The host Shereen played her role well with ease and knowledge. Because of her active and timely queries the session turned very lively and useful. Good debate indeed.
Flaw less , clear , up to the point, invoking interest to layman also- such wonderful conversation is best in recent months. The best thing is Niti ayog expressing confidence in Indian talent . All panelists are at their best . Thanks to news channel and the anchor is also at her best
Anyone remember when Modiji is talking about Digital India , cashless transactions??? people and of course me too used to laugh at him.. Now I feel ashamed 😞 it is really happening.. here in US , we dont use that much digital transactions as compared to India. small roadside vendor does not accept digital transactions here in US, and In India even small vendor has capability to accept digital transfers... I highly appreciate vision of Modi "JI"
Excellent discussion!! Lot of Insights about what is happening in India's highway to growth But less views !!! Going to share across different platform!!
INDIA IS GREAT STRONG SECULAR AND LARGEST DEMOCRACY IN THE GLOBAL WORLD BECAUSE INDIANS ARE SPECIALLY BLESSED TALENTED SMART HARDWORKING HONEST AND HUMBLE 👏
Indians, remember YOU are RESPONSIBLE for this news. YOU elected MODIJI. I would have NEVER expected to see such news before 2014. Thanks to 🇮🇳 and Indians for electing Modiji and the BJP. My head used to hang in shame when I used to see the UPA, it's corruption, its minority appeasement and how PM MMS was treated by pappu and his party. Like the rest of the world, I too was shocked to see the UPA give a non response to 26/11 due to their vote bank politics. If we don't want to return to those days, it's Modi and BJP again in 2024 🙏💪
Such a learned set of leaders, their passion can be seen oozing from their statements with such clarity of thought, commandable space and leadership provided by Mr Modi and his Government.
Digitization of India has happened in spite of the bureaucracy and not because of it. Bureaucracy has very little contribution to India creating the best digital public infrastructure in the world. Indian government is still using paper files for most of its functions. Digitalization of the government should have happened first, that will ensure more transparency and efficiency in government functioning.
Excellent panel... "Technocrats like these are the catalysts of the change we see around today"... I would have hoped TV18 had a equally eminent technologist to host the discussion and ask more pertinent questions than "Shrieking" Bhan !
2 are from IAS. NITI and Telecom. Anchor is knowledgeable. She is asking technical qs properly. On UPA question, she should have asked poor people. Yes , while using UPI many do not know that they are using UPI. Ultimately Govt has to charge on UPI. Where is RBI's digital currency? Shopkeepers charge extra for plastic cards. They will charge for UPI; every shopkeeper will not pay. People have 2 realize that Telecom is not road. People have 2 pay slowly. Why IT Secretary is not invited? Ms Bhan may note 4 future. Banks should conduct properly with poor when they go there. Poor people hesitate. Universalization of UPI is interesting. Ultimately will it lead to one global currency? Banks have imposed some restrictions on UPI transfer; cap on amount. At times we face issues. Banks are charging for transferring money to digital wallet in the name of revenue generation.
9:23 When charges are made to Merchant by Visa or MasterCard we don't have anything to state. But when govt charges it and ensures the money is rotated within the country, why should we have an issue.
A Merchant will only be a Merchant if he finds a way to make the Customer pays for his additional costs. Why does the government feel our merchants are fools?
The people who feel their job is a burden to them ,they should be relieved. How to make India great that aspirations we couldn't see with two speakers,when India is doing so much if we compare 10-15 years from now.Are they not happy people.
India should allow foreign nationals living outside India to join the aydhaar authentication network just like Indian nationals working abroad can. This will allow India to spread its network and economy abroad, not only for inport/export businesses, but will allow foreign customers to buy through ONDC and have products shipped abroad from India (with shipping, customs declarations etc. also handled by ONDC aggregators). Also foreign nationals and companies can remote work in India for customer facing services and freelancing in those countries for Indian companies, and pay Indian and foreign taxes as required by both India and the foreign country requirements as necessary. Because joining and providing data like fingerprints and retinal scans would be voluntary, the foreign countries cannot prevent this using data localisation laws, because the adhaar data would be submitted voluntarily and would be held in India. This could also help in prevention of terrorism, tax evation and fraud by foreign nationals trading with, visiting, or spying or carrying out terrorism in India because their identity can be traced.
Unless Rupee is fully convertible, the growth of UPI across the border is questionable. Today if you remit money abroad, a significant % gets stuck in the system due to Rupee not being convertible.
10:03 "customer doesn't pay, merchant pays" Where does the merchant get money from? 😂😂😂 Merchants will have to increase their prices to pay those charges, so ultimately customer has to pay!! Kisko murkh bana raha hai??
All this is good, but if India need to be of better service to its citizens, the mandatory minimum wage need to be raised to living wage. That would help a lot of people get out of poverty. I feel the middlemen is what makes all the money in India where the producers and consumers are severely punished. For example, clothes are very expensive in India compared to other countries but the people foot soldiers - working in the textile industry are not rich, and the consumer is forced to pay high prices for textiles - finished goods I mean. Same story with farmers.
Modi has come up with a new formula - the govt. owns the infrastructure upto the villages But private parties own the internal village equipment ( they charge money for its use & maintain it)
Any revolution is good if it innovates the human experience of creating and enjoying life with meaning, joy and peace of mind to each member in a country!
A Merchant will only be a Merchant if he finds a way to make the Customer pays for his additional costs. Why does the government feel our merchants are fools?
The host Shereen played her role well with ease and knowledge. Because of her active and timely queries the session turned very lively and useful. Good debate indeed.
Flaw less , clear , up to the point, invoking interest to layman also- such wonderful conversation is best in recent months. The best thing is Niti ayog expressing confidence in Indian talent . All panelists are at their best . Thanks to news channel and the anchor is also at her best
What a fantastic conversation...!! Amazing clarity...by these leaders !! Amazing vision..!!
BharatNet CEO Mr. Raja Raman is a real leader, acknowledging the real heros and also giving credit to Aadhar implementation.
Anyone remember when Modiji is talking about Digital India , cashless transactions???
people and of course me too used to laugh at him..
Now I feel ashamed 😞 it is really happening.. here in US , we dont use that much digital transactions as compared to India. small roadside vendor does not accept digital transactions here in US, and In India even small vendor has capability to accept digital transfers...
I highly appreciate vision of Modi "JI"
Excellent discussion!! Lot of Insights about what is happening in India's highway to growth But less views !!!
Going to share across different platform!!
INDIA IS GREAT STRONG SECULAR AND LARGEST DEMOCRACY IN THE GLOBAL WORLD BECAUSE INDIANS ARE SPECIALLY BLESSED TALENTED SMART HARDWORKING HONEST AND HUMBLE 👏
The day Muslim votes gose as majority in country it will be end for BJP.
Well done Shereen Bhan! Keep up the great work!
When leadership is great, everything falls in right direction.
Yaa. But of late the leadership is being belittled to the extent of hate.
🙊Rahul-'IndiaBad' USA-'IndiaGood'😀
Wow , feeling so happy to hear quality discussion on innovations done by Bharat .
Subramanian ji superb .
Shirin did a good job .
Indians, remember YOU are RESPONSIBLE for this news. YOU elected MODIJI.
I would have NEVER expected to see such news before 2014. Thanks to 🇮🇳 and Indians for electing Modiji and the BJP. My head used to hang in shame when I used to see the UPA, it's corruption, its minority appeasement and how PM MMS was treated by pappu and his party. Like the rest of the world, I too was shocked to see the UPA give a non response to 26/11 due to their vote bank politics. If we don't want to return to those days, it's Modi and BJP again in 2024 🙏💪
You are right.
🙊Rahul-'IndiaBad' USA-'IndiaGood'😀
Very insightful and encouraging panel of technocrats, amazing discussion!
Such a learned set of leaders, their passion can be seen oozing from their statements with such clarity of thought, commandable space and leadership provided by Mr Modi and his Government.
Very informative program by a very smart moderator who seems to have done her homework very well. Keep it up!
Great panel, host also knowgelable
Wonderful question “are we doing enough to create our own brand?”
Digitization of India has happened in spite of the bureaucracy and not because of it.
Bureaucracy has very little contribution to India creating the best digital public infrastructure in the world.
Indian government is still using paper files for most of its functions. Digitalization of the government should have happened first, that will ensure more transparency and efficiency in government functioning.
Thank you for this episode Shireen-ji🙏
Excellent panel... "Technocrats like these are the catalysts of the change we see around today"... I would have hoped TV18 had a equally eminent technologist to host the discussion and ask more pertinent questions than "Shrieking" Bhan !
2 are from IAS. NITI and Telecom.
Anchor is knowledgeable.
She is asking technical qs properly. On UPA question, she should have asked poor people. Yes , while using UPI many do not know that they are using UPI. Ultimately Govt has to charge on UPI. Where is RBI's digital currency?
Shopkeepers charge extra for plastic cards. They will charge for UPI; every shopkeeper will not pay. People have 2 realize that Telecom is not road. People have 2 pay slowly. Why IT Secretary is not invited? Ms Bhan may note 4 future.
Banks should conduct properly with poor when they go there. Poor people hesitate. Universalization of UPI is interesting. Ultimately will it lead to one global currency? Banks have imposed some restrictions on UPI transfer; cap on amount. At times we face issues. Banks are charging for transferring money to digital wallet in the name of revenue generation.
The basic principal is "the Merchant never pays" as he always passes on the charge to the customer!
9:23 When charges are made to Merchant by Visa or MasterCard we don't have anything to state. But when govt charges it and ensures the money is rotated within the country, why should we have an issue.
Enlightening conversation
🙊Rahul-'IndiaBad' USA-'IndiaGood'😀
Well done Shereen.
Modi has evoked the potential of the country!
The modi minister (ex army general) had said indians had transgressed into china hundreds times more than chinese into india.
Files moving is not a government achievement, it’s part of the global progress which the commerce in general has adopted.
A Merchant will only be a Merchant if he finds a way to make the Customer pays for his additional costs. Why does the government feel our merchants are fools?
Good. Go India go.
CONGRATULATIONS 👏 AND BEST WISHES FROM RAVINDER TALWAR JALANDHAR CITY PUNJAB INDIA
Jai bharat
The people who feel their job is a burden to them ,they should be relieved. How to make India great that aspirations we couldn't see with two speakers,when India is doing so much if we compare 10-15 years from now.Are they not happy people.
India should allow foreign nationals living outside India to join the aydhaar authentication network just like Indian nationals working abroad can. This will allow India to spread its network and economy abroad, not only for inport/export businesses, but will allow foreign customers to buy through ONDC and have products shipped abroad from India (with shipping, customs declarations etc. also handled by ONDC aggregators). Also foreign nationals and companies can remote work in India for customer facing services and freelancing in those countries for Indian companies, and pay Indian and foreign taxes as required by both India and the foreign country requirements as necessary.
Because joining and providing data like fingerprints and retinal scans would be voluntary, the foreign countries cannot prevent this using data localisation laws, because the adhaar data would be submitted voluntarily and would be held in India. This could also help in prevention of terrorism, tax evation and fraud by foreign nationals trading with, visiting, or spying or carrying out terrorism in India because their identity can be traced.
Unless Rupee is fully convertible, the growth of UPI across the border is questionable. Today if you remit money abroad, a significant % gets stuck in the system due to Rupee not being convertible.
For a change i don't see nandan explain india stack
10:03 "customer doesn't pay, merchant pays"
Where does the merchant get money from? 😂😂😂
Merchants will have to increase their prices to pay those charges, so ultimately customer has to pay!!
Kisko murkh bana raha hai??
All this is good, but if India need to be of better service to its citizens, the mandatory minimum wage need to be raised to living wage. That would help a lot of people get out of poverty. I feel the middlemen is what makes all the money in India where the producers and consumers are severely punished. For example, clothes are very expensive in India compared to other countries but the people foot soldiers - working in the textile industry are not rich, and the consumer is forced to pay high prices for textiles - finished goods I mean. Same story with farmers.
Modi has come up with a new formula - the govt. owns the infrastructure upto the villages But private parties own the internal village equipment ( they charge money for its use & maintain it)
👏
It investing in stock market so easy then why are 98/ percent of people making losses ?!
Madam please try to go for a good makeup artist...
Powder/foundation thoda halka sa kam ho gaya...🤡
Jesus, the hostess seems as if she had just flown in from Hollywood.
Naade wali file. 💯🤣😂😂😂🤣
What a pathetic video quality!!
That too a video on digital boost. Better you get a proper internet connection first.
UPI will soon be levying charges for transactions. THIS bodes well for it's growth
India is one of those counties that count its chicken before it hatches.
Host is should be more professional, too much unnecessary laughing.
Any revolution is good if it innovates the human experience of creating and enjoying life with meaning, joy and peace of mind to each member in a country!
in my opinion, below quality host
A Merchant will only be a Merchant if he finds a way to make the Customer pays for his additional costs. Why does the government feel our merchants are fools?