Salman Rushdie & 'The Satanic Verses' : Whose Freedom? Whose Speech? (1989) - The Fifth Estate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ต.ค. 2024
- From 1989 Eric Malling looks at the controversy surrounding Salman Rushdie's book 'The Satanic Verses', which has aroused varied responses of outrage from Muslim groups around the world. Malling interviews Salman Rushdie who attempts an explanation at the abstract concepts he was trying to get across, which did not intend any offense to Islam or Muslims.
---
Subscribe for more videos from The Fifth Estate : bit.ly/25W8cpn
Connect with The Fifth Estate online :
Website : bit.ly/1d0FBxq
Facebook : bit.ly/1UO9B8S
Twitter : bit.ly/237VM8P
Instagram : bit.ly/25W8SLs
About the fifth estate : For four decades The Fifth Estate has been Canada's premier investigative documentary program. Hosts Bob McKeown, Gillian Findlay and Mark Kelley continue a tradition of provocative and fearless journalism. the fifth estate brings in-depth investigations that matter to Canadians - delivering a dazzling parade of political leaders, controversial characters and ordinary people whose lives were touched by triumph or tragedy.
![[DRIP] ‘CLIK CLAK’ PREVIEW](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bcxkcOSbpac/mqdefault.jpg)
These people are so thick... they BOUGHT copies of the book, in doing so supporting the author and publisher.
Think they do not have that capacity to think that far with their right brain thinking ;) :D ahaha
Point has been made
So Salman got the last laugh in a sense.
😂😂😂😂
Mercenary Knight Maybe, but getting the last word in isnt what im concerned with
It seems like these guys proved Rushdie right.
Exactly
He proved that he was right
OMG .this comment is even more relevant now
100%
that's what happens when you mix virgins wine and religious stupidity !!!!!!!!!!! you know all for the prophet and allah .....allah made up the blasphemy laws gave them grabriel and gabriel gave them to mohammad ???? or did allah transmit them another way ????
“Blasphemy is a capital crime in Islam punishable by death.”
Ok well the book was published in England, where it isn’t punishable by death.
So if a person eat pork he should be killed, even if he eats that in England 😂😂😂
For now.
😉😉😉
doesn't matter, islamic rules should apply everywhere
apparently...
Wait a few minutes and probably will be...
After the stabbing a few days ago I am again reminded and so disappointed in these days and times we live in. My thoughts are with him and hope he recovers quickly.
❤❤❤❤ ***The Messiah has come*** ❤❤
th-cam.com/video/NQErICgt4SM/w-d-xo.html
May Allah guide him
@@ajajssksk1757 ISRAELI MISSILES kILLS PALSTINE PEOPLE WHY IS ALLAH NOT SAVING THEM IS HE AFRAID OF MISSILES
@Worstje Knak 🙃
@Worstje Knak there's no god in the moon after mohammed split it, just like aisha's hymen.🙂
*ALL religions, deserve criticism and scrutiny.*
@Dear dad what do you consider "genuine questions"? Can we only ask how to clean out butts? Or how to shave our armpits??
Islam doesn't have answers to genuine questions only silly questions.
@Dear dad cab we say that Mohammed(The best prophet of Islam) in fact had BLACK SLAVES....and there was a time where he traded TWO(2) of his black slaves for one non black salve.
Hadith👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇😂
"A slave came and pledged to the Prophet to emigrate, and the Prophet did not realize that he was a slave. Then his master came looking for him. The Prophet said: 'Sell him to me,' and he bought him for two black slaves. Then he did not accept the pledge from anyone until he asked: 'Is he a slave? "'
@Dear dad BTW, in Islam you are only allowed to ask silly questions like how to wipe your but or is it is allow to fart during prayers....
Islam is a JOKE
True ! Religion SUCKS.
@@simpleenglish1 says the guy who doesn’t even know how to clean himself and don’t talk about Hadith it’s to much for your little brain .and Islam and Hadith have answers to all religion so again don’t talk about religions you have not studied.And basic hygiene is important and you need to be clean to pray
The religion of peace as long as you don't criticize the religion lol
Bryan Stewart what is going to happen when we die? How can u be so sure nothing is going to happen. So then why are we here? Who came up with the concept of God . May be the first human on earth?? But why he thought of god? Just curious to know what you think about this
Xorodo nut No one came up with the concept of God. God is the beginning and the end. God was revealed to us. We are living now what makes you think we can not live again?
Bryan It's violent even if you don't criticize it.
Bryan Stewart, as long as you don't criticize and convert to it!
@@megabushcraft you sound like your quoting the quran. Word for word
Who else is watching after hearing about Salman Rushdie's stabbing?
me
Me
Me
my government funded tv skipped over that like it didn't even happen and went on to more pertinent human rights issues of the day
an muslim fanatic stabbing a praised writer over religion no human rights issue there
"Blasphemy is a capital crime in Islam and punishable by death" - Um, there's so many things wrong with that sentence. Firstly, blasphemy is not blasphemy if the person is outside of your faith, put simply you cannot condemn someone for committing a crime that they do not believe in, what that actually is in reality is you murdering someone because of the offence you inferred. Secondly, Islam is a religion not a country, so these are not laws agreed by all for you to then enact upon all - basically he broke no laws, no rules, you just want to kill him because you're upset and using religious dogma to justify murder.
When in rome do as the romans do
@@BilalBilal-wj3ze : Why arent Muslims living in western societies doing that?
Exactly!!! Well put!!
basically
Why
They criticize other religions but they cannot accept criticism? That is very hypocritical. Well, not really surprised.
Cos islam is the truth "Allah guides whom he wills" the author was an ex Muslim and these thick ex muslims spread propaganda and a load of lies cos they are totally misguided ppl. Anyone who goes against our prophet my Allah punish them
@@saadusman6617 "islam is true" this is your stance and your opinion don't try to impose this ideology on everyone. If muslims can criticize other religions and can falsify all the religions so how is criticizing islam not a fair play hun??
Cherish when prophet Mohammad criticism to others religion.U got to learn about prophet Mohammad good luck
@tweety tweety
Ive heard what you've had to say, but guess what i dont care.
Goodbye
Humayun Laskar Good luck too, and it would be best for you to learn about him too and read the Quran and the Hadiths with the same critical mind as you would any other books.
This is beyond eerie to watch after what happened today.
They're proving his point... Lol and buying his book to burn...
That's what I think too.
That is what he wanted.
EXACTLLYY!!!
We muslims can afford to buy and burn don't be naive like you don't know Muslim countries supply your oil, Qatar owns 40% of London, your football teams are owned by Muslim s,so grow up
@@omarhussain9013 that doesn’t change the fact that you fed the troll you tried to stand against
It is okay for muslim rulers to have destroyed several Hindu, Zoroastrian, Sikh, Jewish temples/place of worship. impose tax on non believers, but no one can criticize their religion. The Prophet himself ordered the destruction of all the idols in Kaba, these people don't think that was unjust? Muslims can say all sort on nonsense about other religions, but no one should say anything about their Prophet (NoPBHU).
The kaaba is from start a point of one god no idol worship, and the pegans had turned into an idol trading spot. Worship was done for the sake of buissness. Thus owas bought back to its glory.
Muslims impose jizziya on the non-believers as a price for not participating in the military and to protect the minority. Read the story of andalousiya to understand how jizziya was fully practiced.
Critizicing Islam is openly welcomed in the qurhan and in the teaching of the prophet.
Qurhan says find an error or produce a surah like it. And in the hadheeths we have many people throwing garbage at the prophet or pissing inside the Masjid, and they lived.
Don't put thease things on Islam, like I'd never put actions of hindus into Hinduism.
Agilen Jey - ISLAM = Legalized paedophilia + wife beating + sex slave
iddah of 3 months in Quran 65:4 is applicable to prepubescent girl. According to Quran 33:49 those who dont need idda/waiting period are those who are divorced before consumated.
O you who believe if you marry believing women and then divorce them before you have touched them (read tamassūhunna or tumāsūhunna) that is, before you have copulated with them, there shall be no [waiting] period for you to reckon against them, [no] waiting period [needed to preclude pregnancy] or otherwise. But provide for them, give them what they can use for [securing] comforts, in cases where no dowry has been fixed for them; otherwise theirs is to retain half of what was fixed, but no more - this is what Ibn ‘Abbās said and it is [the opinion] followed by al-Shāfi‘ī’; and release them in a gracious manner, leave them be without [the intention to cause them any] harm.
Qur'an 33:49
Tafsir al-Jalalayn
This verse effectively removes the apologist's objection to Qur'an 65.4 as we see clearly that if a man has not consummated his marriage with his wife then she does not need to observe an 'iddah. If Qur'an 65.4 specifies that pre-pubescent females must observe a 3 month 'iddah then clearly sexual intercourse is halal to Allah.
Your religion is disgusting just like your paedophile Muhammad.
Your a dog
Muslim before settling in west : we love to live in west .its secular values, freedom for religions.
Muslim settled in west: Our shariaa is above your secular values. Gee Jaa juuu 🤣
why would a Muslim want to leave a Muslim country run by Allah for the evil west that just dosent make any sense
The durka durkas are ruining western civilization
😂😂😂😂
👌
Gotta buy the book this man's a genius
It’s been refuted in full, ur just wasting money
Still gonna buy it
@@Ohnthr I don’t care if u wanna waste ur money 😂😂😂
@@boogus1670 absolutely nobody asked for your opinion
@@boogus1670 Its available for free online, do u want me to send it to you?
The kid at the end was the MOST REASONABLE person in that group. Although I do not agree with him in the slightest it's just sad to see a child have a better sense of equality than adults around him.
Is he the young Naheed nenshi- mayor of calagry
The other men were dragging their knuckles to burn the books they bought 😂
@@abumaliha7266 very well could be
He brings up an interesting topic. You have to choose between freedom of expression and respecting the dignity of ethnic groups. That is the sentiment of living in a multicultural society. You can not have both when the ethnic groups don’t value freedom of speech as much as we do in the West. So you have to either choose, or change their mentality. These are not simple tasks. But not difficult enough for you to be ignorant about them.
If you prefer freedom of speech, then you will see ethnic groups flooding the streets. But please, don’t act surprised when they do.
@@_phildogwell thats ridiculuos, cause the freedom of speech doesn't necessaraly have to do with the dignity of these ethnic groups. For example if i critisize a book/god/religious leaders because its followers threat woman as second. Then i come up for the dignity of these woman. (at least from my own perspective)
If i for example say that white people are racist, then if you are a white person you will be more affected, by that statement, then a non white person, are someone who also thinks white people are racist.
I think that its human behaviour that we get offended, the real problem here is that one group has such a strong identity that they think they can control the whole public sphere by forming new rules, without critisizing their own standpoint about it. So in the interview there also critical things about the christian religion. but they dont know that or choose to ignore it. Thats the real problem here, double standards by a strong groupsidentity.
So how does this point out, if you feel offended by a thing, but your group says, it just a person or get over it. Then it wil have a different effect as lets say, that infidel, or the west is always mocking is, we deserve respect.
I think they just need time and alternatives from their own groups to change this groupsbehaviour.
"P" in Islam stands for Peace
😂
you’re very ignorant my friend
😂😂😂😂
.
.
Internet is exposing Islam more than ever.
True
And Quran exposed internet 1400 years ago, try reading it once so you'll understand better
@@kill54boys
How?
@@sunnyearthling192 in the quran its mentioned about how the people of the end times will be surrounded with diseases with no cures and here you are
@P N chill bruh u look like u mad asf
This imam says the book insulted Islam, as if authorities and non-Muslims should care.
Yes,because they are living in non Muslim lands.And in our land,you follow our rules.Simple.
Muslims believe that the Quran is the recicitation of gods word to al humanity, and that all under god must adhere to its authority though. It’s part of the mindset.
Neil Vanderveen and they believe someone should be killed for criticizing
Simon Peter they believe the whole world was made for their prophet this whole purpose for us here today how crazy it that !?
Muslim fundamentalism in Canada is just as bad as Christian fundamentalism is in the states but for some reason being an Islamic fundamentalist isn't as frowned upon in society. It's funny because both types of fundamentalists refuse to adapt to modern society, both want to ban blasphemy, and both want to impose theocracy with religious law.
Emotion, emotion, emotion - no plain common sense - as usual!!!! When emotion overrides intelligence there is nothing more to be said!!!!!
This is why the Middle east and the Indian subcontinent region are the most religious
That happens when cousins procreate
only someone who has the emotional maturity of a child cannot examine their feelings from the outside, just because people feel something strongly, does not make that feeling justified.
You people are intelligent abuse your Jesus in your lame Jokes hahaha you people have no common sense your God had no value
I like the way you put it, i just call them brainwashed
So peaceful! That's why every Islamic country is perfect paradise!
Matt Sherv tell me about it 🤣🤣🤣
Because the USA and UK didn't invade Afghanistan Iraq and dismantled the entire Middle East. Because prior to the meddling of Western Powers the Middle East was doing absolutely fine.
Yuh!! Tell me what will u do if someone trash-talked about your mom?
love country
blasphemy laws did that
Salman Rushdie was right about Islam.
What do you mean???
He doesn't know half of what he's talking about. He just took a controversial Islamic story and decided to make a profit off Islamophobes. Y'all follow each other blindly like a blind man guiding a deaf man without any knowledge of hadith or tafsir.
And may I ask if Islam is not the true religion, then what religion should I follow? Because I am almost entirely sure each and every one of you will give me a different answer. And no matter which religion I follow, people will still be angry. People like you are the reason we will never get world peace. So stop whining and crying and give people a rest.
Yeah Islam is virus that destroys the thinking capabilities....
You can't have negative criticism about islam , when you have then you die in gutter...
Intolerant as fck....
He was right about fabricated hadiths 🤣
100%
Now for sure his book is gonna be a superhit
Lmao a Hindu the last people who should be talking about religions 😂
Hit the trash can that is
Yes
How many Christian churches and schools are tolerated in ISLAM?
Many
Muslims badly need this Christian run schools. Muslims schools are lost or get lost otherwise it's called a maddrassa that indoctrinate muslims about hatred against non muslims and muslims whom radical muslims viewed as not muslim enough
@@chewie1355 nonsense.
@@chewie1355 you cant openly practice your religion in saudi arabia. There are no churches of other faiths there
@@brandon266s Intolerante Islam ☪
Many people probably already know, but in Islamic nations, marrying your 1st cousin is an acceptable practice and that can be part of the reason why some of them seem to have something wrong with them due to the institutionalized and generational incest.
Yes but the west is picking up the medical bill for all the ills of that practice. And when a atrocity is committed by them they cite a mental imbalance. Go figure.. an inbred society with mental ilness that is endemic... really? Surely thats not medical fact but a critique of a sick society... or as they would put it blasphemous hate speech. Cant win can you
@Umer Tracker you cannot even u try ur 100%
It is acceptable islamically and god knows his creation more than the creations knows himself
a multi-generational incested mental case goes crazy when offended especially over religion. religion really reeks havoc on a crazy man
generational incestral inbreeding for centuries what could go wrong with that ???
If you don't question a teaching then you cannot learn. It's unfair to say don't question because that means anyone can say and add anything that is false.. Even the Christian Bible says question in order to get knowledge..
There is a difference between mocking a religion and asking questions
@@jahedul.H Islam is trash mohamed is a pedophile who was visited by demons
@@maychiu1419 why are you trying to provoke people? They're sharing their opinions in good faith, and you say this
@@jahedul.H Islam deserves to be mocked it's absolutely pathetic and pitiful and a stain on humanity.
questioning is different ,criticizing is different.who is preventing you to question,you clarify ,you will get answer.it is like H2o is water,if any one says why cant be H3o,there is no answer for that it is something else cannot be water,I hope you will agree with me.
Why is it so difficult for these people to understand that the people in a given religion are the ones who have to follow its rules. I'm not in your silly religion I'm not bound by its crazy rules.
Artificial Avocado Islam isn't a religion, its apolitical movement of conquest.
Bruh theyre knuckleheads these muslim they were brainwashed from their childhood ya cant do anything to change their mind theyre stupid.
shut up at least respect it
@Alfred E Respect to other faiths
then what are you doing i just simply said to respect our religion ....smh
who is asking you to accept ,it is your wish,if you dont want to accept truth,but you have no right to criticize others beliefs.
this is the story of how an average book became a best seller
Bullshit. It's one of the greatest novels of the 1980s.
Ive read it and it is amazing
Justice for Salman Rushdie when...
Salman Rushdie is a hero and very educated person to know islam from inside out.
Hahahhaha because he do hate speech he never was a Muslim
Then send your mother to him
Do you know about Islam??
Yes your right, suppose he wrote a book about your mother would you still class him as being very educated 🤣🤣🤣
Prov it
Judge a tree by the fruit it bears. If Islam is peace why do they produce so much violence?
Every religion has its own black sheep. Don't single out islam.
@@TheFarouk73 thing is though you cannot deny islam is causing most of the problems in the world. Not all muslims.
Islam
@@optimusprime4090 i dont hear "chrstian terrorists" when catholics commits crime. But when a muslim-sounding name did, Islam is the headline. #foreheadslap
You forget your own people the last 100 year and more who killed more than millions of people. Don't talk rubbish.
@@TheFarouk73 lol okay your religion has absolutely nothing to do with violence. Thats what you want to hear about your religion. Abrahamic religions are violent. You may not be a violent person but thats in spite of your religion. Not because of it. You have every right to believe islam is a religion of peace. Thing is if we got rid of religion thrre would be no more black sheep as you put it. They would just be regular murderers then.
FUN FACT : ALL OF THEM ARE FROM PAKISTAN.
Any religion that can not sustain questioning is a fools religion.
So all of them?
By that logic is Holocaust a fools story tale?
@@Werchmant just say you don't think the holocaust was real
If I would make a book like this, I would release it anonymously if I could, and have a laugh and drink some tea 🍵
Would you risk your life for a laugh and a cup of tea? Salman Rushdie was literally sentenced to execution by Khomeini. Almost every single Muslim tried to murder him because of Khomeini's fatwa.
your book would get anonymously lost in space too... like your tea
@@NZyoutube bold of you to assume I have the material resources, to send my book and tea in space.
The book will not published if it already rejected
Dream on
He brought facts from their own books.
If you haven’t read the book or study on the matter keep your mouth shut. keep quiet about what you don’t know
@Brother Asked a good Question.
th-cam.com/video/vtxDK8NlX9M/w-d-xo.html
🙂
@Salahuddin Ayubi who cares!
@Salahuddin Ayubi good for the idiots
Imagine being so insecure with your religion that a novel blows up your faith. (No pun intended)
The only way to save Salman Rushdie, Patty Samuel , Nupur Sharma and Kanihya Lal is to promote free speech critical of Mohammed and Quran. Offense is the only defense.
Call it whatever you want to call it… we respect the religion of Islam very much & we won’t anyone to disrespect it. You must pay for disrespecting Islam and its prophet
Few words from the brides mom 👆🏼👇🏼
@@saadabdi8196 then move to another country. You don't get to impose your Islamofascism on us. We have freedom of speech here. Bye
@@saadabdi8196 In that case crawl back into the cave you climbed out of.
In the next years we Will study him in history classes, as an Hero...
learn a little grammar first 😂
@@abdullahmohammed2582 I hear Mo was didn't know how to read and write? Did he?
Never possible
Go and learn grammar before you talk, you are speaking poor English
try english study first a hero
He was 52 she was six !!!! But you have problems with a book !!!! Lmao
Lol😂
If you said this in India, you'd have a fatwa on ur head with people lurking to rip your head off your body. That is the sad reality of Nupur Sharma.
Different times Christopher. You should know better
perversion in the past is ok
if it's ok in the past it must be ok now right
This is the main problem I have with Islam, they are TERRIFIED of criticism and respond to it with death threats and try to erase all traces of said criticism. I have to say it makes their faith in Islam seem fragile and weak.
Oh and I’d be willing to bet the masses didn’t even read the book. That’s just my opinion
I insult paul Stanford’s wife and you keep quiet cos then your deep love is gonna be shown
Islamic thought process is just like virus
a weak ego is a defensive ego
Yeah Islam can't really stand on it's own feet.
Actually I am going to buy the book. It is considered as a gold.
Can we buy this book from Amazon?
Me too i wanna read it!
Yabba dabba doo
I literally bought it with an extra gold case and it has all-black cover. It looks marvellous, not to mention the book itself is masterful.
Great book 📕
I just read the book, it is a fantasy story, can't understand how they got so out of joint over it. Oh well, at least Rushdie a fabulously creative author made it through this craziness.
yes it is llike Roman or Novel or story. Either it is against or not, it doesn't matter, let people talk and write. What is the problem with this.
Because it implies that the version of the Koran that they think is the literal word of God is in fact a set of Satanic verses. I mean, it doesn't really because it's fiction, but that's how they see it.
I would like to add that there is hadith that indirectly link to the event of the satanic verses that the Prophet (PBUH) recited. Claiming Allah was merciful made light of the situation and relieved him of his grief.
www.answering-islam.org/Shamoun/possessed.htm
@@thegoodlydragon7452 that’s not true. The satanic verses is based on an actual event that occurred during Muhammad’s life, It’s recorded in authentic Hadiths and even by his earliest biographers before they started censoring it. The event itself wasn’t that big of a deal, people’s reaction to it was.
It's a great novel and I heartily recommend Shalimar the Clown and Midnight's Children as well. Oh, and The Enchantress of Florence.
I am happy that thanks to these videos we can see how important was and it is this book today
He should have spent more time interview the kid at the end. I'll be curious to know what he's up to decades after.
I agree. I'd love to hear from that kid
Decades after, the kid might have been either an atheist or a middle aged man far away from religious practices.
Religion of peace and tolerance...??
Wait... am I missing something?
'Where' is the peace and the tolerance?
in reading that book of truth and not taqqiya for once.
Its not a religion peace. Its a religion of war.
Islam is now kinda joke
@@joshuamuanlal6936 your religion is joke now not Islam
only someone who has the emotional maturity of a child cannot examine their feelings from the outside, just because people feel something strongly, does not make that feeling justified. There is no room in this world for totalitarian ideologies.
But here we are lol
2 billion muslims on this planet now. Scary.
The religion seems to promote such emotional immaturity
Christ is the only way , light and truth . Read the Bible and meditate on his word. Away from these pagan gods that promote violence polygamy and repetitive prayers like parrots …
I don't like offending anybody (if I can help it), but if you cannot handle *absolute* freedom of speech in our societies, perhaps you should return to your own... 😑 I don't know much about the man, and have not read the book, but in order to be compatible with the western world, you have to internalize one's *(absolute)* freedom of speech. The western world figured this out centuries ago, and our societies are doing, well... great...
“If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.” -George Orwell
Watching and laughing in 2020.. 🤣
How about this week?
"ek din marr jayega kutte ki maut, jag me kehlayega marr gaya madharch*d" .... The song proved just to be accurate !
All you can do is terrorize people that’s what your religion teaches, it teaches force and violence.
I am born in a Muslim family and am not in the least offended by it, infact I'm curious to read it.
We exist, please don't generalise a whole populace based on the extremists
Yes you exist and that percentage is 0.5%
@@sushilsharma4202 NOT AT ALL. I know a lot of people who think the same as me. Some people just want to judge others based on extremists because they are themselves prejudiced
You are the minority, and I'm not speaking anecdotally. I know very qualified and seemingly knowledgeable people eho cannot handle criticism.
Its not the fault of the individual Musoims who behave this way, this is how they were brought up from childhood.
Islam now is what Christianity was a thousand years ago
@@throwawayuser9931 you have talked to specific people you know. I'm from within the circle and there are very few like what you describe and i certainly don't consider extremists to be the representative of any religion, and this one I've actually observed from the inside.
Everyone is not life that. And I don't need your agreement on this fact.
@@throwawayuser9931 and if they can't hadle basuc criticism they're exactly what you said, only seemingly knowledgeable, i know manyyy actually knowledgeable people who are open minded.
And bullshit islam is now what christianity was back then. I can't talk about the middle east because their hate it tied to political causes of western exploitation but most muslims are NOT REMOTELY on the kevel on christianity was at a thousand years ago. Maybe chstianity 100-200years ago in some very conservative/orthodox households but still civilised and with minds still opening and becoming more accepting day by day
His book has just become hugely popular with prices rocketing
Love and respect... We're there any women present at this protest who were given the opportunity to express their personal opinions?
Gypsy Soul
Of course not Woman to them to serve and make babies only that’s the reason for her to be around
Trust me woman’s. Before Islam came to the world woman had more respect and positions all around the arab area and some of them they were Queens who their voice was heard and some of them were leading countries and some of them as a knights too
and after the Islam came to the existence changed everything and as I said they are to serve and making babies that’s all
Anon[712] who said lol
Gypsy Soul yeah women hate that old geezer too. Lol
Well.... there would have to be a ratio of 2:1, women to men, in order to even be allowed to speak. A womans testimony is worth half that of a man's in islam, as they teach women are deficient in intellect and religion.
@@mamamarianovits9029 not at all. Read the verse where it says that. May allah guide u
He is the best open mind we have had for a long time
A muslim just stabbed Salman
We don’t care who’s is hurt as long one sick man can practice his freedom of speech👍🏾
My dad told me that the reaction to the book was like the release of the Thriller album with the opposite reaction
Solution is simple. Don't immigrate, stay inside your Islamic countries. Don't move to the free world and expect to turn the free world into a prison.
Shut up he
Churchill's message to queen Elizabeth: "Your majesty, there is nothing more destructive than Islam and I assure so long there is Islam in middle east, middle east will remain our strong colony."
He must have been a smart man huh some idiots
less stab his corpse
Do you really share this colonialist bullshit quote as something good? lmao
The two questions Rushdie asks at 2:36 are still the questions the relitards of all stripes refuse to answer. And his point at 5:25 still stands as well.
I thought I was the only one that got the significance of those questions especially the firsts one that can be used to measure the character of the Islamic faith.
If you have chosen to have no religious faith, that is your choice. Fine. But you have no right to label people who do embrace a religious faith, "relitards." As a Christian, I assure you I do not fit that descriptive terminology.
@@Listening4Gabriel Not having a religion is not a choice. Having a religion is a choice.
a brought up religion is no choice it's an indoctrination
Now I want to read his book!
Thank you for telling us 😂
@@ajajssksk1757 😂
30 years later nothing changed
Wonder where the kid with the glasses and mittons at the end is now?
Probably an ex moose now
The only one with a sensible voice
I'm pretty sure "The Last Temptation of Christ" was published first. When the movie came out, it didn't play in several Bible Belt states. When people react this way, it only instigates the success of a religiously banned book.
Would you believe they actually came out within a few weeks of each other in August/September 1988. I just looked it up. I definitely agree banning something only gives it more power. Movie theaters choosing not to show a movie is a little different than an entire country banning a book in terms of censorship but I get what you're saying
If you read the hadiths, you will discover that Salman Rushdie was very mild in his writings. The Hadiths reveal even worse about the prophet of Islam. Islam is indefensible.
Everybody needs to buy this book!
Nice to know mikey 😆
When he write about hazrat isha webought thisbook
@@ajajssksk1757 You do know that his book is Fiction...not real right? Islam scholars have already outlined in several videos that it is fiction, made up.
@@nasreenakhter7927 what
Those who dislike it are buying more to burn it...
It’s sad because the young chap at the end seemed so bright it’s upsetting to see he’s been indoctrinated
No he’s been taught the truth
@@ajajssksk1757 Oh great! I had hopes someone would teach him the truth and he would become atheist!
he only repeats what he's heard bright or not he's already a religious mental case
Name something more dangerous than ignorance.
Ur ignorant bubba may god guide u bro
I was gonna say muslims, but it's pretty much a synonym.
@@truthserumbackup4151 😂 you need guidance bubba. We all do
@@ajajssksk1757 Guidance to what?
@@truthserumbackup4151 to the truth.
You should never kill anybody for what they said or wrote, a human who believes in God will have a free mind and nothing will insult him/her as this is how God created his children. 🙏
He is still alive
@@syeddastageerullah2417 many have not been so lucky.
@@syeddastageerullah2417 alive but unable to write and speak. Ironic how that’s his fate after he spread lies about god. What’s happened to him had it coming one way or another. Even if it wasn’t about Islam and merely something else. For every action a reaction.
Don’t forget how the US handled foreign policy for the past 30+ years. It used to pay attention to people like this man. Their drive was hate and speculation.
What Salmaan Rashdi said that" A GOAT 🐐 WAS REALLY WAS A GOAT" . There is nothing wrong in his words. Peaceful are peaceful but also terrorists are terrorists he (may be a Prophet or Godman).
Salman Rushdie a well deserved knighthood well done fella for all your literary genius
You know he wrote the right book when Muslims get angry 😂
The kid at the end was really well spoken. I don't agree with him, but he was very mature for his age.
Crescent moon lunacy disorder
🌙🧕🧕👳🏾♂️🧕🧕🌙
Quraish tribe main god was Moon god
Oh my non-god.. Those children... The indoctrination.. It's just so sad
Salman Rushdie is a legend!
I'm Christian, and nothing you could say about God or Jesus would make me want to physically hurt you.
The thing is, I'm secure in my belief.
Someone criticizing my beliefs has no real chance of making me change my mind.
Wise words ! Even i believe the same. It boggles my mind , how one could think of taking lives , getting upset over something like this. Plus i am always ready to crticise any BS in my religion and advocate to reform it wherever necessary. Being a fanatic never helps. Sad that so few yhink this way.
@@abhishekbourai1832 💀💀💀 are you some Hindu
As a Canadian it is now my duty to read this book.
What's horrifying is that Islamic scripture calls for the killing of those who are "blasphemers and apostates". Pretty much sums up how peaceful the religion is.
Very very frightening 😳😳😳
That's not true and the context needs to be framed properly. By and large muslims and islamic civilization has been historically been more tolerant than most civilizations. People need start respecting others again where material like this isn't published and authors aren't threatened.
@@ummpearlsThat's the problem with you lot. You are extremely intolerant of others and their rights.
Ur silly dann. U need to read some books
@@ajajssksk1757 Which books? the Quran and the Hadith? 😂😂😂 Stop being a bozo, I've read more books than you will ever do in your bedouin goat herding life.
islam, a devils device and scheme, and so many were deceived..........
That kid at the end was very educated. Hope he woke up and left such religion alone....... peace
How educated is he? The boy is suggesting to you the application of sharia law and you're praising him? Do you know was sharia is?
@@FoJ-REAPP Did you hear even a word I said? I said I hope he leaves such religion alone. What don't you understand?
I'm about 100% sure that your a Christian? And if you are, Then how educated can you be? Especially if you believe in an out dated book called the bible.... lol
@@ivstova47 u sound silly please shush.
@@FoJ-REAPP a Christian should not be speaking. The guy is strong in his religion I believe and I hope
99.9% of the people featured here never read the book. That's just a fact. Therefore any opinions expressed by them are totally meaningless. I personally notice that almost all of my Muslim friends have very defensive feelings when you question their faith and that to me is a sign of insecurity that is very telling
"Blasphemy is a capital crime punishable by death"
Feminists/Liberals be like: I will pretend I didn't see that.
He portrayed their prophet like an animal?
Having studied the Hadith myself I find Muhammed to be portrayed as a perverse 'animal' by Islamic hadith yet the Muslim world isn't burning Hadith. .
Islam allows too many wrong doings towards women and children! I believe Muhammad was deceived! OR he knew and made himself a cushy lifestyle with the power he had! Any God I've heard of never allowed this or violence against non-believers or just people with common sense that saw through him!!
At least they made him rich
The kid at the end I need to find out who he is he had really good points given and I really respect for what he did mashallah
he was wrong.
1.Blasphemy in Islam is death.2.They are living in non-muslim land and salman rushdie is not a muslim so why should he be killed? 3.A multicultural society should be allowed to criticise,killing someone just because they offended youor insulted you just proves that you are an uncultured swine.
@@truthhurts1936 agreed, if they want to kill someone, then they are free to kill each other as much they want, on their arabic lands.
@@danieldd1804 : You have a point,from 1981 to 1989,the nation of Ir an and Iraq,both Muslim country,killed each oth er at a tune of 4.million casualty, that span for 8years....The occutic glo balist Illuminati will cre ate 1.religion only for th e whole world,for the re ason that religion is one reason for world bloody war.The only god to be worshipped is satan/lu cifer,all other god is puni shable by death,a repeti tion of the incident in the book of Daniel.Prophet D aniel was punished with death sentence,food for 7.days fasting lions!!..gui lty of praying to other Go d within the prescribed limit of 30days.Daniel pr ayed to God not approv ed by the king of Baby lon..... Such theory and reasoning to create 1.w orld religion is tragedy waiting to happen: Iran and Iraq are both muslim nation yet they engaged in bloody war for 8.years as the world watch....The Catholic Holy Inquisition from 10th-18th century had murdered 200.milli on plus peoples,mostly protestant/born again christian....Wrong start, wrong ending... Garbage in,garbage out....This say ing was tested for the pa st thousand of years.....O nly the genuine peace of God can create genuine and perfect peace...Only Lord Jesus can give true PEACE...(John 16:33)....
If you got offended when somebody criticize your faith then you believe in lies.
Yes ... Where is the turning of the other cheek
that's it! i'm going to buy this book.
Offended by everything, ashamed of nothing. Aggressively demand respect by everyone who gives you refugee, and give absolutely none back.
They just take, take, take as did their 'prophet'.
If Rushdie wrote about what was already written, What's wrong with that?
He lied mocked Islam too
The fact you have to go and by the book first and read it in order to be offended says it all about the Religious mind.
Thirty eight mosques in Bradford?! And now? Bradford taken over completely.
Keep your law in Middle East.
That guy at 0:55 basically said, "I can excuse vicious attacks against myself and my family, but I draw the line at criticizing my fictional deity."
Somebody swears at your parents and you'll tolerate it? That's just disappointing
Really is , these guy gotta
Open their eyes
@Rupesh Sahu I love my prophet more than my family. Muslims do. And so it makes sense that nothing should be said like this or consequences will occur out of emotion.
@ajajssksk1757 He is a paedophile though 😂. Sahih Al Bukhari 5133
I respect the rights of religious people to feel anger when something blasphemous is published but I also think that religion doesn’t take precedence over the right to free expression. There are obvious limits to our freedoms but simply causing offence isn’t enough to say someone doesn’t have the right to put something out in the world.
What if we applied that logic to someone mocking or making a parody or insulting characters from the religion of Judaism or doubt the occurrence of the holocaust. No publisher would dare publish such a book out of fear of consequences. Why mess with Islam when one cannot even think of messing with another religion?
@@szehrar you don't mock reality tragedy and victims its common sense . But You criticise politician, state head, religious figures , religion .see the difference . Why we criticise a religion because it tries to sell something . If guy says he is the son of God or messenger of God and split moon or sea then we laugh .its because we know it's not reality . But disasters are real its victims are real
@@7_years_and_ Good point. Israel expanding into Palestine is a reality. Try criticising that.
@@szehrar You are doing that now . people are doing that every where with out getting stabbed. what else do you want
@@7_years_and_ i tried it, and was called anti-semitic. The act of one lone wolf stabbing Rushdie does not mean that the entire Muslim world supports the act. He may have been a mentally ill person.
When your guts burns you know that it's true and you are caught red handed.
That's why Europeans and Americans guts hurt when we talk about Islam right ?
@@hamzasaleem2550 your cult is so fragile till it couldn't handle any criticism. It easily breaks into pieces.
@@hamzasaleem2550 imagine believing your "holy" words hold so much value.. lol ppl need to get over themselves and especially religions that make such insane and controlling demands of there masses..
@@hamzasaleem2550 may lawda misguide you brother aaa thuu.
then aggression comes
If you don’t like the book, don’t buy it! It’s really funny how he unintentionally made himself more famous and popular because so many people were ‘outraged’ at his depictions of people.
In our Hindu Culture, Books are Sacred Objects which represent the Hindu Goddess of Wisdom. We would never think of Burning Books or even throwing them around or Tearing them, Even if dislike or disagree with what is written in the Book.
I guess not all Cultures are the same..
Which ones the book wisdom one? I only know Shiva and Kali.
Lol. As if you are the only hindu in the world
@@TylerShacklefordDurden Saraswati is considered the Hindu Goddess of Wisdom and Learning.
If in the so called book the writer writes filthy stuff about Shiva n Ram n your holy personalities what would be your reaction???? You Hindus dont even tolerate blasphemy of the Cow which you call it Maaataa
@@madihawaqas6410 true, bunch of hypocrites
These same men protesting treat women like trash
Actually the kid at the end was the most impressive person in this clip. Not that I agree with him but for his age he made well mature arguments. The kid is smart as fvck.
Why is Islam so weak..that a book can upset so many Muslims..if u claim Islam is the truth..then defend your faith with strong words not by using force n criminal acts.
It just shows that free speech totally depends on depends on who you're talking about, where and when. To me, social media rules make the most sense because what's forbidden is usually just that which causes violence
Salman Rushdie is a great scholar a great writer novelist
He's a great writer. He's not a scholar
A proud Indian ex muslim here
Hello dear friend... A proud atheist iranian..
❤
@@shinchannohara5621 🤝
How do u guys stay alive. I mean because In Hindu households, our parents don't care about being religious.
@@xxxxxxxxxxx-ps8pn we stay alive because not every Muslim is an extremist and follows islam as it is.
Blasphemy against religion is not blasphemy against God. Religion is not God. Period.