ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2024
- This video outlines five key changes to the Children's Online Privacy Protection Rule that your business needs to know about. The revised rule expands who's covered by COPPA, puts additional protections in place, and streamlines other procedures companies must follow.
Content creators, are you looking for information on the definition of “directed to children” under the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule? Read the Business Blog for staff guidance from FTC’s Kristin Cohen about what COPPA covers: www.ftc.gov/ne...
******************************
Partial Transcript:
When it comes to information that companies collect online from kids under 13, parents should be in control. That's the thinking behind the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act and the COPPA rule. The rule has been in place for years. But the Federal Trade Commission, the nation's consumer protection agency, has revised COPPA to keep pace with technology. If your company has been complying with COPPA, the basics still apply. You still have to give notice to parents and get their verifiable consent before you collect, use, or disclose personal information from children under 13. You still have to keep kids information secure. And the revised COPPA rule retains Safe Harbor provisions so that groups can submit programs for FTC approval. But five key changes to COPPA take effect July 1, 2013. Here's what your business needs to know.
I'm Peder Magee, an attorney with the FTC.
So what's new about COPPA?
The first important change is that the FTC has revised some definitions to expand who's covered by COPPA and the kinds of information that require companies to comply with the rule.
The rule has always applied if you operate a website, an online service, or an app directed to children under 13.
It also applies if you have a site, a service, or an app directed to a general audience and you have actual knowledge that you're collecting personal information online from kids in that under 13 age group.
Revisions to the rule make it clear that COPPA also covers an operator of a child-directed site or service where it allows outside services like plug-ins or
advertising networks to collect personal information from visitors.
In addition, if a plug-in or ad network has actual knowledge that it's collecting personal information through a child-directed site or service, the plug-in or ad network is covered by COPPA too. The upshot?
The rule applies to companies that may be new to COPPA compliance.
The FTC also has revised the definition of the types of information COPPA covers.
The rule has always applied if companies collect certain kinds of personal information from kids under 13, like their first and last name, a home address, a phone number, an
email address, online contact information, or a screen or user name that functions as online contact information.
But the FTC has clarified that definition.
The COPPA rule covers geolocation information that can identify a street name and the city or town.
And we've expanded the rule to include photos, videos, and audio files that contain a kid's image or voice as well.
Something else covered under the revised COPPA rule, persistent identifiers that can be used to recognize a user over time and across different sites or online services.
But there's a notable exception here.
COPPA's parental notice and consent requirements don't apply if the identifier is used just to support your site's internal operations.
Take a look at the rule for more about the meaning of internal operations in this context.
Another change to COPPA relates to what operators need to tell parents.
It's still the law that you have to notify parents directly and get their verifiable consent before collecting personal information online from their kids.
But now you need to know to put certain key pieces of information upfront within the notice you send.
You'll want to read the rule for the specifics.
But the big picture is that it's not enough just to give parents a link to something on your site and expect them to figure things out for themselves.
This change will make it easier for parents to get the important details they need when they need them.
The rule also streamlines what you have to include in your online privacy policy about your information practices The third change involves new ways to get the parental consent COPPA requires.
In addition to the methods already in the rule, including FTC approved Safe Harbor Programs, COPPA now gives businesses more ways to get a parent's OK.
For example, electronic scans of signed consent forms, video conferencing, the use of government issued IDs, and alternative payment systems, assuming they meet the same stringent criteria as credit cards.
Content creators, are you looking for information on the definition of “directed to children” under the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule? Read the Business Blog for staff guidance about what COPPA covers: www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2019/11/youtube-channel-owners-your-content-directed-children
FTCvideos Why did you pick 13 out of all ages for COPPA. I genuinely believe the age should be lowered to 11 because that’s when adolescence kicks in and kids start to get more mature. At the age of 11 and 12 information from children do get collected because there in middle schools and use email on chromebooks . I firmly believe COPPA should target 10 and under rather than, 12 and under because yes there are huge maturity differences between 12 and 10. A 12 year old usually knows if it’s an ad and should be smart enough not to reveal a lot of info about themselves on the internet. I sure was when I was 12 and so we’re all my friends.
I am thinking about shuting down my other channel
"do you guys not have phones"
kids love adult things swearing vaping , smoking drinking , violent content. kids want to grow up and be adults. everything that is adult falls under coppa even net neutrality videos
your greedy you want money hah do you know what its like to be homeless you strict little insult to us the creators of youtube your not gonna stop me im 13 years old so might as well stop it get some help and go back to school because your disobeying our rights.
These idiots are going to ruin the internet for everybody. Kids can get around anything in that you put up.
Obviously
Thanks very much for the FTC for protecting our kids from this monster website exploiting our children to make billions of dollars
@@POneSnake most of those youtubers you talking about made millions of dollars enough for their whole life
@@POneSnake it's time those greedy bastards stop using our kids for money
@@POneSnake I'm not talking about small channels maybe like yours mate. I'm talking about giant kiddie channels like vlad and nakita, toy unboxing, play like nastya, bla bla bla all are making millions of dollars monthly and yearly by showing a ton of streamed ads to our kids make them freaked consumers
TH-cam Kids: *Exist*
FTC: TH-cam Kids no exist
TH-cam Kids: *Am I joke to you?*
@@AlvinFS27 to be fair, it doesn't exist on PC, and that is stupid.
what the FTC needs to understand is this:
Parents need to protect their kids;
freedom of speech is a right, not a privilege
go after offenders for sure, but stop regulating every fucking thing; radio, tv, internet are all things you choose and can choose to not intake.
parental controls are available, could be made more convenient for parents
Censorship is never the answer ... looking at you TH-cam and demonitizing videos because the creators say 'corona virus' even once in a video. Fuck off you totalitarian assholes controlled by dumbass advertisers. Make a list of all advertisers who are having you enforce this policy, so the consumers can decide whether they want to patron them or not (I know they won't read this, just letting the steam out from that bullshit).
ARE YOU DUMB?!?!!!!!!!?!
YOU ARE RUIN EVERYTHING ON TH-cam
Nobody likes COPPA
I mean, I don’t like it, but it’s a law that makes sense.
It doesn’t make sense to me. I can’t change my age when I clearly set it wrong. How would I be 1 and be able to make a social media account?
GD Happybon It’s also making TH-camr loses money. COPPA is so dumb.
Well, that’s the thing, they weren’t be old enough to really do much yet, so having a Social Media page would be a waste of time, since it would have to have the parent to own it. If you set it wrong, sign out and wait until you’re old enough to use social media sites like Facebook. You will be complying with COPPA.
“Wait until you are old enough” Dude I am old enough. I SET MY BIRTHDAY WRONG BY ACCIDENTE. And COPPA doesn’t allow me to set it right. And why would I wait freaking 12 years.
We already have yt kids and restricted mode
We don’t need coppa
I need it for my kids
Thanks for the FTC for stopping the monster Google from making billions of dollars exploiting our kids
Don’t worry this person is just a bot, at least I hope so...
Why is TH-cam at fault if google is the one collecting data?
@@zahizahiharerr122 it is not youtube's fault, and if u want to give your kids safe videos then get youtube kids
We all know theres TH-cam Gaming and TH-cam Kids
Why did the government do this.
@JackyBoi because kids aren’t watching what big studios produce anymore so they’re using the government to get rid of their main competition
because they didnt go to social studies and learn about the decarlation of independice.
billion dollar interests for the war of the internet and more financial control.
BECAUSE WE CRAWE MONEY. MONEY IS NEEDED. WE NEED M O R E
@@chrishansen9568 I know your not the real FTC but still. If the dang government spent less on useless things and more and STUFF THAT ACTUALLY MATTERED I'm sure you would have a bit more money
This is such a waste! We have so much already! You are ruining internet for everyone!
D Star Agreed
As a regular TH-cam viewer, I believe the current implementation of COPPA rules will severely hurt content creators and content on the platform. I regularly watch content creators who have raised concerns over the current COPPA rules and I believe their ability to monetize and create content on TH-cam while also supporting themselves financially is at stake here. TH-cam is nothing without its creators and without them being able to support themselves and their businesses on the platform, TH-cam will indeed become a "desert of crap". I urge you and the fellow FTC members to reconsider the current COPPA laws and change them to suit the needs of the modern world today.
Yeet Yeet its a publisher now. Not a platform...
Thanks very much for the FTC for protecting our kids from this monster website exploiting our children to make billions of dollars
@@zahizahiharerr122 Since your spamming, I will too until you get it through your head.
TH-cam is for 13+, it says so in terms and on the google play store. TH-cam Kids is, shockingly, FOR KIDS. Get your children off TH-cam, it's YOUR job as a parent to WATCH your child, blaming TH-cam is like giving your child the TV remote, leaving, and then complaining for the shut down of TBS because when you came back your child was watching a sex scene on an adult comedy show.
@@zahizahiharerr122 Insist on your overprotective opinion? Well, you must look after your kids, WE'RE NOT BABYSITTERS! It's your fault if your kids end up watching Happy Tree Friends, porn, etc.
@@zahizahiharerr122 I heard from La Zona Cero (a Mexican animation channel) that Internet isn't a good babysitter. I bet you're watching some stupid TV show and let your kids navigate in a website, that, according to the website's policy, isn't for their age. Don't blame content creators for making content. They're YOUR kids, not our kids.
You are making TH-cam even more strict, when this site is for users over 13 years of age or older. There is a TH-cam Kids you know. :/
Why do people always say that??? As many have said before, YT Kids is for everyone below 8 and even that would be a bit high. What is every other kid going to do? Imo TH-cam should make YT Kids a bit more mature
@Trump Pence lol
AND restricted mode.
COPPA if you launch, you can make many TH-camrs lose their jobs and money. FTC, don't you realize what you're doing?
BlueBella Cookies they dont care, because of the new thing youtube put out its all about money, fining videos they hate for 42,000$ its all about money
@@akaiama I understand but nothing isn't always about money. TH-cam and the FTC are being stupid with this COPPA rule.
ExtremelyBlue It’s not they hate them, it’s just they think the person putting it not being for children could be lying for a lot of monetization. But yeah, fining someone for 40,000 dollars just for pressing the wrong button is stupid.
The do realize but dont care cuz they want the moneyz
And lose years worth of work!
Raid COPPA Headquarters
They can’t fine all of us.
StyzFruit yeah!
Oh hell yeah I will get my firsuit on
At last pillar men them existed along with C4s..
DESTROY THE FTC!!!! 😈
LETS GO RAID THE HQ BOYS AND GIRLS!
This is age discrimination
I don’t get how this is age discrimination, sine they are trying to protect the privacy of Children, not exclude them from Internet access.
It is mainly because of the time and cost of compliance with COPPA which makes most sites exclude them, because they care about Children’s privacy.
GD Happybon It’s age discrimination
Proof???
GD Happybon My proof is I feel deprived because COPPA doesn’t let me make my age right when I set it wrong
Feelings are not evidence.
I asked ACTUAL CHILDREN if they thought coppa was a good thing. They all said no.
*Bruh*
They're smarter than they look
Only selfish and irresponsible parents think this is a good thing.
I'm 12 and hate it
@@sb14andmore50 Exactly, all the boomers in the FTC headquarters think that every kid is a little innocent 5 year old
I miss 2011 where TH-cam was peaceful and coppa barely touched it 🥺😭
I miss 2009 TH-cam
Me too :(
if COPPA keeps doing this, they're going to break the whole internet
also has COPPA heard of NordVPN?
I Don't think so But good point!!
I don't think VPNs are going to work for TH-cam crap
EU TH-cam has this law cuz Is a 1 server
I hope the internet will declare war against The FTC
Well, Mr. Big-mouth, they have NOW!!!
This law will destroy everyone and will make family’s poor and live on the streets! Is this what you want? Money? Fame? No we will not stand for this.this sucks for me! I’m in middle school so I have to stick to baby shark videos now?? Like what is this??
Agreed, never thought I'd ever agree with a Gacha Life fan lol
I hate u COPPA
Everyone else does too
The likes will show it
👇👇
COPPA is unfair for under 13. It makes like under 13 shouldn't play, they should be banned. I don't think that under 13 should have this protection. It's not safe, it's unfair.
Word
Parents should signup on every device instead of penalizing content creators.
TH-cam kids: *exist*
FTC and COPPA: I’m just gonna act like that never existed
Me: There’s YT kids and Restricted mode, isn’t that already enough?
What happened to the First Amendment
TH-cam forgot it and disobeyed it😬
It's been dead for years.
I WILL USE MY FIRST AMENDMENT TO USE A MACHINE GUN AND KILL ANYONE WHO FORCES ME TO PAY THE 42,000 FINE AND ANYONE WHO ENFORCES COPPA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
WE DONT NEED FTC!!!!!!!!!!
They forgor 💀
These fools are going distroy TH-cam why they don't fine something else to do
And you’re the reason they’re destroying it. I can see you are a tween (underage)
Peanut Boi you do know that he can be in this site because you said he was a teen
Also it doesn’t matter if you’re underaged
@@Xyearo TH-cam said ITSELF "the best video platform for kids *8+"* not 13+ so they basically screwed themselves and everyone else. I won't be able to watch TH-cam on the TV and show them the creators I like, because they will have to make their videos 13+. This whole thing sucks man
It’s not 8+..... you should really read the rules and literally what’s happening
@@Xyearo no they advertised themselves as 8+ soooo uno reverse card
Dear FDC,
Please stop. After I come home from school creators but a smile on my face. Force youtube if you want to ruin peoples lives for something that has no relation to youtube. I REPEAT. THIS HAS NO RELATIONSHIP WITH TH-cam. so just stop. Stop. You want the community to get angry and lose motivation.
FTC*
Yeah
Dear COPPA,as much as TH-cam is already a mess you're adding fuel to the fire.
You made TH-cam have a new slew of rules which could harm MANY creators who does kid content for a living.
COPPA you need to think about the people out there not just children and not all animation is for kids.
Yours sincerely,A fellow creator
Ah, this has nothing to DO with protecting kids!!!
The evil Empire ( the counsel of Sith Lords - there’s probably 7 of them!!! ) has discovered something that has made them PINK with joy!!! All they gotta do to pass any evil law imaginable ( online OR off!!! ) is label it “CHILD PROTECTION!!!” They could pass a bullsh it federal nationwide CURFEW where everybody must now be indoors by 9:00, all because somebody supposedly imagined that a little girl got a mere “wink” from some homeless dude!!! Now, EVERYBODY must obey and be indoors by 9:00, not just the KIDS!!! The wise counsel of Sith Lords will make sure that the “CHILD PROTECTION” label is well in place!!!
Stalin’s Soviet Union, Hitler’s Germany, and Xi Ginping’s Communist China can all merge into a system of hellish electronic enslavement unlike anything the world has ever seen, and all they have to do to “make it happen” is put the “CHILD PROTECTION” label on it!!!
• WELCOME TO THE EMPIRE, LUKE !!! •
Did you know that there is TH-cam kids?No?NOW YOU KNOW!YOU'RE GOING TO DESTROY TH-cam YOU SELFISH PEOPLE
Calm down, The FTC are willing to speak about it with someone.
THIS MAKE EVERYTHING SO MUCH HARDER AND IDIOTIC!!!!
No It’s bad please stop it you are hurting youtube and you tubers just stop
TH-cam viewers and creators petition the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to clarify and reconsider the new Children’s Online Privacy Protection (COPPA Rule) regulations on TH-cam creators. Shutting off personalized ads on creators’ content will cause more harm than good, especially for children. Quality family-friendly content will shrink, while more mature content will grow - yet kids will still be watching.
The FTC should not expand COPPA regulations for content creators. Broadening the definition of “child-directed” to include “child-attractive” would force many more creators to turn off personalized ads. As a result, even more quality content will dry up, and more mature and extreme content will fill the platform.
The free TH-cam Kids app is a better solution than regulation targeting family-friendly creators. TH-cam Kids removes privacy concerns around personalized ads. Parents buy devices and allow their children to watch TH-cam Main. Many parents prefer to use TH-cam Main because it has more features and less barriers. Creators should not be punished when parents choose not to use TH-cam Kids. COPPA is about putting parents in control of protecting their children’s personal information online. The FTC should not use COPPA to remove parents from the process in regulating content and online advertising.
While large corporations will survive these changes, small business creators face terminating employees, changing their business model, or shutting down production altogether. These regulations will particularly hurt young underserved audiences who participate in TH-cam communities on topics like special needs, faith, and minority groups. Limiting quality free content for kids expands the digital divide. Turning off personalized ads on kids’ content also encourages increased product placement and brand deals within kids’ content.
Creators face COPPA fines up to $42,530 per video, yet the regulation and definition of “child-directed” is vague. The FTC needs to provide creators with enforcement clarity.
We ask the FTC to:
1. Provide an enforcement statement for creators
2. Clarify the definition of “child-directed,” and not expand it to cover “child-attractive” content
3. Delay enforcement against creators until the FTC concludes its review of COPPA
4. Allow parents to use TH-cam Kids or TH-cam Main, without forcing creators to turn off personalized ads when parents choose to use TH-cam Main
You don’t REALLY think that they are going to LISTEN to anything we say, do you?!?!
If you really believe that these COPPA laws are about protecting kids, I have a BRIDGE to sell you!!!
@@redredmane5544protegerlos? Yo creo que TH-cam es para mayores y para adolecentes, la ley COPPA, es algo mal implementado. Para eso esta TH-cam Kids, que es un espacio para los niños. Lo que YT debería hacer es controlar el contenido de YTKids, no con el yt normal.
Estas leyes arruinan y censuran varios contenidos, que no estan hechos para los niños
Y la responsabilidad de lo que consumen los niños, son sus padres. Ellos deberian estar pendientes de lo que ven y no responsabilizar a otros de su mal habito de darle internet sin restriccion a su hijo
My 12 year old self enjoying good ol 2010 TH-cam laughs and cries at this.
These revised rules, while they have good intention, will do more harm than good.
The categorization of "children's content' is extremely vague. By enforcing COPPA is such a way on TH-cam, many content creators will be encouraged to either cease making content, or to convert their content to something more mature. For those who do comply with COPPA when creating kids' content, this can disrupt entire livelihoods, as well as forcing them to alter their entire business structure. If certain creators are fined, as the FTC claims they will, it can destroy entire lives. The huge issue is that it doesn't matter if you perceive your content to not be directed towards kids, because ultimately the final decision on whether or not you are compliant lies in the hands of someone who may not watch the entire video, goes only off of the title and thumbnail, and may not understand pop-culture and the vast interests of young adults. Many content creators who do not intentionally direct their content towards kids, yet still attract such an audience, will be impacted.
Ultimately, this fear of not being COPPA compliant will encourage the creation of less kids' content because there is no monetary advantage in doing so. With less and less children's content available, kids will be exposed to more and more mature content. Ultimately, kids will always find a way on to the platform.
Another issue is that vast amounts of children watch creators such as Jake Paul, and he isn't someone who is necessarily child appropriate in my opinion. Due to the legal definition of kid's content being so vague, if a channel such as his can be considered as directed towards kids, then where will the line be drawn?
While it is true that there are a small handful of channels who do exploit kids using targeted ads, that is an extremely small minority. COPPA unnecessarily puts other channels at risk. In the TH-cam terms of service you must be 13 or older to begin with, which is why they have been considered COPPA compliant until now. The issue the FTC fails to understand is that in most cases children are using accounts that are either their parents, or have been set up by their parents, which is a form of implicit agreement to TH-cam collecting data on said accounts and issuing targeted ads. This is honestly an issue that has arisen because of the FTC's lack of expose to modern internet culture, and lazy / ignorant parents. If parents want their children to not be subjected to targeted ads on the platform, TH-cam provides alternatives such as TH-cam RED subscriptions and TH-cam Kids. If a child lies about there age to create an account, which would then be subjected to information collection, the blame lies not with the content creators , but with the child for breaking TH-cam's terms of service and the parents for not policing their children.
The exploitation of kids does not lie in the blame of Google or TH-cam. The FTC is not at fault in this situation either, they are simply doing their jobs, and this situation is due to misinformation. The FTC wants to solve the problem and up until the 11th of December were accepting feedback on the proposed regulations.
In the end, COPPA will only be destructive to TH-cam, and several other platforms, in more ways than one. To reiterate, it will only result in the production of less child-suitable content, which would then ultimately expose children to greater amounts of mature content because many utilize parent approved accounts that can view 13+ content to begin with. Furthermore, the monetary impact will be severely damaging to many creators who may or may not have believed themselves to be creating kids content.
What are your opinions on the matter? I would love to have an *intelligent* conversation.
Exactly
The sex offender laws are EQUALLY vague!!! They apply ALL of these “CHILD PROTECTION” laws with poorly defined tenets and a very broad, sloppy, wide and indiscriminate “brush!!!” The thing is,… the rulers, the powers and the mighty elites ( under the directives of the evil council of Sith Lords ) are not STUPID enough for this to be a mere MISTAKE!!! NO!!!
The “powers that be” know PRECISELY what they are doing!!!
It’s called TAKING FREE SPEECH and SOCIAL MEDIA AWAY FROM THE PEOPLE!!! They discovered that in order to get away with unlimited human rights violations and annihilate the Constitution in the process, all they have to do is slap the “CHILD SAFETY” or “CHILD PROTECTION” label on it!!!
Look at the SEX OFFENDER LAWS!!! The way those are being “misapplied”, it can NOT be due to mere “oversights”!!!
• WELCOME TO THE EMPIRE, LUKE !!! •
Frick COPPA.
That word is a little to kid friendly, might wanna spice it up a bit
Slur ikr
@@sirskiiit4804 I am trying to get COPPA to lay off by reporting anything with inappropriate content or heavy swearing
4 Words:
You are ruining TH-cam.
This is censoring and punishing the thousands to millions of adults that love and enjoy games, shows and other topics that are family friendly, and therefore, maybe confused for kid content.
Censorship does mean lying, and being disrespectful
2019:area 51 raid
2020:FTC raid
Raid FTC: They can't censor us all!
Just add a restricted mode to the childrens gadget or just download youtube kids??
There is a restricted mode, they're just lazy and/or put the kids on their account so don't want to restrict themselves OR use it signed out.
@@sorastrife3297 like my mom just put restricted mode and also even there is nothing wrong with the vids i just cant watch it so i told her and she turned it of...
@@endahkiran And that's considered concent from the parent and it's okay. In fact the FTC said that if a child lies about their age (example an 11 year old saying they're 13 by making an account) then there's no fault on the website. The problem here is TH-cam allows people to use it signed out. Signed out they don't get you agreeing to terms which state your 13+ so watching signed out they assume your 12 or younger and THAT'S the issue.
TH-cam could fix this all by making people make an account to watch, but won't because it cuts into their profit.
youtube should just add an age feature to their platform to recommend the content right for that age base and dsicard any inappropriate content from that age base. TH-cam should basically combine youtube kids age feature into normal youtube to make things better. No more of that coppa crap
TH-cam. You know you are putting hundreds of thousands of under 13 TH-camrs at risk? They might not know what their content is about, choose not for kids and do kids content then the adult is fined so much!! DOWN WITH COPPA
Since when do children only age to 13? I am not legally responsible after age 13. Cool.
13 is the age when someone becomes a teenager.
age discrimination
Yeah, and if you play a game you like, and put an early birthday. ( LIKE ME BECAUSE I DIDN’T DISCOVER COPPA ) Then it’s some sh-t.
i want yum what kids are not suppose to be on TH-cam it’s 13+
Lisa Martinez that's the new age of consent
This wasn’t even needed.
Thanks for the FTC for stopping the monster Google from making billions of dollars exploiting our kids
Exploiting? What do you mean? Google seeing what a person likes and advertising it to them isn’t bad for any age, especially when that funds the free content that we see on TH-cam.
@@zahizahiharerr122 TH-cam is for 13+, it says so in terms and on the google play store. TH-cam Kids is, shockingly, FOR KIDS. Get your children off TH-cam, it's YOUR job as a parent to WATCH your child, blaming TH-cam is like giving your child the TV remote, leaving, and then complaining for the shut down of TBS because when you came back your child was watching a sex scene on an adult comedy show.
yeah
Agree
Your going too far, you do know you're gonna kill youtube?
Think of some other way, this is messed up, your not doing anything
YOUR JUST RUINING TH-cam FOR PEOPLE, YOU AREN'T PROTECTING ANYTHING
YOUR RUINING PEOPLES CAREER.
The way this is implemented goes against the first amendment by being so broad, you guys need to either be constitutionally compliant or be replaced.
It definitely should be unconstitutional, but not just for that reason. If everyone is required to correctly label whether their videos are for kids or not under threat of government fines, regardless of whether they monetize or run targeted ads or not, that is a form of prior restraint or imposing a requirement in order to exercise free speech. That's also arguably involuntary servitude which is against the 13th amendment, especially if also required for videos that have already been uploaded and published, which is also ex post facto unconstitutional meaning it's retroactively criminalizing something that was done in the past. There's also the fact that the content creators aren't the ones doing the data collecting; that's TH-cam. Unless creators specifically consent to benefit from that data such as by agreeing to run targeted ads on their videos, then they have no involvement.
If you're younger than 13 years old, you really shouldn't even be here!!
too bad...Jk im older then 13
Pretty sure COPPA is just unfair. Everyone made an account during the age 10-12 maybe even 7-9. COPPA is a stupid act that doesn’t understand grouping toddlers and pubescent kids is stupid. Also the fact it’s not the website if parents can’t control their kids.
@@BruhTumbleweeds BRuh i had a yt channel and im 12 and almost 13 Gotta LOSE ALL MY PROGRESSED *Triggered*
RandomMajin there's more decency on the whole of TH-cam than in one Disney movie
I’m 13 and I watch family guy
And another just installed TH-cam kids we don't need coppa don't be dumm
Do you know why passwords exist? Do you know PARENTS PUT THE PASSWORD IN, NOT THE CHILDREN, THE PARENTS.
This is absolutely absurd. So many youtubers are quitting because of this law. Even OUT OF COUNTRY youtubers like me. TH-cam kids is a thing, but now apparently it’s not. So this thing is actually just destroying people’s lives.
Its sad
We're Content Creators, Not babysitters
I see that you have videos of children in your video but haven't marked this video as "kid friendly" due to the fact that there are still comments here. I hope you'll fine yourselves $42000 on January 1st.
Them: no TH-cam children safe bla bla bla
Me:children you say this Is why we grow up stupid
Congratulations, FTC! You've ruined TH-cam! First Susan Wojcicki, and now you!
One of the first things they say is, parents should be in control
Then why do we need this law? You’re right parents should absolutely be in control! They should be supervising what their kids watch if they really care
Take a look. Take a look at the comments. Look at the videos about your act. Look what you did. You ruined it. You are not helping. You are disallowing people from doing this jobs, their hobbies and what they love. Thank you. Thank you so much for ruining this great website.
We are content creators, not babysitters.
What about TH-cam kids
Message: The Freedom Of Speech, The Freedom Of Creative Freedom, And The Freedom To Do What You Choose Is A Actual Thing. Its An Ammendent. And That's What TH-cam's Premise Was. So, The Fact That Someone Actually Decided To Waste Millions Of $$$ To Sue The Creators, Force Them To Work With The FTC And COPPA To Mess With The Platform, Kill It, And Destroy Our Freedom Is More Than Staggering, Its Life-Changing For Some People Who Make The Revenue Off The Platform. You Guys Could Of Worked Over This But You Handed The Job To The FTC, The Guys With The Nitrogen Bomb (COPPA) And Wait For The Creators To Fall Into The Trap. My Response To This Absolutely Stupid Act Is To Either Spend More Time With Your Children And Generally Create Moments With Them, Or At Least They Should Tell The Kids To Watch Something Different Like TH-cam Kids...
I Hope you Guys Realized You Just Killed The Most Popular Streaming Platform On The Net. I Hope You Enjoy This Unfunny Prank.
Yep! And it was no “accident!!!” They will soon use the false banner of “CHILD PROTECTION” and “CHILD SAFETY” to justify Soviet Union style CURFEWS, the MICRO-CHIPPING OF ALL HUMAN BEINGS, the A.I. RUN “NO ENTRY” GROCERY STORES, INFINITELY BIGGER SEX OFFENDER REGISTRIES, and the INDEFINITE IMPRISONMENT AND EXTERMINATION OF COUNTLESS HUMAN BEINGS!!!
Need I go on?!? The horrible reality is,…
• WELCOME TO THE EMPIRE, LUKE !!! •
A “prank?!?!” Is that the full scope of your understanding??? If only it WERE just a silly “prank!!!”
@@redredmane5544 my understanding isn’t that short sighted. I was saying it’s an unfunny prank due to it being something I foolishly thought would dry over 3 years ago. Now my judgement has matured and people have found a way to accept these terms or find ways around them. And it’s something that TH-cam has fully integrated. It’s as simple as that.
Why is there Videos Labeled "Made for Kids"
If TH-cam is 13+?
Websites out here thinking we're Stupid
BrUH
We dont need COPPA, this is so stupid
go away plz
i don't need my dad's permission to watch Hazbin Hotel
so why do i need this
One thing to say
WHY?!
What about ppl abouve 13 like 14 or 15 huh?
How did this go right over our heads? This was 2013?!?
Everyone thought it was too stupid to pass and was worried about the "family friendly" rules/purge at the time.
Wow imma just cry all night why it had to happen???
FTC, this is the 1 billionth time you mislabeled a video for kids. Fix your COPPA now.
This should definitely be shared more with the COVID going on
Might as well just shut down TH-cam now, as this is where this situation is eventually headed.
ftc: animation=kids content
sausage party: *exists*
TH-cam Kids: *Exists*
FTC: Im gonna pretend i didnt see that.
This was 6 years ago ?!?!?!
Elite samurai the gavel is only now coming down
The law was actually signed in 1998, and put in effect in 2000. It was updated in 2013.
Now its getting revised in 2020 instead of 2023 because child protection protesters are pushin
This is going to ruin TH-cam
Yes I'm happy this going to happen for this disgusting website
Hariri Swelem Um, not everything on TH-cam isn’t for kids. There is still child appropriate content on this site.
@@zahizahiharerr122 TH-cam is for 13+, it says so in terms and on the google play store. TH-cam Kids is, shockingly, FOR KIDS. Get your children off TH-cam, it's YOUR job as a parent to WATCH your child, blaming TH-cam is like giving your child the TV remote, leaving, and then complaining for the shut down of TBS because when you came back your child was watching a sex scene on an adult comedy show.
@@KanselDumbass They're spamming, I think they work for the FTC tbh and they're trying to make it seem like people are agreeing with them XD
Amanda LaPee I have no idea. Maybe they just blindly believe the law.
Welp there goes my favorite animators
@blue cats lol I do I did lots of bad thinggs
The likes were from Parents, the dislikes were from COPPA haters, we may have a chance
109 parents liked this..UNCULTRED SWINES
FTC: You still have to keep kids information secure.
9-year-olds: Why should our information be secure?!
Um u should keep ur information secure for all ages
Reply and tell me if i have any misconceptions included in the details of these ideas:
1. Children should not be considered the same as general audiences, although this may be hard to implement because children will still watch general content.
2. The FTC should allow websites like youtube to handle content “for kids” and “not for kids.” It would make more sense to allow creators to decide if their content is for kids or not, and instead of using a bot to check if they’re “wrong,” allow users under 13 to enter (with permission from an email from parents). Instead of trying to fine creators on vague grounds, don’t recommend “not for kids” videos to kids under 13. I consider this similar to adult-oriented cartoons not being aired on children’s networks.
3. Instead of avoiding recommending videos “for kids” altogether, use a non-personalized recommendation algorithm for those ONLY to avoid collection of data. Separation of “for kids” and “not for kids” is important.
4. If a video is deemed “for kids” run ads targeted at kids in general instead of tracking individual users
5. As an idea for a “general audiences” category of video, it could appear individually in both the children and adult algorithm but treat the user differently based on the age of the account’s user
COPPA ( the Federal Trade Commission ( the F.T.C. ) and the Federal Communications ( CENSORSHIP ) Commission ( the F.C.C. ) does not consider “General Audiences” a valid category!!! With them, it’s either for ADULTS or it’s for KIDS, there is no “General Audiences” ( grey area )!!! Try to list your video as “General Audiences”, and they will fine you $42,000.00 ( I hear they’ve UPPED the amount to something like $42,530.00 now ) for being an obvious pedophile and trying to DECEIVE COPPA!!!
Friend, get your head out of your a$$!!! Seriously, you don’t actually believe that these F.T.C. and F.C.C. Child protection laws are about PROTECTING CHILDREN, do you?!? Surely you’re not THAT gullible!!!
The powers, the rulers and the mighty elite ( under the evil council of Sith Lords ) all know that in order to anonymously pass and enact laws nobody in their right mind would ever APPROVE of, all they have to do is slap the false “CHILD SAFETY” or “CHILD PROTECTION” label on it, and “VOILA!!!” the law is passed and accepted without question!!!
This is PRECISELY how “they” are taking all free speech AWAY from us, starting with the INTERNET!!! Liberal communist “woke” style censorship is the OTHER way they are accomplishing this!!!
• WELCOME TO THE EMPIRE, LUKE !!! •
Thanks to politics, thanks to Trump, and thanks to COPPA!
This pretty much goes against the first Amendment, freedom of speech.
This is absolutely unacceptable!
For that there is TH-cam kids no?but do not kit TH-cam!
theres youtube kids
TH-cam KIDSSS!!!!
Coppa was like the villain in TH-cam
FTCvideos got verified but they got 22.8k subs
TH-cam is unfair
Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (C.O.P.P.A.) SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
There’s something called youtube kids
Coppa:exists
Kreekkraft: im about to end this things whole job
There is literally TH-cam kids why are you doing this to TH-cam many creators will lose their work that they put a lot of hours to make they won't make any money you have to think of something better than this!!!!!!!!
😡😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬🤬
I am literally disgusted by this!!!!
First of all, have you forgot about kidstube? COPPA IS SO DUMB!! TH-cam is meant for older people anyway -.-
well underaged kids will lie about their age when making their channels so..
These people even look like the kind of bafoons that would push for this law
When your video gets worse ratings than the Ajit Pai's christmas video....you should know at that point that you've fucked up BADLY.
TH-cam already have TH-cam Kids.
You've basically laid-off family friendly channels. 😢
The very foolish thing about all this is that it's parents who pay for data and buy devices for kids. So go to telecoms companies and get parents to sign that they'll never let kids on the internet and see if that works.
What is the point of COPPA?
Parents should be in control… yea its called don’t let your kids go online. I grew up in a world without internet and TH-cam and turned out fine.
*its funny how TH-cam kids is already a thing*
"I commited war crimes and you?" "I used a mario toy in my bg for a vid"
I respect COPPA and understand their piont of view
but WHAT THE ACTUAL F__K ARE YOU DOING?!
no no you have youtube kids SO STAY THE FRICK AWAY
FROM REGULAR TH-cam MY CONTENT IS NOT FOR KIDS NOT EVEN IN YOUR DREAM
You guys can legit make Credit Card Credentials cumpolsory for an account and kids will still get around it. So leave the job to parents who are actually supposed to parent them, and not spend 3 hours on Facebook watching TikToks
You know that COPPA could ruin the lives of content creators. All they want is to share and interact with people who are interested in them. You could make content creators lose their money, and make them have a hard time to get through. If a child learns things he/she should not be learning at their age then that is the parents fault because they should be more aware and careful on what their child does in the internet. This will deeply affect content creators because they will create what they are forced and have certain limitations. TH-cam should promote TH-cam Kids more so that parents will know and won't ruin the content of TH-cam. I am 13 but I do not agree on this "COPPA".
3:48 wow... literally telling people it isn’t enough to give parents the information they need to figure things out themselves! what madness is this?!! at least not giving the whole thing means they actually have to read it!! what has this disgusting monster of a law come to?
Oh come on just stop this or i will request everyone to raid your company, TURN ON THE COMMENTS ON FOR KIDS CHANNELS NOW!
That's the thing I hate most, like a third of YT videos are considered kid-friendly by the FTC and so many comments were deleted
Stop ruining lives.
COPPA and TH-cam's newer policies are making this site partially unusable.
Hi FTC, I'd love TH-cam to be left as is but it should be rated E., for everyone.