"You want the victim to survive because they are a trove of information" damn, this guy is cold and probably a great detective, factual at every second
True Detective season 1 is not only the best serial killer/thriller TV show of all time, but legit one of the top 10 best single seasons of TV you'll ever see. It's so much more than just trying to find who's doing these murders.
What are some of the other seasons of shows you would watch? I loved house of cards season 1 and prison break 1 and a the Americans. I’m asking because I would like to be recommended a few and I’ve heard good things from true detective and somehow have not watched. Thanks
@@vigilante7 The Wire season 4 is maybe the best thing ever made for TV, but you'd want to watch 1-3 to get there, rather than on its own. Deadwood s1 is right up there too, and it works on its own if you don't want a huge time investment. But 3 seasons + the movie is time well spent.
I wish they gave guests more context. In True Detective, the second scene is when they're both PI and the reason he goes in the house alone is to find a phone since there's no cell reception. But he gave it a 9 so I'm good.
While you're not wrong, I prefer it when they get the "real" stuff correct in fantasy movies as it allows the fantasy elements to feel more believable.
In the 1960's TV series, Batman was fully deputized by Gotham City. Don't know about the films. I think they are pretentious, hyped, over produced junk.
I love the little touch in SILENCE OF THE LAMBS that the FBI guys use the nose stuff, but the undertaker (played by the great character actor Tracey Walter), who has presumably handled way more corpses, does not.
Seems like Dexter would have been a perfect show to rate 😂 also As a woman with long hair who merely works as a bartender, i am constantly distracted by portrayals of women at crime scenes or medical exams etc with loose hair & never have their hair up !!
I think the loose hair in the postmortems are due to it being combed for evidence which is standard in real life. At crime scenes probably because directors want to show it’s a woman plus long hair generally is seen as more attractive. Not realistic but a messy bun traditionally hasn’t brought in the ratings.
I'm also a woman with long hair (it goes down to the half-height of my hips), but I wear it loose most of the time unless I'm working out, taking a bath, or when it's oily. It's just my habit.
A point about Ed Kemper, he was is an extremely affable and cordial person, and he had a knack for ingratiating himself with authority figures. In both the mental hospital he spent time in as a youth after killing his grandparents and in prison he became someone that the authorities relied on to help keep order and to assist with different things. I believe he's doing less of those types of things because he's quite old and has had a stroke now.
Kemper has diabetes and suffered a stroke years ago. He also has coronary heart disease and a pacemaker. Although he is confined to a wheelchair. A psychiatric evaluation in April of 2024 ranked him as “high risk” to reoffend.
@@Sietse3399 Yeah that high risk evaluation is never gonna go. Not after several experts having judged him to be rehabilitated and well adjusted after the years he spent in psychiatric care, only for him to go on and do what he did. He's never getting out of prison, no matter how old or deteriorated health-wise he is going to get.
This detective is wrong on one point. The scene with Ed Kemper happened in real life except it was in an interview room and there were no chains whatsoever. Ed timed it at the changing of the guard so no guard was there to help Douglas when he stood up to intimidate him. Ed didn’t plan on doing anything, just letting him know that he could. It 100% happened.
According to Forensic Files (a documentary show about the forensics side of actual crimes), the shoe manufacturers (as well as tire manufacturers) have all agreed to make unique prints for each new style that comes out. A book of all existing prints is kept and updated regularly by both the police and the manufacturers-- all to help catch criminals. Criminals never fully appreciate how much effort and what lengths people will go to to catch a murderer.
In real life most serial killers are not scheming geniuses. They tend to be impulsive sociopaths, often with a history of head trauma. It would probably be better for society to portray them honestly, but that doesn't bring in $$$
Yeah but that's the thing, ''disorganized'' serial killers as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Even the detectives who interviewed him constantly admitted he was the smartest person in the room by far. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly isn't the most prolific serial killer in the history of the world because he's an ''impulsive sociopath with a history of head trauma''. This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
Yeah but that's the thing, the ''disorganized'' ones as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So they are the majority sure but there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Even the detectives who interviewed him constantly admitted he was the smartest person in the room by far. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly didn't get away with it for decades because he's an ''impulsive sociopath with a history of head trauma''. This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
Yeah but that's the thing, the ''disorganized'' ones as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So they are the majority sure but there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly didn't get away with it for decades because he was ''impulsive''. This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
As someone who works in wine I'd disagree, almost all of what we 'taste' is actually processed in your olfactory nerve, in your nasal cavity. With a blocked nose you can 'taste' very little. So breathing through your mouth will definitely limit what you both taste and smell.
@ maybe the times I’ve tasted disgusting things have actually involved breathing through both the mouth and nose. It’s kind of hard to avoid breathing through the nose unless you physically plug it. But I would still argue that some taste is likely to happen. It’s not an experiment that I am terribly eager to perform.
@@connorthompson8376 I must have a rare ability to block my nose passage/opening without using my fingers...I don't know of a single other person who uses my "breathe through your mouth" trick to avoid bad smells.
@adrianmyles4844wine and dead bodies age a bit differently, friend. I've only had to clean up items and materials that are contaminated with death, and even with that we would always use at the very least a half face mask respirator with biofilters
Interesting how he says that Kemper being left like that without guards would never happen even though that scene is taken from the book, don't remember if it's from Douglas's or Ressler's book, but it did happen
There’s a great moment in a movie called Out of Sight - my opinion, the best movie released in 1998 - where Jen Lopez’s character tells the strike team leader out to catch George Clooney and Ving Rhames that the ram that they brought to break into their apt wasn’t going to work because all the doors were steel. Great little detail! They end up using a shotgun round that supposedly would burst the door lock or hinges but they cut away before we can see how effective it was.
Between True Detective, Mindhunter, Se7en, Zodiac, and The Silence of tne Lambs, we have some of the greatest shows/flicks of all time. (And a lot of Fincher.) But True Detective reigns supreme.
The rule of TV/Movie writing is COULD it happen, not DID it happen. Hannibal was a Psychologist in the movie so it’s plausible he would try and diagnose people
Here wasn't just a psychiatrist, he was the killer's psychiatrist. He knew who it was and everything about him from the beginning. He was toying with them with all his pycho mumbo jumbo.
This gentleman is one of the most intelligent detectives I've heard speak. He has photographic memory. But by looking at him, you can tell by his expressions that this is the face of a man who's seen too many things.
Except he doesn't know why serial killers sometimes pose victims, and he's tasked with hunting them down from cold case's, also there is no such thing as a photographic memory
@lokuajc Just on crime shows. I admit I don't know what a good detective is, but this guy had a show on the Discovery channel, and he could recite the most minute details. Google him.
15:10 that wouldn't have really been a consideration back in 1969, since DNA testing wasn't discovered until the mid-70's (and even then was frequently wrong). In Zodiac's time, they could show the basic blood group the genetic sample belonged to (even then, they hadn't known about the positive and negative of each class), but that was about the extent of it.
Yes! I love this series, but I wish they evaluated historic scenes, like from Zodiac, in the context of best practices AT THAT TIME, not based on modern standards.
In Zodiac when the detective picked up the shell on his pen it was even worse than the clip shown here. He started gesturing with the pen and I wanted to see the evidence fall off and bounce into a storm drain.
I was listening to the Seven disc commentary track with Brad Pitt and he was saying that John C McGinley who played the SWAT leader was really amped up for playing the part. Said he was a great actor to work with too.
This guy was great, he seems like a very experienced detective. I loved Mind Hunter & Dahmer they paid attention to the little details and he gave em high ratings too!
Huge issue with Silence of the Lambs I just noticed. The victim was prone when the “star-shaped entrance wound over the sternum” line was delivered. If you’re prone, you’re lying on your sternum. No way to know the wound is on the sternum.
To be fair for the Seven movie, the reason the dont call back up was because they were there from illegal information from the FBI. They had to pay a hooker to tell the police that she was the one that call the detective to came to this allegedly killer apartement.
Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil, and Vile (Ted Bundy movie with Zac Efron) isn’t a movie that’s often talked about anymore, but I’ve always liked it and I’m glad it got some recognition
When the cops went into and searched Dahmer’s home one of the cops walked over to the fridge, opened it, and found a man’s head. That guy’s, understandably, been afraid to go near fridges since then.
Thoughts on the lipstick killer? specifically due to his message written on a wall near one of his victims in lipstick saying "For heaven's sake catch me before I kill more I cannot stop myself". I mean, if he sincerely wanted to be caught why not just turn himself in as Edmund Kemper did? Was it in hopes of in case he DID get caught using it to show he was ill (and thereby try for an insanity plea, even though that wouldn't work as the note itself shows he knew what he was doing was wrong). Curious what you all think of that one.
Mr.Pat Thank you for appearing in Insider. I could underdtand the doubts I had for a long time,and was able to solve them. I`m a fan of Hitchcock and Thomas Harris,Stephen King. However sometimes it was too biblical, My ideas which camefrom many works became simlplifiesd. (for example,on the backgrounds of roots,religous reasons) I was relieverd to know "Hannnibal`s case is a little over the top". Evenif I know, I have kept to love the movie. I cannnot want to say too loudly,but this kind of American crime shows is very popular in my country, and is supported by many people.
He was a cop for 32 years in Nashville. He's got the stereotypical cop mustache. And yet his voice, his accent, it sounds very old, Irish New York city. Just saying. He pronounced the word killer as killah. I notice these things.
Reminder most serial killers that go on long sprees without getting caught are usually the result of incompetent cops not them being criminal masterminds.
@drax065 basically every serial killers was nearly caught multiple times. Dahmer killed ten more people because a cop refused to help a victim he thought was gay
@@drax065watch a timeline of the cases of Jeffrey Dahmer and John Wayne Gacy in particular, they each had huge glaring events where the police ran into people they were trying to kill and they completely ignored a billion red flags. They turned one of Dahmer's victims back over to him after he escaped from his apartment naked with a hole drilled in his head and tracked down some cops. Dahmer showed up and said "oh don't mind him" and dragged him back home and finished killing him.
No way to know that. Serial killers are extremely difficult to catch, especially when they kill with the sole motive of "killing someone". If you have no personal link to the victim you are pretty much impossible to catch. Reminder that only 54% of murders are solved in the US. And most of those are family members or partners killing one another.
Ok, I have an issue with what this detective said about serial killers and how Hannibal Lector. Ted Bundy is a prime example and FBI agents talked to him for HOURS and the insight they learned from him was incredible. So there are really Hannibal Lectors in the world.
*EDIT: I apologize I didn’t finish a sentence: how he talked about how Hannibal Lector talked towards Agent Sterling. Ted Bundy WAS this kind of person.
Stop asking these guests what their favourite clip was from what was SHOWN. We clearly can tell what those are by looking at the ratings they give. Instead ask (which you have done in some videos actually) what is your favourite movie/tv clip that they've ever seen on the topic
Ok I got a question: He worked 75 Cold Cases and 6 Serial Killer Cases, my question is this how in the F does he know what it’s like to walk into a crime scene (Because I’m willing to bet the Serial Killer cases were cold cases as well).
He’s got more experience with serial killers than you do. Thats why they didn’t interview you for the video, random internet armchair criminal expert. You know it’s ok to leave mom’s basement every once in a while, right? Go get some fresh air, bruh. You need it.
@Bishop228 buddy. I have a very good familiarity with the job titles detectives have. Plenty of comments here are confused thinking he was a SERIAL KILLER and a detective. That's the point.
Notification popped up and I thought they brought in a serial killer to rate these scenes.
"I would have eaten him, personally"
Lol same
That would have been mad though
Maybe he's a serial killer killer
Not this time, but I wouldn’t be surprised
Him giving True Detective such a high mark, validates that season even more as one of the best stand alone seasons of any show.
True Detective first series was brilliant.
Facts.
"You want the victim to survive because they are a trove of information" damn, this guy is cold and probably a great detective, factual at every second
I thought we want them to survive because, you know, its sad when people die
Bro I missed the “detective “ part of the title I thought y’all deadass had a serial killer reviewing movie scenes 😂
🤣 same
😂😂😂😂
Yeah I thought they were just being edgy
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Would be interesting video
True Detective season 1 is not only the best serial killer/thriller TV show of all time, but legit one of the top 10 best single seasons of TV you'll ever see. It's so much more than just trying to find who's doing these murders.
What are some of the other seasons of shows you would watch?
I loved house of cards season 1 and prison break 1 and a the Americans. I’m asking because I would like to be recommended a few and I’ve heard good things from true detective and somehow have not watched. Thanks
I agree, season one of true detective is still my favorite show
Time is a flat circle
@@vigilante7Deadwood, Rome, Sopranos seasons 1
@@vigilante7 The Wire season 4 is maybe the best thing ever made for TV, but you'd want to watch 1-3 to get there, rather than on its own.
Deadwood s1 is right up there too, and it works on its own if you don't want a huge time investment. But 3 seasons + the movie is time well spent.
In Se7en, the reason they didn’t call for backup was because they weren’t supposed to be there.
I wish they gave guests more context. In True Detective, the second scene is when they're both PI and the reason he goes in the house alone is to find a phone since there's no cell reception. But he gave it a 9 so I'm good.
How this man spent that many years in Nashville and still has an Italian American New York accent idek lmao iconic
Lol. I was thinking the same thing!
If I moved to Tennessee, I'd keep my accent out of spite.
He can't pronounce his own name properly tho.. posti gl iooon
instead of postiliooné
@@stijnvandamme76 you tried to correct him and spelled it wrong as well. At least get it right yourself dawg lmao
If you move when you’re a grownup most people keep the accent that had
Good to see someone willing to give 10s. Too many are like, this was spot on... eight out of ten, lol
Right? lol
For the Batman... is it customary to have masked vigilantes investigating crime scenes?
While you're not wrong, I prefer it when they get the "real" stuff correct in fantasy movies as it allows the fantasy elements to feel more believable.
No but, I've heard of third party investigators such as self proclaimed mediums/psychics being brought in to assess a scene
In the 1960's TV series, Batman was fully deputized by Gotham City. Don't know about the films. I think they are pretentious, hyped, over produced junk.
I'd love an entire video just on the Mindhunter :) there is so much more than just these 2 clips
This guy is phenomenally matter of fact and informative. Love this one.
I love the little touch in SILENCE OF THE LAMBS that the FBI guys use the nose stuff, but the undertaker (played by the great character actor Tracey Walter), who has presumably handled way more corpses, does not.
That was my thinking too as it shows Clarice s lack of experience with corpses. I think he raised it because of his experience it seems unusual to hom
@@nayrbmc2452Her boss does it too, and he is an FBI veteran.
Fun fact: the other coroner, the older guy, was played by Kenneth Utt, one of the producers. He’s the guy who said “Wrongful death”.
This is one of my favorite movies. Of course Hannibal was over the top, he a narcissistic sociopath! 10/10.
Hannibal wasn’t just a serial killer though. He was a forensic psychiatrist. So Clarice wasn’t just interviewing a serial killer.
Seems like Dexter would have been a perfect show to rate 😂 also As a woman with long hair who merely works as a bartender, i am constantly distracted by portrayals of women at crime scenes or medical exams etc with loose hair & never have their hair up !!
I think the loose hair in the postmortems are due to it being combed for evidence which is standard in real life.
At crime scenes probably because directors want to show it’s a woman plus long hair generally is seen as more attractive. Not realistic but a messy bun traditionally hasn’t brought in the ratings.
Dexter would get about a 1
I'm also a woman with long hair (it goes down to the half-height of my hips), but I wear it loose most of the time unless I'm working out, taking a bath, or when it's oily. It's just my habit.
I only watched Bones and I love that that her hair is almost always up when she's at the crime scene
How is it possible that dude lived in Nashville for over 3 decades and still sounds like he’s a Brooklyn cab driver.
I said the same exact thing. This guy doesn't sound like he's from Nashville.
I bet his extended family still lives there, so every time he visits or they visit him it reinforces the accent
A point about Ed Kemper, he was is an extremely affable and cordial person, and he had a knack for ingratiating himself with authority figures. In both the mental hospital he spent time in as a youth after killing his grandparents and in prison he became someone that the authorities relied on to help keep order and to assist with different things.
I believe he's doing less of those types of things because he's quite old and has had a stroke now.
He seemed to get along with men well socially - but women… well, that’s another story.
Kemper has diabetes and suffered a stroke years ago. He also has coronary heart disease and a pacemaker. Although he is confined to a wheelchair. A psychiatric evaluation in April of 2024 ranked him as “high risk” to reoffend.
@@annwilliams6438 I think he became unhinged when being interviewed by women.
@@Sietse3399 Yeah that high risk evaluation is never gonna go. Not after several experts having judged him to be rehabilitated and well adjusted after the years he spent in psychiatric care, only for him to go on and do what he did. He's never getting out of prison, no matter how old or deteriorated health-wise he is going to get.
This detective is wrong on one point. The scene with Ed Kemper happened in real life except it was in an interview room and there were no chains whatsoever. Ed timed it at the changing of the guard so no guard was there to help Douglas when he stood up to intimidate him. Ed didn’t plan on doing anything, just letting him know that he could. It 100% happened.
Thank you was about 2 say that
The way he was so sure of it too. Impossible he said.
@@jeffvideau maybe its impossible now because something like this happened
@@jeffvideau
Yep, makes one question everything he said
You beat me to it
According to Forensic Files (a documentary show about the forensics side of actual crimes), the shoe manufacturers (as well as tire manufacturers) have all agreed to make unique prints for each new style that comes out. A book of all existing prints is kept and updated regularly by both the police and the manufacturers-- all to help catch criminals. Criminals never fully appreciate how much effort and what lengths people will go to to catch a murderer.
In real life most serial killers are not scheming geniuses. They tend to be impulsive sociopaths, often with a history of head trauma. It would probably be better for society to portray them honestly, but that doesn't bring in $$$
What percentage of normies have head trauma?
🌴👀🌴…Tua?
Yeah but that's the thing, ''disorganized'' serial killers as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Even the detectives who interviewed him constantly admitted he was the smartest person in the room by far. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly isn't the most prolific serial killer in the history of the world because he's an ''impulsive sociopath with a history of head trauma''.
This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
Yeah but that's the thing, the ''disorganized'' ones as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So they are the majority sure but there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Even the detectives who interviewed him constantly admitted he was the smartest person in the room by far. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly didn't get away with it for decades because he's an ''impulsive sociopath with a history of head trauma''.
This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
Yeah but that's the thing, the ''disorganized'' ones as he called them just...get caught. Almost immediately. So they are the majority sure but there is no show or movie about them because almost no one has heard of any of them. The ones people know about are very much the ''scheming geniuses''. Ed Kemper, for example, only got caught because he wanted to be caught. Or the Zodiak never even got caught precisely because he was a methodical schemer. And doctor Harold Shipman certainly didn't get away with it for decades because he was ''impulsive''.
This is like complaining about a movie about the best tennis players in the world by replying with: ''most tennis players aren't that good''. Well that's exactly why you don't know most tennis players ain't it?
I understand wanting to avoid breathing through the nose to avoid a smell, but then you taste it if you breathe through your mouth.
As someone who has worked in healthcare, I strongly agree with your assessment
As someone who works in wine I'd disagree, almost all of what we 'taste' is actually processed in your olfactory nerve, in your nasal cavity. With a blocked nose you can 'taste' very little. So breathing through your mouth will definitely limit what you both taste and smell.
@ maybe the times I’ve tasted disgusting things have actually involved breathing through both the mouth and nose. It’s kind of hard to avoid breathing through the nose unless you physically plug it. But I would still argue that some taste is likely to happen. It’s not an experiment that I am terribly eager to perform.
@@connorthompson8376 I must have a rare ability to block my nose passage/opening without using my fingers...I don't know of a single other person who uses my "breathe through your mouth" trick to avoid bad smells.
@adrianmyles4844wine and dead bodies age a bit differently, friend.
I've only had to clean up items and materials that are contaminated with death, and even with that we would always use at the very least a half face mask respirator with biofilters
11:10 "You want the victim to survive." Wow. I love this behind the badge stuff.
Professional and extremely clear explanations.
Very much agree it’s like watching the ^God Logic podcasts 😮
Interesting how he says that Kemper being left like that without guards would never happen even though that scene is taken from the book, don't remember if it's from Douglas's or Ressler's book, but it did happen
It happened with Ressler.
19:05 I remember the FBI agents' talking about the interview with Kemper, 2 on 1 with no guards around
There’s a great moment in a movie called Out of Sight - my opinion, the best movie released in 1998 - where Jen Lopez’s character tells the strike team leader out to catch George Clooney and Ving Rhames that the ram that they brought to break into their apt wasn’t going to work because all the doors were steel. Great little detail! They end up using a shotgun round that supposedly would burst the door lock or hinges but they cut away before we can see how effective it was.
Great stuff, Insider! Keep 'em coming!
Between True Detective, Mindhunter, Se7en, Zodiac, and The Silence of tne Lambs, we have some of the greatest shows/flicks of all time. (And a lot of Fincher.) But True Detective reigns supreme.
True Detective Season 1 is one of the greatest things ever. Dont even bother with the other seasons.
Thanks for the tip. Hate when a show goes downhill so fast. Like the wire... gonna get rekt over that opinion prolly lol
How they even called the next seasons by the same name as beyond me.
The rule of TV/Movie writing is COULD it happen, not DID it happen. Hannibal was a Psychologist in the movie so it’s plausible he would try and diagnose people
Here wasn't just a psychiatrist, he was the killer's psychiatrist. He knew who it was and everything about him from the beginning. He was toying with them with all his pycho mumbo jumbo.
This gentleman is one of the most intelligent detectives I've heard speak. He has photographic memory. But by looking at him, you can tell by his expressions that this is the face of a man who's seen too many things.
Except he doesn't know why serial killers sometimes pose victims, and he's tasked with hunting them down from cold case's, also there is no such thing as a photographic memory
Heard many detectives have you?
@lokuajc Just on crime shows. I admit I don't know what a good detective is, but this guy had a show on the Discovery channel, and he could recite the most minute details. Google him.
15:10 that wouldn't have really been a consideration back in 1969, since DNA testing wasn't discovered until the mid-70's (and even then was frequently wrong). In Zodiac's time, they could show the basic blood group the genetic sample belonged to (even then, they hadn't known about the positive and negative of each class), but that was about the extent of it.
Yes! I love this series, but I wish they evaluated historic scenes, like from Zodiac, in the context of best practices AT THAT TIME, not based on modern standards.
In Zodiac when the detective picked up the shell on his pen it was even worse than the clip shown here. He started gesturing with the pen and I wanted to see the evidence fall off and bounce into a storm drain.
I was listening to the Seven disc commentary track with Brad Pitt and he was saying that John C McGinley who played the SWAT leader was really amped up for playing the part. Said he was a great actor to work with too.
Love these!!!!
Next video "Serial Killer Rates Serial Killer Movies".
This guy wrote an excellent book. Worth reading for sure.
The book is written by Michael Arntfield. Not sure why you would say that when it clearly isn't.
@@Johnnystrangeways it's called making a mistake. I remembered the detective's name not the author. And I was going off memory. A fickle thing.
@ it's easy to double check before you post misinformation online but you admitted to it so it's all good.
@@Johnnystrangeways it's also easy to do things in a rush. Jesus you're a pedantic twat
This guy was great, he seems like a very experienced detective.
I loved Mind Hunter & Dahmer they paid attention to the little details and he gave em high ratings too!
WOW, that is one lovely suit you are wearing. I love it! 😃
True Detective Season 1 is 10 out of 10 no matter what
Huge issue with Silence of the Lambs I just noticed. The victim was prone when the “star-shaped entrance wound over the sternum” line was delivered. If you’re prone, you’re lying on your sternum. No way to know the wound is on the sternum.
To be fair for the Seven movie, the reason the dont call back up was because they were there from illegal information from the FBI. They had to pay a hooker to tell the police that she was the one that call the detective to came to this allegedly killer apartement.
He actually sounds like a detective😂
Kemper was a huge human being like 6’9” 300lbs with a genius IQ to
> to
to what?
Good to see I wasn't the only one to misread the title.
How matter of factly this guy talks about bodies he’s seen to much death😬
I'm in healthcare and it's crazy how comfortable you have to be with death and the process
Brilliant as usual
Would be EPIC if you could get a serial killer to rate serial killer movies 😂
I love this guys show, Deadly Recall, on ID.
11:10 I have always loved how the victim has 3 hands :D
Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil, and Vile (Ted Bundy movie with Zac Efron) isn’t a movie that’s often talked about anymore, but I’ve always liked it and I’m glad it got some recognition
Damn. This dude’s a g
Bring him on true crime podcast
14:00 not surprised Ted Cruz was "organized"
When the cops went into and searched Dahmer’s home one of the cops walked over to the fridge, opened it, and found a man’s head. That guy’s, understandably, been afraid to go near fridges since then.
Opened the comments to say what many people have already said. About missing the "detective" part in the title
Thoughts on the lipstick killer? specifically due to his message written on a wall near one of his victims in lipstick saying "For heaven's sake catch me before I kill more I cannot stop myself". I mean, if he sincerely wanted to be caught why not just turn himself in as Edmund Kemper did? Was it in hopes of in case he DID get caught using it to show he was ill (and thereby try for an insanity plea, even though that wouldn't work as the note itself shows he knew what he was doing was wrong). Curious what you all think of that one.
Off topic I can't still get over with the fact that they casted Pattinson as Batman lol
Surreal
Mr.Pat
Thank you for appearing in Insider.
I could underdtand the doubts I had for a long time,and was able to solve them.
I`m a fan of Hitchcock and Thomas Harris,Stephen King.
However sometimes it was too biblical, My ideas which camefrom many works became simlplifiesd.
(for example,on the backgrounds of roots,religous reasons)
I was relieverd to know "Hannnibal`s case is a little over the top".
Evenif I know, I have kept to love the movie.
I cannnot want to say too loudly,but this kind of American crime shows is very popular in my country,
and is supported by many people.
Should've had him watch "Manhunter"
Are you blind and deaf?
Have to get him again for Dexter and Hannibal
21:33 hmm i am fairly ambidextrous....like 90% in my left arm. I'll remember this . . .
For no other reason 😂
He was a cop for 32 years in Nashville. He's got the stereotypical cop mustache. And yet his voice, his accent, it sounds very old, Irish New York city. Just saying.
He pronounced the word killer as killah. I notice these things.
Are we sure this guy ain't cereal killing? Have we checked on Captain crunch
Can’t believe psych wasn’t on here.
So a movie about a fictional superhero doesn't portray criminal investigation accurately. Really?
Wasn't bite mark "science" debunked multiple times?
I believe it is now used (when reasonably distinct) as exclusionary evidence rather than as inclusionary evidence.
Yes. A lot of "science" the police use is just bullshit. But there's an entire industry based around junk science and paid "professional witnesses"
I have learned much from this guy
Reminder most serial killers that go on long sprees without getting caught are usually the result of incompetent cops not them being criminal masterminds.
How do you know that? I am curious.
@drax065 basically every serial killers was nearly caught multiple times. Dahmer killed ten more people because a cop refused to help a victim he thought was gay
@drax065 look up john balczerak and you will understand
@@drax065watch a timeline of the cases of Jeffrey Dahmer and John Wayne Gacy in particular, they each had huge glaring events where the police ran into people they were trying to kill and they completely ignored a billion red flags. They turned one of Dahmer's victims back over to him after he escaped from his apartment naked with a hole drilled in his head and tracked down some cops. Dahmer showed up and said "oh don't mind him" and dragged him back home and finished killing him.
No way to know that.
Serial killers are extremely difficult to catch, especially when they kill with the sole motive of "killing someone".
If you have no personal link to the victim you are pretty much impossible to catch.
Reminder that only 54% of murders are solved in the US. And most of those are family members or partners killing one another.
9:11
There's your killer. His name is Dennis Reynolds
Breathe through your mouth? No sir.
You should check out Hannibal.
Hm, maybe this video wasn't the best to watch during dinner
Ok, I have an issue with what this detective said about serial killers and how Hannibal Lector. Ted Bundy is a prime example and FBI agents talked to him for HOURS and the insight they learned from him was incredible. So there are really Hannibal Lectors in the world.
*EDIT: I apologize I didn’t finish a sentence: how he talked about how Hannibal Lector talked towards Agent Sterling. Ted Bundy WAS this kind of person.
If serial killer guy and trench guy collaborated for a video, would it cause the space time continuum to implode? Let’s find out😂
Stop asking these guests what their favourite clip was from what was SHOWN. We clearly can tell what those are by looking at the ratings they give.
Instead ask (which you have done in some videos actually) what is your favourite movie/tv clip that they've ever seen on the topic
I'm still waiting for "active serial killer rates serial killers in movies" Cmon get your sh*t together Insider!
Experts tells all.
Ok I got a question: He worked 75 Cold Cases and 6 Serial Killer Cases, my question is this how in the F does he know what it’s like to walk into a crime scene (Because I’m willing to bet the Serial Killer cases were cold cases as well).
I actually thought they have brought a serial killer
why did he say the zodiac killer has been “killing people since the 1970s”?
Cause he said
Guy does not sound like a Nashville resident. Nashville Brooklyn?
Usem o recurso de dublagem automática do TH-cam, para outras línguas.
When you look into his eyes and realize he has seen things.
it's a shame he didn't watch "dexter"
I can't believe this guy was the Bay Harbor Butcher.
the San Francisco Penatrator
It interesting but scary how it explain of the humans condition
Hold on what do they mean by they never found him again.
Can you guys do a rugby player reviews rugby movies/TV
Bonus points if it's a saffa so they can critique Matt Damon's accent.
I appreciate the casting of Ted bunny. The actor does have a resemblance albeit a superficial one. Why is Sheldon the prosecutor?
Good detective but forgets about context of the clips.. kemper bit he was wrong
That was db cooper. Not the zodiac.
No Dexter? 😅
8:29 so lividity is coagulated blood and stuff andf it wont move no matter what?
This guy doesn't sound like he's from Nashville.
Change that title lmao. Hes not a "serial killer detective" hes a cold case detective/homicide detective. "Serial killer detective" isnt a thing.
He’s got more experience with serial killers than you do. Thats why they didn’t interview you for the video, random internet armchair criminal expert. You know it’s ok to leave mom’s basement every once in a while, right? Go get some fresh air, bruh. You need it.
@@Bishop228 lmao omg
@Bishop228 buddy. I have a very good familiarity with the job titles detectives have. Plenty of comments here are confused thinking he was a SERIAL KILLER and a detective. That's the point.
@@Bishop228 also the saints suck
@@Bishop228 you're a Gemini. Found a lot more info than that about ya.
How dare he go after the goat rust cohle
don't worry, Rust will always be our goat. if he watched the show, he would've rated rust alone 10/10
@ hehe been ten years time to rewatch
Should've given Seven a 7.
Hannibal Lecter wasn't doing an 'analysis': he was directing them to what he wanted them to see at any given stage>
The title is wrong on many levels. Please reword 😏
whats detective doing then if rime scene investigators do all that at the scene?