Surya Bhattacharya is undoubtedly a good singer, with a nourished and practised voice. He also is melodious with a commendable classic base. I have followed many of his programmed in U-tube. The problem is, Manna Dey is a legend, and each detail of his songs is deeply engraved in the hearts of music lovers. When someone else sings his song, any deviation from the original tune and pattern immediately strikes our ear, and results in to deteste. Surya tries to improvise his own tune and pattern in Manna Dey's songs, probably without realising that the listeners get into trouble to adopt this to their pre set frame of the song.
Very rightly said Goutam Dutta Ji. You really have very good ears. To catch every variation of a legend like Manna Da is almost impossible for any singer and even for listeners. Still a great attempt by Surya Ji who has a very melodious voice and deserves appreciation for reminding us of such gems of Indian Film Music.
Such a sweet voice and texture. His grasp on the surr is just out of this world. He is bang on regarding catching the tune and rendering it so effortlessly!! I wish him all success. Devi Saraswati resides in his voice.
This song should have more than a million likes, considering the fact that it was uploaded in 2012. Nowadays it seems people like crap!!! Times have changed as it happens always but I just don't understand why not many people like classical numbers. Such a shame to our country which has given birth to such legendary classical singers, be it hindusthani or karnataki classical. Such a pity!!
Awesome👌🙏❤️Classical Song👍It’s Manna De’s Legendary Song which U, did Perform at its Best! U brought in the Nuances & Variations & somehow Rounded Up the Shur that sounded so Whole & Complete to My Ears & Heart! Also the Tabla’s Taal & the Ringing of the ghungroo match the Song & elevated the Song👌Just Right🙏I Loved it👌❤️
आ आ आ रे … आयो कहाँ से घनश्याम॥ रैना बिताई किस धाम ॥ हाय राम आयो कहाँ से … हाँ रात की जागी रे ॥ अँखियाँ हैं तोरी रात की जागी रे अँखियाँ हैं तोरी हो रही गली गली जिया की चोरी ॥ हो नहीं जाना बदनाम हाय राम आयो कहाँ से … सज धज तुमरी का कहूँ रसिया धनिध ध धनिध ध मधप गपम रेमग मगस निस निस निसगमग सगम पनिगम पनिस गमगसा निनिप मगस प सज धज तुमरी का कहूँ रसिया ऐसे लगे तेरे हाथों में बँसिया ॥ जैसे कटारी लियो थाम हाय राम ॥ आयो कहाँ से … हाँ मैं ना कहूँ कछु मोसे ना रूठो॥ तुम ख़ुद अपने जियरा से पूँछो ॥ बीती कहाँ पे कल शाम आयो कहाँ से … ā ā ā rē … āyō kahām̐ sē ghanaśyāma.. rainā bitāī kisa dhāma .. hāya rāma āyō kahām̐ sē … hām̐ rāta kī jāgī rē .. am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī rāta kī jāgī rē am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī hō rahī galī galī jiyā kī cōrī .. hō nahīṁ jānā badanāma hāya rāma āyō kahām̐ sē … saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā dhanidha dha dhanidha dha madhapa gapama rēmaga magasa nisa nisa nisagamaga sagama panigama panisa gamagasā ninipa magasa pa saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā aisē lagē tērē hāthōṁ mēṁ bam̐siyā .. jaisē kaṭārī liyō thāma hāya rāma .. āyō kahām̐ sē … hām̐ maiṁ nā kahūm̐ kachu mōsē nā rūṭhō.. tuma k͟huda apanē jiyarā sē pūm̐chō .. bītī kahām̐ pē kala śāma āyō kahām̐ sē …
Kayya baat,visha very
touching ❤❤
Very well attemted 👌👍🌹
Kyaaa baaat, vishan valo very touching.
Very mesmarising singing. Wah Wah
Simply mesmarising singing
Khub bhalo laglo
Bahut khub sundar aawaj khub sundar saaj rag khamaj thumari
Excellent singing
Bahut shandar
Very classical, voice is phenomenal and mesmerizing! Takes me to a higher dimension , close to God ❤️ ! Thanks so much for this 🙏 rendition!
Very sweet Voice.
Surya Bhattacharya is undoubtedly a good singer, with a nourished and practised voice. He also is melodious with a commendable classic base. I have followed many of his programmed in U-tube. The problem is, Manna Dey is a legend, and each detail of his songs is deeply engraved in the hearts of music lovers. When someone else sings his song, any deviation from the original tune and pattern immediately strikes our ear, and results in to deteste. Surya tries to improvise his own tune and pattern in Manna Dey's songs, probably without realising that the listeners get into trouble to adopt this to their pre set frame of the song.
Very rightly said Goutam Dutta Ji. You really have very good ears. To catch every variation of a legend like Manna Da is almost impossible for any singer and even for listeners. Still a great attempt by Surya Ji who has a very melodious voice and deserves appreciation for reminding us of such gems of Indian Film Music.
Totally Agreed
Very true....
Original Manna Dey is feeded deeply in to the memory traces
Very nice. Very near to original👍
Such a sweet voice and texture. His grasp on the surr is just out of this world. He is bang on regarding catching the tune and rendering it so effortlessly!! I wish him all success. Devi Saraswati resides in his voice.
Agree 💯 , it's coming from his soul ! 🙏 That's why it's effortless , to God be the glory 🙏 ! He's a maestro all the way , that goes without saying !!
What a rendition....remarkable.
This song should have more than a million likes, considering the fact that it was uploaded in 2012. Nowadays it seems people like crap!!! Times have changed as it happens always but I just don't understand why not many people like classical numbers. Such a shame to our country which has given birth to such legendary classical singers, be it hindusthani or karnataki classical. Such a pity!!
Superb
Durdanta performance
Awesome👌🙏❤️Classical Song👍It’s Manna De’s Legendary Song which U, did Perform at its Best! U brought in the Nuances & Variations & somehow Rounded Up the Shur that sounded so Whole & Complete to My Ears & Heart! Also the Tabla’s Taal & the Ringing of the ghungroo match the Song & elevated the Song👌Just Right🙏I Loved it👌❤️
Very very nice dada.I am speechless.
Bohat khoob..god bless
Thank you for this song! You sing it so accurately and soulfully!
आ आ आ रे …
आयो कहाँ से घनश्याम॥
रैना बिताई किस धाम ॥
हाय राम
आयो कहाँ से …
हाँ रात की जागी रे ॥
अँखियाँ हैं तोरी
रात की जागी रे अँखियाँ हैं तोरी
हो रही गली गली जिया की चोरी ॥
हो नहीं जाना बदनाम हाय राम
आयो कहाँ से …
सज धज तुमरी का कहूँ रसिया
धनिध ध
धनिध ध
मधप गपम रेमग
मगस निस निस निसगमग
सगम पनिगम
पनिस गमगसा निनिप मगस प
सज धज तुमरी का कहूँ रसिया
ऐसे लगे तेरे हाथों में बँसिया ॥
जैसे कटारी लियो थाम हाय राम ॥
आयो कहाँ से …
हाँ मैं ना कहूँ कछु मोसे ना रूठो॥
तुम ख़ुद अपने जियरा से पूँछो ॥
बीती कहाँ पे कल शाम
आयो कहाँ से …
ā ā ā rē …
āyō kahām̐ sē ghanaśyāma..
rainā bitāī kisa dhāma ..
hāya rāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
hām̐ rāta kī jāgī rē ..
am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī
rāta kī jāgī rē am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī
hō rahī galī galī jiyā kī cōrī ..
hō nahīṁ jānā badanāma hāya rāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā
dhanidha dha
dhanidha dha
madhapa gapama rēmaga
magasa nisa nisa nisagamaga
sagama panigama
panisa gamagasā ninipa magasa pa
saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā
aisē lagē tērē hāthōṁ mēṁ bam̐siyā ..
jaisē kaṭārī liyō thāma hāya rāma ..
āyō kahām̐ sē …
hām̐ maiṁ nā kahūm̐ kachu mōsē nā rūṭhō..
tuma k͟huda apanē jiyarā sē pūm̐chō ..
bītī kahām̐ pē kala śāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
Behtareen. 🙏
wah wah , kamal kar diya aapne, ati manmohak , bar bar pranam aapko.
Bahut pyara Gaya apne sir varry nicely voise end bhajn so sweet
Pranam
superb
Beautiful rendition. Watched it several times over.
Sir, classical singer der janno hindi te ekta katha ache: Thahrav.....apki gane ki shaili me kya advut THAH-RAV hai....shukun mila....
Excellent singing sir.
Superb , heart touching..
veri veri nice
Be had hi khubsurat prastuti💐🙏☺
My favorite song 😍😍
💚⚘⚘⚘⭐⭐⭐⭐ AWESOME ...AMAZING
Shurjoji Hats off to you
Nice
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
aha ..sundor!!
Excellent
Very nice...............................
तारीफ करना भी कम
बहुत उम्दा
Very nice singing sir. Classical trained lagte hain. Original se kaafi door gaya hai, apni harkatein bahut ziyada bhardi aap ne.
So supar
i wish me bhi aise ga sakta
I wish too
Nice voice nice voice sogs
ā ā ā rē …
āyō kahām̐ sē ghanaśyāma..
rainā bitāī kisa dhāma ..
hāya rāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
hām̐ rāta kī jāgī rē ..
am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī
rāta kī jāgī rē am̐khiyām̐ haiṁ tōrī
hō rahī galī galī jiyā kī cōrī ..
hō nahīṁ jānā badanāma hāya rāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā
dhanidha dha
dhanidha dha
madhapa gapama rēmaga
magasa nisa nisa nisagamaga
sagama panigama
panisa gamagasā ninipa magasa pa
saja dhaja tumarī kā kahūm̐ rasiyā
aisē lagē tērē hāthōṁ mēṁ bam̐siyā ..
jaisē kaṭārī liyō thāma hāya rāma ..
āyō kahām̐ sē …
hām̐ maiṁ nā kahūm̐ kachu mōsē nā rūṭhō..
tuma k͟huda apanē jiyarā sē pūm̐chō ..
bītī kahām̐ pē kala śāma
āyō kahām̐ sē …
Kahan se ho sir ji aap
I subscribed you
Super singing
wow!!!!!!