25 Surprising Secrets in Elden Ring!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 พ.ค. 2024
- Thanks to HelloFresh for sponsoring today's video. Go to strms.net/VaatividyaHelloFres... and use code POGVIDYAOCT65 for 65% off plus free shipping on your first box! #ad
SHOUTOUTS
►SekiroDubi: / sekirodubi
►ZullietheWitch: / zulliethewitch
►Antonius Tertius: / antoniustertius
►Garden of Eyes: / gardenofeyes
►Listen to Heretun Rutun (Ainu Song) here: • Herutun Rutun
►Read the Elden Ring Survey results: www.frontlinejp.net/2022/05/1...
►Ranni's Second Voice source tweet: sekirodubi/status...
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Hymn of the Bats
01:15 The Song of Lament
03:05 No Maidens?
04:03 HELLOFRESH SPONSOR
05:12 Blaggard Big Boggart
06:02 Foreshadowing
06:38 Binocular's Reach
06:54 Spell Reach
07:45 Curl up and...be reborn?
10:00 Short Circuit II - Electric Boogaloo
10:47 Thy Meagre Flame
11:57 The Eyes Have It
12:49 The Player Survey
14:12 At The Deathroot
15:09 Godfrey's Guidance
15:43 Water Under the Bridge
16:37 Final Wish
17:58 THE ALBINAURIC WOMAN
19:09 Rune Tax
20:13 Gostoc the Grafted
21:23 Two-Faced
21:57 Daedicar's Woe
22:51 Radahn's Favourite Animal
23:48 Gurranq's Howl
24:20 The All-memorising
25:17 Soulslike
KINDLE THE CHANNEL [become a patron]
► / vaatividya
SPECIAL THANKS TO
►TheParryGod, for assistance with editing and footage - / xricsx
PLAYLISTS
►My Best Videos: bit.ly/2oMp66a
►Elden Ring Prepare to Cry: bit.ly/3ApeG2N
►Elden Ring Lore: bit.ly/3q3saNf
►Elden Ring Secrets: bit.ly/3RdCNbQ
►Elden Ring News: bit.ly/2ZkDV2d
►Sekiro Lore: bit.ly/2KGEzD1
►Sekiro Secrets: bit.ly/2IsObhW
►Dark Souls 3 Lore: bit.ly/2n0bU13
►Dark Souls 3 News: bit.ly/1NQbgbW
►Bloodborne Lore: bit.ly/1X9doOQ
►Demon's Souls Lore: bit.ly/16mIF86
►Dark Souls Remastered Lore: bit.ly/13x6nNs
►Dark Souls 2 Lore: bit.ly/1dedWjI
►Souls-like: bit.ly/1xCPDnu
SOCIAL
►Follow me on Twitter: / vaatividya
►Follow me on Tumblr: / vaatividya
►Follow me on Twitch.tv: / vaatividya
►Follow me on Facebook: / vaatividya
►Follow me on Patreon: / vaatividya
►Join me on Discord: / discord
THUMBNAIL ART
►Janice Chu
MUSIC (most is royalty-free or licensed from Epidemic Sound. Sign up or browse here: (www.epidemicsound.com/referra...)
PATRONS
►I'd like to give sincere thanks to all my patrons - your contributions have changed the course of my life, allowing me to put more emphasis on video production in the future.
►Special thanks to Soul of Cinder-tier Patrons: John, Mihaf, Matthew, Colin, budhawillyboy, Chattan, Aritz, Erlend, Michael, Finbarwrong, David, AmazinShawn, Aidan, Joshua, Ryan, Cat, Lucian, Nicholas, HugDucks, Kyle, Xavier, Justin, Andreas, Ian, Xensvet, Mike, Loak, Morningstar, Morgan, Vanguard, Ricakardsson, Seleiful, Dain, Diablo, Chase, Andronikos, Nezzly, Rune, Thomas, Jacob, One Unimpressed Boi, Matthew, Aj, GoldenSunX, Yousif, sean, Croonz, ndr.alng, Meistermuall, Armand, Albert, Liam, AJ, Aishlinn, Reiftyr, nicolas, and Ricky. - เกม
Thanks to HelloFresh for sponsoring today's video. Go to strms.net/VaatividyaHelloFreshOctoberYT and use code POGVIDYAOCT65 for 65% off plus free shipping on your first box!
Awesome video as always! but as far i can see no one has mentioned that Great Horned Tragoths helmet is inspired by Ancient Greek Phrygian type helmet 400-300 bc
GET THAT BAG VAATI
Hey man . The bats still do sing. I've heard them recently in patch 1.06. there's like a mother bat that looks different I've only heard it before approaching them.
Will always support my fav creators getting that corporate $, even with the code POGVIDYAOCT65
PREPARE TO FRY
I think the fire wasn't removed from Morgott's intro animation to hide the blade's P2 effect but because the writers realized that Morgott wouldn't want to use any kind of fire magic so close to the Erdtree as fire is considered sinful by the golden order.
he still uses blood flame attacks though
@@BigDBrian yea but only when he is close to death
Yeah, I don't think he can control the blood flame though. It's part of the Omen curse. It would have made more sense if they lefted it in.
@@BigDBrian he literally screems and curses at the tarnished for making him use the blood flame
wow that sound very plausible. Nice one for noticing it. That would be some real attention to detail from the devs if true.
Vaati, I don't know if you noticed but Gostoc is examining the left arm of the dead body (the same arm he is missing) so it is likely he wants to graft himself a new arm.
The left arm is also the one Godrick replaces with the dragon head. Also the arm that gets the shinobi prosthetic in Sekiro.
@@KynElwynn It's also the arm the Last Giant rips off in Dark Souls 2 to try and kill you. This truly goes to show that Elden Ring is just Dark Souls 2 2
@@alfalldoot6715 big if true
@@alfalldoot6715 I've always felt with this game you can see the DS2 impact. The colour palate to me is the biggest indicator
@@paid14 Yeah it actually has color, unlike Dark Souls 3 which is very, very gray. Which I know befits the theme of ashes, but a lot of the areas are very... Meh looking because of the filter.
I think it might sound really cool if Ranni's voice was doubled, but only as a whisper and only on certain words. So it makes you think you heard a second voice from her, but you could also just mistake it for your own imagination.
Gostoc missing an arm is most likely a result of him being a thief. People used to be punished when they were caught stealing by having a hand or arm chopped off. Very fitting for Gostoc's character.
It makes way more since for it to just be that his arm was grafted onto someone else like Godrick. Godrick has like a dozen extra arms on him.
@@gooblop but what if his arm was grafted onto Godrick because he was a thief 🤔 "hey, we have to punish you for stealing, buuuut I won't let the arm go to waste"
@@icewind154 There are 0 in-game things pointing to that. You can headcanon it if you want, but it's no more valid than thinking his arm was grafted because he touched himself or because godrick just liked that arm or because a lottery landed on him and that arm. The purpose of this channel is typically to look at the actual evidence in game to support claims, and there's nothing suggesting this specific claim so it's just one of thousands of equally random theories.
@@gooblop The purpose of this channel is having fun while learning the lore, chill my guy, also, there's not many thiefs in the game missing an arm and coincidentaly the only thief that has lost an arm is located on the place where the ruler likes to cut people's limbs and join them to his own body?
@@gooblop there's also 0 in game things pointing to him having lost his arm from theft.... There's actually multiple things pointing to it being that he was grafted... so by your own logic your first comment here should've been met by your own second comment lol.
He has a missing arm and hates the guy who takes peoples arms, literally having his longest location and animation being him stepping on the head of someone who steals arms. That is not the same degree of valid to "in real life people would get their hands cut off when they were a thief"
the guy who originally said it said "hand or arm" but it is not arms, it was almost always just hands. So... your extreme confidence in putting someone in their place here is entirely unwarranted.
Wow...Morgott's body fading into the guidance of grace and pointing from Godfrey to the player is such an impactful detail that I absolutely did not realize in the moment. I wish I had.
Absolutely my favorite detail to newly learn!
it put into perspective. I just assumed that the guidance was the will of the erdtree, but now with Morgot body grace pointing toward us, how much of it is the will of the god, and does all the site of grace is the grave of someone like Morgot is.
ALmost made me want to cry.
@@jokerledger5400 That's actually hella interesting to think about. I like it. Do we control our fate? or is the will of the gods that ultimately decide? Either way, we straight up, "nah" the Greater Will lol. You also bring up an interesting point about the sites of grace. USually there is some explanation for littered bonfires or lamps, etc. but not much info on why there's sites of grace littered about everywhere.
Reminds me of when varre mentions that grace guides tarnished, and adds, in his own words, "even if it leads you to your own death."
The love Radahn has for animals is kind of explained by the 'Beast Champion Armor' description. It read
"Beasts are drawn to champions, and to lords. And this armor befits a champion worthy of becoming a lord."
Radahn having lots of animal companions could be a nod to his worthiness.
Nice
Whether this is Canon or not, I like this theory.
It could also be a nod to his unusual Charisma.
Radahn's soldiers practically worshipped the ground he stood on, and even his rival demigods like Morgott had respect for him. It makes sense that even animals naturally liked him and wished to be around him, much like his redmane soldiers.
Disney princesses are stronger than Radahn confirmed
@@amazake1252 Now I have the mental image of Elsa fighting Radahn instead of Malenia and blooming a massive ice lotus on his back making the boss arena a tundra instead of a desert.
I really like Morgott's crumbling sword with no flames. It now looks like he's gripping it so hard that the stone falls away. This crushing grip is a much more visceral reminder of the amount of rage he had to bottle up for his entire life.
As well as signifying that he both isn't holding back against you anymore, AND that his physical strength js far greater than yours, being a Demigod Omen.
Honestly I liked the flame way more. It ties into the power hidden in Omen blood, and fits with the sword being MADE of blood
@@jstar3382 gonna use the golden order seal while casting fire magic from now on 🤣
Call him the grip reaper
Local Omen literally too angry to die
Something interesting i just noticed about Renna's (Ranni's) appearance at the start of the game. She appears to fill the church with a sleeping mist, given it's color and the fact that Kale has his head bowed during her interaction. Given that she's a powerful magic user, I could see her being able to selectively apply the effects of her sleep spell so you aren't affected. Cool little detail about how she can keep her appearances outside her tower secret
Oh that is a very cool detail. I always thought Kalé is just asleep because it is nighttime.
Considering she can trap you in an illusionary world to fight a psychic imagining of her mother's fully glory that can still very much kill you... yeah, selectively targeted sleep magic doesn't seem like a stretch.
I thought she did this cause everyone thinks she’s dead
you even get the dark moon in the sky behind her for a few moments.
Maybe a connection to St. Trina?
About two girls at the Stargazer ruins. By combining their names, you can actually find out, that they form a name for jellyfish species Aurelia Aurita (Moon Jellyfish). Pretty interesting detail, considering the form of girls' spirits
And considering they wish to see the stars together, Moon Jellyfish is quite the fitting name.
Stargazers ruins I think is near the place where Ranni met the Dark Moon as well. So despite them saying they wanted to see the 'stars' they probably actually wanted to see the Moon because they are Moon jellyfish.
@@M00nSlippersstargazer ruins is at the giants area in the north
24:20 the idea of Gideon watching me slaughter Malenia, just to think "yup, I can take them" is hilarious to me
Like he's just grocery shopping! "I think I'll grab a Rykard's Rancor, and maybe a Bloodboon... oh, and they're having a sale on Scarlet Aeonia! What a great deal!"
@@Yggdraseed he*
@@yazeed2811 ?
I slaughtered Gideon before he even finished his intro voice line 😂😂😂
@@yazeed2811 what??
I love the significance of the small detail of Godfrey's Guidance. He stopped seeing grace after he felled his last worthy adversary. The Greater Will Itself literally views the player as worthy at this point.
I was wondering, now that you mentioned the two jellyfish sisters and how they wish to see the stars, what if they were born after Radahn stopped the stars? Considering you almost certainly kill Radahn before getting to the reunion, you give them the opportunity to act upon their last wish as you have finally freed the stars from Radahns grasp.
You summon the jelly while fighting Astel, that's a star she won't forget hehe
A cool detail I haven’t seen anyone cover is Rykard’s eyes. In the cutscene where Rykard opens his eyes, you can see a red accent with the gold; implying that the Elder Serpent is vying for full control over Rykard, but doesn’t quite over come Rykard’s ambition and Grace. Then, when you defeat Rykard and his head is on the ground, the red is gone and only gold is left in his eyes. Really cool.
Weird catch lol
Another interesting thing about Rykard is that he is a super weird snake that speaks like Voldemort, showing that the player that beats him is actually Harry Potter. A cool Easter Egg for the recent and poorly optimised Hogwarts Legacy video game.
@@ori-yorudan spoiled gamer is a spoiled gamer
@@ori-yorudan Only Elden Ring could reference things which hadn’t happened yet. I can’t wait to see what other prophecies we can post hoc down the line!
Love how many secrets are in this game. Even ones that take influence from art history and folk lore are so awesome.
I knew most of them just by watching your videos ahah
Could you maybe look into Rennala's egg? I have a crazy theory you may like. The cause of Rennala's obsession with the egg to me, is because it actually is Radagon. It's hard to find a place to start but I'll try. First is Miriel Pastor of vows, he says that a builder "glimpsed the skeleton in Radagons closet" and hid a message in the statue in leyndell. Radagon is Marika, which everyone interpreted as a rebus of some kind. I feel that it actually is that Marika only disguises herself as Radagon as the statue literally dispels an illusion of to reveal Marika. It is also hidden by a powerful incantation only usable by those who deeply invest in the golden order, aka those who truly believe what Radagon believed. I don't know why she would rebirth him and stick him in Erdtree amber. Also all of his attacks in the Erdtree are holy damage and he never uses a golden order incantation once. I strongly believe it's a puppet of sorts that the Elden beast sized control of from Marika then used more directly as the Holy Relic Sword
Edit: I forgot to say Zullie the witch did a video showing its detail and red hair can be found inside it. Also I strongly believe that since the sweetings all look the same and feminine i think Rennala was trying to make a new body for her daughter Ranni who had destroyed her own on the night of black knives
nobody can discover secrets like you, lad. they laughed at you when you said Elden Ring was about mushrooms then look at them now, watching your videos about mushrooms.
Zio, I think your videos are actually better these days.
19:28 On my first time playing I had Gostoc under suspicion in my head, thinking he was trying to lure me into some trap when told me of the hole in the wall, so I acted on these suspicions and killed him, felt pretty guilty hearing his death dialogue. Slightly relieved hearing he was a lanky thief, yet still feeling guilty
He does trap you by closing a door behind you to the dark room where the annoying knight awaits you .
Nah after I kept dieing I killed him still don’t care he made me mad
@@lativity4632 kid named endgame upgrade material :
@@Smorblethere’s plenty more throughout the game. If you NEED more than all the equippable slots in your inventory fully upgraded then NG+ is right there
There's something so poetic about the lowlife deceitful Patches being the only enemy in the game capable of forgiveness. Back in Dark Souls 1, he tries to kill you multiple times, but once you forgive him he becomes one of the only characters in the game who just gives you honestly good advice such as about Lautrec and Petrus. It's these things that makes players love Patches I think. If he is capable of goodness then anyone is.
He's Also the Only Character to Appear in Every Soulsbourne Game Minus Sekiro (Including An Armored Core game). Either he's More Powerful than he lets on, Or Patches is just so Intertwined with Humanity's Various Self-Inflicted Disasters that im starting to think he's an omen of Doom.
@@theta8529I could be wrong but I believe the merchant who sells you intel in sekiro (you can meet him in the hirata memory and he sells you the butterfly kunai) is wearing a patchwork coat. I think he’s meant to be the patches stand in for sekiro. Pretty neat if true
@@theta8529this is the very first I’ve heard that fromsoft has a history of putting the exact same characters in basically all their games. Honestly confuses me a lot more on how exactly the lands between and the whole from soft universe manifests, bcuz how the hell is patches even getting everywhere.
So good news - my audio narration quality should dramatically improve in the next video! I somehow never realised how much of a difference a good audio interface can make, and this new one is putting in work. Excited for that. Prepare to Cry soon!
Thanks, excellent video as always. Very informative.
Can't wait for prepare to cry!!
❤❤❤❤❤
bro....BETTER?! can my ears handle such an angelic sound?
Now that's so great
The near extinct language was really incredible. I wonder if we'll see more in the dlc? I'd be excited for more history and hidden bits!
There's an interesting video on TH-cam channel Nativlang about Ainu. Interesting if irrelevant note, the Ainu are natives of the Kuril islands north of Japan which is a contested territory with Russia.
@@jessevarney3298 russia has way too much land already
If you like Manga I can highly recommend golden kamuy who goes heavy into ainu culture and it’s conflict, also no magic powers and such
@@timhertens8502 Hinna Hinna.
@@Felix-dh9tl most of it's frozen wastes soo..
That tidbit about the Ainu (the indigenous people of northern Japan) is an interesting one. The Japanese government typically isn't fond of bringing them up, as they'd prefer that the world recognize the country as always being just Japanese, rather than it being a place once shared by different (and now conquered) peoples. As a result, the Ainu usually only appear in what could be considered "subversive" pop culture (like the very anti-traditional Samurai Champloo).
This sort of reflects how the Golden Order seeks to rewrite history and cast out people or civilizations that existed before their rule. Whether it was the Crucible that became host to the Erdtree, or the Eternal Cities that may have existed before the arrival of the Numen, those vestiges of the past cannot coexist with the future sought by the Golden Order.
Both ainu and the tribes that gave origin to the modern japanese people came from china. Both are descendent from the same people.
@@manuelsilva6244 I'm not sure that's entirely true. People have existed in Japan at least 15,000 years ago (possibly as long as 38,000 years ago), while East Asian migrants didn't arrive until 900 BCE, and the influx of Chinese culture and people didn't occur until around 200 BCE. The Ainu people were thought to have originated during the Jomon period (14,000 to 300 BCE), which likely puts them before the periods of mainland migration and the China-centric Yayoi period. Overall, historians broadly believe that the Ainu were in northern Japan long before "contemporary" Japanese arrived.
I'd wager they changed that description on the long-fall talisman because comments about it jumping from the branches of the Erdtree reinforces the idea that it makes you immune to falls of any height, which was a big issue with the item at launch.
I would guess that they planned on him having a cat as the animal companion that humanizes him, but changed it to a horse, probably so he could ride around in the battle. Having two critters just draws attention away from the more important one so goodbye kitty
I would have loved that the jelly fish ash to be upgraded by summoning a second jelly fish or summoning a much stronger one if you get Aurelia to see her sister
Or summon Latenna with her Wolf when you managed to finish her quest. This would be a nice reward.
That defo would have been awesome to summon both jellyfish after reuniting them!
That would be cool but if I remember correctly the jellyfish exist because they have business in the living world that wasn’t resolved, which is why they remain. I think the description said something about hopes and dreams, which is why they’re around catacombs. So once you reunite them their business is over and they should both disappear
@@makenaiyomi1083 Yes, but no,
Latenna is on sniper duty, I put her at that unreachable place for a reason.
Rahdan definitely brought random animals home and asked
“Can we keep it!?”
"Mom! Radahn's weird rock momster ate my homework!"
_--Ranni, probably_
I half expect that the red wolf of radagon was a puppy radahn brought in one day and radagon just got attached
Dad didn't want a Red Wolf.
Dad with the Red Wolf:
@@TheMoogleKing93
Radagon: "No Radhan we cant keep it"
Also Radagon: "today im gonna teach you the magic sword trick"
The reason why Ainu is a dying language is because Japanese government slaughtered this population, fmab talk about this situation with the Ishval war referencing it (to everyone wondering no it was not a WW2 reference)
Didn’t think I’d see a fmab reference here but hey nice to know where that reference was from, I always thought it was referring to what happened to the indigenous people in Canada
@@exilemorin04 Sadly, it's a theme throughout human history, of a stronger tribe overpowering their neighbors, and either eradicating or integrating the survivors.
Puts a damper on Golden Kamuy's ending
Just like the American government did to the natives and their languages are slowly being lost as well
@@blazey-one sadly yeah
I highly recommend people research the Ainu, very cool history. I started learning about them after being introduced to their culture in Golden Kamuy.
Fun fact: the Ainu also influenced Prince Ashitakas tribe in Princess Mononoke, one of the best ghibli movies
Blackguard is actually pronounced "blaggard". Blaggard is also an alternative version of the word Blackguard.
"From black + guard, thought to have referred originally to the scullions and lower menials of a court, or of a nobleman's household, who wore black liveries or blacked shoes and boots, or were often stained with soot."
I think that quite a lot of the people who know the word's pronounciation learned it from _Hades's_ Theseus.
"Halt, blaggard!"
@@milk_choc7889 Ironically, it's even spelled 'Blackguard' in Hades too.
@@milk_choc7889 And in CK3. Was very surprised to see it in Hades.
to be honest, I have never come across it spelled with Gs. I had no idea people didnt know that Blackguard is spelled/spoken as it is.
and if you have subtitles on while watching PotC
I'm gonna be honest, I saved boc completely on accident He wanted the larval tear and I did the your beautiful pate as a joke and when the dialogue hit I actually got really sad I has forgotten that while the prattling pate sounds like a raspy whisper to us the player... to those in universe it's the voice of the most loved person in their life...
It’s also sad that our tarnished can only hear the raspy whisper. It can either imply our tarnished was never loved or potentially his most loved person was sick or dying
Actually the "You're beautiful" pate actually is different than the rest.
The rest of the prattling pate tools all have a masculine whisper, but the You're beautiful one is feminine
I gave him the larval tear, and decided that after what I had done I would leave a message to warn those who were uninformed like me, he deserves life
16:54 i actually somehow figured out the puzzle on my own. I was roaming and i thinking about what other jellyfish can be her sister than i remembered Latenna quest line and how it ends with you summoning her and it was like a light bulb lighted on top my heat.
Discovering these secrets in elden ring is definitely one of the most satisfying feelings you can have
For me, I figured it out because I remembered that the jellyfish was named Aurelia from the item description. That stuck with me because it was such an odd detail. It was female name so when there was another jellyfish looking for her sister, it seemed to make sense. I was surprised it actually worked though, I hadn't done the Latenna quest before that.
Radahn being the community's favourite boss is everything I hoped for
The power of Morgotts sword is obviously really similar to the power the Lady Maria of the Astral Clocktower uses in Bloodborne. Which is really cool because they are both guarding the source of their own curse/shame.
Excellent observation.
Damn Homer. That's wise.
Don't forget the Abyss watchers who also have a similar ability in their second phase.
Morgott isn’t defending the source of his curse lol. Wtf are you talking about
@@tonygardner5101 It's the golden order that considers the omen blood a curse. It's the source of his curse/shame because without the Erdtree he wouldn't be considered cursed.
I’ve always had a small theory that Torrent was some kind of animal related to the Ancestral Spirits because Torrent and the Spirits are the only things that have a double jump by using magic.
Malaketh kinda does with that jumping attack of his where he flies around the arena shooting arcs of that red fire at you.
Yeah the big elk bois definitely seem related to Torrent. Same colors, same double jump, same ability to disappear. And of course they share a basic body shape
Also they're both called spirits
For spirit ashes, besides mimic tear, I personally like bloodhound knight Floh. I just think it's neat to summon up a spirit that doesn't really follow you around, you just summon and sort of sick'em on whoever or whatever is nearby.
The Bloodhound Fang, Black Knife weapon, Black Knife Summon and that Scythe weapon you can get from Malenia soldiers - these were my absolute favorites.
I love Gideon’s spells. The whole game he used you as an errand boy, then he turns on you, using the spells you found for him against you.
work smarter, not harder
The mental image of Gideon pouring over his books before seeing a single ember fall on the page, going "OH SHIT" and *sprinting* to the Capital is my favorite
@@inktoxicant and not to mention him taking the Grand Lift up to Altus and him just tapping his foot in a mixture of impatience and anxiety while it goes up
And then gets bodied before finishing his monologue
spoilers!!! /s
Boc might be a minor character but his questline is beautiful.
One of my favorite NPCs next to Alexander and his nephew.
Also props to them for finding a unique use for the emote stones
Surely Vaati is jesting about Boc not being featured in an upcoming video! I demand a Prepare To Cry about Boc.
Beautiful like himself
His questline is beautiful, and so is he
11:24 this was mentioned in the patch notes, devs felt it hinted at an unintentional connection to the frenzied flame
Rannis ending is deservedly the most liked because it's the only side quest ending that has you exploring the most amount of areas and doing the most amount of things
I love how diligent Vaati is about crediting the community. Really makes this whole endeavor feel shared among a collective of scholars and nerds
You mean it keeps his paycheck from being instantly canceled by the same community that feeds him all this content just so he can sell some hello fresh lol
If he didn’t do that bare minimum he would be stealing credit and his videos would be frowned upon
@@CoercedJab Even if it's considered the bare minimum doesn't mean he's still not being respectful to the community. A small minority of the TH-cam community and a huge majority of the Twitch community take others content and never gives even the minor minimum of shouting out said channels responsible for making said content let alone showing respect to other creators. VaatiVidya is being really respectful. Doesn't matter if they have sponsorship or not. Many other TH-camrs have sponsorships too. They need to pay their bills somehow. So I honestly don't understand what your problem is with VaatiVidya. He's not hurting anyone or being disrespectful at all. So why are you upset by it?
@@CoercedJab Having said that, Antonius Tertius,credited by Vaati, really needs more attention.
Boc is such an incredibly kind character, his story makes me so sad and so happy and makes me cry. After you burn the Erdtree and create the Ashen Capital, you can still go back and find him
Another aspect of Gostoc's missing hand could be that in the past (at times) thieves would have their hands cut off. Considering he's a thief it makes sense.
Well now I finally know how the Ancestor Spirit died when I fought it. It started to do the warp thing at 1/6th hp, but just died offscreen instead. I thought it turned into a ram but apparently not.
Just realised I show the wrong Minor Erdtree at 14:27. Pain
No problem Vaati. This video is great and kept me entertained
I just realized the same thing while watching the video and was happy to see your post acknowledging it. No worries! Love your stuff!
A note about reproduction: when you're approaching the Three Fingers under Leyndell and talk to Melina, she urges you to remember that "births continue" in the wider world. So I don't know if it's true that Tarnished in general don't have any interest in reproduction, but rather the Lands Between specifically that is sterile (Tarnished or otherwise) and stagnant.
I don't think that it's the tarnished that have no interest in reproduction, but the people of the lands between who have lost hope. The majority of the tarnished are the descendants of the original tarnished who were the soldiers of Godfrey so they couldn't be sterile.
Yeah if we take it that nobody blessed with grace dies a natural death then it makes sense people may have stopped having children altogether in the Lands Between. And from that of course follows lack of renewal, stagnation, rot, etc. while the rest of the world was basically fine besides lacking the splendor of grace.
Plus Fia implies she was in a sexual relationship with Rogier for a while. She says he often talks "while abed." All we get is a hug, so there was something more intimate.
@@iboofer I am not sure about that. I think she just cared for him while he lays in bed sick. His lower half is paralyzed so I am not sure he would be able to
It may seem shocking to most people, but men who are paralyzed can intact get in the mood in many cases with the right circumstances. Which nerves are affected is more important than simply being unable to walk, and since Rogier’s disability is something he develops later it’s highly likely he still could.
I’m doing an architectural project right now on the Ainu! The first secret was a great resource to look into to discover even more about the Ainu’s culture and heritage. Thanks a ton for sharing it.
Their culture is fantastic to look into and if anyone wants to learn more about them there is a great memoir by one of their descendants that really uncovers what it is to be Ainu and talks about the hardships they had to go through when Japan started to take over their land and enslave their people.
It’s called “Our Land Was a Forest” by Kayano Shigeru.
Is this the same people that the protagonist from Princess Mononoke is (loosely) based off?
@@rand0m508 No, Princess Mononoke is based of the Emishi who used to live on the main Japanese island.
The Ainu lived on Hokkaido, the northern most island of Japan.
"You are beautiful" the fact that such a small detail exists in the game... it's mindblowing.
Oh my gosh, what of Radahn got the idea for gravity magic by watching his cat "defy gravity," as it bounced down from the Erdtree?
That just adds to his entire backstory being, "I became the strongest warrior in the world so that NO ONE CAN EVER HURT MY PETS!"
It’s mentioned in an item description he learned it from one of the Alabaster Lords that wield gravity weapons and magic.
Adorable animal lover Radahn
@@julianadams3710 I think he meant he decided to learn gravity magic after seeing a cat, then went to the alabaster lord to learn it
Doomguy:well said man
radahn actually only learned gravity magic so he could stay by his horses side, because he was naturally gifted with his swordsmanship, but learned magic to stay with his #1
Love seeing so much Zullie the Witch credit in here. Zullie's channel is always a source of interesting facts about Fromsoft stuff.
About the final wish, why the children couldn't see the stars. I think it may be because, at one time, the Erdtree was absolutly radiant to the point one couldn't see the night's sky. They must have heard of the stars in the stories of travelers.
Coming back to this, gotta wonder if Radahn's origin story was altered a bit after release. The long-tail cat description kind of implies that Radahn lived at Raya Lucaria & Leyndell for extended periods of time, and an idea of what time in his life he lived in those places
In the course of the Frenzied Flame ending Malina states that "births continue, there is beauty in that, is there not?"
Is the lack of wanting to get freaky just a tarnished thing?
@@MercurialStatic It probably is, especially considering that birth and intercourse is actually mentioned in an item description, namely the talisman you get after finishing Rya's questline (the ending where she actually is happy and wanders off to find herself)
It might be a curse(?) specific to the Lands Between, too.
Tarnished Archeologist has a fantastic video about this subject. Long story short, the Erdtree is alluded to have replaced the need for reproduction by rebirthing its adherents (or something to that effect). Procreation seems reserved for gods and royalty. The Artificial creation of life is extremely frowned upon (albinauric). Biological reproduction is seemingly more common in less faithful groups, i.e. demihumans and Mount Gelmir snakes.
I like how the lands between main areas, like limgrave and the Altus plateau, all seem to be different seasons, representing how your getting closer to the tune of death and the death of the age.
Hmm, nice observation!
The five seasons: spring, autumn, winter, foggy swamp, and nightmare.
@@Kreacher3 Florida
@@Kreacher3 and Brazil
I'm pretty sure that "blackguard" is an actual historic spelling of "blaggard". You see that word being used in this context in Oscar Wilde's works, for instance.
"Blaggard" is just a re-spelling of "blackguard" because of how people pronounced the latter.
You're correct, I'm not sure if it's just based on the way it was usually pronounced or if 'Blaggard' is just a portmanteau of Black Guard that saw more use as it was easier to say.
yeah, I was gonna comment that he was pronouncing the word wrong to begin with
I also would have loved to see a large cat that you can’t kill, maybe rarely spawning late at night near Lucaria, Caelid, and Altus Plateau, and mysteriously jumps around above you with the occasional “meow”. Would have loved that.
Gostoc's missing hand can also be due to the widely used punishment for those who steal: cutting a hand or both hands off.
The mysteries that you can still find in this game still blow my mind away.
I bet we’re gonna be learning stuff for a long time
@@jonsnowdoe4346 regardless everyone has to start somewhere. Most of the other creators discoveries aren’t portrayed for the average Souls player. Vaati pulls their raw data (with their consent obviously) breaks it down and builds it into the world as if it was a part of the vanilla lore so everyone can comprehend.
@@jonsnowdoe4346 why so bitter?
@joker ledger
Because it isn't his merit and he earns more money than the actual people who discover this stuff.
Sure, he edits very well, but i bet he has a squad behind these vids.
@@alessandrobaggi6129 He helps them getting subscribers though, I'm one of them. I enjoyed every of their content, it's a win-win for everyone.
I think I would have liked Ranni’s double voice. It’s a little jarring at first because we’re used to her normal voice, but if they had chosen to double her voice like that where the second voice isn’t too intrusive, isn’t too overpowering in the volume, and has just enough reverb/echo to be mystical and magical - that would have been a great addition I think.
I havent seen coverage of the following so imma leave it here;
Gravity consumables that can be used in combat seem to be super effective on the origin; the Fallen Star Beasts.
They always drop it, but used when the FSB charges, they actually have an specific animation where they fall and the player can land a couple hits.
Regarding the Ainu, I just started watching the show Golden Kamuy, which involves the Ainu pretty heavily. Learned a fair bit about how they were forcibly assimilated to the Japanese culture, like Native Americans to the English and the Aboriginal to... well, the English. It was only in 2008 that their treatment was actually acknowledged by Japan, apparently.
If you ask me, "forcibly assimilated" doesn't paint a dark enough picture of the genocidal practices and policies that affected those people.
Hinna hinna my osoma
Learnt about Ainu from samurai cahmploo, Ikue Asazaki which sings one of the song sounds exactly like the one in the video.
It wasn't even legally recognized as a language until 2019! 🤣
Remember aboriginal is another word for indigenous.
So aboriginal Americans, Native Americans & Indigenous Americans all mean the same thing.
Generally Aboriginal (capital A) means Australian native.
So if by aboriginal you are referring to a specific country best to put that country name in as well.
I know small thing that seems like nit picking. Wasn't intending it as a insult or policing what/how you say things.
I wish there were more spirit related quests like Latena's. Latena speaking with you as spirit and giving you direction in certain places is so cool. I feel like the this was initial plan since the special spirits have so much details in their description.
I just imagined a version of this game where all of the special ashes (or even the normal ones too) had their own "loyalty quests." Maybe you power them up that way instead of leveling with materials? Or you just unlock alternate versions. That would go a long way to making them more interesting by their own merit instead of just a gameplay mechanic for balancing (or whatever people say. I like summoning, myself).
@@ASpooneyBard max level mimic: becomes boss
@@ruanzinhojogoslol well originally there was supposed to be an NPC Silver Tear that lived inside you, so probably.
God, Boc's questline always makes me tear up. Such a good lad
Also I've never been able to see Gostoc no matter how much I backtrack in the level before Godrick. He just doesn't appear for me, which means I must be doing something wrong, I just don't know what
Once you´ve defeated Margit, go to the main entrance of the Castle and turn left. You´ll find him there, in that room at the right corner.
@@carloscalleja6272 Sorry but no I see him in that room, I mean I don't see him following me through the level haha
@@KodasGarden you won’t see him following you literally. He’lo be following you and stealing your runes when you die but he won’t be aside you
@@carloscalleja6272 He does follow you through the level and you can see him in certain spots throughout, did you watch the video? I'm just saying that I've never been able to find him in these locations
@@KodasGarden yes…. I saw the video…. I said that you won’t be seeing him following literally next to you, did you read my comment?… hahaha!
The second voice to Ranni would have been amazing. I always thought she would cross me thoughout the entire questline, and that second voice would have made her so much more intimidating .
I know Boc's arc isn't large enough in scope to warrant a full video, but man do I love his story and inclusion. The potential for happiness is rare in these games, and I'm glad you can explore that hope with him. Beautiful guy, that Boc.
Beautiful Indeed, fellow Tarnished.
Tbh he basically becomes your submissive servant.
If the player was so kind, they could’ve worked to up his confidence.
Boc and Rya seems to have somewhat decent fates (depending on your actions).
I wonder if the lack of virility is a result of Rennala's rune, the Great Rune of the Unborn, having been removed from the Elden Ring and given to her by Radagon. It allows for the rebirthing process so maybe it also governs regular procreation. If that's true, it may play into why it was given to Rennala when Radagon left her and potentially even why Radagon and Marika's children, the only demigods we know to have been born after Radagon's return, were cursed.
But why would the Golden Order want to prevent people from procreating? Is that somehow also linked to the demigods born after that point all opposing the Order to some extent?
Obviously the speculation only gets crazier the further we extrapolate, but it is interesting.
Also worth pointing out that the word 'blackguard' doesn't have anything to do with being a guard or soldier or serving under any banner. 'Blaggard' and 'blackguard' are essentially the same word in English, with effectively identical meanings.
I doubt that there was any greater purpose to removing the "Great Rune of Boning." I don't think the demigods wanted to prevent procreation, so much as they didn't care what the consequences were. These are the same people who removed the entire concept of death as we know it from their reality just to get one inconvenient person out of the way, and then locked it up to make sure that no one else can use it on them. Then they went to war with each other for more personal power, absolutely devastating the Lands Between and everyone in it, and no one even definitively won really.
It doesn't seem like they particularly care who gets hurt while they do whatever they feel like, and I'm pretty sure that that's the point.
Makes sense with natural death taken.
See Tarnished Archeologist's vids, the Erdtree is rebirthing its adherents. So I guess by removing the rune of death and the unborn, the inhabitants of the world are forced to turn to the Golden Order for life to cycle.
@@carrotslayer4806 I %100 agree... but it makes it harder for me to dissociate the Erdtree from our world government in this planet lol
How you go into your sponsor section’s of your videos is very creative. Love the videos man! I literally laughed at the one where you said why not listen to some audiobooks during the Radahn fight while you wait for the summons to kill him. Great job bud! 😂
21:43 Love the eerie vibes this voice gives me! Obviously not as soothing&/calm, but very fitting^^
One thing I found out that's surprising is that each starter set has an alternate chest appearance but one that doesn't even though it would fit is the Bandit torso: it has a shirt under the bandit vest that seems to resemble a loose-fitting shirt worn by sailors which can be implied that there were tarnished who traveled by sea hoping to get rich by acting as mercenaries.
When thieves are caught, a brutal tradition is to cut off their dominant hand to make sure they don't steal again. This might be what happened to Gostoc.
And he sells bandit class equipments, probably it is his own gear before his left hand was amputated
I remember when I first encountered the harpies song I just sat there listening for 15-20 minutes. Absolutely amazing voice acting and just hit different. Such a cool moment, I felt so sad disturbing the song by crossing through. I still sometimes go back to that area and listen for a minute or two.
Now I love Radhan even more. Ps: there's a bug with Regal Ancestor Spirit in which it dies when switching body (my guess is that there was an unproperly placed spirit animal model under the ground and RAS just yeeted himself from the skybox), happened to me and I was super confused.
You can also find Gostoc following you on the hill near the stormhawks directly after his first room. Gotten him to spawn there twice now. Just survive the locked room trap and then backtrack as far as you can.
you don't have to go the room, you just have to walk far away enough from that small hill, turnaround immediately and you'll find him there stalking you.
Hearing the Song of Lament for the first time brought me chills. I was drawn to her voice like a moth entranced in flame, only to discover a beast instead of a siren.
I wish there was a way to befriend those singing harpies so that it could sing for you or something. Maybe a spirit of the harpy that sometimes sing when your not in combat?
Hearing the Song of Lament really brings back the feeling of playing Elden Ring for the first time.
Climbing up that ravine, surrounded by harpies, to the Altus Plateau and defeating that Magma Wyvern with my Guts build, accompanied by the Song of Lament.
It's one of the best memories I have from the game, maybe ever. :)
I never knew about Bok’s story. Made me tear up.
I like Ranni with a double voice, but I think one of the voices should be quieter. Both to make it more understandable and pleasant, but also it make sense for her spirit half to sound more whispy and ghost like.
There's 2 songs that are sung in the language that the bats sing. They're called "OBOKURI" and "EEUMI". They were put into the anime "Samurai Champloo" so I thought the language sounded familiar
I began to sing the same songs as vaati spoke about them. Those songs have stuck with me since I first heard them
Obokuri-Eeumi is Okinawan (since Mugen was from Ryukyu). The Ainu song in Samurai Champloo is called "Pekambe Uk" by Umeko Ando (who is also the singer for the bats!)
I cried like a like baby when Aurelia and her sista had a grave nearby from the reunion site. I did not know. I thought they really went to look at stars because why not? This game has magic so why can't two jellyfish sisters go look at stars? It was so wholesome. Shooooot I'm tearing up rn.
Ikr. First time I found their graves I dropped my controller and just sat there, silent for a few minutes
Another fun fact about Aureliette is that she and Hyetta have the same voice actor.
I always find these "ngl i cried" comments super cringe. Like, real life is a lot harder than video games and i question how you've gotten by so far without crying every other hour from all the BS real life throws at you.
@@anonnoname.27 Being emotionally touched by fictional characters and stories has nothing to do with ones capabilities with enduring real life stuff.
I didn't manage to cry a single tear at my grandmothers funeral last year, even though she meant a lot to me, and yet i start crying when just listening to a bunch of video game soundtracks.
Different things provoke different reactions.
“Prepare to fry” to end off a Hello Fresh sponsorship, I love it :’)
Radahn being a huge animal lover and generally honorable man is how I see him.
Regarding Gideon, it's not just when you kill the bosses, it's when you've killed and reported everything about them to him, which he uses against you.
He was an asshat to me so i legit never talked to him again on my first playthrough after you first open his door. The "ohshit" moment on my second playthrough when i told him aboot every demigod i killed was actually awesome because i actually didn't know aboot the spell stuff.
I actually kind of assumed Gurranq is howling at Farum Azula, since he's actually Maliketh and he belongs there, since that is where we finally find him and battle him. It would certainly be some great foreshadowing, and we can pretty much tell that the Beastial Sanctum was once part of Farum Azula, considering its name, architecture and location (near Farum bridge as well). Perhaps he is mourning the fall of his civilization, that which was of the beasts and dragons before the Age of the Erdtree? It seems like the direction he howls fits too, if I recall, but I might be wrong on that one.
Big true, he is howling at Farum Azula, I'm surprised at some mistakes and errors in the video as all these "secrets" have been well known and out there for a long time now if you follow the game as a lore hunter or just a big fan of Elden Ring.
He is actually howling in the direction of the Erdtree. If you trigger the interaction and face the direction he faces, it's well off from where Farum Azula would be.
Maliketh is a Shadow, he was created by the Greater Will to serve Marika. He wasn't around before the Age of the Erdtree.
I’m a bit confused since Gurranq was howling into the night for me after I beat Maliketh. I always assumed that Gurranq was grieving the loss of one of his kind. And isn’t it so that you can still go to Gurranq after killing Maliketh? I’m pretty sure I did that.
@@apexkonchu2234 I don't think that assumption can be made without any doubts at all. He was MADE into a shadow, but as a beast, which he clearly is, he may have originated from the older civilization Marika supplanted, and became (or was forced into) being her shadow and "half-brother." He is a clergyman of Farum Azula too, after all, and may very well have a connection to that past before becoming Marika's shadow?
My goodness, the Ainu song that the bats used to sing. That is just tragic but also a beautiful way for Fromsoft to preserve that language in their work. I wish they kept it, but considering how Latin seems to be the language of choice for songs in this game, I understand why they kept it out in the final cut. Thank you for sharing this, Vaati. Your work is so flipping good.
That is the only Latin song in the game, the rest is gibberish as I revealed to the world in May. I also revealed the singer of the song of lament too ^^
@@AntoniusTertius Thanks for clarifying. What about the song that plays in the background for the Godskin Duo? I heard that it was Latin, but is that true?
@@PineCellar You're welcome. No. Gibberish. I already published the official lyrics of that song in June. I recommend you check Vaati's shoutout to Antonius Tertius channel for further info :)
The only Latin song in the game is the song of lament.
More games need to change your characters apereance as you play them, its so cool in elden ring when you notice the first time how something you did changed your characters eyes, or that you have burnmarks on your body.
There are SO many things and ways the other games could implement some same mechanisms and details from elden ring yet they seem to absolutely can't match with fromsoft so I guess we gotta admit elden ring just has to be considered apart from the rest of the production
An extra point on the eye alterations, certain helmets have eyeholes and you can see your eyes through them! I found it works best with the 3 fingers chaos eyes because of their glow. You do have to mess with your character's eye placement to get them centred right, but on certain helmets it looks amazing. Ruler's Mask, Guardian Mask, White Mask, Mask of Confidence, Consort's Mask to name a few.
Mostly masks now I think of it lmao
I'm currently rocking Frenzied Eyes from the Scaled Helmet. Can confirm it looks and feels dope.
Frenzied flame eyes with the skull mask looks badass af
The Norse Horse Rider Helmet looks good as well
@@kiki123456able Skull mask? Like Royal Remains helm? I thought that blacked out your eyes
@@buckyhurdle4776 my bad, it's skeletal mask, not skull mask
The Godfrey one (#14) was my favorite. It's just really cool that the guys we think of as just bosses have their own ambitions and objectives
7:28 funny people say this about the bows and crossbows; my first playthrough was using bows and crossbows, and i somehow managed to beat the game and get all remembrances.
it was amazing; the coward strats, the advantage i took of the game's logic, the glory that was the pully crossbow and the status-inflicting bolt types, the absolute QUEEN that was the mimic tear, it was so much fun! and it's so bizarre because i was barely leveled up for like half the game, since all my runes went towards arrows and bolts (and i had a ludicrous amount of golden runes i just never used since that was the best backup for more bolts and arrows if i was ever broke). bows scale bad and crossbows dont scale at all outside of raw upgrades; outside of weapon stat requirements, you dont got a need for leveling up until later on when you really need the extra health to survive a couple hits. i think it was somewhere around the 15 hour mark, or so, that i actually beat my first boss, since i spent the whole time exploring instead. yeah, bow and crossbow only leaves you VERY weak at first, but by the end, i was unstoppable!
if you haven't tried out bow and crossbow only runs, PLEASE try it out! pully crossbow, pully bow, and radhan's greatbow are the best. the pully crossbow is gonna be your main boss-killer, with the greatbow for when you can take advantage of hit stun and knockback (bye bye every enemy on a cliff!), and the pully bow for normal everyday shots. just make sure you got that arrow reach talisman on you at all times!
remember, the coward lives where the brave would die.
I would rather die with a sword than live with a bow
Edit: I've changed. I will die with a BIG OOGA BOOGA HAMMER IN MY HANDS
"Births still happen"
- Melina trying to talk us down from burning all the suffering away
"Blaggard" is actually an alternate way of pronouncing Blackguard, so they basically mean the same thing
Pretty sure it’s just the correct way to pronounce it
i was going to comment the same thing.
Can second this. Black Guard has to be separating if you want to read it as such. Blackguard is pretty much always pronounced the same as blaggard. This does seem to be changing however simply because it looks like a cool word so fantasy writers and fans assume its spelling makes sense. Alas, English be a cruel mistress.
@@ThePantyBandit Nope, a quick google search will tell you that the word always has been spelled Blackguard and pronounced Blaggard.
@@zerobudgetgamer that’s what he meant lol
Radahn gets more and more wholesome the more we learn about him
Greatest demigod in the game
@@mauz791 Bro. Dont let my waifu Ranni hear this..
@@Dickstick Bruh... She is litterally his sister
@@Dickstick yeah well your waifu is a heartless murderer
@@Dickstick who?
Wow, I thought I was crazy thinking I was losing a percentage of souls every time I died in Stormveil. Thanks Gostoc.
Could it be that Morgott was also approached by the formless mother, but turned her down unlike Mohg and that's why Morgott's sword has a blood-based ash of war?
Another note on Latenna is that if you summon her for the Mohg, Lord of Blood fight, rather than fighting Mohg she will kneel in front of Miquella’s cocoon until she is hit by Mohg
I like that little detail about Sir Gideon Ofnir using spells of optional bosses only if you've beaten them, I remember explicitly thinking "Bro I just killed Malenia after fighting her for the last 40hrs you're no threat to me doing that" while he spammed Scarlet Aeonia three times in front of me during my first run 🤣
That's funny because my brain has always read the name Black Guard as Blaggard and I never questioned it because it was fitting. Only took me until this video to realise I've been looking at the name wrong, but funny that it's actually correct in the Japanese translation 😂
Speaking of special eyes. My Sorcerer build was feeling left out, so now her right eye (which was blinded and has a big burn mark over it, kinda like Zuko from ATLA) is a deep blue with black sclera. It's very cool~ Did it around the time I beat Radahn which was kinda symbolic (it also took me ten tries.)
I love how General Radahn came through from “Ferocious Warrior” to pet lover
Leonard, now the Black Cat… in the future we will discover that he have a tortoise that became bigger than Miriel
honestly, I would've liked to hear Ranni's dual voice. That kind of vocal effect and others like it is something I find interesting
something to note about the jellyfish sisters: they both have Welsh accents - similar to Ranni, Blaidd, Iji and Pidia. Carians seem to all be Welsh, which means the jellyfish sisters also were Carians. They likely want to 'see the stars' meaning to study them in Raya Lucaria, or to journey to the mountaintops where the astrologers were once established.
Ranni’s double voice tickles something deep in my brain, I love ittt it’s so cool and seems to bely a bit more of her strength and depth mebe 🤔
That secret about Gideon is something I actually noticed on my first playthrough. My friends and I were playing through the game at the same time, and I was the first one to reach Gideon. I was the only person in my group to have defeated Malenia before fighting Gideon, so I saw him try to use Scarlet Aeonia (I say "try" as every time he tried to charge it up I just knocked him down with a spell lol) several times throughout my fight with him. Later I watched my friends fight him as they streamed their games, and noticed the lack of Scarlet Aeonia, and the inclusion of Comet Azur. At this point I was sure that his move set changed depending on the demigods you previously fought. Later in my second playthrough I saw the lack of both Rykard's Rancor and Scarlet Aeonia and believed my theory to be correct. It feels gratifying to know that there is concrete code to confirm it!
I'm just speculating but I think the sisters couldn't "see" the stars because of Radahn. Once you defeat Radahn they are able to see the stars.
Doesn't really make sense that you can help them see the stars without beating Radahn though
@@115UndeadAnarchy115 You are right. I forgot that Radahn is kind of an optional boss.
I think it's more a thing of they wanted to see them together, but were separated when one sister was turned into spirit ashes. So you reuniting them fulfills their desire to see the stars together.
Fun fact in the intro cutscene of the game you can see radagon breaking the elden ring, but if you look closely you can see radabon change into marika. The game tells you they are the same person a few minutes into the game.