@@Queen-dl5ju this has become her thing and honestly, her charisma makes up for it since the other members do not really over dance but also almost keeps the same energy as her.
Karina looks like a game character and Giselle’s giving head witch dark academia vibes ♥️🖤 Hope they style Karina’s hair like that next time coz it looks so good on her. A vampire esque style suits Giselle so much
Karina isn't my bias but she is soooooo beautiful in this hairstyle. And Ningning,her presence always makes me feel like there's a tiger(or leopard ?)hunting on the stage.
Girl! Ning ning is really the very underrated ace of this group, just look how she always gives flavors to their entire performance, her passion, good facial expressions and precise movement are so top notch. She definitely always slay for giving her 100% best in everything she do. That amazing vocals, her movement, visual and charisma are all overflowing, plus she can also nail a rap part, if u ever watch their bts of dreams come true. Dang, she has a lot to offer, can't wait for this girl to also shine like the other members💙 Ningning is not my bias but can't deny how powerful and amazing this girl can be as a performer 👏🏻
@@Ari-uc9je she has the visual, she's so pretty, her visual was even praised a lot more by some Americans during their parade than Karina and Winter's, great dancing (she has sharp and good movements dude, try to watch her fancams and tiktok. She's a good dancer) and top notch singing skills (she has wide voal range that makes her scary rookie) can do raps (she has been tested a lot of time, and she proved that she can nail it too) and ofcourse she has an amazing stage presence and charisma, among the aespa members, she has the best facial expressions since black mamba era. That's why she's an 'underrated ace' because she wasn't given enough spotlight yet to full showcase her great potentials and skills.
I totally agree with what you posted. She's my favorite in this group and every reason you mentioned for why she is an ace makes totally sense to me. I LOVE her performances and how she sings. Of course, I love every member of this group, but I have to say Ningning is amazing!
Karina's dancing style is unique. She does not overflow the control in her body and she knows on how to make every move clean and silky-like but there's a little bit of sharpness.
Giselle and Karina’s outfits are my favorites here. Giselle looks so pretty (and the dress seems to suit her style), and Karina looks like such a badass! I loved watching this. I’m so proud of all my girls. Happy New Year, aespa, and happy birthday, Winter! ⛄️❤️
Nining bukan main dancer, tapi gerakan dancenya sangat bagus, benar2 sangat powerfull dalam menari. Selain Jihyo Twice, mungkin nining jg pantas disebut main vocal+main dancer. Pround of maknae
Ningning she walk like a Queen and I really like her shoes. Aeri her outfit stands out cute elegant and beautiful. Winter I always love her soulful voice I swear. Karina she always take the lead she's the ace of the group. Happy new year Queens:)
Giselle is really confident and charming here. She know how to *SLAY* a stage with excellent facial expressions, the black fit on her is just *Chef's kiss
Giselle cant dance and are rlly weak in all terms she dont bring anything good in this grp nor Will she ever and Even herself knows that its a simple fact you or her cant change
I am absolutely STUNNED!! Just started stanning them a few weeks ago but omg??? I'm so in love with Giselles and Karinas outfit. Giselle looks like a beautiful black swan and Karina looks so cool and pretty ♡ Winters vocals are so amazing and ningnings stage presence is no joke, she caught my eyes immediately. Also the intro was fire!! I'm already so in love with them all and I'm happy I got into this fandom haha♡♡
aespa literally beat all the "No stage presence and, No dance break" allegations! Charisma is overflowing + the outfits is just chefs kiss. What a *QUEENS*
@@alanbalcarcel5850 don't interact with that attention seeker. She just want to throw hate to other members. Prolly their parents doesn't give them enough attention now their looking for some here on the internet.
스엠 제발 올해도 6년주기처럼 일좀 잘하자.. 작년6년주기여도 글쎄 에스파한테 3연속 디싱에 음방 next level 4번 그나마 savage 음반 냈어도 컴백 첫주에 음방 안돌았구 결국 5번.. 애네 신인이야 스엠.. 제발 우리 2009~2011년 때처럼 일 잘했잤아.. 그때처럼 일 잘하자 ㅜㅜ 제발 컴백 첫주에 음방 도는 에스파 보고싶어..ㅜ
솔직히 2021년 스엠 열일한거 같은데... 에스파 뿐만 아니라 태연, 효연, 키, 카이, 조이 솔로에 레드벨벳, 엔씨티까지...연말에는 smtown 겨울 스페셜 앨범에 연초에는 온라인 무료 콘서트 그리고 사실 음방도 옛날처럼 주구장창 오래 도는것도 요즘 스타일도 아닐 뿐더러 이미지 소비도 심하고 거의 컴백 2주째까지 팬싸다 뭐다 스케쥴 있었던 거 같은데...또 컴백 첫주에 음방 안도는 대신에 스튜디오 춤이라던가 지체 퍼포먼스 영상으로 먼저 공개해줬어서..😓
Karina visuals is amazing for just a second she looked like a 3d anime character i had to check again 😂😂 Ningning vocals and her little strut at the beginning she was amazing
![[4K] 에스파(aespa)💥데뷔부터 지금까지💥무대 말아드림 | Black Mamba부터 Spicy까지](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aQ2ZfTFW6Qk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] 에스파(aespa)💥데뷔부터 지금까지💥무대 말아드림 | Black Mamba부터 Spicy까지](/img/tr.png)
![จังหวะนี้ - เม้ก อภิสิทธิ์ [ Official MV ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4gQRZCkRyiU/mqdefault.jpg)
Karina is like a doll! Look at her, she's GORGEOUS!
See,if they given a dance break they would devour and look at how they walk during the into especially ningning,they look so powerful.
머리 묶은 카리나 언니 너무 예뻤다 진짜
Ningning's stage presence is really not a joke , she is passionate
Nobody on aspea has stage persence
@@sunnybee2808 why so salty?
Same thoughts
@@sunnybee2808 keep on str3aming. Thank uuu
@@sunnybee2808 aspea
Karina is so charismatic, she also slay that dance break you go gurl!
Karina and Giselle's charisma and Ning Ning and Winter's vocals are no joke.
OT4 forever,,,,happy new year💙🌙❄️🦋
Lypsinc
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 ok bye
hmm giselle is still improving, but in a slow way..
theyre lipsyncing
Giselle being a black swan for 4 minutes straight. Her charisma is overwhelming tho 🖤
her movement this time seem even weaker than before.. is she hurt or something
@@Queen-dl5ju I was wondering the same thing. She didn't do a lot of the moves
@@Queen-dl5juwdym she looked fine to me 🤡
@@Queen-dl5ju 2:22 ummm it was much better today tho
4:05
@@Queen-dl5ju this has become her thing and honestly, her charisma makes up for it since the other members do not really over dance but also almost keeps the same energy as her.
Ningning came to kill the stage. Ningning came to kill the stage. Wow 👑🔥
I really liked Karina's hair. It's kinda rare to see her tying ponytail. She looked so good with it!
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
Karina looks so good with ponytails. She kills the intro dance break. She sure is the main dancer.
yesssssssssss
Ikr!!!!
fr 😭❤
she is literally a goddess so ethereal on any style 🥺
Yes
Oww giselle is really beautiful,
I love her attitude
Ning Ning stage presence is definitely the best!!!
We get to see Karina with ponytails once again. Omg she is so pretty.
very😢❤
Oh my lord, Karina is shiningggg, the dance break, stage presence, outfit, makeup, oh my gosh her eyes guys, she ate them all
Nobody in aspea has stage persence like where
@@sunnybee2808 ok thats your point
karina and ning ning came to kill in that intro dance break, they were so eye-catching
I love that it looks like Giselle is not seriously trying, she looks so cool and superior, I love her attitude my god❤️❤️❤️❤️
Karina's charisma is off the charts, my girl
Karina is so gorgeous, ethereal and unreal. She's art, grace and beauty. She's a living anime.
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 shut up already.
he is at least successful and humble unlike you
@@aseem9235 your name and pfp
✨😂
@@fizaa1128 lmao-
I’m so happy for Giselle, she looks like she’s having fun for once with this comeback!
don’t be happy for a racist
@@angiessaranghae1087 LOL, that's you. Bcs Giselle has already send the statement to apologize abt what she did before 24 hours.
@@peachlion893 just cuz she apologizes before 24 hours doesn’t mean everything. She was getting hated on and she saw that
@@angiessaranghae1087 naw cuz they wanna forget that she said it with her whole chest and that apology was fake as hell
@@angiessaranghae1087 Like for real this is in the lyric of the song, go cry about the song writer and the one promoting it
Karina looks like a game character and Giselle’s giving head witch dark academia vibes ♥️🖤 Hope they style Karina’s hair like that next time coz it looks so good on her. A vampire esque style suits Giselle so much
Ningning is so powerful and she is confident , her energy can destroy the stage. Really the Best performer.
ningning just killed this stage and left no crumbs
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
NingNing is just an ace.
Her talent is not a joke. She is so beautiful and so lovely.
She born to be an artist 🧡.
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
Look at how different are Ningning’s walk & her confident steps between the others, she was like “hey i’m the queen here”👑
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
haha no hate but she only walked like that because her strides weren't as long as the other members and she had to keep up
@@maypeng775 haha thats okay, i appreciate your opinion. We have our own perspective for it. So we do have the same rights to speak.
Karina isn't my bias but she is soooooo beautiful in this hairstyle. And Ningning,her presence always makes me feel like there's a tiger(or leopard ?)hunting on the stage.
Yessss. And OMG I esp agree with the part you say Ning's presence is like a tiger. I feel it too!
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
ningning really knows how to carry herself.she's so confident and charismatic.
She is so powerful
@BTS in your area oh yeah, ningning is such a lingling.
totally agree and the way she walk 🔥
She is so sexy
In my opinion she is the best performer in aespa ❤️
Girl! Ning ning is really the very underrated ace of this group, just look how she always gives flavors to their entire performance, her passion, good facial expressions and precise movement are so top notch. She definitely always slay for giving her 100% best in everything she do. That amazing vocals, her movement, visual and charisma are all overflowing, plus she can also nail a rap part, if u ever watch their bts of dreams come true. Dang, she has a lot to offer, can't wait for this girl to also shine like the other members💙 Ningning is not my bias but can't deny how powerful and amazing this girl can be as a performer 👏🏻
Not an ace
@@Ari-uc9je she has the visual, she's so pretty, her visual was even praised a lot more by some Americans during their parade than Karina and Winter's, great dancing (she has sharp and good movements dude, try to watch her fancams and tiktok. She's a good dancer) and top notch singing skills (she has wide voal range that makes her scary rookie) can do raps (she has been tested a lot of time, and she proved that she can nail it too) and ofcourse she has an amazing stage presence and charisma, among the aespa members, she has the best facial expressions since black mamba era.
That's why she's an 'underrated ace' because she wasn't given enough spotlight yet to full showcase her great potentials and skills.
I totally agree with what you posted. She's my favorite in this group and every reason you mentioned for why she is an ace makes totally sense to me. I LOVE her performances and how she sings. Of course, I love every member of this group, but I have to say Ningning is amazing!
@@RoseFrance facial expressions and stage presence are different
@@lol-yz2kd yas I'm fully aware of that, for the 'meaning' itself. And she has both.
게임에서 튀어나온 완벽한 캐릭터들 같음;;;특히 카리나.. 스엠은 스엠이다 정말
THEIR STYLIST ARE OUT OF THIS WORLD RAISE EM PAYCHECK THEY MAKE EVERYONE SHINE
girl I dont know about you but these outfits are ugly asf
@@australianbeanz8108 hmm no
@@australianbeanz8108 i don't think so..
lol girl no
Ah I'll rate it 4/10
Karina is def one of the best 4th gen visuals in kpop, so pretty 😍 and her charisma is everything too
ngl, yes i agree😭😭 her features unique
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
Giselle looks super good, this is honestly the best stage outfit for SAVAGE she’s ever had in my opinion
Worst ever
Giselle’s confidence and visual is off the roof
She’s on fire here
Wow 😮 😱
Giselle and Ningning stage presence THOO. THEY ARE SO GOOD
Karina's eye make up wooow!! and her and NingNing's costumes suit them.
NINGNING is one of the idols with the BEST stage presence!! Also she could easily be the main dancer, her moves are so powerful and precise
They finally add something new for their performance. Ningning's walk is killer!
Winter the ace in aespa
Karina is blooming today, she's so pretty as always. Aespa slay!!
I love Giselle’s whole visual in this😭 THE HAIR THE OUTFIT THE MAKEUP SHES SO PRETTY
Nining‘s walk at the beginning is me 🤩
Karina's dancing style is unique. She does not overflow the control in her body and she knows on how to make every move clean and silky-like but there's a little bit of sharpness.
i agree 😭 such a main dancee ❤❤
she moves so fast too!! after her first verse when she goes to the back while dancing is so impressive
No
She is a detailed dancer too
THEIR PERFORMANCE, OUTFITS, CHARISMA, VISUALS, TALENTS, AND EVERYTHING ARE ON FIRE! I KNOW THAT EVERYONE IS WAITING FOR AESPA EVEN THE NON-MYs 😌
Ningning is on FIRE!! COMMON SM! GIVE NINGNING A DANCE POSITION RN. HER STAGE PRESENCE IS NO JOKE AT ALL.
Tht bridge my fav bridge from kpop song this year. And one if the best bridge i hv ever heard
Again..the visual and charisma of Karina is overflowing
Karina's stage presence is unmatched go our stage genius!
Ningning gave her all for that powerful walk dang
Giselle and Karina’s outfits are my favorites here. Giselle looks so pretty (and the dress seems to suit her style), and Karina looks like such a badass! I loved watching this. I’m so proud of all my girls. Happy New Year, aespa, and happy birthday, Winter! ⛄️❤️
Karina and Ningning stage presence is insane
Ning only
@@jisoomarryningkingpleaze3988 your bias is 😐 most of the times. what stage presence are you talking about
They don't have any stage presence what are you even talking about 😭😭 they seriously need to improve
@@regularhuhh5216 she is still the one with the best stage presence
@@seralinaland1188 lmao, r u blind?
karina smiling to winter in 2:23 is literally giving me butterflies😊😂
AESPA makes a big bang that gets everyone's attention when they get on stage.
All the girls did well here especially the dance intro, Karina looks so freaking charismatic and pretty!
They slay the stage and finally new intro
Aespa is getting better every performance, their talent its not a joke, not just that, they have a good attitude too
They're so funny too
*Aespa>>>>>>>>>>>bts*
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 what-
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 it’s almost new year and people like you still exists?
@@Dimyixx Your username is literally everything and that pfp oh God i love it.
Nining bukan main dancer, tapi gerakan dancenya sangat bagus, benar2 sangat powerfull dalam menari. Selain Jihyo Twice, mungkin nining jg pantas disebut main vocal+main dancer. Pround of maknae
Giselle slayed, My fave performance of hers so far.
Winter on the thumbnail omg, she's the definition of perfection!!!
Karina killed the scene as usual, she is a goddess dancer.
*Jhorse cant relate cuz he is useless*
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 better then jennie
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 tf?
No
@@peachyjoonie9413 you can defend j hope without bashing jennie
Winter looks so pretty
anybody else love the low part of winter's voice? like i could fall asleep to that on replay
NINGNING SO PRETTY+POWERFULL+CUTE ..
Ningning she walk like a Queen and I really like her shoes.
Aeri her outfit stands out cute elegant and beautiful.
Winter I always love her soulful voice I swear.
Karina she always take the lead she's the ace of the group. Happy new year Queens:)
The intro is short yet is it so impactful. STAN AESPA FOR BETTER LIFE!
The way Ningning's walk at the beginning 🔥
ningning is always so powerful,and Giselle looked so stunning i couldn't take my eyes off of her
Giselle is really confident and charming here. She know how to *SLAY* a stage with excellent facial expressions, the black fit on her is just *Chef's kiss
G so talented,love her so much,and happy new year 2022 for you
agreeeeeeee☺😍😍😍
Giselle cant dance and are rlly weak in all terms she dont bring anything good in this grp nor Will she ever and Even herself knows that its a simple fact you or her cant change
@@yujiminfan3816 u don't bring anything good in this fandom
@@sriatunmustakim3849 😂 huh its a fact that both of them cant dance & are visual holes
giselle's outfit looks SOOOOO PRETTY FUCKING GOOD ON HER. i feel ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
10대 때부터 내 눈길이 가고 음악까지 챙겨듣게 하는 걸그룹은 항상 sm 소속이었다.. sm은 음악이 가장 좋고 비쥬얼도 제일 눈길이 가 최고야
Omg! They literally devoured this stage with their amazing stage presence and charisma! THE DANCE BREAK (^o^) I m screaming... They *ATE*
karina's aura, giselle's charisma, winter's visual and ningning's stage presence!!! this stage is firreeeeee
I am absolutely STUNNED!! Just started stanning them a few weeks ago but omg??? I'm so in love with Giselles and Karinas outfit. Giselle looks like a beautiful black swan and Karina looks so cool and pretty ♡ Winters vocals are so amazing and ningnings stage presence is no joke, she caught my eyes immediately. Also the intro was fire!! I'm already so in love with them all and I'm happy I got into this fandom haha♡♡
ningning looks so confident and I love it, she's so gorgeous.
I can't get enough of Karina with a ponytail I just can't believe it
Giselle is improving I love her so much, they're more powerful and fierce now. Go aespa love ya! Happy New year everyone.
The Gothic style suit Giselle so well. Gothic Princess.
Winter looks so beautiful and Ningning also
KARINA LOOKS SO CONFIDENT AND SAVAGE. HER STAGE PRESENCE IS REALLY GOOD
Aespa did many things for 2021 guys, next level-savage-NY- awards+festival+dreamscometrue-Smtown- girlsontop.
And still give us performance 😭🙏🏻
Sm girlgroup is on next level
I am here because of Ningning's walk. 😘
Same she ✨ate✨😊
aespa literally beat all the "No stage presence and, No dance break" allegations! Charisma is overflowing + the outfits is just chefs kiss. What a *QUEENS*
Ningning is on fire everytime. She's killing it everytime. The Main Slayer.
Ikr. She's so gorgeous 😍
To be clear the Main slayer is karina💙
@@yujiminfan3816 can you get out of my comment? Thanks. Nobody talks about karina here. (I love her) but this section today is about ning. Bye
@@yujiminfan3816 so to be clear with you…. ningning MAIN SLAYER.
@@alanbalcarcel5850 don't interact with that attention seeker. She just want to throw hate to other members. Prolly their parents doesn't give them enough attention now their looking for some here on the internet.
스엠 제발 올해도 6년주기처럼 일좀 잘하자.. 작년6년주기여도 글쎄 에스파한테 3연속 디싱에 음방 next level 4번 그나마 savage 음반 냈어도 컴백 첫주에 음방 안돌았구 결국 5번.. 애네 신인이야 스엠.. 제발 우리 2009~2011년 때처럼 일 잘했잤아.. 그때처럼 일 잘하자 ㅜㅜ 제발 컴백 첫주에 음방 도는 에스파 보고싶어..ㅜ
얘네 시상식 거의 다 도는데 뭔소리임..?
@@dday100 시상식말고 앨범내고 음방 활동 말한겁니다.. next level때 아티스트 몰아주기 때문에 음방 4번돌고 활동 종료 savage 역시 컴백첫주에 음방 안돌았습니다..
솔직히 2021년 스엠 열일한거 같은데...
에스파 뿐만 아니라 태연, 효연, 키, 카이, 조이 솔로에 레드벨벳, 엔씨티까지...연말에는 smtown 겨울 스페셜 앨범에 연초에는 온라인 무료 콘서트
그리고 사실 음방도 옛날처럼 주구장창 오래 도는것도 요즘 스타일도 아닐 뿐더러 이미지 소비도 심하고 거의 컴백 2주째까지 팬싸다 뭐다 스케쥴 있었던 거 같은데...또 컴백 첫주에 음방 안도는 대신에 스튜디오 춤이라던가 지체 퍼포먼스 영상으로 먼저 공개해줬어서..😓
@@user-dp1fu3oq5m 당연히 열일은 했죠. 제말은.. 제발 매년주기 스엠으로 바뀌게 일해줬음 좋겠다 이거죠.
@@user-dp1fu3oq5m 저도 영원님과 같은생각,,
If only this was live... :(
This Giselle outfit is definitely going to my favorite Gigi's stage outfits list. It accentuated her ice queen vibe SO MUCH. She looks breathtaking.
SHE LOOKS SO GOODDD😭😭
i agree with u... Also in an interview Gigi said that she likes the EMO style. I guess she was happy to wear this black dress.
Giselle looks do pretty with this outfit and the intro is so good love this stage
DID ANYONE ELSE NOTICE Winter, Ningning, and Karina all making eye contact at 2:23 and then start laughing? 🤣 It was so adorable
2:23 hshshsksks poor Karina, she was like 🧍🏻♀️ wait- and Winter and Ningning holding their laughter 💀💀💀😭
I love them
I honestly think this is their best Savage performance so far! good job aespa!
Giselle looks like a total princess she is!!
I have made an aespa fmv on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks
gigi is sooooo cute with this dress!
NINGNING MY QUEEN YOU DROPPED THIS 👑
THEY LOOK SO GORGEOUS! Their outfits, their make up, their hairstyle ... Karina in ponytail is definitely DANGEROUS!
KARINA BEST LEADER BEST DANCER BEST CENTER BEST VISUAL BEST RAPPER ALL ROUNDER EVERYTHING KARINA AURA CHARISMA IS OUT OF WORLD
*Ratmonster best racist and ugliest leader*
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 your username say everything.. yeah, ot2
@@jennieandjisoostanot2isthe716 if you don't like them you can just leave them alone.
Don't hate them😶
Omg NINGNIG i was in shock, she never stops that was amazingi can’t take my eyes for her 🤍🤍🤍 fireeee🔥🔥🔥
무대 보는데 확실히
에스파가 뭔가 다르긴한듯(?) 간지나😍
ㄹㅇ 게임캐릭터들 같음...
와 한국인이다!
@@k-poplover 🇰🇷
NingNing's stage charisma is the best...
They slay this performance. And my girl Karina really shine in the intro!! 🔥🔥
Karina visuals is amazing for just a second she looked like a 3d anime character i had to check again 😂😂 Ningning vocals and her little strut at the beginning she was amazing
Giselle's outfit is so 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤