Reka nshimire RTC ku bw'iki kiganiro, ariko nisabire Dr Ismael nk'umwarimu akaba n'umushakashatsi gusobanura ibintu ashingiye kuri principes généraux zijyanye n'amategeko, politiki ndetse na "academics". Ndakeka waje mu kiganiro nka "Analyste" and not "fan or partisan". Ubutaha ujye wirinda kuvuga ukosora abo muri kumwe muri debate ahubwo watanga igitekerezo cyawe gishobora kuba ari ukuri cyangwa ari ibinyoma. Kandi uko ubona ibintu si kamara nawe kuko wagiye wivamo kenshi. Ndagira ngo nkwibutseko Abanyarwanda benshi bamaze kujijuka, yewe n'abakurikiye iki kiganiro harimo n'abafite ubumenyi buri ku rwego rwawe... byari kuba byiza, uko mbyumva, iyo udefanda principes academiques kurusha uko udefanda ibikorwa n'ubutegetsi buhari cyane ko mwese mwemeza ko "Amategeko" meza ahari, ikibazo kikaba kuyashyira mu bikorwa. Nubwo uvuga ko ari ikibazo cya "individus" gishobora kuba ari ikibazo cya system cyane ko biva ku rwego rw'igihugu bikagera ku rwego rw'umudugudu. Mwakoze cyane Imana ikomeze ibahe imbaraga zo gutanga ibitekerezo byubaka mudatinya ko mwabizira. Amahoro kuri mwese
@Darius Nzabakwiza: Uyu mugabo ni umukaraza w'ingoma.Ndabona ari umucengezamatwara wa FPR! Arashaka kutwemeza ibyo yemera ku ngufu. Sinzi niba abona ko yinyuraguramo. Umenya atekereza ko abamuteze amatwi bose ari injiji. Wabonye ko iyo ikibazo kimugonze, agerageza kugikwepa azana ibidafite aho bihuriye nacyo (Il essaie de noyer le poisson !) !!! Nongere mbisubiremo, biteye agahinda kubona umuntu nk'uyu ari mwarimu urerera u Rwanda rw'ejo!!!
Courage Étienne, la barre est haute. None ko mu kiganiro ubushize wagiranye na Tom Ndahiro il t'a visé directement akubwira ko kuvugisha I.Victoire kuri we yita ko apfobya Génocide akakubwira ko kumuha ijambo ari ukumutiza umurindi cg kuba complice ko nawe cg namwe abanyamakuru mwabizira none ni défis umuhaye.hum komereza aho icyo kintu cya débat ukora avec bcp de professionnalisme c très bien. Buhoro buhoro bizaza
Ariko Tom muramwibasira mugakabya. Ni umushakashatsi, ibyo avuga ni ibintu aba yashakashatse. Nta rundi rwego ahagarariye ngo ube wavuga uti nirwo rwamutumye. Ubaye utemerenya n'ibyo avuga wakora ubushakashatsi ukamuhinyuza. Ariko kuza umusebya ntabwo ari byo.
Cyakoze koko uyu mugabo Ismael yahabiriye icyuya. Ubutaha Gatanazi ajye abaha break bafate akuka nabyo bifasha mu gusubiza ubwenge ku gihe. Ingabire we ni "no comments", iyi confidence afite iratangaje
Alpha Blondy yararirimbye ngo science sans conscience n'est que ruine de l'âme!! Ni agahinda kenshi kubona umuntu witwa ko waminuje adashobora kuvugisha ukuri muri domaine yitwa ko yaminujemo!! Ubu se abanyeshuri ahagarara imbere koko si abapfunyikira amazi🤔!! Rwanda warakubititse😣
Mbega unvugiye ibintu... Uyu mugabo ari muri roundabout ntashaka kuyivamo ngo atange igisubizo.. He is just going round and round and no answer.. Abanyarwanda barababaje bameze like this🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️ yebabawe, mbabariye abanyeshuri be!!! Mwarimo abona zero mu bibazo yahawe umunyeshuri we abona angahe? 🤔🤦🏾♀️😂😂😂😂😂
Barakoze Ismael na Victoire ariko cyanecyane wowe Etienne guhuza aba bavandimwe. Ismael yari akwiye kumva ko ari umwarimu muri Kaminuza agatanga ibitekerezo bifatika kurushaho.
Nguyu Dr wigisha muri kaminuza yo mu Rwanda! iyi ubu iri mu ntiti ziyoboye hahahahah! ariko abantu bagiye bagerageza nibura kwihishira koko! ubu niba afite umwana mukuru kweli ubu yareba iki kiganira akumva atewe ishema na se?? aba ba Dr bafite ibyondo mu mutwe nibo batuma urubyiruko rucika intege zo kuminuza! UBUTAHA MUZADUHURIZA UYU MU Dr na Barafinda , then nyuma y'ikiganiro tuzamenya hagati y'uyu na barafinda ugomba kujyanwa kwa muganga
Mbega umugabo wee! Uziko yibwira ko azi byose nta n’isoni? Ubu se umuntu utazi critical thinking yigisha iki muri University? Agomba kuba afite PHD mugusisibiranya.
BBC gahuzamiryango yahaye umukecuru wari wagiye ku nteko yikoreye igiseke ngo itegeko shinga rihindurwe,bamuhaye interview aragira ati twaje ku nteko kwitorera Perezida Kagame bati ese wageze hano ute: ati gitifu yaje kundeba ambwira ko ngomba kwambara neza ejo bakazanjyana ikigali ko kandi bazampa impamba ya 5000 🤷🏿♂️none Dr nawe ararahiye aratsemba ati abaturage basabye ko ingingo ya 101 ihindurwa 😅,ndabona yaba abize n'abatarize mu Rwanda nta ntera nini irimo 😁
Bwana Habumugisha, Birashoboka ko utashakaga ko Paul Kagame atorerwa mandat ya 3 wenda ntiwanamutoye,kandi nuburenganzira bwawe cyane ko atatowe 100%. Ariko nujya kuvuga ibintu byabaye mu gihugu cyose uge ugerageza kugabanya amarangamutima na propaganda ahubwo uvugishe ukuri.Ntushobora kuvuga ko 2017,abaturage banze gutora ari benshi mu gihe abo ubibwira harimo abari bibuze kuri list y'itora bagatakamba bashaka gutorera ku mugereka.
Ntago nashakaga kuvuga ku buswa bw’uyu mu docteur kuko hari benshi bafite academic background nziza ariko nabo babaye nkawe. Uyu mwalimu mu myaka 10 yose ishize nta publication n’imwe iri scientifif arakora( nta SCI indexed paper nimwe afite kuva yatangira academic career ye) , none umuntu nk’uwo uri incompetent gutyo murashaka ko akora iki uretse gucinya inkoro no kuvuga amafuti ngo arebe ko yaramuka? Nge iyo ndebe aba ba Dr b’amafuti nibaza abana bigisha muri kaminuza ibyo babigisha bikanyobera!!! Ni gute umwalimu wo muri kaminuza ufite PhD aganira ikiganiro cyiri technical kuriya akarenda asoza nta na rimwe avuze ibintu biri academic? Nta narimwe asobanuye ibintu mu buryo buri academic aho kudefanda amafuti?? Nge buriya icyo nemerera evode uwizeyimana ni uburyo nibura ashakisha amategeko amurengera mubyo avuga kandi akayabona! Niryo tandukaniro rero ry’umuntu wize neza na bano bagiye gushaka degrees z’amafuti muri Malaysia na India. Icyo nabwira urubyiruko rubishoboye ni uko bakwiga cyane bakaminuza kuko mu myaka iri imbere hazakenerwa abahanga bo gufata akazi mugihe izi njiji zitwa ko zize zizaba zirukanwe!!! biteye isesemi rwose kubona umuntu witwa ko yigisha abantu bo muri kaminuza ikomeye mu gihugu atanga ikiganiro akinyuraguramo muri buri jambo ryose.
@@ismaelabouibuchanan1788 Harimo bimwe ugerageza kuvuga neza cyane iyo ari bireba politique mpuzamahanga. Ariko kuri iyi ngingo byo tu n'as pas été convaincant. Sauf que tu n'avais le choix.
@@ismaelabouibuchanan1788 Ismael bihorere nyine ntituragera kuri niveau ya za débats kuko a benshi bashaka ko Ibyo bavuze ko ariko kuri so bwana Ismael ukubwira ngo uracabiranya nkeka ko na niveau intellectuel ye iri hasi.
HE ati injiji mbi ni izize! Ntago yabeshye kabisa. Birababaje kubona un Dr akaba na professor muri university ananirwa gusobanura ibintu byoroshye nkibi ubu se yigisha iki ko aroga?!! Birerekana ko nawe nta bwisanzure afite bwo kwemeza amakosa y'ubutegetsi buriho.
Dammmmnn it's sooo painful to sée this so called "umushakashatsi" about to collapse.!!! Umwuka uri hafi kumushyiramo Kubera ko nawe gusobanura ikinyoma biri kumurya mubwonko
Njyewe ndikunva ari irritating. Ntakintu arikuvuga, no kubeshya byamunaniye kuburyo yabuze amashangwe.. Uyu ya gutesha umutwe utaramenyako ari zero muri debate. Ngo mu Rwanda hari demokarasi 😂😂😂😂😂
Dr. Mubyubahiro nkugomba, level ya analysis ya we iraciriritse.Title natwe wenda turi hafi yazo arko analysis zawe zigushyira mukiciro cyo hasi. Kukumva biteye uburakari!!!
Nkuyu ngo ni Dr yize iki koko? Ibintu avuga ntibyumvikana kandi arabikora abishaka kugirango ajijishe. Urabona afite ubwoba bwo kunenga ubutegetsi buriho bwa FPR. He talks too much kandi akanivuguruza.
C’est pas croyable yavuze Victor inshuro nyinshi ubundi ngo Immaculée, mu byukuri wagirango yari kuri adrénaline yamamaza amahame ya FPR ku buryo atabashaga gucontrola amwe mu magambo yavugaga! Biteye isoni!
Cyore! Uyu ngo ni Doctor mu biki, utazi ko Démocratie ari "concept universel", ko nta gihugu runaka kigira umwihariko wacyo!!! Umuntu wiyita intiti akarimanganya bene aka kageni njyewe antera ikigongwe!!! My God! Uyu niwe urera abana b'u Rwanda mu bya Politiki koko??? Ibi nibyo twita kugendesha pe!!!
His guy can't control this emotions yet he is doctor. And Victoire is very cool and clear on her points. So, doctor has failed. I don't know if he did philosophy
Gatanazi uri umunyamakuru w'umuhanga ukora kinyamwuga, gusa njyewe ntabwo ndi umunyapolitike, ntabwo nemeranwa na Victoire uburyo yitwaye akigaruka mu Rwanda, ariko Professor Doctor Ismael BUCHANAN
Yayayaya baramubajije bati kuki abari mumashyaka atavuga rumwe na Leta birirwa batukwa bakanahohoterwa, bikagaragara ko ari system ifiye ikibazo, kuki tutumva bahanwa... nawe ati wumvise ko umugabo wakubise umugore yahanwe!!! Ubuse koko ibi ni politique cyangwa ni imibanire y umugabo n umugore?? Yewe yewe
Nonese nibarize uno mushingantahe, bamuzaniye imifuka yuzuye ibiryo ariko akaba atabifitiye uburenganzira bwo kubirya☝️mbese muri make twabyita ko aba yariye🙄🤔ndumiwe pe. Gatanazi I respect you 🤝
Uyu mugabo ari kubeshya ko ngo akora analyse nk’umunyRwanda ariko ni umunyRwanda ushyigikiye FPR bidasubirwaho. Ikindi kandi ibintu byose arabica has: ngo “kuba iyi debat ishobora kuba ni democracy”. He need to differentiate constitutional right and democracy. I hereby send him back to school
Katanazi na Victoire urumva uyu docteur yavugi Ki KO muziko na karasira wagerageje kunenga yirukanwe urumva uyu muteruzi wibibindi yakwemera KO bamwubikira imbehe murako .amaboko Habana burwanda niyo azibohora ingoyi ya F P R
Uko billi kose bilan y'ikiganiro ni positif, kandi ndizera ko izafasha abayobora n'abayoborwa. Ismael yagerageje, gusa ntabwo yayoborwaga na analyse scientifique gusa, naho Ingabire akwiye guhabwa uburenganzira bwe aho bubangamirwa.
Umuntu wumu analyste politique wo ku rwego rwa docteur arahirahira akemeza ko mu Rwanda haba démocratie koko mbona ubwonko aba yarabwimuriye mu gifu, akorera ku bwoba bwo kubura umugati agahora asingiza ubutegetsi. Numuntu utarageze mu ishuri arabibibona ko mu Rwanda dufite ubutegetsi bwigitugu bugendera ku iterabwoba bwamize inzego zose zigihugu niyo mpamvu budashobora kwemerera ingabire gukora politiki adakoreye mu kwaha kwabo bita forum y’amashyaka.
Nanjye sinemera ko mu Rwanda hari democracy nkuko nta n'ikindi gihugu na kimwe ku isi kirimo democracy yewe no mu ijuru tubwirwa nta democracy ibayo dukurikije ibyo tubwirwa. Ikizwi nuko buri gihugu ku isi kiri munzira ya democracy hakaba nibihugu byiyita ko biteye imbere muri democracy ugereranije naho bigeze.
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | เปิดใจ "อาจารย์ เบียร์ ฅนตื่นธรรม" นักสนทนาธรรมสายดุดัน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqaBI_mnoDk/mqdefault.jpg)
Dr. Buchanan iyi débat yayitsinzwe cyane.
Madame Victoire yavuze nka 12% y'ibyavuzwe muri iki kiganiro ariko amagambo make yavuze yari ahagije kugira ngo agaragaze intege nke (faibresse) za Dr. Buchanan. Dogiteri yatangiye arondogora ndetse hamwe na hamwe anagaba kuri Victoire ibitero bitari mu njyana y'ikiganiro. Madame Victoire abibonye yagaragaye nkubangamiweho gake ariko yabyikuyemo neza akoresha uburyo bwo kuvuga makeya ariko arimo imitego mu kuyasubiza. Kandi biraboneka ko iyo mitego yose Dogiteri yayiguyemo akigaragaza nk'umuntu ubogamye cyane, w'umuswa kandi wiyemera.
Ingero nk'eshatu
1) Victoire avuga k'uburenganzira yemererwa n'amategeko y'u Rwanda ndetse n'izindi nzego z'ubutabera mpuzamahanga, Dogiteri yabisubijeho abogamye cyane haba muri contexte y'amategeko cyangwa contexte academique, bihita bigaragaza ko Dr. Buchanan atari umusesenguzi ufite intekerezo zigenga ahubwo ari nk'umufana ugerageza kudefanda inyungu za politiki iyoboboye u Rwanda.
2) Victoire yavuze kuri demokrasi n'amateka ndetse n'uburyo amategeko ariho kuri ubu yanogejwe bijyanye n'amateka, asigira Docteur umukoro wo gusobanura impamvu adashyirwa mu bikorwa. Docteur yabivuzeho byinshi arondogora ariko nk'umuntu ufite urwego rw'amashuri nka ruriya ibyo yavugaga ntiyabisobanuye mu buryo butomoye. Byari ukurimangatanya gusa birimo igisa n'ubwiyemezi.
3) Bavuga ku buryo sisiteme (système) iyoboye u Rwanda, kuva ku bashingamategeko kugeza kubayobozi bo hasi, yirengagiza amategeko hagahonyorwa uburenganzira bugenwa n'amategeko ndetse hagakumirwa ubwisanzure bw'ibitekerezo binenga, Dogiteri yavuze asa nk'uwabikozeho ubushakashatsi ko atari systeme ibikora ahubwo ari abantu ku giti cyabo, kandi ko babihanirwa. Atanga ingero ko buryo hari umuyobozi wahanwe kubera gukubita ushinzwe umutekano, ndetse nundi wahanwe i Musanze kubera gukubita no guhohotera umuturage. Byagaragaye ko Victoire yanze ku musubirisha urugero rwa Mr. Evode ndetse n'urw'uwo muyobozi w'i Musanze, bigaragara ko Madame Victoire yabaze agasanga abakurikira real talk channel aribo bazasesengura bagasubiza Dr. Buchanan.
Gusa ikigaragara nuko jugement yawe ibogamye, igatuma wagaragaza uwo uriwe naho uhagaze.
Ikizwi neza n amacenga ye , mbese ko yaje ahagarariye irindi shyaka nicyi cyatumye arihindura? Nuko yashyize ahagaragara ikidagenda kuryo yari ahagararariye!
Wowe ikikumpunzwe nuko hemejwe ko Dr avuze ngo démocratie irahari. Ikindi kibabaje nuburyo Victoire asigaye yivuguruza nuko amaze iminsi avuga ko hari intambwe u Rwanda ruri gutera, none uno munsi arabihinduye ngo ntayo😂😂😂😂😂😂ubwo se kweli
Ese Mme ko abaturage bhagarara bakabwira Président amakosa cg akarengane bagirirwa , mwakurikiranye musanga bidakemurwa?
@@PRWA-gw7be Buchanan ntiyatsinzwe, ahubwo ni wowe watsinzwe. Va aho uhengamiye ube neutre. Buri wese afite uko yumva ibintu. Ndemera ko demos cratus mu mico y, abanyafrika itari yumvikana. Ingabire afite amateka yigiye ku bihugu nk'iburayi undi n'umwarimu kandi akiyumvamo umuco w'abanyarwanda.
Kuli benshi bumvako majorité iyo ihisemo niyo démocratie. Abahutu ni benshi birazwi none se ko bahisemo kwica kuko babeshywe ibyo twabyita démocratie? Hari umuholandi wambwiye ati, niba umututsi ayobora ari nyamuke nta démocratie mu Rwanda ihari.
Umwanzuro nuko abaturage bava mubujiji. Point barré
murapfa ubusa rwose democracy sicyo kibazo nyamukuru dufite kuko iwacu kuvuga ko aricyo kibazo ni nko gushaka gutangira ishuri ugahera muwa gatanu ,ikibazo nyamukuru ni amateka yacu tutumvikanaho ,mu gihe cyose amateka yacu tutayumva kimwe nta democracy ishoboka . abahutu bagira bati ubwinshi bwacu muri democracy tuzahita tuyobora , abatutsi nabo bati ubwinshi bwanyu ntimwadukanga dufite intwaro zacu , democracy siyo izabanza ,ahubwo ubumwe bw'anyagihugu ( ubumwe n'ubwiyunjye +gusobanura amateka ) , kandi abahutu bagomba kumenyako niba abatutsi barabayoboje amayeri n'ubugome nanuyu munsi bakaba bakibikoresha ,ntanarimwe bashobora kuganira cg gusangira ubutegetsi batarisobanurira uko ibintu bikorwa
@@PRWA-gw7be Ariko kuki umuntu utemeranya namafuti yanyu, nangwa udashyigikira umugambi wa FDLR AHINDUKA UMUHENZANGUNI?
@@rukoranyangabo9128 Hanyuma se mwebwe kuki utavuze ibyo mushaka kumva mwumva ko arumuheza nguni cg umuvugizi wa FPR bitaba uko ibyumva nk'umuntu. Ikibabaje nuko mwunva ko kugeza ubu ingima ya Kinani nabagenzi babo harimo nabagize FDRL amatwara yabo nibyo basize bakoze arubyo byari byiza kuba nyarwanda🤷♀️ mukwiye guhindura imyumvire mugatanga igitekerezo byubaka mukareka guhangana bidafite icyo byubaka Rwandan society.
Bravo, bravo Madame Victoire witwaye neza muriyi débat, uri umuhanga vraiment, merci encore.
Gatanazi merci beaucoup uri umu professionnel muri domaine yawe, komerezaho " bon courage et bon succès.
Nawe Dr Asmael wakoze kwitabira iyi débat, mais ............? ?
Ismael ntabye rwose iyi mitekerereze ya docteur iramusebeje
Reka nshimire RTC ku bw'iki kiganiro, ariko nisabire Dr Ismael nk'umwarimu akaba n'umushakashatsi gusobanura ibintu ashingiye kuri principes généraux zijyanye n'amategeko, politiki ndetse na "academics". Ndakeka waje mu kiganiro nka "Analyste" and not "fan or partisan". Ubutaha ujye wirinda kuvuga ukosora abo muri kumwe muri debate ahubwo watanga igitekerezo cyawe gishobora kuba ari ukuri cyangwa ari ibinyoma. Kandi uko ubona ibintu si kamara nawe kuko wagiye wivamo kenshi. Ndagira ngo nkwibutseko Abanyarwanda benshi bamaze kujijuka, yewe n'abakurikiye iki kiganiro harimo n'abafite ubumenyi buri ku rwego rwawe... byari kuba byiza, uko mbyumva, iyo udefanda principes academiques kurusha uko udefanda ibikorwa n'ubutegetsi buhari cyane ko mwese mwemeza ko "Amategeko" meza ahari, ikibazo kikaba kuyashyira mu bikorwa. Nubwo uvuga ko ari ikibazo cya "individus" gishobora kuba ari ikibazo cya system cyane ko biva ku rwego rw'igihugu bikagera ku rwego rw'umudugudu. Mwakoze cyane Imana ikomeze ibahe imbaraga zo gutanga ibitekerezo byubaka mudatinya ko mwabizira. Amahoro kuri mwese
Wimushuka umugati hano urahenda.
Iryo bara ryademukrasi hano ntirirahagera.ndamwibuka atwigisha yarumaga ahuhaho.
@Darius Nzabakwiza:
Uyu mugabo ni
umukaraza w'ingoma.Ndabona ari umucengezamatwara wa FPR! Arashaka kutwemeza ibyo yemera ku ngufu. Sinzi niba abona ko yinyuraguramo. Umenya atekereza ko abamuteze amatwi bose ari injiji. Wabonye ko iyo ikibazo kimugonze, agerageza kugikwepa azana ibidafite aho bihuriye nacyo (Il essaie de noyer le poisson !) !!! Nongere mbisubiremo, biteye agahinda kubona umuntu nk'uyu ari mwarimu urerera u Rwanda rw'ejo!!!
Ĺ0
Urashakako avuga ibyo ushaka?Wabuze ibyawe c niba ubizi, niba wants Leta urashaka kuinfluanceant abandi
@@sibomanaaimable6070 Oya muvandimwe, debate ni ukungurana ibitekerezo, si ngombwa ko twemeranya ariko hari principes scientifiques twifashisha iyo tuganira (biterwa n'urwego uriho, niko twabyize mu ishuri). Naho ubundi ibitekerezo byanjye cg ibyawe biba ukuri iyo bifite référence. Imana iguhe umugisha
nizeyeko uyu buchanan areba comments, maze akigaya! ni ikimwaro ku mwarimu wa kaminuza, cyangwa yabonye za diplomes Prof. Kambanda yatubwiraga, zimwe babonaga bitwaje imbunda!!! Urisebeje cyane
Wumvaga ko uvuga ibyo ushaka se yavuze ukurikwe nubundi mwe murabahezanguni
Wasanga yararihiwe na farije !!?
Nawe aziko ibyo avuga ataribyo, ni ukwishakira imibereho.
Courage Étienne, la barre est haute. None ko mu kiganiro ubushize wagiranye na Tom Ndahiro il t'a visé directement akubwira ko kuvugisha I.Victoire kuri we yita ko apfobya Génocide akakubwira ko kumuha ijambo ari ukumutiza umurindi cg kuba complice ko nawe cg namwe abanyamakuru mwabizira none ni défis umuhaye.hum komereza aho icyo kintu cya débat ukora avec bcp de professionnalisme c très bien. Buhoro buhoro bizaza
Tom ni igisebo ku gihugu.
Ariko Tom muramwibasira mugakabya. Ni umushakashatsi, ibyo avuga ni ibintu aba yashakashatse. Nta rundi rwego ahagarariye ngo ube wavuga uti nirwo rwamutumye. Ubaye utemerenya n'ibyo avuga wakora ubushakashatsi ukamuhinyuza. Ariko kuza umusebya ntabwo ari byo.
@@benisrael7 ariko ntimugace intege abantu bari kwiga! harya umushakashatsi waba uzi icyo bisobanura? cyangwa nawe urashaka kumera nka babandi bavuga ngo bivuze umuntu ushakashaka??? umushakashatsi ni ijambo rishya mu kinyarwanda ryahimbwe kugirango babone translation y'ijambo researcher cyangwa chercheur. kugirango ube umushakashatsi rero bisaba ko ugomba kuba ufite amashuri abikwemerere( akenshi PhD cyangwa masters in some cases). none wambwira Tom afite ayahe mashuri?( na secondaire ntayo yarangije niba wari utabizi). , ese tuvuge ko ari intiti nka ba newton cyangwa archimede akaba adakeneye amashuri kugirango akora research da, nonese wambwira publication nimwe iri muri peer reviewed journal uwo mushakashati Thom yaba yarapublishinze?. anyway, abibasira Tom bo bamutuka ntago mbashyikiye kuko ni umuco mubi gutuka uwo mudahuje ibitekerezo ariko namwe mujye mushyira mu gaciro! kwita umushakashatsi a high school dropout bitesha agaciro n'abandi bashakashatsi bose
Ismaël azasubire mu ishuri kwiga icyo bivuga amateka n'amategeko.
Biteye agahinda uyu mugabo!!!
@@benisrael7 :
Ngo ni umushakashatsi???
Umushakashatsi nyabaki ?
Tom Ndahiro yakunze kwigaragaza n'umumamyi, umuhezanguni w'umututsi wamunzwe n'urwango n'ivanguramoko. Impamvu ameze atyo ntuyimbaze. Icyizwi ni uko yahoze ari MONAGRI!
Université yaboneyemo impamyabumenyi y'ubushakashatsi muri génocide yanagizemo uruhare sinzi aho iherereye!!!
Mbega byiza! Kujijura abanyarwanda ni uguhuza intiti nk’izi. Biragaragaye ko kudefanda ibinyoma bigora. Ukuri kurivugira. Asante Étienne!
Ikibazo nuko FPR yahinduye abantu injiji kuko amafuti kuyadefenda ntinyoroshye🤔🤔
Nkunze iki kiganiro mpaka rwose bravo Mr Gatanazi wasubije ikifuzo cyanjye nigeze gutanga cyuko wazajya ukora za débats nkizi zihuza impande zose zitabona ibintu kimwe encore merci iki kiganiro cyurubaka abanyarwanda twese turabavandimwe
Victoire Ingabire ni smart pe!!! 👍👏👏👏👏👏 Mbega ukuntu akora debate neza, patience, peacefulness imurimo, mbega byiza😍😍. Uyumugabo we Ismail amaboko ari everywhere, bigaragaza umuvuduko mwinshi w'amaraso kubera atari a free thinker, so aggressive!! 🤦🏾♀️
Cyakoze koko uyu mugabo Ismael yahabiriye icyuya. Ubutaha Gatanazi ajye abaha break bafate akuka nabyo bifasha mu gusubiza ubwenge ku gihe. Ingabire we ni "no comments", iyi confidence afite iratangaje
@@NewGenerattion aha, dore aho nibereye 🤦🏾♀️ uyumugabo niyo bamuha pause as many as you can imagine, still yakomeza kuvuga nk'umuntu wahahamutse kandi ushaka gushyiraho igitugu mumafuti arikuvuga. Mbega gukura, ukiga ntihagire icyo bikumarira we🤦🏾♀️, birababaje!! 😓🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
Ni kibazo niba doctor ufite imyumvire nkiyi ariwe utanga isomo rya politique.
Ni bamwe Kagame yavuze bize ! Ajye yiga no gusobanura muri make, iyo avuze menshi yisubiramo, akivuguruza, akiharira n'ijambo !
Niba umuntu ufite Phd ari paralyzed ubwo abo yigisha bo bazamera bate ?
@@frankmutunzi2666 uvuze ukuri, kandi bikaba biteye ubwoba kuri ejo hazaza😏😏😏
Biteye kwibaza abo yigisha icyo bazavamo. Nguru urwo abanyarwanda tuzize.Kuba uri gogiteri ugasobanura ibintu bya domaine yawe nk'umunyamudugudu wogejwe na we ubwonko birababaje.
@@frankmutunzi2666 barahwereye wangu. Njye mbashije kubona impact ya democracy (freedom of thinking and expression) ku ireme ry'uburezi.
Uwomu docteur arikutubeshya rwose kandi azinezako ibyo atubwira arukugirango yirengere nikangahe ibikorerwa umuturage abigiramo x uruhare usibye kubimutura heju?bakagombye kujya babanza kuganiriza abaturage ibigiye kubakorerwaho kuko byose biza bigonga umuturage.
Alpha Blondy yararirimbye ngo science sans conscience n'est que ruine de l'âme!! Ni agahinda kenshi kubona umuntu witwa ko waminuje adashobora kuvugisha ukuri muri domaine yitwa ko yaminujemo!! Ubu se abanyeshuri ahagarara imbere koko si abapfunyikira amazi🤔!! Rwanda warakubititse😣
Yavuze,ukurikwe keretse,niba ushaka ko avuga,nukuri kwawe
Ahooo ngwino tuganire rero
Umu maman wacu aba yitonze yumva anareba uko uwitwa intiti ishyigikira leta igiye kudutagangaza maman uzubwenge kbs nikigihugu wakiyobora kbs
Kubwawe niba ubona yayobora igihugu, azabiharanire abanyarwanda nibo bafite ubwo bubasha natsinda azayobore uretse ko nyeka ko amategeko atabimyemerera nk'umuntu wafunzwe igihe kingana kuriya.
Abanyarwanda nitwe duhitamo utuboneye.
@@emmyntidendereza7775 sha yagitegeka kurusha izo nkandabitabo bagifashe bakoresheje intwaro. Dukeneye za debates hagati yi nkandabitabo nta opposition, hanyuma abaturage bakihitiramo 👍
@@emmyntidendereza7775 na Nelson Mandela yarakiyoboye kndi ntiyafunzwe igihe gito. Kndi buriya gufungwa sinigitangaza,na Paul yafungwa abaturage babishatse
@@emmyntidendereza7775 ari mandera na victoire uwafunzwe igihe kirekire ninde?
ndumva mujya impaka z’ubusa!! uwo mushyigikiye nimugende mumutereke murugwiro hanyuma urimo mumukuremo koko!!!
Bonjour, uyu munyamakuru ni umunyamwuga koko bravo! Madame Ingabire yavuze ukuri yitonze cyane naho uyu mudocteur ibintu byinshi yivuyemo.
Dr is very clever and Madame
Gusa ibiganiro nkibi birakenewe cyane
Gatanazi waduhemukiye cyane kuzana Ismaël hano. Ashaka kutwumvisha ukuntu 1+1=1
Gatanazi ararengana aradufasha mu kutugaragariza impuguke nka Ismaël uko barimanganya
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mbega unvugiye ibintu... Uyu mugabo ari muri roundabout ntashaka kuyivamo ngo atange igisubizo.. He is just going round and round and no answer.. Abanyarwanda barababaje bameze like this🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️ yebabawe, mbabariye abanyeshuri be!!! Mwarimo abona zero mu bibazo yahawe umunyeshuri we abona angahe? 🤔🤦🏾♀️😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 arahazepeee....ati Democratic irahari
@@lamanene8848 suko se, azajye kubibwira KIZITO cg CYUMA .😭
Urabona ko afite gene arakora amagestes menshi il se pert muri développement yibitekerezo bye
Ntabwo afite conviction
Kumwumva biteye ubute, ubuse niyumva ibintu yavuze ntiyigaya koko ??
Aravuga n'ibintu byinshi bitari ngombwa kugira ngo ajijishe abantu.
Ba.mubwiye ibya kangondo na kibiraro. Areba nka mbega urubwa
Uyu mugabo ni uwo kumara umwuka. Selon J Chirac, il a raté l'occasion de se taire
Hahahhh uransekeje kabisa. Il a raté l'occasion de se taire hahahh umva, nari nashatse expression juste et bien, la voici... hahahh
Yes, he missed an opportunity of being quiet.
Nakunze iki kiganiro but dr yagakwiye kuvugisha ukuri akavuga ko yaje afite ishyaka ahagarariye aho kwitwa umushakashatsi
Ikiganiro cyiza cyane , ariko DR afite ikibazo cyo gushaka gukosora abantu muri debate kandi buri wese agomba gutanga igitekerezo cye
Dr ibyavuga turikumwe demokarasi ingabire ashaka turayizi aho yatugejeje turahazi nonerero ntamuntu uzazana ibinyuranye nikerekezo kigihugu ntituzabyemera nimutuze twubake igihugu cyacu mureke kuvuga ibitubaka Dr komerezaho bazumva
@@nzabanitaferdina2930 hhhhhhh ,ibintu byose bikorwa mu neza y'abanyagihugu ,none se ibyo muvuga byo ni ineza y'abanyagihugu ?
Real talk channel jye mbona yagatewe inkunga kuko tugize abanyamakuru 5 nka Gatanazi ,aba depute bose ibyabo byamenyekana kuko nabo dukeneye kumenya imikorere yabo
Ariko mwaretse kwitwaza amateka nk'inzitizi yo guha ijambo abaturage no gusaranganya ubuyobozi.
FPR yarabyihariye, inica abaturage, irabasahura.
Ariko bukanani aridefanda ese nireta yamutumyex
@@ndizeyedesire6265 I j I. J I. I j. J j. J I iji. I ji. J I. I. J. I nj. I. J
@@ndizeyedesire6265 I j I. J I. I j. J j. J I iji. I ji. J I. I. J. I nj. I. J j j j ii I in I. J j
@@kadage237 I j ij j I ji I. is I ij I ji n j j. Jii j. ji. JJ. Ijij I. I j. Ii I I I j ni. J. Ni Nice j I j j in.
cyari ikiganiro kiza Buchanan Yashatse kuba opposition suko byose ariko abyemera uko wumvaga ko bitamurimo, gusa yitwaye neza ngewe nabikunze yagombaga kutagira umurongo umwe na Victoire kugira Debat iryohe.iyo bahuza umurongo byari kuba arikiganiro gisanzwe kandi Gatanazi uko nabibonye yagiteguye ashaka ko haba ibitekerezo bibiri bihabanye. Bravo Gatanazi ibutaha uge udushakira ababibamo babyumva uko, Victoire nkunda debate ze gusa byanshimisha agiranye nka Debate n'umuntu uri nko muri RPF.
Iyi ngirwa docteur muyirebe neza iyo doctorat yaba yarayibye, ahubwo naregwe gukoresha impapuro mpimbano!
Ntabyo bagirira isoni gukora! Wabona diplome ye ari merci Kagame🤣🤣
Uyu yabonye diplôme yitwa merci kagame
@@costarwanda1739 sha murabo kubabarirwa kabisa ,uwo mugore wanyu yavuze NGO ikibabuza gutaha nuko bavugako mufite ingengabiterezo nonese ubu aho mutabigaragaraza nihe ?niba mutuka uvuga ibyo mutemera mugashima ibyuwo mwemera ubwo niyo demukarasi muzazana,rero ingengabitekerezo murayifite kd muyiterwamo nababyeyi banyu nkuyu ubeshya NGO azateza imbere abaturage azabaha iki badafite?amashuri ,amashanyarazi mituweli amavuriro isuku Niki gishya mufite uretse gutesha abandi agaciro gusa
Barakoze Ismael na Victoire ariko cyanecyane wowe Etienne guhuza aba bavandimwe. Ismael yari akwiye kumva ko ari umwarimu muri Kaminuza agatanga ibitekerezo bifatika kurushaho.
Iki kiganiro cyimfashije kumva aho FPR igeze muri ,"social engineering".
Nibajije niba Ismael ari professeur wa Universite ukuriye ishami rya politiki cyangwa cadre wa FPR.
Umwanya we wagombye kuri Directeur w"Itorero rya FPR. Ndizera ko interview yayitsinze.
Nguyu Dr wigisha muri kaminuza yo mu Rwanda! iyi ubu iri mu ntiti ziyoboye hahahahah! ariko abantu bagiye bagerageza nibura kwihishira koko! ubu niba afite umwana mukuru kweli ubu yareba iki kiganira akumva atewe ishema na se?? aba ba Dr bafite ibyondo mu mutwe nibo batuma urubyiruko rucika intege zo kuminuza!
UBUTAHA MUZADUHURIZA UYU MU Dr na Barafinda , then nyuma y'ikiganiro tuzamenya hagati y'uyu na barafinda ugomba kujyanwa kwa muganga
So true... Uyu niwe ugomba kuryanwa kwa muganga, at least tukamenya impamvu avuga ibintu bidafite shinge narugero
Niba nuyu mwene wanyu Dogiteri mugesera yasebeje isomo rya geography ,thesis ye yakoze yerekanye aho banyuza abatutsi iyubusamo basubira Ethiopia!! buriya abana be bajya bicuza?
Mbega umugabo wee! Uziko yibwira ko azi byose nta n’isoni? Ubu se umuntu utazi critical thinking yigisha iki muri University? Agomba kuba afite PHD mugusisibiranya.
Niyo mpamvu abarangiza kwiga bagera hanze ugasanga ni ntakigenda mumutwe 😪, baba bafite aho babikuye.
@@Queen-ze1tm ibyo nibyo, kuburyo nta bazungu baba batugaya. Twebwe abanyarwanda tuba hanze bikadutera isoni. Ariko tugomba gufasha bene washu baje ukuntu twabaha za aides zukuntu bakwiga mûri za university.
BBC gahuzamiryango yahaye umukecuru wari wagiye ku nteko yikoreye igiseke ngo itegeko shinga rihindurwe,bamuhaye interview aragira ati twaje ku nteko kwitorera Perezida Kagame bati ese wageze hano ute: ati gitifu yaje kundeba ambwira ko ngomba kwambara neza ejo bakazanjyana ikigali ko kandi bazampa impamba ya 5000 🤷🏿♂️none Dr nawe ararahiye aratsemba ati abaturage basabye ko ingingo ya 101 ihindurwa 😅,ndabona yaba abize n'abatarize mu Rwanda nta ntera nini irimo 😁
Hhhhhhhh shaa uramubwiye
Uwo mutype ngo ni umwarimu wa kaminuza? Ariko injiji zibaho yeee!! Gatanazi, rwose wangije umwanya wuwo munyarwandakazi. Iyo ngirwa mwarimu ntacyahizanye kuganira numuntu wumugabo nga INGABIRE.
Victoire ari kumva uko uno mutype abwejagura ubusaaaaaa akibaza ati: UMUNTU NK'UYU YIZE HE KOKO? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ubu yasetse yatemagaye pe!
Hahahahaha, iyi comment iranyishe🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Assia niba mubwenge bwawe uziko harabantu babwejagura, iyiniyo mpamvu iyoboye gutsindwa kwanyu bidasubirwaho. Niba Victoire abamushyigikiye mwese mufite imyumvire iteye gutya, nimukomeza nababwiriki. U Rwanda ntiruzongera n'umunsi numwe guha urubuga abantu bambura abandi ubuzima cyangwase ubumuntu. Uwo mutima w'urwango rw'ubuterahamwe niwo warimbuye abana bu Rwanda.
Nkugire inama ya kigabo, jugunya ibitekerezo by'umwanda, wakire ubuzima bw'urukundo rukunda abantu, nahubundi nutabyipakurura uzicwa nagahinda k'urwango, bizatuma utajya mw'ijuru. Abahekuye u Rwanda, bari bafite umutima nkuyu wawe wo kwambura abantu ubumuntu mukabita amazina yibikoko. NYAMARA EMERAKO AKABI KATSINZWE MU RWANDA, REKA GUKOMEZA KUKIHAMBIRAHO KUKO NUMUVUMO URUTA YINDI YOSE. U Rwanda ntiruzongera kwicwa ukundi, nibi ubona bari kuvuga ngoni Demokrasi, burya iharanira kubaho kwabantu, Ntabwo ari iturufu yokwica abantu, niba ariwo muvuno murambirijeho, uwo mukino watsinzwe kera. ESE UBUNDI UMWAMBURA UBUMUNTU NIWOWE WAMUREMYE? NIba haricyo mutumvikanaho, niki umukosoyeho? Imana ikubabarire igukuremo ibitekerezo byatokoye.
Bravo gatanazi ibi nibyiza abantu nkaba buchanan nibo bakwiye gukora debate na opposition kugira babereke ukuri kwibikorwa na leta merci kbs
Nyamara Ingabire ni umuhanga cyane
Nsoza ndashimira cyane Gatanazi; uyu ni umwihariko wazanye mu rugendo rwo kubaka Demokrasi irambye no kugira igihugu kigendera ku mategeko. Ibindi nko gukorera mu mucyo, Ubutabera, Amatora nyayo n'ibindi nkibyo nabyo bizaza.
NB: Ikibanze ni ukuganira no kwishyira ukizana mu bitekerezo.
Ni hatali kweli 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Science sans consience n'est que ruine de l'âme.
Vive le pardon
Uratubesha kuko ntamuturage wigeze atekereza kujya gusaba guhindura itegeko nshinga barabitegetswe weho doctor ntamunyarwanda utabizi kandi nizo ngingo zamategeko ntazo bazi ntukabeshe rwose keretse kubesha niba aribyo waherewe doctor.
Gatanazi Uri professional
Mbega ismail ngo arasuzuguwe na ingabite!!!!! Reba uko victoire arikumureba yosekera nagasuzuguro. Ubutaha ismail uzisubiteho ntukajye uvugango reka ngukosore ngaho uri kwigisha mushuli, ndakugaye kandi twari ni nshuti tuganira cyane!!!!! Uragayise nogusuzugurirwa mumaso yabanyarwanda
Genda sumayire uri cya rusisibiranya. Kuba witwa docteur nibyo urimo kuvuga ntaho bihuye namahame ya democracy.yahombue kujya mwishuri cgs agasubiza diplome kuko atayikwiriye
Prof Ismaël iyo abategetsi bakoresheje igitugu bakica amategeko ari mw'Itegekoshinga yashyizweho hakurikije amateka y'Igihugu, baba babangamiye democratie. Uravuga ko kurandura Ibihingwa by'Abaturage baba babigizemo ijambo?
Byambabaje kubona academic nkawe wagombye kubera abandi urumuli uza ukabogama urengera amafuti y'abategetsi.
hello every one ndashimira umunyamakuru wahuje ababa banyabwenge ba politike nyarwanda gusa ibiganiro bisanaho ari ukuri undi mwanya bagasa ninyigisho ubutaha muzajye mubivangura ntaho politike yurwanda ikwiye gusanishwa niyahandi kuko ibihugu nababituye baratandukanye ikindi umunyapolitike aho ava akagera agaragaza ko inyungu zibyo aharanira zireba rubanda kandi atari ko bimeze inyungu bwite zabanyapolitike burigihe zihora zituma impfu ,intamabara aribyo bisubizo kubyo baharanira munyihanganire amarangamutima ari muri iki kiganiiro ntakwiye kuko hano byari ubusesenguzi sugusingiza cg kugaragaza ibyo umuntu yifuza munyunguze abanyarwanda ni dutere intambwe yo gukora politike itagamije inda ni hakorwe politike iri mwizina ryayo kd uyumunsi ibyo mwita amateka ubu nibyubu byaba amateka ibyiza rero nuko yazaba amateka meza aho guhora twitana inyamaswa cg ngo dutange ibitekerezo bitukana gusa ntacyo byazamara .
Ku munota 44:33'' haratangaje.ngo habaho na democracy y igitugu!iki kiganiro kiraryoshye cyane.
Ni uburyo bw'imitegekere kimwe na democracy
Munyamakuru turagukunda ariko ntukajyutuzanira utugabo nkutu twindindimanganyi kuko biduteshumwanya wubusa
Sha babidusinyishije kungufu kuko nanjye niga kaminuza banzaniye urupapuro ngo ninsinye ngiye kure ibyo ngiye gusinyira nsanga barigusabako nanjye nakwemeza ubwo busabe kandi narasinye da! Icyo gihe byakorwaga naba mudugudu .kandi nyuma mumatora twabuze abaturage batora president kuko baribake cyane haza gutekinika kuko umubare wabatoye wagombaga guhujwa nabasabye ko itegeko nshinga rihinduka kuko batubwiraga ko ntakuntu baba. Baragaragaje ko 98%basabye ko itegeko nshinga rihinduka ngo nyuma bigaragare ko hatoye abatarenze 29% .barabuze burundu nyuma twaje kubatorera kugirango nibura ya 98% bigaragare ko yatoye ubwo rero ntaka tubeshye kuko abaturage baritoye batarizi kuko hari nabazaga wababaza iryo tegeko ugasanga baziko ariribaha amafaranga cyangwa girinka hari nabaribaziko ariribemerera kujya mukicyiro cyambere cyubudehe
Bwana Habumugisha, Birashoboka ko utashakaga ko Paul Kagame atorerwa mandat ya 3 wenda ntiwanamutoye,kandi nuburenganzira bwawe cyane ko atatowe 100%.
Ariko nujya kuvuga ibintu byabaye mu gihugu cyose uge ugerageza kugabanya amarangamutima na propaganda ahubwo uvugishe ukuri.Ntushobora kuvuga ko 2017,abaturage banze gutora ari benshi mu gihe abo ubibwira harimo abari bibuze kuri list y'itora bagatakamba bashaka gutorera ku mugereka.
Iyo Dr yayikuyehe
Ngaho da ireme ryuburezi ngo ntaryo wakwigishwa nuyu ukazamenya iki!?
Hhh ari kurwana kumugati we
@@kayitarejames9553 yashakuje urwanga ruramurenga.umurezi ntashaka nogutanga akanya ngo Intaripfana zivuge
Nta bya BUCYANA mbonye hano real talk jya ukomeza utuzanire benshi bivemo.
Serusisibiranya Dr uri aha ntasanzwe!! Rwanda warakubititse.... Ngabire yi U Rwanda uri umunyabwenge niwowe natora yaba Democracy yabagaho iwacu
Ntago nashakaga kuvuga ku buswa bw’uyu mu docteur kuko hari benshi bafite academic background nziza ariko nabo babaye nkawe.
Uyu mwalimu mu myaka 10 yose ishize nta publication n’imwe iri scientifif arakora( nta SCI indexed paper nimwe afite kuva yatangira academic career ye) , none umuntu nk’uwo uri incompetent gutyo murashaka ko akora iki uretse gucinya inkoro no kuvuga amafuti ngo arebe ko yaramuka? Nge iyo ndebe aba ba Dr b’amafuti nibaza abana bigisha muri kaminuza ibyo babigisha bikanyobera!!!
Ni gute umwalimu wo muri kaminuza ufite PhD aganira ikiganiro cyiri technical kuriya akarenda asoza nta na rimwe avuze ibintu biri academic? Nta narimwe asobanuye ibintu mu buryo buri academic aho kudefanda amafuti?? Nge buriya icyo nemerera evode uwizeyimana ni uburyo nibura ashakisha amategeko amurengera mubyo avuga kandi akayabona! Niryo tandukaniro rero ry’umuntu wize neza na bano bagiye gushaka degrees z’amafuti muri Malaysia na India.
Icyo nabwira urubyiruko rubishoboye ni uko bakwiga cyane bakaminuza kuko mu myaka iri imbere hazakenerwa abahanga bo gufata akazi mugihe izi njiji zitwa ko zize zizaba zirukanwe!!! biteye isesemi rwose kubona umuntu witwa ko yigisha abantu bo muri kaminuza ikomeye mu gihugu atanga ikiganiro akinyuraguramo muri buri jambo ryose.
@@kezawakassy9212 Bari bagiye kumuhambiriza kubera ubuswa bwe?
Nta democracy mu gihugu gikennye ntibishoboka agahato ntikabura mu gihugu gifite ivangura rishingiye ku bujiji
Amazuru iyo ni impamvu koko?
Amagambo meshi siyo yerekana ukuri!
Mr BUCHANAN, urimo uracabiranya cyane. Ntabwo ufata argument ngo ujye jusqu'au bout ! Nkubwo wari utangiye usobanura neza ibintu, ugeze hagati ugonzwe, ukubitamo iby'ifunga n'ifungura n'iby'urukiko rw'Africa. Kandi Ingabire yakubwiye ko iyo kuri RIB bamuhamagaye batajya bamubwira ko atemerewe gushinga ishyaka! Bamubuza gukora inama, ariko ntibamubwire impamvu!
Ibyo birashoboka mu biganiro kutarangiza arguments bitewe nuko ikiganiro kiba cyagenze ndetse nigihe uhabwa ngo usobanure ibiabzo bibazwa. So wumve neza atari ugucabiranya nkuko ubivuga, ahubwo nuko uba usabwa gusobanura byinshi mu gihe ufite uhabwa nubaza, bityo nawe nkumuntu ukibwira ko warangije byose.. be optimistic ko bishoka kubaho kandi ntabwo ikiganiro gisubiramo ngo ube wasubira mubyo wavuze
@@ismaelabouibuchanan1788 Harimo bimwe ugerageza kuvuga neza cyane iyo ari bireba politique mpuzamahanga. Ariko kuri iyi ngingo byo tu n'as pas été convaincant. Sauf que tu n'avais le choix.
@@ismaelabouibuchanan1788 Ismael bihorere nyine ntituragera kuri niveau ya za débats kuko a benshi bashaka ko Ibyo bavuze ko ariko kuri so bwana Ismael ukubwira ngo uracabiranya nkeka ko na niveau intellectuel ye iri hasi.
Dore ibyago igihugu gifite kugira abantu nk’aba ngo ni impuguke kd ari impumyi
Thank you so much
Ibiganiro nkibi ni byiza cyane rwose. Etienne rwose uri umuntu w'umugabo cyane komereza aho
Gukubita biri mu butabera ntaho bihuriye na democratie je crois.... izi ngero za Ismael ni inappropriés par rapport au sujet du débat!!!!
Bavandimwe uRwanda rugeze aharindimuka niba umuntu wiyita Docteur akaba yigisha muri université, ayobora rimwe mu mashami yigisha amahame ya politique, akaba adashobora kuvuga uko bikwiye izina rya Victoire, aza akavuga amahomvu kuva ku ntangiriro kugeza ku musozo. Ahari ubwonko wagira ngo bashyizemo cassette. J’aurais bien aimé ko Gatanazi anuhuza na Ntaganda. Merci encore Gatanazi pour tes bonnes questions!
Ismael ararengana ahubwo ikibazo namatiku abari mumitwe,nonese koko ubu mubona urwanda ntaho rwavuye ntanaho rugeze?? Nonese wowe wibazako uwaruguha nguruyobore waruyobora ute? Bitekereze niba wageza byibura kuri 2% byaho urwanda rugeze, yewe mwebwe murwanya urwanda muzarira muhogore kuko Imana irubereye maso, rwose mukizwe muve mumatiku.kagame arashoboye cyane akomeze aturangaze imbere.
Uyu se Ismail ibyo avuga ni ibiki? Azi abasore bandikiye PM nubu bakaba bafunze? Ngo babwira abaturage ngo bahinge ariko ntibabyemere kubera imyumvire iyo niyo demokarasi yigisha se? Abo baturage se nibyo bashaka nyamara kuri constitution ngo bubahiriza ibyo bashaka. Ikindi aravuga ibintu byinshi akanigana ijambo Victoire
❤❤❤❤❤❤ bizarajyira mujyezeho kubwiyujye bwoguha abaturajye ijombo nimwubaha amatejyeko
Ikibazo abanyarwanda ntabwo turagera aho dutora umuntu kuko ashoboye ni fanatisme kandi kuyobora igihugu c c'est pas umuntu uwo ariwo wese uvuye aho ashaka ngo ndashaka kuyobora uru Rwanda rwavuye kure mujye mureba centrafrique abaturage babuze icyo bafata nicyo bareka ,
Dr we nukuri watojwe kubintore pee! Ndabona urimo guhamiriza kuruta kuba specific ukaba straight to the point
HE ati injiji mbi ni izize! Ntago yabeshye kabisa. Birababaje kubona un Dr akaba na professor muri university ananirwa gusobanura ibintu byoroshye nkibi ubu se yigisha iki ko aroga?!! Birerekana ko nawe nta bwisanzure afite bwo kwemeza amakosa y'ubutegetsi buriho.
Abo yigisha bazarwara muzunga ubuzima bwabo bwose!!
Dammmmnn it's sooo painful to sée this so called "umushakashatsi" about to collapse.!!! Umwuka uri hafi kumushyiramo Kubera ko nawe gusobanura ikinyoma biri kumurya mubwonko
🤣🤣🤣🤣, reba ukuntu yavuzeeeee kugira twumve kungufu uko ikinyoma cye ari ukuri 100%. Ariko victoire yivugira make kandi azi mumutwe ningingo zamategeko uko zanditse, ariko kano kagabo kari kubwejaguraaaa ntaningingo nimwe kavuga.
Njyewe ndikunva ari irritating. Ntakintu arikuvuga, no kubeshya byamunaniye kuburyo yabuze amashangwe.. Uyu ya gutesha umutwe utaramenyako ari zero muri debate. Ngo mu Rwanda hari demokarasi 😂😂😂😂😂
Uyu ngo ni dr muhaye 5 % . arikurondogora cyane
Ndibariza abakurikiye ikiganiro:muri principes za democracy iyo hapfuyemo imwe ikomeza kuba democracy?
Democracy ntizingana zose
Dr. Mubyubahiro nkugomba, level ya analysis ya we iraciriritse.Title natwe wenda turi hafi yazo arko analysis zawe zigushyira mukiciro cyo hasi. Kukumva biteye uburakari!!!
Nkuyu ngo ni Dr yize iki koko? Ibintu avuga ntibyumvikana kandi arabikora abishaka kugirango ajijishe. Urabona afite ubwoba bwo kunenga ubutegetsi buriho bwa FPR. He talks too much kandi akanivuguruza.
Inkomamashyi , bamwirukanye yahita ajya kwisuka kubera atabona nuwumufasha. Yavugaga ukagira agiye kuguruka ntamababa afite 😅
@@Queen-ze1tm Jye nabonaga yibagiwe ko yicaye ku ntebe !
Erega uyu mu maman yitwa victoire ntago yitwa Victor nagukosoraga monsieur le docteur Ismaël.merci pour la compréhension.
C’est pas croyable yavuze Victor inshuro nyinshi ubundi ngo Immaculée, mu byukuri wagirango yari kuri adrénaline yamamaza amahame ya FPR ku buryo atabashaga gucontrola amwe mu magambo yavugaga! Biteye isoni!
Étienne Gatanazi komeza ubatanage rwose👌👌👌👌👌
Nta democracy iri mu Rwanda! Kuko ntabwo abantu basenyerwa kumanywa yihangu nonese iyo democracy niya bamwe bikaba ibyago kubandi ? Nkuwo rwose democracy yaramurenze mugihe abandi twapfuye tugenda
Impamvu uvuga ibyo ni uko utazi icyo bita government policies!! Numara kubimenya ntuzongera kuvuga ibyo .
Ubu se uyu mugabo ibyo avuga arabizi ko bimusebya (Ingabire,Diane,Barafinda,Theonest hari n’abandi) ayobewe icyo bazize ubu bugoryi bwo kwimurira ubwenge mu gifu mubureke kandi wiseke nta buhanga nkubonanye
Yewe Buchanan aduteye igipindi kuri changement ya constitution !
Cyore!
Uyu ngo ni Doctor mu biki, utazi ko Démocratie ari "concept universel", ko nta gihugu runaka kigira umwihariko wacyo!!!
Umuntu wiyita intiti akarimanganya bene aka kageni njyewe antera ikigongwe!!!
My God! Uyu niwe urera abana b'u Rwanda mu bya Politiki koko???
Ibi nibyo twita kugendesha pe!!!
Mukomeze mwiruke inyuma y'umuyaga muzawufata ! Ukuri kw'isi nuko ntanahamwe hari democratie njye nzi !!!
@@mazimpakagustave6686 :
Kandi Nyakubahwa Doctor akubwiye ko mu Rwanda iganje!!!
Nukwirengera muvandimwe siwe batamwirukana mukazi
Prof.Ukwiye kuba umushinga cyaha da système.Byarangira uhembwe nka MUTANGANA.
His guy can't control this emotions yet he is doctor. And Victoire is very cool and clear on her points. So, doctor has failed. I don't know if he did philosophy
Doctor abura ubwenjye akavuga ubugoryi ngo democracy irahari umuntu atanga igitecyerezo akajya muri gereza impyisi gusa
Dr buchanan ufite geste nyinshi bigaragarako into uvuga utabizi cg urimanganya
Mais birunvikana.ntabwo byoroshye
Kudefanda amafuti.
Ikindi demo mushaka ntabwo izijyera igerwaho mugihugu nkiki kimaze 25 yrs kivuye muri geno kandi hakiri nabantu bagifite gahunda yo kurimbura abandi.
Ndemeranya nawe 100 %
Umunyamakuru na Victoire mbahaye amanota 100/100!! Uriya mutumirwa ntazi abavuga rikijyana nka ba bamporiki bafite ububasha bwo kubambisha abandi ??
Ariko mwalimu Ismael arabeshya,,nawe aravuga ibyo atemera ku mitunganyirize ya démocratie mu Rwanda.
democracy ntago ariyo nzira yonyine ishoboka , murebe ibyabaye muri libya cg irak. democracy nikinyoma cyabazungu.
Wamugabo we sinkuzi ariko ugomba kuba uri umuhanga cyane
Bravo Gatanazi! Komerezaho kuzana ukuri mu banyarwanda.
Abantu nibareke kuba inkomamashyi nyumvira mwarimu uraha bakwirukane bagahe Karasira Aimable.
Gatanazi mwese abapfupfunure mu myobo abahe ijambo, mwivemo nk'inopfu tubamenye.
Ikibabaje nuko mudashobora gutinyuka kuvuga ukuri muzi neza kugirango imbehe zanyu zitubama.
Gusa birababaje.
Abitwa ko mwize murutwa ninjiji zitakandagiye mu ishuli 😈😢😨
DR. Koko wabyitiriwe BAVUZE NTAGANDA arasa hejura avuga ngo nibitekerezo bye ariko we ( agiye kuvuga akavuga ngo Njye nk’umunyarwanda ukibaza mbese n’umunyamahanga wicaye ahongaho NONEHO AKONGERA AKAVUGANGO ( MURI RUSANGE )
Iyo impyisi kagame ivuze ngo bazarasa abantu kumanywa yihangu ntamuntu uvuga ariko iyo umuntu avuze amakosa yabayobozi ajya muri gerza
Buchanan ni n'umuswa mu mategeko : none se cour de cassation ntishobora gusesa urubanza rwaciwe mu rwego rwo hasi ??
Ariko uyumugabo arikuganira canke arikwemeza Ingabire ivyo we ashaka
Iyo FPR itatumye abantu gukora amabi, kuki ntacyo ibakoraho? Wa mugabo, wikomeza gukandagiza abantu amateka twanyuzemo, twese yaradukomerekeje!
Gatanazi uri umunyamakuru w'umuhanga ukora kinyamwuga, gusa njyewe ntabwo ndi umunyapolitike, ntabwo nemeranwa na Victoire uburyo yitwaye akigaruka mu Rwanda, ariko Professor Doctor Ismael BUCHANAN
Dr icyuya cyamurenze.iyo uza kuragira inka, naho kujya kwiga byaraguhombeye.
Yayayaya baramubajije bati kuki abari mumashyaka atavuga rumwe na Leta birirwa batukwa bakanahohoterwa, bikagaragara ko ari system ifiye ikibazo, kuki tutumva bahanwa... nawe ati wumvise ko umugabo wakubise umugore yahanwe!!! Ubuse koko ibi ni politique cyangwa ni imibanire y umugabo n umugore?? Yewe yewe
Nonese nibarize uno mushingantahe, bamuzaniye imifuka yuzuye ibiryo ariko akaba atabifitiye uburenganzira bwo kubirya☝️mbese muri make twabyita ko aba yariye🙄🤔ndumiwe pe. Gatanazi I respect you 🤝
Gatanazi,uyu doctor yihariye ijambo kuburyo bukomeye uramureka ikiganiro cyose yihariye 80℅ wowe wiharira 10℅ Ingabire 10℅
Uyu mugore kwazi ubumenyira bukebuke yitonze ntakintu dogiteri yasobanuye numvise neza kabisa
urakoze cyane gatanazi
Uyu mugabo ari kubeshya ko ngo akora analyse nk’umunyRwanda ariko ni umunyRwanda ushyigikiye FPR bidasubirwaho. Ikindi kandi ibintu byose arabica has: ngo “kuba iyi debat ishobora kuba ni democracy”. He need to differentiate constitutional right and democracy. I hereby send him back to school
Katanazi na Victoire urumva uyu docteur yavugi Ki KO muziko na karasira wagerageje kunenga yirukanwe urumva uyu muteruzi wibibindi yakwemera KO bamwubikira imbehe murako .amaboko Habana burwanda niyo azibohora ingoyi ya F P R
Tubashimiye ibiganiro byiza rwose deba kiyi irerekana demukarase mugihugu cyacu.
Gatanazi Nkunda uburyo ukora inkuru zawe. Kugeza aka kanya nkubona nkuwa 1 muri professionalism mu banyamakuru. Theo aratinyuka, agatangaza inkuru nziza. Ariko kuzivuga ukamuhiga muburyo ubanza, utanga ijambo, uburyo uha umwanya uvuga, ugafata n abatumirwa batandukanye. Cyakora aha sinamurenganya kuko wenda bamwangira ikiganiro nawe.
Nanjye ndagushiimiye cyane
@@RwandaShineTV Thank you Mr gatanazi komerezaho I like the way ubaza ibibazo byawe nyabuneka wazatumiye bamwe mubadepite bacu murizi debat zawe wenda ukabambariza ibibazo ujya ubaza abatumirwa bawe
Murakoze kandi mukomerezaho ubunyamwuga bwanyu
@@muhiziboniface6013 bo bavuga ko bakora neza cyane.
@@muhiziboniface6013 wowe ubona bakwitabira n'urwo uyu ahuriye narwo hano😁😁😁
Gatanazi jya utuzanira abagabo bafite ubwenge n'ibitekerezo badakoreshwa n'inda uyu mugabo ndamugaye kuko inda yayishyize imbere kuruta ubwenge
Uwo Doctor Ismael aragira ngo badahagarika umugati we yabonye urugero rwa Aimable Karasira naho analysis nizawe sizabanyarwanda bose Ismaeli wee ivugire FPR ikubone iguhembe ko nawe wemeye kwimurira ubwenge mubwonko no mugifu . Ngaho gerageza uzabashe kwirira no guhahira ibiryo byabana ntakibazo Ismaeli turabibona ibidukorerwa nakazu FPR yadushyozeho yaba mukwiba no kwikubira ubutunzi nahari Ifaranga hose . Ngiyo FPR ituyoboye muri 26 ans . Ngaho Courage Ismaeli weee kataza ....Tanga urugero rwa James Musoni wasambanije Abagore agahembwa kuba Ambassadeur kubera ko Ari umushumba Wa Kagame Na Nyiramongi mukwiba imintungo nama FRW aza nkinkunga bakayayobya bitwaje Itegekoshinga , tuguhe izindi ngero ? Kaboneka minisitiri wubutegetsi gutukana yahanwe nande ko Famille Kagame babinyujije muri Denis Karera bambuye Abaturage bannyahe ariko barahanwe ra ? Mutsindashyaka Theoneste harya yarahanwe ko yibye Ama FRW yigihugu cg ibishyimbo abaye governor Wa Eastern province cg muzi ko tutareba abanyarwanda tuguhe nabandi Ismaeli ? Ibisambo bya Karibata muri minagri Na bof we muri RAB mukwibira FPR urugero : Project zo kuhira muri Eastern province?Na Agnes binagwaho minisante Na RSSB ukuntu Jeannette yakoresheje mukwiba FRW cg mulefu musaza we niba amakosa yose abo bantu bose barahanwe . Wacecetse Ismaeli harya nguri Doctor ? Subira kwiga analyse yawe iraciciritse tuza .... ubanze ureke tukwigishe wikwigira Ikimara aka wamugani Wa P fly ngo gahunda nukwigira (. Ibimara .)
Bon débat....
Nta Docteur mbonye kbx. Kugira impapuro ntitukabihuze nubwenge ngo mutuzanire ikigoryi nkiki. Wowe Ismael ndabizi uribusome iyi comment arko uri injiji nubwo wishyira hejuru.
Abo yigisha baragoweee!!!
Si injiji kuko arabikora abizi murwego rwo gucinya inkoro.
Uko billi kose bilan y'ikiganiro ni positif, kandi ndizera ko izafasha abayobora n'abayoborwa. Ismael yagerageje, gusa ntabwo yayoborwaga na analyse scientifique gusa, naho Ingabire akwiye guhabwa uburenganzira bwe aho bubangamirwa.
Nshimiye gatanazi ndetse naburi wese watanze comment ariko nanone abanyarwanda tugire gahunda yo kubahana , kuba umuntu ari Dr ntibikuraho ko nawe afite uko yumva ibintu or ngo yitwe umuswa kuko atemera ibintu uko ubyumva ,namwe murebe ibyo muvuga ubwo harya uwabashya kubayobora ngo muhurize kukintu kimwe ubwo yakora ate ?
Umuntu wumu analyste politique wo ku rwego rwa docteur arahirahira akemeza ko mu Rwanda haba démocratie koko mbona ubwonko aba yarabwimuriye mu gifu, akorera ku bwoba bwo kubura umugati agahora asingiza ubutegetsi. Numuntu utarageze mu ishuri arabibibona ko mu Rwanda dufite ubutegetsi bwigitugu bugendera ku iterabwoba bwamize inzego zose zigihugu niyo mpamvu budashobora kwemerera ingabire gukora politiki adakoreye mu kwaha kwabo bita forum y’amashyaka.
Nanjye sinemera ko mu Rwanda hari democracy nkuko nta n'ikindi gihugu na kimwe ku isi kirimo democracy yewe no mu ijuru tubwirwa nta democracy ibayo dukurikije ibyo tubwirwa. Ikizwi nuko buri gihugu ku isi kiri munzira ya democracy hakaba nibihugu byiyita ko biteye imbere muri democracy ugereranije naho bigeze.