''Be with me always-take any form-drive me mad! only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! Oh, God! it is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!"
Very well done. This 2011 Wuthering Heights is very different than the others. It captures the visceral sounds, textures and raw emotions of the times of the novel. I am a fan of the book, all the versions of W. Heights on film, the music of Kate Bush and now this movie. It's a good enough story to embrace many reincarnations. This is certainly the most original. I loved it.
I really felt sorry for Heathcliff during the whole movie :( he was an orphan, everyone treated him like trash, and the only person that showed him kindness really was Cathy. And the only time he smiled was when he saw her. I wish they could have ended up together 😭😭💔💔💔
Visually, this version of the movie is very beautiful. The casting for young Catherine and Heathcliff were very well done as well as older Heathcliff, however I did not like Catherine in this version, plus the lack of dialogue and exclusion of a one of the most important pieces of the story- the next generation, was completely taken out. I felt like it was just a artsy rendition of the story without staying true to the depth and passion in it.
It's very strange the relationship people tend to have with films when they're adapted. I've never read Wuthering Heights (just never got around to it) but as a film I thought it was just incredible. And it is a film. It's not a book on screen, it's something new entirely and I don't think it really 'owes' anything to what it's based on. But that's just me.
As far as I know, 'Wuthering Heights' has made a lot of movies. Among them, 1939, 1950, 1970, 1992, 2009, 2011, 2017 are used as representative. 1992 is famous for the movie which Julliette Binoche starred in our country. The posters are also beautiful, and the desolate landscape of the Yorkshire Moors, especially in the film reporter series, is often seen as the backdrop for the overwhelming cove. Among the many films I have noticed in 2017 is that if other films have made a film that focuses on the content of the novel, it seems that the film was made by the emotional writer of writer Emily Bronte . If there is a genius in the director, a black actress appears in the male protagonist Heathcliff. It seemed to be director directing to want to express pain of love so much in heart. Although the visual beauty is like a music video, it is a sensual representation of the desolate scenery as opposed to the unspoilt beauty of England's Yorkshire Moore. In the middle of the movie, I thought that the scene where the heroine falls on a black ridgeline is a sensuous production that is expressed with the heather that is burned and burned and burned because the soil is buried in the face. The story is longer. I watched your wonderful video. Thank you. 2019.01.09. South Korea Mr OH YUNSEOK 내가 알기로는 'Wuthering Heights'은 영화가 많이 만들어졌습니다. 그중에 대표적으로 1939, 1950, 1970, 1992, 2009, 2011, 2017을 들 수 이쓰는데 우리나라에서는 쥴리에트 비노쉬가 주연을 한 1992년 영화가 유명합니다. 포스터도 아름답고 특히 영화 헤리포터 시리즈에도 나오는 요크셔 무어의 황량한 풍경이 압도적 말함코브가 배경으로 자주 등장합니다. 수 많은 영화중에 제가 2017년 영화를 주목하는 이유는 다른 작품들은 소설의 내용을 충실(중심으로)하게 영화를 만들 었다면 이 영화는 작가 에밀리 브론테의 감성적인 즉 쓰는 사람의 입장에서 영화를 만든 듯 합니다. 감독이 얼마나 천재성이 있느냐면 남자 주인공 히스클리프로 흑인 배우가 등장합니다. 그만큼 사랑의 아픔을 절절한 심정에서 나타내고 싶은 감독의 연출이었던 것 같습니다. 영상미도 뮤직 비디오처럼 감각 적이기도 하지만 잉글랜드 요크셔 무어의 때묻지 않은 아름다운 자연과 반대로 황량하기 그지없는 풍경을 감각적으로 표현 했습니다. 영화 중간에 보면 여주인공이 넘어지는 장면이 검은 뻘 같은 곳에 넘어져 얼굴에 흙이 묻는 데 검게 말라비틀어져 불에 그을린 것 같은 히스와 함께 표현한 감각적인 연출이라고 생각 했습니다. 얘기가 길어 졌습니다. 당신의 멋진 영상 잘 보았습니다. 감사합니다. 2019.01.09. 대한민국서 오윤석
I come here once in a while to rewatch this magnificient video, it is incredibile, love it. WH is my favorite book and this movie is one of my favorite among the others... Really great job, thank you so much!
Many years passed from the time I saw and read this but the clip took me to old times... their love was so simple to feel yet to hard to reach. And the music it selve give me goosebumps. Thanks for recapturing the great story.
Arnold's version of Wuthering Heights is actually my favorite. I think the scenery, acting etc. etc. fits perfectly for what I imagined while reading the book.
i love this book so badly and that's probably why i don't like movies about it... no movie is enough. and actors doesn't fit... really... i can't watch movies based on this story. Cath and Heathcliff will always be my OTP. my madness and my pure love. this video is amazing, editing, scenes, music, how much i love this song? have no idea. this song is epic and it fits really great. amazing job!
I really didn't enjoy the film that much when I watched it, but you really captured the emotion of it all, your editing is super at usual :) Love the song choice
Lyrics Rip the earth in two with your mind Seal the urge which ensues with brass wires I never meant you any harm But your tears feel warm as they fall on my forearms But close my eyes for a while Force from the world a patient smile How can you say that your truth is better than ours? Shoulder to shoulder, now brother, we carry no arms The blind man sleeps in the doorway, his home If only I had an enemy bigger than my apathy I could have won But I gave you all I gave you all I gave you all Close my eyes for a while Force from the world a patient smile But I gave you all I gave you all I gave you all And you rip it from my hands And you swear it's all gone And you rip out all I had Just to say that you've won And you rip it from my hands And you swear it's all gone And you rip out all I had Just to say that you've won Well now you've won But I gave you all I gave you all I gave you all
Todavía está por hacer la adaptación definitiva y creíble de semejante historia. Lo primero encontrar al actor que represente a Heathcliff tan como lo ideó y describió Emily ; no era negro africano ni con ojos azules , era agitanado con ojos, pestañas y cejas negros, pero no africano. Las escenas esenciales..los textos tan maravillosos y emotivos, por favor que sean exactos....La verdad es que entre el libro que he leído cien veces y en todas las traducciones a español y las versiones cinematográficas...no me emocionan ninguna con la novela...sigo esperando esa fiel adaptación.
Foi valida essa pegada do Heathcliff negro, porém as pessoas confundiram qdo a autora se referiu a pele escura. No ver da autora ele era moreno e não negro. Naquela época a maioria das pessoas eram muito brancas, e Heathcliff era escuro perto delas, pele morena, não negro.
It's really gorgeous sweetie!!! Perfect vid, plus my amazing M&S! I never finished the film, I got bored at a moment, but your vid really makes me want to finish it!!! There's a real beauty in this film, and you really knew how to depict it. That's you! You just know how to depict beauty! And there are not very numerous vidders who know how to do that. You are part of those vidders who really inspire me. That's what I want to do, show the beauty in my vids! That's what you always do!
Yeah you're completely right in that noone has yet managed to capture the novel... I think maybe it will always be impossible. Some novels are meant to stay as novels! :P This being one of them. I think the emotion and beautiful dialogue and what is maybe unspoken is too difficult to express visually. Aw well. Haha I don't think this film appeals to literary types at all either! I do English Lit at degree level and some novels are best left alone. :)
Hey yeah, it's interesting that you say it's not your fave version of WH - it's not mine either!! Honestly, I was disappointed really when I bought the DVD :/ I agree though that they captured the more brutal element of their relationship but I was left slightly hanging at the end. Ive read the book and for me this film needed more words, cause the most vital part is speech. Cathy saying "I am Heathcliff" he represents the eternal rocks beneath blah blah. :P It was cut out! But great video :)
I agree with the brutal part; I think the film gave the message of "they hate each other but they still hang out" but the book conveys total friendship for me, with the odd argument and all that jazz. Cathy was too abusive and yeah, there was a total lack of speech. And there was no resolution for Hareton and Cathy, and there was no Linton whatsoever. I ADORE this video but not the film. Wuthering Heights is my favourite book (currently rereading it for the third time) and I was disapointed :{
Did she love him when he returned? It was apparent that heathcliff didn't forget her, but I got the feeling that she liked him because he reminded her of a love they once had. I didn't get that she loved him anymore.
THIS film has not been remade ... it's a new version! However, producers have free will to do as they wish with a classic such as this. You seem to have a major problem with that. It'd be nice to have fans of WH enjoy its discussion without having foul and illiterate imbeciles such as you changing the atmosphere! Now I hope the stench has cleared, never to return!
Wuthering heights is my favorite love story(though it's much more complex than that). But the movie sucks. Starting with the cast. Heathcliff is evil, life made him like that-the only good thing about him are his feelings for Cathy,and she marries someone else. Both of the actors,portraying Heathcliff here exude innocense of angels. To get close to the idea of the raging passions that is Heathcliff,they need to show us these poor people murdering and molesting animals! I can not accept that,I'm sorry. And,really,they cut off a lot of very important literature content,a lot of what makes Wuthering Heights so great. I have watched almost every movie adaptation. Ralph Feins and Juliette Binoche can not be surpassed.
![The Enemy - Mumford & Sons from "Wuthering Heights" 2011 [1080p]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zJH12E6QhY4/mqdefault.jpg)
''Be with me always-take any form-drive me mad! only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! Oh, God! it is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!"
Katrina Doromal 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
So beautiful! I love that book.
Very well done. This 2011 Wuthering Heights is very different than the others. It captures the visceral sounds, textures and raw emotions of the times of the novel. I am a fan of the book, all the versions of W. Heights on film, the music of Kate Bush and now this movie. It's a good enough story to embrace many reincarnations. This is certainly the most original. I loved it.
I really felt sorry for Heathcliff during the whole movie :( he was an orphan, everyone treated him like trash, and the only person that showed him kindness really was Cathy. And the only time he smiled was when he saw her. I wish they could have ended up together 😭😭💔💔💔
this whole thing here is perfect.
the book, first of all.
this movie, this song, the video.
their love.
thank you for that. great job.
A fabulous adaptation - the scenery is so impressive, and acting superb.
This Movie is just amazing. Wuthering Heights is my favourite book of all time
My favorite adaptation of one of my favorite books. Love it.
Visually, this version of the movie is very beautiful. The casting for young Catherine and Heathcliff were very well done as well as older Heathcliff, however I did not like Catherine in this version, plus the lack of dialogue and exclusion of a one of the most important pieces of the story- the next generation, was completely taken out. I felt like it was just a artsy rendition of the story without staying true to the depth and passion in it.
wooaah... your videos are amazing. so simple, no need for big effects.. just a great song and well thought out scene selection. absolutely gorgeous.
It's very strange the relationship people tend to have with films when they're adapted. I've never read Wuthering Heights (just never got around to it) but as a film I thought it was just incredible. And it is a film. It's not a book on screen, it's something new entirely and I don't think it really 'owes' anything to what it's based on. But that's just me.
As far as I know, 'Wuthering Heights' has made a lot of movies. Among them, 1939, 1950, 1970, 1992, 2009, 2011, 2017 are used as representative. 1992 is famous for the movie which Julliette Binoche starred in our country.
The posters are also beautiful, and the desolate landscape of the Yorkshire Moors, especially in the film reporter series, is often seen as the backdrop for the overwhelming cove.
Among the many films I have noticed in 2017 is that if other films have made a film that focuses on the content of the novel, it seems that the film was made by the emotional writer of writer Emily Bronte . If there is a genius in the director, a black actress appears in the male protagonist Heathcliff. It seemed to be director directing to want to express pain of love so much in heart. Although the visual beauty is like a music video, it is a sensual representation of the desolate scenery as opposed to the unspoilt beauty of England's Yorkshire Moore.
In the middle of the movie, I thought that the scene where the heroine falls on a black ridgeline is a sensuous production that is expressed with the heather that is burned and burned and burned because the soil is buried in the face.
The story is longer.
I watched your wonderful video.
Thank you.
2019.01.09.
South Korea Mr OH YUNSEOK
내가 알기로는 'Wuthering Heights'은 영화가 많이 만들어졌습니다. 그중에 대표적으로 1939, 1950, 1970, 1992, 2009, 2011, 2017을 들 수 이쓰는데 우리나라에서는 쥴리에트 비노쉬가 주연을 한 1992년 영화가 유명합니다.
포스터도 아름답고 특히 영화 헤리포터 시리즈에도 나오는 요크셔 무어의 황량한 풍경이 압도적 말함코브가 배경으로 자주 등장합니다.
수 많은 영화중에 제가 2017년 영화를 주목하는 이유는 다른 작품들은 소설의 내용을 충실(중심으로)하게 영화를 만들 었다면 이 영화는 작가 에밀리 브론테의 감성적인 즉 쓰는 사람의 입장에서 영화를 만든 듯 합니다. 감독이 얼마나 천재성이 있느냐면 남자 주인공 히스클리프로 흑인 배우가 등장합니다. 그만큼 사랑의 아픔을 절절한 심정에서 나타내고 싶은 감독의 연출이었던 것 같습니다. 영상미도 뮤직 비디오처럼 감각 적이기도 하지만 잉글랜드 요크셔 무어의 때묻지 않은 아름다운 자연과 반대로 황량하기 그지없는 풍경을 감각적으로 표현 했습니다.
영화 중간에 보면 여주인공이 넘어지는 장면이 검은 뻘 같은 곳에 넘어져 얼굴에 흙이 묻는 데 검게 말라비틀어져 불에 그을린 것 같은 히스와 함께 표현한 감각적인 연출이라고 생각 했습니다.
얘기가 길어 졌습니다.
당신의 멋진 영상 잘 보았습니다.
감사합니다.
2019.01.09.
대한민국서 오윤석
"You Broke my Heart, you killed me."
I come here once in a while to rewatch this magnificient video, it is incredibile, love it. WH is my favorite book and this movie is one of my favorite among the others... Really great job, thank you so much!
Many years passed from the time I saw and read this but the clip took me to old times... their love was so simple to feel yet to hard to reach. And the music it selve give me goosebumps. Thanks for recapturing the great story.
UGH I FINALLY CAN WATCH IT AND COMMENT
Arnold's version of Wuthering Heights is actually my favorite. I think the scenery, acting etc. etc. fits perfectly for what I imagined while reading the book.
i love this book so badly and that's probably why i don't like movies about it... no movie is enough. and actors doesn't fit... really... i can't watch movies based on this story. Cath and Heathcliff will always be my OTP. my madness and my pure love. this video is amazing, editing, scenes, music, how much i love this song? have no idea. this song is epic and it fits really great. amazing job!
woooow!!!! Amazing!!!
I agree with you! this movie it's not my favourite version of WH, but I think that it captures the true spirit of the novel
I really didn't enjoy the film that much when I watched it, but you really captured the emotion of it all, your editing is super at usual :) Love the song choice
Lyrics
Rip the earth in two with your mind
Seal the urge which ensues with brass wires
I never meant you any harm
But your tears feel warm as they fall on my forearms
But close my eyes for a while
Force from the world a patient smile
How can you say that your truth is better than ours?
Shoulder to shoulder, now brother, we carry no arms
The blind man sleeps in the doorway, his home
If only I had an enemy bigger than my apathy I could have won
But I gave you all
I gave you all
I gave you all
Close my eyes for a while
Force from the world a patient smile
But I gave you all
I gave you all
I gave you all
And you rip it from my hands
And you swear it's all gone
And you rip out all I had
Just to say that you've won
And you rip it from my hands
And you swear it's all gone
And you rip out all I had
Just to say that you've won
Well now you've won
But I gave you all
I gave you all
I gave you all
Moc
Beautiful combination of imagery and song. Beautifully done!
this song made me cry
Todavía está por hacer la adaptación definitiva y creíble de semejante historia. Lo primero encontrar al actor que represente a Heathcliff tan como lo ideó y describió Emily ; no era negro africano ni con ojos azules , era agitanado con ojos, pestañas y cejas negros, pero no africano.
Las escenas esenciales..los textos tan maravillosos y emotivos, por favor que sean exactos....La verdad es que entre el libro que he leído cien veces y en todas las traducciones a español y las versiones cinematográficas...no me emocionan ninguna con la novela...sigo esperando esa fiel adaptación.
Wow! This video is perfect! I have to watch the film!
Beautiful pictures 💕
a really flawless and natural video!
Foi valida essa pegada do Heathcliff negro, porém as pessoas confundiram qdo a autora se referiu a pele escura. No ver da autora ele era moreno e não negro. Naquela época a maioria das pessoas eram muito brancas, e Heathcliff era escuro perto delas, pele morena, não negro.
It's really gorgeous sweetie!!! Perfect vid, plus my amazing M&S! I never finished the film, I got bored at a moment, but your vid really makes me want to finish it!!! There's a real beauty in this film, and you really knew how to depict it. That's you! You just know how to depict beauty! And there are not very numerous vidders who know how to do that. You are part of those vidders who really inspire me. That's what I want to do, show the beauty in my vids! That's what you always do!
Yeah you're completely right in that noone has yet managed to capture the novel... I think maybe it will always be impossible. Some novels are meant to stay as novels! :P This being one of them. I think the emotion and beautiful dialogue and what is maybe unspoken is too difficult to express visually. Aw well. Haha I don't think this film appeals to literary types at all either! I do English Lit at degree level and some novels are best left alone. :)
Amazing.
This video carry the real pain of wuthering height
love it great job !!! :) cant wait to watch this
Hey yeah, it's interesting that you say it's not your fave version of WH - it's not mine either!! Honestly, I was disappointed really when I bought the DVD :/ I agree though that they captured the more brutal element of their relationship but I was left slightly hanging at the end. Ive read the book and for me this film needed more words, cause the most vital part is speech. Cathy saying "I am Heathcliff" he represents the eternal rocks beneath blah blah. :P It was cut out! But great video :)
Beautiful, simply beautiful :)
I'm addicted to this video and I haven't even watched the movie yet! (I knew that Kaya Scodelario was agreat actrees ♥)
alguien sabe quien canta
THIS IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL VIDEO ABOOUT WH EVER.
Yeah you're completely right :) the 'friendship' in the book is devastating, it's so powerful!! The film however did not do it justice :(
Aun no he visto la película, pero no he podido ver esta preciosidad y... Pffff, te adoro
Sientente orgullosa de esas manos que tienes.
I agree with the brutal part; I think the film gave the message of "they hate each other but they still hang out" but the book conveys total friendship for me, with the odd argument and all that jazz. Cathy was too abusive and yeah, there was a total lack of speech. And there was no resolution for Hareton and Cathy, and there was no Linton whatsoever. I ADORE this video but not the film. Wuthering Heights is my favourite book (currently rereading it for the third time) and I was disapointed :{
I love your video and choice of cuts but why the filter? The photography needs no adorning and you editing is perfect!
Un día de estos vas a matarme
Joder,eres maravillosa.
Great work! What's your favourite version?
Did she love him when he returned? It was apparent that heathcliff didn't forget her, but I got the feeling that she liked him because he reminded her of a love they once had. I didn't get that she loved him anymore.
James Heller yes she still loved him
she always loved him
Que estilazo,que estilazo.
Larry 4 ever 🤷🏻♀️
how many times are they going to remake this fucking film
it has be remake 13 times
THIS film has not been remade ... it's a new version! However, producers have free will to do as they wish with a classic such as this. You seem to have a major problem with that. It'd be nice to have fans of WH enjoy its discussion without having foul and illiterate imbeciles such as you changing the atmosphere! Now I hope the stench has cleared, never to return!
Es tan tan artistico
if only I had an enemy bigger than my apathy, I could hve won
deep words 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Wonderful !!
michà
please give me the full movie link
Tanto,tanto.DIOS Rebeca
thats effy
que nheca! pode parar....a única versão que presta é a de 1992 ...o resto é resto
Piękne ..
Siempre me dejas muerta ;')
No creo en ángeles, pero ella a de ser uno de ellos
Wuthering heights is my favorite love story(though it's much more complex than that). But the movie sucks. Starting with the cast. Heathcliff is evil, life made him like that-the only good thing about him are his feelings for Cathy,and she marries someone else. Both of the actors,portraying Heathcliff here exude innocense of angels. To get close to the idea of the raging passions that is Heathcliff,they need to show us these poor people murdering and molesting animals! I can not accept that,I'm sorry. And,really,they cut off a lot of very important literature content,a lot of what makes Wuthering Heights so great. I have watched almost every movie adaptation. Ralph Feins and Juliette Binoche can not be surpassed.
3:53
Very disappointed. BORING!!!!!!!!