Lows: Tie. All 3 showes support on all notes showcased here (except for Mariah's D3 which had a very low larynx, and Christina's Eb3 which was airy). Chest: Beyonce for technique and effortlessness , Christina for technique (they were not sung with a bad technique) and tone, and Mariah in between. Btw Mariah's C5 and Christina's C5 sound really similar. High notes: Beyonce, Christina>>>Mariah. Love the notes you used.
+Elizabeth Rey Mariah 's D3 is slighty low larynx but only slighty,Mariah is technique at belting is as good as beyonce's both are can keep an neutral larynx and mariah had some problems whit belting but they were mostly because of her nodules,High notes? Mariah can go up to A6 easy when she warming up her whistles,Beyonce can't go above the C#6/D6 and Xtina can't go above the Eb6,and in headvoice Beyonce>Mariah>Xtina,Beyonce is really the most connected,but mariah can go up to D6 in headvoice easy,Xtina can only use falsetto
mnjim Mariah can only go up to A6 using disconnected whistle register (which doesnt count in opera) the highest shes done in full head voice is Eb6/E6 (which is pretty standard for a soprano). Also, Christina has sustained a C6 with head voice but being a light lyric her head voice can be misinterpreted as falsetto. Like Christina, Mariah opts for 6th octave notes using disconnected falsetto or whistle register rarely ever using her head voice. Out of the three, Beyonce is by far the best technical singer (Mariah &Christina's upper belts are almost non-existent lately and when hit they sound labored, strained or squeezed). Beyonce sings with absolute freedom and ease.
+mrvocal21 yeah but whistles don't produce strain in your voice and her whistles sound very pleasant,Aguilera use mostly falsetto,beyonce have the most connected headvoice i am agree but mariah's headvoice is also very connected,the problem is that the nodules block your access to headvoice whit easy however she used headvoice in 1990-1994 and a lot of times in charmbracelet era and also in 2015 she went up C#6 in headvoice in all the infinity performances ,Christina aguilera's belts are much more strained than mariah's,Mariah is very decent up to E5 since winter of 2015,Christina is very inconsistent and she have more strain issues than mariah,i know that beyonce is belting is better than hers,but her problems in upper belts are because of her nodules,her technique is good,If she remove her nodules she could belt up to G5 effortless.
mnjim "But but whistles don't produce strain in your voice" and falsetto does? disconnected is disconnected and both Mariah and Christina uses disconnected register to produce their 6th octave notes, Beyonce doesnt. ",If she remove her nodules she could belt up to G5 effortless." - doubt that, even in her prime Mariah was pushing her G's plus she would lose her whistle register
The mother MC vs. her 2 daughters. Ther 3 did it amazing last year. ;) I think you should pick better Eb5s to Christina, the rest is okay, her E5 tho O.o.
I must admit that Mariah kills her daughters with their resonance haha Yeah, I should put Eb5 's best Xtina , but were Eb5 's she only sustained this year! I think that Eb5 was pretty good still! Do not know if you 've noticed, but all notes of both from A4 to Eb5 are sustained! E5 's were phrases!
Lows:Xtina has low larynx sometimes but her lows sound rich, Mariah has a good lower register down to E3/Eb3, Beyonce is quite good but she sounds breathy sometimes bellow the D3. Belting:Beyonce is the best she sound quite effortless up to F5 and her belting is quite resonant,Mariah can belt up to C#5/D5 effortless and her technique and resonance is nice (although she sounds nasal), Xtina can support up to G4/G#4 ,but her technique is just too inconsistent. Headvoice:Beyonce is the best again she can go up to C6 easy,Mariah and Xtina use falsetto
Beyonce (she can stay down there forever and technique is great plus she keeps her tone all the way through) Mariah (not at her prime but her voice is still great) Xtina (beautiful tone and I love that she is using better technique)
They both are vocal legends hands down but.. 1 . Beyoncé - still the same after 16 years with ordinary voice but awesome technic she is boring af but still the most relevant hands down! 20 Mariah - Far from her prime being able to hit 3 stable notes in mid chest, her stage presentation is terrible just sitting there and singing thick resonant notes. I am glad she doesn't lip sync anymore. 3.Christina (I adore her) still has her beautiful, amazing, unique, extraordinary tone which got better but abuses her voice in ways that are painfull to hear. As a fighter I love her straining but now I prefer just her singing soft and light.. Not singing like wild animal... That were the bad things but I am saying it again, they are vocal legends(since there is no JB, no Etta, no Whitney...) and the today pop singers are nothing compared to them.
+Kamilar135 Mariah out of prime>>current xtina. Mariah's songwriting skills and production skills>>bey and Xtina. Only one legend here and that's Mariah. The other 2 are icons.
Christina surprised me on the low notes. SING!
I recently found her background vocals where she SANG 30 D3s 8 B2s and an A2. It's in my channel. The song is show me how you burlesque
Lows: Tie. All 3 showes support on all notes showcased here (except for Mariah's D3 which had a very low larynx, and Christina's Eb3 which was airy).
Chest: Beyonce for technique and effortlessness , Christina for technique (they were not sung with a bad technique) and tone, and Mariah in between. Btw Mariah's C5 and Christina's C5 sound really similar.
High notes: Beyonce, Christina>>>Mariah.
Love the notes you used.
+Elizabeth Rey I agree.
+Elizabeth Rey Mariah 's D3 is slighty low larynx but only slighty,Mariah is technique at belting is as good as beyonce's both are can keep an neutral larynx and mariah had some problems whit belting but they were mostly because of her nodules,High notes? Mariah can go up to A6 easy when she warming up her whistles,Beyonce can't go above the C#6/D6 and Xtina can't go above the Eb6,and in headvoice Beyonce>Mariah>Xtina,Beyonce is really the most connected,but mariah can go up to D6 in headvoice easy,Xtina can only use falsetto
mnjim Mariah can only go up to A6 using disconnected whistle register (which doesnt count in opera) the highest shes done in full head voice is Eb6/E6 (which is pretty standard for a soprano). Also, Christina has sustained a C6 with head voice but being a light lyric her head voice can be misinterpreted as falsetto. Like Christina, Mariah opts for 6th octave notes using disconnected falsetto or whistle register rarely ever using her head voice. Out of the three, Beyonce is by far the best technical singer (Mariah &Christina's upper belts are almost non-existent lately and when hit they sound labored, strained or squeezed). Beyonce sings with absolute freedom and ease.
+mrvocal21 yeah but whistles don't produce strain in your voice and her whistles sound very pleasant,Aguilera use mostly falsetto,beyonce have the most connected headvoice i am agree but mariah's headvoice is also very connected,the problem is that the nodules block your access to headvoice whit easy however she used headvoice in 1990-1994 and a lot of times in charmbracelet era and also in 2015 she went up C#6 in headvoice in all the infinity performances ,Christina aguilera's belts are much more strained than mariah's,Mariah is very decent up to E5 since winter of 2015,Christina is very inconsistent and she have more strain issues than mariah,i know that beyonce is belting is better than hers,but her problems in upper belts are because of her nodules,her technique is good,If she remove her nodules she could belt up to G5 effortless.
mnjim "But but whistles don't produce strain in your voice" and falsetto does? disconnected is disconnected and both Mariah and Christina uses disconnected register to produce their 6th octave notes, Beyonce doesnt. ",If she remove her nodules she could belt up to G5 effortless." - doubt that, even in her prime Mariah was pushing her G's plus she would lose her whistle register
D3: Mariah
Eb3: Beyoncé
E3: Xtina
F3: Bey
F#3: Xtina
G3: Xtina
A4: Bey
Bb4: Bey
B4: Bey
C5: Mariah
C#5: Bey
D5: Xtina
Eb5: Mariah
E5: Mariah
F5: Xtina
F#5: Mariah
G5: Xtina
G#5 and A5: Mariah
C6: Mariah!!!!!
For me its Beyonce >>>> Christina >> Mariah ( I dont like the tone shes acquired). Just my take
The mother MC vs. her 2 daughters. Ther 3 did it amazing last year. ;) I think you should pick better Eb5s to Christina, the rest is okay, her E5 tho O.o.
I must admit that Mariah kills her daughters with their resonance haha Yeah, I should put Eb5 's best Xtina , but were Eb5 's she only sustained this year! I think that Eb5 was pretty good still! Do not know if you 've noticed, but all notes of both from A4 to Eb5 are sustained! E5 's were phrases!
by technique Beyonce is better than both, and Mariah has better belts and lows than Christina but Christina is better at falsetto.
Lows:Xtina has low larynx sometimes but her lows sound rich, Mariah has a good lower register down to E3/Eb3, Beyonce is quite good but she sounds breathy sometimes bellow the D3.
Belting:Beyonce is the best she sound quite effortless up to F5 and her belting is quite resonant,Mariah can belt up to C#5/D5 effortless and her technique and resonance is nice (although she sounds nasal), Xtina can support up to G4/G#4 ,but her technique is just too inconsistent.
Headvoice:Beyonce is the best again she can go up to C6 easy,Mariah and Xtina use falsetto
christina
beyonce
mariah
Mario Ruiz de Chavez get some help
Beyonce (she can stay down there forever and technique is great plus she keeps her tone all the way through)
Mariah (not at her prime but her voice is still great)
Xtina (beautiful tone and I love that she is using better technique)
Beyoncè>>>Christina=Mariah
They both are vocal legends hands down but..
1 . Beyoncé - still the same after 16 years with ordinary voice but awesome technic she is boring af but still the most relevant hands down!
20 Mariah - Far from her prime being able to hit 3 stable notes in mid chest, her stage presentation is terrible just sitting there and singing thick resonant notes. I am glad she doesn't lip sync anymore.
3.Christina (I adore her) still has her beautiful, amazing, unique, extraordinary tone which got better but abuses her voice in ways that are painfull to hear. As a fighter I love her straining but now I prefer just her singing soft and light.. Not singing like wild animal...
That were the bad things but I am saying it again, they are vocal legends(since there is no JB, no Etta, no Whitney...) and the today pop singers are nothing compared to them.
+Kamilar135 Mariah out of prime>>current xtina. Mariah's songwriting skills and production skills>>bey and Xtina. Only one legend here and that's Mariah. The other 2 are icons.
Emanuel Guerrero @ Mariah being a legend. I can't even name her songs lol
xtina
Mariah
beyonce
Mariah
Bey
Tina
Bey has flawless C6's