No worry bro, ignore them, I support u. I’m a Malaysian too. Just sharing, from my 30 years of job experience. I believe Most of your haters are not pure born singaporean, they are Malaysian converted but act like singaporean. Trust me, i encounter a lot of them claimed themself as a singaporean, end up I found that they are converted & always act & mimic like singaporean. All of my singaporean friends are very friendly and will not judge people easily. If u stay long enough here, u will realised that most pure singaporean cannot write or type Chinese. Give u another example, Don’t be surprise that a lot Singapore number plate cars that drove to JB are not pure singaporean. During their trip in JB, they like to act like singaporean & critised Malaysia. Most of my singaporean friends are very scare to drive in JB due to safety. They will not drive there unless that a need to go in.
I have to second to what the bro said, to my personal experience, most of the pure local born Singaporean, regardless of race are very friendly and approachable. Like what a lot have said, ignore haters and avoid responding if you do not find any constructive feedback from them. "You will never reach your destination if you stop and throw stones at every dog that barks." Winston Churchill.
Very true what u said. Especially those singapore cars pumping the subisdised RON 95 petrol, 80% are malaysians but singapore PR... The real born and bred singaporean are law abiding people and disciplined.
This one i super agree, some Malaysia born Singaporean/ Malaysia Singapore Permanent Resident really act like taiko lecturing Malaysian while Singapore born Singaporean quite appreciate Malaysia natural beauty and slow and chill lifestyle.
Hey bro. I'm Msian, holding SG PR too. Just ignore those naysayer. Most of them are former Msian that have some much hatred towards Msia. People just hate it when you are doing the right thing, those verbal attack are just solid proof that they are regretting with their choice.
Hi Zack, I seriously think that you should keep your PR status for as long as they allow you to renew. PR status is a privilege in SG. I believe you do aware that it's kind of difficult to get PR approval nowadays. The approval criteria may no longer the same compared to 10-20 yrs ago. Just do what is right for your family is far more important. Ignore those 酸民. Always support you! Jiayou!🤜🤛
Zack, as u a real estate agent in a Msia now. It is best to take up a Real Estate Salesperson course and pass the exams and join a Real Estate Agency company. Then u can sell properties in both Msia & Sg. That way u can constantly travel to / fro Sg and continue a good PR status. What u sell in SG can then be contributed to your Sg CPF account to earn good profit till you retire.
Thanks for sharing. Agree with you: having options is definitely good! Natural that people like to compare singapore vs Malaysia. Both have good and bad lah so no point getting into arguments over this. Ultimately depends on your lifestyle preference and situation eg children's education, caregiving responsibilities
I have been working 98% of time outside singapore for past 15 years due to traveling AP region. Still contributing income tax and CPF every year. No issue for renewing my REP so far.
I employed too by sg company...and I got enter about 100days to sg per year now after COVID......they only renew me 1 year validity for 2 time already ......
Totally agree with you! You live for yourself so don’t waste time listening to others as long as you enjoy your way. Honestly, both Singapore and Malaysia are great to stay as both are good choices, we are neighbours and we both need to respect each other.
If you earn $1 for every stupid comment people say i think you will be rich. Don't need to care what other people say. You worked for it, you earned it. Singapore always welcome you
我在新加坡出生長大, 父母是台灣籍的SPR, 一直拿SPR生份, 因家庭因素之後在台灣工作, 但後來renewal criteria變嚴格, 只給我一年的REP就沒有了... 但我的身份認同一直是新加坡(但也沒辦法在新家坡申請citizenship). so it was a sad day when my REP expired. 最近收到CPF的信, 就是如果SPR身分沒有了, CPF在明年4月前要強迫關帳戶, 不知道您有沒有也接到這樣的消息. i think for you its really your choice to make - as long as you fulfil the criteria for REP renewal, i dont see why not! 如果也有考量之後小朋友要在新加坡就學, 也是一個很好的選擇! enjoy your channel, keep up the good work!!
Bro, PR is the best status in Singapore. If you plan to leave Singapore and West Malaysia for good and wish to renounce your citizenship or PR status, you can withdraw all your CPF. Imagine those with 6 figure CPF, you can withdraw all and stay in Malaysia with RM500,000 allow you to lead a Dato life..
The ICA requires PR holders to fulfill certain obligations, such as residing in Singapore for a significant period, contributing to the country's economy, and adhering to the rules and regulations.
I think you shouldn't give up the S'pore PR status. Continue contributing the CPF as the interest you receive is more than the bank, & like you say the medi shield will come in useful, just in case.. ( touch wood🙏) also Singapore is a nice place, who knows you may also want to start your own business there too one day.
As a singaporean cpf rocks If you have a 90k in SA account 4K interest annually risk free (no need to even pay any fees!) totally shiok ! And also I’m sure there is no other invest medium other than fixed deposit or t bills that can beat a solid 4% per annum interest. Lastly first 60k in cpf gives you an extra 1% interest which means your sa can go up to 5% annum leh … there is no other place I know off that gives you this kind of interest. Jia you!
Just keep your PR, dont give it up bcoz next time, you may not get your PR again. As for those negative unfriendly comments etc, just ignore lah. The mouths on people's body, you cant stop them. So on your end just ignore and do what you need for your family and career as long as you respect/ follow the laws required (example, submit CPF, tax etc).
I agree. At least do what is best for you and your family. As for me, despite being a Singaporean, I like the easy going lifestyle of Malaysia as well. I have plans to semi- retire in Malaysia and maybe once in a while return to Singapore to do freelance school training. Which is why I have gotten a BTO flat in Woodlands. My main priority is the MRT line between Woodlands and Bukit Changar where I can commute both sides regularly. 有工做，我就回新加波。没有的话，我就住在联邦，偶尔去Cuti Cuti Malaysia 吃风。
@@Sohai1901 Wah you have made plans oredi, good for you 👍! Yes SG can be overly crowded and noisy. Personally I prefer the more laid back lifestyle of Msia.
@@wwpoof The plan have gone long overdue for 9 years. I only managed to start executing step 1 this two years ago due to financial constraint and bad health.
i think ICA should do something about this also all PR leave singapore as an self employ and this kind of status a lot of ppl will not be able to get the PR cos they are taken up the quota. for those who are really keen to work and stay in singapore it is unfair.
Hey Zack, I wonder for cases similar to yours: self-employed and living at overseas + continue contribute CPF and pay income tax @ SG, did you ask ICA whether this meets the REP renewal criteria?
I did check but they indirectly told me as long as follow the instruction then should be no issue, unless officer purposely request the proof from me which is I also can proof.🌹
When friend got his REP reduced while staying overseas more than 50% of her last 5yrs rep period, she gotten only a 1yr rep after renewing, although she still has her hb n kids in SG.
after 37 years in SG and PR for 27 years, i am converting to SG citizenship. Why? not willing to pay ABSD for SG property. its quite a hefty sum for pte properties. i also dont see a future of being a chinese in MY.
You come S'pore beacuse of money you earn a lot money can go back rest and enjoy your life S'pore life is very stress everything is not cheap some time we very hard to breathe 🤑
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | เปิดใจ "อาจารย์ เบียร์ ฅนตื่นธรรม" นักสนทนาธรรมสายดุดัน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqaBI_mnoDk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 83 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "พันฤทธิ์ vs ซุปเปอร์บอล วันของโอม MBK"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1b4pkKHa_Fk/mqdefault.jpg)
如果你是我，你会怎么办？🤔
现在马来西亚政治走向极端回教保守化尤其是回教党上台执政联邦政府只是时间问题，要我是你我绝对会hold住SPR只要马来西亚一变回教国马上搬回新加坡住然后申请成为公民永久逃离回教国
我相信你已经误会了contribution这句话吧。你为新加坡付出的是什么？而不是你给那么一点点几百，几千块的。新加坡政府有的是钱。。新加坡要的是你为新加坡🇸🇬贡献什么经济？你这两年来什么都没做都在马来西亚。我相信新加坡的移民局肯定会调查。尤其你播了这个视频。对那些拥有pr的很不公平。
@@人-z2p 你又不是政府，说那么多也是多余的。可以的话，给些有建设性的意见吧！
千万别把cpf的钱拿出来！到你55岁时，1新币可换6马币啊！
@@cpteo8847
他在申请pr一直不过所以。。。都是Z顶着🌍转😁😁😁
我是1986年来新加坡工作,1991年拿到PR,在新加坡买了三房式组屋,儿子在1991年出世,女儿在1995年出世,三房式组屋不够住,再换四房式,当时也是为了不愿意放弃马来西亚公民,所以没有申请新加坡公民,也只好在市场上买二手组屋,二手组屋会比新加坡人买的一首组屋还要贵,换了四房式又迎接了第三个孩子,三个孩子都是在新加坡出世,为了孩子我在2008年换新加坡公民,我很感恩新加坡给我们有好的生活,孩子们有好的環境求学,生活安定,我与先生经营了小生意,生活也过得去,孩子们如今全部大学毕业都已成家立业,平安就好,选择在那里生活都没有对错,最重要的是选适合自己的生活環境.
感谢分享你的个人经历🙏🏻非常可贵的分享👍🏻
你们都做对了选择，有些人跟你们当初的想法一样，迟迟未想申请成为新加坡公民，到最后他们的儿女虽然都成为公民，并且有第三代子孙了，可是他们到今天依旧只是PR。而且已经接近要退休了！申请公民权多次都得不到。见过议员几次，议员也写信帮忙了！都没有用。原因是他们都太迟申请，错过机会了！😅
这当然人各有志，这个国家接受你，你也为国服务互慧互利，也感谢你们。有些人生在福中不知福，酸葡萄的心理要不得
@@sapphoophoon2141子女都是公民了，为何老了还要申请公民？
Ah Boy boy PR must do national service
No worry bro, ignore them, I support u. I’m a Malaysian too.
Just sharing, from my 30 years of job experience. I believe Most of your haters are not pure born singaporean, they are Malaysian converted but act like singaporean. Trust me, i encounter a lot of them claimed themself as a singaporean, end up I found that they are converted & always act & mimic like singaporean. All of my singaporean friends are very friendly and will not judge people easily. If u stay long enough here, u will realised that most pure singaporean cannot write or type Chinese. Give u another example, Don’t be surprise that a lot Singapore number plate cars that drove to JB are not pure singaporean. During their trip in JB, they like to act like singaporean & critised Malaysia. Most of my singaporean friends are very scare to drive in JB due to safety. They will not drive there unless that a need to go in.
Thanks for sharing🙏🏻You remind me about those "actor"😆Yea men, what you said is correct~👍🏻
I have to second to what the bro said, to my personal experience, most of the pure local born Singaporean, regardless of race are very friendly and approachable.
Like what a lot have said, ignore haters and avoid responding if you do not find any constructive feedback from them.
"You will never reach your destination if you stop and throw stones at every dog that barks." Winston Churchill.
Very true what u said. Especially those singapore cars pumping the subisdised RON 95 petrol, 80% are malaysians but singapore PR... The real born and bred singaporean are law abiding people and disciplined.
This one i super agree, some Malaysia born Singaporean/ Malaysia Singapore Permanent Resident really act like taiko lecturing Malaysian while Singapore born Singaporean quite appreciate Malaysia natural beauty and slow and chill lifestyle.
Hey bro. I'm Msian, holding SG PR too. Just ignore those naysayer. Most of them are former Msian that have some much hatred towards Msia. People just hate it when you are doing the right thing, those verbal attack are just solid proof that they are regretting with their choice.
我曾经想在新加坡生活一辈子，现在却回来马来西亚了，看你在哪里的归属感比较多和喜欢怎样的生活，没有对也没有错，最重要活着要开心快乐❤❤❤
👍🏻
我也是古来人 在SG求学工作了25年 也是PR 住在SG也常回古来 今年46岁了 SG和古来 我都很喜欢 都是很适宜居住的地方 但是如果选择退休的地点 我还是选择古来 因为生活会更悠闲更适合 当年纪越来越大时 新加坡的快节奏 会比较吃力 当然这取决于个人 我们都很幸运 新马只在一水之隔 人生很快也很短 走过的都是经历 愿你平安喜乐 在那里生活/工作都开心顺利
感谢分享👍🏻
你的心态很正面，对自己的未来发展有方向感, 勇于探索勇于尝试, 很诚恳。 很好！
谢谢你😎🙏🏻👍🏻
Hi Zack, I seriously think that you should keep your PR status for as long as they allow you to renew. PR status is a privilege in SG. I believe you do aware that it's kind of difficult to get PR approval nowadays. The approval criteria may no longer the same compared to 10-20 yrs ago. Just do what is right for your family is far more important. Ignore those 酸民. Always support you! Jiayou!🤜🤛
Thank you🤜🏻🤛🏻
U r right. The criteria and approval of getting PR status is getting much more difficult nowadays. It will be prudent to keep it as long as possible.
Zack, as u a real estate agent in a Msia now. It is best to take up a Real Estate Salesperson course and pass the exams and join a Real Estate Agency company. Then u can sell properties in both Msia & Sg. That way u can constantly travel to / fro Sg and continue a good PR status. What u sell in SG can then be contributed to your Sg CPF account to earn good profit till you retire.
You are so cheap and Low class…😂
Yes, maybe in 5-10 years only, his daughter can start studying in SG. Also the CPF rate is high.
傑做的好👍
趁年轻, 把握时机去尝试各种不同工作的领域, 才能發展自己的專长.
谢谢你😊🙏🏻
谢谢你对新加坡的贡献。without the contributions from PRs like you , Singapore economy will not be of today status。如果又想回来新加坡工作还是做生意，大门还是为你与家人打开，加油！
谢谢你，我还是相信有像你这样开明的人👍🏻🙏🏻
我和你一样也是新加坡pr,不用理别人说什么，做你觉得对的事情就好，而且你割掉新加坡pr是拿不回新加坡任何身份的，所以不要听别人说把新加坡pr割掉
谢谢你😊🌹
Thanks for sharing. Agree with you: having options is definitely good! Natural that people like to compare singapore vs Malaysia. Both have good and bad lah so no point getting into arguments over this. Ultimately depends on your lifestyle preference and situation eg children's education, caregiving responsibilities
Thanks for sharing🙏🏻👍🏻
I have been working 98% of time outside singapore for past 15 years due to traveling AP region. Still contributing income tax and CPF every year. No issue for renewing my REP so far.
Thanks for sharing🙏🏻Great info for me and my audience👍🏻
because you employed by Singapore company?
@@haroldlbc Yes
I employed too by sg company...and I got enter about 100days to sg per year now after COVID......they only renew me 1 year validity for 2 time already ......
Only when you're still employed by SG entity.
Totally agree with you! You live for yourself so don’t waste time listening to others as long as you enjoy your way. Honestly, both Singapore and Malaysia are great to stay as both are good choices, we are neighbours and we both need to respect each other.
👍🏻
新加坡和馬來西亞都是一样適合就行。两國来往也是很方便、
A balance and honest reply. Well said. Keep up the honesty. 😊
Thank you!🌹
Hi Zack
Do not give up SG PR no matter what. U will do well in SG.
Thank you👍🏻
ignore the haters 啦，don't mind，all about your decision，作為一個獨立自主的人不需要太過注意旁人的眼光，focus on你自己和你的家庭這才是最重要的，誰都有爭取自己更好生活的權利
赞同👍🏻
你说的对，选择，选择，某个年龄需求不一样！加油！
谢谢你🙏🏻
你的做法没错。每个人都有选择的自由，别人没有权利批评或干涉。
我觉得你说的非常有道理 不要管黑粉胡说八道 现在想要拿到PR是个蛮困难的一件事了！继续加油！ 一直在观看你的视频！✌
谢谢你😊🙏🏻
Yes Zack I am s Singaporean just do what ever makes you happy enjoy both benefits why not. Cheers 🎉
Thank you😊🌹
在新加坡打拼的每个人都有付出，无论是国人还是外国人。政府给了你PR 就是你有资格，是你自已的。要为自已跟家人未来打算。我觉得保留没有不好。不需要去介意别人看法，每个人都有选择的权力。
谢谢你👍🏻🌹
在新加坡，PR的数目可以说是固定的，每年大约只有50万人。只是一个建议，如果你肯定不要Sg PR的话，最好是能够放弃那个status，提早让给那些现在需要的人。以前我看过一个数据，每年有12万人申请PR，但批准的只有约3万人（那3万人的空额，很有可能大部份是从PR转成公民😅）。 谢谢。
感谢分享🌹
装圣人吗？
拿得到PR的人都是为了有更好的未来的可能而决定去拿的，而拿不到的人，只能继续努力去争取，否则怪不了别人的。总的来说，不管哪个PR不想放弃自己的PR status也是很合理的
@@mkbong3230 无论是申请PR还是公民，每年都是有个额度的。拿张PR却没有用到，唉！ 一些人还因为自己EP的薪水不够，无法申请家人来新加坡。如果他们成功申请到PR，申请resale hdb，家人来就没有问题了。
@@kcchiew4247 就算是有人把名额让出来了，那些拿不到的人就是拿不到，怪不了别人
我的意思只是这样，那些人拿不拿得到不是因为有没有人让出他们的PR而导致的
errrrrr
我以前也是PR,回来大马后就放弃了。赞成你保留，多一个选择蛮好的，多一个保障。新加坡的确是个好国家❤
谢谢你的分享🙏🏻
我还记得当时官员还劝我们不要放弃去找工延续，他说很多人要拿都拿不到，放弃很可惜。某些原因我们还是坚持放弃了。
請你放弃，給他人有機會。
@@estheryong5900 什么原因方便詵下吗?如不方便説也没事。
机会只有一次要知道多少人在排队等候吗？以后难如登天，也许你比较喜欢乡村生活方式没有竞争一日过一日的生活。
Great information, thanks for the updates 👍
No problem😊Thanks for watching also🙏🏻
If you earn $1 for every stupid comment people say i think you will be rich. Don't need to care what other people say. You worked for it, you earned it. Singapore always welcome you
Thank you😊😎👍🏻
如果你有在看新加坡新聞的話，其實也沒有什麼好吵的，也不用煩惱要不要放棄PR。
新加坡政府已經在清理著那些不在新加坡工作或居住或生活，又把錢留在CPF戶口裡面的存款。
輪不到我們控制，新加坡政府會幫你做選擇，除非進回來新加坡工作。等你的REP renewal能拿到幾年就知道，如果是5年，那就恭喜你，你的‘自僱人士’有效，但如果你的renewal是一年，就要選擇下一站是新加坡或馬來西亞了。
😊😊
感谢分享😊
鱼与熊掌不可兼得新加坡政府比谁都清楚后果的
你有对新加坡作出贡献，你有权利选择，对于那些偏激的人，无需对他们解释过多，偏激的人一般不讲理和思维固化。
你有继续在新加坡缴税，对更新REP比较有利。
谢谢你🙏🏻👍🏻
只要没伤到别人，忠于自己的决定是没错的呀! 祝一切顺心，加油! 😊
👍🏻谢谢你😊
Bro, 你这句话讲得很对。pr不是这些黑粉批给你的，是靠自己的努力争取来的。加油！别管那些偏激人的看法！新加坡政府自己会审核贡献的
赞同👍🏻🤜🏻🤛🏻
如果新加坡的永久居民（PR）因工作或其他原因决定返回本国，其公关身份将不会自动撤销。然而，必须注意的是，在新加坡保持公关地位需要履行某些义务并满足特定标准。以下是需要考虑的几个要点：
1. 再入境许可证（REP）：PR需要确保其再入境许可证（REP）仍然有效。REP允许公关在新加坡境外保留其公关身份。它通常有效期为五年，需要定期续订。未能续订REP可能会导致失去公关状态。
2. 最低居住要求：公关人员应满足最低居住要求，以保持其公关地位。这通常涉及在特定期限内在新加坡度过一定天数。未能满足这一要求可能会影响公关状态。
3. 长期缺勤：在没有正当理由或未满足最低居住要求的情况下长期离开新加坡，可能会引起人们对公关对新加坡承诺的担忧，可能导致进一步审查甚至撤销公关地位。
建议公关计划在海外长期工作，以确保他们了解并遵守相关的公关要求。让当局了解他们的情况并获得必要的批准，如REP续约，可以帮助保持他们的公关地位。如果有具体问题或情况，建议咨询移民和检查站管理局（ICA），以获得准确和个性化的指导。 8:03
新加坡永久居民（PR）的最低居住要求是移民和检查站管理局（ICA）制定的指导方针，以确保PR与新加坡保持实质性联系。具体要求如下：
1. 第一代(PR)公关：对于获得成人（21岁及以上）公关身份的公关人员，他们通常需要在获得公关身份的头五年内在新加坡居住至少两年。
2. 第二代公关：在21岁之前获得公关身份的公关要遵守一套不同的要求。在再入境许可证（REP）的每五年续签周期中，他们通常应在新加坡居住至少两年。
需要注意的是，未能满足最低居住要求可能会影响公关地位的续期，并可能导致公关地位的丧失。此外，保持有效的再入境许可证（REP）对于居住在海外的公关人员来说至关重要，以确保他们能够保持公关地位。
请记住，具体情况和要求可能会有所不同，最好咨询ICA或参考其官方网站，以获取有关新加坡公关最低居住要求的最准确和最新信息。 8:03
感谢分享🙏🏻👍🏻
我是permit的，我认同你说的环境真的不错🎉🎉🎉🎉
👍🏻
沒事啦·欢迎你们·加油
😊🙏🏻🌹
我是马来西亚人，男生，在新加坡打工生活过10年了，一直都是拿着wp,因为不想被认为我不爱国和不想和新加坡人抢饭碗，所以一直做着3D的工作，如dirty,danger,difficult的工作。一直以来我都有一个想法，我想为社会付出我的能力，希望影响社会变更好，一直很羡慕新加坡当兵的男生，虽然很多人不喜欢，可我就喜欢那些制服的工作，为社会服务，可惜我是大马人，我很喜欢sg的鱼圆面，喜欢去stadium看球赛，支持loh kean yew,yeo jia min，30岁了，申请PR应该没机会了，又没有Degree，还是我丢一大笔钱下去读singapore polytechnic,20多千，毕业出来32岁了，还来得及吗？
Hihi.. 有一种说法是当我们没有退路没有后路了，我们就会100％ 把眼前的路走好，就会全心全意的做完做对做好... 因为你一直有 SPR 这个退路也许会一直犹豫不决..
完全明白的想说的，all in这件事可能是我现在没办法做得到的😌谢谢你的留言🙏🏻👍🏻
@@zchannelzack support you always! 不要理酸民。你已经比很多人勇敢！！！
我有一個同事回去大馬一年半後到回來新加坡工作。可是她的PR renewal不能夠renew五年，只能renew最多一年。ica給的理由是指她沒有contribute 什麼給新加坡，所以才會有這個問題
所以我才说contribution很重要🌹👍🏻🙏🏻
Zack, 可以拍一個content information about 如何申請PR嗎？感謝分享
😆這個網上查的到，很多人在分享了🌹
Zack， 如果，如果我是你。。。有大学文凭，目前是PR，看你视频华文英文水准都不错，是可以在新加坡找好吃的好料。而且目前，也可能未来100 年，马国政局，固打，种族问题依旧，看不到前景，我会和Z 嫂和女儿举家落户新加坡。两个PR 可以申请一间HDB， 你工作超过10 多年，CPF 买屋子应该没问题。两个PR 夫妻努力打拼，女儿在新加坡受教育都没问题的，不要太过担忧，如果可以兼职继续拍视频，累计阅读量也能赚点生活费，今天不知明日事，也许你也会大红大紫的一天。等过了几年再考虑是否转公民，从此就落地生根。横竖马国家人就那么一水之隔而已。我自己本身 20出 年前嫁来新加坡，老公两孩子是公民，我从过去17,8 年都只拿 PR，心里盘算着有离婚的一天至少可以“回家”，再来真的爱我的国家，在那次变天的选举，我彻夜未眠守在电脑欢呼，以为国家终于看到未来美好的前程。。结果后来的后门事件，我对国家才彻底死心了，才真正提出新公民的申请。。在MHC提交IC， BC，和PP 那天，我以为会很失落，其实真的没有，然后办理过程，拿新加坡PP和IC 一样平静，然后为新身份兴奋，目前一点都不后悔，毕竟老公孩子都在身边，一切都那么美好，更希望从此岁月静好。看了你许多视频，你很适合在新加坡打拼的，希望你好好想想，三思再三思。。最后决定还是你自己，做出选择后安定下来呗。
你好，其实我是知道你想要表达的，只是很多时候我不能自己一个人决定，所以我也是在找一天对我身边人都好的路😌感谢你的分享🙏🏻我会加油的😊
@@zchannelzack 是，每个人的想法和际遇都不一样，我也只是一个建议，无论你做出什么抉择，还是衷心祝福你。
我在新加坡出生長大, 父母是台灣籍的SPR, 一直拿SPR生份, 因家庭因素之後在台灣工作, 但後來renewal criteria變嚴格, 只給我一年的REP就沒有了... 但我的身份認同一直是新加坡(但也沒辦法在新家坡申請citizenship). so it was a sad day when my REP expired. 最近收到CPF的信, 就是如果SPR身分沒有了, CPF在明年4月前要強迫關帳戶, 不知道您有沒有也接到這樣的消息. i think for you its really your choice to make - as long as you fulfil the criteria for REP renewal, i dont see why not! 如果也有考量之後小朋友要在新加坡就學, 也是一個很好的選擇! enjoy your channel, keep up the good work!!
感谢分享你的经验👍🏻🙏🏻🌹
Z, 我建议你照样给CPF，但我猜ICA当你要renew时有可能看看你的职业与薪水来考量的。所以，你和老婆尽可能在PR renewal前的18个月前随便找份稳定大公司来做。毕竟现在PR已经超级难拿到了！尤其covid过后，超级多中国，印度富商全家都要过来拿PR，而新加坡现在的PR已经是超级贵！不要随便放弃！还有如果能就回来新加坡继续工作apply SG citizen吧, 你老婆不要做sg citizen, remain Malaysian, 这样你将来可以靠你老婆再apply malaysia PR。原因是为了给你整家人普后路! 如果你是SG citizen, 老婆是PR, 你们可以申请HDB, 孩子教育在新加坡是一定比较好的。工作机会也比较多! 还有做youtuber 可以业余做，因为你小孩一开学又慢慢长大，expenses会越来越高，而youtuber的薪金是维持不住的。就算你留在马国，工作机跟新加坡比会也会少一半， 钱也少3到4倍。 最重要是你做property agent不适合你忠厚老实的性格，如果你喜欢地产，我可以建议你教你真正的进入property industry做sales and leasing的工作，有稳定月薪，和能慢慢一步一步升上去。或者你对property mgt 有兴趣， 我也可以教你怎么样入行业。 因为我在你身上看到我年轻时的影子，但我没人帮，指导，所以很想帮帮你和你家庭
谢谢你的分享🙏🏻也感谢你的分析👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@@zchannelzack 不用客气。
应该保留。五十五岁生日那天就选擇公積金终生计画，六十五岁开始公積金局每个月会给你一笔钱到你在这世上的最后一个月。如果可以的话，你或你太太一个人伸请新加坡公民，你的孩子也可以做新加坡公民。如果你失去永久居名，以后你的孩子可以伸请你成为永久居民。
感谢建议🙏🏻
法律在·新加坡国会里头，政府会事宜调整。下个大选，假如第四代接棒团队成绩不牢固，个人预测当局对外国人政策会进一步调正，很可能 连 PR 三年后才能购买HDB 也会拿掉 ？早年前REP从十年缩到五年，现在开始也以积分在评估各个申请者。大方向不是批多富有，而是是愿不愿意融入为佳，还有工作职位与能力。
感谢分析以及分享这些信息🙏🏻感恩感恩🌹
只能说世上没有两全其美的事。你不蠢但新加坡政府也不笨😂你想到的新加坡政府在N年前可能已经有应对的措施只是时间上需不需要，能不能或该不该执行而已。
我是新加坡人 同意你所說 欢迎你！
🌹
不用去理会哪些思想狹隘, 偏激又沒供献的键盘客的无聊留言, 人都是为了自己和家人而活的, 而且你说得对, PR是你自己争取的, 留与不留干他们屁事!？最重要的是自己问心无愧, 也感谢你这十年来对新加坡经济的小小供献, 虽说你也是为了哪对换率。😅
谢谢你🙏🏻👍🏻
Bro, PR is the best status in Singapore. If you plan to leave Singapore and West Malaysia for good and wish to renounce your citizenship or PR status, you can withdraw all your CPF. Imagine those with 6 figure CPF, you can withdraw all and stay in Malaysia with RM500,000 allow you to lead a Dato life..
Thank you😊🙏🏻🌹
I am also a singapore PR. Just keep it and enjoy the benefit. If give up we can withdraw the cpf account and collect cash
Thanks for sharing🌹
The ICA requires PR holders to fulfill certain obligations, such as residing in Singapore for a significant period, contributing to the country's economy, and adhering to the rules and regulations.
Thanks for sharing🌹👍🏻
你得搞清楚contribution这句话，是你为新加坡🇸🇬国家贡献什么？而不是你给的钱？新加坡有的是钱。。看起来你出的这个节目，新加坡🇸🇬ICA肯定会更调查你了!!!你根本这两年就没有为新加坡🇸🇬贡献些什么。
@@人-z2p
你是新加坡政府吗？
别讲大话。
@@daigamessg6725我是你老爸，用脑去想一下问题吧。
@@人-z2p 不要乱乱做政府，你不是自己私人政府！
說的很好。
谢谢你🌹
有两个朋友 在新加坡打拼十多年后 就退pr 回去大马生活了
。他们经济自由了，38岁前就退休了。
🌹
I think you shouldn't give up the S'pore PR status. Continue contributing the CPF as the interest you receive is more than the bank, & like you say the medi shield will come in useful, just in case.. ( touch wood🙏) also Singapore is a nice place, who knows you may also want to start your own business there too one day.
That's the plan!😆👍🏻
agreed
努力创业 加油! 加油! 👍💪
谢谢你😊
As a singaporean cpf rocks
If you have a 90k in SA account 4K interest annually risk free (no need to even pay any fees!) totally shiok !
And also I’m sure there is no other invest medium other than fixed deposit or t bills that can beat a solid 4% per annum interest.
Lastly first 60k in cpf gives you an extra 1% interest which means your sa can go up to 5% annum leh … there is no other place I know off that gives you this kind of interest.
Jia you!
Thanks for the sharing🙏🏻🌹
为你自己，为老婆，为女儿。你现在所做的一切都是最好的选择。绝对没有错。
谢谢你🙏🏻
can plan for kids future study in SG if possible too....
If your person is here in Singapore, but your heart is still in Malaysia,then i think better you go back to Malaysia forever 🙏🙏
🌹
當然要保留 多一個選擇很好。 而且你們有小孩了 為小孩未來著想 不要放棄 新加坡不錯的
👍🏻
感谢分享
我也是马来西亚公民，新加坡永久居民。目前是自己接案子工作，在决定回国长住后也决定保留新国的永久居民。这只影片所分享的讯息非常实用！（我想继续还新加坡 tax)
请问下杰克对于 IC 上的地址是怎么处理呢？直接改成马来西亚地址吗？或是其他方法？
IC可以换成马来西亚的，可以到ICA网站查看详情🌹
@@zchannelzack 谢谢回复 💫
已经查到了， 但经考量后我还是选择过后另换新的新加坡地址好了，毕竟自身接案的客户都在新国，用新加坡地址比较方便。
事情没有绝对的對與錯 主要取决于你哪里的生活過得较舒适 没有太大的压迫感 最重要是開心
是的😎👍🏻
留着咯❤
👍🏻
你在误导观众,PR不是不会过期，而是你的REP一旦被取消你的PR就被取消，REP主要的功能不是去国外，是回新加坡。你说你是self employed 然后是youtuber 然后有CPF contribution 所以PR不会割死所以REP不会不可以renew. 你现在发了视频有两万人在看，如果每一个PR都跟你的pattern 都说自己是youtuber 然后self employed 然后”两块钱”CPF contribution就可以保留PR，我要看ICA是怎么处理，我们新加坡人还面对你们两百万的马劳，还要当2+10年的兵，还要每次出国都需要国防部批准。
感谢留言🌹
說得好！👏👏👏
Just keep your PR, dont give it up bcoz next time, you may not get your PR again. As for those negative unfriendly comments etc, just ignore lah. The mouths on people's body, you cant stop them. So on your end just ignore and do what you need for your family and career as long as you respect/ follow the laws required (example, submit CPF, tax etc).
I agree. At least do what is best for you and your family. As for me, despite being a Singaporean, I like the easy going lifestyle of Malaysia as well. I have plans to semi- retire in Malaysia and maybe once in a while return to Singapore to do freelance school training. Which is why I have gotten a BTO flat in Woodlands. My main priority is the MRT line between Woodlands and Bukit Changar where I can commute both sides regularly. 有工做，我就回新加波。没有的话，我就住在联邦，偶尔去Cuti Cuti Malaysia 吃风。
😊👍🏻
@@Sohai1901 Wah you have made plans oredi, good for you 👍! Yes SG can be overly crowded and noisy. Personally I prefer the more laid back lifestyle of Msia.
@@wwpoof The plan have gone long overdue for 9 years. I only managed to start executing step 1 this two years ago due to financial constraint and bad health.
保留是对的 👌
👍🏻😊🌹
正能量的小火子！加油！
谢谢你🙏🏻
给你小科普哦。。在show 任何🪪 ID ... 要用纸来盖不要用effect 来弄蒙。。因为科技会把蒙点弄清的。这个你们TH-camrs 要注意哦
好的👍🏻感谢分享🙏🏻
Wise to keep! 👏👏👏👍❤️
👍🏻
If you hold a PR in singapore, one year you need to stay in Singapore 182 days, then you can renew your re-entry prrmit
Maybe can refer the ICA website for accurate info🌹
我觉得第一次renew没问题，再过5年有点难。到renew的时候进入新加坡试一下就行🎉
谢谢分享🙏🏻
若沒記錯，好像有個條例，就是RENEW REP前必須是住在新加坡最少半年。
好人一生平安
只要你是地球人，你都可以自由的去选择世界上任何一个地方去生活，没有所謂的那一个地方好，或那一个地方差，只有适合与不适合的问题而已。
赞同👍🏻
希望你能够做一集关于SG Tax 和 Malaysia Tax .
谢谢你
👍🏻
我觉得现在cpf的制度已经很公平了 只要放弃PR 不需要等55岁就能拿出来了 ， 然后新加坡也不会再给利息。 所以PR的强制性存CPF制度 真的性价比很高
🌹
你再回去觀察那些所謂”滾回去馬來西亞“的留言，再去對比你在新加坡親身所接觸過的新加坡人，你肯定那些留言的真實身分是新加坡人？是不是”自己人“為了留住自己人或因某些原因假冒新加坡人留一些言論讓你對星國人反感！你在新加坡已久應該會觀察到虛實！
不关国籍问题啦，是个人修养的问题🌹
讲这类东东的人，都很无知，完全不了解自己国家面对的问题。。。什么淋资源都没有的国家，自己又不要生多点，没有外国人来就业，没有税收，国家肯定吃草。
原来不止是我觉察到这问题。。。
没错！很多是反串坡人,制造对立
@@jywee6202對！很多都是馬來國的二等公民反串的！牠們是jeffreyleow9998，stevenlim9640, gotmyonu1027!
晚上好，端午安康💓💓
谢谢你🙏🏻
其实不需要去和那些酸民解释。
就好像在马来西亚之前说cina balik cina。
要不要割你的PR也是你的选择，要不要回去你的国家也是你的选择。
滚不滚回去自己的国家也不关他们的事。加油！
赞同😊👍🏻
i think ICA should do something about this also all PR leave singapore as an self employ and this kind of status a lot of ppl will not be able to get the PR cos they are taken up the quota. for those who are really keen to work and stay in singapore it is unfair.
Thanks for your comment and point of view.
Hey Zack, I wonder for cases similar to yours: self-employed and living at overseas + continue contribute CPF and pay income tax @ SG, did you ask ICA whether this meets the REP renewal criteria?
I did check but they indirectly told me as long as follow the instruction then should be no issue, unless officer purposely request the proof from me which is I also can proof.🌹
When friend got his REP reduced while staying overseas more than 50% of her last 5yrs rep period, she gotten only a 1yr rep after renewing, although she still has her hb n kids in SG.
Thanks for the info👍🏻
Zack, 可不可以做一期讲关于在新加坡买保险的事，因为刚刚影片中你有提到你有买新加坡政府津贴的保险，身为PR应该买什么样的保险？是新加坡政府津贴保险还是买像Great Esrtern, Prudential这样的保险？
接下来会有类似的影片，请期待🌹
歡迎成為新加坡人，我的兒子的女友（未來媳婦）也是PR不要放棄，以後可以讓你孩子在新加坡讀書受教育，乘年輕時不妨考慮買一間房子，也是一個非常好的投資，從以前到現在新加坡的屋價有上沒下。不管你是在那裡出世或種族，在新加坡你永遠是第一等公民，看看我國有幾位部長他們也在馬來西亞出世，他們現在也是管理新加坡。
🌹
保留。你也可以进军新加坡产业市场和投资股市。反正，你有金融的知识。CPF的利息比银行好了很多，风险低。
感谢分享🙏🏻👍🏻
同意!
如果大多数人选择那条路，我们要反其道而行，逆向思维，别跟着大众走，你成功的几率才会高
😊👍🏻
别太自信你的PR不会被取消，有一些PR从没离开新加坡五年到期后不被Renew的列子也不少，尤其现在新加坡政府对移民政策不停的改变。
好的，感谢留言🌹
@@zchannelzack 我有看过一个英国自媒体人的视频她在新加坡当教师有PR的但五年到期了不被接受Renew。
帅哥，有空可以做个视频如何取消PR，拿CPF的过程。
现阶段我没这个打算噢😆
看过中国人做过，全程不到一个小时，当天滚蛋。😂
很容易的，你只要写一封信拿去ICA告诉ICA你要还回个PR,就直接割了， 我马来西亚的同事就是这样做。
@@pekkimtee463请问需要什么样的信？（退还PR的）
@@winniewong8649 写给ICA 说你要放弃,
就算已确定长期在本地置业讨生活，也不必特意去割掉PR. 就让它自己失效。留着只是为了万一还有可能回头的路。最重要是确定在本地的生活稳定，对自己的要求是可以接受和舒适的，当然也要想想，已现在的收入，是否大概可以应付孩子未来的学费和自己的退休金喔。也要计划未来可有的持续性被动收入和医药保单。
👍🏻
after 37 years in SG and PR for 27 years, i am converting to SG citizenship.
Why? not willing to pay ABSD for SG property. its quite a hefty sum for pte properties.
i also dont see a future of being a chinese in MY.
Thanks for the comment🌹
加油 祝福你顺利 其实永久居民也还是拿着自己国家的护照 津贴也跟新加坡公民差很多 所以这些黑粉真的没什么好生气 而且是人家自己争取来的 不需要时不时就把“滚来滚去”挂嘴边
😆一种米养百种人，世上还是有这种人的😌
努力得来的东西别轻易放弃,你们还那么年轻或许有一天这P'R身份会用上的，不论多麻烦还是乖乖的延长rep吧，更何况不麻烦呢。。
赞同😊👍🏻
I agree, u r always welcome !
🌹
那些激烈份子很可能是馬來西亞和新加坡的境外勢力。他們不喜歡看到幸福的馬來西亞和新加坡人。也想分化我們。
有可能😆👍🏻
偏激份子
保留pr没错，给人生多一些选择。
如果更要保障的话，在新加坡创立公司也是不错的，tax也比较低。前提是要有新加坡客户。
对的，新加坡tax确实低很多，所以外资很喜欢新加坡👍🏻
其实说个公道话给大家想问一句 你的家可以给我住吗？你的车可以给我用吗？你的财产我有分吗？我想大家应该明白我的 意思! 其实分享只是找个知音人或者是找个 伯乐 我们不可能吃饱空闲找人吵架吧¡🤣
😆👍🏻
如果与你这样说，很多外国人来到新加坡申请了，然后再回去他们的国家。新加坡的pr的申请人数不是很多了吗？都没有为国家提供任何经济的效益。。新加坡移民局给出的pr就是要他们留在新加坡，为新加坡 贡献。。我看你已经搞错了Contribution这句话了。。
需要meet minimum stay requirement的。
👌🏻
先生你的选择是十分正确✅👍
🌹
你的选择是对的👍
🌹👍🏻
保留是對的，👌👍
🌹
你可以做一集比较新马个人税务的不同和高低让我们了解一下
谢谢你🙏🏻👍🏻
不要被这些假相骗了，tax有direct和indirect.这里的income tax肯定比较低，可是那个indirect tax 就吓死人，那一些？，gst,stamp duty, utility, petrol, coe等等。。。
当然还有，市面很多东西都没有津贴，价钱肯定较高。
比较想看你和二胎的生活❤快点生多一个宝宝
😆🌹
👍👍👍
🌹🌹🌹
新加坡和马来西亚都是一样的我觉的都是自己人。👍
👍🏻😊
曾经在新加坡工作了12年都拿不到PR所以选择回来马来西亚了，想问你，以前是东马人如果要选择回去不再回去新加坡工作是可以拿完CPF的，西马的必须等到退休年龄才可以拿，现在是西马人选择不要PR了也是同样可以拿？
这个我不太清楚哦，因为我没有要丢掉PR的打算🌹
对，今年CPF发出的文告。。限不是公民和PR 到明年3月尾可以申请出CPF，就算 没领出，三月过后也不再给利息。
我是北京的，我想要东马的PR😁以后研究研究怎么搞
😆👍🏻欢迎来马来西亚😊
You come S'pore beacuse of money you earn a lot money can go back rest and enjoy your life S'pore life is very stress everything is not cheap some time we very hard to breathe 🤑
🌹