You probably don't remember this specific game, but you ran a game for me in one of the many online groups you are no doubt a part of some years ago. I was elated to find out you have a thriving channel tonight! We played an AD&D game, and you were one of the main inspirations I had to run my own game - one that ran for several years and ended last year! How fitting that, in the process of planning my next campaign setting, I should find you again! Thanks for what you contribute to the community, friend!
That’s awesome! Thanks so much, I’m happy to have found such a great online community to play the games I love. AD&D is such a fun system, your lost here makes me want to run it again when my schedule frees up. I hope your campaign is amazing
My players love the cities and villages I give them. They're all well mapped and look extremely realistic in their layouts. How do I do it? I trace portions of real world city street maps and add my own buildings. Is that cheating? I dunno. All I know is that it is fast and it works.
What's that meme advice? If for some reason you need to wing a megadungeon, just get the map of some mall or museum and use its already confusing layout.
Traders, enslaving, undead is the plot of the 1st Edition module "Egg of the Phoenix" an Illusionist makes them look like weird humanoids and they sell them to the people of Nimbortan. Pure luck that you hit on one of the best mods there is!
Merchant worshiping a veteran- sounds like a good opportunity to add some lore about a saint or hero of the city 🧐 Awesome video as always, will definitely implement some of these ideas going forward
One thing as a viewer is putting time stamps in your videos for when you switch topics. It really helps as a reference if you want to go back to a video multiple times to listen to a specific topic. I love your content, keep em coming!
In the Chaosium book for Sanctuary known from Thieves' World, you get a random encounter roll every 15 minutes starting from the moment you walk out the door on the morning. The city is packed with people. Whatever you do, there's a chance some idiots are going to walk by. Most are not even going to be hostile, unless the PCs look like they're good-for-nothing paramilitary bums. You can use the other variations on encounter charts. A d12 roll for daytime, and a d20 roll at night. A different chart for "regions" or neighbourhoods of the city. Weekly city events that affect the place as a whole. Rumour tables with less obvious city information. Most cities can be traversed in less than a day. Getting someplace isn't hard, the game becomes essentially a pointcrawl. The PCs point at the city map (local city maps are not hard to find) and a few random encounter rolls are made depending on which areas they need to cross. Most of the city will not be mapped, unless the players and the DM really want to sit there and roll up how many bakers a street has. Which is what you did in Sanctuary from Chaosium. Mordheim is set in a city that is definitely hostile and hard to traverse where warbands need to move from building to building as they search a warp-torn ruined and half-inhabited place for loot and warpstone.
first time ever running a crawler, the players are stuck in a city where a portal to the feywild has been opened and the city is warping around it. This video came in at the perfect time!
I've been on the lookout for something like this! It's a rather simple perspective change from a GM standpoint and one I'm kicking myself for not landing on personally ages ago. I've always been intimidated at running city crawls for some reason, likely because i'm a homebody that doesn't leave his apartment much, lol. But I've been floating an idea in my head for running an adventure that lands the party in a place like the old Walled City Kowloon, but D&D-fied: small, tight alleys that twist and turn endlessly, leading you up and down floors and balconies of tightly packed apartment high-rises, with "shops" being nothing more then a unkempt dwarf in a wife beater with an outside facing apartment window open, hawking silver baubles he's smelting/molding/hammering in his living room, scorch marks and tools all over the place. Or a halfling couple running a bar in their small family kitchen as their kids run around the patrons' ankles, with the eldest making frequent trips to their distillery: a converted bathroom (or worse yet, an unconverted one). elderly elves sit on the rooftops in a listless daze for days on end, smoking pipeweed they harvest from the few plants found in this open area, having long lost themselves to this tired and compact world and recounting the "good old days, before the town lost it's soul" of centuries past to whatever soul is around. the sewers are just packed densely with kobolds doing maintenance while creating new tunnels and blocking off collapsed ones, animal messengers are seen bouncing across the laundry lines slung between buildings to pass along messages. Goblins live among garbage and use weapons and armour made from salavaged trash shoddily stitched or hammered together. almost like the area is a living megadungeon, but more tightly packed, chaotic and fluid in nature. Now toss in lots of minor magics and fantastic elements: street preachers of long-forgotten gods peddling minor cure wounds at exorbitant prices, hedge wizards selling shoddily made everburning torches that glow with the strength of a candle, thieves selling heavily diluted monster poisons mixed with partially fermented fruit juices as street drugs to anyone looking for a quick buzz while making crazy claims on it's origin, etc... Throw in gangs from different cultures and walks of life vying for power: an old orc warboss with a makeshift street gang made up of anyone with a weapon looking to prove themselves, some elves who run a tightly run russian-mafia-esque ring of corruption among various community leaders allowing them to trade in illicit affairs, etc... Toss in a few problematic parts to shake up the already powderkeg of a status quo like some newly arrived cultists looking to gain a foothold in this potentially acolyte-dense area, a viral outbreak of ghoul fever occurs in this densely populated area, an entire building just disappears and leaves a hole in the ground giving access to multiple sub-basement/underground areas, members of both the community watch AND local gang are going missing and they're blaming each other... Listening to this video, it never really hit me to run it similar to how i would a hexcrawl or dungeoncrawl. I'm thinking to run it with each "hex" being a couple stories of a given city block or something, and just layer it atop itself for small patches of communities or districts. outside of specific "hex-tricts" being put aside for specific NPCs or organizations, i could setup a random encounter table and just have the PCs take "dungeon-turns" to roughly explore a hex and get a feel for it's particular vibe (which i could roll to see if there's anything of note, like i would with any outdoor hex), if they get lost in the maze of alleys and uninhabited places used as thoroughfares, as well as if they run into any local or situation.
The dragon in the city could be a dragon in mortal guise. This would be hidden from the players, but could be a way to introduce a particular mover or hint to a quest or something.
Awesome tables at the end. I will use them for my sandbox campaign. Thank you ❤ Also a good add-on for running cities is „Cess and Citadel“ or Vornheim.
Doing a full city adventure has always been a holy grail of a campaign that I've wanted to try, but never had the opportunity as a player or DM. The adventure module Baldur's Gate Descent into Avernus has a surprisingly robust section on adventuring in Baldur's Gate, even though most of the module takes place in Avernus.
I highly recommend 'The Nocturnal Table' by Gabor Lux for city adventures. We are lucky, in Hungarian, the Day Tables are also available, I hope he is translating it for you soon.
I live in a fairly walkable city. It's over 3 million people, so walking from one side of the city would take hours, but in general, I could walk from one district/area to another in 10 to 20 minutes. There are just a lot of districts! I think 10 minute turns are still appropriate to a city crawl game, especially for the default medieval sort of setting most D&D games use. Cities aren't going to be that large, and it shouldn't take hours to get from one district to another. Other than that, I think you've got a lot of great advice for city adventures.
I'm running a game of RIFTS (Savage Rifts, to be exact) and I've been avoiding going to Chi Town because I really don't know how to do it in the game. I never thought of doing it like a dungeon crawl. Nor have I considered it like a hex crawl. This is brilliant.
I used Atelier Clandestin's City Pointcrawl Generator for a huge city that I have coming up. I'm also planning on using Judge's Guild Ready Reference Sheets for random encounters there. The party is looking for a kidnapped person and the city itself is run by hostile warlords and an evil church. They are trying to fly under the radar. Should be interesting.
Very cool ideas. The tables reminds me of many years ago I had done the same thing for creating storylines; rolling from a table of character archetypes and matching each with a roll from a storyline-role table, end up with things like Recluse Turncoat, Nobility Sidekick, Artist Mentor, etc. Was really handy in making NPCs to fill factions or create historical lore. I had a lot of fun with that, but had completely forgotten about it until I saw your video. Cheers!
@BanditsKeep Thanks, I always had the most fun rolling multiple story-roles for each character to make things more interesting, then I'd just play around with the order of events. Have a goodun
@@BanditsKeepAfter the Rhondian Empire fell, the City of Waterfront was officially taken over by the wealthy merchant families which had always ruled from the shadows in the past. Being particularly snooty, their first order of business was to confine the "undesirables" to a small rectangular district roughly 280ft long by 130ft wide. The local thieves' and assassins' guilds were both quick to capitalize on this, directing construction of the bizarre vertical town themselves. Because of this, only the guilds know how to reach the upper levels. One can only get so high up using the external walkways...
Great video! Love the idea of using passers-by llike dressing in a dungeon. When you describe it, dungeon crawl procedure works really well in urban scenarios: You walk slowly looking into the windows and the alleys and inspecting places of interest, and this behavior can bring attention of unwelcoming dwellers. I wonder if it is enough to play as a sheriff, patrolling streets every day.
I generally GM Modern Superhero games but something drew me to your channel. I realised how I could use this to randomise plots. This type of villain is in town to do this to this type of citizen. Very cool.
Excellent video. I've always been saying: cities are the same as dungeons, its just a different ratio of threats vs. Friendlies. From a storytelling perspective to be clear.
Never seen you or your channel before. Something about the video preview (thumbnail or title or combination thereof) hinted me that when you say "D&D", you don't mean D&D by WotC/Hasbro. And this is why I clicked.
I've done kind of a point crawl with the official Lankhmar stuff transplanted to a motte and bailey castle floating in the center of the celestial sphere in my Spelljammer campaign
I love the idea of interpreting the dice feels like I'm an oracle reading the bones as they crackle in the fire. hmmm i see ....300.... yes. 300 orcs.... In a Bar!
Damn, two different city related videos by two different dnd youtubers on the same day? Just as I'm planning for some city stuff for my next session? Well I'll be
You can also treat large groups of NPCs as environmental hazard. Not even the strongest barbarian can walk around the Kaaba the wrong way round without being trampled or taken by the flow. As you were talking about the uneventful NPCs moving trough the city kind of as tapestry, I had to imagine a central square or a city block where 3-4 large streets meet with some offset, so that during the daytime or a least during rush hour, a kind of natural malstroem of people forms. Maybe it's clockwise in the morning and anti-clockwise in the evening with people streaming in and out of this or that district. Maybe it even forms eddies of some sort at corners or market boths. The same rules can apply to large populated marketplaces. Ever wandered a Christmas Market in NYC? Sometimes, you just gotta go with the flow and make a round around the ice rink to return to that sweet hot toddy place, because you just cannot move those 3 meters against the flow. And rightly executed, a party runs the risk of being separated and individual party members getting lost, which can make a whole scenario, especially when filling / compensating for player absence. Thanks for the inspirations in the video.
I run a Sunday 1e Lankhmar Campaign each week, My (7) Players never leave the city, 2/3 of the enemy are Humans, This is a Thief city with Faction Gangs, a Thieves Guild, City Watch, Normal Pedestrials, and a huge Sewer system as well, if a Monster its normally found in there, the players made all human except 2 Half-elves I allowed, were about 3-4 months in, and 2-3 Level ... Besides all the Adventures Ive come up with I also have all the TSR, DCC, and Savage Worlds Lankhmar stuff for inspiration. MY Lankhmar Citie Wandering Monsters: Pedestrian (they may overhear a Rumor), adventure Party (very Small chance), Thieve (Is there a Bounty on their read or the thieves' leader want them), Guard & Bounty Hunters (Do they have a Wanted Poster on them).
One confusion I had is, the undead on your roll table aren't any less (or more) common than anything else. If you're only rolling one die, each result has the same chance. If you're rolling 2 or more and I missed it, then 1 needs to come off the bottom😂
This is one reason I like to reference Justin Alexander's excellent thought experiment with urbancrawls - it deals with exactly this issue. Into the Cess & Citadel is another great resource.
@@stewi009Or it could mean that you found the wrong person. Someone dangerous, if you were very unlucky. Using the same logic, the paths between locations are relationships between people and factions are biomes. In my city crawls people and relations between them are generated and locations are secondary, derived from those people. Recently I started cyberpunk campaign in which I use depth crawl rules to generate a web of relationship that leads deep into a sect of nanobit worshippers. I'm curious how it will go.
I don't actually like random encounters, so I tendo to plan them more like side missions. Also, if the city is big enough, I make public and private transportation available to move through it so the plot is not delayed because the pc's have gotten lost. As an example of both points, I had the pc's, who usually moved along the city riding on a chaotic version of a subway, have a subway accident that left them stranded in a not-actually-uninhabited cavern complex under the city complete with its own ecosystem, insidiously dangerous flora, two different creature settlements at war with each other over resources, the ghost of a lovely lost dog and, at the end of it, some look at the homeless and disposessed and homeless surviving indide the crevices of "civilised" society
@@BanditsKeep I mean, the city setting lends itself to be a sandbox with infinite options but I tend to have *things* happening in the shadows: conspirations, cults, movements, guild interests, government stuff, mob wars... players tend to eventually find one or more of those threads and, hopefully latch on to them
How I handle getting lost in any environment city or wilderness is just add time. If its a village or town perhaps 1d6 x 5 minutes or a city 1d4 hours, a ocean vovage 1d6 days. I used to map cities but have found it extremely time consuming and a waste of time. It's much better to subdivide a city into districts with each district having its own set of day/night encounters, adventures, etc. For each district have a list of one or two of the following. A tavern, inn, shop, armorer and trader, you can even use the same one but with different names if your really lazy.
@@BanditsKeep there were very few representational maps of cities before the modern era, so spreading out a bird's eye view in front of the players doesn't match how their characters would experience the urban space. On the flip-side, a map, especially a labeled one, can include clues, dangers, resources and points of interest, allowing the players to take the lead in the narrative.
I concluded that cities worked best as point crawl, and just narrate the travel for flavour. There should be a hundred taverns in a 25000 person city. This just didn’t justify mapping etc to me.
I dunno, i think if you want to keep it a little more medieval most cities are actually very very small, tho I will still this for my campaign where there are a bunch of abandoned buildings,
I don't get the purpose of treating a city like a dungeon. It doesn't really matter how long it takes the heroes to get from their inn to a sage's house or whatever. Just have a few NPCs prepped for the players to talk to when they need to (street vendors, a town crier, an official, a guard, a beggar, some kids). And have several shops handy, so you can say "you pass some shoemaker shops; up ahead are stationer shops." (Craftsmen in the same trade always lived near each other in medieval cities, for some reason.)
Sponsored by Only Crits new Kickstarter Guillmans Guide to Speed: www.kickstarter.com/projects/onlycrits/guillmans-guide-to-speed?ref=d00ssx
You probably don't remember this specific game, but you ran a game for me in one of the many online groups you are no doubt a part of some years ago. I was elated to find out you have a thriving channel tonight! We played an AD&D game, and you were one of the main inspirations I had to run my own game - one that ran for several years and ended last year! How fitting that, in the process of planning my next campaign setting, I should find you again! Thanks for what you contribute to the community, friend!
That’s awesome! Thanks so much, I’m happy to have found such a great online community to play the games I love. AD&D is such a fun system, your lost here makes me want to run it again when my schedule frees up. I hope your campaign is amazing
My players love the cities and villages I give them. They're all well mapped and look extremely realistic in their layouts. How do I do it? I trace portions of real world city street maps and add my own buildings. Is that cheating? I dunno. All I know is that it is fast and it works.
That’s a great idea
That's not cheating, that's smart DMing! Excellent idea
I just take the entire early modern period. You're not even in a fantasy setting, you are in Marseilles.
What's that meme advice? If for some reason you need to wing a megadungeon, just get the map of some mall or museum and use its already confusing layout.
Just don't use New Orleans. Completely unrealistic.
Traders, enslaving, undead is the plot of the 1st Edition module "Egg of the Phoenix" an Illusionist makes them look like weird humanoids and they sell them to the people of Nimbortan. Pure luck that you hit on one of the best mods there is!
That sounds super interesting, I’ll have to check it out
The quality of the information in your videos is the best for OSR.
Thank You!
Brilliant- Loving the idea of roll tables for city encounters!
Thank You!
Merchant worshiping a veteran- sounds like a good opportunity to add some lore about a saint or hero of the city 🧐 Awesome video as always, will definitely implement some of these ideas going forward
Great idea!
One thing as a viewer is putting time stamps in your videos for when you switch topics. It really helps as a reference if you want to go back to a video multiple times to listen to a specific topic.
I love your content, keep em coming!
Good idea
Be that fan that lists timestamps for the channel.
In the Chaosium book for Sanctuary known from Thieves' World, you get a random encounter roll every 15 minutes starting from the moment you walk out the door on the morning. The city is packed with people. Whatever you do, there's a chance some idiots are going to walk by. Most are not even going to be hostile, unless the PCs look like they're good-for-nothing paramilitary bums.
You can use the other variations on encounter charts. A d12 roll for daytime, and a d20 roll at night. A different chart for "regions" or neighbourhoods of the city. Weekly city events that affect the place as a whole. Rumour tables with less obvious city information.
Most cities can be traversed in less than a day. Getting someplace isn't hard, the game becomes essentially a pointcrawl. The PCs point at the city map (local city maps are not hard to find) and a few random encounter rolls are made depending on which areas they need to cross. Most of the city will not be mapped, unless the players and the DM really want to sit there and roll up how many bakers a street has. Which is what you did in Sanctuary from Chaosium.
Mordheim is set in a city that is definitely hostile and hard to traverse where warbands need to move from building to building as they search a warp-torn ruined and half-inhabited place for loot and warpstone.
Cool
first time ever running a crawler, the players are stuck in a city where a portal to the feywild has been opened and the city is warping around it. This video came in at the perfect time!
Nice
I've been on the lookout for something like this! It's a rather simple perspective change from a GM standpoint and one I'm kicking myself for not landing on personally ages ago.
I've always been intimidated at running city crawls for some reason, likely because i'm a homebody that doesn't leave his apartment much, lol.
But I've been floating an idea in my head for running an adventure that lands the party in a place like the old Walled City Kowloon, but D&D-fied: small, tight alleys that twist and turn endlessly, leading you up and down floors and balconies of tightly packed apartment high-rises, with "shops" being nothing more then a unkempt dwarf in a wife beater with an outside facing apartment window open, hawking silver baubles he's smelting/molding/hammering in his living room, scorch marks and tools all over the place. Or a halfling couple running a bar in their small family kitchen as their kids run around the patrons' ankles, with the eldest making frequent trips to their distillery: a converted bathroom (or worse yet, an unconverted one). elderly elves sit on the rooftops in a listless daze for days on end, smoking pipeweed they harvest from the few plants found in this open area, having long lost themselves to this tired and compact world and recounting the "good old days, before the town lost it's soul" of centuries past to whatever soul is around. the sewers are just packed densely with kobolds doing maintenance while creating new tunnels and blocking off collapsed ones, animal messengers are seen bouncing across the laundry lines slung between buildings to pass along messages. Goblins live among garbage and use weapons and armour made from salavaged trash shoddily stitched or hammered together. almost like the area is a living megadungeon, but more tightly packed, chaotic and fluid in nature.
Now toss in lots of minor magics and fantastic elements: street preachers of long-forgotten gods peddling minor cure wounds at exorbitant prices, hedge wizards selling shoddily made everburning torches that glow with the strength of a candle, thieves selling heavily diluted monster poisons mixed with partially fermented fruit juices as street drugs to anyone looking for a quick buzz while making crazy claims on it's origin, etc...
Throw in gangs from different cultures and walks of life vying for power: an old orc warboss with a makeshift street gang made up of anyone with a weapon looking to prove themselves, some elves who run a tightly run russian-mafia-esque ring of corruption among various community leaders allowing them to trade in illicit affairs, etc...
Toss in a few problematic parts to shake up the already powderkeg of a status quo like some newly arrived cultists looking to gain a foothold in this potentially acolyte-dense area, a viral outbreak of ghoul fever occurs in this densely populated area, an entire building just disappears and leaves a hole in the ground giving access to multiple sub-basement/underground areas, members of both the community watch AND local gang are going missing and they're blaming each other...
Listening to this video, it never really hit me to run it similar to how i would a hexcrawl or dungeoncrawl. I'm thinking to run it with each "hex" being a couple stories of a given city block or something, and just layer it atop itself for small patches of communities or districts. outside of specific "hex-tricts" being put aside for specific NPCs or organizations, i could setup a random encounter table and just have the PCs take "dungeon-turns" to roughly explore a hex and get a feel for it's particular vibe (which i could roll to see if there's anything of note, like i would with any outdoor hex), if they get lost in the maze of alleys and uninhabited places used as thoroughfares, as well as if they run into any local or situation.
Cool
I got a big city coming up to run, perfect timing. Thank you!
Awesome, let me know how it goes
Listening through your back catalogue has been my new comfort activity for the past week or so. This is the first new notification I've clicked!
Awesome, thanks!
The dragon in the city could be a dragon in mortal guise. This would be hidden from the players, but could be a way to introduce a particular mover or hint to a quest or something.
For sure!
Awesome tables at the end. I will use them for my sandbox campaign. Thank you ❤
Also a good add-on for running cities is „Cess and Citadel“ or Vornheim.
Thanks!
I Love ALL Bandit's Keep videos! Especially his back catalog.
Thank You!
Doing a full city adventure has always been a holy grail of a campaign that I've wanted to try, but never had the opportunity as a player or DM. The adventure module Baldur's Gate Descent into Avernus has a surprisingly robust section on adventuring in Baldur's Gate, even though most of the module takes place in Avernus.
That’s cool, I’ll have to check that out
I highly recommend 'The Nocturnal Table' by Gabor Lux for city adventures. We are lucky, in Hungarian, the Day Tables are also available, I hope he is translating it for you soon.
I own the Nocturnal Tables - very good product!
I live in a fairly walkable city. It's over 3 million people, so walking from one side of the city would take hours, but in general, I could walk from one district/area to another in 10 to 20 minutes. There are just a lot of districts! I think 10 minute turns are still appropriate to a city crawl game, especially for the default medieval sort of setting most D&D games use. Cities aren't going to be that large, and it shouldn't take hours to get from one district to another.
Other than that, I think you've got a lot of great advice for city adventures.
Makes sense - of course medieval cities have nothing to do with my fantastical world.
This is a genius idea. Not in a hundred years I would ever come up with this. I love it!
Thank You!
I'm running a game of RIFTS (Savage Rifts, to be exact) and I've been avoiding going to Chi Town because I really don't know how to do it in the game. I never thought of doing it like a dungeon crawl. Nor have I considered it like a hex crawl. This is brilliant.
If you try these techniques, let me know how it works out. Is savage rifts using savage worlds?
channel seems to be steadily growing! I love it how hyped you are in the first five minutes talking about city campaigns. heck yeah city crawls!
Thanks!
I used Atelier Clandestin's City Pointcrawl Generator for a huge city that I have coming up. I'm also planning on using Judge's Guild Ready Reference Sheets for random encounters there. The party is looking for a kidnapped person and the city itself is run by hostile warlords and an evil church. They are trying to fly under the radar. Should be interesting.
Sounds awesome
I'm working on building an urban setting for my next Pathfinder 2e campaign, this was a big help! Thank you!
Awesome!
Great thumbnail as usual, makes it really easy to identify you quickly!
Thanks, I love finding fun art
Another great video. Super relevant to one of my upcoming Metropolis City Campaign. Perfect timing.
Awesome
I love city adventures! I'll definitely be using some of your suggestions in my next campaign.
Awesome!
Very cool ideas. The tables reminds me of many years ago I had done the same thing for creating storylines; rolling from a table of character archetypes and matching each with a roll from a storyline-role table, end up with things like Recluse Turncoat, Nobility Sidekick, Artist Mentor, etc. Was really handy in making NPCs to fill factions or create historical lore. I had a lot of fun with that, but had completely forgotten about it until I saw your video. Cheers!
That’s a great use of this technique I will have to try it!
@BanditsKeep Thanks, I always had the most fun rolling multiple story-roles for each character to make things more interesting, then I'd just play around with the order of events. Have a goodun
That Walled-Cityesque illustration reminded me of something I've always wanted to try.
Cool, care to share more details if you have them?
@@BanditsKeepAfter the Rhondian Empire fell, the City of Waterfront was officially taken over by the wealthy merchant families which had always ruled from the shadows in the past.
Being particularly snooty, their first order of business was to confine the "undesirables" to a small rectangular district roughly 280ft long by 130ft wide.
The local thieves' and assassins' guilds were both quick to capitalize on this, directing construction of the bizarre vertical town themselves.
Because of this, only the guilds know how to reach the upper levels. One can only get so high up using the external walkways...
Great video!
Love the idea of using passers-by llike dressing in a dungeon. When you describe it, dungeon crawl procedure works really well in urban scenarios: You walk slowly looking into the windows and the alleys and inspecting places of interest, and this behavior can bring attention of unwelcoming dwellers. I wonder if it is enough to play as a sheriff, patrolling streets every day.
That would be interesting - maybe for a 1 on 1 campaign - occasionally bring in other players as deputies if things go sideways
I just subscribed.
I needed this video months ago when my players kept getting lost in a magical forrest!
Welcome
This really is a good video example of rolling for random people you meet and what they do!
Thanks!
I generally GM Modern Superhero games but something drew me to your channel. I realised how I could use this to randomise plots. This type of villain is in town to do this to this type of citizen. Very cool.
Awesome! What system(a) do you run most? I’ve played a bit of the old Marvel Superheroes and some Tiny Supers, but not much else
Awesome video Daniel. Very much enjoying your channel and the amazing advice offered!
Thank You!
Excellent video. I've always been saying: cities are the same as dungeons, its just a different ratio of threats vs. Friendlies. From a storytelling perspective to be clear.
For sure
Thanks for the watch: I'm kicking off a new campaign this week in Fighting Fantasy's Port Blacksand so it's excellent food for thought!
Cool
Interesting setup i useally just make it up as i go this seems to randomly build interactions with NPCs thats a good Way to interduce new NPCs ❤
Thanks!
Check out the Kickstarter for Guillmans Guide to Speed here: www.kickstarter.com/projects/onlycrits/guillmans-guide-to-speed?ref=d00ssx
Great stuff. I would love to see you apply some of the adventure creation elements in the rule book that you have done in the past to a city setting.
Great suggestion!
Brilliant video! Using basic/expert to make the city come alive.
Thank You!
Never seen you or your channel before. Something about the video preview (thumbnail or title or combination thereof) hinted me that when you say "D&D", you don't mean D&D by WotC/Hasbro. And this is why I clicked.
I try to create content that can be used in any version of D&D and the many many clones/offshoots.
Another great topic and video, sir. This channel should have million subscribers.
Thanks!
I've done kind of a point crawl with the official Lankhmar stuff transplanted to a motte and bailey castle floating in the center of the celestial sphere in my Spelljammer campaign
Nice
I love the idea of interpreting the dice feels like I'm an oracle reading the bones as they crackle in the fire. hmmm i see ....300.... yes. 300 orcs.... In a Bar!
Yes!
I appreciate the use of older systems. Not as much love for them as they deserve these days.
For sure
Are there any good City creation books? Full of random tables and events, etc.
Thanks.
Some people in the comments have mentioned a few
Cool video, I liked the idea of putting a sage deeper into a lost part of the city
But I'm not quite sold on the idea of city crawls still
They are definitely not for everyone
Damn, two different city related videos by two different dnd youtubers on the same day? Just as I'm planning for some city stuff for my next session? Well I'll be
Something must be in the air!
Invisibility and fly spell are so very useful in these sorts of settings.
Yes they are!
You can also treat large groups of NPCs as environmental hazard. Not even the strongest barbarian can walk around the Kaaba the wrong way round without being trampled or taken by the flow. As you were talking about the uneventful NPCs moving trough the city kind of as tapestry, I had to imagine a central square or a city block where 3-4 large streets meet with some offset, so that during the daytime or a least during rush hour, a kind of natural malstroem of people forms. Maybe it's clockwise in the morning and anti-clockwise in the evening with people streaming in and out of this or that district. Maybe it even forms eddies of some sort at corners or market boths. The same rules can apply to large populated marketplaces. Ever wandered a Christmas Market in NYC? Sometimes, you just gotta go with the flow and make a round around the ice rink to return to that sweet hot toddy place, because you just cannot move those 3 meters against the flow. And rightly executed, a party runs the risk of being separated and individual party members getting lost, which can make a whole scenario, especially when filling / compensating for player absence.
Thanks for the inspirations in the video.
I really like this!
I run a Sunday 1e Lankhmar Campaign each week, My (7) Players never leave the city, 2/3 of the enemy are Humans, This is a Thief city with Faction Gangs, a Thieves Guild, City Watch, Normal Pedestrials, and a huge Sewer system as well, if a Monster its normally found in there, the players made all human except 2 Half-elves I allowed, were about 3-4 months in, and 2-3 Level ... Besides all the Adventures Ive come up with I also have all the TSR, DCC, and Savage Worlds Lankhmar stuff for inspiration. MY Lankhmar Citie Wandering Monsters: Pedestrian (they may overhear a Rumor), adventure Party (very Small chance), Thieve (Is there a Bounty on their read or the thieves' leader want them), Guard & Bounty Hunters (Do they have a Wanted Poster on them).
Cool
One confusion I had is, the undead on your roll table aren't any less (or more) common than anything else. If you're only rolling one die, each result has the same chance. If you're rolling 2 or more and I missed it, then 1 needs to come off the bottom😂
Undead are common in my cities
Great video!
Thank You!
Thank you for this idea for city dwelling!
My pleasure!
Yes, dr. Banner hides here in brasil 😂 some neighboors looks like dungeons sometimes with weird inhabitants too.
Yes!
In city crawls obstacles are social, not geographical. It's factions and people that you want to reach, not locations, really
Good point
This is one reason I like to reference Justin Alexander's excellent thought experiment with urbancrawls - it deals with exactly this issue.
Into the Cess & Citadel is another great resource.
Interesting point. "Getting lost" in a city crawl could mean you arrive at the desired location, but the person you were looking for is not there.
@@stewi009 Or it's the secret doppelganger sent to assassinate them and take their place!
@@stewi009Or it could mean that you found the wrong person. Someone dangerous, if you were very unlucky.
Using the same logic, the paths between locations are relationships between people and factions are biomes.
In my city crawls people and relations between them are generated and locations are secondary, derived from those people.
Recently I started cyberpunk campaign in which I use depth crawl rules to generate a web of relationship that leads deep into a sect of nanobit worshippers. I'm curious how it will go.
Monte Cook's Ptolus is a great example of city exploration.
I have heard of this but never playing in it
To paraphrase Chris McDowall (of Bastionland-fame): The city is not a hub. The city is not a main menu.
Not sure I follow - how are cities not hubs?
@@BanditsKeep The line of thought is that a GM shouldn't see cities as a stepping of point to the REAL adventure, cities are adventures by themselves.
@@verlandes1 i agree
Around 13:40 I was taught to use a deck of cards
Cool
I don't actually like random encounters, so I tendo to plan them more like side missions. Also, if the city is big enough, I make public and private transportation available to move through it so the plot is not delayed because the pc's have gotten lost.
As an example of both points, I had the pc's, who usually moved along the city riding on a chaotic version of a subway, have a subway accident that left them stranded in a not-actually-uninhabited cavern complex under the city complete with its own ecosystem, insidiously dangerous flora, two different creature settlements at war with each other over resources, the ghost of a lovely lost dog and, at the end of it, some look at the homeless and disposessed and homeless surviving indide the crevices of "civilised" society
Interesting! I don’t work with preplanned plot lines, but if you do I could see the random stuff being an issue
@@BanditsKeep I mean, the city setting lends itself to be a sandbox with infinite options but I tend to have *things* happening in the shadows: conspirations, cults, movements, guild interests, government stuff, mob wars... players tend to eventually find one or more of those threads and, hopefully latch on to them
How I handle getting lost in any environment city or wilderness is just add time. If its a village or town perhaps 1d6 x 5 minutes or a city 1d4 hours, a ocean vovage 1d6 days. I used to map cities but have found it extremely time consuming and a waste of time. It's much better to subdivide a city into districts with each district having its own set of day/night encounters, adventures, etc. For each district have a list of one or two of the following. A tavern, inn, shop, armorer and trader, you can even use the same one but with different names if your really lazy.
That makes sense
Found this video in time
Excellent
The Incredible Hulk from 2008 starring Edward Norton takes place partly in Brazil, where Brice Banner is hiding out.
Ah yes! Thanks!
Is there a sub-table to randomly generate types of prostitutes?
Feel free to add that if you wish 🤦🏻♂️
Got to consult a sage with this specialization. 😅
I go back and forth over "map, or no map". Having a map on the table damages verisimilitude, but improves player agency.
How so?
@@BanditsKeep there were very few representational maps of cities before the modern era, so spreading out a bird's eye view in front of the players doesn't match how their characters would experience the urban space. On the flip-side, a map, especially a labeled one, can include clues, dangers, resources and points of interest, allowing the players to take the lead in the narrative.
As a Brazilian I can relate to moving through a city and feeling like dungeon crawling hahaha
🌆
I concluded that cities worked best as point crawl, and just narrate the travel for flavour. There should be a hundred taverns in a 25000 person city. This just didn’t justify mapping etc to me.
Point crawls can definitely work. For that kind of population I might do the dungeon thing for about 1/2 the city
I dunno, i think if you want to keep it a little more medieval most cities are actually very very small, tho I will still this for my campaign where there are a bunch of abandoned buildings,
Perhaps, I tend to go with fantasy / sword and sorcery over medieval.
I don't get the purpose of treating a city like a dungeon. It doesn't really matter how long it takes the heroes to get from their inn to a sage's house or whatever. Just have a few NPCs prepped for the players to talk to when they need to (street vendors, a town crier, an official, a guard, a beggar, some kids). And have several shops handy, so you can say "you pass some shoemaker shops; up ahead are stationer shops." (Craftsmen in the same trade always lived near each other in medieval cities, for some reason.)
It can add a bit more game vs story - certainly not for everyone
❤
❤️