Crossable Wormholes?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ค. 2024
- How can we visualise a black hole? Are wormholes real or fantasy? Are wormholes physically plausible? All these answers in 14 minutes
For more videos, subscribe to the TH-cam channel : / scienceclicen
And if you liked this video, you can share it on social networks !
To support me on Patreon : / scienceclic
or on Tipeee : tipeee.com/ScienceClic
Facebook Page : / scienceclic
Twitter : / scienceclic
Google+ : google.com/+ScienceClic
Alessandro Roussel,
For more info: www.alessandroroussel.com/en
_
To learn more :
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wormhole
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellis_w... - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Beware, a little mistake has crept into my animations at 4:42. The light ray should not have been drawn as if it was "reflected" by the white hole. It should just have escaped from within the horizon.
In fact, because it is an extension of a black hole's geometry, the white hole is still attractive, it draws things in, towards its center just like any other object. The difference is that nothing can ever reach its horizon. This is because the white hole is technically in "the past". So, because we can only travel towards the future, its impossible to go through it.
Based on my understanding, a black hole does not pull you in so hard that you can't get out of its event horizon, it removes the "out" geometrically so all directions take you to the singularity. similarly, a white hole removes the "in" curving all directions of space away from its singularity. so it's clear that there is no "reflection". the animations seem correct, the light travels through a straight line curved by the gravitational effect of the white hole.
@@thekid317 A white hole can be thought of as a black hole that happens to exist in a metric where time flows backwards. Since that particular worldline of light in the animation could not exist if the white hole were a black hole, it is cannot be the case with a white hole either. The correct scenario would be the light ray approaching the white hole's horizon. Correct me if im missing something
@@abstract_nonsense8683 I don't see that you're missing anything, but the thing is I highly disagree with the fact that the metric surrounding a white hole is reversing time, it is believed that a white hole does not push you out, it pulls you in exactly like a black hole and since time is running backwards the effect is played backwards too, but that's wrong because a black hole never pulls in at the first place, a black hole distorts spacetime so that all XYZ direction take you to its singularity. if a white hole is a black hole is a reversed time, it'll stay inescapable ad it'll look black, the real analogy is that a white hole distorts spacetime in a way that reveals time and all XYZ directions take you out. which means that a backwards time is not the cause of the lightpath, it's a consequence of the same effect behind the lightpath's bend, gravitations distortion
4:55 "We are able to stick it underneath our original hole" I dont want anything to stick underneath my hole... 😂😂
just wanted to point out that wormholes DEFINITELY WILL exert a huge amount of compression and/or decompression force on anything trying to enter/escape/cross it; because the liner momentum of the object's particles are along geodesics which converge and/or diverge by a huge degree. This might even give the travelers a nifty taste of some sweet sweet nuclear fusion and/or fission. Also might cause heat changes, melting/freezing the ship and the crew within.
I highly doubt the human body, that evolved on the african savannas for hunting meaty animals, can survive such topological torments. :'(
p.s. been a huge fan of this channel. love what u r doing.
"We didn't like the way the math initially told us the hole would form, so we made the math tell us another way"
That’s a very interesting thought, sometimes I wonder to what extent people have done this in other areas
"It just works!"
-guess who
Gerado Solusyon Todd Howard lol
This comment is somewhat beautiful. It's basically how science is being done (for better or worse).
Is this a critic, a comical portrayal of the science behind this concept, both or neither? I'm Legitimately curious
This channel is so underrated. This is million subscriber content right here.
I thought this was literally million subscriber content
True
We need to help this guy
He will get there!
Absolutely True!
1000x the better explanation than a documentary on cosmos
because network tv is more concerned with being woke and getting diversity hires than actually putting out good content
@@zwan1886 deadass
@@zwan1886 u say it like network tv i special in that regard
@@zwan1886 “OMG the gaes and feminists and blek peeal are literally destwoyin societee, woek badd 😡😡🤬”
@@zwan1886 uh, not that isn't the case.
I don't understand how such a high quality video has so few views. This is excellent content, sir, truly!
Edit: This comment was posted 8 months ago when the video only had a few thousand views. I'm glad to see that it has gained some of the attention that it deserves.
I wonder the same, he has made some very good ed videos and deserves atleast a million subs
It's due to the channel's relative youth. It's a translation to English of the original channel (with the same name) that is in French.
I also once commented the same....
Exactly
Well, the voice is kinda arrogant in the tone. It may repel some viewers.
If a wormhole couldn't bring us beyond it's time of creation, is it essentially a time checkpoint that human could travel back to at the end of the world
Except it was stated that one cannot travel 'to the past', which would have been a feature of the white hole should it have allowed travel.
@@epmcgee Agreed. What I got from this is that a wormhole connects 2 presents in different parts of space at the same time, unless you think of them as connecting different universes which may open the possibility of having the wormhole connect to a copy of this universe but in a different timeline or timeframe.
@@grggarro1 it's mentioned that time is also a dimension, and it mentions the function of the Einstein Rosen bridge where you move toward the future and not the past, hence travelling back through a white hole is impossible
@@epmcgee technically we can very easily time travel just go really fast(light speed) in space for a few years then come back and bam your time was like 20 years and theirs is like 20 years and a day!
@@grins9882 no
8:13 The fact that you're so close to a huge gravity generator ensures that, even if it only takes a few days to cross the wormhole, thousands of years have passed for everyone else.
This channel deserves more recognition for its quality
he needs to up his thumbnail game and sound a little bit more excited , he will blow up if he did so
same.
I am going through a period of depression these days, but your videos are so beautiful and stimulating they save my sanity by transporting me to a higher plane. Like looking at a starry sky (can't see many in London). Thank you.
👶
Learning Quantum Mechanics is what saved me from part of my depressive state when I had an existential crisis around determinism!
Best channel for scientific phenomenon so far...
Hats off to the creators.
I like you profile pic of the very first homosapien to exist. Very cool!
I landed on this video while executing my 10 minutes daily random video views.
1) I am blown away by the quality of the video: script, science content, graphical representation and animations.
2) There's a perfect balance between advanced concepts and simple explanations, context and good use of examples.
Super happy, discovered a pearl. Fairly certain that this channel will explode with millions of subscribers...
Also, by reading the comments, I'm super happy that the viewers are also surprised by the video quality and channel content, meaning that we all have similar quality threshold
Made my day!
yh
This was amazing. You seamlessly combined concepts that other TH-cam videos cover during multiple videos, yet you did it in 15 minutes, and in a vivid, easy to understand way. Loved it!
! GOD. The Quality of these videos...
You have a Patreon or something? Somewhere I can donate??
Very glad you like them ! I recently started a Patreon page : patreon.com/ScienceClic
Ima have to do the same
@@ScienceClicEN
Congo m8
@@ScienceClicEN
I'm poor, can't financially help, but stand here as an OG and Determined viewer.
@@TheRandomizerYT gr8 m8
I've watched this dudes videos 4 times already. This is my go to science Channel. I love so much. Thank you for explaining physics to us dumbs.
This content is fantastic! Feels like "In a Nutshell" mixed with the delivery of "Ahoy". So concise and easy to receive, props man!
Am a fan of science and especially theoretical physics, in fact, I have been so since my childhood, I saw thousands and thousands of sophisticated well made videos and documentaries, but this, this is a whole different level, to simplify all these complicated ideas and pack them in 15 min, that's a high-quality work 👌✨ "simplicity"
Truly high quality content, animation, narration and explanation of phenomenon! Well done!
Thank you !
@@ScienceClicEN What's wormholes character if they appear nested within each other's throats?
@@ScienceClicEN Thanks 😊 for the great knowledge
The quality of this video was incredible. You are literally the best educational TH-cam channel I have ever come across. If you keep this up, gret things are coming!
All those fancy documentaries that i have ever seen related to space or physiscs , not a single one of them could match the videos of this channel in terms of quality and details
Love the channel. Makes complex concepts much easier to understand. I’ve always struggled with understanding quantum mechanics but your videos have really helped me grasp that and many other concepts. You deserve more recognition. Keep up the great work
Should’ve came w me ;)
Holy shit! I didn't realize how few subscribers and views this channel has until I looked at the comments.
Wow. This is some professional content here!
subbed and liked^^
I predict that this channel would grow exponentially in the near Future
Yup
No, leave that to kittens on Tiktok. This channel will grow much further, based on quality, but growth will be steady. In 10 years I might review this comment, if I'm spared :)
Beautiful. Thank you so much for creating this.
I love this channel. You guys explain everything so well.
Imagine trying to cross a wormhole and getting trapped in a hellish nightmare for a quintillion years.
How heart gives out automatically when we go really fast or slow so no
And that's why you always have your gellar field always on.
@@ANTSEMUT1 plus we can navigate using our warp cores and dillithium crystals
Remember the good ol’ days when we thought this world was “normal”?
That was around 5000bc so I don’t know
@@rajeshdevkota4376 I think they believed some pretty wild, mystical stuff even in 5000bc.
@@gileee What about 50,000 BC?
@@crim22 I'm not sure. You'll have to ask them.
I think that’s called ignorance.
Chill narration, great animation.
A truly superb work. Thank you.
Aside from other factors being mentioned in the video, if the space inside the wormhole is being stretched outwards from its center in order for it to exist in a valid/cross-able form, wouldn't that make, things that go through , possible to be ripped apart *depending* on the force needed to have it opened the first place and sustained?
What a content, even If one doesn't know a thing about laws of relativity, he/she can find interesting stuffs throughout the video. Excellent work, keep working on your good works.
Thanks a lot 🙏
Your graphics are amazing! Really helps me grasp the concepts.
I like how you always bring up the formulas for everything
I like how you waited to near the end to drop the bomb that general relativity is not perfect.
I think there is some misconception that gives a lot of people mistaken idea of mass = gravity (higgs = graviton) when saying because of it's mass it distort the space time around it ( 0:45 ) , from what I understood after searchig for Higgs - graviton differences, it's the energy not the mass distorting the space-time, photons that are massless can also have gravity fields around them. Also theoretically a blackhole from photons can exist. Correct me if I'm wrong but that what I came out after searching for higgs - graviton correlation
yeah thats right
Brilliant video, black holes, worm holes and time dilation are some things I could talk about for hours and not get bored of it, fascinating.
Badass videos without even asking people to like or subscribe.. you know they will!
Extremely good and clear explanations of very tough themes, really glad, that youtube showed me this channel.
I love how spacetime is represented as a 3D fabric field rather than a 2D plane. It can be misleading to younger children to think that there is fixed direction in gravity.
yyyh
Ok but what happens if you FOLD that
I would like to ask you the next time you put a mathematical equation to mention the meaning of its parts and components, that would help a lot in understanding the philosophy of "why" and "how". thank you, u deserve respect for this excellent work.
This is my new favorite channel! Thank you so much for all your amazing videos! ❤
you explained gravity... with gravity
great
After taking a ton of math classes in college, I feel like I sort of understand now 🤯🤯🤯🤯
This channel explaining so intuitive
This is what i needed from longer time but don't know why it is underrated he explained very well
I always find it fascinating that we as humans don't have our scientific curiosity as our number one priority, or else videos like this would be at a billion views.
5:06 but would that be a whole or simply spacetime expanding everywhere equally? Kinda like what our universe does?
I loved your work. Very well explained .
At the time of writing this comment, I can see this channel has less than 140k subs. That's just criminal! You deserve a million plus, no question. Honestly, you're probably the best source for hi quality science explanations of topics that can get very confusing, very quickly! Hats off to everyone involved. 👏👏👏
This is one of my fav channel
Your doing a great work. Thankyou for your efforts that made us to understand quickly 💓💓
Very clearly explained
Amazing quality! Good visual representation can do wonders for education. Thanks a lot!
This is the first time I have heard fourthly, also the quality of this is unbelievable
Phenomenal work! This explain much more than the scientific theories.
Wow excellent videos! I can definitely see this channel blowing up
I suddenly feel *almost* smart!
0:31 the best graphic description of the fabric of space warped by gravity I've seen.
This is some genius work… thank you for your hard work!
Another great video. Would love to see your treatment of potential shapes of the universe, since I've never been able to understand that, and I bet you'd do a great job.
One side comment: you mention that quantum physics applies to microscopic stuff. It's funny people always say that, because electromagnetic waves can be the size of the Earth or bigger.
Now that's some real science, well done professor
way of presentation is super awesome. excellent explanation of all topics 👌👌
Gawd I love your content :) Thanks for such bad-ass videos. Legitimately original man ... this is the first time I've ever even seen a video about wormhole geometry and whether or not they can feasibly be crossed. Really fxk'n interesting :)
People watching in 2400:
people who have mastered time travel, please don't spoil it for this age like we did for year 2231
@@niclassjrslev4458 kid you legit have a Pokémon off your not a time traveler
@@sebastianlondono. look at this edge lord who can't take a joke.
@@niclassjrslev4458 look at the coper whos joke got btfo because it was shit :)
people in 2000: we're going to have wormholes by 2400
2400: banging rocks together because we had a nuclear war
this channel is underrated!
I love how logically everything is explained here 🌟
darn. really underrated channel
I don't understand how this channel doesn't have atleast 1million subs yet
Black holes are solid spheres of mass, not holes in ¨spacetime¨...
Yeah, it's pretty brazen how they manipulate folks' lack of understanding of the rubber sheet metaphor.
Black hole is not solid. It is just empty space with infinitely concentrated mass.
@@MEBVishwaS That´s a viewpoint not many physicists would agree with. When stars collapse into neutron stars, there[s still a super dense sphere there, it doesn´t magically disappear and it´s the same for the more dense black holes. No magic, just super dense spheres.
Neutron stars r solids cause they balance their gravitational force with the strong between neutrons. But black holes exceed that limit and became infinitely concentrated to zero dimensional point. It doesn't disappear but it is shrink to zero radius but it is there. If u fall into the black hole u won't hit it's surface cause it's not solid but u will be spagettified towards singularity. Physicist doesn't say it disappear but it is there, unreachable from our vision.
This guy doesn't even understand spacetime and quantom physics smh
Some really amazing sci-com 💛🌟⚡️
Commenting for the algorithm! Such masterpieces need to be heard by more people!
*_so it's possible that Spore is perfectly canon?_*
hell yes
When people start making up mathematical "possibilities" it ceases to be science and becomes wishful thinking. Still, it's interesting, and a fertile ground for science fiction.
If its mathematically possible but hasn't been observed or proven isn't it still science because its proven to be possible with the matj
Well information. Good show.
These are the kind of videos I enjoy. You did your research
I had a dream about this happening once and the way to get through the hole is two make a black hole made of a positive energy source and a black hole made of antimatter. Then push them together and it almost instantly resets time in the region of space and the hole is distilled at a time that is not toward or backwards
Wondering how you'd re-imagine this video with your new GR visualization in mind
An amazing video again!
excelent animation and explanation
12:50 the siri on mac has this switching manifold lol
Why?
Some Physicians (i think) think that wormholes using exotic matter, which have a negative mass. Am I saying false things that make no sense or you didn't take that in consideration? Although, thanks for the beautiful and very instructive video.
Thanks ! Indeed, I explain it at the end of the video : a stable wormhole would require negative energy / mass to exist. Matter with a negative mass (exotic matter) is thought to be impossible though.
@@ScienceClicENNice! Thank you so much!
Physicists not Physicians
@@uvofsam yea sry
Yeh you can put a minus sign where a plus should be. But thats not any kind of observed reality.
Great video ScienceClic English and I like your videos so much :]
The gravitational lensing of blackholes, white holes and wormholes look so pretty. It's like an extraterrestrial magnifying glass floating in space. It looks almost magical and majestic as you can see the stars behind bend and transition behind it.
I dont think that you wuld end up anywhere near a galaxy if you would exit (as radiation^^) a white whole...because it's a white whole xD
Maybe it is because of that that they can not be seen - because light cant show it to es either...it bounces away in all directions, so there cant be light hitting us directly. The spot pointing directly at us would be infinite small.
MAYBE...oof...this could be black matter. This is why it can not be detected...it pushes galaxies away from each other, because they can only exist between galaxies.
They cant be detected, because spycetime is only pointing away from them. So even if you try to look at it, the light you see was bounced and comes from somewhere else... (like a good magigician - doesnt matter how hard you try to look where he exchanges cards, he always fools you to look somewhere else)
I feel smart right now, but I am probably totally wrong xD
Indeed you are completely wrong. First of all that is not how we observe, the scattering of light would make an object more visible not less, a white hole would be ostensibly bright, brighter in fact than any other object in the universe.
How you link a white hole to dark matter is beyond me, like what?? This is being a peak layman, linking two completely different things together. It's like saying a sandwich isn't as fast as a boeing 777. Doesn't make any sense.
Dark matter doesn't push galaxies away, in fact the only property of dark matter we know is that it gravitationally 'binds' with other matter, so the opposite of pushing. Dark energy expands the universe and causes the increasing distance between distant galaxies.
12:51 Siri is just a string theory
Why?
@@ranjitsarkar3126 because the graphic used at that point of the video to express string theory looks like the graphic used on iPhone to express Siri.
@@tolsti1 ooh
😂😂😂
Grandiloquent but informative narration.
Man you deserve WAY more subs and views
The algorithm really hate you
"our universe"
Is this a critic on how we humans put a sort of possession label on the universe??? I kinda got confused there
In which case I think the video is correct, considering that there's the parallel universes theory going around, which also states that they might have different physics than ours. And given that the latter is necessary for explaining the video's subject, I think that there's no problem in saying "our universe" since this kind of precision might be necessary. Whereas with the possession thing, it might be inherent to some imprecision in modern English. That's my take on it.
Soviet Anthem plays
it was a joke and if you don't find it funny that's fine
It’s weird how sometimes you say something, and then you say the exact same thing a few seconds later with a different tone.
Ahah do you have an example of this ?
@@ScienceClicEN 3:39
The idea here is that the topology of space can allow holes, but if you travel towards this hole it will always close in on itself, therefore these holes are impossible to "probe" (the topological censorship states that the topology of space : its "holes", are impossible to probe)
Thank you for this amazing content
Great content. Amazing voice over.
Great video!
Very informative!
0:30. One of the better visuals of the fabric of space that I’ve seen before.
You seem to know exactly what I don't quite manage to understand from other videos and show exactly what I need to get it right. There's some information about a lot of things in my head, somewhat out of place or with missing connections, and you're videos just put them in the right order, connect them together.
thank you im so glad that i got the sceince behind white holes this is great work
Fantastic video.
You sir, have just earned yourself +1 sub for quality content.
Wow what an excellent explanation
This was really neat. Did you cover the other two types of wormholes displayed in this video ever?
Admin is a genius person .. and knowledgeble ..
your graphics was Insane 💥✌️
very good work!