EVERY Doctor Who Season Ranked! (Tier List, 1963 - 2023)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มี.ค. 2024
- This is a video I've been wanting to make for so many years, and on the verge of Season 1 of the brand new Who's debut, I thought it'd be the perfect time to Tier rank every single season of the show since 1963!
-----
Take a peek at my Threads:
www.threads.net/@lewis_palmer...
Give my Instagram a gander:
/ lewis_palme. .
Mock my TikTok:
/ gargantuanapple
Feast your eyes on my Letterboxd (or else) :
letterboxd.com/GargantuanApple/
#DoctorWho #TierList #Ranking - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![อยู่ได้แล้ว - LIPTA feat. Mirrr [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-9-hpntNym4/mqdefault.jpg)
Hope everyones enjoys!
This was recorded back in December, hence the decorations haha
More commentaries coming very soon now!
You don’t like Evil of the Daleks 😳
Oh dear oh dear. You were doing so well!
Jokes aside. Loved the way you’ve done the ranking. It’s really nice, flows and displaying the stories per season is a nice touch.
Terrific ranking 😁
Hehe, I know, bad fan😅
Thanks so much, glad you enjoyed!!
Cant imagine what an absolute nightmare it was putting this video together! 😅
Haha, yeah it kind of wrecked me, I didn’t expect it to, but there’s a reason I shot it in December and it’s only now gone up😂
Now this is a fun way to spend an hour! I agree with many choices and disagree with many as well, as it should be, lol. I prefer season 4 to season 5 myself, and how can you not like Evil of the Daleks?!!! Monster of Peladon does a really good job with developing Sarah Jane though, I always give it that. Revenge of the cybermen is so underrated, though it does have a massive plot hole that holds it back. Season 13 is just so so so GOOD, love it. Planet of evil does have that amazing jungle set, it's really impressive. Season 18 is so unique. Nice to see someone else that appreciates season 24. I also love the McCoy era! Series 3 is my favorite of the modern series and one of my favorites over all, nice to see you are so fond of it as well!
Yes, as it should be! Haha
Yeah the Evil thing is definitely proving to be my most controversial take 😅
Yeahhhh I do get a bit tired of always seeing S24 at the bottom of lists, like I say, ever since the Blu-ray came out I completely fell for what it was doing, and it’s a miracle it even exists given how hurried it all was!
This is EPIC Lewis! I feel like this has been in the making for a long time. We've been watching the 3rd Doctor recently and it is all still a favourite, currently going through S11. I'm not a Tom B. fan as you know lol, so we'll see how I go at watching some of 4 lol. I'm not even sure I've seen it all, at least not for years. As a 5 fan, so glad to hear you like Black Orchid too! I don't know why people slate it, I have a real soft spot for it. I agree that they really found his Doctor in S21. The 6th Doctor was never given a proper chance. No matter how bad it gets, Colin is always acting his socks off and honestly he single-handedly saves it for me.
Hehe, thanks very much! Yeah I love the whole vibe of the Pertwee era, it’s very very cosy.
Haha that’s fair! 4 probably wouldn’t make my top 5 doctors but it’s almost impossible not to get swept up in how iconic he is. And yes, Black Orchid is wicked, I love it!
I completely agree, Colin’s never the issue in his era and I love Sixie, could watch him for ages, without him that period of the show would be really tough.
@@TheGargantuanAppleHMPBTS Yes I wish we had gotten more of Sixie, I forget how short-lived he is too. He kept the show alive so he's basically a hero of the show in my eyes.
Great video! It was really fun to rank along with you and see how our thoughts compared. For my ranking, I quickly decided to pay less attention to what I feel is objectively better / worse and paid more attention to how fond I was of each series as a whole, because I find there is a difference between what you think is stronger vs what is your favourite. I have listed classic seasons as SE and Nuwho series as SR. I decided to include all specials within their prior season aside from the 60th which I haven't ranked (but would probably land somewhere in B-tier):
S - SR1, SE2, SE7, SE6, SR4, SR3, SE26
A - SE25, SE10, SR5, SE1, SE16, SE14, SE13, SE5
B - SE12, SE9, SE8, SR6, SR2, SE4, SE11
C - SR10, SE3, SE22, SE23, SE20
D - SE21, SR8 SE18, SE19, SE17, SR9, SR11
F - SR7, SE15, SR 13, SE24, SR12
Thanks for watching and sharing your own list! I agree with you, I think it’s always better to go by what you enjoy rather than objectivity, that’s definitely true of my one, as is clear by the fact S24 is so high haha! Nice to see SE2 so high, always love to see Hartnell getting some love!
@TheGargantuanAppleHMPBTS 😊 yeah I am immensely fond of season 2 as when I decided to marathon the whole show, it was the season that made me fall head over heels for classic who
17:55 it’s the ‘bit racist’ 🤣🤣
A lot there I agree with. I think the one I disagree with you on most is Series 9 (Capaldi), I like Magician’s Apprentice/Witch’s Familiar, I think Under the Lake/Before the Flood and Invasion/Inversion are great, Face the Raven too. Heaven Sent is my favourite episode of Doctor Who full stop, and although I don’t really like the fact Clara gets her own TARDIS in Hell Bent, up to that point I do actually really enjoy the episode and where it takes her and the Doctor’s characters. Felt like the natural conclusion to the Clara becoming the Doctor plotline. All that said I can’t rewatch Sleep No More, it’s not for me, and The Girl Who Died/Woman Who Lived is a dire pair of episodes.
Thanks for watching!
Yeah like I said I definitely appreciate S9 much more now and I can see myself revisiting it a lot more now compared to when it aired. It’s a taste thing really, I do agree about Woman Who Lived though, it’s probably in the bottom 10 of all time for me…
You don't like Evil of the Daleks?
Very good, very good! I was worried that we wouldn't agree on anything!
Since I'm copying someone else's comment, I will agree with them on how good the ranking structure was. The music especially was very appreciated.
Haha!
Thanks bud, really appreciate it!
Other than hugely over rating the McCoy years, not a bad list at all. Didn’t watch the ranking of the rebooted series so can’t comment.
Dude, I love the Martha era too! So much. Always underrated. And the Doctor Donna is superb! The Capaldi era is not good for kids at all. My nephews don't even watch him (they are 8+12). This is why I love the Chibnall era as he removed pretentiousness and brought it back to a proper family show, and kids love Jodi. It's such a shame that S13 suffered from the pandemic - that must've been a nightmare behind the scenes. I do wish he had another year. This was a great marathon! I really enjoyed your vid!
I do agree, like I say here, I’ve found a new appreciation for the Capaldi era and overall I’d say I like it, but I do think, as much as people deny it, there’s a reason a lot of families tuned out during that period, it’s very very pretentious, and that’s why I think S11 was *such* a breath of fresh air when it aired.
Thanks for watching!!!
@@TheGargantuanAppleHMPBTS Yea I do love Capaldi as the Doctor though, I must say, even though his character was a bit all-over-the-place (not his fault of course). I agree with you that Bill certainly helped that era a lot. Great job on the vid sir!
ngl the actress for martha was fine but catherine tate just worked so much better with david.
The disrespect on Capaldi, calling series 4 overrated - placing the McCoy era so highly. This one just Isn't it for me. :(
Decent video though, gg for putting it all together.