I personally think that the production team should not even allocate this song to start with. Like what others have mentioned, it is too hard a song, especially when these girls did not receive much/any training prior to the program. In this sense, it was unfair to those who had to perform. However, GFriend's songs are supposedly very hard too, especially the dance, but those performances were quite pleasant to watch, especially the group who performed "Rough". I was really impressed.
@@nereaa7896 no one will look at ugly faces,they are public figure,visuals over talent,even if the group have talents but if they are ugly i assure you no one will stan them,yes not even you,the first thing we look at an idol is face,not their skills,that's the truth
I stopped watching the show a few episodes in and simply forgot about it. But I think some of these are kinda bad because they try to sound like the original artist instead of themselves. It just doesn't feel all that amazing when it's just imitation.
I just want the 'Step' team to debut together now that this planned and biased show is over. They had such good chemistry and they're really good together
Some of these girls are tone deaf LMAO. I don’t even understand how Like Ooh Ahh is higher than some of the performances below it. The vocals are like terrible.
I think is korea is fine that a pretty girl doesn’t have a very stable and good voice only for that reason, “she is pretty now I understand why she is not a good vocal” and I am like “wtf why because she is pretty is ok she is not a good vocal?”
More than half of the girls here are normal girls, there were picked out in public and you expect them to be godly vocalists? These girls have never been in the trainees system so they don't know any better.
Mine would be 19.Rookie 18.Catallena 17. Whistle 16.Cheer Up 15.Forever Love 14.Boss 13.Forever Love 12.Pretty U 11.Like Ooh Ah 10.No no no 9.Me Gustas Tu 8.I'm Your Girl 7.Mr Mr 6.Adrenaline 5. Wee Woo (For me, the most debut-like performance) 4.Just In Love (Have the best vocals but kind of lack in dancing) 3.Hush (The wind and the hair flipping made this performance very good) 2.Rough (They really got the feel of the song) 1.Step (Do I even need to explain this?) I didn't include their original songs because I didn't really like those excet for Pinnochio. EDIT: Reasons why I choose the top 5
Nekocookies XII yeah, after watching the final result I think the same, the positions between 14-20 are kinda messy, since some performances that were objectively good are in lower places xd But anyway, I think that ah choo's vocals weren't bad, actually most of them we're really good (add that their expressions and dance were good for a first performance)
yeah i agree about the placing, but about ah choo their vocals arent bad for first performances (compared to others) but i think cheer up and me gustas tu were better than them. Also ah choo's vocals were really strained and they were all out of breath (you can hear it in their voices) so yeah
Nekocookies XII speaking of vocals you're right, but I tried to take in consideration the dance and other factors (facial expressions and visuals) and not just the vocals. If it were because of that all Nayeon, Dahee and Sia's performances could be in top 10. Thanks for the feedback anyway, I'll try to be more conscious next time 😊
well all im saying is a lot of the member's voices were really uncomfortable to listen to, wasnt really that great but it was decent for their first time
Of course magical would be number 1. The best of all performances. Even the formis could not beat them. Good luck for formis and magical girls! This is the beginning.
A highly skilled dancer..no secret when she came from a family of dancer!!! And good vocal!! But now she's back in Singapore so I wish all the best for her future endeavour!!
People saying that most of these girls can't sing but the best 15 performances include better vocals than Twice perfomances in Sixteen. Not saying Twice is bad, just that everyone can improve a lot like Twice proved.
Sian in the thumbnail i was like OWWW SIAN IS ON THE IDOL SCHOOL??? BUT I KNOW THIS SHOW IS DISAPPOINTING I WISH SHE DID A GREAT JOB HERE BECAUSE IN PRODUCE 48 SHE REALLY DID A GREAT JOB
STEP is one of my favourite performance on idol school :)) The four girls who performed STEP should debut as a team cause honestly the performance is really awesome and they have lots of potential !!
OMG the 1st and 2nd place 😭😭 STEP and MAGICAL. I literally agree with you. These days (after I finished watching Idol School), I always went to youtube and watched Step and Magical. It's like it's just those two performance that win my heart THOSE BEST 2 PERFORMANCE ON IDOL SCHOOL AND NONE OF STEP AND MAGICAL MEMBERS ARE IN FROMIS 😭😭😭😭
search knk inseong, hurry up!! Because of Korean people like a visual then the talent😩i feel dissapointed about this show bcs the talent people didn't make it😭
michael zquad not gonna lie, vocally yes nearly all the performances sucked, most of them can't sing to save their lives but I guess they might improve in the future. Their dancing was decent tho.
19... wasn't bad at all... if you look at them as international fans, you might not even understand. The song was basically old, and it was an old concept. Skills were good, high notes were also good... just don't judge on the quality...
Herim deserved better, she left sm entertainment and Sm rookies to go to idol school and finally have the chance to debut but she lost and gave up her dream to be an idol ;(
aldonsetmm oh, i had no idea but actually that’s not a surprise to me, I mean the kpop industry is so cruel, she probably will be so much happier with a normal life than an idol life. But she is full of talent and was just a normal girl who wanted to be an idol, it’s really sad that she couldn’t debut, but I respect her decision and I think that probably have a normal life is the best for her. She looks so much happier on her TH-cam channel 💕
Maybe the show isn't as good as you all want, but PLEASE DON'T SLEEP ON FROMIS_9 BECAUSE OF THAT. They improved alot since this show, and they latest song is really good. Please listen to Fun.
am i the only really upset that jessica dew doesn't want to be an idol anymore? i mean i respect her not wanting to do it anymore,, i just hope its not because she didn't get popular right away :(
![[Iz*One] Produce 48 - Performances from Worst to Best](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NJRYq6epsho/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Iz*One] Produce 48 - Performances from Worst to Best](/img/tr.png)
Everyone, thanks for the support and nice comments, i'll try to upload new videos like this in the next weeks (so maybe suscribe is a good idea)
Sooooo we are all agree that Rookie is the worst right?
adliya nindya you spelt best wrong
yes, yes we sure as hell do😂
han loves jiho no i don't think we did, sweetheart.
adliya nindya Yup. Agree so Muvh
adliya nindya i agree, but rookie is the best song that they can't handle with their ability
Rookie was bad... but Nayeon saved the whole performance. sad she didn't make it
BB Sone the most accurate comment honestly
Her high note was actually screaming not singing tho-
rookie number?
Cherry Witch that doesn’t change the fact that she can sing better than most of the contestants
Cherry Witch Wendy Screams it too kind of
The rookie performance is so annoying
Ayesha Ramos tbf rookie is rlly difficult to dance and sing to but yea it was painful to watch
especially the girl with the buns and yellow shirt
I'm satisfied that they're last in this list LOL
I personally think that the production team should not even allocate this song to start with. Like what others have mentioned, it is too hard a song, especially when these girls did not receive much/any training prior to the program. In this sense, it was unfair to those who had to perform. However, GFriend's songs are supposedly very hard too, especially the dance, but those performances were quite pleasant to watch, especially the group who performed "Rough". I was really impressed.
When no one debuted from the top 2 performances.
this show was about pretty girl “learning” to be an idol
the most relevant was the pretty face
I kinda feel bad for fromis9...because of the concept of the show (pretty over talent) not many pple know them ot want to know them?
The girl with the bangs from the Like Ohh - Ahh one debuted in Fromis 9 I think
but they debuted from the top 3
@@nereaa7896 no one will look at ugly faces,they are public figure,visuals over talent,even if the group have talents but if they are ugly i assure you no one will stan them,yes not even you,the first thing we look at an idol is face,not their skills,that's the truth
This show was so disappointing
amen
Thank god I watched sixteen again over this
Actually not, disappointing contestants to be exact :)
agree.....
pink bubble so true
watching this video makes me sad over lee dahee and tasha and bae eunyoung not debuting all over again
sewoon's snack bag and natty cuz she totally deserves to debut
taehyung's sugakookies ESPECIALLY NATTY
kim nayeon and shin sia too 🙂
Eunyoung is in Produce48, please support her!
and eunyoung not debutiing once again :(
I stopped watching the show a few episodes in and simply forgot about it. But I think some of these are kinda bad because they try to sound like the original artist instead of themselves. It just doesn't feel all that amazing when it's just imitation.
I just want the 'Step' team to debut together now that this planned and biased show is over. They had such good chemistry and they're really good together
Some of these girls are tone deaf LMAO. I don’t even understand how Like Ooh Ahh is higher than some of the performances below it. The vocals are like terrible.
Jungshook ikr
Soyeon I quite enjoyed Ooh Ahh, of course that doesn’t mean you have to, but I thought that they did well and Natty’s dance break was amazing!
They sound Just like twice,soo..
I think is korea is fine that a pretty girl doesn’t have a very stable and good voice only for that reason, “she is pretty now I understand why she is not a good vocal”
and I am like “wtf why because she is pretty is ok she is not a good vocal?”
More than half of the girls here are normal girls, there were picked out in public and you expect them to be godly vocalists? These girls have never been in the trainees system so they don't know any better.
I think Me Gusta Tu and BO$$ are better than Ah Choo...
Tu Le Nguyen i agree with you
Haya Sama thank you 💞
boss is disgraceful. they were so stiff
Useful Polls anyway, I choose BO$$ :))
I dont like ah choo too because noh jisun, it looks good just because the visual noh jisun. If noh jisun not in here, ah choo could be better.
Me gustas tu wasn’t bad at all??? And just in love was probably the best performance in all idol school
IWannaDreamHiddenOnceBlinkBuddy-L I agree with u. I really like Me Gustas Tu. I thought it should be no.10 at least
Excuse me but Boss and Me gustas is like better than Ah choo like 10000000000000×
Tae's Wifeu its their opinion you know
Yess i wanna say that and also boombayah dont deserve 21th place, anyone agree?
Anything is better than achoo lmao
I think me gustas tu Should’ve been ranked higher & Just in love should be #1♥️(The Main Vocal Queens Of The Show)
Yeah,i really loved Just in love :C
Actually, before i added the performances from the last episode it was in the top 5 :C
I think so
lee seul did really well there!
THE MAIN VOCAL IN ME GUSTAS TU IS DAHEE
truee
1st evolution: Me Gusta tu is the best
2nd evolution: Hush, Andrenaline, Mr Mr, Step are the best
3rd evolution: Magical of course
Just my opinion
KPOP LOVER *evaluation u thought of pokemon when I saw your comment XD
I think pretty u should be ranked higher but yeah
There were four evaluations btw.
Didn't like ah choo, the one thing that save them was Jisun killing part. And one of my favorite are MrMr, Adreline and Magical.
Mine would be
19.Rookie
18.Catallena
17. Whistle
16.Cheer Up
15.Forever Love
14.Boss
13.Forever Love
12.Pretty U
11.Like Ooh Ah
10.No no no
9.Me Gustas Tu
8.I'm Your Girl
7.Mr Mr
6.Adrenaline
5. Wee Woo (For me, the most debut-like performance)
4.Just In Love (Have the best vocals but kind of lack in dancing)
3.Hush (The wind and the hair flipping made this performance very good)
2.Rough (They really got the feel of the song)
1.Step (Do I even need to explain this?)
I didn't include their original songs because I didn't really like those excet for Pinnochio.
EDIT: Reasons why I choose the top 5
Kyle Muncada agree.. I still cant get over cheer up.. That sht was cringe as fk
What I really like is rough.
You did NOT do Bo$$ and Adrenaline dirty like this omg
I really disagree about the Ah-choo placing like i get that jisun's killing part was good but the thing is everyone else's vocals were like really bad
Nekocookies XII yeah, after watching the final result I think the same, the positions between 14-20 are kinda messy, since some performances that were objectively good are in lower places xd
But anyway, I think that ah choo's vocals weren't bad, actually most of them we're really good (add that their expressions and dance were good for a first performance)
yeah i agree about the placing, but about ah choo their vocals arent bad for first performances (compared to others) but i think cheer up and me gustas tu were better than them. Also ah choo's vocals were really strained and they were all out of breath (you can hear it in their voices) so yeah
Nekocookies XII speaking of vocals you're right, but I tried to take in consideration the dance and other factors (facial expressions and visuals) and not just the vocals. If it were because of that all Nayeon, Dahee and Sia's performances could be in top 10.
Thanks for the feedback anyway, I'll try to be more conscious next time 😊
yoo do u know what strains are i mean her voice basically screamed straining it was so uncomfortable to listen to her hit the high notes
well all im saying is a lot of the member's voices were really uncomfortable to listen to, wasnt really that great but it was decent for their first time
Magical is one of my favorite performance but none of them got in the final lineup 😭😭😭
Four Cats I have a question, did Heechul cry in Magical? Because I thought he was, he also turned around during the performance
Miichan yeah, and why this shit happen?
Irfan ISMH i Think she drop her mic while the performance and maybe she already know that they will lose
MaiMai 9
I really2 agree for #1 & #2, but none of them made into final line up. This show is full of mess :(
BribriLix Nyoung | lets be honest be here, idol school was all about visuals instead of talent.
LOONAJUICE so are all survival shows
I really disagree with ah-choo ranking...their vocal are worst
Ng MingHui lol right. And ppl are saying it should be higher z😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Rookie was a bad choice to preform in my opinion.... it wasnt TERRIBLE though.
In my opinion cheer up and rookie team should have been switched, and Rookie could have been a really good one xd and maybe cheer up too
aldonsetmm I agree👏🏻
aldonsetmm OMG AGREE THO I feel like all the unnecessary aegyo they were doing in Rookie would fit in Cheer Up
Of course magical would be number 1. The best of all performances. Even the formis could not beat them. Good luck for formis and magical girls! This is the beginning.
Mr K *Fromis 😂
Maybe its better but dont say that fromis cant beat them.
i think she meant that noone in magical debuted with fromis
Idol school had some terrible stages, but I really enjoyed the show, fell for many of the girls, and I totally love Fromis_9♥
Step sweetie im so sorry you deserved first on this list
Watching this make me wanna Jessica to debut :')
I agreed with Magical and Step rank. But still sad cuz none of them made into fromis_
Anonymous -;- who perform the Magical ?? What Number it is
Twice Once it’s No. 1. Performers; Natty, Haein, Haneul, Eun young, Lee Sian, Eun seo.
Anonymous -;- although this is really late, it’s actually Eun Suh 😂
Agree with Step & Magical ranks. But I really don't understand why #teamstep or #teammagical can't debut although their stages are so amazing.
My Top 3 Step team, Sia, Nayeon, Dahee team, Pinocchio+Magical (cant choose Pinocchio and Magical)
Magical, still sad none of them made it 😢
KimSamuel 김사무엘 i do
adrenaline> wee woo
"boomb boomb" i can't XD
This show was terrible tbh
IKR
But now, we have a very good group!
(FROMIS_9)
I love them!
@@colorcix I love them too!
I thought the concept of the show was amazing, but MEH
What can u expect from a show where most of the contestants were teenagers and barely had any experience in training
Not just that Watch a video where a trainee? From the show exposed stuff about Idol School,
Really disappointed that Tasha is out. Girl got talent, but not enough korean fan crowd
Cecilia Ang
Tasha is good in rap😍
A highly skilled dancer..no secret when she came from a family of dancer!!! And good vocal!! But now she's back in Singapore so I wish all the best for her future endeavour!!
Andrenaline should be in the top 10!!!!!!
KPOP LOVER YAAAS JIWON, SEOYEON AND HERIN SLAYED 😍🔥
Adrenaline
I disagree with ah choo ranking
rookie was so bad, nayeon saved it
Super agree with the 1st and 2nd rank!!❤️
People saying that most of these girls can't sing but the best 15 performances include better vocals than Twice perfomances in Sixteen. Not saying Twice is bad, just that everyone can improve a lot like Twice proved.
Sian in the thumbnail i was like OWWW SIAN IS ON THE IDOL SCHOOL??? BUT I KNOW THIS SHOW IS DISAPPOINTING I WISH SHE DID A GREAT JOB HERE BECAUSE IN PRODUCE 48 SHE REALLY DID A GREAT JOB
In my opinion, Step performance is #1. I've watched it thousand times :))
Mai Anh Trịnh Me too..
I disagree in many performance....
Once Channel` so do i
same
Well I mean it's the creator's opinion so you can disagree but you can't change his/her opinion :)
Once Channel` maybe that's her/his opinion
Truee
STEP is one of my favourite performance on idol school :)) The four girls who performed STEP should debut as a team cause honestly the performance is really awesome and they have lots of potential !!
They did my baby rookie so dirty
Tru, the main vocal saved it tho
OMG the 1st and 2nd place 😭😭 STEP and MAGICAL. I literally agree with you. These days (after I finished watching Idol School), I always went to youtube and watched Step and Magical. It's like it's just those two performance that win my heart THOSE BEST 2 PERFORMANCE ON IDOL SCHOOL AND NONE OF STEP AND MAGICAL MEMBERS ARE IN FROMIS 😭😭😭😭
Mutiara Rifka feel sad for them😢
cant believed boss is at that number when the dance line killed that performance
Me gusta tu should be in number 14 or more higher lol and rough is better than hush
I agree with Magical and Step, the vocals are so great though, and Boss is a great performance.
5:29 her high note really superb! Why she didn't make it to debut line 😭
search knk inseong, hurry up!! Because of Korean people like a visual then the talent😩i feel dissapointed about this show bcs the talent people didn't make it😭
search knk inseong, hurry up!!
cuz she's "not pretty enough" 😔
Rigged group.
2:22 look at that talented queen
magical is ❤ i hope the "Magical" all debut soon specially Natty .. pls go to yg😁😁
I'm want to see Natty debut so much!! Although she is still young
Those Vocal Trinity deserved much more (Nayeon,Dahee and Sia)
let's be honest all their performances sucked dunno why they did this show
michael zquad not gonna lie, vocally yes nearly all the performances sucked, most of them can't sing to save their lives but I guess they might improve in the future. Their dancing was decent tho.
so damm right, dancing might be not too bad, but the singing was sooo terrible
Most of them didn’t get traind before tho if i remember right, so they can improve with good training
Like any of them had vocal skills, tf happened in the auditions?!?!
There were a lot of talented Girls... Fromis_9 have a lot of potential
all the performances they did later in the show are in the end just shows how all of them IMPROVED
Pledis would proud of this trainers sang their artist's songs (Orange Caramel, Seventeen and Pristin)
I reckon Step, Just in love and Rough are the best performances excluding their original songs.
we know that adrenaline was the best perfomance😍
19... wasn't bad at all... if you look at them as international fans, you might not even understand. The song was basically old, and it was an old concept. Skills were good, high notes were also good... just don't judge on the quality...
I really miss them...
I personally like KARA - Step performance very much!
22. U only show nayeon part. But nayeon actually kill it.
Teayones I picked the best moments of every performance
aldonsetmm oh
Herim deserved better, she left sm entertainment and Sm rookies to go to idol school and finally have the chance to debut but she lost and gave up her dream to be an idol ;(
In fact she gave up on the industry, she has spoken up against the racism and cruelty of the kpop world
aldonsetmm oh, i had no idea but actually that’s not a surprise to me, I mean the kpop industry is so cruel, she probably will be so much happier with a normal life than an idol life. But she is full of talent and was just a normal girl who wanted to be an idol, it’s really sad that she couldn’t debut, but I respect her decision and I think that probably have a normal life is the best for her. She looks so much happier on her TH-cam channel 💕
The iconic worst performance
Lol i think am the only one who love rookie’s performance
kyungmin park I like that perf, but is bad AF 😂
Wtf
everyone just agree at Rookie in last place i'm screaming
i loved idol school!
10000% agreeeing on magical being #1 cuz the stage is so lit and i miss haein so much😭❤️
Rookie will never be forgotten. Worst
No. 8 should be the top 1 :(
I just love the no.8
OMG! 4:40 TASHA from (formerly) skarf! I miss you, GIRL! Finally reunited, you need to make it (if this show hasn't ended already, lol)!
Just because of their backup vocal
For those who didn't know, I love how Siah and Dahee performed the exact same vocal run LOL (5:02 & 5:24)
1. i'm your girl
2. Pinnochio
3. NoNoNo
4. Magical
5. Mr. Mr.
6. Step
7. Like' Ooh Ahh
8. B.O.S.S
9. Rought
10. Whistle
My fave performances were Hush, Pinocchio, You in my fantasy, Rough, Magical, Adrenaline and Step!
2:23 why the hell is nobody talking about this high note ? 😂
My blood sweat and tears are playing with fire because she was evil edited as fuck
aldonsetmm damnit this is why I have trust issues 😭
Just in Love should had been ranked 1st tbh....
It has the Main Best Vocals!!💕
And yup! Step was the best!!! T_T
Lets say that is from best to the best
i love step performance. They're just so good
nayeon’s, siah’s and dahee’s performance just 8th?
That three talented vocalist in the show just get waste like a rubbish..i feel sad for them😭
That trio deserved better
Rookie performance was bad because no one can be like red velvet💞
Actually if Cheer up and Red velvet team changed songs, the overall of the first round would be so much better
knew which one would be last before watching
This whole show is for us to see covers of our idols basically
Just another show where talent was overlooked for visuals. Glad I avoided it
why didnt the girl at 5.25 make it? like seriously
그냥수정
Koreans who voted were just sleeping on talent. Can’t blame them tho, this is a beauty pageant after all.
J S I think she’s cute. Looks like SinBs and Eunhas love child lol. Idol School was overall a disappointment.
Nayeonnie
Yeahh, those talented and beautiful ones weren’t even in top 9 in the end. Doubt fromis will even go as popular as ioi.
yaaaaaaaaaaas
NATTYYYY 😍
Still disappointed for Natty😞
im your girl should be in the top 10 lol its better than wee woo. anyway i agree with no 1, 2, 3 but the 4th place would be pinocchio imo
Maybe the show isn't as good as you all want, but PLEASE DON'T SLEEP ON FROMIS_9 BECAUSE OF THAT. They improved alot since this show, and they latest song is really good. Please listen to Fun.
i honestly only clicked on this to see Rookie in last place NDKDKD
am i the only really upset that jessica dew doesn't want to be an idol anymore? i mean i respect her not wanting to do it anymore,, i just hope its not because she didn't get popular right away :(
Jason Hoover she said that it was because of the idol world was very strict and had standards that she thought that she didn't fit 🤷
ahh yeah thats what i was afraid of :( i don't understand why she didn't get more votes and love.
What is the song name of 19 ? I forgot😂
YingYing Jjiang finkl forever love
oberdamujigae Thanks
YES MAGICAL DESERVES TO BE FIRST PLACE SO FREAKING MUCH I CANT BELIEVE THEY DROPPED THIS WHOLE TEAM OF TALENTS
MAGICAL!!!!😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
1:24 WHAT’S HER NAME OMG
ppippoppippo min Park Somyung ❤️ she was in me gustas tú, Wee Woo and Pinocchio (6th)
Whistle 21?? seriously?
I love all so I'm not complaining
STEP AND MAGICAL ♡