"Hey Obi-Wan, great talking with you. Oh and by the way, Palpatine is the Sith Lord." "It was nice talking with you too, Anakin. May the Force be w-WHHHHHAAAAAAT?!"
So, Anakin was arrested after Obi-Wan was a screw up in handling the issue with Palpatine, being revealed as the Sith Lord? Anakin was trying to keep his brother alive and protect Padme along with their children, yet because he 'betrayed' the Jedi and the Senate he was convicted despite his reasoning. Anakin didn't even go on a murdering spree, and he ended the threat of the Sith. He fulfilled his destiny as the chosen one to bring balance to the Force and he is rewarded with time in prison? Senate and Jedi: "Yeah, thanks for saving us all and fulfilling the prophecy, Anakin. But you still collaborated with the enemy, despite being blackmailed to do so and protecting those you love and care about as well as risking your life to fight for the Republic, so f*ck you. You're going to rot in prison for the rest of your miserable existence." Even Obi-Wan turned his back on Anakin during this and threw him under the bus. Just wow. That's just cold-blooded, even for a Jedi. I know this is supposed to be the 'good ending', but I'm calling that into question here.
I concur and prepose and extension to this where Bail get elected Challencer and Pardon’s Anakin and The Jedi are sanctioned and have to pay for their own breaches of the law. Oh and also Anakin simply Leaves with his wife and kids and teaches them his own way, later being Joined by Snips and others who either were disillusioned with the Jedi or screwed over by them and started a new order on Naboo as an Alternative to the dogmatic and politicized order and given amnesty and Asylum by the Naboo Government.
They couldnt sense his force energy, as in at all. This is unheard of previously, or at least amongst living Jedi. Such a talent hadnt been since the likes of Darth Bane. So they had 0 proof he was even force sensitive. Even then, they did suspect him of working with Darth Sidious, just not that he was Sidious himself.
In world reasoning or real world reasoning? In world it was because the dark side was clouding their vision, Palpatine also hid his connection to the force. They had figured out someone close to him was the sith lord. In the real world it's because the pre-sequels needed to end in a particular way so they don't conflict with the already made original trilogy.
As the reasons stated above, one more needs to be added: arrogance... complacency. The Sith disappeared for a thousand years in the old republic. And this wasn't a Jedi turning into one like Revan or Exar Kun but a genuine Sith empire. The Sith of the modern era adapted and evolved while the Jedi stagnated. One line of the phantom meance is: "The Sith have been gone for a millenia." And they and they disregarded all to the contrary until Qui-gon died.
Eh, sorry I don't think Anakin being arrested should've happened at the end. Palpatine got exposed, and Anakin killed the man who started the Clone Wars. That right there should've been enough to clear him of all charges.
2:06-2:08 sounded like EP II Obi-Wan and Anakin relationship when Anakin told Obi-Wan he thinks him of as a Father instead of the dynamic brotherly relationship we got in III haha
Why do I have the feeling that the mere idea of Anakin telling Obi-Wan about Palpatine in Revenge of The Sith would not only give the Sith a run for their money but is also a very bad thing for everyone involved…specifically their enemies. Plus it’s nice to see an amazing ‘what if’ centered around Anakin telling Obi-Wan about Palpatine because for some reason it just makes sense for Anakin to tell Obi-Wan about Palpatine because I always felt that Anakin is one of the strongest characters in SW history and is just so beneficial in so many ways and he would definitely conquer any challenge that’s thrown his way with Obi-Wan because his enemies wouldn’t stand a chance against a battle hardened warrior and it would fit perfectly well within the SW universe. Plus, who doesn’t love a good Anakin and Obi-Wan adventure…afterall two badass Jedi saving the galaxy like it’s a typical Tuesday is just so beautiful. Also Anakin would definitely want to confide in Obi-Wan with this…aside from Padme and Ahsoka, he’s the only one he trusts. Also the voice acting for Anakin, Padme, Obi-Wan and Palpatine was just amazing. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s
Surprised that: -none of the executive orders were used -the Senate simply understood the notions of "sith Lord" without the explicit explanation that as the sith Lord he was in control of both the cis and Republic armies the entire time, that the entire war was a sith plot/scheme, etc -palpatine accepted the accusation without negation, just jumps directly into evil overlord act without any attempt to use the Senate as a meat shield to keep his evilness hidden
What if Darth Vitiate came back as a force ghost during the Phantom Menace fully intending to dismantle Revan's order. He waltz into the council chamber but then he takes one look at the current Jedi and goes "NO! What the hell is this? You're no Jedi !" "What do you mean you can't use Tutaminis or Force Heal?" In his frustration, he decides to start teaching them the Jedi ways of old.
@DarthTheorist What If Darth Revan awakened during the Sequel Trilogy with Finn and Rey? What If Obi Wan Had Visions of Anakin's Fall and Order 66? What if Qui Gon Jin survived and went to Geonosis instead of Obi Wan who is alive? What if the Father communicated with the Jedi BEFORE the MORTIS ARC?
Obi Wan should have had a recording device or mini-camera on him during the “arrest” attempt while live-streaming all of what was occurring. Obi Wan is at fault here.
What if... Anakin left the Jedi at the start of the Clone Wars and lived as a bodyguard to his wife? What if... The Jedi refused to fight in the Clone Wars? What if... Maul escaped unharmed? What if... Count Dooku found the Death Note? What if... Yen Sid was a jedi master?
Q: What if there were 17 Billion Jedi? A: The Jedi Council would deploy only four of the 17 Billion to confront Palpatine. Mace Windu, Kid Elbow, Agent Couloir, and Sizly Tin. Good Lord the Jedi deserved it.
Hey darth theorist i love how much time and efforts you made on your videos. I love how you brought a Marvel crossover. I was wondering if you do a video on where Anakin becomes The Herald of Galactus. It will be a change of dynamic shift in the star wars universe due to Galactus unwavering and overwhelming presence. Pls i would love a story about it
at min 2:55 i am like WTF!!!! this is like it should have happened... but not at all. the episodes 4-6 were out there already. the story had to unfold that way...
@DarthTheorist What If Superman was a Force Sensitive Jedi or raised by the Jedi on Coruscant? What if Team Avatar joined the Jedi and the Republic? What if Hancock (Will Smith) travelled to or was in the Star Wars Universe ? What If Deadpool and Wolverine went to the Star Wars Universe? What if Spider-man 2099 or the Web Warriors from Across the Spider-Verse were on Coruscant in the Star Wars Galaxy? What If Qui Gon Jin was the real Chosen One? What If Wakanda was a Planet in the Star Wars Galaxy ? What If Godzilla and the Titans from the Monsterverse were found by the Jedi or DARTH REVAN in the Star Wars Galaxy? What If Darth Revan awakened during the Sequel Trilogy?
It's a good story, let me get that stated. Everyone talks about how Anakin "betrayed" the Jedi Order and the Jedi Council, and that's 🐂💩. Anakin didn't trust the Jedi, and the Jedi didn't trust him. If there's no trust between them then neither side can betray or be betrayed by the other. Mace Windu proved that the Jedi Council didn't trust Anakin in the temple. "If what you told me is true, then you will have gained my trust?" That's all the proof you need that he wasn't trusted. It's too much 🐂💩 saying that the Jedi were betrayed. They brought it on themselves. They brought what amounts to a wild animal into their home slapped it around, tried to convince it to be a cute little puppy, slapped it around some more, then put it in a fighting ring, brought it back home, yelled at it, beat it some more, and then got butt hurt because it found a way to bite back. It's sickening to hear all this betrayal crap. The Jedi Order got better than it deserved. Only the younglings should be pitied in this or any scenario that involve Jedi. Jedi suck! Great story. It actually got me to be a little emotional.
Hehehe. . . . . . . they already were drifting apart before, even before Anakin was placed on the Jedi Council by Palpatine. Since 4 hundred years being a Sirh was no longer considered to be a Crime, it was more a philosophical ideal, and persecution was condemned
What if Anakin was never found by the Jedi and became Red Hood? What if Anakin became Moon Knight after he slaughtered the tusken raiders? What if Rex killed Ahsoka during order 66? What if Appo went to Mandalore and Rex went to Coruscant? What if Galactus found Darth Maul and Savage Opress instead of Pre Vizsla and made them his heralds? What if Palpatine killed Maul instead of Savage? What if Darth Maul was found by the Jedi? What if Revan awakened during the sequel trilogy and led the First Order?
Why did Obi Wan only take two masters with him to face Sidious? Even mace who is far more arrogant then him took more with him. Also i kinda doubt that he would do anything this arrogant after what happened to quigon. Otherwise great theory
What charges would anakin even be arrested for lmao and why would everyone be so pissed at him? I get maybe windu would be but the Jedi were using anakin as a political weapon almost just as much as palpatine and the Jedi wronged anakin more times to count. He practically single handily saved the republic in the video and didn’t commit any crimes considering he stated he was under the chancellors orders. The only consequence should be maybe expelled from the order and the galaxy wouldnt worship him as a war hero anymore. This is like the 3rd video I’ve seen where anakin gets arrested with no crimes
"Hey Obi-Wan, great talking with you. Oh and by the way, Palpatine is the Sith Lord."
"It was nice talking with you too, Anakin. May the Force be w-WHHHHHAAAAAAT?!"
“One of these days you’re going to be the death of me…”. I love that line sm. Lol
The irony
So, Anakin was arrested after Obi-Wan was a screw up in handling the issue with Palpatine, being revealed as the Sith Lord? Anakin was trying to keep his brother alive and protect Padme along with their children, yet because he 'betrayed' the Jedi and the Senate he was convicted despite his reasoning. Anakin didn't even go on a murdering spree, and he ended the threat of the Sith. He fulfilled his destiny as the chosen one to bring balance to the Force and he is rewarded with time in prison?
Senate and Jedi: "Yeah, thanks for saving us all and fulfilling the prophecy, Anakin. But you still collaborated with the enemy, despite being blackmailed to do so and protecting those you love and care about as well as risking your life to fight for the Republic, so f*ck you. You're going to rot in prison for the rest of your miserable existence."
Even Obi-Wan turned his back on Anakin during this and threw him under the bus. Just wow. That's just cold-blooded, even for a Jedi. I know this is supposed to be the 'good ending', but I'm calling that into question here.
I concur and prepose and extension to this where Bail get elected Challencer and Pardon’s Anakin and The Jedi are sanctioned and have to pay for their own breaches of the law. Oh and also Anakin simply Leaves with his wife and kids and teaches them his own way, later being Joined by Snips and others who either were disillusioned with the Jedi or screwed over by them and started a new order on Naboo as an Alternative to the dogmatic and politicized order and given amnesty and Asylum by the Naboo Government.
when you think about it, why didn't the jedi council realise he was the sith lord much earlier?
The Sith used the dark side to cloud the force. There's a book on it.
@@TheIrishRushin The Novelisation of Revenge of the Sith?
They couldnt sense his force energy, as in at all. This is unheard of previously, or at least amongst living Jedi. Such a talent hadnt been since the likes of Darth Bane. So they had 0 proof he was even force sensitive.
Even then, they did suspect him of working with Darth Sidious, just not that he was Sidious himself.
In world reasoning or real world reasoning?
In world it was because the dark side was clouding their vision, Palpatine also hid his connection to the force. They had figured out someone close to him was the sith lord.
In the real world it's because the pre-sequels needed to end in a particular way so they don't conflict with the already made original trilogy.
As the reasons stated above, one more needs to be added: arrogance... complacency. The Sith disappeared for a thousand years in the old republic. And this wasn't a Jedi turning into one like Revan or Exar Kun but a genuine Sith empire. The Sith of the modern era adapted and evolved while the Jedi stagnated. One line of the phantom meance is: "The Sith have been gone for a millenia." And they and they disregarded all to the contrary until Qui-gon died.
Eh, sorry I don't think Anakin being arrested should've happened at the end. Palpatine got exposed, and Anakin killed the man who started the Clone Wars. That right there should've been enough to clear him of all charges.
Yea i am sure Anakin would have had plenty of people backing him like Asoka and Padme and some of the clones like Rex
@@LyokoisGreat2 The vast majority of clones would've backed him as he was one of the few jedi who actually led on the front lines.
@@megaman37456 yea there would have been outrage if he was jailed
Very nice voice filter for the hologram calls, nice touch
😁
These videos are awesome, but can you make one that Kit Fisto doesn’t die. 🤣 thanks for the video
This definitely took some turns i wasn't expecting. Great story.
What was Anakin arrested for again? For lying under pressure? He didn't kill anyone in this scenario.
Oh. He'll be out for good behavior in 5 years
What If our Solar System, planet Earth and Cybertron from Transformers were teleported to the Star Wars Galaxy and appeared in the Outer Rim region
Megaton would squish Palps
Why would Obiwan helping Anakin cancel out that business on Cato Nemoidia? That incident didn't count to begin with!
🤣 Anikan will never let it go! even when revealing the identity of the Sith Lord, he brings it up.
What if Darth Vader travels back in time to save Padme on mustafar
What if Maul and Savage killed Darth Sidious on Mandalore?
Darth Theorist cannot be touched when it comes to Star Wars Fan Fiction Storytelling & This is facts 🔥🔥🔥
What if Dooku had visions of Palpatine's betrayal.
Yeah dude, I wish that the prequels had more dooku dueling, him being a master duelist and all, even if he was super old
What if Palepetine revealed himself much earlier. Maybe when anakin was a padawan
2:06-2:08 sounded like EP II Obi-Wan and Anakin relationship when Anakin told Obi-Wan he thinks him of as a Father instead of the dynamic brotherly relationship we got in III haha
What if the Star Fox team fought in Clone wars
Why do I have the feeling that the mere idea of Anakin telling Obi-Wan about Palpatine in Revenge of The Sith would not only give the Sith a run for their money but is also a very bad thing for everyone involved…specifically their enemies. Plus it’s nice to see an amazing ‘what if’ centered around Anakin telling Obi-Wan about Palpatine because for some reason it just makes sense for Anakin to tell Obi-Wan about Palpatine because I always felt that Anakin is one of the strongest characters in SW history and is just so beneficial in so many ways and he would definitely conquer any challenge that’s thrown his way with Obi-Wan because his enemies wouldn’t stand a chance against a battle hardened warrior and it would fit perfectly well within the SW universe. Plus, who doesn’t love a good Anakin and Obi-Wan adventure…afterall two badass Jedi saving the galaxy like it’s a typical Tuesday is just so beautiful. Also Anakin would definitely want to confide in Obi-Wan with this…aside from Padme and Ahsoka, he’s the only one he trusts. Also the voice acting for Anakin, Padme, Obi-Wan and Palpatine was just amazing. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next.
I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s:
1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling.
2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever.
3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this.
4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st)
I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s
What if... Kamino used a VR algorithm to predict Palpatine betraying them and lent it to the Jedi secretly?
Surprised that:
-none of the executive orders were used
-the Senate simply understood the notions of "sith Lord" without the explicit explanation that as the sith Lord he was in control of both the cis and Republic armies the entire time, that the entire war was a sith plot/scheme, etc
-palpatine accepted the accusation without negation, just jumps directly into evil overlord act without any attempt to use the Senate as a meat shield to keep his evilness hidden
What if Darth Vitiate came back as a force ghost during the Phantom Menace fully intending to dismantle Revan's order.
He waltz into the council chamber but then he takes one look at the current Jedi and goes
"NO! What the hell is this? You're no Jedi !"
"What do you mean you can't use Tutaminis or Force Heal?"
In his frustration, he decides to start teaching them the Jedi ways of old.
@DarthTheorist What If Darth Revan awakened during the Sequel Trilogy with Finn and Rey?
What If Obi Wan Had Visions of Anakin's Fall and Order 66?
What if Qui Gon Jin survived and went to Geonosis instead of Obi Wan who is alive?
What if the Father communicated with the Jedi BEFORE the MORTIS ARC?
Let's not involve that garbage sequel trilogy into this.
@CosmicGoku529 So we can involve the Original and Prequel Trilogy but not the Sequel Trilogy. Having Revan in it COULD POSSIBLY make it BETTER
@@joshuamerriweather2861 Better yes, but a polished turd is still a turd.
Crossover with OG Modern Warfare (Price, Shepherd, Shadow Company) or Deus Ex or Sniper Elite
This is awesome!
Another hit! Darth Theorist is an inspiration to some of our content! We’ve got 5 videos up the last week!
Obi Wan should have had a recording device or mini-camera on him during the “arrest” attempt while live-streaming all of what was occurring. Obi Wan is at fault here.
The jedi turned their body cams off. They always do that. 😋
What if... Anakin left the Jedi at the start of the Clone Wars and lived as a bodyguard to his wife?
What if... The Jedi refused to fight in the Clone Wars?
What if... Maul escaped unharmed?
What if... Count Dooku found the Death Note?
What if... Yen Sid was a jedi master?
Excellent!
What if the x men lived on the planet coruscant instead of earth during the clone wars
1:24 / 5:14 / 7:19 / 8:32 / 9:40 / 14:40 -- 17:20 / 19:42
What if the Martians From DC comics Had invaded the star wars galaxy ?
Q: What if there were 17 Billion Jedi?
A: The Jedi Council would deploy only four of the 17 Billion to confront Palpatine. Mace Windu, Kid Elbow, Agent Couloir, and Sizly Tin. Good Lord the Jedi deserved it.
Hey darth theorist i love how much time and efforts you made on your videos. I love how you brought a Marvel crossover. I was wondering if you do a video on where Anakin becomes The Herald of Galactus. It will be a change of dynamic shift in the star wars universe due to Galactus unwavering and overwhelming presence.
Pls i would love a story about it
What if Shmi was a Retired sith lord when Qui-Gon Took Anakin ?
Day 11 of asking for a Starkiller what if
Gibt es Darth Theorist auch bei Spotify?
at min 2:55 i am like WTF!!!! this is like it should have happened... but not at all. the episodes 4-6 were out there already. the story had to unfold that way...
Cue Anakin's dark deeds
LFG!!!!
I do see him doing so in an alternate universe to type of scenario/
@DarthTheorist What If Superman was a Force Sensitive Jedi or raised by the Jedi on Coruscant?
What if Team Avatar joined the Jedi and the Republic?
What if Hancock (Will Smith) travelled to or was in the Star Wars Universe ?
What If Deadpool and Wolverine went to the Star Wars Universe?
What if Spider-man 2099 or the Web Warriors from Across the Spider-Verse were on Coruscant in the Star Wars Galaxy?
What If Qui Gon Jin was the real Chosen One?
What If Wakanda was a Planet in the Star Wars Galaxy ?
What If Godzilla and the Titans from the Monsterverse were found by the Jedi or DARTH REVAN in the Star Wars Galaxy?
What If Darth Revan awakened during the Sequel Trilogy?
Why would obi -wan go in without more backup.
Would love to see you do a what that puts you in Star Wars
Why would Palpatine wait to execute order 66?
I find you lack of faith disturbing, master kenobi
This be pretty interesting ❤
What if Palpatine went back to the Kotor/Kotor 2 era and the jedi civil war.
What if Palpatine built Unicron instead of the Death Star?
What if Samus Aran from Metroid was in Star Wars?
Wassup bro how you doing man?
What if Anakin realized that the Jedi Council needed him, but he didn't need them at all?
It's a good story, let me get that stated.
Everyone talks about how Anakin "betrayed" the Jedi Order and the Jedi Council, and that's 🐂💩.
Anakin didn't trust the Jedi, and the Jedi didn't trust him. If there's no trust between them then neither side can betray or be betrayed by the other. Mace Windu proved that the Jedi Council didn't trust Anakin in the temple. "If what you told me is true, then you will have gained my trust?" That's all the proof you need that he wasn't trusted. It's too much 🐂💩 saying that the Jedi were betrayed. They brought it on themselves. They brought what amounts to a wild animal into their home slapped it around, tried to convince it to be a cute little puppy, slapped it around some more, then put it in a fighting ring, brought it back home, yelled at it, beat it some more, and then got butt hurt because it found a way to bite back. It's sickening to hear all this betrayal crap. The Jedi Order got better than it deserved. Only the younglings should be pitied in this or any scenario that involve Jedi. Jedi suck!
Great story. It actually got me to be a little emotional.
Hehehe. . . . . . . they already were drifting apart before, even before Anakin was placed on the Jedi Council by Palpatine.
Since 4 hundred years being a Sirh was no longer considered to be a Crime, it was more a philosophical ideal, and persecution was condemned
What if count dukoo confronted quigon and obiwan on naboo as part of his full fall to the darkside could he kill quigon
What if Anakin was never found by the Jedi and became Red Hood?
What if Anakin became Moon Knight after he slaughtered the tusken raiders?
What if Rex killed Ahsoka during order 66?
What if Appo went to Mandalore and Rex went to Coruscant?
What if Galactus found Darth Maul and Savage Opress instead of Pre Vizsla and made them his heralds?
What if Palpatine killed Maul instead of Savage?
What if Darth Maul was found by the Jedi?
What if Revan awakened during the sequel trilogy and led the First Order?
Of the little riding version?
@Commander.Starfleet No DC comics version
I don’t get why they would be mad at anakin. If he didn’t do when palps said he will kill obi wan. Anyone would understand that.
What if anakin wanted padme to die in childbirth so he could get her money
damn 😐
What if Darth Maul was the son of Lucifer Morningstar
Why did Obi Wan only take two masters with him to face Sidious? Even mace who is far more arrogant then him took more with him. Also i kinda doubt that he would do anything this arrogant after what happened to quigon. Otherwise great theory
What charges would anakin even be arrested for lmao and why would everyone be so pissed at him? I get maybe windu would be but the Jedi were using anakin as a political weapon almost just as much as palpatine and the Jedi wronged anakin more times to count. He practically single handily saved the republic in the video and didn’t commit any crimes considering he stated he was under the chancellors orders. The only consequence should be maybe expelled from the order and the galaxy wouldnt worship him as a war hero anymore. This is like the 3rd video I’ve seen where anakin gets arrested with no crimes
What if the COD Zombies invaded the Star Wars universe?
What if ash and Serena were trained as padawans by Anakin Skywalker during the clone wars
(pokemonXYZcrossover)
So the Jedi still betrayed anakin good to know the Jedi are still as bad as the Sith.
First
Stupid story bro
I have to agree
These videos are awesome, but can you make one that Kit Fisto doesn’t die. 🤣 thanks for the video