'I Sensed Pakistani Duplicity Ahead Of Kargil'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- Pakistan has not grown as a nation; it remains deeply insecure and army-dominated. This was how G Parthasarathi, described that country where he was serving as high commissioner 20 years ago. As he observes today, little has changed. In this edition of 'Mission Possible', Parthasarathi looks back on those tumultuous days, including Pakistani perfidy on the Kargil heights. He also recalls an address by then Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf that even if Kashmir was resolved, low-intensity war against India would continue.
#India #pakistan #Kashmir
Super-Duper. I am awestruck by the humility of G Parthasarathi and the sagacity of the interviewer Surya Gangadharan to remain in the background all throughout.
Best SNI interview in my opinion so far!
We want to see more of Parthasarathy. It is such a joy to just listen to him
I can see , Amb. G Parthasarathi Sirs Health is not good. Take care of yourself
Age related illness maybe..I hope he recovers from it
Lets all pray for his health.
May be too much light in his eyes.
Excellent interview!
I've always been an admirer of Ambassador Parthasarathy.
This a pleasure to listen to.
I hope those Canadian, British and American Sikhs watched this and took lesson.
Doubt it ..... some of them were sure seen at Kartarpur Sahib doing same things
The Sikhs in Washington DC still have protest March fir Khalistan
Very learned and experienced bureaucrat...always a pleasure listening to him
Always good to see and hear Parthasarthy Sahab.
What a scholarly gentleman, thank you sir for your service.
When ever I listen to Pardhasarthi Sir feel proud and excited.
I personally feel Modiji govt should have used his services more better way.
We would like more of his views on other important Indian centric diplomatic aspects with other Countries also.
Once again we thank you 🙏.
If possible please come to Hyderabad for all ur needs
The most interesting man to listen to. His years of experience with Pak is invaluable.
Parthasarthi sir,
please take care. Simply love to listen to you. Best wishes...
Never trust the Pakistani Punjabi Army
@APS Chauhan.... Wow..... Just wow.... Great in belittling a community who had won and protected Indian sovereignty on countless occasions.....
@APS Chauhan This was really a stupid talk of belittling Indian community, shame on you.
@APS Chauhan such stupid and uneducated rhetoric. Our Punjabi brothers had been the shield defending India and the sword punishing India's enemies. Respect for my Sikh brothers from a Bengali❣️
@APS Chauhan Indian Punjabis (both Hindu and Sikhs) as a whole have always been at the forefront when it comes to serving for the country. Khalistan thing doesn't track much support in Punjab either. It's only those Sikhs who don't even live in Punjab. Btw, Chauhans in Pakistan (yes, they've people with this surname too) also call themselves Punjabis, Rajput Punjabis to be precise.
@@732anoop, u have to develop the ability to recognize a punjabi pakistani acting as punjabi Indian.
Partha Sir you are strong iron man I m fan of you. Whenever you comes on times and Republic your each word sounds weight. Hats off you Sir.
Such an insightful interaction. Thank you SNI for another excellent interview.
Please name these episode so that we can Indentify it later when they go out of trending. Thank u
In the deliberation at the very end, Ambassador you said about sensible people in Pakistan, but do they really carry any weight, or their views count in Pakistan, you did not elaborate on it. What counts in Pakistan is their army, in every aspect, and you are absolutely right that we can never trust, Punjabi dominated and to much extent radicalised Pak army. The only treatment is obvious without words.
As always, insightful. Amb. Parthasarthy - please take care of yourself sir. SNI - thanks for this interview.
Good chat. Was hoping to hear more about Parthasarathy's views on the post Kargil diagnosis in Pakistan about the misadventure and the conclusion that it was planned entirely by 4 generals without any political involvement.
It's good to listen from horses mouth. May God give Partha health n long life.
All well spoken, but what parthasaarthy just said in the last 20 Seconds, is unacceptable. This is exactly the kind of problem that bugs us - a forgiving & self destructive tendency in some of our frontline fellows till this day, since the Mahabharata period. Arjun's predicament or Dharam Sankat to put it precisely was demolished by bhagwaan krishna on the battle field.
Wake up Hindus and stay mentally strong - ruthlessly, mercilessly & ferociously offensive, never defensive in Ur mindset.
Jai Hind...
Palan Harish - Absolutely right. The belief that ahimsa under all circumstances is a virtue is a self defeatist attitude. The only language that Punjabi Muslims of Pakistan Army understand is that if you step on our toes we will cut off your feet.
Pruthvi raj Chauhan defeated Mohamad Ghauri in the first battle of Tarain
Ghauri understood how rajputs fight: that Rajput fight only from sunrise to sunset and how ethically a Rajput fight is more important than winning the battle
So the next year he came and attacked the rajputs at night and won and established the first Islamic kingdom
Fantastic interview. Great insight by one of most distinguished ambassadors G Parthasarathy.
Let's be honest, Atal Bihari made the same mistake as Nehru. He was also vying for Noble, to please the Muslims, and blinded himself from reality. War comes to those who are least prepared for it. So, if you want to avoid war, always be prepare for one.
@john doe We may have won, but we came so close to losing the Kashmir. Had it been not for Israel's critical help, we may as well have ended up losing Kashmir or a large chunk of it had the world power pressurize Vajpayee enough to stand down.
Roshan Chachane if you want Peace be ready for war.
@john doe Would you please come with a thorough research
@john doe Israel supplied with Laser Guided Bombs and Sattelite map of the summits, where the Pakistani infiltrators were holed up.
Parthasarthy Sir is too good
Fascinating ringside view of developments leading up to the Kargil war, giving valuable insights into the duplicity of the Pakistan establishment, particularly its army. Congratulations.
What they done to abhinandan when is India going to avenge that😡 I hope Indian air force never forgives😓 Hope the next India faces Pakistan should be an endgame🤔
I wish you asked the views about Ambassador about Cpt. Saurabh Kalia.
Fantastic... Do more such interviews
Good discussion
What an amazing interview... As rightly said by GP Sir - We still have not learnt to understand how treacherous can Pak Army be...
Kargil was the absolute failure of intelligence and diplomats in Pakistan.
Thanks for Uploading.
Very good episode. Kindly discuss Afghanistan with Mr Parthsarthy and also ask him about the backchannel talks of the plane hijack which he is talking about.
The statement that Army was told not cross LOC was appreciated by Foreign powers
What BS is this.
This probably is one of the causes for heavy casualties and loss of precious, innocent Indian army lives
@john doe What a joke! The Indian Army fought off the enemy from Tololing Ridge, Drass, Kargil, Mushkoh Valley, Tiger Hill, and numerous other features despite having one hand tied behind its back by the Government of India. None of these features were regained through diplomatic negotiations. In fact, our government decided to give safe passage to the surviving infiltrators when we were in a position of strength, by prematurely agreeing to a ceasefire.
@john doe If the government hadn't restricted us from crossing the LC, we would've severed their logistics channel from Skardu within 48 hours, and the infiltrators would not even have grass to eat within a few days. The frontal assaults caused us massive casualties.
Our ability to regain territory was never in question. It is just that a lot of needless Indian blood was spilt because of the manner in which we went about it.
@john doe Many of those casualties were a result of frontal assaults. If we'd avoided this naive tactic, crossed the LC, and cut the enemy's logistics, we'd have finished the war earlier and with fewer casualties.
@john doe One quarter the cost??? We lost far too many men. We'd have lost very few, had we launched special operations along the Skardu-Kargil axis and disrupted the enemy's logistics. The 7:1 or 9:1 ratio came into play only because we were forced to carry out frontal assaults. This was completely avoidable.
@john doe True! And the political dispensation at the time, ended up being over-conservative.
The Intelligence failure as claimed by this foreign secy is totally wrong.
I was told that Defence Intellegence and RAW gave a clear picture of what was coming soon (??Kargil war) to the then Defence minister George Fernandez ( and of course PM Vajpai too) .
These arrogant fellow George Fernandez underestimated and result isloss of precious Indian army lives
SNI is my favorite TH-cam channel
Excellent conversation sir 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Great interview very authentic and very real !
Of course Mr. Parthasarthi is right when he says that Pakistan has not grown up. Pakistan is certainly a Bonsai Republik
right word, Bonsai Republik
Kargil infilitration was a failure on Indian part, due to complacency of Vajpayee Govt, which was in peace talks with Shariff Govt.
Great to listen his views.
But now since all the documents are in public domain, and it clearly show that young officers even brigadier rank officers informed the superior officer about Pakistan occupation and trying to capture key feature in our areas well before between Nov 1998 to Jan 1999. But senior leadership failed to react and we lost so many soldiers.
I can't seem to stomach the fact that Mr G . Parthasarathi said ' that the greatest intelligence failure in our Indian history was our inability to discover movement of Pakistani forces towards our border' . I guess he forgot to mention the Chinese. Who not only built a road in our territory now ( aksai chin) in 50's but it took us a decade to discover it . And now we don't even have it.!!!!!!!!
Which one is the bigger failure? Sir tell me
D he is probably a nehru gandhi lover.. ofcourse doesn’t have the guts to speak the truth
These sort of persons r also like soldier confronting with diplomatic front. They have their own weapons to turn treagdy into triumph.
It was a pleasure listening to your views..
First time, I have heard our inside story of Kargil. G Parthasarthy Sir is great, very honest.
By the way, I have seen lot of videos wherein many Pakistani journalists and thinkers have openly blamed and critisised Musharraf & his 3 generals who inflicted Kargil on us.
Sir , प्रणाम ,,,,,
You are an institution ,,
You are hero Sir
excellent interview will follow SNI ftom now on . people like Partha should be used. great interview
U r simply and indirectly endorsing Modi.
Presently Modi is right man for pak, militarly, politically, economically.
Nice to Note Sir! that you have remained as Prompt and Prepared for any type of Question as you used to be during the Days gone by! Ambassador (Rtd) Harsh Manral.
Intelligent and insightful..Thank You!
Excerpt from Naseem Zehra book
Sartaj Aziz pointedly asked his PM whether the plan the army had made was not contrary to the undertaking in the Lahore Declaration. “Sartaj Aziz Sahib, can we ever take Kashmir through paperwork? We have here an opportunity to take Kashmir,” was a relaxed Nawaz Sharif’s response. By contrast, his foreign minister was perturbed. He was clear that this operation would not help Pakistan get international support for Kashmir.
@ 19:01, “ Never trust the Punjabi speaking Pakistani army”.
Gospel Truth.
🙏🙏🙏🙏
What a personality. Never seen long time on many channels.
Such a nice talk.. Thank you 🙏
Fantastic piece of conversation
Partha Sarathi Sirji - I am a great admirer of yours. Pl. reply my "impertinent" question. Question: Prelude_ I totally agree that BOFORS was a great help in retaking the hills. But Sir - Why still the casualities of our Young Officers were very high. Did Airforce deployment/Bofors Gun depoloyment was made a bit late.
Hegemonic country of course in a natural way since it’s the oldest civilizations which continues to thrive and is Pakistan’s Ma and Baap they can’t change history
An Embassader par excellence. He served in Pakistan in abnormal and desperate conditions under life threatening circumstances.
Sirji - Do you think was Simla Agreement a lost opportunity for India (having had 90,000+ PoWs ). If a light is thrown on it we will be thankful.
Great interview simply. Healthy life to u sir
GP is a good man. But this interview is irrelevant because Gen V. P. Malik has covered most of these points quite succinctly in his book. He has also accepted that the initial belief of the local commanders that mujahideen were involved in the infiltration as a failure of the military intelligence. Gen Malik has further said that only four Pakistan military officers were involved in the planning of the Kargil operations. That Nawaz Sharief was informed at a much later stage by telling him that if Kashmir could be separated from India then Sharief’s name would be written in golden letters and that he would be sung as the liberator of Kashmiris. So Sharief also started seeing a dream for himself. At this point it was not possible to safely retreat from the occupied heights. Gangadharan could have probed the ambassador on these aspect. Gen Musharraf’s statement that even if Kashmir issue is resolved the attempt to destabilise India, which he (read Pakistan Army and puppet political leaders) regards as a hegemonic state, would continue, is new. This should make Indian government sit up and think seriously.
Parthasarathy needs to learn some basics that are Ben small time marketers know. Duplicity, used for your benefit, is a good thing.
Surprised at the basic flaw in this man’s knowledge.
Bhai nut ko tight karne ke liye socket ka istemaal kiya kare, chisel hammer ki jagah second hand 200 Rs tak mil jayega ❤❤❤
I am reminded by a press conference by Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto soon after fiasco of 1971 war lost by PAKISTAN,
Bhutto was asked what will be his first order of business after taking over as president,
BHUTTO said, get rid of all the fat and flabby GENERALS of the army.
India needs to introspect regarding our generals ALSO
simply superb...
Voice of wisdom, him and K. C. singh..
PM Vajpayee was naive and deserved to be rejected by Indian voters in 2004.
Great knowledge
Government has not taken lessons from Kargil seriously. There are two phases of Kargil war. Pre'bofors and Post Bofors artillery induction. The first phase India was losing miserably and the second phase we got a fighting chance. Lesson learnt - use your Artillary, helicopters, missiiles, RPGs and drones first before using army as cannon fodder and not the other way round, and be prepared for the worst scenario don't scramble after the damage is done.
Listening to parthasarthyji is a bliss
Good interview!!
Brajesh Mishra was much ahead of his predecessors ,
India has got the bright history of , Menons , haksars all others but ,Brajesh Mishra was a stalwart among the other gods of strategic affairs,,,।
God bless to Mr. Ambassador
Thé bofors guns were obtained in 1987 and because of the corruption scandal it was put in storage without usage
During Kargil war, Vajpayee and George Fernandas took the decision to use the bofors guns
Each bofors Shell cost $1000
India reestablushed deal with bofors abs got the shells
Such a stupid thing to put the guns in storage for 11 years that we paid for and denying the army of these guns
👌
Good
G.Parthasarathy(GP) was an excellent advisor to Indira Gandhi on Srilankan tamil issues
GP was a Tamilian, from the Hindu newspaper family group: The Kasthuri Rangan group
His advise was:
To Eelam tamils: give defunct weapons to Tamil militants so that they keep engaged against Srilankan army but not a win for Eelam
To Sinhalese: offer them tea and express sympathy
Rajiv Gandhi came to power and replaced GP with Romesh Bandari, an arrogant Brahmin from UP who had no clue about Tamils or Dravidians
This led to indo-Srilanka accord which threatened Rajiv Gandhi life on the day it was signed by a Srilankan naval cadet and later led to the murder of Rajiv Gandhi
Rajiv Gandhi betrayed Tamils and died licking tamil soil
Very interesting.
Q: do ordinary pakistanis not support their jihadi army's terrorist designs and anti-india sentiments
@Maneesh Singh Damn right.
Parthasarathi has been around since Nehru!
wal dan pak armi wal dan
GP Were you in DEMENTIA for 28 long years? Must be entered in Guinness world records.!!
Khalistan movement is nurtured in Pakistan
This Mufti requires BATA
We need more South Indians or people from South India in the diplomatic relations especially in Pakistan and Bangladesh. The reason being that in the past and even now sometimes there is still a soft corner in some North Indians who see Pakistani people as their long lost brothers ( it is true in many cases) but this is not wrong on the people Level but when it comes to relations between governments, the Pakistani Army and establishment is much more devious than what the people in the Indian government especially North Indian community think who have has some family ties with the people or with the place living in the Pakistan . This has been misused by the Pakistani Government and Army and its ISI on numerous occasions. Let it be Sikh Community for a very good example. If you think I have anything against my own people in North India, don't get me wrong. But time and time again this has been true especially and mostly with India Pakistan relations .
G parthasarathi now after retirement wants to be an astrologist.
He is proved right by looking at current Pak condition.
🙏🙏🇮🇳
Vajpayee, Brijesh Mishra was chutiya sad to put this line , but parliament, Kashmir assembly,kandhar, Kargil so on...attack ans still Aman ki asha.. chutiya Raja.. India should under the hands of leader like sanjay gandhi and narendra modi ,not chutiya and gandulike Nehru , Vajpayee...
Who was the Indian defence minister, who kept sleeping during kargil incursion..?
Hindi mein kyon nahi karte Sir ji....atleast Hinglish bhi chalega....pls....🙏🙏🙏🙏
Parthasathy looks frail. Take care of your health sir
There was no need to talk about khalistan, punjab have congress govt.
No one talks about khalistan in punjab but media. Stop that.
So how India won the war when enemy has crossed the line and came so deep in our territory?India had lost the war when it gave enemy so much space..salute to the courage of Pakistani generals for taking on such an enemy which is much higher in numbers and budget..
Never trust pakistani punjabi army
Did you sense the duplicity of India in case of Hyderabad and JK.
Bull shit he is Indian diplomat not Pakistani
G partha is a gem 💎 stay Blessed always ❣️😊