I’m not aware of there being one, if anyone else does insha’Allah reply to this comment. But JazakAllah Khair for bringing this to my attention, I didn’t know Shaykh Uthaymeen رحمه الله wrote a refutation on socialism. I’ll give it a read insha’Allah
@@thesalafislav Definitions for political ideologies will differ between people, since they’re man made and not scriptural there’s no structural outline, so naturally people will have different interpretations. That doesn’t make the Shaykh’s interpretation inaccurate. But hopefully the point of the video wasn’t missed. The Shaykh is exposing the deficiency of this ideology and how eventually it leads to an unstable society, regardless of small details the Shaykh may have simplified/overlooked.
@FawaidAbuIyaadI think if the sheikh was trying to go based off a Marxist Leninist approach of socialism, then I’d say it could be inaccurate; the sheikh mentions the government’s responsibility to feed and clothe the people which is an inaccurate description of socialism. If you have an email ya akhi, we could discuss this further if you’d like
@@kevenlopez2782it’s not appropriate for me to discuss these topics as I’m not well versed in politics myself. If you want more clarification I’d recommend reading the article and other articles on the website in the description. Alternatively you can visit the Shaykh and ask him personally in his classes in Middlesbrough and Bradford. BarakAllahu feek
Can I have a link to the full lecture, please?
@@ummabdurahman9254 it’s in the description at the bottom, BarakAllahu feek
Is there a translation of sheikh al-Uthaymeen's book "Evidence of the invalidity of Socialism"?
I’m not aware of there being one, if anyone else does insha’Allah reply to this comment.
But JazakAllah Khair for bringing this to my attention, I didn’t know Shaykh Uthaymeen رحمه الله wrote a refutation on socialism. I’ll give it a read insha’Allah
@FawaidAbuIyaad He/you say it in the audio if this video, that's how I looked it up. Barak Allahu feekum.
@ You’re right ‘afwan akhi I didn’t catch that, may Allah preserve you
@FawaidAbuIyaad Wa iyyak.
There were some inaccuracies regarding socialist ideology, but this video was beneficial nonetheless.
جزاكم الله خيرا
What inaccuracies?
@@thesalafislav Definitions for political ideologies will differ between people, since they’re man made and not scriptural there’s no structural outline, so naturally people will have different interpretations. That doesn’t make the Shaykh’s interpretation inaccurate.
But hopefully the point of the video wasn’t missed. The Shaykh is exposing the deficiency of this ideology and how eventually it leads to an unstable society, regardless of small details the Shaykh may have simplified/overlooked.
@FawaidAbuIyaadI think if the sheikh was trying to go based off a Marxist Leninist approach of socialism, then I’d say it could be inaccurate; the sheikh mentions the government’s responsibility to feed and clothe the people which is an inaccurate description of socialism. If you have an email ya akhi, we could discuss this further if you’d like
@@kevenlopez2782it’s not appropriate for me to discuss these topics as I’m not well versed in politics myself. If you want more clarification I’d recommend reading the article and other articles on the website in the description. Alternatively you can visit the Shaykh and ask him personally in his classes in Middlesbrough and Bradford. BarakAllahu feek
@FawaidAbuIyaad jazakallah khair akhi