You are spot on how this is more traditional. It's because this is actually an older song than the last one. Even though the caption said 2010, But actually he wrote this song a long time ago for another singer, it was first released in 2001.
More than a decade has passed since he sang this song. He has improved tremendously since then. Would love to your comment on his latest performance on his JJ20 world tour. 😘
he wrote this song for amei 张惠妹, a female singer from taiwan. you can react to that too. she's an absolute lengend. she is the pioneer to jj lin. this song is older than 2010. it's damn sad. in a nutshell, it's about a broken promise to be tgt forever.
I really appreciate your honesty when critiquing and you have already doing your best in maintaining the objectivity when giving comments. Please continue with this. People need professional and genuine vocal coaches like you to educate them about singing techniques and stuff. You are amazing. ❤
It's funnt that she can give so much detail on what is happening but when you see those singing competitions in western TV, the coaches only know how to say "this is amazing"
In the future when she do manage to react to all the recent JJ videos, would be very meaningful to conclude with a video similar to the David Tao one; where she watch the changes & evolution to JJ's singing style (before & after his 100 days of voice loss as well till the recent much more SLS-ish singing style) 😄
He is a big fan of MJ, which makes even more sense when you know that they used to have the same voice teacher :v I hope you will do one more reaction to his live performance of 输了你赢了世界又如何 in the show "梦想的声音3". All of JJ's performances in that show are outstanding! And thank you so much for your video
Interesting. She could actually pick out the difference in the compositions between this song (virtually JJ's 1st hit composition for A-mei, not even himself, and hence still very classical sounding) and She Says that is written more than a decade later when JJ was arguably at the start of his epitome for writing ballads and a much more delicately beautiful composition. For this song, the version to listen is preferably his opening for JJ20 where the arrangement is updated and his singing well no need to say.
Yes I miss the ballads, agree with you for English pop, and chinese mandopop too. The era of pop has sort of *paused* i think By the way JJ did record some English tracks too.
HK has so many talented singer not only focus on the idols Hins Cheung King Hin Ken Hung Cheuk Lap Alfred Hui Ting Hang Jacky Cheung Hok Yau William So Wing Hong Eason Chan Yick Shun hope to see the above vocal reaction in the future and I really like the vocal reaction series!!❤
這老師真材實料且精通音律，
各種聲樂技巧解說流行音樂唱法完全信手拈來，
既沉浸欣賞表演也適時評論節點，
我由衷佩服!
這老師真的很厲害耶！JJ學生時期真的是學古典樂的！！
Rozette真的很厲害！第一次聽JJ的她說就一次兩次到最後確定他一定是Michael Jaskson的粉絲，我真的驚呆了。
她真的厲害的好可怕
聽音算命欸😂
歌唱節目要請的是這種評審老師吧！專業
這太屌了哈啊哈哈哈 很貴
這種的太認真了🤣會沒有效果
哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
這種最原始的點評對選手才是最好
@@powei413 就算有在電視上為了收視率也不會講得如此細膩
這才是真正「專業」歌唱講評 從發音 混音 咬字 轉音 音準 共鳴等等 不是只會嘴巴講或是只憑個人喜好 還會親自示範說明👍👍👍
如此專業的聲樂老師 形容及解釋都如此清楚
由此可知他同時也是很有實力的歌手
很多時候只有歌手懂歌手 點出問題不是為了比較分高低
而是為了彼此下一次更棒的演出
老師唱歌也好好聽❤而且他的示範跟提點如此精確，這在外面超貴的😂我們真的很幸運可以免費上課
突然發現老師的刺青是音符組成的 好酷 喜歡老師也喜歡JJ 更喜歡老師講評JJ 太棒了聽出新的深度
1:06 完全同意，我最愛的也是90、2000年代的流行歌曲，現在的歐美跟韓國流行音樂很少單純帶著飽滿情感的歌曲了。
哦買嘎 這是我看過這麼多reaction最最最讓我有種真的“好專業”的feel的一個老師~
老師看到感受到 然後陳述出來的東西 都讓我會認真的甚至重複看幾次~👏🏻
謝謝用心~♡
每看一次這位老師的解析才覺得這才是真正的老師啊，言之有物還能示範不同的方式呈現出不一樣的效果❤。
我觉得在老师里好像也是教授这种大师级别的，强到有点过分，难道每个声乐老师都这么厉害的？
Vocal coach Rozette又再一次驚艷了我！JJ就是學過古典音樂的～你真的太厲害了！盲歌對她來說竟然都聽出了端倪～always on point!! Love❤
老师的表演活灵活现，太有趣了，耳朵非常敏锐。
這老師分析的好棒，JJ 還真的是聽MJ聽很多 也把他當偶像!
Great comment. Thank you.
這位老師講的真好....超級專業！
這才叫做評審老師!!
好喜歡聽老師評JJ❤一看再看還是會會心一笑😊
厲害，不懂歌詞完全從聲音去感受歌手，超專業！
終於等到了
Would be amazing to have a reaction to JJ Lin's cover of 输了你赢了世界又如何
Let’s make it happen 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Will get to it eventually😂
Amazing live version by JJ Lin 输了你赢了世界又如何, and this cover he performed since 5 years ago :)
@@ClubZeroMedia好期待❤
@@ClubZeroMedia有林俊傑的領悟嗎 期待
可以給老師也聽聽看夢想的聲音時期的林俊傑或者2017到2021的巔峰時期,跟10年相比有很大的進步喔,她應該也會很喜歡
听老师的点评也能学到不少东西，赞
喜歡看林俊傑的！！！任何 多一點 ！！拜託
Agreed with you! I love his older song too
很早就想說了！
今天剛好是520
祝國外聲樂老師跟林俊傑
能早日合作。
天啊！林俊傑一開口唱歌就像直接來到仙境般的美 ❤
JJ一直是我心中的歌神之一❤
我也喜歡也想念 90年代 2000前後的音樂，更注重情感共鳴跟情緒價值，有溫度的年代⋯現在只能在KTV 唱了
麥可傑克森是世界POP之王
JJ是華語流行歌壇的人肉CD播放機
You are spot on how this is more traditional. It's because this is actually an older song than the last one. Even though the caption said 2010, But actually he wrote this song a long time ago for another singer, it was first released in 2001.
谢谢你的点评，听得我一身鸡皮疙瘩，太棒了，专业！
我現在也還是最愛抒情歌了，好懷念
老師好棒 好專業 停不下來一直看這些點評影片
老师流口水了，JJ小心啦
一看就好喜歡這個老師，這才是真心的點評，更喜歡最後的一小段技巧教學，好受用!
支持療癒系歌王 JJLin 👍👏👏👏👏👏
看了Rozette老師的reaction之後覺得好多其他的根本是在打醬油🫢 老師講的太精闢了！那個發脾氣的比喻貼切的讓我情不自禁的笑了出來😂
He is also my favorite Mandarin singer!!!!!!!
專業
歌唱老師，精僻的天花板
JJ is gifted and multi talented. He live performances are hard to beat.
I love this guy too😂
这系列很棒，加油加油👍
這老師的的評論之所以能讓大家共鳴，因為他真的專業而且本身也能力足夠，大家應該有發現他雖然聽不懂它國的語言，但點評某一段時，常常會一模一樣的回唱再說明，這不是他突然學會中文了，而是專業素養讓他們已進入音樂無國界，聽的是聲音而不是語言，而且一遍就記住可複述，真音樂人
除了專業， 說個題外話， 老師應該有好幾打各種顏色的背心。她的最愛。😂
I learn so much about vocal 😮
老师真的好专业讲的
好
He started playing classical music at the age of 4 and he wrote this song in his teens. 🙂
專業的講評
❤very classy and professional comments!
JJ LIN 《输了你赢了世界又如何》Please!
Yes I miss these ballads!! He is a master at it!!
Wow, she's very on point!
推薦 林俊傑 JJ Lin 起風了
Should listen to his 除了爱你还能爱谁. She will love it!
Can I learn singing with her . She look so great ❤
MJ是JJ最喜歡的偶像😂
More than a decade has passed since he sang this song. He has improved tremendously since then. Would love to your comment on his latest performance on his JJ20 world tour. 😘
I have the same feeling with every words you said!
mj也是jj的偶像
FAVOURITE GUY??? YOU'VE GOT TASTE! ❤
这首记得很久沒有播放JJ唱他唱的非常棒我喜欢听可以播放出来吗？JJ唱❤
he wrote this song for amei 张惠妹, a female singer from taiwan.
you can react to that too. she's an absolute lengend. she is the pioneer to jj lin.
this song is older than 2010. it's damn sad.
in a nutshell, it's about a broken promise to be tgt forever.
This song was composed by JJ Lin in 2001 for A-mei which was a big hit for her. Later JJ debuted as a singer in 2003.
林俊杰也喜欢mj，以前出国跟教mj的声乐老师学习过。
He just completed his 1st round of 20yrs world tour concert including US, Europe, Asia and Australia 1st half of this year.
I really appreciate your honesty when critiquing and you have already doing your best in maintaining the objectivity when giving comments. Please continue with this. People need professional and genuine vocal coaches like you to educate them about singing techniques and stuff. You are amazing. ❤
JJ Lin is my favorite Mandarin singer ✌️🤩🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Awesome review, again. You point out all the layers and colours and textures of singing so that we can learn to experience a song like a painting.
Pleaseeee show her some JJ’s newer lives. He’s progressed so much since then!!!
this song was born in 2001 and its for AMei Zhang ，the writer is JJ and 2010, JJ released he's cover album, this song is in.
His nickname is “Walking CD” in China😃
It's funnt that she can give so much detail on what is happening but when you see those singing competitions in western TV, the coaches only know how to say "this is amazing"
2023年的演唱会这首歌改的也很好听，可以的话可以让老师对比一下，2023的感觉更成熟了
In the future when she do manage to react to all the recent JJ videos, would be very meaningful to conclude with a video similar to the David Tao one; where she watch the changes & evolution to JJ's singing style (before & after his 100 days of voice loss as well till the recent much more SLS-ish singing style) 😄
這才叫評審嘛，現在節目常常請一堆來領便當的
有些歌手還比坐在椅子上的評審強
現在中國都是內定好聲音
尤其是有些連音唱不出/不到還在BB耀武揚威無針對性問說個人感受但批評卻没改善策略真討厭
领便当的😂😂这个比喻好
呢個老師有料
great to have this. suggest to having recent JJ songs. he is now far more crazy than before in terms of music standard.
We will eventually get to the more recent ones.
@@ClubZeroMedia That would be great :>love to see more JJ
@@ClubZeroMedia thats awesome
@@ClubZeroMedia Nice 3000 :)
He is a big fan of MJ, which makes even more sense when you know that they used to have the same voice teacher :v I hope you will do one more reaction to his live performance of 输了你赢了世界又如何 in the show "梦想的声音3". All of JJ's performances in that show are outstanding! And thank you so much for your video
真的！！！我都是喜欢以前的歌 我才觉得有情感在，现在的音乐华语乐坛的真的很少让我印象深刻，有时候名字我都不知道😂可是以前2010的歌很多还是我在ktv会点的
do review jj lin and han hong's duet 飞云之下。。
曹格、林志炫，都是很值得拿來討論 技巧也是很棒
林志炫⋯⋯⋯⋯
@@hanjc4232 林志炫不錯啊 混聲混得好，混到老沒煩惱⋯周杰倫跟陶喆，都是仗著年輕狀態好硬上 撐不到40幾歲就退化到快嚇死人
反觀老外的Aero smith、Air supply 主唱，都沙場老將征戰多場、年紀70還沒退化像它兩人那麼可怕
听一位新加坡的声乐老师说，JJ过去有向MJ的声乐老师拜师。
『輸了你贏了世界又如何』必須讓她聽❤
我讀書時的神曲，
希望林志炫和林俊傑的版本都可以一起讓大家品味。
推 拜託讓老師聽
I think JJ’s 崇拜 would also be amazing.
Interesting. She could actually pick out the difference in the compositions between this song (virtually JJ's 1st hit composition for A-mei, not even himself, and hence still very classical sounding) and She Says that is written more than a decade later when JJ was arguably at the start of his epitome for writing ballads and a much more delicately beautiful composition. For this song, the version to listen is preferably his opening for JJ20 where the arrangement is updated and his singing well no need to say.
辛苦老師了！
说起“演”唱就想到JJ唱的三天两夜啊哈😂😂😂他的声音即使没有音乐依然那么漂亮，应该说清唱更听清楚那份感动了❤
2:22 這形容真的太妙了
張惠妹這首記得其實是2001年發行的，的確就是當時流行的曲風，詞和JJ的曲完美結合，現在聽還是好聽。
阿妹2014的live th-cam.com/video/Wc4xz49JVug/w-d-xo.htmlsi=UmPSk2DNDBA9hTrd
這老師是真的強欸 記得的確相比她說早了不少吧?
THISSSS
好希望老師能去聽看看李聖傑
Can't wait to see 😊❤
看到老师说歌手演唱时使用情绪太过了，好奇之下去搜了这首歌的背景故事：歌曲《记得》的灵感是来源于林俊杰17岁时和女朋友因为感情问题而产生的一次吵架，他和他的初恋女友因为各自有各自要追寻的梦想，所以不得不分开。他不知道自己和她还能走多远，于是带着这样的情绪写出了这首歌。
在创作的过程中，林俊杰带着自己和自己相爱的人被迫分开的无奈谱曲，以悲伤为基调，节奏较为缓慢。而与此同时《记得》这首歌也记录下了林俊杰当兵时，对事业或感情抱持着单纯和执著的态度。它永远提醒着林俊杰，那应该是做音乐不改变的心态。
Hey I like Rozette! Invite her react to more Madarin singers!
可以請她去聽【領悟】
I like your comment so much .
I like him so much before .
But，his soul is changed .
He becomes a better and stronger person despite the malicious wrongs against him
98-2010是华语乐坛真的是黄金时代，现在真的没这些歌了，世界流行趋势是一样的
Yes I miss the ballads, agree with you for English pop, and chinese mandopop too. The era of pop has sort of *paused* i think
By the way JJ did record some English tracks too.
HK has so many talented singer
not only focus on the idols
Hins Cheung King Hin
Ken Hung Cheuk Lap
Alfred Hui Ting Hang
Jacky Cheung Hok Yau
William So Wing Hong
Eason Chan Yick Shun
hope to see the above vocal reaction in the future
and I really like the vocal reaction series!!❤