rhda8386 Also, Robin couldn't have been more than 8 years old at the time living in Port Charles. What would she know of Robert and Holly's relationship at the time? Another thing, if she was in a coma, her family would most likely be responsible for putting Ethan up for adoption, which they would would have done in a heartbeat as payback to Robert (and Luke).
if Ethans conception time is correct as Robin figured, Holly was in Australia waiting for Robert's return from the mr. Big caper...did Holly cheat on Robert with Luke then? She told Robert she had never been with any other man when she came back in 91? crazier things have been created!
Holly and Robert were so crazy about each other during that time when she left for Australia and when he joined her that it is a complete slap in the face to fans. Whatever they make up, it just was not psychologically possible in 85. The whole story was Robert and Holly’s passion for each other. Luke and Laura were happy with a baby.
@@ravenel2 , but Robert had feelings for Ana at that time. Remember he passionately kissed her at the airport, right before he joined Holly in Australia. And Luke still had lingering feelings for Holly. And Holly was torn between Luke and Robert and apparently she still had some lingering feelings for Luke. Or Maybe Ethan is not Holly's child.
Robin says she sincerely doubts that Robert Scorpio is Ethan's father .... Well, I have always sincerely doubted that Robert Scorpio is Robin's father. Robert is a fool for not getting a paternity test. Given all the women Robert has been with, I am more inclined to believe that Robert is not able to father a child than I am to believe that Robin is his daughter. If he had discovered back in 1985 what is likely the truth, then Robert would still be in Australia happily married to Holly.
Chris Terry Naw her brother is Heinrich Fasion even though that story is more stupid than this one because they messed her mother who is a legendary character up
@@sergioparker7736 I agree that the Heinrich Fason story is stupid. Hard to say which is more stupid 'cause this is pretty bad, too. They really screwed around with characters that their audience know better than their writers. The good news is that Heinrich is not Anna's son. At least there's that.
Not unless I missed someone else. Peter August was really Alex Devane's son with Caesar Faison. Some twin experiment done on them made Alex and Anna have each others memories and think they were their own or something bizarre like that. It had something to do with the memory mapping done on Jason and Drew, also Franco.
The problem with Mr. Big and "using history" is they forgot to follow through to when Ethan would have been born ... smack dab in the middle of Holly's coma in England.
I actually thought that the Mr. Big thing was a year before that. Robin called Robert. he came back, but was still married to Holly, and then when the mob thing wa sover he went back. he came back the following summer and said that Holly had died. But, what it does mean is that he would have been born when Robert and Holly were married, so you would have think Robert would have noticed.
Mr. Big was the last six months of 86. Robert returned to PC mid 1987, so, yeah he should have noticed she was pregnant, and, Holly would have had Ethan while in the coma.
The writers are so obtuse! Don't they do their homework? Holly was locked away on a coma when Ethan would've been conceived! And I really doubt Luke would cheat on Laura anyway, at least at that point! I also can't imagine Luke or Holly having any romantic interest in each other! Their story is ancient history! L. is the love of Luke's life, and R. is the love of Holly's life! This storyline is a farce.😞😬
Or perhaps considered a premature birth ! Robert was back in Australia with Holly from mid Jan '87 to the end of March After Robert left again, Holly was in a car accident and a coma in April '87 - Feb '89, so if Holly is the mother she may not have gone full term - - and since she was in a coma, she wouldn't remember the birth or giving him up for adoption ... so I feel the person we see in the 21st century story lines has been her look alike half sister Paloma impersonating Holly for some reason.
Muertos, Robin doesn't need a sibling. There's nothing wrong with being an only child. I prefer Robin as an only child. She is perfect just the way she is.
Robin seemed like she didn't want to even consider the possibility that Ethan could be her brother. Same way she was with Peter. She seems to want her parents to only have her as their child so she could remain the only star in their lives.
You what would be kinda awesome, if Robert isn't his father (even tho I'm soooo NOT an Ethan fan)? If it was Mac... Think about it...we have NO idea what he was up to until he came to Port Charles in '91. He probably looked a lot different back when he was a mercenary and if they ever do a DNA test, it would explain why he would have factors in common with Robin and Robert!
Since when do the writers follow old storylines? It's like they don't give a damn about continuity. Let's set the record straight: Holly was in a coma in England at the time she would've gotten pregnant Robert was working on a big crime lead in Port Charles. His daughter figured that out easily (she's a surgeon, after all). Now Ethan's Aussie accent might lead to Robert, but the logistics make that impossible ( until a new group of writers show up and make up their own scenarios). Many of them might not have even been born when R & H were the supercouple of those days! Please kids, read the back stories!
I can’t even watch this. The idea that Holly would have Luke’s baby or give up Robert’s baby is insane.
I still think he is Roberts son after all these years.
Holly Said Ethan was her only son, not only child.
rhda8386 Also, Robin couldn't have been more than 8 years old at the time living in Port Charles. What would she know of Robert and Holly's relationship at the time? Another thing, if she was in a coma, her family would most likely be responsible for putting Ethan up for adoption, which they would would have done in a heartbeat as payback to Robert (and Luke).
if Ethans conception time is correct as Robin figured, Holly was in Australia waiting for Robert's return from the mr. Big caper...did Holly cheat on Robert with Luke then? She told Robert she had never been with any other man when she came back in 91? crazier things have been created!
Holly and Robert were so crazy about each other during that time when she left for Australia and when he joined her that it is a complete slap in the face to fans. Whatever they make up, it just was not psychologically possible in 85. The whole story was Robert and Holly’s passion for each other. Luke and Laura were happy with a baby.
@@ravenel2 , but Robert had feelings for Ana at that time. Remember he passionately kissed her at the airport, right before he joined Holly in Australia. And Luke still had lingering feelings for Holly. And Holly was torn between Luke and Robert and apparently she still had some lingering feelings for Luke. Or Maybe Ethan is not Holly's child.
Robin says she sincerely doubts that Robert Scorpio is Ethan's father .... Well, I have always sincerely doubted that Robert Scorpio is Robin's father. Robert is a fool for not getting a paternity test.
Given all the women Robert has been with, I am more inclined to believe that Robert is not able to father a child than I am to believe that Robin is his daughter.
If he had discovered back in 1985 what is likely the truth, then Robert would still be in Australia happily married to Holly.
Little did we know. Robin really did had a long lost sibling
Chris Terry Naw her brother is Heinrich Fasion even though that story is more stupid than this one because they messed her mother who is a legendary character up
@@sergioparker7736 I agree that the Heinrich Fason story is stupid. Hard to say which is more stupid 'cause this is pretty bad, too. They really screwed around with characters that their audience know better than their writers. The good news is that Heinrich is not Anna's son. At least there's that.
Peter is not even her at it turn out that Peter is Alex son
Not unless I missed someone else. Peter August was really Alex Devane's son with Caesar Faison. Some twin experiment done on them made Alex and Anna have each others memories and think they were their own or something bizarre like that. It had something to do with the memory mapping done on Jason and Drew, also Franco.
How tf would Robin know if her dad had an affair ? She so certain like she was there with him 24/7 it's a little weird 🤨
The problem with Mr. Big and "using history" is they forgot to follow through to when Ethan would have been born ... smack dab in the middle of Holly's coma in England.
I actually thought that the Mr. Big thing was a year before that. Robin called Robert. he came back, but was still married to Holly, and then when the mob thing wa sover he went back. he came back the following summer and said that Holly had died. But, what it does mean is that he would have been born when Robert and Holly were married, so you would have think Robert would have noticed.
Mr. Big was the last six months of 86. Robert returned to PC mid 1987, so, yeah he should have noticed she was pregnant, and, Holly would have had Ethan while in the coma.
The writers are so obtuse! Don't they do their homework? Holly was locked away on a coma when Ethan would've been conceived! And
I really doubt Luke would cheat on Laura anyway, at least at that point! I also can't imagine Luke or Holly having any romantic interest in each other! Their story is ancient history! L. is the love of Luke's life, and R. is the love of Holly's life! This storyline is a farce.😞😬
@@katydalton4759 , no. Luke still had feelings for Holly and vice versa.
Ethan's backstory makes no sense at all. No matter how much the writers use Robin to prop it all up. All to please TG's ego. Oh well.
This has got to be the worst storyline in soap history. How could the writers give in and make Ethan Luke's child? This still bothers me to this date.
Robins a doctor you think she could have at least ran a DNA test
Or perhaps considered a premature birth !
Robert was back in Australia with Holly from mid Jan '87 to the end of March After Robert left again, Holly was in a car accident and a coma in April '87 - Feb '89, so if Holly is the mother she may not have gone full term - - and since she was in a coma, she wouldn't remember the birth or giving him up for adoption ... so I feel the person we see in the 21st century story lines has been her look alike half sister Paloma impersonating Holly for some reason.
@@deborahvanbeuren8557 , maybe Paloma is Ethan's mother.
All these years later and I still say Ethan should be a Scorpio. Damn you Tony Geary! Smh
I'm glad Tony Geary did that. I want Ethan to be a Scorpio.
@@renealexander2703 Not me. And I think u mean Spencer then?? Even if your opinion does suck 🤷🏼♂🤷🏼♂
@@christerry1611 , well, Ethan is Luke's child.
i wish robert was ethan father at least robin would have a sibling
Muertos, Robin doesn't need a sibling. There's nothing wrong with being an only child. I prefer Robin as an only child. She is perfect just the way she is.
Robin seemed like she didn't want to even consider the possibility that Ethan could be her brother. Same way she was with Peter. She seems to want her parents to only have her as their child so she could remain the only star in their lives.
Nygirl, I prefer Robin as an only child. I don't want Robert or Anna to have any other kids. I want Robin to be their only child.
Tony Geary's burner account everyone lol
You what would be kinda awesome, if Robert isn't his father (even tho I'm soooo NOT an Ethan fan)? If it was Mac...
Think about it...we have NO idea what he was up to until he came to Port Charles in '91. He probably looked a lot different back when he was a mercenary and if they ever do a DNA test, it would explain why he would have factors in common with Robin and Robert!
So, what is Ethan's date of birth?
I guess now...Ethan IS a Scorpio
I prefer Ethan remain a Spencer.
@@renealexander2703 Tony "Rene Alexander" Geary folks lol
@@christerry1611 , If I'm "Tony Geary" are you "Emma Samms?"
poor Ethan :-( I did love his hair in this scene though. I think it's a little too long now. Still a cutie though
Since when do the writers follow old storylines? It's like they don't give a damn about continuity. Let's set the record straight: Holly was in a coma in England at the time she would've gotten pregnant
Robert was working on a big crime lead in Port Charles. His daughter figured that out easily (she's a surgeon, after all). Now Ethan's Aussie accent might lead to Robert, but the logistics make that impossible ( until a new group of writers show up and make up their own scenarios). Many of them might not have even been born when R & H were the supercouple of those days! Please kids, read the back stories!
The Greatest Wedding (Pregnant & Birth Scene)
GH - Holly Reveals The REAL Truth - 05/29/09
@TER246 yes i found that interesting as well lol
@belliebelle im glad ethan wasnt robert's, i like that robin is their only child
I agree. I want Robin to remain an only child.
Family Fun Pranks! / AllAroundAudrey