I was an atheist but then "The Indian Seculars" made me a #Hindu. I was a Hindu but then "The Indian MSM (mainstream media a.k.a. #PRESStitute) made me a Communal Right Winger.
Respected Ramesh Jaura, You have not moved on from Nehru time. You are seeing thing with old perspective and not seeing with new modern world. It seems other respected former German ambassador knows more about current Indian affairs.You also have missed to mentioned how Congress has developed mechanism where people becomes more poor and corruption thrives.
@WAR MONGER stole?? Knowledge is not a commodity to sell or buy or steal. It's a gift. They are making the best use of Sanskrit. What's wrong with that? Our people don't acknowledge such a language
@@vonkleist4068 they are not making best out of it. They just stealing the things mentioned in vedas and naming them as they discovered these stuff . Thats stealing for sure. U have to take permission before using someone religious texts
vsuperstar69 your opinion is correct but they choose to ignore this on every possible way because of the fever of hidden potential that can topple the top
@Ruemann because britain silently took control over india and looted everything and everything europe and britain has is made up by resources stolen by india and jewels. Fckin looters nomads. Imagine if indians still have that resources and money they would have invented a lot more than britishers just like how indian ancestors invented a lot in past.
Shree Modiji don't like Interviews, bacause some reporters are not fair and its obvious why the hell he shoukd waste his time?. IF THE POOREST OF THE POOR have trusted him and voted him to this post of PM.The world knows how honest and noble he is?. This reporter needs an interview to know him better.
unlike congress modi dont have to feed his family with corrupt money and i m frm gujarat and i can say that modi really means the good of our country and for now i must say he has created a good face of our country in the world and i really believe he is doing much better than congress maybe the result is not as good as he promised but better he is always gonna be better than now corrupted and always family branching congress
I feel Germans is having good opinion on India.. Salute to Germans and Indian Journalist should be come out of Nehru and Congress time.. Our country has changed now
Mr Ramesh Jaura should really catch up with what exactly is happening in india.. and would request him to come out 1950s-60s. The other fellow Mr. Thomas has much more relevant points to speak.
India is in a much better shape and sharing the positive sentiment with inclusive development for all without any discrimination after PM MODI has come to the fore and is going to be a huge success in Delhi as he was in Gujrat.
Ha HA ...Where the hell Church was attacked? Later media felled on face when it was discovered that it was a robbery (Theft) in Church in Delhi which had nothing to do with religion and no one was harmed.
@@achalkhare3962 your so funny lol. Modi got 7 years and did he do his promises ? Congress is of course a corruption factory but blaming Congress for everything is funny
I do not think India is in the race of Superpower. Instead, shall we call India a Soft power, a Champion for peace and harmony in the world. It is a spiritual land, which laid foundation for human civilization on the Globe. Its hardest efforts for economic growth is meant for feeding the millions of poverty stricken society. Modi's mantra is mainly for improvement/development of the poor Indians. India should not be in Super power race.
s.dilipkumar Singh we are not . but if you compare to the world standard we are not far back either . we never entered the race now, we been on top for many years and it's history repeating itself
Superpower is a loaded word - India can achieve faster growth now at 7-8% compared to its traditional 2% under decades of Congress Party rule. The late Narasimha Rao was the only economic reformer in the Congress Party, and it's no coincidence that he's the most hated by that party today. The Congress Party exists to preserve the interests of the Nehru-Gandhi family and its pyramid of cronyism. Economic reformers like Narendra Modi have their work cut out for them, but there's an increased optimism that he can make headway in loosening India's knot and breaking the logjam.
India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined. We can make the same technology you have 10 times cheaper with same sustainability and efficiency. we just need the resources and right funding.
+Saral Thakur that's just a logical fallacy, most of those "indian" engineers are educated and trained in the west. ie if Somalia were to be given the same education system as US or UK they will also provide their proportion of engineers. also I doubt your claim that 80% of engineers in the world are indian.
obsidianstatue HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA..you must have never heard of IITs and NITs. JEE is world's toughest entrance exam happens in india,you won't even make the cut. you still think india is 3rd world country,then visit india 1st. it's like saying America is just a country of criminals because they have the highest crime rate,lower in population than india but higher crime rate. lmfao.
+Saral Thakur you said and I quote "India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined." I said and I quote " I doubt your claim that 80% of engineers in the world are indian" seems like the call center idiot can't read or write, how typical. also the toughness of exams are not a measurement for quality of education it simply means the lack of education resources in india, compounded with the effect of a huge population thus creating a very competitive yet lacking education system. perhaps you should address the fact that only 74% of indians are literate, then maybe boast about your imagined "figure of 80% of the world's engineers are indians."
obsidianstatue Dumb ass i said double of UK and USA combined. America can barely run without chinese or indians guys around. And did you even take science as a subject? how do you know anything about resources in india? IIT delhi students created a supercomputer,how much resource do you want? problem is you guys are jealous simple as that. I bet you can't even play with lego bricks properly. and if you think you are tough try to solve at least 1 sum of that paper.
+Saral Thakur here's what you said "India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined." maybe you can't read your own comment, but you said and I here explain "80% of the world's engineers are indian," or "indians makes up 80% of the world's engineers" or "india provides 80% of the world's engineers" whatever the case they are all lies =) btw last time I checked india has no top 10 supercomputers, they are either in China japan USA Germany or Switzerland. =) yet another lie. again maybe you should address the fact that only 74% of indians can read =) the world average in literacy rate is 84%, so in that regard india is closer being a 3rd world hole in the ground than a "80% world's engineers are indian" type of country =) another fun fact according to the United Nations there are 646 million indians who defecate in the open daily, apparently you dont have enough engineers to build enough toilets LOL
I must say a very realistic and unbiased presentation of Modi and India. It is heartening to note world powers are taking India in right constructive domain. They are convinced of rising strength of India economically and improvement in living conditions of poor, rising urbanization, great business co-operation.
@6:07 He says - 'Prime Minister of Gujrat'. He was the Chief Minister of Gujrat, not the PM. In the federation of India, the HOG of the country is the PM and the HOG of various states is the CM.
Pandit Nehru gave opposition lot of time to talk in the parliament - has nothing to do with progress of the country and the wrong policies that were taken by his government - to name a few was the admission of India to UN as a permanent one - to not unite Kashmir with India - to not do proper diplomacy with China and to allow partition of India instead of using force to stop it - that is what is the real mistakes which India is stilll paying for even today - but with Modi we feel confident to over come most of it !
***** Hey..that was nice of you to reply..you have covered a lot of ground and I am not quite up to it to understand/grasp it all...I must look into the M17 haplogroup and then Max Muller and into German culture...anyways,you gave me a lot to chew over thanks a TON!!!:):)
Since 22nd May 2014, I am troubled with many questions very frequently and took interest in watching at our country's polatical Issue videos. Unfortunately no Indian journalists project the issue to solve the questions raising up in my mind. After viewing this video, I am some what satisfied that our Prime Minister is very well aware of things reflecting in my mind and has got some approach to them. This is a good and informative video and the intellectuals participating in the discussions are very efficiently touching every point of what India is? What it wants and what it can provide other countries? Worth sharing for the information of fellow Indian citizens for their information.
Why this talk about being a superpower? Let India first become a nation that can take care of its citizens, give them good education, jobs, have a fair police system and judiciary. Rest will follow.
+Sridhar Kaushik I think the main motive is that how india will perform under modi? AND also to compare it to other countries like China,Usa,Russia etc
Best way for indian to be super power to shake hands with Europe and Germany. Modi indeed a smart and knowledgeable leader proud to be Hindu and indian.
+sachin kunder Why India would shake hand with Europe?As Indian economy is much better than those of Europe.But there is some about infrastructure and little about Defence.Otherwise India is doing good and should shake hand with Asian countries rather than European countries.
India is slowly becoming superpower , But In that sense India should be fully Develop in Technology , Force Initiative , Human Force , Quality, rich Labour, poverty eradication
Mr. Ramesh really is old for this discussion in terms of his knowledge about India to come out 1950s and 60s. Mr. Thomas is more wise and knowledgeable.
Most people see India by the eyes of orientalism ,and by the lenses of western media , can't you see , on the macro level India is having so much changes , the problem is also with our media , it doesn't show new accomplishmentsof our counyry , in the next 2 decades , you will also see the change on micro levels
THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
I really really enjoyed this talk show, however as most of them have pointed out very well two Germans knew more about India than our own fella... However he made one very good point about India is that - It never wanted to be a Super-Power. Else we would have also repeated history by another Hiroshima Nagasaki incident. I am really pleased n very happy to see finally India being on the right track and the whole world is witnessing it. Kudos to our Modiji for changing the picture n impression
This level of journalism is way better than what is in India right now, shout out to these guys to go facts and beyond. About the attacks on churches, it only happened at a very minor scale but yes it happened and it is in our concerns. The attacks were not primarily a conflict between two religions, it was more of a individual hatred. The attacks happened in the less enlightened parts of the country but with the passing time, religious minorities in India are feeling safer and safer. Slowly with the young generation going more secular and secular, the religious extremists will fade away. A lovely discussion. Thanks for this
I request Mr Ramesh Jaura to visit India once a while, please sir visit here once a while, its really nice completely new set of people..... no jhinna no nehru only little bit trace of that dynasty is left which they themselves are adamant on wipeing out via some really special personalities like rahul... visit soon ...
A real and natural discussion. Almost everything addressed correctly. This is how a discussion should be carried out within our country by the intellectuals and by the politicians. If we could do this and follow the outcomes , we can solve all our problems and differences ultimately become a superpower. Superpower doesn't mean to have thousands of nukes but to be capable enough to protect the country from any external or internal threats, superpower means a super economy, super society, super education system, super infrastructures, advanced and modern technologies, best life style, maintaining diversity, in rich culture and and harmony.
I would like these able gentlemen to have another discussion specifically on PM Mr. Modi's prowess regarding coping with the issue of "minority community" now that Germany has tasted this ale in terms of huge no. of refugees pouring in their homeland. Please take the voices on ground zero while addressing the issue.
Any Indian leader who expects great things for India needs a different vision towards the future of India. The main task for any new leader who expects to make India a superpower has to realize that the task lies in transforming the personality of India into a totally presentable one to the modern world not only superficially but in a deeper sense. The leaders have to teach Indians how to be efficient, disciplined, no-nonsense, with proper priorities, with a proper sense of proportion, professional, keep the environment clean, with a quality for the Indian population equal to any country in the world. When you change the people, economic progress will happen by itself. At the moment 50 % of the population is either walking around doing nothing or using only half of their time properly. Gov't offices are half empty. Public industries are all at a loss. It's chaos everywhere. All these things have to change. So the main task for the leader is to change the people and the set Indian ways. Once you change the people all the other changes will come by itself.
India is set to become a superpower by 2016, many cities such as 1Thiruvanathapuram 2Kollam 3Kochi 4Honnavar 5Panjim 6Mumbai 7Chennai 8Visakhapatnam And more that would take too long to list, are all currently under plans to scrap poor infrastructure and replace it with modern 21st century infrastructure, roads, apartments, and even suburban houses. Theres a lot plans for better agricultural methods, to feed people much cheaper and lift "people" out of poverty. 369 its gonna happen soon
The most intelectual and well managed debate i have come across in the recent times...this includes the western and the indian media...touched upon both sides of the story and still remained relevant and optimistic....you have to be optimistic about the present situation...there no way out
There are Indians in Germany, but they are often reluctant to learn more than English as they regard German as an unnecessary burden. This makes it unlikely that Indians will develop deep roots in Germany, necessary for more success and migration. Germany offers international English speaking workspaces and Hindi speaking specialized grocery shops. The situation is changing to a degree by integrating the German language into Bollywood cinema, which has far reaching positive effects for Germany, because of the global cultural importance of Indian cinema far beyond its borders. Cultural affinity is necessary to extremely helpful for language learning success and is acquired by the voluntary leisure time consumption of cultural products. Despite the increased economic potential, the money is usually not sufficient to motivate enough for the long journey of learning any new language. In the video you can hear very strong German accents which are a strong sign that these speakers learned English at a German school and utilized it occassionally for their work. But they never immersed themselves much into spoken English cultures, leaving their strong German accents intact. The Indian participant in the discussion makes very good contributions. The former German ambassador to India hasn't researched Indian history well. India was the second country in the world that industrialized after Great Britain and contributed a significant number of British ships during the Napoleonic wars. India industrialized decades earlier than Germany, which was a latecomer in Europe. India is the first country that was forcibly deindustrialized by the British Raj that prior gave them the know-how and structures for their early industrialization. Ghandi explicitly attacked these de-industrialization policies of the British Raj with his non-violent disobediance.
In order to develop good, Modern technologies has to be integrated into culture constructively .and donot breakdown the cultural backbone .hope IT space automation revolution help not only corporates but ordinary too.
Well, Very common issues like poverty, education, healthcare, industrialization, etc. must be dealt with in a high pace! And "Superpower" as called by "peoples" will be automatically entitled!
We indians, don't want to super power. Taking care about agricuture and respecting farmers will change super power. Our backbone agriculture is totally gone now. All pescticides, also farmers doesn't have food not govt will take care much actoions to protect the farmers. Modi govt has to be focused on Agricutlure, we need technolgy to improve the county , but food is necessary to live. Lot of indians are having obesity, diabties, bloodpressure, cholestrol etc.. These all we got a punishment for changed a nature.
Does these Indian and German gentlemen know that in Indian Schools German language is given as an Optional language for the Kids to learn and majority of them opt to learn german language , Do they know that the courses in German language institute run by the german government are always fully booked till next two sessions .
The German- ex ambassador in India is 100% correct. India needs good infrastructure, roads, airports, communication, education system which does not only gives degrees but degrees with good practical knowledge, good & clean electricity, good source & distribution of clean water, including modern FARMING, etc & India needs help & expertise from all it's well wishers, friends, countries who believe in democracy & also who does not believe in democracy because they also have certain contribution to make towards India's growth. Germany is one of that country with huge technical knowledge & expertise of almost everything that India needs. And MODI is the person who can do it- because he is 100% HONEST, & he wants India to progress, The two most obstruction in the process are-- RELIGIOUS BIGOTRY< & caste system. made worse by Pakistan & few other xenophobic countries. But both these problems are being tackled in a positive way by MODI & his ministry. Naxals are not a problem as some of your members suggests, naxals are on way out. & there is no violent nationalism in India, Modi & all the govt's in India were or are NOT violent. INDIANS of any religion are not violent & they do not believe in violence. These voices are raised by some orthodox religious groups , CHRISTIANS, MUSLIMS, SOME HINDUS. this is everywhere in the world including the so called developed countries. India has now a leader who wants India to progress democratically & i would like to call upon the democratic world to come forward & join with its progress towards a better world. May I say that I am not an YES MAN.
India and Germany together can help each other at economical level in the first place. As said by the Ambassador, Indian young force need to be trained in vocational skills and hence decent industrialization can happen to employ, increase GDP and lift lower middle class out of penury. India can develop models that of Poland, Germany et all from 10th std onwards to develop industrial skills in partnership with Germany. Also as part of JV, German Companies like Bentz etc., can open their design subsidiaries to develop Indian engineers in high level skill training. Germany has invested in Phillippines but not in India. Modiji using his foreign policy can influence such important industrial breakthrough for India's future. Likewise India can help Germany with its huge soft power as it looks Germany is not digitized completely to support it's economic powerhouse. Cultural exchanges will also sentizise the Indian diaspora there. Learning German language and Indian languages can also help in future for political understanding. Also student exchange programs in builing world class automobiles which India is also good at but never in the same league of Germany. Nuclear policy is one area to look at. Developing clean energy is a huge challenge for India and Germany can help in transferring the technology for solar panels, reactors, heavy water production etc., Also how to improve technological inventions. Germany can help to build world class innovation centres in India to develop indigenous technology by Indian technocrats in India itself.
Same old Anti-Hindu tirade. I thought Germans were educated and well informed. It seems they are motivated by their Christain organisations. That is where they get their info from. Even Hindus are ill informed about their culture and history. Looks like Modi has huge task. He will need all help we can give .
Indeed Modi is a remarkable personality. Matter of concern is when talent is retained and engaged in India. Addressing the ground level issue's pertaining to fundamental equal human rights, reformation in policies, standards and regulatories, infra development, importance in reinstating citizenship, more transparency and connect with people, vis-a-vis includes pre/post retirees well planned scenario, having proper databank of individuals and corporations, technology adoption alike some of the advanced countries, judicials to justify it's role. Reinstating Hinduism culture, tradition and heritage, normalising anti-nationalists. Capping required to be imposed on wealth, capital, income, expenditure, property, product pricing, etc. Huge gap between Govt & Non-Govt issue's. Ethnic issue's is another serious matter. The interacted deliverance in this discussion is u ique of it's kind which covers many aspect of concerns.
if India grows at 10% a year (now it is growing at 8%) India will have $62.47 trillion in next 22 years while China will have only $47 trillion after 22 years if it grows at current pace. there is a reason why people across the globe are optimistic about Inda
Togepi 1972 Chinese are going to.be there as long as we are there and that has been the case in all history. when India fall into Britain and China fall too . when china fall to Mongolia, India too conquered by Khan's . it's time to stop comparing and start accepting
I was an atheist but then "The Indian Seculars" made me a #Hindu.
I was a Hindu but then "The Indian MSM (mainstream media a.k.a. #PRESStitute) made me a Communal Right Winger.
Same here
Same here bro.
Congress designed education made us ashamed of our own Culture. Let's be proud of Bharat . Jai Hind.
Me too
Congratulations.....
Respected Ramesh Jaura, You have not moved on from Nehru time. You are seeing thing with old perspective and not seeing with new modern world. It seems other respected former German ambassador knows more about current Indian affairs.You also have missed to mentioned how Congress has developed mechanism where people becomes more poor and corruption thrives.
He is an Urban Naxal
He was a disappointment in this panel.
The irony is the Germans know India better than the Indian sitting there.
That's why everyone respects and admires Germany. Matter of fact.
Mandar Bhatodkar proud of Modiji.
they're expert dude, wth
@WAR MONGER stole?? Knowledge is not a commodity to sell or buy or steal. It's a gift. They are making the best use of Sanskrit. What's wrong with that? Our people don't acknowledge such a language
@@vonkleist4068 they are not making best out of it.
They just stealing the things mentioned in vedas and naming them as they discovered these stuff .
Thats stealing for sure.
U have to take permission before using someone religious texts
India is secular because of Hinduism
vsuperstar69 your opinion is correct but they choose to ignore this on every possible way because of the fever of hidden potential that can topple the top
Ruemann No, Actually Britain encouraged religious divide which led to bloody partition in which more than 1 million people died.
@Ruemann because britain silently took control over india and looted everything and everything europe and britain has is made up by resources stolen by india and jewels.
Fckin looters nomads.
Imagine if indians still have that resources and money they would have invented a lot more than britishers just like how indian ancestors invented a lot in past.
Agreed. And India becoming violent and majoritarian because of Hindutva.
What does that even mean!?
Shree Modiji don't like Interviews, bacause some reporters are not fair and its obvious why the hell he shoukd waste his time?. IF THE POOREST OF THE POOR have trusted him and voted him to this post of PM.The world knows how honest and noble he is?. This reporter needs an interview to know him better.
R u there?
That dude Ramesh should really get an update on India. The Germans know well about India than our own guy.
He is an Urban Naxal
Let's support Modi to make in India :-)
Krishna Rao i wanna know do u still support him?
Made in India ok
But not the one you mentioned
unlike congress modi dont have to feed his family with corrupt money and i m frm gujarat and i can say that modi really means the good of our country and for now i must say he has created a good face of our country in the world and i really believe he is doing much better than congress maybe the result is not as good as he promised but better he is always gonna be better than now corrupted and always family branching congress
mac zer 👍👍👍☝️
I agree but Modi has failed on economy and has created one of the biggest job losses in the history of the country
I feel Germans is having good opinion on India.. Salute to Germans and Indian Journalist should be come out of Nehru and Congress time.. Our country has changed now
Mr Ramesh Jaura should really catch up with what exactly is happening in india.. and would request him to come out 1950s-60s. The other fellow Mr. Thomas has much more relevant points to speak.
Sed life Lol 🤣🤣🤣
India is in a much better shape and sharing the positive sentiment with inclusive development for all without any discrimination after PM MODI has come to the fore and is going to be a huge success in Delhi as he was in Gujrat.
Ha HA ...Where the hell Church was attacked? Later media felled on face when it was discovered that it was a robbery (Theft) in Church in Delhi which had nothing to do with religion and no one was harmed.
I blame Congress for keeping India poor for so long. For running a country for the benefit of one family and not for the people of the country.
So now there is no poverty?
@@almond3963 That's what I'm saying. India is still poor bcz of the policies of Congress from 1947 to 1991.
@@achalkhare3962 your so funny lol. Modi got 7 years and did he do his promises ? Congress is of course a corruption factory but blaming Congress for everything is funny
I do not think India is in the race of Superpower. Instead, shall we call India a
Soft power, a Champion for peace and harmony in the world. It is a spiritual land, which laid foundation for human civilization on the Globe. Its hardest efforts for economic growth is meant for feeding the millions of poverty stricken society. Modi's mantra is mainly for improvement/development of the poor Indians. India should not be in Super power race.
s.dilipkumar Singh we are not . but if you compare to the world standard we are not far back either . we never entered the race now, we been on top for many years and it's history repeating itself
S.Dilip Kumar Singha soft power 😂😂😂😂 world listens to hard powers buddy soft power is nothing in today’s world , India is already super power now
@@sivasriram7588 Bollywood movies are popular in China
I hope our spirituality ends rapes in India.. done by mostly poor people.. who vent in this way!
Here in 2022... India growing @8%. With 100+ unicorns.. UPI.. Digital India.. Make in India.. And many more.
Superpower is a loaded word - India can achieve faster growth now at 7-8% compared to its traditional 2% under decades of Congress Party rule. The late Narasimha Rao was the only economic reformer in the Congress Party, and it's no coincidence that he's the most hated by that party today. The Congress Party exists to preserve the interests of the Nehru-Gandhi family and its pyramid of cronyism. Economic reformers like Narendra Modi have their work cut out for them, but there's an increased optimism that he can make headway in loosening India's knot and breaking the logjam.
India is a spiritual superpower since time immemorial
india was and is a super POOPER
India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined. We can make the same technology you have 10 times cheaper with same sustainability and efficiency. we just need the resources and right funding.
+Saral Thakur that's just a logical fallacy, most of those "indian" engineers are educated and trained in the west. ie if Somalia were to be given the same education system as US or UK they will also provide their proportion of engineers. also I doubt your claim that 80% of engineers in the world are indian.
obsidianstatue HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA..you must have never heard of IITs and NITs.
JEE is world's toughest entrance exam happens in india,you won't even make the cut.
you still think india is 3rd world country,then visit india 1st.
it's like saying America is just a country of criminals because they have the highest crime rate,lower in population than india but higher crime rate. lmfao.
+Saral Thakur you said and I quote "India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined."
I said and I quote " I doubt your claim that 80% of engineers in the world are indian"
seems like the call center idiot can't read or write, how typical.
also the toughness of exams are not a measurement for quality of education it simply means the lack of education resources in india, compounded with the effect of a huge population thus creating a very competitive yet lacking education system.
perhaps you should address the fact that only 74% of indians are literate, then maybe boast about your imagined "figure of 80% of the world's engineers are indians."
obsidianstatue
Dumb ass i said double of UK and USA combined.
America can barely run without chinese or indians guys around.
And did you even take science as a subject?
how do you know anything about resources in india? IIT delhi students created a supercomputer,how much resource do you want?
problem is you guys are jealous simple as that.
I bet you can't even play with lego bricks properly.
and if you think you are tough try to solve at least 1 sum of that paper.
+Saral Thakur here's what you said "India gives out 80% engineers to the world double of USA and UK combined."
maybe you can't read your own comment, but you said and I here explain "80% of the world's engineers are indian," or "indians makes up 80% of the world's engineers" or "india provides 80% of the world's engineers" whatever the case they are all lies =)
btw last time I checked india has no top 10 supercomputers, they are either in China japan USA Germany or Switzerland. =) yet another lie.
again maybe you should address the fact that only 74% of indians can read =) the world average in literacy rate is 84%, so in that regard india is closer being a 3rd world hole in the ground than a "80% world's engineers are indian" type of country =)
another fun fact according to the United Nations there are 646 million indians who defecate in the open daily, apparently you dont have enough engineers to build enough toilets LOL
2030 india will become superpower
As German investors they are very right with their concerns and their investment. Completely agree with speakers. Good debate....
I must say a very realistic and unbiased presentation of Modi and India. It is heartening to note world powers are taking India in right constructive domain. They are convinced of rising strength of India economically and improvement in living conditions of poor, rising urbanization, great business co-operation.
@6:07 He says - 'Prime Minister of Gujrat'. He was the Chief Minister of Gujrat, not the PM. In the federation of India, the HOG of the country is the PM and the HOG of various states is the CM.
Pandit Nehru gave opposition lot of time to talk in the parliament - has nothing to do with progress of the country and the wrong policies that were taken by his government - to name a few was the admission of India to UN as a permanent one - to not unite Kashmir with India - to not do proper diplomacy with China and to allow partition of India instead of using force to stop it - that is what is the real mistakes which India is stilll paying for even today - but with Modi we feel confident to over come most of it !
What about now ? 😂😂
India needs "thoroughness" the famed German "grundlich",,,,,,I just love the German efficiency!!!:):):)
***** Hey..that was nice of you to reply..you have covered a lot of ground and I am not quite up to it to understand/grasp it all...I must look into the M17 haplogroup and then Max Muller and into German culture...anyways,you gave me a lot to chew over thanks a TON!!!:):)
I want Modiji should reelected as PM of India in 2019 for next 5 years.
And It happened too
done
Yeh Dil mange more...till 2024
@@monalisadasgupta418 wo bhi milega
Are tension mat lo modi 2029 me bhi aayega
Since 22nd May 2014, I am troubled with many questions very frequently and took interest in watching at our country's polatical Issue videos. Unfortunately no Indian journalists project the issue to solve the questions raising up in my mind. After viewing this video, I am some what satisfied that our Prime Minister is very well aware of things reflecting in my mind and has got some approach to them. This is a good and informative video and the intellectuals participating in the discussions are very efficiently touching every point of what India is? What it wants and what it can provide other countries? Worth sharing for the information of fellow Indian citizens for their information.
ramesh's views are dancing around the stage whereas that ex ambassador is bang on target...just listen to him, ignore rest.
Proud to be indian
RAMESH jaura should reply to the question or shut his mouth
Why this talk about being a superpower?
Let India first become a nation that can take care of its citizens, give them good education, jobs, have a fair police system and judiciary. Rest will follow.
+Sridhar Kaushik I think the main motive is that how india will perform under modi?
AND also to compare it to other countries like China,Usa,Russia etc
Best way for indian to be super power to shake hands with Europe and Germany.
Modi indeed a smart and knowledgeable leader proud to be Hindu and indian.
+sachin kunder Why India would shake hand with Europe?As Indian economy is much better than those of Europe.But there is some about infrastructure and little about Defence.Otherwise India is doing good and should shake hand with Asian countries rather than European countries.
21:00 Thomas said it what India exactly doing it right now.....
India is India today not because of any religion, but because they wanted to live free. India was for freedom loving people.
does Mr. ramesh even know abt the present trends and scenario in india... what the he'll is he speaking??
kumar
+kumar yes,the german panelist seem to know more about india than him
+kumar Within first few mins, even i had the same doubt bro!!
He is an Urban Naxals
India is slowly becoming superpower , But In that sense India should be fully Develop in Technology , Force Initiative , Human Force , Quality, rich Labour, poverty eradication
India is superb. great industry,great technology great education and great infrastructure.happy now,Indian people ?
What is your problem with India.
very informative thx all
Who is here in 2020
gr8 discussion...
I forget, Confucianism is based on the wise leader and everything will fall into place.
Those two foreigners are more unbiased than the Indian guy
Christian Wanger's accent is surprisingly similar to an Indian Bengali's accent!
Mr. Ramesh really is old for this discussion in terms of his knowledge about India to come out 1950s and 60s. Mr. Thomas is more wise and knowledgeable.
yes it is a superpower now
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙂
India must aspire super prosperous rather than superpower
Most people see India by the eyes of orientalism ,and by the lenses of western media , can't you see , on the macro level India is having so much changes , the problem is also with our media , it doesn't show new accomplishmentsof our counyry , in the next 2 decades , you will also see the change on micro levels
We are in 2022 & Yes india 🇮🇳 is became a Global Superpower
THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
Bharat is not new superpower, its old superpower.
its true
I really really enjoyed this talk show, however as most of them have pointed out very well two Germans knew more about India than our own fella... However he made one very good point about India is that - It never wanted to be a Super-Power. Else we would have also repeated history by another Hiroshima Nagasaki incident.
I am really pleased n very happy to see finally India being on the right track and the whole world is witnessing it. Kudos to our Modiji for changing the picture n impression
Mukund Inamdar we should portray this to opposition.
India: The Future of "Returns on Investment" made.
Modi Is Best.....
all and all a pretty good discussion..just one negative..the RSS is not a militant organisation.(36.00)
Great talk.
No , not deep unemployment
But those problem has.. will be improved in future..
Hmm this is the most unbiased analysis by dw
Hope this kind of analysis can be done nowadays
I watched whole video... can't believe
Very good discussion.
yes....! long term. we will have to bear with this . It is of course an ancient unique Indian style.
This level of journalism is way better than what is in India right now, shout out to these guys to go facts and beyond. About the attacks on churches, it only happened at a very minor scale but yes it happened and it is in our concerns. The attacks were not primarily a conflict between two religions, it was more of a individual hatred. The attacks happened in the less enlightened parts of the country but with the passing time, religious minorities in India are feeling safer and safer. Slowly with the young generation going more secular and secular, the religious extremists will fade away. A lovely discussion. Thanks for this
I request Mr Ramesh Jaura to visit India once a while, please sir visit here once a while, its really nice completely new set of people..... no jhinna no nehru only little bit trace of that dynasty is left which they themselves are adamant on wipeing out via some really special personalities like rahul... visit soon ...
I respect German about practical knowledge and positive thinker.
Former German ambassador was right, India needs to utilise its young work forces & its soft power to further our economy and foreign relations.
conduct the same interview, with same panel after 10 yrs or now
will be interesting
Yes bro our India has become a big power in this world after modi
@@almond3963 really?????
@@julitamahanty5656 r u Indian?
@@almond3963 yes
Ich bin im Deutschland und sagt Heil Modi Heil Hindustan .
A real and natural discussion. Almost everything addressed correctly. This is how a discussion should be carried out within our country by the intellectuals and by the politicians. If we could do this and follow the outcomes , we can solve all our problems and differences ultimately become a superpower. Superpower doesn't mean to have thousands of nukes but to be capable enough to protect the country from any external or internal threats, superpower means a super economy, super society, super education system, super infrastructures, advanced and modern technologies, best life style, maintaining diversity, in rich culture and and harmony.
The children of Hitlers brownshirts are doing well in DW.
I would like these able gentlemen to have another discussion specifically on PM Mr. Modi's prowess regarding coping with the issue of "minority community" now that Germany has tasted this ale in terms of huge no. of refugees pouring in their homeland. Please take the voices on ground zero while addressing the issue.
Proud to be indian modi g is great
I am middle class indian I see the world view for our country not help India until and unless I self stand our feet thanks.
Any Indian leader who expects great things for India needs a different vision towards the future of India. The main task for any new leader who expects to make India a superpower has to realize that the task lies in transforming the personality of India into a totally presentable one to the modern world not only superficially but in a deeper sense. The leaders have to teach Indians how to be efficient, disciplined, no-nonsense, with proper priorities, with a proper sense of proportion, professional, keep the environment clean, with a quality for the Indian population equal to any country in the world. When you change the people, economic progress will happen by itself. At the moment 50 % of the population is either walking around doing nothing or using only half of their time properly. Gov't offices are half empty. Public industries are all at a loss. It's chaos everywhere. All these things have to change. So the main task for the leader is to change the people and the set Indian ways. Once you change the people all the other changes will come by itself.
India is secular and democratic until hindus are in majority,
Love India-Pak friendship...
What superpower ....
India is set to become a superpower by 2016, many cities such as
1Thiruvanathapuram
2Kollam
3Kochi
4Honnavar
5Panjim
6Mumbai
7Chennai
8Visakhapatnam
And more that would take too long to list, are all currently under plans to scrap poor infrastructure and replace it with modern 21st century infrastructure, roads, apartments, and even suburban houses.
Theres a lot plans for better agricultural methods, to feed people much cheaper and lift "people" out of poverty.
369 its gonna happen soon
Robit Destroyer We are in 2017. now
The most intelectual and well managed debate i have come across in the recent times...this includes the western and the indian media...touched upon both sides of the story and still remained relevant and optimistic....you have to be optimistic about the present situation...there no way out
OMG Christian Wagner
There are Indians in Germany, but they are often reluctant to learn more than English as they regard German as an unnecessary burden. This makes it unlikely that Indians will develop deep roots in Germany, necessary for more success and migration. Germany offers international English speaking workspaces and Hindi speaking specialized grocery shops. The situation is changing to a degree by integrating the German language into Bollywood cinema, which has far reaching positive effects for Germany, because of the global cultural importance of Indian cinema far beyond its borders. Cultural affinity is necessary to extremely helpful for language learning success and is acquired by the voluntary leisure time consumption of cultural products. Despite the increased economic potential, the money is usually not sufficient to motivate enough for the long journey of learning any new language.
In the video you can hear very strong German accents which are a strong sign that these speakers learned English at a German school and utilized it occassionally for their work. But they never immersed themselves much into spoken English cultures, leaving their strong German accents intact.
The Indian participant in the discussion makes very good contributions.
The former German ambassador to India hasn't researched Indian history well. India was the second country in the world that industrialized after Great Britain and contributed a significant number of British ships during the Napoleonic wars. India industrialized decades earlier than Germany, which was a latecomer in Europe. India is the first country that was forcibly deindustrialized by the British Raj that prior gave them the know-how and structures for their early industrialization. Ghandi explicitly attacked these de-industrialization policies of the British Raj with his non-violent disobediance.
We will make our mark in this world,
No super power & arms rave. India DESERVES a permanent seat in UN security council considering its share of world's population, economy and influence.
In my opinion, India's soft power is yoga, Buddhism and Curry.
our curry is very testyyiu are supose to taste it
michaltruthspeaker
u r absolutely right
India pak bangladesh indonesia all has same problem population.
If they can find a way to develop it will be great achievement
Fmr Germen Ambasoddor is excellect analyst...
Ramesh Jaura did not answered any question correctly. He answered something else.
In order to develop good, Modern technologies has to be integrated into culture constructively .and donot breakdown the cultural backbone .hope IT space automation revolution help not only corporates but ordinary too.
Dr. Shashi Tharoor you need to see this video !
Well, Very common issues like poverty, education, healthcare, industrialization, etc. must be dealt with in a high pace! And "Superpower" as called by "peoples" will be automatically entitled!
This aged well!!
We indians, don't want to super power. Taking care about agricuture and respecting farmers will change super power. Our backbone agriculture is totally gone now. All pescticides, also farmers doesn't have food not govt will take care much actoions to protect the farmers.
Modi govt has to be focused on Agricutlure, we need technolgy to improve the county , but food is necessary to live.
Lot of indians are having obesity, diabties, bloodpressure, cholestrol etc.. These all we got a punishment for changed a nature.
German Guys giving the correct answers , unfortunately the Indian guy seems to be from opposition talking about his olden days again and again
Does these Indian and German gentlemen know that in Indian Schools German language is given as an Optional language for the Kids to learn and majority of them opt to learn german language , Do they know that the courses in German language institute run by the german government are always fully booked till next two sessions .
The German- ex ambassador in India is 100% correct. India needs good infrastructure, roads, airports, communication, education system which does not only gives degrees but degrees with good practical knowledge, good & clean electricity, good source & distribution of clean water, including modern FARMING, etc & India needs help & expertise from all it's well wishers, friends, countries who believe in democracy & also who does not believe in democracy because they also have certain contribution to make towards India's growth. Germany is one of that country with huge technical knowledge & expertise of almost everything that India needs.
And MODI is the person who can do it- because he is 100% HONEST, & he wants India to progress, The two most obstruction in the process are-- RELIGIOUS BIGOTRY< & caste system. made worse by Pakistan & few other xenophobic countries.
But both these problems are being tackled in a positive way by MODI & his ministry.
Naxals are not a problem as some of your members suggests, naxals are on way out.
& there is no violent nationalism in India, Modi & all the govt's in India were or are NOT violent. INDIANS of any religion are not violent & they do not believe in violence.
These voices are raised by some orthodox religious groups , CHRISTIANS, MUSLIMS, SOME HINDUS. this is everywhere in the world including the so called developed countries.
India has now a leader who wants India to progress democratically & i would like to call upon the democratic world to come forward & join with its progress towards a better world.
May I say that I am not an YES MAN.
India and Germany together can help each other at economical level in the first place.
As said by the Ambassador, Indian young force need to be trained in vocational skills and hence decent industrialization can happen to employ, increase GDP and lift lower middle class out of penury.
India can develop models that of Poland, Germany et all from 10th std onwards to develop industrial skills in partnership with Germany.
Also as part of JV, German Companies like Bentz etc., can open their design subsidiaries to develop Indian engineers in high level skill training. Germany has invested in Phillippines but not in India.
Modiji using his foreign policy can influence such important industrial breakthrough for India's future.
Likewise India can help Germany with its huge soft power as it looks Germany is not digitized completely to support it's economic powerhouse. Cultural exchanges will also sentizise the Indian diaspora there. Learning German language and Indian languages can also help in future for political understanding.
Also student exchange programs in builing world class automobiles which India is also good at but never in the same league of Germany.
Nuclear policy is one area to look at. Developing clean energy is a huge challenge for India and Germany can help in transferring the technology for solar panels, reactors, heavy water production etc.,
Also how to improve technological inventions. Germany can help to build world class innovation centres in India to develop indigenous technology by Indian technocrats in India itself.
ohh we dont want superpower status ..simply we want a good aducation ,infrastructure ,mainly sanitation ....now we have enough weapons ...
I want them to talk about India or Modi right now....
Same old Anti-Hindu tirade. I thought Germans were educated and well informed. It seems they are motivated by their Christain organisations. That is where they get their info from. Even Hindus are ill informed about their culture and history. Looks like Modi has huge task. He will need all help we can give .
Indeed Modi is a remarkable personality. Matter of concern is when talent is retained and engaged in India. Addressing the ground level issue's pertaining to fundamental equal human rights, reformation in policies, standards and regulatories, infra development, importance in reinstating citizenship, more transparency and connect with people, vis-a-vis includes pre/post retirees well planned scenario, having proper databank of individuals and corporations, technology adoption alike some of the advanced countries, judicials to justify it's role. Reinstating Hinduism culture, tradition and heritage, normalising anti-nationalists. Capping required to be imposed on wealth, capital, income, expenditure, property, product pricing, etc. Huge gap between Govt & Non-Govt issue's. Ethnic issue's is another serious matter.
The interacted deliverance in this discussion is u ique of it's kind which covers many aspect of concerns.
India can be the superpower but not now. Maybe after 3 to 4 decades, India will be one of the major power in the world.
if India grows at 10% a year (now it is growing at 8%)
India will have $62.47 trillion in next 22 years while China will have only $47 trillion after 22 years if it grows at current pace.
there is a reason why people across the globe are optimistic about Inda
Haopeng Zhang yes but in 2150 there will be only 2 super powers. India and China.
Togepi 1972 Chinese are going to.be there as long as we are there and that has been the case in all history. when India fall into Britain and China fall too . when china fall to Mongolia, India too conquered by Khan's . it's time to stop comparing and start accepting
Bala T Subramanian hmm
Bala T Subramanian but India and China will be 1st and 2nd position depending on how it goes
Modi Chanakya of 2017
11:02 He said it to the point! no BS!
11:44 Yup