It’s not that crazy that they were 8th graders per sey. 8th graders are usually at the age of puberty. However the use of AI in this time of their life is definitely new and alarming!
8th grade was the most scandalous year of my childhood education. High school was tame in comparison. 8th grade is the last year that doesn't go on your college application transcript.
when I was in 8th grade all my class mates were perverts. even the girls. we had one girl that would go out in the hall and moon the entire class from the doorway while the teacher was looking the other way.
They need more homework then. Too much time on their hands and a lack of knowledge about hurting others. Had a kid that looked up p+rn in the library with his friends supposedly around that age when I was in middle school. They were like 3 ft away from the teacher and we were all in the library for a book report. Kids are crazy.
Certainly faked images have exited for a long time. Photo-shopping of course has been a thing for a long time. But especially in the last year AI has seen a lot of progression, making it a lot easier and faster to create convincing deepfakes. We're in the early phases of it now, but this is definitely going to be a fast-growing problem from here on out.
@@LebronCCP Not at all, AI "art" steals real artists work and DEEPFAKE technology is AI used to make real or even fake generated AI people appear to do things they've never done such as crime or corn. Taylor Swift recently had to sue because of deepfake ai making fake corn out of her. Also, many corn websites are being taken over by people who make corn using deepfake of real people from celebrities or real life people ESPECIALLY MINORS and it's a massive issue. We were warned a long time ago by techbros like zuckerburg and many others who aren't even on his status level that we need to be wary of AI and that it is NOT READY to be mainstream because there are very very few laws and regulations that protect innocent parties from being exploited and having their likeness, voice, or ideas created. AI is so out of control that just because there aren't any government regulations over it yet and it's basically boomed into our society that even emails are being used to train ai without consent, your phonecalls, video calls, etc bunch of companies are exploiting the lack of regulations while they can to keep training up more ai products. They are literally created to replace humans as much as possible but also by stealing (or as techbros call it: "learning") from us.
While I would like to be hopeful along side the other comments, we gotta remember that something that may seem easy to shake off & logic-through for an adult can be SIGNIFICANT & world ending for a kid or teen who is already struggling to figure themselves out all while physically changing & struggling with hormones. The embarrassment & social effects of having even a fake "leak" could be there for her.
You can't use this one example for all of AI. That way if thinking is dangerous. What about the good that AI has done? It's helping the science community come up with new proteins and new antibiotics. You are blaming the tool and not the person using the tool. Please stop being so simple minded.
@@alexmendez3681 And you can't dismiss one person's opinion and act like your statement is a 100% true statement. IT IS NOT. Please follow your own advice and stop being so simple minded. Both of you are speaking truths!!!!!
@@Drilla81 You can definitely dismiss one's opinion especially when it's atrociously wrong. If you were to tell me the world is flat, I would dismiss you super quick. But if you were to tell me the world isn't perfectly round that there's a slight bending or bulging, I would want to listen. But let me challenge you hotshot. What about my statement is wrong? Let's hear it. 😁
Yes. I had raging hormones in middle school. There were a few girls that scared the crap out of me, with there hormonal aggression. That was 37 years ago.
@@richatlarge462 It's NOT AI. Artificial Intelligence is the theory and development of computer systems able to perform tasks that normally require human intelligence, such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making, and translation between languages. Cutting and pasting images then blending them IS NOT AI, or a form of AI.
@@ChrisL-oz4lp I'm not too worked up about it. AI basically means "faked by technology" in common parlance. One can for example use AI to create a body using keywords before blending it.
All thanks to the woke school boards and educators along with the proliferation of social media which is rotting the brains of our children. Absentee parents play a large part in this also.
Have you ever stopped to think there is a good reason for this? It just so happens to be the mechanism used to procreate. Of *COURSE* we are supposed to have some "excessive fascination". 🤦♂️
@@maureenbuck4795 Try "biological imperative". What part of "it's absolutely necessary" is difficult to understand? It gives "reward" to entice us into the activity. Without it, we wouldn't be having this (or any other) discussion, now, would we... 🤦♂️
@MadScientist267 I just left the Walmart, they had a lock and key on the condoms and lubricants...doesn't sound like it's the procreation aspect people are indulging in. Just saying.
Fighting results in minimum suspension. What was done here was several magnitudes worse, since this basically involves CP and extreme cyber-bullying. Trying to compare the two is a trash take
I'm glad the school staff were smart enough to understand that these pics were AI made and not real. Too many stories of students and staff of getting their NSFW leaked and getting expelled/fired. This could have gone really bad for the victims, not that this is much better...
A wild over reaction id say! Must be a slow day in the hills. In my day 7th and 8th graders were geting naked not just sharing pictures. These adults and so called Drs of education need to get adult priorities!
Yet the parents will defend these sweet kids because how dare you accuse those poor angles. Parents are just idiots for not disciplining their kids at home correctly.
Yes! Parents really need to get mathematics and geometry into their kids heads! No more accusing angles! Justice for ALL angles. Make Arithmetic Great Again
@@runits oh dang, thank you for the gigantic revelation. 🤦🏻♂️ . My if was sarcastic., of course they have it, they are the only ones with it., also kind of weird you say they are not using it for porn, on a post about them using it for porn. 🤦🏻♂️
@@omi_god your logic.. is why every city is twirling down the toilet. I can explain it to you and you still won’t even understand. A frying pan will only cook food., not a whole country’s brain at once.
This is another reason people need to stop sharing their children online. People are doing disgusting things and even stalking and finding these children.
Well, I'm surprised to see some REAL 'zero-tolerance' on serious juvenile criminality. I'm impressed...usually school districts fold-up quickly and submit to the lousy parent(s) of the lousy children. The parents of those 16 students now need to sue the parent(s) of the 5.
This has been done for years with PhotoShop. It's only because "AI" is such a hot button topic that is why this is news at all.....Oh and "B.H. High School" also adds a few million clicks
This could be done before photoshop in a wet lab. As a joke my father put the Chief of Polices face on a Hell's Angel leader with two nudes hugging him and he did it in a wet lab. It was pretty epic and funny. Of course it was not shown to the public.
The difference here is the more photos you feed into the AI of the victim, full body, cheer leading out fit, skirt etc, the AI can virtually "strip" the person then animate them into poses etc.
That shouldn't even be a crime, but yes. Unfortunately, they'd also be arrested. Tyrants have made it illegal for even the adults to have personal protection on school property.
The A.I. isn't the problem, it's the lack of Ethics taught to those who have used it in this way, which is a reflection of the failure of the parents and teachers. Communities as a whole need to do better.
These parody images, not photos, were generated by computer. Is it creepy? Absolutely, but don't lie that someone's privacy was violated. Don't be surprised if the school district gets sued by the students if the images were distributed and produced with non school district equipment.
What's up with parenting? This is the third story I've seen in as many days of groups of teens kicking doors (TikTok challenge), uploading trashy inciteful photos, etc. There are plenty of teens with access to the same technology who opt to do the right thing and steer clear of trouble and hurting others. I chalk it all up to how much respect a teen has for their parents (and themselves) and focus on making their parents proud, not on creating attorney fee expenses and having them going back and forth to court.
Teens always blame the ills of society on older generations, when in reality it's the bad-behaved members of their own peer group who perpetuate the ills of society and carry their behavior forward into adulthood.
@@yaash4123So true. Which is why it's important not to blame "Boomers" as a group for today's issues, or for future young generations to blame "Millennials" as a group for tomorrow's issues.
Every generation complains about every generation dating back since the 1200s when the first generation was recorded. Fun fact the 80s and 90s generation were more violent than today's generation according to data
I knew it was going to be a problem when this Al was first introduced. Creating false photos and profiles. Feel bad for the online dating scene and everything in general
Hold on there , at 1:37 they're saying this case could be prosecuted using the current child pornography law ! WTH ! ! ! Then WHY aren't the current child pornography laws being used to prosecute each of the schools & libraries allowing the accessible display of pornographic materials to children & sex acts being performed for children ?
this is a perfect example of the traffic in praise and blame. why aren't you adults ashamed of yourselves for literally poisoning kids w/the food and drink you serve?
@@ChrisL-oz4lp It’s interesting to notice the decline of “polite society” over the last 5 (or so) decades. Teenagers in the 50’s and 60’s wore button up short sleeve shirts, and got dressed up for dinner, and going out (today they wear pajama bottoms out in public, with a stocking cap. Airplanes decades ago served real dinners, with excellent service, today you barely get a bag of pretzels. …….It’s definitely been a STEADY decline in the past decades. 🤔🤷🏼♂️🤔🤷🏼♂️
@@eddieg6436 People today are way better people in general than 5 decades ago. It's the current generation cleaning up after the previous one in a lot of sectors like global warming, clean energy, environmental-consciousness, etc. Sure, in the 50's people got dressed for dinner and got better airplane service, meanwhile expecting black people to sit in the back of buses lol.
@@samuelfuentes3327 …..I own an electric Genesis GV60, and have solar panels on my home’s roof, bring my reusable bags to the grocery store (organic produce only!), and recycle like crazy. ……but I wish kids had respect for the police, and elders (they don’t ), and I wish I didn’t see them wearing pajama bottoms going to school, and the store. 🤷🏼♂️🤔
Man... I knew that this exact scenario would happen sooner rather than later, but I was really hoping it wouldn't quite be *this* soon... I fear what other news reports involving the use of A.I. we'll be seeing in the near future...
This is both the AI and parents fault. Whoever provided the ai model, most likely OpenAI needs to set restrictions on their AI, and the parents should keep track of what is on their phone.
In Beverly Hills, that's the nanny's job. The parents are either off on exotic vacations with their new partners or at a white wine bistro running up a $700 tab
Age limits on AI usage should be a thing just like anything else that can cause health or legal repercussions. As much as I am against censoring anything, reasonable measures should be considered or limits to AI functionality applied.
Delaying is not censoring. People's brains don't finish developing until around 25. Children do not have the capacity to deal with every issue, so you can't call it censorship.
Look around you. How many adults use their technology responsibly? 99 out of 100 adults have zero discipline with their tech. We need regulation that is overseen by individuals that are not engrossed in tech. If that can even be achieved these days
@@JoeSmith-ru9xu I don't disagree however adults have a better grasp of the possible consequences if they're using their devices in a way that can get them in trouble with the law.
@@JoeSmith-ru9xu have you seen the mark Zuckerberg court hearings and the type of technical questions they asked him? those dinosaurs couldn't create viable technological laws. We need someone that understands tech to create proper regulations
I dont get why they have all types of different classes for kids,,music, sports,woodshop,,art, etc,,,,,but i never hear of an ETHICS class...something to make students think about themselves, their actions,,,i know,i know,that should be done at home by parents,,,,,some parents just DONT DO THAT FOR THEIR KIDS for whatever reason,they just dont,,,so the school should help out ,,,a little in some way,,,,,give a class on KNOWING THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG AND CARING ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE.....
In my opinion: Nudity has a finite boundary to what would be considered pornography. An erect male or showing of the interior labia would be considered traditional pornography even though no suggestion or penetration might exist. Nudity can be pornography. It would be the PlayBoy vs Hustler argument. Some of which would have become the subject matter of courts. But courts have been known to unlawfully rule on behalf of social policies aside of required legislative actions. Like Row vs Wade & various forms of gun control. - In my opinion.
This actually raises some legal questions. Like forget morality, that's a whole different subject, just legality. If someone used AI to create CP, would that be illegal? Assuming no actual people were involved, no real photos used, it was all entirely AI generated... In terms of artwork, you could go out and buy some oil paints, and paint the most depraved CP scene you can think of. And as long as you don't go SHOWING that to minors...you're legally in the clear. It's a protected freedom of expression, because it's entirely done by an adult, for an adult, with no children being involved.
this is more a case of the piece of paper being found by someone's mum and shown to the principal who has to expel someone in order to be seen as doing something about it. pieces of paper get handed around all the time and most of the kids, being semi-awake, never get caught. life's lessons 101
Definitely not CP. I'm also not certain what the crime would actually be, since we're basically talking about a facsimile of someones face attached to an image of a fictitious body. No money was made from this (unless I missed something). And, the original image that the AI was given, probably came from a publicly posted source. Obviously, this was inherently wrong, and we instinctively know that. But, I'm not sure what crime was committed.
Not exactly the same thing but I remember years ago when celebrities phones were hacked and lots of pictures were leaked some people claimed some were fake. Thing was either they were fake and the celebrity couldn't really do anything about it since technically it wasn't pictures of them, or they could try and stop it by admitting the pictures were real. So if they deny it like you say then it will make it harder to remove the videos/ photos.
@@tonyblake7569 That's interesting. But surely placing one's face on a naked body is libel,though. I mean technically your falsely accusing someone of being naked while engaging in porm activities, because you're showing them do it. And if they make the deepfake talk - it should be a charge of slander. I wonder if that falls into it, correctly.🤔
I teach at a middle school with 6th/7th graders Students have been caught taking their phones into bathrooms and taking images of others using the bathroom then sharing them This is with a school rule that cell phones are supposed to be in lockers all day no exceptions They still sneak them Kids do not need smart phones . Period.
If its not actually a real person is it a crime? Lawfully i don't think its crime and won't stand up to scrutiny in a court if criminal charges are file for certain specific crimes like child porn. Why because their actual has to be a real victim that can be identified and if charges can be filed over fake images then the first amendment itself would be in trouble and compromised. I mean think about that they cant even file charges when adults who like like kids make porn to look like its kids. If fake pictures can be a crime then the most mondame stuff will put people in jail. Its actually a kid nude. May be just their face, but its not actually them. People can be upset and say its morally wrong all they want too but it doesn't rise to the level of a crime.people might want it it because if the nature of it but legally it doesn't. They might bebable todo some type of bully thing through the school but honestly thats probably it. Even if by some chance they get charge and gonto jail. They will win on appeal might even have to gonto the supreme court but I'm telling you know way they will let someone get charges over pictures that are not even real. Ots gonna be hard because of the way people feel morally but when it comes to law peoples feelings don't matter and feelingbstart to matter more than the law thats when you start getting corruption and people getting arrested not because they committed ancrimenbut because they made someone mad. Its when you start to get people who are so convinced that what someone did is wrong they break the law themselves just to make sure that justice is served because their feelings matter more than the law does.
Is it peer pressure or are they just naturally borderline sexual predators? Because really, what was done is a way of gaining power over their victims. Are they ignorant of how inappropriate their actions were? It doesn't matter if the pictures were AI or not. The act of doing it is predatory and demeaning to the victim. Did the parents of the offenders have any comment?
For a country that brag itself about being world leader, you never take precautionary measures before release powerful risky stuff into an uncontrolled environment filled with crazy human and when things goes south, you start doing meaningless progress through your legislation to repair and contrôle the damage.
The school did the right thing, but the expelled kids' parents should sue the school, the district, and the police department. The legal expert laid it all out. "The laws WILL catch up to technology." The laws haven't caught up yet, though. So those kids technically didn't do anything illegal.
I'm not sure that the school actually did do the right thing. Seems an overreaction to me. This was inappropriate behavior, of course, so an action WAS required by the school. A more appropriate course of action would have been to require the offending students to engage in some sort of community service for the remainder of the school year, and probably through the summer.
This is unquestionably horrible for the people involved but it's literally all fake. Non of it is real and I would be willing to bet that the imaginary rendering of these fabricated photos, from an aesthetics point of view are most likely more flattering than reality. I am not at all condoning any of these actions but seriously..... when the world of technology, on this level, with availability to everyone (especially young imaginative children) coupled with the whole social media generation mentality what did you think would happen? And, odds are, if this didn't happen in a place like Beverly Hills, It would be less of a story. The whole world is flying off the rails yet somehow people are "shocked" when things like this happen. Welcome to 2024.
This sort of thing has probably happened at other schools across the country. Give middle school, or high school, students access to pretty much anything, and they'll do dumb, irresponsible things with it, sometimes. At that age, naked people are funny. Jokes about private anatomy are funny. This was predictable.
🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ The law will catch up?!? The law hasn't even caught up with the internet crimes yet.... it is still catching up at the speed of dial-up 🙄🙄🙄
![일상 속 기분 좋음 [Proto disco meme]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DwmEIaZ7XGQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Crazy thing is that these were 8th grade students...
It’s not that crazy that they were 8th graders per sey. 8th graders are usually at the age of puberty. However the use of AI in this time of their life is definitely new and alarming!
Exactly! Also A.I is still new and getting better which is scary. @@Fanged.Fiend.Reactor
8th grade was the most scandalous year of my childhood education. High school was tame in comparison. 8th grade is the last year that doesn't go on your college application transcript.
when I was in 8th grade all my class mates were perverts. even the girls. we had one girl that would go out in the hall and moon the entire class from the doorway while the teacher was looking the other way.
They need more homework then. Too much time on their hands and a lack of knowledge about hurting others. Had a kid that looked up p+rn in the library with his friends supposedly around that age when I was in middle school. They were like 3 ft away from the teacher and we were all in the library for a book report. Kids are crazy.
This is only an example of students getting caught. Imagine the other unknown cases?
You calling expulsion harsh? They lucky they didn't get charged for distribution of child pornography.
That's acutally still being discussed.....
Not happening. The nude parts were not real children.
Rich kids
Absolutely asinine characterization! They should have gotten community service in addition to, picking up garbage on the side of the road.
This is Beverly Hills! Rules don't apply
I bet this happens far more than anyone knows
Certainly faked images have exited for a long time. Photo-shopping of course has been a thing for a long time. But especially in the last year AI has seen a lot of progression, making it a lot easier and faster to create convincing deepfakes. We're in the early phases of it now, but this is definitely going to be a fast-growing problem from here on out.
no it happens less often
We're probably already in it. Usually when news like this comes out it's generally already happening across the board :/@@CranberryFo
Says the guy who makes deepfake xP@@LebronCCP
@@LebronCCP Not at all, AI "art" steals real artists work and DEEPFAKE technology is AI used to make real or even fake generated AI people appear to do things they've never done such as crime or corn. Taylor Swift recently had to sue because of deepfake ai making fake corn out of her. Also, many corn websites are being taken over by people who make corn using deepfake of real people from celebrities or real life people ESPECIALLY MINORS and it's a massive issue.
We were warned a long time ago by techbros like zuckerburg and many others who aren't even on his status level that we need to be wary of AI and that it is NOT READY to be mainstream because there are very very few laws and regulations that protect innocent parties from being exploited and having their likeness, voice, or ideas created.
AI is so out of control that just because there aren't any government regulations over it yet and it's basically boomed into our society that even emails are being used to train ai without consent, your phonecalls, video calls, etc bunch of companies are exploiting the lack of regulations while they can to keep training up more ai products. They are literally created to replace humans as much as possible but also by stealing (or as techbros call it: "learning") from us.
This is no joke. It's a form of bullying imo and victim may commit suicide.
Be smart and be strong.
only someone one the edge of checking out would do it because of images that aren't' real and never happened.
Very well said words. Thanks for that. I agree fully.❤
If they're not real nudes you shouldn't feel so shamed you know they're fake.
While I would like to be hopeful along side the other comments, we gotta remember that something that may seem easy to shake off & logic-through for an adult can be SIGNIFICANT & world ending for a kid or teen who is already struggling to figure themselves out all while physically changing & struggling with hormones. The embarrassment & social effects of having even a fake "leak" could be there for her.
Life is bullying..... kids can and will cope. Shut up with the crying of bullying.
A.I IS STARTING TO SHOW HOW BAD ITS GONNA GET IN THE FUTURE
You can't use this one example for all of AI. That way if thinking is dangerous. What about the good that AI has done? It's helping the science community come up with new proteins and new antibiotics. You are blaming the tool and not the person using the tool. Please stop being so simple minded.
shhh don't tell this guy about Adobe photoshop!
@@alexmendez3681 And you can't dismiss one person's opinion and act like your statement is a 100% true statement. IT IS NOT. Please follow your own advice and stop being so simple minded. Both of you are speaking truths!!!!!
@@bobbob-vw4cc😂😂😂
@@Drilla81 You can definitely dismiss one's opinion especially when it's atrociously wrong. If you were to tell me the world is flat, I would dismiss you super quick. But if you were to tell me the world isn't perfectly round that there's a slight bending or bulging, I would want to listen.
But let me challenge you hotshot. What about my statement is wrong? Let's hear it. 😁
AI is going to be a total sh*tshow for hormonally-driven middle school adolescents
Cyberbullying
Slander.
more like cyberfapping
@@bleepbloop7039a teen bro? keep those comments to yourself
@@vane_9182 lmao your soft ahh cant even take a joke comment take yo sweet ahh home and take a nap lil boy
So what... same as if you photoshopped it... bullying takes new forms, but the coping stategies stay the same... ignore and go forward.
And so it begins..
Back in my day, getting a picture from your crush with your name on it was brag-worthy for a whole year.
Remember when getting a nude was a Polaroid picture?
Damage the picture and its gone forever. 😅
Middle school?!?!?! Wtf
Yeah, these kids are nuts!!!!!
Yes. I had raging hormones in middle school.
There were a few girls that scared the crap out of me, with there hormonal aggression.
That was 37 years ago.
14/15 yr olds
Well duh. I’m sure this is happening everywhere.
Ikr
This was bound to be among the first real-world applications of AI technology.
It's actually called, Photo Shop. Been around for decades.
@@ChrisL-oz4lpTrue, but next-level with AI.
@@richatlarge462 It's NOT AI. Artificial Intelligence is the theory and development of computer systems able to perform tasks that normally require human intelligence, such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making, and translation between languages. Cutting and pasting images then blending them IS NOT AI, or a form of AI.
@@ChrisL-oz4lp I'm not too worked up about it. AI basically means "faked by technology" in common parlance. One can for example use AI to create a body using keywords before blending it.
Yep, when deepfakes came out a few years ago this was happening
This is so disturbing and sad.
gay lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pics or it never happened.
Oh right...
"I got kids expelled from school and I got away with it." -A.I.
AI doesn't send out deepfakes....PEOPLE do
Our society has an unhealthy preoccupation with sex. Sad.
All thanks to the woke school boards and educators along with the proliferation of social media which is rotting the brains of our children. Absentee parents play a large part in this also.
Have you ever stopped to think there is a good reason for this? It just so happens to be the mechanism used to procreate. Of *COURSE* we are supposed to have some "excessive fascination". 🤦♂️
@MadScientist267 your definition for "excessive fascination" sounds very similar to addiction?
@@maureenbuck4795 Try "biological imperative". What part of "it's absolutely necessary" is difficult to understand? It gives "reward" to entice us into the activity. Without it, we wouldn't be having this (or any other) discussion, now, would we... 🤦♂️
@MadScientist267 I just left the Walmart, they had a lock and key on the condoms and lubricants...doesn't sound like it's the procreation aspect people are indulging in. Just saying.
Meanwhile kids fighting and busting peoples teeth out. They come back to school all the time.
How do you know that?
Fighting results in minimum suspension. What was done here was several magnitudes worse, since this basically involves CP and extreme cyber-bullying. Trying to compare the two is a trash take
@@samuelfuentes3327 There's visual violence and then there's actual violence.
@@omi_god no it isnt nonsence, there are no brown or black bastartds in beverly hills schools
I'm glad the school staff were smart enough to understand that these pics were AI made and not real. Too many stories of students and staff of getting their NSFW leaked and getting expelled/fired. This could have gone really bad for the victims, not that this is much better...
A wild over reaction id say! Must be a slow day in the hills. In my day 7th and 8th graders were geting naked not just sharing pictures. These adults and so called Drs of education need to get adult priorities!
No guardrails on AI - the level of immorality in the state is stunning.
This is how Skynet begins 😅
Agreed. We were warned...
You came to us from the future, didn’t you !!! 😂
Yet the parents will defend these sweet kids because how dare you accuse those poor angles.
Parents are just idiots for not disciplining their kids at home correctly.
Angles...lol.
Angels.
@@Leviatiemily
...guessing they weren't
Math students 😊
Yes! Parents really need to get mathematics and geometry into their kids heads! No more accusing angles! Justice for ALL angles. Make Arithmetic Great Again
I love a right angle! 90°
@@TheAlabamaWildmanDefinitely not geometry. 😂
It could be the AI in the comments defending the AI
Yup...this is how it starts.....skynet has become aware....
Like this comment.
This may be the start of any video "evidence" being deemed inadmissible in court.
No.
I can remember saying 'the camera never lies' as a kid...we're doomed...
At this _current_ point, I would have a hard time considering any video or audio 'evidence' as being genuine...
AI is trash
Especially if rich people have it.
@@Hezekiah1rich people do have it. They are not using it for porn. They are using it to control money flows in the markets.
@@runits oh dang, thank you for the gigantic revelation. 🤦🏻♂️ . My if was sarcastic., of course they have it, they are the only ones with it., also kind of weird you say they are not using it for porn, on a post about them using it for porn. 🤦🏻♂️
@@omi_god your logic.. is why every city is twirling down the toilet. I can explain it to you and you still won’t even understand. A frying pan will only cook food., not a whole country’s brain at once.
ur basically an NPC anyway
Its not a bug, its a feature
This is another reason people need to stop sharing their children online. People are doing disgusting things and even stalking and finding these children.
The parents of the victims should sue the perpetrators.
the parents should be fine. You need to know what your kids are doing.
Well, I'm surprised to see some REAL 'zero-tolerance' on serious juvenile criminality. I'm impressed...usually school districts fold-up quickly and submit to the lousy parent(s) of the lousy children.
The parents of those 16 students now need to sue the parent(s) of the 5.
that wont stop AI
@@ronnieloya9667 No one is stopping AI, just hold people who commit crimes with it accountable.
Yeah, this IS a shocker. Can kick the crap out of students,bully them, and just get suspended. Yet send a couple of fake nudes and you get expelled! 🙄
just a twist on an old problem. Nothing new@@geoffh1
@@geoffh1What crime was committed?
We need regulations on ai, how many more incidences like this need to happen before we do anything?
cats out of the bag. Good luck controlling it.
It will be taken seriously when it happens to a man
The reporter said the laws will catch up. I doubt it, though. US law has always been lacking behind technology by at least a couple of years.
This has been done for years with PhotoShop. It's only because "AI" is such a hot button topic that is why this is news at all.....Oh and "B.H. High School" also adds a few million clicks
I commented the same thing earlier. No one spoke up when this was done with Photoshop.
Well it’s a lot easier now
Most people can't use photos shop. It's expensive and very complicated software.
This could be done before photoshop in a wet lab. As a joke my father put the Chief of Polices face on a Hell's Angel leader with two nudes hugging him and he did it in a wet lab. It was pretty epic and funny. Of course it was not shown to the public.
The difference here is the more photos you feed into the AI of the victim, full body, cheer leading out fit, skirt etc, the AI can virtually "strip" the person then animate them into poses etc.
“Believed to be responsible.” Were they the guilty parties, or were they made scapegoats?
Curious question from someone not living in the US: Would those kids also got expelled if their crime was bringing a fully loaded gun to school?
That shouldn't even be a crime, but yes. Unfortunately, they'd also be arrested.
Tyrants have made it illegal for even the adults to have personal protection on school property.
The A.I. isn't the problem, it's the lack of Ethics taught to those who have used it in this way, which is a reflection of the failure of the parents and teachers. Communities as a whole need to do better.
People will always be trash. That’s why there is government and laws.
Was anyone else thinking this would make a really good south park episode?
South Park S26E04 'Deep Learning' (AI) and S17E10 'The Hobbit' (Photoshop/fakes) - noting is lost on those guys
How bout punishing those responsible for the behavior of those 8th graders, the parents.
These parody images, not photos, were generated by computer. Is it creepy? Absolutely, but don't lie that someone's privacy was violated. Don't be surprised if the school district gets sued by the students if the images were distributed and produced with non school district equipment.
It’s also happening to teachers and others in different countries.
What's up with parenting? This is the third story I've seen in as many days of groups of teens kicking doors (TikTok challenge), uploading trashy inciteful photos, etc. There are plenty of teens with access to the same technology who opt to do the right thing and steer clear of trouble and hurting others. I chalk it all up to how much respect a teen has for their parents (and themselves) and focus on making their parents proud, not on creating attorney fee expenses and having them going back and forth to court.
Teens always blame the ills of society on older generations, when in reality it's the bad-behaved members of their own peer group who perpetuate the ills of society and carry their behavior forward into adulthood.
Stuff happens in every generation.
@@yaash4123So true. Which is why it's important not to blame "Boomers" as a group for today's issues, or for future young generations to blame "Millennials" as a group for tomorrow's issues.
Every generation complains about every generation dating back since the 1200s when the first generation was recorded. Fun fact the 80s and 90s generation were more violent than today's generation according to data
Nobody has enough money to be proud of anything
I knew it was going to be a problem when this Al was first introduced. Creating false photos and profiles. Feel bad for the online dating scene and everything in general
People who create these types of pictures should keep it private and not share them with anyone.
Hold on there , at 1:37 they're saying this case could be prosecuted using the current child pornography law !
WTH ! ! ! Then WHY aren't the current child pornography laws being used to prosecute each of the schools & libraries allowing the accessible display of pornographic materials to children & sex acts being performed for children ?
this is a perfect example of the traffic in praise and blame. why aren't you adults ashamed of yourselves for literally poisoning kids w/the food and drink you serve?
Oh, my God, that's disgusting! Where? Where did they post these, and how exactly did they generate them?
Thank God I'm old This society is falling about more and more every day. Good Luck folks in the future.
……you couldn’t PAY ME to be a young adult in these times!!!
@@eddieg6436 I'm 66, that is exactly what my parents said in the 70s.
@@ChrisL-oz4lp It’s interesting to notice the decline of “polite society” over the last 5 (or so) decades. Teenagers in the 50’s and 60’s wore button up short sleeve shirts, and got dressed up for dinner, and going out (today they wear pajama bottoms out in public, with a stocking cap. Airplanes decades ago served real dinners, with excellent service, today you barely get a bag of pretzels. …….It’s definitely been a STEADY decline in the past decades. 🤔🤷🏼♂️🤔🤷🏼♂️
@@eddieg6436 People today are way better people in general than 5 decades ago. It's the current generation cleaning up after the previous one in a lot of sectors like global warming, clean energy, environmental-consciousness, etc. Sure, in the 50's people got dressed for dinner and got better airplane service, meanwhile expecting black people to sit in the back of buses lol.
@@samuelfuentes3327 …..I own an electric Genesis GV60, and have solar panels on my home’s roof, bring my reusable bags to the grocery store (organic produce only!), and recycle like crazy. ……but I wish kids had respect for the police, and elders (they don’t ), and I wish I didn’t see them wearing pajama bottoms going to school, and the store. 🤷🏼♂️🤔
This is nothing new. It's just harder to do in Photoshop.
What is wrong with the kids nowadays? Don’t they understand. This is so disappointing, where are the parents?
Working, everyone is working because we’re broke
Definitely lawsuits… this will be on the internet forever.
Technology will be one step ahead of these laws if the state senators don't do their jobs!
Poor rich kids
Man... I knew that this exact scenario would happen sooner rather than later, but I was really hoping it wouldn't quite be *this* soon... I fear what other news reports involving the use of A.I. we'll be seeing in the near future...
And it begins!
this aint nothing new. back in the day this used to be photoshop
This is both the AI and parents fault. Whoever provided the ai model, most likely OpenAI needs to set restrictions on their AI, and the parents should keep track of what is on their phone.
Parents are not teaching their children that actions have consequences.
“There’s no doubt that the law will catch up to AI technology.”
AI: Hold my malted beverage.
Are the parents responsible for their children’s conduct I would think this would leave them open to some severe litigation.
AI is not going to be a good thing for humans.
I've been saying that, for a while now.
Parents need to get offline and help their kids grow up take some responsibility
In Beverly Hills, that's the nanny's job. The parents are either off on exotic vacations with their new partners or at a white wine bistro running up a $700 tab
Age limits on AI usage should be a thing just like anything else that can cause health or legal repercussions. As much as I am against censoring anything, reasonable measures should be considered or limits to AI functionality applied.
Delaying is not censoring. People's brains don't finish developing until around 25. Children do not have the capacity to deal with every issue, so you can't call it censorship.
Look around you. How many adults use their technology responsibly? 99 out of 100 adults have zero discipline with their tech. We need regulation that is overseen by individuals that are not engrossed in tech. If that can even be achieved these days
@@JoeSmith-ru9xu I don't disagree however adults have a better grasp of the possible consequences if they're using their devices in a way that can get them in trouble with the law.
@@JoeSmith-ru9xu have you seen the mark Zuckerberg court hearings and the type of technical questions they asked him? those dinosaurs couldn't create viable technological laws. We need someone that understands tech to create proper regulations
Definitely need more government involvement in our lives
I dont get why they have all types of different classes for kids,,music, sports,woodshop,,art, etc,,,,,but i never hear of an ETHICS class...something to make students think about themselves, their actions,,,i know,i know,that should be done at home by parents,,,,,some parents just DONT DO THAT FOR THEIR KIDS for whatever reason,they just dont,,,so the school should help out ,,,a little in some way,,,,,give a class on KNOWING THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RIGHT AND WRONG AND CARING ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE.....
The rich kids' parents should take away phones
And laptops and desktops!
It’s one thing for someone to use AI for their own advantage , but using it to send explicit materials to others without consent is so wrong!
this happened at a MIDDLE SCHOOL? wow.
Jail time!
Now just imagine what adults are doing with this tech.
More laws….. great
8th grade boys and girls in beverly hills. Smarter than you
I hate it when they have a story but no pics of the "details', yes?
Freak.
Bro, these are barely teenagers. What are you suggesting?
???????????? ?
Just the beginning of the AI crimes.
Parents are reponsible to teaching their child regarding nudity and what are the consequences if not abiding by the school rules.
In my opinion: Nudity has a finite boundary to what would be considered pornography.
An erect male or showing of the interior labia would be considered traditional pornography even though no suggestion or penetration might exist.
Nudity can be pornography.
It would be the PlayBoy vs Hustler argument. Some of which would have become the subject matter of courts. But courts have been known to unlawfully rule on behalf of social policies aside of required legislative actions. Like Row vs Wade & various forms of gun control.
- In my opinion.
This actually raises some legal questions. Like forget morality, that's a whole different subject, just legality. If someone used AI to create CP, would that be illegal? Assuming no actual people were involved, no real photos used, it was all entirely AI generated... In terms of artwork, you could go out and buy some oil paints, and paint the most depraved CP scene you can think of. And as long as you don't go SHOWING that to minors...you're legally in the clear. It's a protected freedom of expression, because it's entirely done by an adult, for an adult, with no children being involved.
Photoshop existed before AI did it for you. People were making photos like these back in the 90s on AOL. Not a new thing.
Expulsion?!?! Overreaction….no different than drawing on a piece of paper and passing it to others. 🤷🏾♂️
this is more a case of the piece of paper being found by someone's mum and shown to the principal who has to expel someone in order to be seen as doing something about it. pieces of paper get handed around all the time and most of the kids, being semi-awake, never get caught. life's lessons 101
A crime of some type? Perhaps. Child pronography? Definitely not.
Definitely not CP.
I'm also not certain what the crime would actually be, since we're basically talking about a facsimile of someones face attached to an image of a fictitious body.
No money was made from this (unless I missed something). And, the original image that the AI was given, probably came from a publicly posted source.
Obviously, this was inherently wrong, and we instinctively know that. But, I'm not sure what crime was committed.
Middle school! OMG what the hell.
Well, now nudes of anyone in any videos can easily be denied.
Not exactly the same thing but I remember years ago when celebrities phones were hacked and lots of pictures were leaked some people claimed some were fake. Thing was either they were fake and the celebrity couldn't really do anything about it since technically it wasn't pictures of them, or they could try and stop it by admitting the pictures were real. So if they deny it like you say then it will make it harder to remove the videos/ photos.
@@tonyblake7569 That's interesting. But surely placing one's face on a naked body is libel,though. I mean technically your falsely accusing someone of being naked while engaging in porm activities, because you're showing them do it. And if they make the deepfake talk - it should be a charge of slander. I wonder if that falls into it, correctly.🤔
Hopefully it wasn't guys ai pictures 😂 that is actually hilarious 😂 this new generation has a special sense of humor.
Take the phones out of schools!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You'd think people would find this issue a problem but oh well
Giving private school a whole new meaning
😑😑😑
i went to srgt touchys private school of whats that place im touching in the dark
@@bloodlove93😂😂😂
This is a public school. BHUSD.
This is not a private school. This the Beverly hills city school
Middle school ?? Wow.
I teach at a middle school with 6th/7th graders
Students have been caught taking their phones into bathrooms and taking images of others using the bathroom then sharing them
This is with a school rule that cell phones are supposed to be in lockers all day no exceptions
They still sneak them
Kids do not need smart phones . Period.
If its not actually a real person is it a crime? Lawfully i don't think its crime and won't stand up to scrutiny in a court if criminal charges are file for certain specific crimes like child porn. Why because their actual has to be a real victim that can be identified and if charges can be filed over fake images then the first amendment itself would be in trouble and compromised. I mean think about that they cant even file charges when adults who like like kids make porn to look like its kids.
If fake pictures can be a crime then the most mondame stuff will put people in jail. Its actually a kid nude. May be just their face, but its not actually them. People can be upset and say its morally wrong all they want too but it doesn't rise to the level of a crime.people might want it it because if the nature of it but legally it doesn't. They might bebable todo some type of bully thing through the school but honestly thats probably it. Even if by some chance they get charge and gonto jail. They will win on appeal might even have to gonto the supreme court but I'm telling you know way they will let someone get charges over pictures that are not even real.
Ots gonna be hard because of the way people feel morally but when it comes to law peoples feelings don't matter and feelingbstart to matter more than the law thats when you start getting corruption and people getting arrested not because they committed ancrimenbut because they made someone mad. Its when you start to get people who are so convinced that what someone did is wrong they break the law themselves just to make sure that justice is served because their feelings matter more than the law does.
Is it peer pressure or are they just naturally borderline sexual predators? Because really, what was done is a way of gaining power over their victims. Are they ignorant of how inappropriate their actions were? It doesn't matter if the pictures were AI or not. The act of doing it is predatory and demeaning to the victim. Did the parents of the offenders have any comment?
For a country that brag itself about being world leader, you never take precautionary measures before release powerful risky stuff into an uncontrolled environment filled with crazy human and when things goes south, you start doing meaningless progress through your legislation to repair and contrôle the damage.
Because it's all about the $$$$ not about creating a good society
how you charge a child for child pornography? is that really a lawyer?
kids are charged with creating or distributing CP all the time, usually due to nudes they take of themselves
When I was 13, I did it a lot. But it was all in my head 😂
Where are the parents??????
To be honest, I thought the AI thing was not allowed to generate nude images? Yikes.
what the heck?
The school did the right thing, but the expelled kids' parents should sue the school, the district, and the police department.
The legal expert laid it all out. "The laws WILL catch up to technology." The laws haven't caught up yet, though. So those kids technically didn't do anything illegal.
I'm not sure that the school actually did do the right thing. Seems an overreaction to me.
This was inappropriate behavior, of course, so an action WAS required by the school. A more appropriate course of action would have been to require the offending students to engage in some sort of community service for the remainder of the school year, and probably through the summer.
It’s because social media platforms advertise these applications to children. TH-cam does it too. It’s all greed.
This is unquestionably horrible for the people involved but it's literally all fake. Non of it is real and I would be willing to bet that the imaginary rendering of these fabricated photos, from an aesthetics point of view are most likely more flattering than reality.
I am not at all condoning any of these actions but seriously..... when the world of technology, on this level, with availability to everyone (especially young imaginative children) coupled with the whole social media generation mentality what did you think would happen?
And, odds are, if this didn't happen in a place like Beverly Hills, It would be less of a story.
The whole world is flying off the rails yet somehow people are "shocked" when things like this happen.
Welcome to 2024.
This sort of thing has probably happened at other schools across the country.
Give middle school, or high school, students access to pretty much anything, and they'll do dumb, irresponsible things with it, sometimes.
At that age, naked people are funny. Jokes about private anatomy are funny.
This was predictable.
Sue the parents
🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ The law will catch up?!? The law hasn't even caught up with the internet crimes yet.... it is still catching up at the speed of dial-up 🙄🙄🙄
All they were saying is look in 10 years this is what you're going to look like
So , fake pictures are illegal? I've heard it all now . Well, to be fair , everything is illegal.
Harassment is illegal genius, tell people you took pictures of them and see what they do to you
you can but he say he want nothing