So many excuses. I am pretty sure he isn’t the only person to have ever worked while being sick. His voice is just average at best. This is what you would expect to hear at a karaoke sing along… not from a professional singer
識貨咪睇到佢哋依3個月有幾努力,值得多D支持,樹都喺summer blue said 香港人應該多D讚美🥹 I am so proud of them 🥹🥹🍭🍭🌲🪵🌲🪵🌲🪵🌲🪵相信鐘意樹林的朋友仔都唔係只係鐘意CP, 係真係欣賞佢哋自己做音樂既堅持, 感受到佢的成長,努力, 佢哋既”love, vibe and mean in a friendly way" too cute too sweet. 有興趣就research 下, 我都唔係一開始就咁鐘意佢哋. 但係了解完你就會Respect
Before us, we have a very talented young man who arranged, produced, sang and danced for a musical like performance. I would not comment without basis. In terms of his voice, he did very well in breathing, stability, timbre, tone quality, vocal registers and passaggio, articulation, agility and intonation. He did particularly so well in this phrase “我嗌阿媽救命，ha~~~~~”. The feelings, tension and flow is beautifully done in 浪子心聲。 He showed case his second voice when he sang with Serrini whose voice is also unique and sweet. He added weight to the chorus of 太陽花。congratulations. Well done.
They are good singers by all means because I watched their live performance when they sang in the "normal" way. At the same time I understand they created their "unique" styles of singing which were reflected in this performance, though it's not my cup of tea, I would not doubt their abilities.
A moving homage to Hong Kong cinema history. Terence and Serrini’s unique and modern interpretation of such classics offers a powerful statement to the creative force of the industry.
![林家謙 focus《從不知 | 靜夜的單簧管 | 有心人 | 戀愛預告》新城台慶音樂會2023 [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/weSyW0_N7wc/mqdefault.jpg)
多謝家謙自己upload咗自己嘅version🥰
大家快啲去聽🖇️
👉🏻 th-cam.com/video/71A3FC4-wF0/w-d-xo.html
多謝你無私嘅分享！❤
唔係佢哋fans，純粹睇完新聞想睇下係咪真係咁差，但睇完覺得個表演好睇喎，亦唔覺得林家謙唱得差，反而浪子心聲唱得好好聽，繼續加油啦💪🏻
佢地兩個好有粵語長片feel, 將故事對白口語咁唱，好演繹到個種懷舊feel。不錯。兩位年青人，加油！鍾意Danny嘅我聽到家謙唱太陽花好驚喜。感謝大會俾個機會呢兩個後生仔女，電影好音樂又好，都要承傳。❤到現時為止，我覺得林家謙番唱Danny嘅歌唱得最好聽。多謝家謙！❤
太陽花同浪子心聲唱得好好聽，係咁loop !!
呢條片已經不斷咁睇，睇完又睇，再三回味，好窩心，好sweet。
最喜愛太陽花🌻
家謙同serrini用心的準備，個Opening好有心思同新鮮，好正呀!家謙剛病好，唔係最佳狀態，但巳盡力表演得很好。謝謝樹林，帶出咁精彩的表演。
So many excuses. I am pretty sure he isn’t the only person to have ever worked while being sick. His voice is just average at best. This is what you would expect to hear at a karaoke sing along… not from a professional singer
唔明點解咁多人淨係識得踩人，我就覺得成個開場表演好完滿好精彩，睇得出表演者有用心去準備，甚至挑戰自己唔擅長嘅項目。覺得好唔好睇好唔好聽一向都係好主觀，點解永遠淨係將自己審美套落去全部人身上？而我睇到現場反應亦覺得好熱烈，大家都好鍾意。同時間其實唔係唔接受批評，但批評內容已經去到同表演無關，甚至有人身攻擊，到底香港嘅批評文化點解會病態成咁。(竟然又有留言話選歌差，無人熟悉？但首首全部都係經典歌，自己井底之蛙唔該唔好衝出嚟)
所以話啲睇慣電視TH-cam嘅人, 唔識欣賞表演藝術
成個production真係算好好semi-musical咁想點⋯ 但謙仔上台嘅energy實在低到有點唔正常
選歌無問題，arrangements 都get 到編者想點；Serrini 我覺得佢做到能力以內嘅野，交到戲，no complaints；但林家謙由比眼神，入歌，跳舞（if 你覺得果種係跳舞），都捉唔緊個拍子。只可以講編者揀錯左演員，浪費左自己一番心血。或者你要接受有啲人天生四肢係無咁協調，只可以坐係度唱歌，唔可以比咁多野佢同時做。
姐係你唔會叫莫華倫表演後空翻，又唔會叫郭富城飆男高音咁……何苦呢😅
最喜歡家謙自弹自唱嘅浪子心聲，好 relax. 全部經典電影插曲，經家謙的重新编寫及演繹又有一番新時代味道。音準，和音都是最强。加油!🙌👏💪
最後佢哋兩個好可愛咁坐埋位😆
A very good way to end the performance 😊
樹林好正，用新聲音唱出舊歌，尤其樹唱魔術師好touching, 林嘅太陽花好有味道！
大會可能從歌手氣質、類型挑選表演嘉賓，而不是從跳唱表現挑選。過去不少歌手會自己寫電影歌曲，許冠傑、林子祥、陳百強…..，所以在當今樂壇選氣質相似的，就會選上他倆，並希望藉此帶出點點文藝氣息，傳送精彩歌舞不是大會首要目標，這是我的想法。
見住家謙嘅改變覺得好感動！ 🥹❤ 由以前做幕後作曲、到出道唱歌、今次用埋戲劇，真心大突破！
以前嘅「木獨男」唔識跳舞，宜家仲記到咁多舞步，帶動到現場氣氛，期待你未來嘅改變🥹！
聽完～我搵到個問題係邊，家謙同樹妮妮都係唱作歌手，本身style都比較獨特，你叫佢地隨便cover咁經典既歌曲，唔係人人handle到，同埋個感覺會怪怪的。就好似一個小朋友唱「冷得我騰騰震」咁，個身份跟本不適合，好難做到完美。本身樹妮妮係響亮既懷舊聲線，所以效果比較好。大會係要揀呢d歌，咁冇計🤷♀️我就睇得好開心，好鍾意佢地❤
好玩味好fresh好開心嘅opening, 好有心思，可以聽番咁多經典電影主題曲！❤❤
我覺得兩位表現得好好！ 好有heart ! 音樂編曲 演繹方法都好好！
我細個爸爸成日聽呢啲歌，覺得好娘好煩，而家家謙同serrini咁樣重新演繹改編返一啲update嘅歌詞用返而家呢個年代嘅唱腔去唱，令我重新認識同欣賞呢啲經典，thank you～
雖然每次佢跳舞我都想笑，但兩位獨立歌手上到金像奬真係唔容易，PROUD!!!
特倫斯 求求你講聲你可以 ……..
我個❤溶咗…. 🌲 林so sweet❤
呢個係咪佢地結婚嘅first dance?
原來咁多人唔識分把聲震音多同埋音準😂
Mami聲底厚同埋performance習慣用得多vibrato但音係準㗎喎⋯
兩位聲線都好有個人特色同埋好有感染力，唱前輩嘅歌都可以保留到自己嘅vibes覺得好犀利👍🏻Respect！
識貨咪睇到佢哋依3個月有幾努力,值得多D支持,樹都喺summer blue said 香港人應該多D讚美🥹 I am so proud of them 🥹🥹🍭🍭🌲🪵🌲🪵🌲🪵🌲🪵相信鐘意樹林的朋友仔都唔係只係鐘意CP, 係真係欣賞佢哋自己做音樂既堅持, 感受到佢的成長,努力, 佢哋既”love, vibe and mean in a friendly way" too cute too sweet. 有興趣就research 下, 我都唔係一開始就咁鐘意佢哋. 但係了解完你就會Respect
4:03 可惜只是播歌咪嘴， 林家謙 仲要隊咪比Dancer時照播緊佢把聲， 睇到好尷尬
夾口形到自己都呃埋
@@kahoilim3645 其實你要唔要聽清楚啲？嗰把聲唔係林家謙把聲嚟，係dancer把聲，有興趣了解多啲可以去嗰位dancer本人嘅ig度求證吓，人哋就係唱得咁好
@@kahoilim3645 你耳仔及眼睛是否出了毛病？check下好啲喎。明明兩個人兩把聲。
好似睇緊小劇場，好開心🥳
林家謙好cute
樹林真係世一 what an artistic and inspiring performance💙🤍
好值得回味，好多畫面。編排編輯節奏真係好完美
我以前勁唔鐘意林家謙啲歌，覺得好怪咁，但女朋友好鐘意，八月陪佢去睇完林家謙個演唱會，之後變左勁鐘意佢啲歌，日日不停聽😂
我以前勁唔鐘意林家謙啲歌，唱歌欠技巧，無感情，完全平聲………今次聽完，感覺其後台背景強大，打手超多👍👍
如果改唱“大悲咒” ，可能更動聽👍👍
可能因為佢同以往既香港流行樂唔一樣，用大量弦樂同偏classical style既編曲，再加上特登及大量既off beat，一開始未必聽得慣，除非聽開indie或者後現代啲既音樂
❤林仔同Mami一步步由獨立唱作人變身成多元化發展的MC, 代言人，model 等唔同角色，so impressed by their potentials and talents!!!
Before us, we have a very talented young man who arranged, produced, sang and danced for a musical like performance. I would not comment without basis. In terms of his voice, he did very well in breathing, stability, timbre, tone quality, vocal registers and passaggio, articulation, agility and intonation. He did particularly so well in this phrase “我嗌阿媽救命，ha~~~~~”. The feelings, tension and flow is beautifully done in 浪子心聲。 He showed case his second voice when he sang with Serrini whose voice is also unique and sweet. He added weight to the chorus of 太陽花。congratulations. Well done.
整體來講，成個編排好順，特別係開頭結尾都好鍾意。有左第一次經驗，相信佢地兩個會愈做愈好～
家謙同Serrini 真係表演得幾好，唱出新鮮感👏🏻我好鍾意林亞珍，四眼妹好得意， 謙謙唱歌好聽，雖然跳舞係有啲緊張，但個表情可可愛😊
呢個opening真係好正，好特別。🎉🎉👍👍👍
家謙把聲唱這些懷舊歌原來是咁正👍
係👍🏻 你睇吓許冠傑演唱會第一場嘉賓，家謙同首歌好夾 - 心裡日記
@@wenwendy1101 咁點解唔搵許冠傑同許冠文做 開場表演嘉賓? 許冠文都在啊
唔好玩啦！我都很希望長江推後浪，但差太遠！！！
Great performance! Thanks Serrinj and Ka Him!
林生嘅鈣質舞真係好正，每日都要睇一次
These lovely two are what the world needs🥹❤️
非常好既opening ❤❤
感謝你和團隊用❤的制作和付出，非常精彩的演出，成個表演編排好好, 謝謝家謙 & Serrini
多謝你嘅post, save 咗打算每日1loop, 樹林黨既vitamin ❤❤, 林仔扭蛋扭到樹樹好正！笑死! 都係樹叻, 昨天搵MV 嚇到佢好番晒超好performance 😊😊 💕💕💕
嚇到佢好返晒🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣魔藥for each other 🥰
樹林世一 。印象中最好的香港金像奬opening.
mami把聲真係好正👍👍
So musical vibe ! ❤ loving this
They are good singers by all means because I watched their live performance when they sang in the "normal" way. At the same time I understand they created their "unique" styles of singing which were reflected in this performance, though it's not my cup of tea, I would not doubt their abilities.
I love their chemistry!! What a fun performance & great visual art!!
Both Terence and Serrini sang and danced well. Such a great performance! Love their chemistry ❤
4:03 Just play Song file, not a live performance
@@kahoilim3645 韓國歌手唔係對口型表演？ 你唔走去韓國鬧人地？
@@kahoilim3645 he gave the mic to the backup dancer bro, watch carefully before u comment 😂
@@fusiu8374 要拿人家來比 ，不如把自己做好...
最愛聽林家謙拉鐵閘🤟💕
btw用力恥笑佢跳舞嘅黑粉一律當真愛粉處理🥰
林家謙 唱danny的歌很不錯
呢個opening真係好有心思,好好睇~
樹林超正一生推～
Mami嘅高貴優雅+林仔嘅治癒心靈，2個一齊勁可愛♡
唔洗理啲hater，作為fans會繼續行動支持你哋(*´꒳`*)
cute 到一個點.... 好可愛.... ; 我唔怪D haters / 酸民, 可能佢哋鐘意睇恬静嘅沙畫、爆肌爆肺地唱歌、刺激的吊網絲……百貨應百客... 冇計... (打COMMENT這刻，大馬電台傳來MAMI首「樹木真美」... 咁啱geh... ) [ I am from 大馬]
Great performance, both
謙B和樹妮永遠匹配的一對❤❤❤❤
你當Tyson Yoshi死架？😂😂
有埋TYSON就PERFECT，但好難控制TYSON唔講粗口XD
真係好希望佢地結婚。😂😂🎉🎉
@@chantania6017 係好朋友❤唔好迫佢地啦😂
賞心悅目的表演❤
好聽好好睇
我睇得好開心
另外除了樹林唱得好好之外，想講音樂伴奏超好聽好厲害，將成個表演層次提升。 初初loop 個表演係因為樹林，但聽聽下完全被伴奏吸引住 👏🏻
伴奏勁到 枝咪離開咗冇唱都會有林家謙把聲，將成個表演層次提升 4:03
@@kahoilim3645 😂😂 你真係唔識架喎！ 唔識分係播聲定live 唱、人地把聲似d 林家謙就話係林家謙唱、個表演者唱得好又話係人地播聲。 仲周圍留言話睇到勁尷尬，我覺得你尷尬d 喎 🤧
@@happyfriday2510 咁你鬼揞眼到 有晒片甩晒嘴離晒咪 來播歌都覺得冇問題, 已經冇討論空間啦
@@kahoilim3645 我都覺得同盲目hater 冇討論空間 byebye ~~
@@happyfriday2510 Un 下un 下撐艇嗰句係個dancer唱嫁😂
好多人都誤會左
我都係睇左幾次先發現
舞姿驚人！
愉悅😊😊😊
I ❤ them both. 幾好睇呀個opening
选曲太棒了
感謝樓主cut🙏好鍾意成個編排，俾左個good start，欣賞mami同家謙肯挑戰musical同跳舞，睇得好開心😂
樹林世一❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️
聽人講話好差，耳聽為實，都唱得不錯呀，而且成個rundown，舞台設計和燈光效果都好有心思
好正！
支持2位開歌舞劇！！！！
浪子心聲 個下，唱得有feel。對比呀sam，係另一種味道。
有聽開佢地就知呢個live 同錄音一樣水準，係佢哋獨有風格同聲線。唔識佢哋既人，一定無留意香港樂壇起碼5年😏
佢哋獨有風格同聲線. 真係拍得住巴黎鐵塔反轉再反轉. 🤭
一直都有留意同聽，林家謙寫歌好，錄音室版本OK嘅，live一般般。MC Jay Fung 呢啲好啲。至於女仔…sell另類風格，頂籠錄音室版本係幾特別咁。頒獎禮個台，Live同車禍冇乜兩樣。。
錄音本身就唔係太好 佢哋都唔係vocal見長嘅歌手。Viu請佢哋唱live好似整蠱佢哋咁
@@ceriselll 唔係Vocal 見長的歌手? 唔通兩位係跳舞歌手?
我又真係有聽林家謙live 把聲的確麻麻哋 係才華搭救
+him 都係自彈自唱最charm
但跳舞都好有歡樂氣氛😂😂😂大家睇得高興咪幾好😊😊😊
They’re just too cute together💕
唔好以為搵家謙同樹妮妮就可以改變大會形象，睇到最後竟然頒獎俾十九，可見呢個會同普世價值背道而馳，執七佢啦！
佢兩位演出精采，同大會無關， 係viu tv嘅設計精彩啫， 呢個頒獎禮不嬲都不被認同，俾面派對而已 。
當通關之後，班吸血鬼喺大陸吸完錢，又返嚟搞香港。之前幾年佢哋個個困喺大陸，香港本地文化無論影壇、樂壇同電視都靠一班年輕人去擔當，迎來新氣象、小陽春，而家佢哋一返嚟，又想生霸死霸扮大牌做大佬，要所有人跟返佢哋嗰套嚟玩，繼續俾面派對，佢哋請啲年輕表演者都係做形象工程，後面其實就死咬住唔會俾呢啲新生代主導，嚟緊香港娛樂市場又會攞番啲舊嘢番炒再番炒，呢班吸血鬼只會整死香港
好有質素的opening
好喜歡這個opening
好好聽同睇🤙🏼
好好睇, 2個都好好
精彩 🎉🎉🎉
兩位最近都做過 Sam Hui 演唱會嘉賓🎉🎉🎉👍👍👍
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊.
聲底夠厚，夠響就有好多可能，聲音聽入耳令你舒服就巳經夠。
4:03 夾口形假唱嘅， 想做到幾多可能都得啦， 最緊要啲電腦推得夠響
@@kahoilim3645 有咩證據
@@kahoilim3645 邊度規定演出唔俾對嘴？ 你唔去投訴BLACKPINK？
❤好鍾意佢地
正喎～～❤
希望佢哋兩個未來可以合作做歌舞劇，一定買飛入場撐
唔係話想買就買到😅
一啲都唔差喎，當晚我好晏先睇， 聽到幾呢幾日嘅評語，仲諗緊真係咁差，真係一啲都唔差👍🏽👍🏽💪💪
好好呀🎉
點指兵兵好啱林家謙唱， serrini 唱林亞真都唱得好好 ，金童玉女， 表情鬼馬， 非常合拍， 歌舞編排令人耳目一新 ，尤其最尾唱完跟手坐番埋位，好特別。👍👍👍
兩個都好正呀，好好聽呀，好fun!!! 唔洗理啲haters的留言
見到 4:03 夾口形假唱， 覺得唔好， 就係Hater？
@@kahoilim3645 把聲都唔係家謙把聲。邊到夾口形？🤣
@@kahoilim3645 嗰句係特別安排dancer唱，點會係夾合形？
@@cloudddsoup 可惜林家謙 掛住玩出賣咗件事，支咪高高 低低咁唔對dancer嘴 但又收音清晰, 有埋片都睇唔到個Dancer 幾尷尬😆
@@kahoilim3645 邊度規定歌手唔可以夾嘴型演出? 講
排得好仔細
一個好正的live 表演、有排loop🙏🏻!
夾口形假唱， 聽聲就可以啦
@@kahoilim3645
認真識少少audio聽力正常就知一定唔會呢場係mic嘴
@@kahoilim3645 邊度規定演出唔俾對嘴？ 你唔去投訴BLACKPINK？
好睇wo...絕對無外間講得咁差
都唱得好好呀！
真係無啲人講到咁差喎😢
仲幾夾幾好聽幾好睇😅
好正👍👍👍
好正
兩位的聲線很適合唱這些懷舊曲
佢兩個擺明往鬼馬雙星方向發展😂（最後啦啦啦啦咁耐，作為fans都有少少失去耐性😅）
睇得好開心，好enjoy 多謝樹林！！！
超出色既opening
好聽好睇❤️🔥
真係識睇睇留言😂😂😂兩位表演真係好，好到絕頂呀😂😂唔需要再進步，千祈唔好改🤣，千祈唔好冇咗而家嘅自己…有呢批粉絲夠㗎喇，千萬要一直都咁樣保持😄😄😄😄😄
樓主 #曲線要講明 成班盲粉見到負評就話人hater😂
梗係林生同班fans拉你入泥睇😂😂辛苦晒你啦😂😂😂
A moving homage to Hong Kong cinema history. Terence and Serrini’s unique and modern interpretation of such classics offers a powerful statement to the creative force of the industry.
佢哋真係編排得好好
so sweeeeeet
loveeee
點解家謙唱親歌我都覺得好有周星馳喺戲中唱歌咁😂有冇人有同樣感覺呢？
冇。係歌,唔係哥。
People seem to enjoy picking on the 2 singers rather than enjoying the whole production & performance 😅 Relax, haters!
for real 😂
唔覺有咩問題，都做得幾好丫，無外面講到咁差喎
係咪我耳仔有問題？我覺得好好聽喎😂林仔同樹都唱得好有味道 ❤ 支持🎉個人心地唔好 聽咩都唔覺好聽嫁啦
人唔進步 下下都話以前好，點解唔活在當下，珍惜而家仲出嚟唱歌既歌手
同舊歌手致敬， sam hui 演唱會嘉賓延續!
4:03 播歌咪嘴， 都算係一種進步？
@@kahoilim3645 你唔去鬧韓國啲歌手? 表演夾嘴型有咩問題?
好撚正❤
Terrance之後多寫一點，多唱一點香港電影主題曲，在不久將來再表演一次Medley然後都是自己的歌，那就沒有網民會批評，畢竟自己的歌誰能夠批評呢 XD
製作出色❤真係好好睇
樹林世一❤