This is more than just an Elden Ring mod..
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ย. 2024
- Asmongold Reacts to: NEW Malenia, True Consort of Miquella Boss Showcase (Elden Ring The Garden of Eyes DLC Mod)
by @GardenOfEyes • NEW Malenia, True Cons...
► Asmongold's Twitch: / zackrawrr
► Asmongold's Twitter: / asmongold
► Asmongold's Sub-Reddit: / asmongold
► Asmongold's 2nd YT Channel: / zackrawrr
Channel Editors: CatDany & Daily Dose of Asmongold
If you own the copyright of content showed in this video and would like it to be removed:
x.com/CatDanyRU
x.com/DAsmongold
Bro imagine if Elden ring reached the same heights as skyrim did in terms of modding man that shit would be otherworldly.
Id pay for mods of this scale
that won't be possible if they kept using their trash engine
@@fuhkyu8146 go for it, since this is paywalled.
Well the difference is Skyrim can run on anything, and if jt can you can get the 32-bit legendary edition (the original one)
Elden ring, while great, can't run on medium low to low end rigs, which is also very understandable and reasonable
@@fuhkyu8146 the mod already costs money lol
This is more than a mod. It's someone's application for their new job.
Hopefully they don’t have blue hair.
i don't know how to explain to people that don't play video games how impressive this is for a mod
And a nose ring with hipster glasses
It's not @@chains_xo
@@sirhc8927 or pronouns
The annoying part mod from GoE are all paywalled.
Which is crazy since as far as I am aware, you can't paywall any copyrighted assets.
Are they actually reselling anything copyrighted tho? Sure, ER itself is, but they can probably just add their own stuff and call on the in-game library for the base game assets they need, but I haven't analyzed their files, I can't say.
it is illegal yes, but he isnt big enough for bandai namco/fromsoft to look into
at this point I would call this fair use lmao this is just better than any fucking fight in the main game
@@ZanderSabbag well you don't need to resell it.
You simply can't paywall copyrighted assets anywhere.
I remember read that Nintendo take down an emulator app because they paywalled a copyrighted assets (which is their code).
Just because you add more stuff, GoE still fundamentally use copyright assets as the base unless GoE recreated every new asset from scratch, which is unlikely and can also become another legal problem.
I never see or hear that GoE have any license from Fromsoft themself so yeah, if they come to GoE, he is cooked.
This is why most mod like Convergence, they put it for free and all income are through donation.
This is how they dodge all legal consequences and less likely to get shot by a lawsuit because the mods are technically unprofitable and free for public.
Depends if bandai/from take action. I'm adament that's what was yuzus downfall. Was stupid to paywall the beta
Never underestimate modders, i learned this through the years and this mod once again proves it
modders are the developers who arent bound by their managers
I dunno. Looks very amateur in a lot of places and the fight itself looks like big bullshit beyond either Malenia or Radahn tiers.
I realised it when I knew that Modders are carrying Skyrim for years.
Lookup at anbennar mode for europa universalis 4. Its like its own stand alone game and setting
As someone who was browsing Nexus randomly and found a Skyrim mod that added a whole region of Tamriel that only had 100 endorsements at the time, I concur. Summerset Isle btw, if anyone's curious. Adds the homeland of high elves complete with dungeons, towns, voiced NPCs, treasures, & 180 quests. Easily as large as TES games usually are vanilla. It's got 1700 endorsements now, still tiny compared to the sheer scale of it. Not that I've played it yet.
I don't understand how Garden of Eyes hasn't been squashed by Fromsoft/whoever else yet. You can't sell mods for a game you don't own. All mods are "if you want to support me you can donate, if you don't you can still use it".
There's no way GoE has permission to do this and sell it. I guess they either don't know or don't care enough about it.
Yeah, I mean, this is one of those few times where the players would, majority anyway, would be on the company's side too.
You know what's more crazy about this comment? Nobody asked, and plenty of other mods are behind a paywall.
Cyberpunk 2077 VR mod has been a paywall for over 2 years.
What about all the mods Bethesda used and never gave money to the creators of said mods? even though they charged $5+ for every single bs mod for console dorks like yourself.
Only problem with this mod is it's behind a paywall and I'm pretty sure that can get you in trouble
What are you, the mod police?
Yeah charging for mods is a no no
Its illegal
Well the mod is not finished, its "early access" , full release will probably be free
@@dawe0039Doesn’t change a thing.
A reminder that Garden of Eyes is a mod thief, and that paying to use mods is an immoral practice that abuses copyright. It is not GoE's intellectual property to monetize, and puts other mods in jeopardy of being taken down as a result of his greed.
GoE has tried to hide this by changing their channel name, as they were formerly known first as Sanadsk, and later Omegafantasy, respectively. They have stolen content and bullied people off various platforms and underpaid people to make mods for him, and gaslit people when accused of wrongdoing.
As cool as GoE's stuff looks, it is not worth supporting and therefore condoning bad their behaviour, especially when it's still very much easily discoverable.
@@slavicsandvich5967 yuh but it looks fun so
@@shirouemiya737 well, you are part of the problem
Yo, that explains why Sanadsk is gone! I had no IDE!
@BIaireau sorry I just enjoy having fun, is what they are doing wrong sure I didn't deny that
IT looks fun on video's, the mod itself is meh with few incredible moments like this one, unlike Convergence mod which is awesome.
Is GoE still breaking copyright law by charging for all the mods lol
How is that breaking copyright lol wtf
@@ZanderSabbag bc he doesn't have the rights to the assets he's selling. that's why pretty much every mod in existence is free
You can't be serious.
@@Aona_Music Is he actually selling FS assets tho? They are making stuff themselves here, and I didn't see proof they are packaging stuff from FS.
@@ZanderSabbag It's stolen assets, they've been in trouble for doing the same shit before, which is why they're now called GoE, they changed their name multiple times
You know what's more crazy about this mod? It's paywalled.
Garden of Eyes is an incredibly unethical project that pays a team to steal content from other modders & FromSoft themselves and then redistributes / paywalls it on Patreon btw, wouldn't support the mod or the author in any capacity.
ethics are subjective
@@ryansreaction tell that to the people that the scam sites he promotes ripped off
As cool as it looks. If you got to pay for it. It is dumb, and gamers would be dumb to do so.
@@ryansreaction Everyone says that until a greedy Nintendo modders puts a dollar sign behind their program and the nintendo ninjas come knockin.
@@ryansreaction the art of missing the point of philosophy
Still can’t convince me after their paywall
the mod is paywalled?
5 bucks bro
@@permad5189 which is illegal. It's against Fromsoft's TOS to resell their assets, and this mod uses Sekiro and Elden Ring assets
@@permad5189 that's 5 bucks too much
imagine paying for mods
@@permad5189 it's literally illegal though
Souls modders have so much fun I bet this even has voice acting this is kinda insane
AI
Remember this dude is a mod thief, reuses fromsoft assets and puts a price tag on them as mods (this is illegal), and promotes rune selling.
You don’t think this mod has added more content worth paying for?
Rune selling is the saddest scam that happened to a souls game. Basically a trap for new players who don't get how these games work
@@packagecdo you know what mod thief is
@@janogabor7697I was about to say. That sounds so dumb. There’s no way anyone but old people fall for that. Or is it people who play EA games that fall for it?
@@RIP_ZYZZ1738 i think there was wrestler who paid a lot of money for it. Sadly with the sudden influx of intrest scammers also came in. It's easy to think nobody falls for these, but they do
Asmongold is delivering Garden of eyes team to the court with this one
Honestly, with the history of Sanadsk, is about time. This is not more than the tip of a sh!tty iceberg.
@JoseViktor4099 what else did he do besides the pay walling? Thats the only thing that I know of him as of now.
@@brandonperez8133 Well, he for instance participated on a Cripto Scam, and GoE also has the "relevance" of stealing assets from another mods, such as the Seamless Coop
@@JoseViktor4099 Who's Sanadsk?
@@anonisnoone6125 The last nickname of Garden of Eyes creator. Wharever anything went wrong for him, he had a lot of nicknames and changed identities.
This mod just shows how much more potential souls like games have.
So disappointed that Asmon would react to this Elden Ring mod of all things. The one with the most controversy, stolen assets from FS games and other ER modders, pay wall instead of being free and the mod owner just straight up being a dickhead.
If you want to see and appreciate the hard work of actual good modders for Elden Ring check out: Elden Ring Convergence, Graceborne, Elden Ring Reforged. All amazing mods and FREE.
After learning about the mod creator's background I'm disappointed.
@@shareen_ben convergence is free and better than this mod
This isnt a mod , this is the manifestation of gold diggers who dont want to create an alpha release like convergence :/ this fight is good but go check convergence , they take a little more time to create things but they work is MUCH better ! And to be honest this is one of the rare good work in they mod , they don't reuse other moveset of bosses ect ...well often .
the coffin of Miquella and Malenia
hol up-
MALENIA! LET ME BE THE ANDY OF YOUR LEYLEY AND MY LIFE IS YOURS!
Isn't this mod paywalled
Also accused of stealing assets from several other modders without permissions from mods that are actually good?
Actual 🤡
Am I the asshole for thinking this jsut looks ok? Some of the new effects and animation are great, but the fight doesn't seem particularly well designed
No garden of eyes is a mod scammer. Support the convergence and Reforged modders
The mod maker is so bad they have to use god mode to showcase the fight.
No you’re not. It looks alright at best
nah you aint wrong thats just the mod. Comparing it to others, this is very overrated.
No, you dont. This have the 1:1 issues of Pre-nerf Radahn, the only good thing about this fight is the custcene and the music. Visual clutter , very easy to recognice Sekiro copypasted moveset, which results on an overtuned one which makes the posture break basically impossible, because surprise surprise, *despite what people says, Elden Ring bosses acts like Elden Ring bosses, not Sekiros*
Anyone got the torrent for this? I don’t plan to pay for a paywalled mod when financially supporting free mods is the right dynamic.
8:10 that’s literally an isshin phase 2 attack
No is the true monk from the same game
Mommy Malenia
Rotussy
@@v4lpha not anymore, now it holussy!!
@@escanor3787 must feel DIVINE
Hand to hand combat looks goofy af and doesn't fit her at all imo
I like how you can beak her sword, and that's when she goes hand-to-hand. Cool idea.
Jetstream Sam from MGR Revengenace fights even harder if you take his sword away
I'm sure Blue Dancer had some moves back in the day, he was her Master after all.
Wait you can take his sword? How?@@SpecShadow
wait malenia...consort of miquella....SWEEET HOME ALABAMMMAAAAA
Garden Of Leechs
Looking her doing martial arts make me chuckle lil bit 😂
Didn't created any new game, it's just copy paste files from FromSoftware assets and classic finishing touch on this is that it is hidden behind a pay wall.
Just a thief doing immoral practices.
This thief didn't
The pc modding community is literally undefeted
How is that the edited version?
Don't really see whats so special about this. Modders have been doing this for ages.
Asmong and the average twitch chatter / youtube commenter are sadly pretty impressionable folk
It's just that this mod has better marketing and the majority of people eat it up when there are better mods out there.
Miquella should have had 2 consorts.
After Radahn, you fight this.
This would have fit perfectly for Miquella enchanting EVERYONE. That he has multiple consorts and just uses others for his goals.
Garden of eye's mods should be taken down imo
Before the dlc came out he modded in some weapons that were part of the dlc. And put it behind a paywall. He reuses assets and puts it behind a paywall. You dont see the people behind convergence or ERR charging people for mods do you?
This dude is abusing how chill fromsoft it.
But Malenia being Miquella's twin and consort at the same time? Sweet home Alabama
Radan and Mogh are his brothers. So not much different really.
@@ghostoffantomyeah but they’re also twins
@@jaahman0098twincest vs gaycest. U decide the worst wincest. Lmao
@@psychopassisamasterpiece1997 I’m not going to decide but word on the playground is twincest is slightly worst
@@ghostoffantom I didn't know, I don't play Elden Ring and not much into lore either.
I don't think Asmon knows or cares, but GoE is paywalled when it shouldn't be. The mod author went by another name, Sanadsk. He's had a controversial history for stealing and plagiarizing from other mod authors and scamming his fans. He even sponsored a rune selling site on one his videos recently, that alone should tell you a lot about this person. His Garden of Eyes overhaul mod paywalled through his patreon. Since he's using copyrighted assets (including from other FromSoftware games like Bloodborne, Sekiro, Dark Souls) which is considered illegal. To how he keeps getting away with this is beyond my comprehension, maybe Bamco or FromSoftware don't know or don't care. Point is, Asmon played Archthrone's demo and that mod was FREE and will remain that way once its finished. Convergence is FREE and still getting updated with awesome boss designs. Reforged is also FREE. Sanadsk will NEVER make Garden of Eyes free, no matter what he promises. Early access doesn't equal to having a paywall. He could easily suggest to donate like most mod authors would do and that would've been fine. Honestly, if he just took down the paywall and stop trying to scam his fans, Garden of Eyes would be a decent overhaul mod to play, since he ported over assets from other games, including bosses. I do like some of his weapon changes, but I heard there are balancing issues with his mods. I'll admit one thing is that at least he puts in effort to make something cool like what's showcased in this video. That is the only positive thing I can say about Garden of Eyes.
TL;DR Convergence > Garden of Eyes
if that really bothers you, send them a link to this vid to fromsoft or whoever you want to, in twitter, etc etc you're in your right to do so (it's fine for me, don't feel bad)
after that, if ppl want to pay them... well, it doesn't matter what you say, it's not your right to tell others what they can do
how it should've been in canon (+if devs changed lore and Malenia's empyrean status, then it's 10 out of 10)
paying for mods is peak tardation , and from what I'm seeing in the comment section the modder has quite the shitty reputation lol
Unpopular opinion, but man, do I hate these mods. Their just too gawdy, the over the top anime moves give me a headache and often times just don't work mechanically.
I mean, it's fine, its a mod, no one is forcing me to play it, but the more popular these become, the more Fromsoft will start copying them. And in the ER dlc I definitely felt like Fromsoft was trying to replicate these types of mods. It wasn't bad, I can handle a few obnoxious anime weapons and one screen blinding boss, but I just fear that it's going to eventually become the norm.
Wait until you hear that the mod creator has rebranded himself 3 times due to stealing other modders' works, ripping assets from other games and then charging money for access.
same thought i had honestly the dlc's was pushing it and i think its a experimental move.
but these mods are too spectacle extravaganza that you can't even enjoy the game. looks like a circus show or some sort
I don't mind these types of mods, at least just from viewing (not sure how truly balanced it actually is). As long as fromsoft doesn't take notes from these, luckily I think elden ring dlc is the most insane bosses will get. At least spectacle wise
arent there some big scandals around the garden of eyes mod?
Yes
very so. major controversies about the author throughout the years in the Souls game modding scene
Yeah its not just an Elden Ring mod, its an illegal one at that. It is against TOS to sell mods. Its a shame that you post this video without even looking into what GoE is doing.
Garden of Eyes has been doing this under the premise of "Early Access" but they never release it for free. This mod reuses Fromsoft assets from Elden Ring and Sekiro, illegally paywalling it.
if u guys couldnt tell, the blood flying attacks 100% took inspiration from AC6's SPOILER IF U DIDNT FINISH AC6 SPOILER IF U DIDNT FINISH AC6) ayre and the ibis series boss
You shouldn’t be plugging this mod. The creator steals most of his work from other mods without crediting them and he puts his mods behind paywalls. No you DO NOT deserve payment for making a mod. If you want money for making something. Make your own game. Mod makers who charge money need to be put on blast.
This gets it taken down faster. There's concern trolling as much as Karen's existing on the Internet so expect an email being sent to the Fromsoft team
modders are like a second half of the industry that goes entirely underappreciated. Modders have given Skyrim, Cyberpunk, Stalker, and so many other games entirely new life. They created DOTA / League, Counter-strike, and so many others. Games really should try to accommodate them more. Say what you will about Bethesda, I will always respect them for putting out mod tools
Looks good. Too bad this is behind a paywall. This is why the Convergence team will forever be the best souls modders
You know fromsoft fucked up lorewise when people are changing the final boss of the dlc lmao
Without the paywall, this would’ve been perfect
This mod is more intense than the whole concord game. 😂
Saw this a few days ago, It's insane how much of a better boss this would have been
Na, this is way worse than radahn. Constant blood loss, and she heals on each hit.
Fr, way better
@@shirouemiya737 check your eyes
Even a mod can't quit with the incest.
BTW those are all reused animations from the game, this is an alright mod but it's not as big of a deal as yall make it out to be.
it would be amazing if they add it in as an alternate ending. like if you kill Malenia before coming to Miquella, then Malenia will replace Radahn. but if you didnt kill Malenia, it will be Radahn like normal. this is amazing none the less
You guys are giving asmon too much credit. He would never do research like that. Shout out to the comments though for letting everyone know this is paywalled copyright theft
a missed opportunity to make the boss godwyn
Yeah not even looking at morality of buying that mod and all that stuff, the mod simply doesn't match my taste, it's to extra for me.
Not entirely new move set, some are from sekiro and Dark soul.
this is not a mod this is a scam. common Garden of scam L
It's infact just a mod and a paid one at that so f**k em.
But if it's Malenia, Mohgg doesn't have to die, right? She's all for it.
Theoretically every soulsborne game could get Sekiro Deflection. Will probably only see it in Elden Ring, but theoretically modders could make every soulsborne function like Sekiro combat even Demons Souls and Bloodborne.
Would be the ultimate remaster for From Software games.
The moment i finished terraria calamity mod i knew exactly that modders are insane
I swear by GOD that I had an idea of this in my head, like an impossible dream.
Honestly man when you see modders create shit like this and wonder why a full on studio couldn’t have just added something like that is mad, not hating on the game or devs as I love them both myself but it is just crazy to think someone just made this because they could and were probably disappointed with the doc ending which is fair enough. So well done on this
Unfortunate it's a mod you got to pay for. I'll admit it's a cool fight, but I'll stick to Convergence if I want to play with mods.
man it was crazy but i want anotherr mod that give us gloam eyed queen and godwyn the golden too its very sad we dont get them
Too bad the authors use a game that isn't theirs to make money by paywalling the mod in a world where every other mod is free. Hope to see a lawsuit
1:10 this is like the one from DMC: devil may cry
A guy walks into a bar and asks for 1.4 root beers.
The bartender says "I'll have to charge you extra, that's a root beer float".
The guy says "In that case, better make it a double."
Now let's see Paul Allen's consort...
yep, the difference between someone who sees, and does it as a job, and someone who does it for love, and passion.
I guess the player character had infinite health cause I never saw the player heal at all.
First phase does not give me Consort vibes at all, more like a demonic resurrection as Miquellas last resort to stop the Tarnished. So it makes 0 sense to me when phase transitions.
There should be a huge holy-scarlet bloom at 20% of phase 2, just for show
people ned to STOP saying AI on everything, some artists spend hours and weeks on a project and get called an AI. imagine how it feels if you spend all your hard work on something and someone told you an AI had to have done that
I know there was a lot of work put into this , but to me it kinda looks tasteless for a boss to be such an amalgamation of different weapons/attacks/move sets (most of which belong to other bosses from the game). Kinda lacks style . I'm curious if so many people would have liked it if it was made by a professional studio 🤔
fromsoft should sign a cooperaon deal and allow this as a mod in the literal game just add in the menu mods or alternate realm whatever some cool name so people can play this make it feel like a bonus dld or whatever this is whatt is missing in their games anyways now people made it for them and its good imagine the cooperation and making this better for a fun bonus dlc.
Are we sure this is not a sekiro + bloodborne boss now?
I think its funny actually that mods for games like this is normally just a reskin of a sword or something, so when there actually is a new boss with new moves a basic cutscene and stuff, people lose their mind 🤣 I mean its good work and all, i just find it odd that people are so surprised
u telling me a boss can have a cool design and cool atks without them being arena wide, fps dropping, 3 shoting and allow you to play the game?
C R A Z Y
Imagine saying all that after seeing this shit looking boss
@@janogabor7697bait grade:F
Try a little harder next time lil bro😂😂
@@bromanr7209 imagine defending someone who pomotes actual scam sites. There are better mods like convergence to praise
I find it funny how this mod creator complained about bosses and weapon being too flashy and over the top in his elden ring dlc review. Meanwhile, the stuff he makes:
I saw clips of the fight earlier but didnt realize they also added cinematics to it too!
If they stopped making content and just made the game multiplayer enabled with mods, I’d play the shit out of these crazy mods with my friends.
That phase 2 was insane!
The person that done the modding
did such a great job 👏💪
I liked the second stage fight, but first one seems like it was suffering a bit from original boss problem - too many flashy moves. I think a little bit simpler move set would have worked better.
The Assassin Game Looked Like Something I could TRY. I am all about Shooting, The VR makes it look real 🏀but its just more about the Mechanics of The Game IG
Modders are the reason I’m on play through 10 currently. Like Skyrim this game will never die.
I always wanted for From Soft games to have permanent destruction from fight and blood stains that stay in the bosse arena even after defeating them, so the more bloody and chaos there is . Imagine if even the blalde swing at 6:58 leave a trench in the floor that add up on every try you made on the boss during this playthrough burned zone , coroded one if boss do poison , shining aura if magic hit , or things like that, i rather have CPU/GPU capability used for those than juste adding ultra high resolution or " reality look" tree or grass whatever make the game more pleasing to look at but not as impactful of those idea i think
Thats a good job from modder. The only thing i feel lack is the elegant and grace movement from original Malenia.
Let me solo her: our battle will be legendary.
Bro this dev player must have untold amount of frustration testing this during development.
Look how much he keep back stabbing her lmfao
imagine instead of thinking you beat the 2nd phase? the mod creator said fuck it 3RD PHASEE!!!!!!!!
Meanwhile at the billion dollar company EA studios.
Devs: Any ideas for the new Maddeb 2025?
EA:Change the 2024 number from the previous game to 2025 and ship it.
This is what the DLC should have been. Not Radahn, but Malenia, who was always loyal to Miquella. The next God, the next Empyrean. Redeemed and here for her brother.
The voicelines are also from content that was never added, where Miquella would be part of the Malenia fight.
All my homies don't fuck with GOE mods
Don't get me wrong this is amazing and looks cool as fuck but it doesn't look as hard as either Melania or PC Radahn
The only thing bro did is make a custom theme (tbh this is the only good part), edited the model with fromesoft assets, added moves from other souls games and people really glaze him for this? Like isn't it the standard? Like even without the fact that its illegal to sell copyrighted assets (they get away becouse they say its "early acess" but their other mods are still paywalled) the boss looks kinda unfun.
This is the power of a good game with no bullshit ! It will have fans from all over the world who love and support it with epic mods like these 🥰
Some of the new attacks are all from armored core 6. Still impressive tho.
How crazy that I literally started another playthrough last night, and just stopped like 20 min ago, sat down, pulled up the tube, and saw this at the top. That’s pretty sick. I wonder what the next fromsoft title will be. It’s going to be tough to keep topping themselves. Elden ring 2, dark souls 4, bloodborne 2, Sekiro 2, or something completely new? Or how bout all the above please….. 🙏
100% likely there will be none of the above, aside from the new things of cours and armored core 7
99% of the players wont even see 99% of her attacks if this was in the game.
That's all Elden Ring needed was more epic music like this.
This is why there are die hard Bethesda fans. Starfield is crap to you now but give it a year and you'll see starfield can be anything you want
Melania looking like Phage The Untouchable