“.....Madison City, Missouri Sir 😀, ...never heard it ...😔::” simply a brilliant moment from General Sutherland.. Vernon L Pinkley ! Thank you for this wonderful segment 👍
Veg4Ev Which is strange because he played this role and in the Big Red 1 which is Army 1st infantry. And both roles were about the European campaign while Mr. Marvin served in the Pacific campaign.
"But you're really quite emotional, aren't you?" Priceless line from one of the best war movies ever. Lee Marvin and Robert Ryan had worked together the previous year in another classic, The Professionals, always striking exactly the right note, whatever they did. I hate to use a cliche but they really don't make them like this anymore.
Here is why The Dirty Dozen worked so well - it was set in World War II. Lee Marvin, Richard Jaeckel, George Kennedy, Charles Bronson, and Robert Ryan all served in World War II, and made sure The Dirty Dozen was made to 'close to perfect'.
Saw that interview with Donald Sutherland; he wasn't t the original actor who was supposed to be "the general" in this scene-but he sure knocked it our of the Park- and this scene convinced the Hollywood big shots he had star potential.. His Big Break..
The Woke nonsense pervading the West has affected even martial music. These days the most apoplectic nonsense is played from the US to GB in the name of march or military band music. God spare us!!!
@@surferdude44444 My respect for Robert Ryan has already gone up. Thanks for sharing that. Him and Borgnine (a Navy vet) made an amazing picture in the Wild Bunch. To be fair Marvin's experience was cut short too.
@@williameaton9058 Lee Marvin was the original choice to play the lead in The Wild Bunch but he turned it down to play in Paint Your Wagon and they chose William Holden to replace him
I have got this movie DVD of Lee Marvin with Ernest Borgnine Charles Bronson Clint Walker Donald Sutherland Jim Brown Robert Webber and Telly Savalas in The Dirty Dozen I am dedicating this movie DVD to my old school friends who are both sisters as I hope to see them both again very soon to Chris and Hester from Billyxxx
Great movie I remember seeing this in the drive in my dad took us he was a WW2 veteran. He loved this movie. He also took us to see Patton that was his favorite.
My favorite part is how Marvin looks like he's about to lose it with Sutherland but then realizes he's being watched and instantly regains his composure.
I have to say Lee Marvin was one of the Great Actor's you just don't see them like him anymore. I enjoy seeing the airborne taking a few laughs for the common infantry soldier even if he is part of the Dirty Dozen,
General looks like Boogy from something pass about Mary. This scene is epic, to convert a militar reception in a clown performance, seeing the colonel's face while the major and "the general" are walking checking the force....no words : ))))) A scene typical from Monty pyton's films but without them. Congratulations to the director.
Up to this point, Pinkley was characterized as being not very bright. But this General Gag was a stroke of genius, which makes for one of the highlights of the whole movie!
The anachronisms like a pair of sunglasses can be overlooked in this film. Whats more surprising is how many movie audiences still dont realize this is a dark film in actuality. The funny moments and music soundtrack is a purposeful contradiction.
This video was right about one thing. American Generals, when inspecting troops, will walk slow, look dumb and act stupid. Many are so doddering with their swagger sticks that they hardly know what’s going on in the rank and file.
It's funny my late father looked like Donald Sutherland. Our last name is Pinckley. That spelling is unusual. Funny stuff first watched this for 1st time 30 or 40 years ago!
Reading some of the comments on here, it doesn't really surprise me that much that people have completely missed the point of this clip. For example "the anachronistic sunglasses" - I have a pair of "RAY-BANS" - no shit! - that were issued to USAAF pilots in WWII
Song name? I almost thought "HM Jollies" But then went against it. I used to play this song... but now its driving me crazy because I don't remember the name anymore.
There is something uniquely American about this scene. The mocking of the European style of spit and polish discipline in favor of a rough and ready appearance favored by American troops for 2 centuries.
No dipshit, its a sentiment shared by 3rd party observers to the American military since von Steuben. The rough and ready nature of the US military has been a staple of our existence since 1775. Colors of our uniforms and accoutrements, as well as the lack of brightly colored lace in the 18/19th centuries all indicate this mentality. Not only that but the composition of the Continental Army and the later Union Army all lean towards the less than impressive militia units that often wore civilian attire and buckskins with an inclination towards camouflage.
A.G. The drabness of your uniform colours from hundreds of years past were born of economic convenience and stayed in that vein because of a vague adherence to tradition. But if believing otherwise makes you feel tougher, by all means go for it.
“.....Madison City, Missouri Sir 😀, ...never heard it ...😔::” simply a brilliant moment from General Sutherland.. Vernon L Pinkley !
Thank you for this wonderful segment 👍
Lee Marvin !!!! What a GREAT actor......A true legend !!!!
a US Marine in WWII
Lee Marvin being in the Marine Corp himself played a magnificent role in this movie. This scene is the best part instrumentally!
Yea he is just bang on
He was far too old.
@@markharrison2544 No he wasn't. He was 43 yrs old and this is accurate for the rank of major. Younger ones are cases of nepothism.
Veg4Ev
Which is strange because he played this role and in the Big Red 1 which is Army 1st infantry. And both roles were about the European campaign while Mr. Marvin served in the Pacific campaign.
@@GrayFoxROU exactly. And imagine what turned the poor fucker's hair white... 😔
Lee Marvin " But you're really...pause...quiet emotional" the best line for me delivered with Marvin coolness
newellgirl AGEED. 100%
I like the quote 'I don't care if they hang you for 10. dollars or 10 cents, it makes no difference to me
This is one of the best movies ever made
"But you're really quite emotional, aren't you?" Priceless line from one of the best war movies ever. Lee Marvin and Robert Ryan had worked together the previous year in another classic, The Professionals, always striking exactly the right note, whatever they did. I hate to use a cliche but they really don't make them like this anymore.
Yes and both movies were excellent. The Professionals is one of my all time favorite movies!
And Bad Day at Black Rock a decade earlier
@@josephvitielo1693 Very true. Two great actors.
@@Hessian1011 thank you so much
"They're very pretty, colonel. But, can they fight?"
I love this scene.
I wonder if the Colonel jumps with his men into active combat zones?
"Pinkleys gonna be a general.... What for ???? Shut up and watch" 😉 This dialogue is precious and one of many 😜😜😜😜
How much was ad lib
@@raymondweaver8526 A lot of ad libbing I bet 😛❤️
"Just walk slow, look dumb, and act stupid" hahaha
+Revan2908 Just like a politician.
newalm Quite.
+Revan2908 that was the biggest mistake that Major Reisman made to the Ding-bat, that made this happen 12-13-15
I don't think Donald Sutherland had to act to pull that one off.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
"I'd rather be a civilian, sir"
"You ever pull another stunt like that again, and I'll beat your brains out!"
Hahahahaha!
great, lines!
Greatest Military Music in a movie of all time!
What is the name of the military music of the song?
@@jandrimanuelalcivar8556 the first one is emblem march and the second one when he is inspecting the troops is semper fedilis
the goofy look on the band leaders face is priceless
Loved it when they would keep showing it..that smile😂😂😂
That's the great M. Emmet Walsh.
The job.
Here is why The Dirty Dozen worked so well - it was set in World War II. Lee Marvin, Richard Jaeckel, George Kennedy, Charles Bronson, and Robert Ryan all served in World War II, and made sure The Dirty Dozen was made to 'close to perfect'.
It's literally about a real group, the FIlthy Thirteen
Robert Webber, Ernest Borgnine, Telly Savalas and Clint Walker also served in World War II. Robert Ryan never went overseas iirc.
No combat ready unit ever passed inspection.
No inspection ready unit ever passed combat.
That's a hell of a quote son
Except for gurkhas.
@@edhoughton2609 Murphy's Law Of Combat Operations, look it up.
This marching band music composed of 3 different music compostions is the bomb i love this part of the movie.
Saw that interview with Donald Sutherland; he wasn't t the original actor who was supposed to be "the general" in this scene-but he sure knocked it our of the Park- and this scene convinced the Hollywood big shots he had star potential.. His Big Break..
CLINT Walker was chosen originaly
Little young to be a General, but he definitely played the part to a "T".
Sutherland would reprise this quirky G.I. character in Kelly’s Heroes (1970) as Sgt. Oddball.
I LOVE this movie!!! And this is my very favorite scene of all. Thanks for posting:)
I love Franco's reaction when the major picks him to be the general.
Perhaps the Greatest Military Music 4 a Motion Picture!
What is the name of the military music of the song?
Cassavetes' facial expressions are priceless.
The Best Ever Military Music of All Time!
The Woke nonsense pervading the West has affected even martial music. These days the most apoplectic nonsense is played from the US to GB in the name of march or military band music. God spare us!!!
This scene is an art masterpiece.
The Best ever of any military combo music of all time. ThanKs to the band leader and his band
My favorite musically with one of my favorite all time actor Lee Marvin who played Major Reisman to the T
I love the band conductor's sycophantic smile.
After so many attempts of playing the music... he finally got to.
the conductor is funny and the colonel too when he says not now.
Dirty Dozen and Kelly's Heroes....both classic movies and Donald Sutherland and Telly Savalas are in both of them.
Wilsonspen WOOOF WOOOFFFF!!! BOW WOW!!!!!
Great Dark Comic movies of the 60' s.. Hollywood isn't capable of them anymore... "Get another Comic Book Character"...
Agreed
Two fantastic actors. They could play anyone.
lee marvin is way cooler...
Even the crazy man Telly Sevalis was grinning and stiff Sargent Richard Jackael had to look down and supress a grin. Classic scene!
3:23 the moment when Donald Sutherland realized Lee Marvin wasn't acting:)
Perhaps Semper Fidelis was played because Lee Marvin was a Real Marine in WWII...
Antonio Perez
so was Ryan
Marvin was wounded twice in Saipan......shot in the butt and the foot. Ryan was a DI at Pendleton....never went overseas.
@@surferdude44444 My respect for Robert Ryan has already gone up. Thanks for sharing that. Him and Borgnine (a Navy vet) made an amazing picture in the Wild Bunch. To be fair Marvin's experience was cut short too.
@@williameaton9058 Lee Marvin was the original choice to play the lead in The Wild Bunch but he turned it down to play in Paint Your Wagon and they chose William Holden to replace him
Fine scene from a classic movie. Great cast.
"Walk slow, look dumb and act stupid."
He just described the former Romanian minister of defense.
So well written, directed and acted. Love this scene!
great film, great action, GREAT humour....just what's missing from today's films...
"where you from soldier?" "Madison City Missouri sir!!" "Never heard of it" !! lol
Dirty Dozen....Great war movie!!! And driving the jeep is my idol Trini Lopez!!!
Best Ever Military Music of All Time
Thanks a lot!! I`ve just enjoyed it from this wonderful TH-cam.
The Best Ever Military Song of all Time. 9/24/16
"Neeeeever heard of it."
My favorite line of the movie...
😂😂
I’ll beat your brains out
"I'd rather be a civilian, sir" I died laughing the first tme i heard that line
I have got this movie DVD of
Lee Marvin with
Ernest Borgnine Charles Bronson
Clint Walker Donald Sutherland
Jim Brown Robert Webber
and Telly Savalas in
The Dirty Dozen
I am dedicating this movie DVD to my old school friends who are both sisters as I hope to see them both again very soon to Chris and Hester from Billyxxx
Great movie I remember seeing this in the drive in my dad took us he was a WW2 veteran. He loved this movie. He also took us to see Patton that was his favorite.
Lee Marvin 1 of the most underated actors of all time of whom is 1 of very few I like
his son sounded just like him in a interview he did
You got that right:) He was a real Marine, too.
I've grown up being a Lee Marvin fan and I've been saying that for years that he is the most underrated actor ever
I remembered the "never heard of it" scene when I saw this as a child
My favorite part is how Marvin looks like he's about to lose it with Sutherland but then realizes he's being watched and instantly regains his composure.
This is one of my favorite movies of all time! I had crushes on all of them (unheard of before for me)! (smile!)
One of the most funny scene i ever witnessed. From Budapest. Dirty Dozen is favorite.
This and davy Crockett were my favorite childhood films:)
Lee marvin was so badass in this, very convincing
This scene made Sutherland a star.....
My favorite scene in the movie! RIP to the incomparable Donald Sutherland!
Sutherland...an under rated actor... comedy..drama...action...der Adler ist gelandt
How is Sutherland underrated? He's pretty darn popular.
"Very Pretty Colonel, but can they fight?"
"Where are you from son?"
"Madison City Missouri sir!"
"...never heard of it..."
The soldier looked so crestfallen.
@@SPARTANSAM1 That soldier was, I believe, William Christopher, who later played Father Mulcahey on MASH...can anyone back me up or correct me???
I was Nine Years old when I saw this at the theatre with my family.....probably seen it 100 times, literally, So good,
I get such a kick out of the crushed look of the guy from Madison City
That was William Christopher who would later be known as Father Mulcahy on MASH...
I've heard of Independence, Mo., but not Madison City
@@timchristopherson572 Nope, not finding that anywhere.
That was the padre from Mash?
Best movie scene ever to be shot in Colindale, North London.
Best ever military music!
Best Military Music of All Time!
i love the band composer!!! he has this look on his face and he doesn't stop composing....LOL
I have to say Lee Marvin was one of the Great Actor's you just don't see them like him anymore.
I enjoy seeing the airborne taking a few laughs for the common infantry soldier even if he is part of the Dirty Dozen,
Maybe Mr Eastwood.
In my opinion the Best Ever Military Music of All Time per movie!
When I was in the Marines we had so many crazy things happen.
This movie is not far from the Truth
The three marches are National Emblem by Edwin Bagley, then The Thunderer, John Philip Sousa, finally Semper Fidelis also Sousa
Thank you so much!! I've been searching these songs names fol like an hour XD
Jim Brown died May 19th 2023, aged 87 R.I.P.
My favorite military music of all time. 10/23/16
What is the name of the military music of the song?
General looks like Boogy from something pass about Mary. This scene is epic, to convert a militar reception in a clown performance, seeing the colonel's face while the major and "the general" are walking checking the force....no words : )))))
A scene typical from Monty pyton's films but without them. Congratulations to the director.
In my opinion the best ever military music of all time! Thanx to Frank DeVoe and Orchestra
Lee Marvin was so good in this film and the orchestra was right on with the music!
Still the Best ever Military Music of All Time in a Movie
"You're really quite emotional, aren't ya?"
You gotta love Lee Marvin's biting wit!
Love this movie!
dont make em like this anymore! Great action, characters, dialogue, music..and most of all, humour! :) classic
Lee Marvin...the ultimate thumb-ur-nose-at-regulations officer! 👍😁
Best ever military theme song of all time!
Legendarni film sa legendarnim glumcima...!!!
This scene was filmed in Hendon the old RAF base, its a housing estate now(Grahame Park estate was built in the 60s)
Old man Sutherland has some pretty good lines in this scene.
What is the name of the music piece?
Semper Fidelis :)
gotta love the anachronistic sunglasses
issued to aviators since WWII.
Baron Feyd Rautha Harkonnen not the black lens sunglasses, those were not issued to 👩✈️
Gotta love people that try to pick faults with something when there aren’t any.
RIP GENERAL PINKLEY ❤❤
What is the name of the song? Sounds like a Sousa march.
Salute to all military personnel!
Up to this point, Pinkley was characterized as being not very bright. But this General Gag was a stroke of genius, which makes for one of the highlights of the whole movie!
Perhaps the Best ever Military theme ever
The anachronisms like a pair of sunglasses can be overlooked in this film. Whats more surprising is how many movie audiences still dont realize this is a dark film in actuality. The funny moments and music soundtrack is a purposeful contradiction.
Sunglasses existed in WW2, I don't know about that particular brand.
i take 2 hour for discover the name of this great movie of my youngt days almost dont remember how good it was
What's named the first March? Thanks
Ps great movie!
National Emblem March.
@@SPARTANSAM1 thanks!
This music which is a blend of a few musical pieces is done superbly and makes you proud and honored to be an American
Yes - great martial music - sort of "get the fk out of the way" type music
This video was right about one thing. American Generals, when inspecting troops, will walk slow, look dumb and act stupid. Many are so doddering with their swagger sticks that they hardly know what’s going on in the rank and file.
It's funny my late father looked like Donald Sutherland. Our last name is Pinckley. That spelling is unusual.
Funny stuff first watched this for 1st time 30 or 40 years ago!
Reading some of the comments on here, it doesn't really surprise me that much that people have completely missed the point of this clip. For example "the anachronistic sunglasses" - I have a pair of "RAY-BANS" - no shit! - that were issued to USAAF pilots in WWII
John Philip Sousa, "Semper Fidelis" march, at his best - arranged by Frank De Vol for the film - "The Dirty Dozen". Love it!
Do you know which march is the first song? It sounds like a Sousa song as well.
@@BS-ib2ch Hi, I don't. I will check when I get another oppurtunity to see the film.
@@BS-ib2ch Sorry for the delay. I'll need to revisit the clip.
Ah Lee, we miss you.
What is the march the band is playing??
can anyone plz tell me what marching tune is playing in the background of this movie. I would really love it.
+Joseph Girsh they play a compilation of "National Emblem" and "Semper Fidelis" marches
the West point blues....lol
The first one is Trio, National Emblem. Not sure about the other
2:14 an aircraft is moving left to right just above the tree line on the background.
Song name? I almost thought "HM Jollies" But then went against it. I used to play this song... but now its driving me crazy because I don't remember the name anymore.
WinterKaust But we solved it National Emblem 1:15 :P
:p Indeed. I posted it before solving.
The best scene of the movie. Hiliarious!!!
There is something uniquely American about this scene. The mocking of the European style of spit and polish discipline in favor of a rough and ready appearance favored by American troops for 2 centuries.
+US Marine Rifleman
Spoken like someone who has never had to form up for parade inspection.
My graduation from bootcamp was that fucking inspection dumbfuck.
A.G.
IOW, you did just as much "spit and polish" as "European" troops. This admission makes your OP hypocritical and/or full of shit.
No dipshit, its a sentiment shared by 3rd party observers to the American military since von Steuben. The rough and ready nature of the US military has been a staple of our existence since 1775. Colors of our uniforms and accoutrements, as well as the lack of brightly colored lace in the 18/19th centuries all indicate this mentality. Not only that but the composition of the Continental Army and the later Union Army all lean towards the less than impressive militia units that often wore civilian attire and buckskins with an inclination towards camouflage.
A.G.
The drabness of your uniform colours from hundreds of years past were born of economic convenience and stayed in that vein because of a vague adherence to tradition. But if believing otherwise makes you feel tougher, by all means go for it.
but can they FIGHT......