When Ganesh asked about the vision for the next 5 years? Congress leader is unfortunately quoting the same promises that they have been making since 70 years. Really !!? Do they want us to believe in their false promises anymore? It's very ironical to hear such answers from a failed party. BJP is the only way and the solution forward. We will have to become a Manufacturing Nation. Services won't bring us that level of respect. I know how I have been impacted by that because we are not a manufacturing hub. Ganesh, please ask some strong questions.. if's its being broadcasted LIVE which I don't think it is. But Kudos to the entire Thinkschool team for bring out some great content.
Kerala peoples are still rich , and one of the thinks school video , he said that upa took 70 years to rich 1.5 trillion economy and NDA took only 10 years to increase it again by 1.5 trillion , that idiot don't even the know that gdp growth is measured in term of percentages , Lastly I don't know why you tubers are baised toward a single party , dhurve rathee is congress puppet and thinks school is bjps puppet.
No I will not imagine that. I will imagine a particle going at the speed of light and colliding with a similar particle which was also moving at the speed of light.
He is the only congress politician (currently) who never disrespect India in foreign land for the personal political profit. (Infact he always sang the glory of India). Huge respect 🙏🏻.
@@ThinkSchoolHey ganesh, This video was quite good. Informative, to say the least. But here's one thing... I think i felt a little hostility from your side. Maybe it's just me... I can't say with surity. But overall the conversation was rich. Especially , in the MSP case, I was able to understand view of the other side. Kudos to you.
@@devukhare5580Though it may appear so but Ganesh's questions towards Congress manifesto that actually made Shashi uncomfortable. I have nit seen a single congress leader able to properly explain ir justify what is written in manifesto. Shashi Tharoor perhaps was not prepared to answer any manifesto related questions... So it's not Ganesh, it's Shashi himself to blame if there is any discomfort...
Lol... He's saying that the government will regulate the amount of crops to be put under MSP... As if the farming community is an individual entity... 😂@@vinod1147
@@user-br1xp7mu6i exactly, this channel is on finance, at large. swamy raised some legit questions on GDP calculations and most importantly, abolishing income tax and how he credited gadkari for making highways with using bond issued money. I really wanna know what his plans are. No one answered his questions.
Some of his facts aren't accurate so if Ganesh catches on with that, it be epic since Swami do got some expose of the current and past govt @@Nolan608
After 15th commission, kerala lost almost 50% of its income , that's why kerala facing economic problem , still the people's are rich , also kerala is performing well in hdi index, and reality is up , bihar is worst than Pakistan. But think school is totally baised,
@@amanchaurasiya3993 The last thing we need in a capitalistic India is a CPIM, if my name doesn't suggest my experience with them then you need to meet more ppl PS: I am from Bengal and ppl got rid of CPIM due to their dada giri and arm twisting the ppl but the party we got just copied the CPIM and went further
Well done Ganesh These are type of interviews which should be happening more, especially during elections Based on numbers, logic not on emotions and passions I am glad that we have reached a stage where these are beginning to happen More power to your tribe
Yes. But congrats is not owed to Ganesh but tharoor for giving Ganesh a chance to ask these powerful questions. Will BJP leaders allow him to ask such questions?
Iam a keralite and i graduated in electronics 15 years ago ..i couldnt even find any remote job in kerala in which i majored.. Now working in sales field.I hope new generation dont end up like many of us..
Come to gujarat we might be hard-core Hindus because we consider developemnt along with securing down the civilisational heritage and beliefs as a duty to us but in jobs sector especially business we are trained from that right from childhood. "how to make money in any field in the market" is motto of gujjus and apart from that there are more jobs options for engineering society in Gujarat and maharastra than what kerala had for young generation
@@leokatetribute6860 Don't worry, the neighboring state Tamil Nadu really doing well. Second biggest economy and industrial state in India after Maharashtra. It is also a good option.
May be you were passionate enough with your degree did you study for gate examination like competative exams or what were your project in your engineering days
Why didn't you try outside India - GCC? Try - start with IRS.2 lakhs plus and future may go 3x per month; All states compete to export their manpower - you may try with TN, KA, KR, UP, MH all ; $125 bn is the last year remittance receipt of India
I can see the hard work you have done behind every such video. the Questions, your way of asking, putting Mr. Tharoor in different circumstances to get every aspect of the answer out ...truly appreciable. keep it up . looking forward for more such amazing podcasts.
I am from Thiruvananthapuram and he has been our MP for the last 15 years! But we are not that much satisfied...... But, he is the only man, in my POV, who owes respect from Congress....
@@TheGeoPoliticsShow hypocrispy ek sema hothi hai , bro , you are not satisfied with him as MP butyou owes respect for what , for his english Work should speak , How much you study that is not important , you should be connected to ppl
In job sector yeah i agree but other sectors of social index Kerala is performing better than many bjp governed states and has equal social index with some major European nation which is evident from niti ayob reports kerala model of development concentrated on social infrastructure than productive infrastructure that’s the reason for unemployment not generating enough industries and spending heavily on social needs which helped to make Kerala from being the poorest state in the 1960s to one of the least poor state. Which needs a change
@@asifmuhd left destroyed education too .. other growth is all funded by gulf money.. driving jobs in ME in the past kept india float and it's not high skill development we know that.. 😂😂 onnupoda
@@asifmuhd Kerala cannot have industries like TN and Gujarat, Kerala is 54% forest and no IT like Bangalore Hyderabad and Chennai either. Need to find alternate solutions for generating employment in Kerala.. everyday atleast 50K ppl from Kerala come to Mangalore
What an interview!!! I have learned so much from this conversation than watching 15+ years of tv news channels. Also, good to see oppositions point of view as well on current topics.
If you were listening closely to learn and not just to criticize then you'd understand that he did explain the difficulty of doing business and investing in Kerala which in turn leads to less employment opportunities. And you missed it all even with solid examples given. Whaaaat!!!!
6rs can hardly get 1 good sized lemon. Where will you get pineapple for this price? 😮😮 Maybe he meant to indicate that farmers are forced to sell their produce at really low prices... But he could have quoted a more realistic number
Few things I admire about this video and would like it in your future interviews. 1. It is unedited 2. Well researched questions 3. Not trying to lead the questions to create something controversial or sensational.
No vision, No ideas for congress expect for freebies to come to power.. I'm from Shashi Tharoor's constituency - Thiruvananthapuram. No development. Just decay. People continue to leave Kerala. No hope, no jobs. no future.
@@issacalbertp lol...funny how you guys still didn't realise who is stabbing your head and heart!!! Keep voting Congress and Left. In a democracy, people only get what they deserve...you guys deserve Shaahi Tharoor and company..lol
Did anyone else also got this message at the beginning of this video??? "Viewer discretion is advised The following content may contain topics related to suicide or self-harm."
I am from Kerala and What Mr. Shashi Tharoor says is exactly what happens in Kerala. What the Left thinks that if new renovations comes to Kerala, they fears that they will loss their job, instead of thinking getting jobs to the next generation.
But Tharoor too doesn’t have any new thing to add Same congress 5 6 lines from last 70 yrs He was not able to counter any facts number and logic It made me happy seeing comment section that many are more firm why BJP should again come to power 🎉
I really surprised kerala being an educated state and in thier record book they show they spend more than other state for education and medical. Fact is north kerallites study in mangalore and Southern kerallites study in Bangalore and tamilnadu moreover Mangalore given employment to many kerallites and North kerallites use to visit Mangalore for medical. Then where the he'll money invested. Let me tell you what I noticed most of the private medical polyclinic owned by kerallites in middle East. That means govt. Funds been routed out through hawala to middle East to run private medical polyclinic . Now most of the NRI s buying Flats in dubai. Which worth around 1.5 million AED . So money flowing out from kerala . And people also burden for other states . Like Bihar
*Education:* Don't agree with him. Central Government has adopted new Education Policy. Children will learn Coding from Class 6. Vocational Training or Skill Training will be given importance. Even extra curriculum activities like dance, Singing, Yoga, Sports will be important. US Education system is not perfect. Look at US and Britain, most Doctors and Engineers are Indian. Previous Central Government had failed to give importance to Education sector. Even present NDA Government has done little in Education sectors. Yes present Government has build more IIT, IIM, AIIMS and other institution. But Government should do more. Specially Government should work hard with State Government to implement New Education Policy. Yes it will take time but work should be done war footing. By the way many companies has opened R&D center in India recently. *Kerala:* Kerala is surviving because of remittance income. After Covid and Increase of Social media Influence and better travel Infrastructure; tourism has increased. Otherwise Kerala would have bankrupt by now. Both the coalition partner UDF and LDF is partially responsible. He said there should be less regulations but the question is who made those regulations. Answer is mostly his party. *MSP:* The interviewer ask the question regarding Indian economy but he gives answer is purely political. Swaminathan commission has probably given report on 2004-2006. Indian economy would have collapsed if it is implement now on 2024. He is talking about Farmer's suicide if MSP would be implemented completely then Middle class will be collapsed. *How would people buy Rice or Wheat probably Rs 200 Kg or more?* Entire Country's income would go to only one direction. No money would be left for Education, Security, Infrastructure, Healthcare etc? Votebank Policy will kill the Nation. If MSP would be implemented completely by a political party and it would be permanent like Reservation. No political parties would dare to reverse it even economist would suggest to scrap MSP policy. He said that UPA had run the country without bankruptcy. That's partially wrong as Dr Manmohan Singh Sir's report on Banks during his term or UPA time. All banks were in disastrous conditions. But now Banks (Some) has done phenomenal success. Recently SBI has surplus Reliance Industries in terms of Profit. *Mahalakshmi Scheme:* Government can't give mammoth amount to anyone. It will be middle class who have to pay for politically motivated Schemes. This Scheme would be equal to Education budget of the entire country. If Government would implement it, how Government give MSP on crops, where will the money comes? *Human Development:* Yes more money should be there to implement New Education Policy. More Money should be there for Jal Jivan Mission (Note : Water is a State subject but first time in history Present Central Government has taken up the Scheme). More money should be in Healthcare. Last 10 years phenomenal sucess on Infrastructure, Companies will grow, Government would get Revenue and then Government could spend more on Human Development. *Old Pension Scheme:* He said that he would explore many options or He would suggest expert committee for it. But the party has talked about differently. Party doesn't want to explore various options, party strictly wanted to implement Old Pension Scheme. Himachal will run out of money for young people soon. Himachal is a small state will lesser employee but it would be implemented in Telangana, Karnataka; it probably became disaster for Youths and the State.
What he said is true but will the congress change anything? Ommen chandy brought about serious reforms but I don't think the current congress or BJP will do much better.
what is the difference between a communist party and a party that says, "give 1 lakh to one woman in a household", and "give 1 lakh to all unemployed graduates"?
@@rsubhasify certain developed countries do it, doesn't mean that it is feasible for us, our states outnumber their total population, he gave example of Scandinavian countries, you cannot draw parallels between India and Denmark. It will be detrimental to the nation
This was worth spending one hour, I really liked the way questions were bought up by not comparing with parties and there negatives and positives, but looking at it in a constructive manner and keeping the goal to bring out the thought process behind the policies that a party is going to implement. I felt the answer given by Sashi Tharoor sir was more what is gonna happen, but no clarity on how it's gonna happen. Thanks for bringing this Ganesh and keeping it simple and straightforward.
Modi is giving loads of money to crony capitalists, but everything failed to create jobs. It was an old idea that if you give money to capitalists it will trickle down to poor, that has been proved wrong again and again. Its better to give money directly and help the poor to uplift themselves
@@ShafiqueM Capitalism is the only way because socialism is not self sustainable, it doesnot generate money . Because no matter how much freebies you give, it will not help them. If you give money in the hands of the people demand of goods will increase thereby increasing the price and causing more inflation and then govt will again give freebies and then again this process will continue and it will also make people dependent on the govt thereby causing an economic crisis like that of Sri Lanka. And on the other hand huge sum of budget will go into freebies and will reduce infrastructure budget, education budget and therefore will cause really bad economic crisis. Even if it is a trickle down effect, there is atleast something coming but if you go the socialist way, we will be at the mercy of IMF again exactly like 1991.
A native from Trivandrum here Shashi might be eloquent in English and giving political sermons, but one cannot see him GSD (get shit done) on the ground with respect to public schemes, but he will be good as a spokesperson at the UN, etc
So what appeasement has he done for minorities . Ur saying he did nothing for Trivandrum and appeasement for minorities then the minorities would have benefited from this appeasement which would have helped Trivandrum because thses miniorities are people of Trivandrum right 😂
The issue of MSP is not an issue of economics but that og humanity. Farmers deserve sustainance Dnanpith winner of 2015 BV Nemade said, Economics is for cunning people who use it as a tool to exploit the ignorant. In this case it is kind of true
@@aditfinanceno, BJP at the centre. Unless of course you think asking what the favourite mango variety is ‘hard hitting journalism’ . Remind me, when was the last time Modi sat for an interview and was asked tough questions?
I commented on the last video where you asked hard questions to the analyst about BJP and here you are asking questions to Congress member where media is doing nothing just making this election a drama and you here making it easier for us to understand each party ideologies. Thank you THINK SCHOOL. Just do your work and we will always back you when you need us the most.
MSM is catering to a different demographic and this English youtube channel is catering to a totally different demographic. Mostly top 10-15% earners in country watch this.
He speaks a lot well when he’s prepared. Here answering your valid questions i saw him struggling. Frankly i had respect for him as someone sensible but looking at the comments in the section doesn’t seem like he did much for his constituency too and wasn’t able to answer the question related to them properly too. Well good job Ganesh. Glad you are asking the tough questions with well researched data so they just won’t get away with vague answers. Keep it up.
Tbh MPs don't have much influence on their constituencies. They're supposed to make central policies. Local issues have to be dealt by MLAs and councillors.
Sorry, but those are saying did nothing for the constituency are either not from the constituency or haven't bothered to look it up. He ranks second amount the MPs who have spend the most of their MP funds. That too despite the fact that Centre took away that fund since Covid. He is an MP from a party that's not in power in both state and center and the MP fund is the only avenue for him to work for the constituency and that is what should be analyzed with the fact in mind that center had taken that away as well.
I had same opinion about him from last few years. But when you try to analyze his arguments and reesponces, those are not exact solution but just stating in a fashined way that we will handle it like this/that. He did not have a exact answers of the drawbacks of their policies
@@dhirajpatil1602 true that brother. I've always realized that he never gives away his concrete opinion and just presents a diplomatic answer to get away from the question. His arguments surely are questionable but I just love him because of his hold of the English language!
If OPS is so important and people can't live without it, how are private employees surviving after retirement? Only Govt employees life is a concern for you? Not Private employees??
Ops is adv associated with govt employees @ the same time rate of pay hike is dis advantage they have as a govt employee I don't want ops if I can get same growth Opportunity that of ptv, poor salary growth poor ability to to save makes imp to have Ops
@@shivareddykv1114 the same way pvt employee asks for the safety a govt employee has. It's you who has to choose if you want growth or safety. Both don't go hand in hand. Pvt lives in fear every fresh day, some where some countries fight a war, and here we lose jobs by morning. So every thing comes with an adv and disadv.
@@shivareddykv1114 In many sectors govt employees are getting more than private employees. take examples of govt teachers. they getting more than private teachers. private teachers will get an average of 15000 pm but govt salaries are almost double for the starter. 15 years ago that situation was there like govt emp. had lower salaries but not anymore. now they are earning more and even if they work less at least work less competent and they behave like they are a superior race when some one go to govt offices for any work.
@@shivareddykv1114 I will say, you kind of live in a bubble. Do you think a small shop keeper or a thela vala gets major hike? Or corporate majoor get free healthcare and other allowance for free? Rather than giving these arguments you should ask someone who actually work in private sector, people who work in private sectors are one health crisis away from bankruptcy. We have soo many examples around us that usually ignored.
Ganesh has grown from strength to strength... love his confidence while countering such a big political personality. the confidence comes because of the homework he and his team has done.
He “confidently” said that the farmer income nominally grew by 100% and backed it up by lying that he checked the data couple of months back. Humble on the part of Dr. Tharoor that he agreed he will the numbers again. This sort of false confidence is not good and propping it up is just emboldening people like him to lie on the face and then give a short footnote later that he was wrong.
@@siby3060 if the numbers mentioned by ganesh are wrong then you could have corrected him in a decent manner... but you are trying to call him a lier... so we all know which party you belong to...lol
@@siby3060 I'm not a fan of any political party...i vote based on their performance...i feel no one should be a fan of any party or politician... just vote for them based on their performance
@@shreyps I called out his lie since he did lie on the face when he said he checked those figures couple of months back. Its not something that I pulled out of thin air. And calling out something factual isn't a support to any party. If you are linking me to a party because I called out someone's apparent lie then that clearly shows that you are aligned to certain other party even if you claim that you are not a fan of any party. Also, nobody said anything anything about voting based on performance. Vote as per your metrics and conscience, that is the whole point of democracy. However, that is not the point of my original comment.
Great great great work brother. Loved the Interview! I thought you won't question him on MSP but you did and that too with so much clearity and even Mr. tharoor would not have expected. Keep up the great work! 👏👏
@@subhashsahay5218 he hasnt spoken any facts.Can Msp benefit?if congress is introducing it its manifesto then should be answerable. But Manifesto is just to fool people,practically not at all possible
@@yam2050 u tell me what facts have has he got.I know about msp ànd no government can buy at msp rate.Reason 1 1)If bought at MSP then there will imbalance in supply and demand ,for u let me explain Say govt says wheat MSP is at Rs 40,then farmers will focus on profitable MSP and increase the supply side. Now govt cannot pass the rate to public?why inflation will increase.so what option will govt have? Either sell to traders in loss or store it.
One problem with congress and a line seen throughout this video is that "when we come into power we'll do this we'll do that, then why didn't you do it when you ruled for the last 60 years , how can we trust that you will do it when you come into power. Congress and Commies ruled Kerala in all of it's history, congress is also responsible for it's situation today. As far as the literacy rate is considered even in 1950s before Kerala as a state was formulated we still had the highest literacy rate in India it's the people of Kerala who should deserve more credit for all it's developments.
Ruled for ten yrs and still blaming congress. After 2000 it was bjp which ruled for 14 yrs the most and congress ruled 10 yrs. If the pm is really good he should have talked about his development and not about congress, mangalsutra.who the hell are u man. Even if bjp rule for next twenty yrs u guys will blame only congress
@@vv-sz4yh Talking about development doesn't fetch you votes my friend. And the only reason for me hating the CONGRESS is the speed at which Infrastructure is developed by BJP should have been completed by Congress by max 1990's so that we could match the levels of Japan China USA. For those 60 years Congress did nothing but divide the society on the basis of caste this breaking the society and changing the mentality of Indians. Now it's high time that we can't change the mentality of people in terms of caste thanks to congress , parties are left with no option than speaking of religion and caste to obtain votes because you don't know the ground reality that how CONgress has fucked the whole system and created a number of vote banks. If they would have focused on uniting the country and infrastructure development from the beginning i would have been a fan of them....
@@vigneshnayak6969infrastructure development is necessary but what about other sectors? Holistic development giving equal importance to all sectors is necessary which has been completely ignored by the BJP....
@@vigneshnayak6969Most of the IITs and IIMs, the industry at large, land reforms, focusing on swadeshi made goods all done by the Congress. That being said a lot of corruption as well as other things has reduced Congress to this state. You can't blindly say that Congress did nothing and India knew nothing about development and progress until Modi arrived. Don't be a clod. Think a little.
@@aniketshukla3824 Bro I'm not at all biased towards the BJP. But you can't deny the fact that INFRASTRUCTURE development was Fucked up by the Congress party. What they should have done in 30-40 years is still being done now. Compare our infra with Japan where they were hit by a missile attack in the 90's but still way ahead of us and China too. You may tell the number of iit iim have been established by Congress but it's the infrastructure that matters at the end so that Businesses can be set up and a country can lead towards development. And please don't talk about corruption brother I live in a Congress ruled state (Karnataka) because of these FREEBIES 1. My electricity bill has increased by 150% 2. Stamp papers value have been increased from 10 to 100 and 100 to 500. Giving FREEBIES is the BIGGEST CORRUPTION where the end goal is not uplifting the lives of people rather making them more lazy.
FYI Kerala's unemployment situation isn't since today it has been ages... Me, My father others in my family are prime example of that who had to move out of the state or country for job.
Another reason, families forcing their youth to do only white color jobs. That’s why we can see North Indian people working in Kerala for daily wage jobs. And Kerala is a huge job market for North Indian people.
@@mrhunter3886 nah if you have done higher studies why would you do labor work. Instead people will try to go in devolved country work in their respective fields
Well done Ganesh .. iam very impressed by your point to point discussion which is very much needed iin mainstream media.. By the way his answers are only political not practical. Anyway well done ..want dr jaishankar next in your podcast
@The wire @The deshbhakt @Ravish kumar @Dhruv rathee etc all godi youtubers of left parties and their brainless trolls who were calling u a godi youtuber are in shock now .They dont want to listen to anyone who is opposing their view and directcly they call them andhbhakt ,godi media etc but in reality they themself are pawns .
i think so is the case with right wing....I fell both wings should engage in educated discussion..instead of rubbish like Dissolution of Constitution or "ayega toh modi hii" BS
@@hargundeep1866 When opponent parties have started instilling fear among common people by stating nonsensical things like "BJP will rewrite the constitution" or "This is the country's last election" and started alluring people by terming caste census some revolutionary steps to end poverty in India then your theories or facts will surely go down the hell.
Media is biased on both sides of political spectrum. It's the many on the left who think they are standing for the democracy, reality is far from it. First bring new ammendments & interparty elections
@@hargundeep1866 This is a problem all over the world. Politics has become a game of binaries where either you are my friend or my enemy. Both sides claim to be neutral but get instantly triggered once the first question is asked that challenges their theory! Politicians and TH-camrs/Influencers make money, while the general public like us get used as pawns making a f00l out of ourselves.
I am a software engineer. I always think when india will have our own products like Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, Google, Microsoft, Spacex, OpenAI and so many. And its not just only companies but standards too. I will say nearly impossible. Even we have some companies or products, that also on top of american standard or technologies. Even the simple 50USD software certification itself. And if we look at TCS and Infosys, these all are service based companies not product based. Ofcourse we need that but some product companies too. India is nothing to do with AI rather than using that amaerican tech. Anyway we are not bad while comparing with other countries with america. May be the investment focus is the problem. May be because they got independence 247 years ago and we just got 77 years ago. Anyway entrepreneurship is the only key to become better.
Bro japan lagbhag hamare sath hi democratic hua tha aur singapore ko hamare baad azadi mili aaj vo log kaha aur ham kaha hai 77 saal bohot hote hai taraki karne ke liye hume jitni karni chahiye thi hamare size ke according uski aadhi bhi ki hai humne a abhi
@@vinayaksharma9270vaha religion ke basis pe devision hone ki possibility hi nahi hai. Sab ki identity is JAPANESE 🇯🇵 first baad ke unke casts and clans
@@ogthakurLook up "Meiji Restoration". That's how Japan transformed from an underdeveloped country to a highly industrialized one, comparable to Europe and us. Any large reform like that would give our major parties heart attacks. Congress would claim Ambani Adani are destroying us. BJP would claim western culture is destroying us.
@@yatishyadav26111 80% of whose budget !!? 😂. Bro, please stop spreading such false claims !! I urge you to research on how much did the adani's and ambani's contribute to tax compared to farmers !!!!
Great video....He says BJP is gaslighting with the mangal sutras but Rahul Gandhi is openly saying that if your community has 50% population then you have right to 50% wealth which is just an underhanded way of saying we will bring about wealth redistribution (especially when taken along with statements like we will bring a radical revolution). Enforcing equality of outcome is not just a disastrous idea but its also evil because its been seen time and again that it can lead to crumbling of entire nations economy at best and death and destruction of millions of people in some of the worst cases where this was tried to be implemented. And any politician or "intellectual" who advocates it is either naive or evil.
I am from Tamil nadu. What is shocking is our people want more freebies. But this model is not working in north states. Eventhough poverty rate is higher there ,they are voting for development.
@@MKirushnan3925Caste based voting is high in North, they will accept their life is changed, better in last 10 years, but then when you ask. Them , who will they vote, Yadav will say SP, RJD, dalit will say SP /BSP, Jaat in haryana is also voting for opposition, Students preparing for government jobs will vote for opposition. People are gone mad everywhere.
Let's start with those who are still beating their chest for getting this country independent with Charkha and are famous for imposing emergency on this country.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 really? Really? Like how can your thought process be so immature and vhildish. This isn't a cricket match. We are talking about the future of a democracy
@@Stephensofceealike they are interviewing gadkari and ja Shankar 🤔🤔 might bcs of your love for Congress you haven't seen it They came on multiple podcast oh no why am I telling you as if you are blind
I am from Kerala, this guy is the most hyped person in recent times he couldn't do any notable development in his constituency from last 15 years.....my advise is preach only what you follow
I second that. I also had the impression that he was visionary. But this election campaign proved me wrong. He is yet another politician with no vision. He even listed all the central projects as his achievements in his election manefesto.
@@Nobel521 he become popular because of foreign minister.. at that time we had good relationship with all the countries including China.. now see all our neighbors hate us.. not good with Canada, Australia.. exports to foreign countries not improved.. many young generation moving out of the country due to lack of opportunities in India..
The new era of podcast by one and only Ganesh from think school , I was very keen to watch this episode. 👍👍 Keep informative , love your valuable content and you sprade great energy ❤
Right questions no beating around the bushes. I appreciate both, the interviewee and interviewer. Ganesh has studied the topic in detail and makes the conversation more meaningful as others in similar field.
Mannn !!!! The last line !!! Chef's Kiss. Greatly envy your way of communicating to someone with such a contrarian viewpoint to yourself in such calmness. Continue Growing.
Great interview Ganesh! Glad to see number,statistic driven discussion. I used to like Mr.Tharoor, now i realise i liked him because of his command on the language, when the conversation became number/statistic driven, he still relied on his vocabulary skills as a distraction when he couldn’t provide answers to the queries!!!
@@vv-sz4yh so you expect modi to sit quiet when congress publicly does muslim appeasement- not happening -and he will expose congress and their agenda again and again
what a podcast and salute to Dr Tharoor sir As well as Ganesh for listening and making such brilliant podcast you are a great podcaster listner and Good communicator ❤❤
The questions asked regarding to MSP was a huge hit Also the impact of it explained couldn’t get an reasonable answer from sashi sir Great job brother 🙌🏻
When Shashi Tharoor talks about Farmers and that Modi government was unable to double their revenue, he should be reminded that it has his Congress Party that orchestrated Farmers Protest in many states and choked Delhi for months against the Farm Bills that were designed to give them freedom. I am surprised why the host didn't pose this counter to him.
Job of the opposition is to voice the issues people face, regarding farmers issue you wouldn't understand what we are facing on ground. Trying to burry it under other issues using media bjp has failed.
The context of this podcast to understand business outcomes over social outcomes. Possibly why Ganesh is trying to keep the discussion free of conflict.
Good work Ganesh....and kudos to Mr. Tharoor for being able to tackle the question with the subject knowledge backed with stats........ Ganesh we as people of India the only hope for us is quality education...this will take us par with other global nations.
@@rsubhasify yeah that's true, I do agree with you But this guy recently gave clean chit to terrorist ajmal kasab, he has become a terrorist sympathiser like the party he belongs to. He has also given a number of controversial statements in the recent times. I do know that he is a very knowledgeable person but he is associated with the ideology of Congress which is very dangerous.
My two takeaways....Ganesh you rock!!...and Sashi Tharoor's English is good to hear...though what all he said was nonsense. Kudos to Ganesh for not getting mystified by Tharoor's words and sticking to his wits.
@@ajithms8757 yeah I was against the cap, but his response was much beyond just a cap he went further to show their rationale behind it and offered a solution that has merits to have a second look at including the concept of making the poorest labor participants to the economy. These are debatable concepts and not nonsense unless you are politically motivated.
@@AguiarMelwyn there is no use in MSP if a farmer sells a private buyer rs. 50 per kg instead of Rs. 30 the buyer will store it and sell the same at rs. 100 per Kg if you want to help farmer provide him proper storage facility and allow him to sell in open market that will bring diversification in cultivation of crops otherwise we will be in trouble in next 3 years.
This man was the HR minister of congress for a considerable period of time. Why did he not make any effort to update and modernise the syllabus? Ohh yes he was busy creating the IPL team for Cochin. and creating Barcelona.
Best interview i've heard in a long time. Unfiltered, unedited. Talking about economies of scale and keeping the people of india into consideration. Such cross question and debated should be mandatory for every candidate contesting in election. No noise debates as in tv news which do not even do fact check or even cross question anything. People literally lie on national tv and everyone believes it as anchors dont even question them. When candidate participate in debate/interview they will have a fear or being proven fake/liar and hence be educated enough to speak only what can be done and not just 'jumlas'.(And much much more)
Lol... Sashi Tharoor hardly answered any practicality of his manifesto... Also, for him to use the notion of 'human development' by being a representative of a particular Political party who's been in power for around 80% of the period after independence... I mean take a look at Singapore...
Well done Ganesh , This is the best interview by any TH-camr I have ever seen. Its nice you covered the legislative they are from and cover all aspects of current policies, promised policies and its feasibility
I liked this podcast very much. Hats off to the host for asking the questions that generally politicians will beat around the bush. Farm Laws should not have been repealed. It had shortcomings which could have been amended
Loved the podcast the questions were awesome and also the part where Ganesh had facts to back his question that's how real interview should be....The only problem I think about this podcast is it should be live so the guest can't ask you to edit their responses and answers.
Still didn't ask about waqf act , appeasement etc etc .......which was the most prominent question put up by everyone in the comments section of your post 😹😹 Congress and pseudo-secularism go hand in hand with each other .
@@amantiwari4987yeah I think education is a big ground where still bjp had to come out and play their innings specially for the private sectors loot mainly by different medical and engineering colleges
I'm currently a student doing my bachelors in IT in Melbourne. But somehow Ganesh's content fascinate me always and I make sure I don't miss them. Thanks Think School for such amazing podcasts and content ;)
How it matters to the readers whether you are doing your bachelors in IT in Melbourne or Timbaktu. Those cannot get admission in good colleges in India are joining some obscure universities in Australia or Canada. So your university or city need not be highlighted.
![ตั๋วเมีย (ຕົວະເມຍ) - SOMBATH.97 Ft. YOUD SALAVAN [ Official music video ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GV6qHagpp50/mqdefault.jpg)
Are you satisfied with Dr Shashi’s answers? Did you like our questions? Please drop a detailed feedback about the episode ❤ as a reply to this comment
1. No' 2. Yes
When Ganesh asked about the vision for the next 5 years? Congress leader is unfortunately quoting the same promises that they have been making since 70 years. Really !!? Do they want us to believe in their false promises anymore? It's very ironical to hear such answers from a failed party. BJP is the only way and the solution forward.
We will have to become a Manufacturing Nation. Services won't bring us that level of respect. I know how I have been impacted by that because we are not a manufacturing hub.
Ganesh, please ask some strong questions.. if's its being broadcasted LIVE which I don't think it is. But Kudos to the entire Thinkschool team for bring out some great content.
1. No
2. Yes
1
❤, yes thank you Ganesh, Congress should engage more in these kind of discussion to let people understand their agendas better.
Ganesh smiled when Shashi Tharoor said Congress has sensible leaders 😂
will you give me timestamps
33:25
😂😂
Kerala peoples are still rich , and one of the thinks school video , he said that upa took 70 years to rich 1.5 trillion economy and NDA took only 10 years to increase it again by 1.5 trillion , that idiot don't even the know that gdp growth is measured in term of percentages ,
Lastly I don't know why you tubers are baised toward a single party , dhurve rathee is congress puppet and thinks school is bjps puppet.
I watched it again, it was Mr. Tharoor who started grinning as he put out those words. And that just broke Ganesh 😂
Problem with Kerala is Congress is considered Right Wing in Kerala. Imagine that.
Right wing for Moslems only BTW espically in Malabar area
No I will not imagine that. I will imagine a particle going at the speed of light and colliding with a similar particle which was also moving at the speed of light.
😂😂 true that
lol
Lol
Why is this an age restricted video and why am I getting a suicidal disclaimer?
Maybe because of congress 😂
BJP IT CELL reporting the video
Because the word "suicide" was mentioned a lot of times in the video.
@@satviksharma78 here comes the conspiracy
@@satviksharma78 bjp is waiting that Congress PPL start giving interviews, it will help them only
He is the only congress politician (currently) who never disrespect India in foreign land for the personal political profit.
(Infact he always sang the glory of India).
Huge respect 🙏🏻.
What do you consider as disrespecting towards India? When international media outlets say Indian PM has links to the mass rapist who fled India?
@@sohammanna7929y
@@sohammanna7929could you name specifically who?
@@nonsense2048 Feel free to recent news articles and you'll know who I am talking about.
Haha
Ganesh interviewed far superiorly than any TV anchor has ever interviewed. Well done Ganesh. You have put in a lot of effort on this one.
Thank you so much
@@ThinkSchoolHey ganesh, This video was quite good. Informative, to say the least.
But here's one thing... I think i felt a little hostility from your side. Maybe it's just me... I can't say with surity.
But overall the conversation was rich. Especially , in the MSP case, I was able to understand view of the other side.
Kudos to you.
@@devukhare5580Though it may appear so but Ganesh's questions towards Congress manifesto that actually made Shashi uncomfortable. I have nit seen a single congress leader able to properly explain ir justify what is written in manifesto. Shashi Tharoor perhaps was not prepared to answer any manifesto related questions... So it's not Ganesh, it's Shashi himself to blame if there is any discomfort...
Benefits of being an engineer.
Lol... He's saying that the government will regulate the amount of crops to be put under MSP... As if the farming community is an individual entity... 😂@@vinod1147
Next Ganesh should interview Dr S.Jaishankar!!!
maybe later, right now bring in dr. swamy. no one is able to counter him on economy. will be interesting to see how ganesh does it.
Yeah ur right even he's honest unlike any other political leaders whose scared to criticize their own party@@user-br1xp7mu6i
@@user-br1xp7mu6i exactly, this channel is on finance, at large. swamy raised some legit questions on GDP calculations and most importantly, abolishing income tax and how he credited gadkari for making highways with using bond issued money. I really wanna know what his plans are. No one answered his questions.
@@user-br1xp7mu6i precisely, I have never seen anyone who has won a debate with him on economy. Guy is a beast, bring him on.
Some of his facts aren't accurate so if Ganesh catches on with that, it be epic since Swami do got some expose of the current and past govt @@Nolan608
He knows in his heart that MSP is not the solution but still justifying
U didn't understand 😂
Yah
After 15th commission, kerala lost almost 50% of its income , that's why kerala facing economic problem , still the people's are rich , also kerala is performing well in hdi index, and reality is up , bihar is worst than Pakistan. But think school is totally baised,
If the country become economic superpower and 50% people are below poverty line , then such large economy is useless
Then u give the solution
INDIA alliance has CPIM and in their manifesto they mentioned to remove intelligence agencies and get 370 back 😢
And also they promise to neutralize Atom bomb 😆 can u imagine the audacity 😂
Omg
And they will also take your mother's mangalsutra
@@rationalist455before barking shit, why don't you go through the CPIM manifesto
@@amanchaurasiya3993 The last thing we need in a capitalistic India is a CPIM, if my name doesn't suggest my experience with them then you need to meet more ppl
PS: I am from Bengal and ppl got rid of CPIM due to their dada giri and arm twisting the ppl but the party we got just copied the CPIM and went further
Well done Ganesh
These are type of interviews which should be happening more, especially during elections
Based on numbers, logic not on emotions and passions
I am glad that we have reached a stage where these are beginning to happen
More power to your tribe
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
True, but these episodes addresses only minor percentage section of India!
Every little counts
absolutely! such relevant and "to the point questions" asked by him(in mostly all of the interviews)!
Yes. But congrats is not owed to Ganesh but tharoor for giving Ganesh a chance to ask these powerful questions. Will BJP leaders allow him to ask such questions?
Iam a keralite and i graduated in electronics 15 years ago ..i couldnt even find any remote job in kerala in which i majored..
Now working in sales field.I hope new generation dont end up like many of us..
Come to gujarat we might be
hard-core Hindus because we consider developemnt along with securing down the civilisational heritage and beliefs as a duty to us but in jobs sector especially business we are trained from that right from childhood. "how to make money in any field in the market" is motto of gujjus and apart from that there are more jobs options for engineering society in Gujarat and maharastra than what kerala had for young generation
@@leokatetribute6860 Don't worry, the neighboring state Tamil Nadu really doing well. Second biggest economy and industrial state in India after Maharashtra. It is also a good option.
May be you were passionate enough with your degree did you study for gate examination like competative exams or what were your project in your engineering days
Vote BJP... Njanum Malayali aa...
Why didn't you try outside India - GCC? Try - start with IRS.2 lakhs plus and future may go 3x per month; All states compete to export their manpower - you may try with TN, KA, KR, UP, MH all ; $125 bn is the last year remittance receipt of India
Congress should consider Mr. Tharoor as their PM candidate, he is so clear with his thoughts and any day more knowledgeable than Rahul Gandhi
Congress is a family business more lol. It's impossible
Rahul gandhi harvard me speech deta ae uska karale podcast chaljegi reality maloom
But congress is monopoly of gandhi family 🙃
I can see the hard work you have done behind every such video. the Questions, your way of asking, putting Mr. Tharoor in different circumstances to get every aspect of the answer out ...truly appreciable. keep it up . looking forward for more such amazing podcasts.
I am from Thiruvananthapuram and he has been our MP for the last 15 years!
But we are not that much satisfied...... But, he is the only man, in my POV, who owes respect from Congress....
Hello bot
@@TheGeoPoliticsShow bhai congress IT cell naraz ho jayega
same from TVM
I am also from tvm. He is all talk but no action
@@TheGeoPoliticsShow hypocrispy ek sema hothi hai , bro , you are not satisfied with him as MP butyou owes respect for what , for his english
Work should speak , How much you study that is not important , you should be connected to ppl
Unions & Commies have destroyed both Bengal & Kerala. ⚒️
💯
In job sector yeah i agree but other sectors of social index Kerala is performing better than many bjp governed states and has equal social index with some major European nation which is evident from niti ayob reports kerala model of development concentrated on social infrastructure than productive infrastructure that’s the reason for unemployment not generating enough industries and spending heavily on social needs which helped to make Kerala from being the poorest state in the 1960s to one of the least poor state. Which needs a change
@@asifmuhd left destroyed education too .. other growth is all funded by gulf money.. driving jobs in ME in the past kept india float and it's not high skill development we know that.. 😂😂 onnupoda
@@asifmuhd Kerala cannot have industries like TN and Gujarat, Kerala is 54% forest and no IT like Bangalore Hyderabad and Chennai either. Need to find alternate solutions for generating employment in Kerala.. everyday atleast 50K ppl from Kerala come to Mangalore
Bro😂 kerala invented first techno IT park in indian even before banglore started its first it company...@@Kumar_Gowda96
What an interview!!! I have learned so much from this conversation than watching 15+ years of tv news channels. Also, good to see oppositions point of view as well on current topics.
He didn't answer why Kerala has comparatively higher unemployment than other states 😂
If you were listening closely to learn and not just to criticize then you'd understand that he did explain the difficulty of doing business and investing in Kerala which in turn leads to less employment opportunities. And you missed it all even with solid examples given. Whaaaat!!!!
Either you didnt watch the video or you're a bot.
He answered that when he was asked about buisness environment in Kerala.
He gave general answer why unemployment is high in India in general.
Ànd there are many issues where he is not giving perfect answers.
Like on that one lakh per women issue@@bulletclash9188
If fdi don't bring employment, then what? Giving one lakh gives
This is better journalism than every mainstream media house out there and most you tube media houses.
I'm from Puthenchira Trichur kerala. I recently brought pineapple for Rs 45 each directly from a farmer and feel cheated now
Damnnnn bro😅😅
Exactly, which farmer sells pineapple @6 rs
ROFL 😂😂😂😂😂
6rs can hardly get 1 good sized lemon. Where will you get pineapple for this price? 😮😮 Maybe he meant to indicate that farmers are forced to sell their produce at really low prices... But he could have quoted a more realistic number
😂😂
One of the best podcast in recent days.. very impressed with how critically structured entire interview was..!
Good job Ganesh!!
What a interview!! Significant questions asked by Ganesh Sir especially MSP... Thank you so much sir wholeheartedly!!
Few things I admire about this video and would like it in your future interviews.
1. It is unedited
2. Well researched questions
3. Not trying to lead the questions to create something controversial or sensational.
49.22 its edited
@@MemeVidyalaya-qg3dmMaybe a bathroom break.
@@strawmanfallacy8666 may be
No vision, No ideas for congress expect for freebies to come to power.. I'm from Shashi Tharoor's constituency - Thiruvananthapuram. No development. Just decay. People continue to leave Kerala. No hope, no jobs. no future.
But you in Kerala still vote for Congress and left.
@@starxd5697 Standing between sea and devil better than stabbing on our own head.
@@issacalbertp lol...funny how you guys still didn't realise who is stabbing your head and heart!!! Keep voting Congress and Left. In a democracy, people only get what they deserve...you guys deserve Shaahi Tharoor and company..lol
@@issacalbertp why not do it. At least you will face God by saying you chose neither of them but honour .
@@whentheimposterissus8376 you cant feed your kids with honour
It was a treat to watch this. This was researched so well and the questions were well prepared. This is the new benchmark for an interview.
Did anyone else also got this message at the beginning of this video???
"Viewer discretion is advised
The following content may contain
topics related to suicide or self-harm."
I am from Kerala and What Mr. Shashi Tharoor says is exactly what happens in Kerala. What the Left thinks that if new renovations comes to Kerala, they fears that they will loss their job, instead of thinking getting jobs to the next generation.
If left does this, then why has everyone been voting for him
But Tharoor too doesn’t have any new thing to add
Same congress 5 6 lines from last 70 yrs
He was not able to counter any facts number and logic
It made me happy seeing comment section that many are more firm why BJP should again come to power 🎉
I really surprised kerala being an educated state and in thier record book they show they spend more than other state for education and medical. Fact is north kerallites study in mangalore and Southern kerallites study in Bangalore and tamilnadu moreover Mangalore given employment to many kerallites and North kerallites use to visit Mangalore for medical. Then where the he'll money invested. Let me tell you what I noticed most of the private medical polyclinic owned by kerallites in middle East. That means govt. Funds been routed out through hawala to middle East to run private medical polyclinic .
Now most of the NRI s buying Flats in dubai. Which worth around 1.5 million AED .
So money flowing out from kerala . And people also burden for other states . Like Bihar
*Education:* Don't agree with him. Central Government has adopted new Education Policy. Children will learn Coding from Class 6. Vocational Training or Skill Training will be given importance. Even extra curriculum activities like dance, Singing, Yoga, Sports will be important. US Education system is not perfect. Look at US and Britain, most Doctors and Engineers are Indian. Previous Central Government had failed to give importance to Education sector. Even present NDA Government has done little in Education sectors. Yes present Government has build more IIT, IIM, AIIMS and other institution. But Government should do more. Specially Government should work hard with State Government to implement New Education Policy. Yes it will take time but work should be done war footing. By the way many companies has opened R&D center in India recently.
*Kerala:* Kerala is surviving because of remittance income. After Covid and Increase of Social media Influence and better travel Infrastructure; tourism has increased. Otherwise Kerala would have bankrupt by now. Both the coalition partner UDF and LDF is partially responsible. He said there should be less regulations but the question is who made those regulations. Answer is mostly his party.
*MSP:* The interviewer ask the question regarding Indian economy but he gives answer is purely political. Swaminathan commission has probably given report on 2004-2006. Indian economy would have collapsed if it is implement now on 2024. He is talking about Farmer's suicide if MSP would be implemented completely then Middle class will be collapsed. *How would people buy Rice or Wheat probably Rs 200 Kg or more?* Entire Country's income would go to only one direction. No money would be left for Education, Security, Infrastructure, Healthcare etc? Votebank Policy will kill the Nation. If MSP would be implemented completely by a political party and it would be permanent like Reservation. No political parties would dare to reverse it even economist would suggest to scrap MSP policy. He said that UPA had run the country without bankruptcy. That's partially wrong as Dr Manmohan Singh Sir's report on Banks during his term or UPA time. All banks were in disastrous conditions. But now Banks (Some) has done phenomenal success. Recently SBI has surplus Reliance Industries in terms of Profit.
*Mahalakshmi Scheme:* Government can't give mammoth amount to anyone. It will be middle class who have to pay for politically motivated Schemes. This Scheme would be equal to Education budget of the entire country. If Government would implement it, how Government give MSP on crops, where will the money comes?
*Human Development:* Yes more money should be there to implement New Education Policy. More Money should be there for Jal Jivan Mission (Note : Water is a State subject but first time in history Present Central Government has taken up the Scheme). More money should be in Healthcare. Last 10 years phenomenal sucess on Infrastructure, Companies will grow, Government would get Revenue and then Government could spend more on Human Development.
*Old Pension Scheme:* He said that he would explore many options or He would suggest expert committee for it. But the party has talked about differently. Party doesn't want to explore various options, party strictly wanted to implement Old Pension Scheme. Himachal will run out of money for young people soon. Himachal is a small state will lesser employee but it would be implemented in Telangana, Karnataka; it probably became disaster for Youths and the State.
What he said is true but will the congress change anything? Ommen chandy brought about serious reforms but I don't think the current congress or BJP will do much better.
Very impressed by Ganesh! He brilliantly countered Dr. Tharoor on anything he found to be doubtful and clearly there was a lot of confusion.
Good to know , People are asking real question and LOOKING FOR REAL ANSWER...
So happy to see that you have started the podcasts.. most reliable channel for me 🤗
what is the difference between a communist party and a party that says, "give 1 lakh to one woman in a household", and "give 1 lakh to all unemployed graduates"?
Do you know the difference between central planning and a free market economy?
Then they will spend all it for EMI and credit card bills.. LOL 😂
Why have developed countries implemented minimum income ?
Nothing 😂 just missing sickle and hammer in their party symbol
@@rsubhasify certain developed countries do it, doesn't mean that it is feasible for us, our states outnumber their total population, he gave example of Scandinavian countries, you cannot draw parallels between India and Denmark. It will be detrimental to the nation
Ganesh bhai your msp question and example is just awesome 🤯🤯🤯
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
This was worth spending one hour, I really liked the way questions were bought up by not comparing with parties and there negatives and positives, but looking at it in a constructive manner and keeping the goal to bring out the thought process behind the policies that a party is going to implement.
I felt the answer given by Sashi Tharoor sir was more what is gonna happen, but no clarity on how it's gonna happen.
Thanks for bringing this Ganesh and keeping it simple and straightforward.
brilliant discussion, very well framed, organised, flow was great, very informative . great questions were asked and answered!
Instead of giving 1 lakh to women, amassing the wealth, how many jobs can be developed? Freebies should only be given for disabled and old!
Modi is giving loads of money to crony capitalists, but everything failed to create jobs. It was an old idea that if you give money to capitalists it will trickle down to poor, that has been proved wrong again and again. Its better to give money directly and help the poor to uplift themselves
You both the commentee and the commenter must be made the PM of this country!! 💐❤️🔥
I am telling it in true sense.
No exaggeration
@@ShafiqueM muslim logic
@@ShafiqueM Capitalism is the only way because socialism is not self sustainable, it doesnot generate money . Because no matter how much freebies you give, it will not help them. If you give money in the hands of the people demand of goods will increase thereby increasing the price and causing more inflation and then govt will again give freebies and then again this process will continue and it will also make people dependent on the govt thereby causing an economic crisis like that of Sri Lanka. And on the other hand huge sum of budget will go into freebies and will reduce infrastructure budget, education budget and therefore will cause really bad economic crisis. Even if it is a trickle down effect, there is atleast something coming but if you go the socialist way, we will be at the mercy of IMF again exactly like 1991.
A native from Trivandrum here
Shashi might be eloquent in English and giving political sermons, but one cannot see him GSD (get shit done) on the ground with respect to public schemes, but he will be good as a spokesperson at the UN, etc
വളരെ ശെരി oxford English കൊണ്ട് നമ്മൾക്ക് എന്താണ് ഗുണം ??
Rajeev was union minister. What did he do ?
@@vv-sz4yh Technocracy, Rajeev will be a game changer if he wins in Trivandrum
Well said. The likes of ST and Raghu rajan are superbly eloquent and the west have orgasms listening to them, but extremely shallow within
This time also he can win with peaceful community
What a wonderful conversation. Very well thought out questions and very well answered 👏👏
I could have listened to it for another 2 hours, the quality of conversation was just amazing
Im from trivandrum,he hasn't done anything for his constituency.😂he won last time bcoz of minority votes... appeasement
well i think same can be said for a lot of politicians, nowadays majority appeasement & fear mongering is trending for arranging vote banks, lol
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
True
In 2019 41 % vote share with more than 1 lakh majority is because of minority vote nibba go to kindergarten for sake.
So what appeasement has he done for minorities . Ur saying he did nothing for Trivandrum and appeasement for minorities then the minorities would have benefited from this appeasement which would have helped Trivandrum because thses miniorities are people of Trivandrum right 😂
Watching Ganesh drill the economics of MSP and the farmer income is just fantastic. This is the fearless journalism that I come to this channel for.
I only saw Mr. Tharoor educate ganesh on practicality rather than depending on theories based on inaccurate stats !
The issue of MSP is not an issue of economics but that og humanity. Farmers deserve sustainance
Dnanpith winner of 2015 BV Nemade said, Economics is for cunning people who use it as a tool to exploit the ignorant. In this case it is kind of true
Congress ko koi bhi question Kar sakta hain. Fearless are those who can and will question the power
@@dineshbfacesYou mean the Left Front in Kerala?
@@aditfinanceno, BJP at the centre. Unless of course you think asking what the favourite mango variety is ‘hard hitting journalism’ . Remind me, when was the last time Modi sat for an interview and was asked tough questions?
Nailed it Ganesh! Look forward for many more of such great conversations.
First time saw your video and loved the way you asked questions directly 😮
I commented on the last video where you asked hard questions to the analyst about BJP and here you are asking questions to Congress member where media is doing nothing just making this election a drama and you here making it easier for us to understand each party ideologies. Thank you THINK SCHOOL. Just do your work and we will always back you when you need us the most.
MSM is catering to a different demographic and this English youtube channel is catering to a totally different demographic. Mostly top 10-15% earners in country watch this.
He speaks a lot well when he’s prepared. Here answering your valid questions i saw him struggling. Frankly i had respect for him as someone sensible but looking at the comments in the section doesn’t seem like he did much for his constituency too and wasn’t able to answer the question related to them properly too. Well good job Ganesh. Glad you are asking the tough questions with well researched data so they just won’t get away with vague answers. Keep it up.
Yeah he is ruling for ten yrs 😂😂
Ganesh definitely was holding back so many questions
Tbh MPs don't have much influence on their constituencies. They're supposed to make central policies. Local issues have to be dealt by MLAs and councillors.
Sorry, but those are saying did nothing for the constituency are either not from the constituency or haven't bothered to look it up. He ranks second amount the MPs who have spend the most of their MP funds. That too despite the fact that Centre took away that fund since Covid.
He is an MP from a party that's not in power in both state and center and the MP fund is the only avenue for him to work for the constituency and that is what should be analyzed with the fact in mind that center had taken that away as well.
His answers on MSP was dumbest ever
Finally someone heard and bought Dr. Tharoor over a podcast. It was such a delight listening to him!!
I had same opinion about him from last few years. But when you try to analyze his arguments and reesponces, those are not exact solution but just stating in a fashined way that we will handle it like this/that. He did not have a exact answers of the drawbacks of their policies
@@dhirajpatil1602 true that brother. I've always realized that he never gives away his concrete opinion and just presents a diplomatic answer to get away from the question. His arguments surely are questionable but I just love him because of his hold of the English language!
what a phenomenal interview . Every second of it was a catch
If OPS is so important and people can't live without it, how are private employees surviving after retirement? Only Govt employees life is a concern for you? Not Private employees??
Ops is adv associated with govt employees @ the same time rate of pay hike is dis advantage they have as a govt employee I don't want ops if I can get same growth Opportunity that of ptv, poor salary growth poor ability to to save makes imp to have Ops
Unfortunately 6th pay commission deprived govt employees pension.
@@shivareddykv1114 the same way pvt employee asks for the safety a govt employee has. It's you who has to choose if you want growth or safety. Both don't go hand in hand. Pvt lives in fear every fresh day, some where some countries fight a war, and here we lose jobs by morning. So every thing comes with an adv and disadv.
@@shivareddykv1114 In many sectors govt employees are getting more than private employees. take examples of govt teachers. they getting more than private teachers. private teachers will get an average of 15000 pm but govt salaries are almost double for the starter. 15 years ago that situation was there like govt emp. had lower salaries but not anymore. now they are earning more and even if they work less at least work less competent and they behave like they are a superior race when some one go to govt offices for any work.
@@shivareddykv1114 I will say, you kind of live in a bubble. Do you think a small shop keeper or a thela vala gets major hike? Or corporate majoor get free healthcare and other allowance for free? Rather than giving these arguments you should ask someone who actually work in private sector, people who work in private sectors are one health crisis away from bankruptcy. We have soo many examples around us that usually ignored.
Ganesh has grown from strength to strength... love his confidence while countering such a big political personality. the confidence comes because of the homework he and his team has done.
He “confidently” said that the farmer income nominally grew by 100% and backed it up by lying that he checked the data couple of months back.
Humble on the part of Dr. Tharoor that he agreed he will the numbers again.
This sort of false confidence is not good and propping it up is just emboldening people like him to lie on the face and then give a short footnote later that he was wrong.
@@siby3060 if the numbers mentioned by ganesh are wrong then you could have corrected him in a decent manner... but you are trying to call him a lier... so we all know which party you belong to...lol
@@siby3060 I'm not a fan of any political party...i vote based on their performance...i feel no one should be a fan of any party or politician... just vote for them based on their performance
@@shreyps I called out his lie since he did lie on the face when he said he checked those figures couple of months back. Its not something that I pulled out of thin air.
And calling out something factual isn't a support to any party. If you are linking me to a party because I called out someone's apparent lie then that clearly shows that you are aligned to certain other party even if you claim that you are not a fan of any party.
Also, nobody said anything anything about voting based on performance. Vote as per your metrics and conscience, that is the whole point of democracy. However, that is not the point of my original comment.
Great great great work brother. Loved the Interview!
I thought you won't question him on MSP but you did and that too with so much clearity and even Mr. tharoor would not have expected. Keep up the great work! 👏👏
Wow actually a person who asks good and tough questions, unlike a certain someone
This interview proves, Just because a person speaks a good English doesn't mean that he is intelligent to discuss on variety of topics.
Absolutely right
How ?
@@subhashsahay5218 he hasnt spoken any facts.Can Msp benefit?if congress is introducing it its manifesto then should be answerable.
But Manifesto is just to fool people,practically not at all possible
@@ak-rz2cpmaybe you should watch the video again.
@@yam2050 u tell me what facts have has he got.I know about msp ànd no government can buy at msp rate.Reason 1
1)If bought at MSP then there will imbalance in supply and demand ,for u let me explain
Say govt says wheat MSP is at Rs 40,then farmers will focus on profitable MSP and increase the supply side.
Now govt cannot pass the rate to public?why inflation will increase.so what option will govt have?
Either sell to traders in loss or store it.
One problem with congress and a line seen throughout this video is that "when we come into power we'll do this we'll do that, then why didn't you do it when you ruled for the last 60 years , how can we trust that you will do it when you come into power. Congress and Commies ruled Kerala in all of it's history, congress is also responsible for it's situation today. As far as the literacy rate is considered even in 1950s before Kerala as a state was formulated we still had the highest literacy rate in India it's the people of Kerala who should deserve more credit for all it's developments.
Ruled for ten yrs and still blaming congress. After 2000 it was bjp which ruled for 14 yrs the most and congress ruled 10 yrs. If the pm is really good he should have talked about his development and not about congress, mangalsutra.who the hell are u man. Even if bjp rule for next twenty yrs u guys will blame only congress
@@vv-sz4yh Talking about development doesn't fetch you votes my friend. And the only reason for me hating the CONGRESS is the speed at which Infrastructure is developed by BJP should have been completed by Congress by max 1990's so that we could match the levels of Japan China USA. For those 60 years Congress did nothing but divide the society on the basis of caste this breaking the society and changing the mentality of Indians. Now it's high time that we can't change the mentality of people in terms of caste thanks to congress , parties are left with no option than speaking of religion and caste to obtain votes because you don't know the ground reality that how CONgress has fucked the whole system and created a number of vote banks. If they would have focused on uniting the country and infrastructure development from the beginning i would have been a fan of them....
@@vigneshnayak6969infrastructure development is necessary but what about other sectors? Holistic development giving equal importance to all sectors is necessary which has been completely ignored by the BJP....
@@vigneshnayak6969Most of the IITs and IIMs, the industry at large, land reforms, focusing on swadeshi made goods all done by the Congress. That being said a lot of corruption as well as other things has reduced Congress to this state. You can't blindly say that Congress did nothing and India knew nothing about development and progress until Modi arrived. Don't be a clod. Think a little.
@@aniketshukla3824 Bro I'm not at all biased towards the BJP. But you can't deny the fact that INFRASTRUCTURE development was Fucked up by the Congress party. What they should have done in 30-40 years is still being done now. Compare our infra with Japan where they were hit by a missile attack in the 90's but still way ahead of us and China too. You may tell the number of iit iim have been established by Congress but it's the infrastructure that matters at the end so that Businesses can be set up and a country can lead towards development. And please don't talk about corruption brother I live in a Congress ruled state (Karnataka) because of these FREEBIES
1. My electricity bill has increased by 150%
2. Stamp papers value have been increased from 10 to 100 and 100 to 500.
Giving FREEBIES is the BIGGEST CORRUPTION where the end goal is not uplifting the lives of people rather making them more lazy.
Very well done Interview. Great insight into key matters.
Really amazing work. Loved the podcast, looking forward to the next one.
FYI Kerala's unemployment situation isn't since today it has been ages...
Me, My father others in my family are prime example of that who had to move out of the state or country for job.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
True even after college I am going to do the same
Another reason, families forcing their youth to do only white color jobs. That’s why we can see North Indian people working in Kerala for daily wage jobs. And Kerala is a huge job market for North Indian people.
@@mrhunter3886 nah if you have done higher studies why would you do labor work. Instead people will try to go in devolved country work in their respective fields
@@mrhunter3886 go back congressi go back
Well done Ganesh .. iam very impressed by your point to point discussion which is very much needed iin mainstream media.. By the way his answers are only political not practical. Anyway well done ..want dr jaishankar next in your podcast
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
You asked absolutely correct question related to legalising MSP. Very happy to see the questions and counter questions discussion afterwards.
Watched the full episode sir. Very informativeand thought provoking insights
@The wire @The deshbhakt @Ravish kumar @Dhruv rathee etc all godi youtubers of left parties and their brainless trolls who were calling u a godi youtuber are in shock now .They dont want to listen to anyone who is opposing their view and directcly they call them andhbhakt ,godi media etc but in reality they themself are pawns .
i think so is the case with right wing....I fell both wings should engage in educated discussion..instead of rubbish like Dissolution of Constitution or "ayega toh modi hii" BS
@@hargundeep1866 When opponent parties have started instilling fear among common people by stating nonsensical things like "BJP will rewrite the constitution" or "This is the country's last election" and started alluring people by terming caste census some revolutionary steps to end poverty in India then your theories or facts will surely go down the hell.
@hargundeep1866 dissolution?
Media is biased on both sides of political spectrum. It's the many on the left who think they are standing for the democracy, reality is far from it.
First bring new ammendments & interparty elections
@@hargundeep1866 This is a problem all over the world. Politics has become a game of binaries where either you are my friend or my enemy. Both sides claim to be neutral but get instantly triggered once the first question is asked that challenges their theory! Politicians and TH-camrs/Influencers make money, while the general public like us get used as pawns making a f00l out of ourselves.
I am a software engineer. I always think when india will have our own products like Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, Google, Microsoft, Spacex, OpenAI and so many. And its not just only companies but standards too. I will say nearly impossible. Even we have some companies or products, that also on top of american standard or technologies. Even the simple 50USD software certification itself. And if we look at TCS and Infosys, these all are service based companies not product based. Ofcourse we need that but some product companies too. India is nothing to do with AI rather than using that amaerican tech. Anyway we are not bad while comparing with other countries with america. May be the investment focus is the problem. May be because they got independence 247 years ago and we just got 77 years ago. Anyway entrepreneurship is the only key to become better.
Bro japan lagbhag hamare sath hi democratic hua tha aur singapore ko hamare baad azadi mili aaj vo log kaha aur ham kaha hai 77 saal bohot hote hai taraki karne ke liye hume jitni karni chahiye thi hamare size ke according uski aadhi bhi ki hai humne a abhi
@@vinayaksharma9270Japan ka size and pre indipendence condition dekho zara.
@@vinayaksharma9270vaha religion ke basis pe devision hone ki possibility hi nahi hai. Sab ki identity is JAPANESE 🇯🇵 first baad ke unke casts and clans
@@ogthakurJapan ka partition bhi nhi hua tha religion ke basis pe
@@ogthakurLook up "Meiji Restoration". That's how Japan transformed from an underdeveloped country to a highly industrialized one, comparable to Europe and us. Any large reform like that would give our major parties heart attacks. Congress would claim Ambani Adani are destroying us. BJP would claim western culture is destroying us.
38:48 is where i fall in love with the interview! Well done Ganesh!
Great interview. Shashi answered all questions in an excellent manner ❤
Freebies are not uplifting a poor life but it is turning them lazy..
When adani Ambani gets freebies it is called "vikas" but when farmer's ask for money which they deserve is called freebies 😢
they get loans... Farmers won't give back money... Do you know what are you even saying? @@Targetagent2005
@@Targetagent2005 80% of our budget in freebies to farmers will actually ! ambani and adani will pay back to the country farmers wont
@@yatishyadav26111 80% of whose budget !!? 😂. Bro, please stop spreading such false claims !! I urge you to research on how much did the adani's and ambani's contribute to tax compared to farmers !!!!
Well said.
Great video....He says BJP is gaslighting with the mangal sutras but Rahul Gandhi is openly saying that if your community has 50% population then you have right to 50% wealth which is just an underhanded way of saying we will bring about wealth redistribution (especially when taken along with statements like we will bring a radical revolution). Enforcing equality of outcome is not just a disastrous idea but its also evil because its been seen time and again that it can lead to crumbling of entire nations economy at best and death and destruction of millions of people in some of the worst cases where this was tried to be implemented. And any politician or "intellectual" who advocates it is either naive or evil.
Don't worry just vote for modi
Inc is just trying everything they can offer to get more votes
Sad
Greed of indian over good governance is all time high
I am from Tamil nadu. What is shocking is our people want more freebies. But this model is not working in north states.
Eventhough poverty rate is higher there ,they are voting for development.
Seriously this is happening? @@MKirushnan3925
@@MKirushnan3925Caste based voting is high in North, they will accept their life is changed, better in last 10 years, but then when you ask. Them , who will they vote, Yadav will say SP, RJD, dalit will say SP /BSP, Jaat in haryana is also voting for opposition, Students preparing for government jobs will vote for opposition.
People are gone mad everywhere.
I hope someone do such stern interviews with people who have been in power for the last 10 years!
He did,😊 his first interview is with gadkari ji and I think he's the man also in power for the last 10 year.
Let's start with those who are still beating their chest for getting this country independent with Charkha and are famous for imposing emergency on this country.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 really? Really? Like how can your thought process be so immature and vhildish. This isn't a cricket match. We are talking about the future of a democracy
@@Stephensofceealike they are interviewing gadkari and ja Shankar 🤔🤔 might bcs of your love for Congress you haven't seen it
They came on multiple podcast oh no why am I telling you as if you are blind
Great work. Looking forward to more such interviews
Classic example of Brain without Action
I am from Kerala, this guy is the most hyped person in recent times he couldn't do any notable development in his constituency from last 15 years.....my advise is preach only what you follow
I second that. I also had the impression that he was visionary. But this election campaign proved me wrong. He is yet another politician with no vision. He even listed all the central projects as his achievements in his election manefesto.
What power he has? You elect commis in state and BJP in central…
@@nkt3132 he had power when Manmohan Singh term then also he focused on foreign trips and chat with Pakistani journalist
@@Nobel521 he become popular because of foreign minister.. at that time we had good relationship with all the countries including China.. now see all our neighbors hate us.. not good with Canada, Australia.. exports to foreign countries not improved.. many young generation moving out of the country due to lack of opportunities in India..
Still he is better than RaGa.
The new era of podcast by one and only Ganesh from think school , I was very keen to watch this episode. 👍👍 Keep informative , love your valuable content and you sprade great energy ❤
Right questions no beating around the bushes. I appreciate both, the interviewee and interviewer. Ganesh has studied the topic in detail and makes the conversation more meaningful as others in similar field.
Mannn !!!! The last line !!! Chef's Kiss.
Greatly envy your way of communicating to someone with such a contrarian viewpoint to yourself in such calmness. Continue Growing.
Great interview Ganesh! Glad to see number,statistic driven discussion. I used to like Mr.Tharoor, now i realise i liked him because of his command on the language, when the conversation became number/statistic driven, he still relied on his vocabulary skills as a distraction when he couldn’t provide answers to the queries!!!
Ask to moodi ji he will talk about jihadi and mangalsutra
@@vv-sz4yhmodi has taking that names bcoz congress is doing it go and research
@@vv-sz4yh
so you expect modi to sit quiet when congress publicly does muslim appeasement- not happening -and he will expose congress and their agenda again and again
Why do you think that someone who doesn't like Congress will be BJP follower, i hate Indi alliance but I also don't like BJP @@vv-sz4yh
He did in fact state multiple statistical figures
Go and check the video again
Ganesh…! Its was a great to the point interview and the questions, counter everything was crisp and clear!
what a podcast and salute to Dr Tharoor sir As well as Ganesh for listening and making such brilliant podcast you are a great podcaster listner and Good communicator ❤❤
The questions asked regarding to MSP was a huge hit
Also the impact of it explained couldn’t get an reasonable answer from sashi sir
Great job brother 🙌🏻
When Shashi Tharoor talks about Farmers and that Modi government was unable to double their revenue, he should be reminded that it has his Congress Party that orchestrated Farmers Protest in many states and choked Delhi for months against the Farm Bills that were designed to give them freedom. I am surprised why the host didn't pose this counter to him.
Exactly
Farm bill need to repeal
Job of the opposition is to voice the issues people face, regarding farmers issue you wouldn't understand what we are facing on ground. Trying to burry it under other issues using media bjp has failed.
The context of this podcast to understand business outcomes over social outcomes. Possibly why Ganesh is trying to keep the discussion free of conflict.
Baccha kya hi puchega!!
Good work Ganesh....and kudos to Mr. Tharoor for being able to tackle the question with the subject knowledge backed with stats........ Ganesh we as people of India the only hope for us is quality education...this will take us par with other global nations.
Excellent discussion..
This was the highest standard set by you for a podcast amongst Indian TH-camrs.... LOVED IT!!!❤
This is a podcast i was looking forward to , want to see a professional answer questions like , why freebies? and impact on economy ..
He'll just defend the stance of Congress....
@@Anshuman-axisbetter strategy is to listen first and then comment
@@Anshuman-axispajeet detect
@@Uchiha_Patir_ hate monger detected
@@rsubhasify yeah that's true, I do agree with you
But this guy recently gave clean chit to terrorist ajmal kasab, he has become a terrorist sympathiser like the party he belongs to. He has also given a number of controversial statements in the recent times.
I do know that he is a very knowledgeable person but he is associated with the ideology of Congress which is very dangerous.
Great to see the growth of this team. Better than any news channel s interview
My two takeaways....Ganesh you rock!!...and Sashi Tharoor's English is good to hear...though what all he said was nonsense. Kudos to Ganesh for not getting mystified by Tharoor's words and sticking to his wits.
Which part was nonsense?
😂
@@AguiarMelwyn putting a buying cap for MSP
@@ajithms8757 yeah I was against the cap, but his response was much beyond just a cap he went further to show their rationale behind it and offered a solution that has merits to have a second look at including the concept of making the poorest labor participants to the economy. These are debatable concepts and not nonsense unless you are politically motivated.
@@AguiarMelwyn there is no use in MSP if a farmer sells a private buyer rs. 50 per kg instead of Rs. 30 the buyer will store it and sell the same at rs. 100 per Kg if you want to help farmer provide him proper storage facility and allow him to sell in open market that will bring diversification in cultivation of crops otherwise we will be in trouble in next 3 years.
This man was the HR minister of congress for a considerable period of time. Why did he not make any effort to update and modernise the syllabus? Ohh yes he was busy creating the IPL team for Cochin. and creating Barcelona.
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
Why are people blaming him, he had no real powers
@@akhripasta2670 If his party does not give him power, then he must not fool people by contesting elections.
@@richardv9648 do you think BJP chachas in their party has any power? Whatever Modi/Shah says they do
Best interview i've heard in a long time. Unfiltered, unedited. Talking about economies of scale and keeping the people of india into consideration. Such cross question and debated should be mandatory for every candidate contesting in election. No noise debates as in tv news which do not even do fact check or even cross question anything. People literally lie on national tv and everyone believes it as anchors dont even question them.
When candidate participate in debate/interview they will have a fear or being proven fake/liar and hence be educated enough to speak only what can be done and not just 'jumlas'.(And much much more)
Lol... Sashi Tharoor hardly answered any practicality of his manifesto... Also, for him to use the notion of 'human development' by being a representative of a particular Political party who's been in power for around 80% of the period after independence... I mean take a look at Singapore...
The only thing I agree with him is on the investments on University by Private companies...
Well done Ganesh , This is the best interview by any TH-camr I have ever seen. Its nice you covered the legislative they are from and cover all aspects of current policies, promised policies and its feasibility
One of the best interviews in recent time.. felt like developed country interview.. clarity in questions and in answers..
Do an interview with Anna-Malai
he's not worth
@@paris9332Who Annamalai?? 😮 Are you kidding me
Annama lie.....
அண்ணாமலை mass ❤🎉 நல்ல தலைவர்.. ஜனங்களின் ஒருவன்
Perfect guy
I liked this podcast very much. Hats off to the host for asking the questions that generally politicians will beat around the bush. Farm Laws should not have been repealed. It had shortcomings which could have been amended
This is honestly one of the best interviews I have ever seen. @ThinkSchool, thank you for this
Loved the podcast the questions were awesome and also the part where Ganesh had facts to back his question that's how real interview should be....The only problem I think about this podcast is it should be live so the guest can't ask you to edit their responses and answers.
Still didn't ask about waqf act , appeasement etc etc .......which was the most prominent question put up by everyone in the comments section of your post 😹😹
Congress and pseudo-secularism go hand in hand with each other .
You need to mature
it is too controversial to ask that question
What about Hindu appeasement 😮 ,
@@Criticsyou appeasement in what
@@prajwalmuralis2101 why? Bruh it's affecting us and they r not feeling ashamed or controversial to promote this acts
Fantastic interview Ganeshji!! Concise and to the point. May you grow more!
One of the best podcast I have ever heard. Business, Reforms, Policies, Education, so many topics has been covered in this podcast.
Well done Ganesh, amazing interview, amazing homework done ✅ before doing interview
I don't support freebies. You can have social welfare schemes that subsidies stuff, but giving cash is bank accounts is just too much.
Why do you give money to rich people then
@@gauravdey4163because they create employment, gdp contribution,hospitals,ngo's etc
because they create jobs 🤦@@gauravdey4163
Subsidy for investment is good for jobs , export , tax collection
@@gauravdey4163: which rich people got money ?
It's an art to ask a political question without getting politically biased.
Thoughtful conversation.
Smartest question ever asked by think school!
I think u should share this episode with nitin gadkari, He is also a good leader but the education system should change.🎉🎉❤❤
Incongruous Nasty Dynasts' Ignominious Alliance (compiled by Dr. Thashi Sharoor)
New education policy by bjp he forget that to mention
@@JyotiAgarwalofficialnot implemented. What's the use of introducing a reform u r not going to implement
@@amantiwari4987 implementation has started in CBSE schools (kendriya vidyalaya and navodaya) but yeah many boards haven't even started.
@@amantiwari4987yeah I think education is a big ground where still bjp had to come out and play their innings specially for the private sectors loot mainly by different medical and engineering colleges
I'm currently a student doing my bachelors in IT in Melbourne. But somehow Ganesh's content fascinate me always and I make sure I don't miss them. Thanks Think School for such amazing podcasts and content ;)
Great to hear :)
How it matters to the readers whether you are doing your bachelors in IT in Melbourne or Timbaktu. Those cannot get admission in good colleges in India are joining some obscure universities in Australia or Canada. So your university or city need not be highlighted.
Very well conducted podcast. Liked your confidence.