to heaven or hell according to our beliefs and actions as Allah told us through his words and through the messengers
@yeloSolo Thank you for reminding me to pray for him again. Praying for him heals worries and forgives sins. In other hand, what about you ask God guidance now, before you face death then you ask God at that moment, which better!
@@HamzaHanma I have no intrest in death cults. Btw did you know that you are only half of a man, meaning you have only half mental capacity of a man as per your Prophet PBUH.
Thank you guys for helping to spread the prophet's name, may the almighty creator bless us all with His blessing, forgiveness and guidance to the truth, amen
if anything they are disrespecting their own intellectual property and the historians that worked their heart out to find truth. This Hart guy didn't even want the prophet Mohammed to be first on the list. He had to accept it after finding evidences. But lil guy siting on his couch thinks he can do better . That kind of arrogance will always be fascinating to me
@@ma-px1nb At least they did not disrespect islam or muslims. They did make up their mind already though, so they're not watching to do anything but ... watch. I don't know why people are expecting them to convert or something. They made up their mind, and we'll all find out at the end, won't we?
@ Muslims will always wish for non Muslims to find the creator. It’s just wishful thinking that maintains some of them here. Yes they did not disrespect Muslims and that’s because it’s not their first rodeo. They’ve been reacting to Islamic content for a while they know better than be disrespecting our religion. They don’t want that heat. So they allow themselves to do ANYTHING ELSE. As long as they can keep the Muslim views. their criticism are ill founded, make nonsense most of the time. They are just waisting viewers time and hope. Which I find calculated and manipulative.
I wanted to say more, but just as the Prophet Muhammed Sala ALLAHU alayhi wa salam Said : "Whoevers believes in ALLAH and the Final Day, let him say something good or he keept silent." So I will say May ALLAH the Almighty guide you both to the Truth, if you are truely seeking the Truth. 😢
Seriously, when you start focusing on how YOU feel about the way he is lecturing instead of what he is saying in the lecture, you know there's something wrong with the way you approach it. You will always find problems, issues , something you do not like. Because at the basis of it all, you reject the core Idea of God and his messengers. It does not matter How the person will explain it to you, the problem is not him , but you , and your "feelings". I wonder if y'all judge yourselves the way you judge others. You do not assess whether or not you are being fair to the subject. You dont do research but reject other people research's.. I mean.. What exactly is this ? Are you even serious about finding truth , or did you make your channel to reject GOD and make people adhere to your conviction ? People who have spent their entire live studying something, yet you feel like if YOU search a little bit you'll find something they did not find. Funny thing is , you dont even bother searching ! You just move on after questioning and rejecting ! That's pure arrogance. I know people are saying that you are respectful and all those thing, but I believe that you are disrespecting your own intelligence, you betray your logic many times, just to refute the idea of Allah. I really hope you take time to read your comments. Because I want to say something very important: Your experience, what you went through, will never be a justification to negate the existence of a creator. If you use it to try to explain the non existence of God, you actually subscribe to the same philosophy that tyrant like Hitler used to commit atrocities: People are just atomes. God do not exist , there is no afterlife, no hell no paradise, so killing millions of people equal rearranging couple of atome in order to get what you want. The core idea of morality become null. Please use your logic, dont use your experience. Your experience will fail you, not your logic
سبحان الله عندما قال في كتابه العزيز "ورفعنا لك ذكرك" عندما بحثت في فيديوهات هذه القناة وجدت ان هذا الفيديو اكثر مشاهدة في هذه القناة رغم مرور فقط 10 أيام
My humble advice: take a moment to genuinely investigate the claims in these videos. As Muslims, we are taught to question our beliefs, and many of us have studied other religions with that mindset. But here, I see people dismissing these videos without consideration, only to divert the conversation to irrelevant points. And honestly, it feels patronizing. We’ve done our research, and we’re encouraging you to do the same-yet it’s met with quick dismissal.
If you can't see him as a prophet, at least see the solutions he brought no means to push passion on you. The Western world can really be revived by his teachings and we the Arab side of the world are good example yes there is poor countris, but due to wars that happened they became like this even my country Iraq is in ruins because of war the British divided my country and Americans destroyed it.
the man, the father of his child, the husband of his wife, the leadership, warrior in battle and entrepreneur. yes, hes the greatest man. and the most important he achieve everything with the most realigius sides too, sometimes man focus on worldly life only. thats rare and why he sucsses in both way earth and heaven. cz Allah promise him heaven but he still pray all night long every-day. im just a little dust here still forget my 5 minutes prayer😢
Im a muslim, but this video is a lil bit more towards idolizing Prophet Muhammad the more i watch it. He's a great prophet but he didn't want people over idolizing him as the way Jesus being idolize by Christian.
لكننا المسلمين لا نعبد محمدمثلما تقول نقتدي به في سلوكنا وافعالنا واقوالنا هو قدوتنا وشفيعنا يوم القيامه وامتثال لامر الله اطع الله ورسوله هكذا امرنا الله بالقران مفهومك هو الغلط
what the hell are you even saying? Saying that he is the best man created by Allah is idolizing him ? WHEN Allah himself told us that ? Pls sit this one out
Muhammad was no more than a messenger . He is only the last prophet. His lifestyle and biography recorded sayins are really cool romantiques reasonables and intresting i really encourage you to read it thanks ❤❤❤❤
It's not a drama and the quotations are from non Muslim scientists and scholars.. It's a strong faith that only touches the real believers who really understand the message and know the prophet peace be upon him.
Thanks for the video guys. You can read about bibliography of Muhammad S.A.W. to know more about Him from childhood until the end of His life. All of what He is going through in the whole life can be taken as the role model.
The Prophet Muhammad told about the word of god that prove the truth...why afrraid or won't to learn.just only to improve knowledge...you will see that the word of god or The AL-QU'RAN is PERFECT
The writing graphics behind you clearly reads STAY SPIRITUAL .. but what you are talking about is more about responding to the speaker's narrative style rather than listening, examining, concluding and responding to the essence of the content being narrated.. Everything seems very out of tune ...
@@ma-px1nb Yes, it was natural for them to focus on their spiritual specialty and take spiritual actions from the clips and take positive things for people.
This is the easy question to the Atheist, that NO Atheist is able to answer? ● Firstly, you're certain of these facts by Logic, Science and human experience: 1- You have NOT created and shaped yourself! 2- You have NO control over When you're born! 3- You do NOT know when you die! 4- you did NOT choose your parents or your children! 5- You do NOT even know what might happen to you in the next hour or day! 6- You have NO influence on the creation or the existence of the Universe. 7- You have NO explanation of how the universe came to be, in such a fine tuned and perfect harmony...etc. ■ And I'm not going to ask you about your Monkey grand father, or perhaps the Fish grand mother, at the end of the day you're merely electrons randomly bumping into each other without a purpose!! ! And as you may know that All believers of the Atheist "religion" agree, on certain principles: 1- There's Not really Good and evil in the world! 2- There's NO difference between (Eating your food, murdering innocent people or having sex with your Child!) {Very shocking!} 3- Each Atheist can define moral values based on personal subjective experiences, and depending on the pains and pleasures they experience! 4- There's No need for the limited human beings, to seek guidance from a higher being, who is unlimited in his knowledge and wisdom! 5- There's no common laws govern all Atheists, just make up your mind as you go...etc !!!! So my 3 easy questions are: ???? 1- Can you prove to me morally and logically, that having sex with your kids good or evil? (Provided that both of you agee to it) 2- Can you prove to me morally and logically, that murdering innocent people is good or evil? 3- Is there a moral and intellectual difference between the Criminal and an innocent person? ● I'm waiting for your honest reply if you truly stand for your beliefs! ● And if you fail to respond, than at least you now know that Atheism is dangerous for the society, and help spread Criminality.
Just relax bro, as a Muslim, you have the right and freedom to judge something that you can convince yourself of. continue to hone your insight with an open mind and don't feel intimidated by Muslims, Christians, Hindus or others.
God Chose His Final Messenger Prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H as Mercy & Guidance for The Worlds not for his people Only! Other Prophet's or leaders were their for their own people or goals or desires (except Prophet's)
12:25 you mean he is forcing you to belive in it? No. It's your choice to watch the content. He didn't ask you to watch him. If you have such mentality, your solution is to stop watching it. Simple😄
I believe or see a bit of arrogance in the reactions but I also see good intentions and hope which can lead in whatever right way you are in currently, specially the guy on the right.
if it wasn't for his mate, that guy on the right would already be a Muslim. When he starts seeing logic in the teaching of islam, the other one is always next to him, reminding him of "life experiences" that is supposed to "negate" (?) God's existence. May the creator ( they hate when we say Allah) guide them on the right path
People started worshipping prophets like Abraham, David and Jesus, though these messengers strictly followed monotheism. People in ignorance even worship ordinary men like Sai Baba, Rajneesh , Nithyananda etc. But 2.5 billion muslims are ready to give their life for Prophet Mohammad . Not a single muslim will worship him.😮.
"""Growth is the basis of disbelief, so Pharaoh, Abulhab, Qarun, Nimrud and others disbelieved, and still most people have grown up in their hearts, so the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: ""He does not smell Paradise."
Shaykh Khalid Yasin, who is speaking in the video, used to hear Malcolm X speak back in the day! They are expressive in the same way.... same way MLK spoke passionately. It baffles me how this could rub people the wrong way.
@10:10 "Heaven lies under the feet of the mother." Prophet Muhummed (saww). Even though he lost the touch of a mother at 6 years old. The greatest attainment is heaven, yet the importance of mother is more. Think.
نريد ترجمه على الفيديوهات كى تعم الفائده ويكون الثواب أعظم جزاكم الله خير الجزاء على ما تبذلونه من مجهود فى نشر الدعوه الاسلاميه ونصرة الدين الحق 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Yes, the truth is hard to accept. It takes sincerity to do that. And if that sincerity is not there you are only left with assumptions to look away from it.
They were not comparing the prophets only they were comparing all the Men to find the greatest man. That's why he mentioned Gandhi, etc. Is it really hard to understand? You always insist people to think from another perspective have you tried to try it on yourself? You always seem very eager about the fact that people should think like the way you think. To be honest you guys just like to run your mouth and like to criticize what is in front of you.
Why is the man on the right talking so much and looking a bit arrogant? I want to tell you something. Your opinion doesn't matter. The truth will remain the truth no matter how much people try to deny it. If you are afraid of changing, don't speak arrogantly as if you were the center of the universe.
Let me give you some glad tidings to the people who don’t wanna live forever. You should forget God so he forgets you and doesn’t give you an eternal life
Quran(7:172) When your Lord asked all the offspring of Adam (before their birth), "Am I not your Lord?" All of them testified and bore witness to their testimony that on the Day of Judgment they would not say, "We were not aware of this (fact),"
You know I have to say, it’s good that you question things but it’s interesting how you perceive the religion. It’s almost as if you’re battling with your Conscious/sub-conscious bias. In any case, I wouldn’t disregard something the prophet did because others have - it just shows his humanity. We are all humans, some of us are selected by the creator to teach.
You tube videos need audio and visual effects to attract people attention. If you want proper discussion in soft tone, then you need to discuss things with Scholars in this case Islamic scholars.
لن اقول لك ان تفعل هذا وذاك لكنني انصحك بأخذ كتاب عن سيرة رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم وقراءتها في بث مباشر ملاحظة انا خريج جامعة تخصص علم النفس وقد كنت اقرأ لغة جسدكما لذالك اظن انكما بذلتما المجهود للانفتاح على امر غريب عليكما كما تعلمان ان تكونا وسط مجتمع لايفهم الاسلام وان يكون لديه معلومات مغلوطة من وسائل الإعلام لذالك انصحك فعلا ومن كل قلبي اقرء عن الاسلام
You have said a lot of things when putting your reactions into words, but at the end of the day, you have said yes read about this and that people, yet dismissed his request that you should read about Muhammad PBUH; so please why not consider reading the biography, for example, so at the end of the week, you might say, I know about this prophet (and here is what I think, based on what you have found out or read>!
They would have to actually care to be able to do this. I dont believe they care. They've been reacting for a looking time. They never do follow up research. The refute the infos they find or they say "its good teaching but it does not prove Allah's existence." And then they move on and never look back.
My friend muhammed brought a book and he claim it’s from god While jesus didn’t bring a book the “bible” its sayings of unknown persons Boudha is nothing more a way of life Why its hard I don’t understand just examine the claims of quran if it’s not true everything collapse and if not it is simply the truth
@@Jibreel-jt1qh Allah/God is not a human+God do not go to toilet and he don't need any price to forgive sins(believing all those fallacies are pure blasphemy) think deeply and accept Islam
@deceiver-paul If muhamad will say something false in allah name then allah will cut his aorta (Quran 69:44-46) At deathbed muhamad said he feel that his aorta is being cut by the poison given at khaibar (Sahih al bukhari 4428) This implies that muhmad used to say false in allah name, he fabricated verse for his own benefit. Muhmad made verse to justify marriage with daughter in law zainab (Quran 33:36 33:37) Muhmad made verse to justify his marriage with any woman (Quran 33:53) Muhamad justified intimacy with slaves (Sunan an nasai 3959) Qura n is not revelation from al lah, verse is made by muhmad for his own benefit. Follow real prophet and real god.
🛑Peace be upon him prophet Mohamed to answer you about why he said go read about prophet mohamed and not others if you are arguing for something thing or for specific message you put the your arguments to that message and that’s last part was call to action it’s encouraging the people to find out more about that’s message so it’s clear
I don’t like those two they never gonna understand the message they just looking for the person who speak when you look to their entry you know who they are, and you can tell their background You see the video with the one eye yall know what I-meant
@stayspiritual No, thank you. As a Muslim, I sensed what you were aiming for with that video. The response felt passive and somewhat closed-minded-it didn’t resonate as genuinely spiritual. It’s okay; I understand the deep-rooted resentment. You can't help it. No worries about it, its not your fault.
They basically calls alll the subscribers & viewers stupid fools. Yet self respect less viewers watching their videos 😂 I came to their video almost a year later. After seeing it in my recommendation again
I don't think you are a stupid fool, but we are allowed to think differently. Life would be pretty boring if we all thought the same thing. So I say... appreciate the diversity. Your welcome here anytime, even if it is just once a year. 😉🖖
@stayspiritual paths can be different but destination/truth is one, so, if u don't want to accept it for the sake of maintaining diversity. None can do anything about it. By watching reaction videos u can only know 1/2% u might even have some doubts too. I think u guys r christians right? According to ur talks, u guys don't even know prophets marry too. May be in the history of prophets only JESUS didn't/COUDN'T marry. & u surprised hearing prophet Muhammad's(s) marriage & kingdom. Do u believe in trinity? Ur answer would explain ur intellect. Waiting..
@@habiladam6363 they are not searching for truth. They think they already have the truth. In a way they react to these videos to dissect them and find any trivial flaw that they can focus on. Today was the narrator's speech.
@ yes, I also had hope that they would do research on the things they encounter here. But it’s clear to me that they just react and move on. It’s not about searching truth for them. We are the one mistaken
Seeing their faces like they're really those ignorant persons but hells r their real place and Michael was mathematician and historian but who r u dude 😂 have u ever research on anything
I’m Muslim and I’m saddened to see this comment. Don’t ever presume to know where people will end up in the afterlife. You are NOT God, you don’t do the judging or know what is in James’ and Justin’s hearts. James and Justin, I enjoy your videos and keep it up! 👍🏼
@@acy2004 I didn't say they'll go to hell but their acts and lack of knowledge and ignorance will lead them to hellfire, they don't know anything or any knowledge bout any books how they claim without researching or knowing??so their eyes r not blind their hearts,, Allah guided them who r truthful and honest with their hearts, if they don't change they surely in hellfire
ha-ha...seems a little suspect...especially the "categories" used. The one thing that was NOT noted in Hart's list was that the overarching assessment using his categories was of INFLUENCE, NOT of CHARACTER. If character (values/teachings) was used, another list results. Shouldn't really cast stones at other leaders when Mohamed had a child bride, betrothed at 6, consummated relationship at 9??) Yeah, probably better to get an un-biased set of categories analyzed by a more impartial presentation. I liked the banter guys, and the idea that observation is important (the proof is in the pudding, not in the directions)..people are a ball of yarn...made me smile :)
sir you do realize what you said was the norm back then or hell even 200 years ago in the US people had child brides lol you're viewing this through the lens of presentism
May Allah forgive you. Aisha was 16 when she got married to the prophet. Consummated relationship at 17. The prophet was not a lustul man. If you havent read about his life, sit this one out
@ like I said, there’s only one truth. So I’m either brainwashed.. or you are wrong and driving yourself to hellfire. Either way, I like my odds better because at least I base my opinion on verified knowledge. You base yours on trolling and mocking one’s religion. How fun is that ☺️. We’ll find out when we die 😂
I enjoyed your reaction, but I noticed that most of your discussion focused on the way the original speaker presented the topic rather than on the points he made about Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). Since the video title is 'Prophet Muhammad - The Greatest Man in History | Non-Muslim Reaction to Islam,' I was hoping to hear more of your thoughts on the actual content related to the Prophet’s character, achievements, and teachings. It would be great if you could balance your critique of the speaker with more of your reaction to what was shared about Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) himself. Thanks!
thats what i notice!! for some reason they are looking for excuses to not address the main point being anxious its going change them
أنظر ما قال و لا تنظر من قال
Agreed.
They are here to deceive people for views and other reasons.
yha thay alway talk about speakers not content of video.
You can't find anyone in history his life recorded his actions and saying like Muhammad pbuh, sorry but you can't said if I do research I will find try to research first, do you think this man put him number 1 without research the life of others?
The arrogance of this guy baffles me every time. You could slap him with the truth , he wouldn't even realize
@@ma-px1nb😂😂
@@jibreel_ahmed😂😂
As a Muslim what he said obviously I don’t agree with him. But having said that we as a Muslims need to develop patience. Prophet message was to be kind and don’t judge other people. Understand his point coz I guess they don’t believe in any religion. Whatever we say to him about our religion or our prophet he won’t comprehend coz he doesn’t believe in anything. As a Muslim I can pray for him that may Allah guide them. Give them a credit to listen the video… yes they need to refrain about passing any comment without knowing but again their knowledge about religion is not enough.
@@sabrinalopez4714 they do not seek knowledge. They seek to deny knowledge that is provided to them. If they wanted knowledge they would do research on what they hear instead of flat out calling it “bulls**t” that’s where I see friction between what they say and what they actually portray. They still react to Islamics videos for the viewership, I don’t condone that personally
Indeed, There is No Greatest person and prophet in the whole world than Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)❤❤💛
Such a joke 😂
indeed, if you know, you know.
Life is a test,
Islam is the answer.
P!$$|@m is a mental disorder.🤣😂
@@NobodyForsomeone-hp9bv what you will get after this test ? 72 virgins ? 😂😂
Life is not a Test,
ISLAM is other name for intolerance, and probavly abbreviates to International Syndicate for Lies and Manipulation.
You must watch the series, The Muhammad by Zafar for enlightening facts.
@@NobodyForsomeone-hp9bv and you guys are failure in every sense 🤣🤣
@@khazurpakhmay Allah guide u brother 🤲
Jesus, Muhammad and Moses all three stood against oppression and taught us to support the opressed. May God almighty help our poor, oppressed and abused brothers and sisters in humanity, in Gaza.
Aatankwadi hai sab ke sab
The speaker is christian pastor who reverted to Islam after finding the truth.
A dangerous cult is what it is.
@@yeloSolo keep fooling yourself 😂
@@TasinHussain your scriptures speak about it.
The fact is you have been brainwashed to seek Muhammad and his Allah, which is not really different from the Old Testament. The sooner you realise the better.
It seems you have not even completed the Tharjuma of the un-holy book.
@@yeloSolokeep crying😂😂
@@yeloSololol what are talking about? How can someone be so ignorant 😂
He was a role model to all mankind. That's why God made him a father, a husband, a neighbour, a ruler
Thanks brother for saying peace upon him 🙏and thanks for this video.
I can relate to what Justin was saying about having religion and ideologies being forced upon you as a child. It puts a bad taste in your mouth and makes religion seem bad.
It wasn’t until I was 14 and started to read the Qu’rān myself with an open mind that my belief became real. The Qu’rān actually addresses humans directly and tells them to question and use their intellect. This really appealed to my logical mind.
I then learned about the life of Muhammad pbuh when I was 19 and started to read the Qu’rān again. I had a brand new experience this time because I had more context.
May Allah guide us all. insha’Allah. ♥️😊
❤
Your hearts are opening and it’s beautiful to watch the light of Islam on your faces 🫡💚
I do not see their heart opening nor do I see the light of islam on their faces.
Both these comments together killed me 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@stayspiritualReact to surah AL-mouminoun(THE-believers) by most merciful channel.
@@stayspiritual idk what exactly is funny about it. But glad someone found it funny.
@stayspiritual
You know what just don't listen to all comments and continue doing what you are doing right now but if you are truly seeking the truth and knowledge trust me you'll find it no matter how much time it takes from you and you don't know how your life will be inext years only Allah knows best
It takes time but as long as your heart and mind is open to learn and seek knowledge and find the truth you'll find it
I'm Muslim ❤❤
The truth doesn't care about your or anyone opinion the truth will remain the truth whatever the case so it's not a choice to have eternal life or not, the truth that there is eternal life the only choice we have if we will go to heaven or hell according to our beliefs and actions as Allah told us through his words and through the messengers
I love Muhammad, he is the greatest man in history
Thank u for blessing our ears by Muhammad pbuh life.
If you heard the real life story, you would definetly not say this!
@yeloSolo Thank you for reminding me to pray for him again. Praying for him heals worries and forgives sins.
In other hand, what about you ask God guidance now, before you face death then you ask God at that moment, which better!
@@HamzaHanma I do not live with fear for what comes after life, nor do I pray for anything afterlife.
@@HamzaHanma I have no intrest in death cults.
Btw did you know that you are only half of a man, meaning you have only half mental capacity of a man as per your Prophet PBUH.
@@yeloSolo well, may God guide me and u
لآ اِلَهَ اِلّا اللّهُ مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُوُل اللّهِ
May Allah bless us all
Yes
Thank you guys for helping to spread the prophet's name, may the almighty creator bless us all with His blessing, forgiveness and guidance to the truth, amen
I don't agree with what you say, but I click like just because you haven't been rude and you still try to be respectful. So thank you.
if anything they are disrespecting their own intellectual property and the historians that worked their heart out to find truth. This Hart guy didn't even want the prophet Mohammed to be first on the list. He had to accept it after finding evidences. But lil guy siting on his couch thinks he can do better . That kind of arrogance will always be fascinating to me
@@ma-px1nb
At least they did not disrespect islam or muslims. They did make up their mind already though, so they're not watching to do anything but ... watch. I don't know why people are expecting them to convert or something. They made up their mind, and we'll all find out at the end, won't we?
@ Muslims will always wish for non Muslims to find the creator. It’s just wishful thinking that maintains some of them here. Yes they did not disrespect Muslims and that’s because it’s not their first rodeo. They’ve been reacting to Islamic content for a while they know better than be disrespecting our religion. They don’t want that heat. So they allow themselves to do ANYTHING ELSE. As long as they can keep the Muslim views. their criticism are ill founded, make nonsense most of the time. They are just waisting viewers time and hope. Which I find calculated and manipulative.
I wanted to say more, but just as the Prophet Muhammed Sala ALLAHU alayhi wa salam Said : "Whoevers believes in ALLAH and the Final Day, let him say something good or he keept silent."
So I will say May ALLAH the Almighty guide you both to the Truth, if you are truely seeking the Truth. 😢
Thank you God for everything
Seriously, when you start focusing on how YOU feel about the way he is lecturing instead of what he is saying in the lecture, you know there's something wrong with the way you approach it. You will always find problems, issues , something you do not like. Because at the basis of it all, you reject the core Idea of God and his messengers. It does not matter How the person will explain it to you, the problem is not him , but you , and your "feelings". I wonder if y'all judge yourselves the way you judge others. You do not assess whether or not you are being fair to the subject. You dont do research but reject other people research's.. I mean.. What exactly is this ? Are you even serious about finding truth , or did you make your channel to reject GOD and make people adhere to your conviction ? People who have spent their entire live studying something, yet you feel like if YOU search a little bit you'll find something they did not find. Funny thing is , you dont even bother searching ! You just move on after questioning and rejecting ! That's pure arrogance. I know people are saying that you are respectful and all those thing, but I believe that you are disrespecting your own intelligence, you betray your logic many times, just to refute the idea of Allah.
I really hope you take time to read your comments. Because I want to say something very important: Your experience, what you went through, will never be a justification to negate the existence of a creator. If you use it to try to explain the non existence of God, you actually subscribe to the same philosophy that tyrant like Hitler used to commit atrocities: People are just atomes. God do not exist , there is no afterlife, no hell no paradise, so killing millions of people equal rearranging couple of atome in order to get what you want. The core idea of morality become null. Please use your logic, dont use your experience. Your experience will fail you, not your logic
I believe they are not assuming you guys are christian, they just wanna convey the message to you guys.❤
سبحان الله عندما قال في كتابه العزيز "ورفعنا لك ذكرك" عندما بحثت في فيديوهات هذه القناة وجدت ان هذا الفيديو اكثر مشاهدة في هذه القناة رغم مرور فقط 10 أيام
My humble advice: take a moment to genuinely investigate the claims in these videos. As Muslims, we are taught to question our beliefs, and many of us have studied other religions with that mindset.
But here, I see people dismissing these videos without consideration, only to divert the conversation to irrelevant points.
And honestly, it feels patronizing. We’ve done our research, and we’re encouraging you to do the same-yet it’s met with quick dismissal.
If you can't see him as a prophet, at least see the solutions he brought
no means to push passion on you. The Western world can really be revived by his teachings and we the Arab side of the world are good example yes there is poor countris, but due to wars that happened they became like this even my country Iraq is in ruins because of war the British divided my country and Americans destroyed it.
I love Islam ❤…
*Not You!* *Not Me!* *Not Our Parent!* *Nor Our Grandparent!* *Nor Any Our Ancestor!* that can match this man *(Muhammad)*
صلى الله عليك ياحبيبي ويارسولي ونبييي محمد صلاة قائمة دائمة ماتعاقب الليل والنهار
May Allah (God) guide y’all and all of us to the truth❤
the man, the father of his child, the husband of his wife, the leadership, warrior in battle and entrepreneur. yes, hes the greatest man. and the most important he achieve everything with the most realigius sides too,
sometimes man focus on worldly life only. thats rare and why he sucsses in both way earth and heaven. cz Allah promise him heaven but he still pray all night long every-day.
im just a little dust here still forget my 5 minutes prayer😢
Im a muslim, but this video is a lil bit more towards idolizing Prophet Muhammad the more i watch it. He's a great prophet but he didn't want people over idolizing him as the way Jesus being idolize by Christian.
لكننا المسلمين لا نعبد محمدمثلما تقول نقتدي به في سلوكنا وافعالنا واقوالنا هو قدوتنا وشفيعنا يوم القيامه وامتثال لامر الله اطع الله ورسوله هكذا امرنا الله بالقران مفهومك هو الغلط
No one is idolizing him, they're telling facts about who he are a peace be upon him
what the hell are you even saying? Saying that he is the best man created by Allah is idolizing him ? WHEN Allah himself told us that ? Pls sit this one out
Muhammad was no more than a messenger . He is only the last prophet. His lifestyle and biography recorded sayins are really cool romantiques reasonables and intresting i really encourage you to read it thanks ❤❤❤❤
لا إله إلا الله محمد رسول الله☝️☝️☝️☝️❤❤👍👍
It's not a drama and the quotations are from non Muslim scientists and scholars.. It's a strong faith that only touches the real believers who really understand the message and know the prophet peace be upon him.
Don't focus speaker pay attention to the massage please
Thanks for the video guys. You can read about bibliography of Muhammad S.A.W. to know more about Him from childhood until the end of His life. All of what He is going through in the whole life can be taken as the role model.
The Prophet Muhammad told about the word of god that prove the truth...why afrraid or won't to learn.just only to improve knowledge...you will see that the word of god or The AL-QU'RAN is PERFECT
The writing graphics behind you clearly reads STAY SPIRITUAL .. but what you are talking about is more about responding to the speaker's narrative style rather than listening, examining, concluding and responding to the essence of the content being narrated.. Everything seems very out of tune ...
thanks. Its like they forget their own motto when it comes to islam hahaha. The hell with spirituality when its time to discuss Allah 😂😂
@@ma-px1nb Yes, it was natural for them to focus on their spiritual specialty and take spiritual actions from the clips and take positive things for people.
there obviously view farming with the islamic videos, but deep deep down they know
“when I put this on, I’m going AMEN….. or Peace be Upon him”
😂 that was funny lol
Sub'han-Allah. Alhamdulilah. Muhammad Rasul Lal ❤
mashallah very thanks for you
😂🤣😂🤣
@@Zust_NishantMay Allah save shiva (the blue god) from hell
This is the easy question to the Atheist, that NO Atheist is able to answer?
● Firstly, you're certain of these facts by Logic, Science and human experience:
1- You have NOT created and shaped yourself!
2- You have NO control over When you're born!
3- You do NOT know when you die!
4- you did NOT choose your parents or your children!
5- You do NOT even know what might happen to you in the next hour or day!
6- You have NO influence on the creation or the existence of the Universe.
7- You have NO explanation of how the universe came to be, in such a fine tuned and perfect harmony...etc.
■ And I'm not going to ask you about your Monkey grand father, or perhaps the Fish grand mother, at the end of the day you're merely electrons randomly bumping into each other without a purpose!!
! And as you may know that All believers of the Atheist "religion" agree, on certain principles:
1- There's Not really Good and evil in the world!
2- There's NO difference between (Eating your food, murdering innocent people or having sex with your Child!) {Very shocking!}
3- Each Atheist can define moral values based on personal subjective experiences, and depending on the pains and pleasures they experience!
4- There's No need for the limited human beings, to seek guidance from a higher being, who is unlimited in his knowledge and wisdom!
5- There's no common laws govern all Atheists, just make up your mind as you go...etc
!!!! So my 3 easy questions are: ????
1- Can you prove to me morally and logically, that having sex with your kids good or evil?
(Provided that both of you agee to it)
2- Can you prove to me morally and logically, that murdering innocent people is good or evil?
3- Is there a moral and intellectual difference between the Criminal and an innocent person?
● I'm waiting for your honest reply if you truly stand for your beliefs!
● And if you fail to respond, than at least you now know that Atheism is dangerous for the society, and help spread Criminality.
Just relax bro, as a Muslim, you have the right and freedom to judge something that you can convince yourself of. continue to hone your insight with an open mind and don't feel intimidated by Muslims, Christians, Hindus or others.
God Chose His Final Messenger Prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H as Mercy & Guidance for The Worlds not for his people Only! Other Prophet's or leaders were their for their own people or goals or desires (except Prophet's)
12:25 you mean he is forcing you to belive in it? No. It's your choice to watch the content. He didn't ask you to watch him. If you have such mentality, your solution is to stop watching it. Simple😄
If someone said this is your father and u say i don't think so ..i mean u don't believe reality and facts
Slaves of rapist mommd giving trash logic...🤣😂 Father's proof can be tested by DNA test...
I believe or see a bit of arrogance in the reactions but I also see good intentions and hope which can lead in whatever right way you are in currently, specially the guy on the right.
if it wasn't for his mate, that guy on the right would already be a Muslim. When he starts seeing logic in the teaching of islam, the other one is always next to him, reminding him of "life experiences" that is supposed to "negate" (?) God's existence. May the creator ( they hate when we say Allah) guide them on the right path
not just a little bit, they are jews look at their background, they reject the prophets
yes...i hope you read about Muhammad and tell us
People started worshipping prophets like Abraham, David and Jesus, though these messengers strictly followed monotheism. People in ignorance even worship ordinary men like Sai Baba, Rajneesh , Nithyananda etc.
But 2.5 billion muslims are ready to give their life for Prophet Mohammad . Not a single muslim will worship him.😮.
You may find it insightful to focus on the substance rather then style. Just a food for thought.
Wallahi every true muslim if you can prove Islam wrong will leave it 👍🏾
"""Growth is the basis of disbelief, so Pharaoh, Abulhab, Qarun, Nimrud and others disbelieved, and still most people have grown up in their hearts, so the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: ""He does not smell Paradise."
Only Allah guides hearts. You may want these guys to believe but if they’re not actually seeking the truth, you’ll never be able to convince them.
No nodbody near .0000000000001% infinite times Muhammad
Shaykh Khalid Yasin, who is speaking in the video, used to hear Malcolm X speak back in the day! They are expressive in the same way.... same way MLK spoke passionately. It baffles me how this could rub people the wrong way.
@10:10 "Heaven lies under the feet of the mother." Prophet Muhummed (saww). Even though he lost the touch of a mother at 6 years old.
The greatest attainment is heaven, yet the importance of mother is more. Think.
10:10 is not q random nombre think ❤ you are good person ❤
❤❤ From india (bihar)
Regardless of being a christian or whatever still we will share it and recommend it 😅
نريد ترجمه على الفيديوهات كى تعم الفائده ويكون الثواب أعظم جزاكم الله خير الجزاء على ما تبذلونه من مجهود فى نشر الدعوه الاسلاميه ونصرة الدين الحق 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
يقولون أشياء سلبية عن الإسلام
Yes, the truth is hard to accept. It takes sincerity to do that. And if that sincerity is not there you are only left with assumptions to look away from it.
Beautiful Islam Quran my Ferind
Prove Islam ☪️ wrong and any other religion right, and I’ll convert on the spot.
They were not comparing the prophets only they were comparing all the Men to find the greatest man. That's why he mentioned Gandhi, etc.
Is it really hard to understand?
You always insist people to think from another perspective have you tried to try it on yourself?
You always seem very eager about the fact that people should think like the way you think.
To be honest you guys just like to run your mouth and like to criticize what is in front of you.
I agree with all your comments
He didn’t put Jesus or any other prophets in the list when making comparison because we Muslims don’t make distinction between the prophets
Why is the man on the right talking so much and looking a bit arrogant? I want to tell you something. Your opinion doesn't matter. The truth will remain the truth no matter how much people try to deny it. If you are afraid of changing, don't speak arrogantly as if you were the center of the universe.
Let me give you some glad tidings to the people who don’t wanna live forever. You should forget God so he forgets you and doesn’t give you an eternal life
Quran(7:172)
When your Lord asked all the offspring of Adam (before their birth), "Am I not your Lord?" All of them testified and bore witness to their testimony that on the Day of Judgment they would not say, "We were not aware of this (fact),"
Are you aware that there are other scriptures from other faiths that say similar things?
Allohumma sholli ala sayyidina Muhammad Wa ala ali sayyidina Muhammad
You know I have to say, it’s good that you question things but it’s interesting how you perceive the religion. It’s almost as if you’re battling with your Conscious/sub-conscious bias. In any case, I wouldn’t disregard something the prophet did because others have - it just shows his humanity. We are all humans, some of us are selected by the creator to teach.
Allah chose Moses Jesus Mohammed. WHO ARE WE TO CRITICS THEM ?
You tube videos need audio and visual effects to attract people attention. If you want proper discussion in soft tone, then you need to discuss things with Scholars in this case Islamic scholars.
May Allah guide all the blind followers of fake christ(jesus_paul delusion)
لن اقول لك ان تفعل هذا وذاك لكنني انصحك بأخذ كتاب عن سيرة رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم وقراءتها في بث مباشر
ملاحظة انا خريج جامعة تخصص علم النفس وقد كنت اقرأ لغة جسدكما لذالك اظن انكما بذلتما المجهود للانفتاح على امر غريب عليكما كما تعلمان ان تكونا وسط مجتمع لايفهم الاسلام وان يكون لديه معلومات مغلوطة من وسائل الإعلام لذالك انصحك فعلا ومن كل قلبي اقرء عن الاسلام
You have said a lot of things when putting your reactions into words, but at the end of the day, you have said yes read about this and that people, yet dismissed his request that you should read about Muhammad PBUH; so please why not consider reading the biography, for example, so at the end of the week, you might say, I know about this prophet (and here is what I think, based on what you have found out or read>!
They would have to actually care to be able to do this. I dont believe they care. They've been reacting for a looking time. They never do follow up research. The refute the infos they find or they say "its good teaching but it does not prove Allah's existence." And then they move on and never look back.
I Recommend you to read “ The Sealed Nectar” by Safiur Rahman Al Mubarakpuri. It is a comprehensive biography of the prophet Muhammad PBUH.
Just read it.....
My friend muhammed brought a book and he claim it’s from god
While jesus didn’t bring a book the “bible” its sayings of unknown persons
Boudha is nothing more a way of life
Why its hard I don’t understand just examine the claims of quran if it’s not true everything collapse and if not it is simply the truth
MY friend, MAY ALLAH guide you polytheist human worshippers into Islam.(I fear, Paul will face a tremendous punishment in the day of judgement)
How many followers and kind of teaching they have?
الله اكبر 👑🕌🕋🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Got NEWS FOR YA FOLKS.
MOHAMED DID NOT COME WITH ISLAM..
ISLAM CAME BEFORE
ABRAHAM IS THE FIRST MUSLIM ❤
PEACE
Actually Adam is the first Muslim
Muslim mean is the one who submits to Allah through worship
Only a fool would compare real monotheistic religions to pagan bhuddism... 😂
What people believe and reality about Muhammad is different.
What christians Believe and reality is so so different.. May Allah guide you polytheist people
@deceiver-paul stop prostrating to kaba and stone.
May god guide you to light.
@@Jibreel-jt1qhYa jahil man worshippers, May Allah guide you polytheist pagan into Islam. +stop spreading false propaganda
@@Jibreel-jt1qh Allah/God is not a human+God do not go to toilet and he don't need any price to forgive sins(believing all those fallacies are pure blasphemy) think deeply and accept Islam
@deceiver-paul
If muhamad will say something false in allah name then allah will cut his aorta
(Quran 69:44-46)
At deathbed muhamad said he feel that his aorta is being cut by the poison given at khaibar
(Sahih al bukhari 4428)
This implies that muhmad used to say false in allah name, he fabricated verse for his own benefit.
Muhmad made verse to justify marriage with daughter in law zainab
(Quran 33:36 33:37)
Muhmad made verse to justify his marriage with any woman
(Quran 33:53)
Muhamad justified intimacy with slaves
(Sunan an nasai 3959)
Qura n is not revelation from al lah, verse is made by muhmad for his own benefit.
Follow real prophet and real god.
Good luck finding one let us know
By the way, The one on the right looks similar to wwe superstar Kevin owns....does he relate to him in any way?
lol, not we know of
Read the short story about prophet Muhammed pbuh and the old lady.
Plz react to the last sermon of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
✨🤝✨👍
🛑Peace be upon him prophet Mohamed to answer you about why he said go read about prophet mohamed and not others if you are arguing for something thing or for specific message you put the your arguments to that message and that’s last part was call to action it’s encouraging the people to find out more about that’s message so it’s clear
REACT TO SURAH YASSIN FROM THE MERCIFUL SERVANT. HAVE A GOOD DAY🤲
I don’t like those two they never gonna understand the message they just looking for the person who speak when you look to their entry you know who they are, and you can tell their background You see the video with the one eye yall know what I-meant
Why did I watch this?
🤷 thanks anyway 🖖
@stayspiritual No, thank you. As a Muslim, I sensed what you were aiming for with that video. The response felt passive and somewhat closed-minded-it didn’t resonate as genuinely spiritual.
It’s okay; I understand the deep-rooted resentment. You can't help it. No worries about it, its not your fault.
@@OAB9282 thank you. Idk how people don’t see it. Their aim is pretty clear to me .
They basically calls alll the subscribers & viewers stupid fools. Yet self respect less viewers watching their videos 😂
I came to their video almost a year later. After seeing it in my recommendation again
I don't think you are a stupid fool, but we are allowed to think differently. Life would be pretty boring if we all thought the same thing. So I say... appreciate the diversity. Your welcome here anytime, even if it is just once a year. 😉🖖
@stayspiritual paths can be different but destination/truth is one, so, if u don't want to accept it for the sake of maintaining diversity. None can do anything about it.
By watching reaction videos u can only know 1/2% u might even have some doubts too.
I think u guys r christians right? According to ur talks, u guys don't even know prophets marry too. May be in the history of prophets only JESUS didn't/COUDN'T marry. & u surprised hearing prophet Muhammad's(s) marriage & kingdom.
Do u believe in trinity? Ur answer would explain ur intellect. Waiting..
Guys
Stop giving them views
No need to watch
Any way
I hope this does not pop up to me again
?
What did they do that's bad?
@@habiladam6363 they are not searching for truth. They think they already have the truth. In a way they react to these videos to dissect them and find any trivial flaw that they can focus on. Today was the narrator's speech.
@@ma-px1nb
oh, ok. They used to be good before. I didn't watch the whole thing cos I had to go
@ yes, I also had hope that they would do research on the things they encounter here. But it’s clear to me that they just react and move on. It’s not about searching truth for them. We are the one mistaken
Seeing their faces like they're really those ignorant persons but hells r their real place and Michael was mathematician and historian but who r u dude 😂 have u ever research on anything
Exactly, some random pagans on youtube, could be jews too
I’m Muslim and I’m saddened to see this comment. Don’t ever presume to know where people will end up in the afterlife. You are NOT God, you don’t do the judging or know what is in James’ and Justin’s hearts.
James and Justin, I enjoy your videos and keep it up! 👍🏼
@@acy2004 I didn't say they'll go to hell but their acts and lack of knowledge and ignorance will lead them to hellfire, they don't know anything or any knowledge bout any books how they claim without researching or knowing??so their eyes r not blind their hearts,, Allah guided them who r truthful and honest with their hearts, if they don't change they surely in hellfire
@@acy2004 those who reject truth are going to hell
React to surah almouminoun by most merceful channel (mind-blowing).
ha-ha...seems a little suspect...especially the "categories" used. The one thing that was NOT noted in Hart's list was that the overarching assessment using his categories was of INFLUENCE, NOT of CHARACTER. If character (values/teachings) was used, another list results. Shouldn't really cast stones at other leaders when Mohamed had a child bride, betrothed at 6, consummated relationship at 9??) Yeah, probably better to get an un-biased set of categories analyzed by a more impartial presentation. I liked the banter guys, and the idea that observation is important (the proof is in the pudding, not in the directions)..people are a ball of yarn...made me smile :)
sir you do realize what you said was the norm back then or hell even 200 years ago in the US people had child brides lol you're viewing this through the lens of presentism
انت منحاز
May Allah forgive you. Aisha was 16 when she got married to the prophet. Consummated relationship at 17. The prophet was not a lustul man. If you havent read about his life, sit this one out
@@ma-px1nb you are brainwashed 😂
@ like I said, there’s only one truth. So I’m either brainwashed.. or you are wrong and driving yourself to hellfire. Either way, I like my odds better because at least I base my opinion on verified knowledge. You base yours on trolling and mocking one’s religion. How fun is that ☺️. We’ll find out when we die 😂
Nice perceptive,Justin. Everything's okay right?
12:19 bro, how to be happy already explained by Qur'an very detail, just read it bro. pleaseeee
Also, I wouldn’t judge the Islamic scholars based on the judgment of personal comments you get from viewers, difficult… I know
What is that you have makes you happy then????
Lots of things, but happiness comes and goes... it is not my goal. What gives me peace, appears to be my growing ability to accept what is.
@@stayspiritual Amazing; Contentment is an unconsumable treasure. Wish you the best. Peace.
6 - 1 = 5 💯