Why Indonesia’s Debt Is One of the Lowest in the World
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- Indonesia, a rising economic powerhouse, holds one of the lowest debt-to-GDP ratios in the world. While global giants like the US and UK drown in debt, Indonesia has kept its borrowing in check. But is this financial discipline a strategic advantage or a hidden limitation? Could a higher debt fuel even greater growth, or would it invite disaster?
Discover in this video how Indonesia’s debt strategy has shaped its economy-and what it means for its future.
This is Macro Moments! We create well-researched, concise, and digestible insights into macroeconomics, empowering YOU to understand complex global economic topics with clarity and confidence.
🔵SUBSCRIBE to Macro Moments ➤ tinyurl.com/Ma...
🔵LIKE the video for support!
#Indonesiadebt#Indonesiaeconomy#Indonesia
Copyright disclaimer section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976. "fair use" is allowed for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarships, and research.
national debt is a very sensitive issue in indonesia. if the government announcing that they will adding more debt, it will become a hot topic anywhere in the country and people will get mad because of it. this because of what happened in 1998. indonesian economy colapse because of debt. many profitable state owned company are being forced to be sold because of debt and indonesia's firstborn aircraft that 100% designed and created by indonesian being forcibly stopped from development by IMF because of debt. talkibg about national debt is a taboo among indonesian policy maker. they will be mocked if adding debt and will be praised if lowering debt
Many American puppets in Indonesia. They are so sensitive about debts, China, Syiah etc.
No it’s because the opposition threw out the issue in 2018-2019. It became successful to attack the former current goverment. It’s still a sensitive issue until now I think.
@@Sghshaianagehhdvdvdhdbebejdjdn if you already born in 1998, you should have known that even since the crisis broke and people know about the reason which is debt, national debt already become a very sensitive issue. it is not a new issue, but already a 27 years issue
@Sghshaianagehhdvdvdhdbebejdjdn The USA disliked Jokowi
It used to be that the term debt is politicized by politician during election period, but now dumbfounded people use it all the time 😊
Indonesia has experienced times when it fell into an IMF debt trap that required various conditions (such as tax increases and subsidy cuts) that made the Indonesian people suffer.
Indonesia does not want to fall into an IMF trap again.
true, i believe that this video and similar one spread propaganda among our historical uneducated citizen so make imf debt trap look legit 😂
@@robustta5898
Because the IMF, as well as the World Bank and other international organizations are created by the US for their political interests.
Indonesia Never Learn,From 1997 Finacial Crisis For Example This Video Mention Malaysia Have 60%Debt Yeah True But It Internal Debt,Only 3 % Is External Debt
Indonesia 40%Debt Is External Debt /Foreign Debt It Clearly Show Indonesia Never Learn But Malaysia Learn From The 1997 Finacial Crisis Because If Another Finacial Crisis Happen Malaysia Can Default 60% To 0%,Since It Internal,While Indonesia Cannot Default Because It External Debt
Did You Think Singapore,And Other Country That Lend Money To Indonesia Will Default They Loan And Say Okay Indonesia No Needs To Pay It Free
@@sayfolman7752 NOpe, That's false!! 80% internal debt,, the external debt only 20%. according to Indonesia's ministry of finance. haha... I'm also bought indonesia govenment bonds since 2018.
@@kudajingkrak4919 Last time I checked (mid-2024), Indonesia's internal debt comprises 89% of the country's total debt
How rare is it to see a success story for once! Good Topic selection!! I can't believe how underrated Indonesia is when it comes to debt management!
@maarijthewriter thank you for your compliments! Absolutely. In Western society we usually never hear something about the Indonesian economy, while we can definitely learn from them.
Shame on USA with their debt the highest in the world and they cannot pay it back.
The world map is so wrong since Mercator 1569.
Indonesia is Huge and the only The Emerald of The Equator in the entire world.
Indonesia has experienced times when it fell into an IMF debt trap that required various conditions (such as tax increases and subsidy cuts) that made the Indonesian people suffer.
Indonesia does not want to fall into an IMF trap again.
Well, you know, Indonesia is the most underrated country in many ways..
But.. they just don't give a f about what the others think about them.. lol..
More like a honeybadger in the animal kingdoms.. they can survive anything, until God said the time is up.. well, they are a country which believe in God..
Once the leader just eats & sleeps, there will be no debts. Just let the poor's find their own way to survive even becoming illegal workers in other countries. Their leader only will respond by blaming other nations if anything bad happens to their illegal workers. Their leader will pay some money to create chaos at another embassy to cover up their failure. The low IQ people will follow the politicians rhythm for one penny pay. Shameful leadership with shameful people.
You explained it well. Additionally, many people in Indonesia believe that the country's debt stems entirely from external borrowing rather than domestic sources. This perception is often weaponized to create division between the government and the public.
Sri Mulyani is one of those rare politician/Minister who managed to be so popular despite being strict and multiple times being attacked by media who wanted to smear her life.
Her talent at managing the country finance is quite literally 10/10.
Sri Mulyani is a professional in the ministry setting, not a minister. We're glad she took the responsibility.
She is just smart in the book, but not smart to think out of the box. She is not rare like you say, just average of bookworm like others.
@@terusanzues6571 🤣 I regard you as a hater instead. Managing a country within the top 3 biggest populations in the world is no joke, not even past ministers can do their job well like her. I'm grateful we finally got trusted into BRICS, although things aren't perfect today. No countries are perfect, but we did well.
exaggeration indeed.. Hubris in economy n finance is worst combo
Shameless@@terusanzues6571
Indonesian are traumatized with debts, 1% raise even only planned will make the people to riot. Other than fiscal reasons, debts are also very frowned upon in any culture and religion, only normalized by the global institutions thriving on having people owing them something.
and still media in indonesia always talk about debt increase like there is no other thing to talk about
Yepp because of oposition interest.... , and they heavely pay for it😅
@@FilipaKresensia Anti-debt people aren't just from opposition.
people that dont understand will always said wow the debt is thousands trillion rupiah, LOL
Because some people are still ignorant. They don't know the difference between government debt and our own debt😝guoblok *baca pake tone Dr Tirta
its in our culture, not politics.
We have deep trauna, both people and the government about our 1998 crisis which our debt literally almost ended us
LOL That's how the USA created debt trap. Starting from 9% of Shares in Freeport and the killing of Soekarno.
As an indo I'll give a perspective, while debt may be low our economy is at it's low est point or at least I feel, an ultra intense version of the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, more people are on the streets than ever, and all of a sudden the goverment is trying to mask it up by saying "hey look guys low debt haha"
Agreed
which explains Indonesia slow growth, debt is bad if its uncontrolled but if managed can accelerate economical growth
And we cant control i
@@mustaqimalfarabi8082yap, indonesian government cannot control it
Because we have trauma in 1998
Low human resources
@@cleanbubble7969japan and korea had the same trauma from 1998 and yet look where they are now economically..
Our Finance Minister, Mrs Sri Mulyani is an EX World Bank Director.
and she said quoted Litteraly “Dont ever borrow money from IMF”
one of the major reason, was her. reluctancy of debt by western “institution”
we all know us and eu is behind 98 crisis in ASEAN and now Indonesia joint BRICS,a friendly economic country 😊.
European Union, Japan, Singapore, America they are involved
CIA is always involved in regime change around the world.
Indonesia by national law can’t have debt-to-GDP ratio more than 60%, and faces high resistance by its citizens for any tax increase. What a challenge for the government.
Kultur jg berpengaruh besar, disamping itu mungkin jg pengaruh ajaran agama. Kultur rakyat kita tidak terbiasa berhutang utk spekulasi, bisnis dan konsumsi. Orang Indonesia terbiasa memulai usaha dgn modal apa adanya meskipun hasil tidak terlalu besar, tp setidaknya tidak punya beban utang. Sy pribadi merasa nyaman dgn kebiasaan ini. Mengejar target pertumbuhan besar dgn berutang membawa resiko yg besar jg. Biarlah kita berjalan santai tp aman.
@ alon-alon asal kelakon. Mangan ora mangan sing penting kumpul. 😅
great content from underrated channel
May my neighbour continue to prosper.
we were being trauma of IMF and that's why debt is one of the hottest political economy issues here
wow, the lowest debt in the world isn't surprising. Fun fact average person living in Indonesia can only afford $20-$40 per day, with their montly sallaries around $220-300$/month, Some people even get paid as low as $100/month. Earning more than that could be considered living in luxury. Maybe this is one of the many reasons why Indonesia's debt remains low since everyhing is cheap ?.
07:50 Thanks for your insight !!!! This is my first time learning that most country in asia besides Indonesia, faced the same fate in 1997 😧
It's the other way around lmao majority earn $100 per month.
While *only* Jabodetabek people earn $200-300 per month 😂
Any Indonesian who can afford $20 up to $40 per day is clearly not your average Indonesian.
could afford $20-40/day with $220-300/month? did u just imply the barely survive a month? the math isn't mathing there
@@multatuli1 TF that's wild !!! cost like food, goods, rent is raising in the past couple years it's not that much but it is noticeable, $100 wages for a month its unsustainable.
they could pay rent and food but not with the goods,
they pay rent and good they can't afford food,
they buy food and goods how the fk are they even paying rent.
if that's is majority, no wonder many say the middle class in Indonesia will disappear in the next few years. the gov should focusing on fix this issue or we might repeated 1998 before we know it
@@gustafstefanus yes sir you're correct !!! , most of us live from monthly wages and borrowing from micro lending. even our moto for living is "Without debt, life has no challenge" .it's always become hot topic every month in our mainstream media, i know its pitty but it is what it is😂
This channel is very underrated, i genuinely thought this channel was really popular but then i see 300 subs. Keep up the good work!
If you are confused about why Indonesia national debt is so low, just look at most comments from Indonesian here, you will understand that it really a very sensitive issue for Indonesian government, it can even lead to an impeachment of president. 😂
Indonesian have PTSD with country/govt debt 😅
meanwhile singaporean japanesse dont
ga lucu 😠😠😠😠
Yes, they treat govt dept just as they own dept lol
happy to hear that. although many of Indosians always think that our debt is too high.
Indosians!
? 😅😂
Cuma anak abah dan kader pks yg berpikir dmikian dari 2014 makanya kalah mulu pas pmilu
lu mau ngutang nutang aja sendiri biar bangkrut kayak eropah 😂 actually i'm feel so blessed that our country indonesia doesn't easily got american debt trap even china and japan ditches their US tressury bond that will make usd unstable and will drag every nation that stand with lame ass usd
@@RIZFERDINDOSIAR 😂
@@Leonhart84alhamdullilah setelah Pak Prabowo jadi Presiden beliau gak mau nambah hutang buat nutup anggaran. Beliau lebih milih hemat anggaran.
Indonesian and their PTSD with debt, it almost broke us into pieces once in our young independent life as a nation...
I hate it when people talk about debt as if it's something normal. High or low, we should not normalize being in debt, wheter for Indonesia or for any other nation, wheter as a country or as an individual. We should not normalize it.
We should be able to provide for ourself by our own money. Debt should be the last resort in critical moment for fulfill our needs and it should be paid afterward, not continue to grow.
If we talk from religious side of it, although it is allowed, being in debt could nullify your chance of entering heaven despite doing good deeds for your entire life if you didn't pay it. So make sure you don't die before you pay all your debt, or if you died already, make sure there's someone who is willing to pay your debt.
I agree with it. In the same time i guess isn't should gonna be normal thing. However we now live in modern day. Our currency "money paper" need "debt" for fuel so the modern currency still running ever. Is not same with the old currency system.
You know that who was Made this modern currency system. They born from "Bani Israil". They is smart but evil in the same time. Idk what they thought or reason behind that's
But listen, if the old currency system is still running today. World we know today is not the sama as we know now. Beside the modern currency have some advantage effect. Tanpa mereka kita gak bisa bakal hidup tanpa uang.
KECUALI, jika ingin hidup tanpa uang. Tinggalkan society and create your own version society without money to life. Tapi Allah, menciptakan kita bukan hanya sebagai manusia saja. Melainkan makhluk sosial. Remember, Makhluk sosial.
Of course Im not an economic researchers or other like that. But i guess, debt is good if we know how it works and have other plan to against if fail to fight debt. I hope this helpfuly to inform you if debt is normal thing with education as well we can get it.
ah yes, let’s run a country like a toddler with a piggy bank.. no debt, no investment, no growth, just vibes.. and broke. because every successful nation totally built itself without borrowing, right? oh wait…
and heaven? what a joke. spend your life doing good, found the cure to cancer, solved world hunger, but die with Rp10K you owed your friend in high school? straight to hell. meanwhile, a mass murderer says magic words before dying? VIP access to paradise, with 72 virgin hoors waiting to serve their new heavenly master. what a flawless, totally-not-stupid system!
those western people didn't get this simple logic, that's the main reason why they are confused with our current situations.
National debt is a sensitive issue due to past 98 crisis memory, it's worsen when this issue was weaponized on 2020 election and the damage is still presist
Thanks man! I've reached out.
Shame on USA with their debt the highest in the world and they cannot pay it back.
The world map is so wrong since Mercator 1569.
Indonesia is Huge and the only The Emerald of The Equator in the entire world.
They can if they want.
they have debts in the form of dollars that they print themselves.
So in theory they cannot go bankrupt.
unless they choose to go bankrupt on purpose.
@@ary2407Yes US have certain privilage but any country can go bankrupt. If they can't catch up with interest rate (almost equal to Indonesia GDP Nominal already) then they go bust.
Debt is good when the world economy is bullish as it can boost the country's growth, but debt is bad when the world economy is bearish and you borrow money to cover your previous liabilities
The world map is so wrong since Mercator 1569.
Indonesia is Huge and the only The Emerald of The Equator in the entire world.
They said Indonesia is on Debt Trap when borrowing money from China for the High Speed Train ............... but is it?
thiss ... OCCRP itself make the list of corrupt people lately, Jokowi the previous president were in the list
we indonesian mostlikely believe in china dept rather than imf debt trap
Nope that project is 50-50 joint venture betwen kai and china
The debt will be covered by tickets,rents and others but will not covered by state
Just media propaganda 😂
Majority debt is from State Debt Bond 89%, foreign Debt is just 11% and we are IMF free ❤❤❤
I trust China more than the IMF.IMF forced us to sell our aircraft and car industries.
It's better to live simply than to have debt
a debt can ruin someone life
For the infrastructure development from 2014-2024 (such highway) the government made a lot of debt, but they make it fast in fast out, debt --> build highway --> sold right of management the highway to private company for fixed time contract --> paid the debt then they made new debt, that way, our debt ratio keep low
8:21 the currency of won and rupiah are switched. It should be rupiah that was initially pegged at 2.000
Amaizing channel, i will follow cause iam intrested in macro economy too
But the interest is extremely high, Indonesia pay debt interest more than 20% of it's government budget each year, bigger than education and health.
I checked. And the interest have only 1.25% difference with country like US and UK. I checked the expenditure percentage. It's 34% other, 20% education, 15% social security, 13% infrastructure, 8% subsidy, 6% health, 4% defense. That mean, debt expenditure is so low that it was not included. You are lying or misinformed.
Edit: Found another paper that separated the spending by type and by function. Education and health exists in function but not in type which where debt interest payments is located. In type, debt interest payments is 13.73% with the biggest being 28.97% for subsidy. While in fuction, education and health is 10.56% and 2.15% with the biggest being general service at 65.62%. this is the average from 2005 and 2013. So, so, from 2005 to 2013. It's definitely not bigger than 20%
Where did you get more than 20% anyway
I see a lot of bankers try to get us into debt，they try with the country, now they are trying directly at personal by micro lending.
60-80% of Indonesia debt is from local issues bond and local currency rupiah (IDR) called SBN and SBSN that's makes Indonesia have no problems with the debts
Indonesia learnt it in the most traumatic way possible on how a debt cant be mismanaged.
like, one race almost get cleansed thanks to it.
If you have good credit, a history of borrowing and repaying on time, you can take out a loan from any financial institution that offers good interest rates along with other benefits. Borrowing money is not always a bad thing ot actually a good thinh of you do it right!
As for Indonesia, they lost their creditworthiness due to borrowing and defaulting on a massive scale during the Asian economic crisis in the 1990s with IMF issue. That is why Indonesia's credit rating is only BBB, compared to Malaysia's A- and Singapore's AAA.....
If there is one lesson Indonesia should learn, it is to avoid over-reliance on loans, especially from overseas which they're doing very well.
Orang malaysia berdenial,dalam segala hal selalu mencari alasan atas kekurangannya dengan menjelek-jelekkan pihak lain yang notabene lebih baik.mereka selalu merasa lebih baik dari orang lain.pola pikir mereka,jika mereka jelek,tentunya orang lain lebih jelek.mereka tidak bisa menerima fakta, karena pola pikir mereka sudah di setting begitu sejak lahir 😂
ok now make a video about why corrupt people in indonesia got low sentences / jail time but locals get 5x times more jail time when stealing a piece of wood.
fr
Despite this, average Indonesians barely knew anything about debt management, seeing it as bad and should be avoided. No wonder our growth is so slow and we're so easily played by politicians using this issue like it's going to end us all, ridiculous 😂
Pemikiran keblinger yang dianggap intelek: 1. Supaya maju tambah hutang 2. Supaya negara bisa berjalan maka pajaki rakyat
Even with low dept compared to others country, Indonesian always blame their presidents for having dept.
Yes Indonesia have lower total debt. But compare USA, Indonesia have higher foreign debt. (USA 22%, Indonesia 29%). So Indonesia debt have more threat from currency exchange stability and could be have more risk.
Hehe.
Sri Mulyani is a fiscal QUEEN❤
Funny thing is Indonesian people in the internet practically talking about national debt NONSTOP as if our debt is the biggest in the world and everyone need to pay it by themselves.
gas s7 kita harus menambah hutang lebih banyak lagi. gas 10 ribu triliun
@ilTasver huh?
I hope someday Indonesia has no debt so future generation will not shoulder the burden.
Nah, we have 520 million dollar debt, and lots of money just get inside politician pockets 😢
Brought to you by Indonesian Goverment
For Indonesian, Indonesia have The most Debt in the World,
Wow such a good video, as an Indonesian myself I actually learned some new things here. However, I should point out that Prabowo's plans to relax the debt limit is a continuation of Jokowi's stance. If you checked your graph, you'll realize our debt to gdp ratio started growing again in 2015-2019, this is basically Jokowi's first period. Jokowi couldn't continue to borrow at the same accelerating rate in his second term due to covid. It's still too soon to call what Prabowo's policies will be since he just got elected.
Our debt is low because our currency is very weak. If you just check the real conditions of Indonesian economy, you will never make thia video
Simple question, if Indonesia debts are so low, why its currency value increase so slow compared towards to USA allies although all USA allies are having higher inflation than Indonesia. However, this will not apply when Indonesia debts are so high. When this situation happens, at sudden, Rp goes free fall, Re: 1998.
it's part of indonesian policy, since they are using USD as their saving, they deemed it as "unwise" to get it lower than Rp.15k so they try to stabilize it at that number. since they joins BRICS now, if they could change their national saving currency, then GG USD.
@IricAlexis Indonesia saving? LoL. Nope. There is no rule in Indonesia nor in the world that USD should be a must saving currency.
Until Indonesia has no natural resources, Rp will be no value at all, similar to all non-USA allies, especially the ones with natural resources. This is according to a book published in the 1960s by an officer from the US foreign affairs department. I can not recall the title of that book.
That's why being a democratic and capitalist country like Indonesia is a wrong decision. You see now, with very low currency, oil was gone sold at a very low rate. This makes Indoensia have no options to buy whatever oil price sold by the US and its allies. Indonesia also can not be rich as no one can surpass the US GDP. Especially when its all economic ministers graduate from US universities, thanks to Suharto.
@@MSDGroup-ez6zk There is no rule in Indonesia nor in the world that USD should be a must saving currency. that is fact, but since they decide to change gold with USD on 1998 crisis, it's hard just to flip another thousand billion saving or debt on USD to anything else in short amount of time. And why indo have to buy oil from US and their allies again??
oh and adding why they change to USD on 1998 crisis, that is because they have large debt that has to be pay in USD. like in the video they have 80% dept to GDP at that time. at that time maybe that is the most make sense for them. dunno.
Because that isnt how currency works. The US dollar is strong and relatively stable, despite having the highest debt in the world.
@@nationalistliberal1320 nah, please let me know how this happened.
1. USA aliles
a. UK - 1 USD = 1 Pound
b. Europe - 1 USD = 1 Euro
c. Jordan - 1 USD - 0.3 Jordan dollar
d. Singapore -1 USD = 1 Singapore dollar
e. etc
2. Non-USA allies
a. Iraq - In Saddam era, 1 USD = 0.3 Iraqi dinar. Now? After Saddam was hung, 1 USd = 1400 dinar
b. Syria. In 2020, 1 USD = 20 Lira. Now? 1 USD = 1400 Lira
c. Venezuela, 1 USD = 2722 Bolivar, Now? 1 USD = 31 million bolivar
d. Indoensia, Soekarno era 1 USD = 7.5 Rupiah. Soros came in 1998, 1 USD = 16,800 Rupiah.
e. etc
Can you how the US uses its USD as a weapon and is being manipulated?
idfc abt the debts.. but the corruption
masalah terbesar indonesia adalah korupsi... negara yang besar dan sumber daya alam yang berlimpah namun masih banyak kemiskinan. pejabat memperkaya diri sendiri, setiap anggaran negara 70% di ambil, sisanya untuk negara.
2:32 Why you put mumbai metro video on indoneshia topic
What do you mean low debt? Its already in debt trap.
What debt trap ?? 😂😂😂
wkw bocil
Don't let that mercator projection map fools you!
Indonesia is wider than US, wider than Chine, wider than Australia continent.
It's even wider than the whole Europe, from UK to Turkiye.
so what's your point?
But taxes is everywhere. Example for car or motorcycle we paid annualy
Debts and the countries that indonesia lending money from, are big issues for government from indonesian people. No politician will dare making promise to have big debts for building much needed infrastructures or any big plan for development. This carefulness while praisable make indonesian government only have limited options for wider developments.
it's a simple trick...they don't consolidate state owned enterprise debt to their balance sheet, non standard accounting practice
as an indonesian i almost laugh when reading the thumbnail
Because you dont understand how country debt work 😅
kaget dikasih fakta?
Yeah low debt but alot of corrupt government
the biggest reason is 1998 financial crisis made Indonesian people have really bad opinion of debt. We pursue stability over development.
Argentina and Turkiye take notes
True
Low debt but one of the highest in corruption lmao
I think your exchange rate chart beetwen USD/KRW and USD/IDR is switched off
Sebenarnya GDP Indonesia sangat tidak masuk akal,
Coba bandingkan dengan negara lain, bagaimana bisa GDP Indonesia sebesar itu?
Justru GDP kita kalo diliat total penduduk Indonesia masih relatif kecil karena masa Penduduk terbesar ke 4 cuman ranking terbesar 16 ekonomi dunia... Ingat bro banyak penduduk > banyak yang kerja > banyak hasil duit > banyak GDP
I'm Indonesian. Thiis is not true, even if it's only slight percentage of GDP but Indonesian Government wouldn't be able to repay the debt because it's cost us 30% of our annual budget. another 30% to paid the government staff. 20% for education and the other 20% goes to anything else. We're doomed soon
Indonesian debt is 2.5X of their annual budget.
If using an annual budget, then a lot of countries are much worse than that.
Take for example:
- Malaysia
Annual budget, 2024 = 88.69 billion USD (393.8 billion MYR).
Debt, Sept 2024 = 306 billion USD or 345% of the annual budget.
- Indonesia
Annual budget, 2024 = 170.21 billion USD (2781.3 trillion IDR).
Debt, Sept 2024 = 428 billion USD or 251 of the annual budget.
Source: CEIC (debt), XE (currency exchange).
There's a good reason why the debt ratio mainly uses GDP instead of anything else, you can look it up using the internet.
nahh bro you say that low debt because you count that in dollars, but in rupiah it was HUUUGGEEEEE
1 dollar = 16.000 rupiah
morre than that, in reality we only spend 5.000 - 18.000 rupiah in a day, which is too low, the economy said that our economy run in quite fast stable but it was not.
sorry for bad english, english is not my first language
hight debt in dollar is very risk to rupiah currency, when time to pay
I smell some High propaganda from this direction😊
Low debt hah.??? Indonesia goverment paid you bro.??
gw juga curiga gitu mas kayanya ini channel bayaran, masih baru juga ini channel nya pas dicek
Indonesia jumlah hutang nya 440 Billion USD ranking 25 di dunia dengan jumlah hutang terbanyak dengan GDP per capita yang rendah
Kita bandingkan dengan Malaysia ranking 34 di dunia dengan jumlah hutang 247 billion dengan GDP per capita Malaysia yang jauh lebih superior dibanding Indonesia.
Kalau liat penghasilan rata2 masyarakatnya dengan jumlah hutang yang ada saat ini masih tinggi banget.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt
www.globalfirepower.com/external-debt-by-country.php
Indonesia have 80% debt of gdp, they government just didn't tell that for political save. Like when they didnt tell if they pay VOC debt/sanction after KMB that finished around 2002 when Mrs. Megawati become president.
Source : trust me bro 😂😂😂
Typical Malaysia shit talker, Malaysia debt is much more worrying then Indo
For 4 months old TH-cam channel, discussing about indonesia debt, after there are many countries in this world, but you choose to make a content about debt of indonesia, i think you have an agenda.
Hey man! How do i contact you.
@aerocynix just sent you a message.
Low debt, low income
wdym? it's considered low compared to their income (GDP), did you even watch the video?
@@ardath7128he is jealous only
You are so stupid😂😂😂 better you watch until the end, poor you💩💩🤡🤡
This is dangerous video ,
Dollar to IDR is higer higer and higer . If Indonesia adding more debts imagine this country will broken
well u should also include the state owned enterprise debt, and u will get the real debt
i mean their soe debt is really high, some estimate higher than private sector, that is not healthy.
@@almerammar8601
Don't spread hoax
Learn about liability and debt
Learn also about source of debt.
Its internal debt which the money still in the country, not going to imf or world bank account. Read about SUN (surat utang negara) or sukuk.
Why would Indo include stated owned enterprises 😂😂😂... its not in the parameter anyway
Wait, what?!
although indonesian's debt has doubled since previous terms
No don't say that, my government Will getting some debt if they know about this😂😂
Are you bullshiting me right now we got the low debt and yet we struggle so much wtf man
Salahkan mafia
Iam Indonesian, and iam not struggle...
Mybe its you prblem, not country problem
@@joMan1060 ok quick question, how much for 3kg gas in Indonesian?
its like poor person has $70 debt.
and the rich has $7000 debt.
u can't say Indonesian debt is low man 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dibayar berapa bikin video kek begini?
Emang gak jelas nih video , Utang Indonesia itu gak bisa dibilang sedikit.
@@iskandardimassaputra9479 belajar dulu dek
@@jokogentho123 sprei gratisnya dulu mana
"Anti Riba Club"
Funny that Indo considered to have the lowest debt ratio, but the low educated people of Indo always complaints about how high our debt is (due to so called “influencer”) 🤣
fomo co😂,soalnya di tiktod byk konten kreator yg sok sipaling politik yg nyalahin pemerintah karna Indonesia gde hutang nya pdhl klo dibandingin sama negara lain kita masih keitung low in debt
Masih tinggi sebenernya mas. Video ini sebenernya yang sesat. Cek aja jumlah hutang dan per capita nya.
Indonesia jumlah hutang nya 440 Billion USD ranking 25 di dunia dengan jumlah hutang terbanyak dengan GDP per capita yang rendah
Kita bandingkan dengan Malaysia ranking 34 di dunia dengan jumlah hutang 247 billion dengan GDP per capita Malaysia yang jauh lebih superior dibanding Indonesia.
Kalau liat penghasilan rata2 masyarakatnya dengan jumlah hutang yang ada saat ini masih tinggi banget.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt
www.globalfirepower.com/external-debt-by-country.php
@@penjahatbandung ??? Situ pakai Wikipedia kan? Coba cek lagi deh.
- Malaysia $306 billion total debt ($8.721 per capita), GDP per capita $13.142
Hutang 66.4% dari GDP per kapita.
- Indonesia $428 billion total debt ($1.521 per capita), GDP per capita $4.981
Hutang 30.5% dari GDP per kapita.
this video was paid by indonesian govt
Do you count BUMN debt?
BUMN bukan pemerintah
gak bisa dihitung
😂🤫🤫
bangkrut kan saja garuda. Gak guna. 😂.
Bumn punya hutang tapi aset lebih besar gimana sih aset bumn itu 15000 ttiliun
@@otakufilsufbumn itu ya defacto bagian dr pemerintah, cuma cara kerjanya aja beda. kementerian dan lembaga biasa gk nyari keuntungan, sdk bumn nyari keuntungan. itu aja bedanya.
Why Indonesian corruption is one of the highest in the world 😂😂
Indonesia GDP 2024 itu sekitar 1388 Billion Dollar... Short term debt nya dari total hutang 425 Billion USD itu cuma 10-12%..Ibaratnya Gajian masih lebih gede dari Cicilan.. Lalu pengeluaran yang besar sebagian besar untuk investasi di Infrastruktur.. Jadi kenapa harus takut? Jangan terjebak Kaum penebar ketakutan
any debt is too much debt
Live within your means
Indonesian old provebs; jangan besar pasak daripada tiang, meaning; dont build with nail bigger than the pillars to be nailed.
What's so controversial aboutbbeing prudent?
THANKFULLY, IMF COME TO THE RESCUE!! Iykyk 🤣😂😂
8:57 Very arrogant IMF 😮
This image is extremely humiliating for Indonesian...
Honestly that's the fault of Soeharto himself. Soeharto misused the debt (utang negara) for his family's wealth and spent it for populist programs (like subsidies).. instead of using the debt for building Indonesia's manufacturing capability & developing his country. All the development during Soeharto's era was centered on DKI Jakarta only
Psyop, this country is so close to disintegrating and collapsing, i don’t understand why westerners keep thinking that Indonesia is an economic powerhouse, this country will be gone before 2030, screenshot this comment
Imagine ironically thinking like this 😂, no wonder you 16% are so stupid. The country is fine, move on with your life
mohon maaf adek hancurnya karna apa yah,,
apa yang alasan anda mengatakan itu...
@@nationalistliberal1320 Disintegrating is a bit far off. But fine? Fine??? Do you think the current situation is "fine"?
@ yes, to believe otherwise is doomer nonsense
@@nationalistliberal1320
saat ini Indonesia telah fokus pada energi, pemenuhan energi dalam negeri, membangun beberapa kilang minyak di setiap wilayah dan smelter emas tembaga di sebagian pulau, dan kami juga memiliki proyek, kelapa sawit menjadi biodiesel, sebagai pengganti solar, sedang membangun kawasan pertanian 1 juta hektar, dan puluhan unit perumahan murah, sekitaranya 2030 akan 100% selesai..
lihat beberapa proyek di vidio yang saya posting.
walaupun itu sebagian investasi dari barat tapi itu berdampak jika selesai.
Jokowi added so much debt
Ironically, Indonesians are always talking about the rise of the amount of their country's debt yet nullifying the GDP, the amount they generate from the debt. So as long as what we are harvesting are much that what are borrowing, it's okay. I mean, not a big deals. Also, the government have considered the debt management. Menyala Bangsaku 🔥
Lebih rendah utang Vietnam di asia tenggara, yang tinggi justru utang Singapura
Missnaration...this is not totally correct since state enterprise debt & civil servant pension is not included, otherwise the ratio approximately 100%...this is why current administration under probowo is aggresively cutting expense budget