192: Story of Ifk: Which Prophet's Wife is Exonerated in Surah Nur? | Our Prophet

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ม.ค. 2025

ความคิดเห็น • 120

  • @Thaqlain
    @Thaqlain  2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S:
    I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt).
    II) Subscribe: Connect with us on TH-cam & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1
    III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

  • @trailblazer7108
    @trailblazer7108 2 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    Syed Ammar Nakshawani’s analysis of this event is exceptional. A sunni I know converted as a result.

    • @Zulfiqar32
      @Zulfiqar32 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Salaam do you have a link?

    • @trailblazer7108
      @trailblazer7108 ปีที่แล้ว +6

      @@Zulfiqar32 can’t post links here. Just search in TH-cam, “Nakshawani ifk” it will come up.

  • @adamnouri23
    @adamnouri23 2 ปีที่แล้ว +18

    I am an ex sunni maliki Muslim and I strongly believe in the prophet's statement saying : " لا تدع عائشة عداوتنا نحن أهل البيت " - 'Aisha would never let go our enmity , we Ahlilbayt -
    So , it is definitely absurd , non sense , not recommended ,, actually forbidden to ask Allah to be pleased with someone who killed the prophet of Islam ; 'Aisha.

  • @editorowl
    @editorowl 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +15

    I was a staunch salafi, worked for a duat as well. Converted to the real islam just recently. It is truly shocking how the truth is twisted by the sunnis. Wallahi I feel blessed to be gifted with this

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

      Welcome to the path of divinely appointed leaders. Keep us in your prayers 🙂 🤲

    • @Khann12341
      @Khann12341 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      What is your name😂

  • @NP0451
    @NP0451 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Thanks for enlightening us. May Allah bless you for all your efforts.

  • @MM-rb6lu
    @MM-rb6lu 2 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Shaykh Baqir Qazwini like other respected Shia Ulama - Shaykh Yasir AL Habib FADAK TV London, Shaykh Hasan Yari California, Shaykh Ahmad Salman Tunisia, Shaykh Abdul Jabbar AL Maqdisi Paris, Dr Ammar Nakswani is extremely academic and well mannered in his approach and this is required by all rational Quranic Muslims. We are ONE UMMAH of our beloved Rasulullah and Ahlul Bait ❤️

  • @HadithOfThaqlain
    @HadithOfThaqlain 2 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I wonder where that "Sushi" comment guy is now, have fun defending Aisha after seeing this video.
    I ask Allah to send his blessings on the Prophet peace be upon him and his purified and holy progeny, and curse be upon their enemies.

    • @MM-rb6lu
      @MM-rb6lu 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      The "sushi guy" is a Muslim and is entitled to his opinions like anyone else. Let us NOT descend to gutter thinking. We are ONE UMMAH of our beloved Rasulullah...!!!

    • @HadithOfThaqlain
      @HadithOfThaqlain 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@MM-rb6lu Read the following hadiths, especially since these are from Sunni sources and then understand why a negative view is held towards Aisha:
      Imam Ali Telling Rasulallah To Divorce Aisha:
      bukhari:4750
      bukhari:4141
      bukhari:2661
      muslim:2770a
      Aisha Was A Test:
      bukhari:7100
      bukhari:3772
      Aisha’s House is where Satan's head would come out:
      bukhari:3104
      Aisha & Hafsa Against Rasulallah:
      bukhari:4915
      bukhari:4914
      bukhari:4913
      bukhari:4916
      muslim:1479b
      muslim:1479d
      muslim:1479e
      ahmad:222
      ahmad:339
      Umar Talking Trash About Aisha:
      muslim:1479b
      ahmad:222
      bukhari:5843
      muslim:1479e
      muslim:1479a
      Aisha Hitting Rasulallah:
      nasai:3955
      ibnmajah:2334
      Aisha Has A Devil with her:
      nasai:3960
      Do Not Be Misled By Aisha:
      bukhari:5218
      bukhari:4913
      muslim:1479a
      muslim:1479b
      muslim:1479e
      ahmad:222
      Prophet telling aisha to breastfeed a man (sahih hadith)
      muslim:1453a
      abudawud:2061
      Wives Differed With Aisha On Breastfeeding:
      ibnmajah:1947
      Aisha Doesn’t Like Mentioning Imam Ali:
      bukhari:665
      tirmidhi:3657
      ibnmajah:1235
      muslim:418b
      muslim:418c
      Abu Bakr Scolding Aisha:
      muslim:367a
      abudawud:320
      Aisha Spying On Rasulallah:
      muslim:974b
      nasai:3964
      nasai:3963
      Aisha Was Bewitched:
      adab:162
      Aisha used to hate praying with hands on the flank
      bukhari:3458
      Aisha Desired Abu Bakr To Be Caliph:
      muslim:418d
      muslim:418e
      Aisha’s Lies/Obscenity:
      mishkat:3278
      muslim:1474b
      muslim:1474a
      bukhari:6691
      bukhari:5268
      nasai:3958
      Aisha Beating Children:
      adab:142
      Rasulallah Doesn’t Trust Aisha (incident of ifk):
      muslim:2770a
      bukhari:4141
      Rasulallah Anxious With Aisha:
      bukhari:3774
      Aisha Sharing Others Private Life:
      bukhari:5825
      Aisha’s Blood Play:
      bukhari:312
      ibnmajah:652
      abudawud:364
      muslim:293b
      bukhari:309
      Aisha Compared To Bone Broth:
      bukhari:3769
      bukhari:3770
      tirmidhi:3887
      bukhari:3411
      Abu Bakr Hitting Aisha:
      bukhari:6845
      bukhari:6844
      bukhari:4608
      muslim:1478
      Aisha/Women Compared To Animals:
      muslim:512d
      bukhari:511
      bukhari:514
      bukhari:519
      ibnmajah:950
      tirmidhi:338
      ibnmajah:951
      ibnmajah:952
      ibnmajah:953
      Aisha’s suspicion:
      bukhari:299
      bukhari:297
      muslim:290
      ibnmajah:538
      muslim:288a
      abudawud:371
      muslim:1453d
      tirmidhi:116
      bukhari:4450
      bukhari:302
      bukhari:261
      abudawud:2061
      bukhari:2647
      mishkat:546
      muslim:350
      tirmidhi:728
      muslim:293b
      bukhari:5191
      ibnmajah:1943
      muslim:1453e
      muslim:301
      muslim:288b
      muslim:288c
      muslim:291a
      muslim:293a
      muslim:294
      muslim:321d
      tirmidhi:116
      bukhari:303
      muslim:1449a
      muslim:1453a
      muslim:1453b
      muslim:1454
      muslim:1453c
      muslim:1455a
      ibnmajah:1945
      ibnmajah:608
      tirmidhi:132
      ibnmajah:539
      ibnmajah:538
      ibnmajah:537
      ibnmajah:536
      muslim:301
      bukhari:5102
      Aisha’s Obscenity/Disrespect:
      nasai:3957
      mishkat:3278
      muslim:1464a
      tirmidhi:3691
      muslim:1474b
      bukhari:3818
      muslim:2435d
      bukhari:3821
      muslim:2435b
      riyadussalihin:344
      muslim:1479a
      bukhari:5843
      bukhari:2468
      bukhari:6691
      bukhari:5268
      nasai:3955
      ibnmajah:2334
      nasai:3956
      abudawud:3567
      nasai:3958
      nasai:3959
      tirmidhi:2502
      muslim:2437
      tirmidhi:1359
      bukhari:513
      bukhari:519
      bukhari:3816
      bukhari:3817
      ahmad:772
      bukhari:4913
      bukhari:4912
      bukhari:4915
      bukhari:4916
      muslim:1479b
      muslim:1479d
      muslim:1479e
      ahmad:222
      ahmad:339
      muslim:314b
      muslim:310
      tirmidhi:3875
      tirmidhi:3876
      muslim:2165c
      muslim:2165a
      muslim:2165d
      bukhari:7484
      bukhari:382
      bukhari:383
      bukhari:384
      bukhari:6004
      muslim:1462
      bukhari:515
      bukhari:514
      bukhari:511
      bukhari:5229
      bukhari:5267
      abudawud:4875
      nasai:3421
      Aisha Using Excuses For Laziness:
      muslim:298a
      muslim:298b
      muslim:299
      tirmidhi:134

    • @HadithOfThaqlain
      @HadithOfThaqlain 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@8heavyhchamp8 Nobody is asking you to believe everything you see or hear, but when you have overwhelming evidence that SOME of the "companions" and wives of the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, weren't that great as Sunnis claim, you have to take a clear stance against them.
      In this video, it becomes even more clear the type of person Aisha was, so it becomes necessary to condemn her for the actions committed by her throughout her life against the Prophets' family, alayhisalam.

    • @HadithOfThaqlain
      @HadithOfThaqlain 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@8heavyhchamp8 She literally went to war with Imam Ali alayhisalam, have you forgotten the Battle of Jamal? He was the Imam of her time and the Khalifa, thousands of people died because of her actions. What more proof do you want?
      I gave a huge list of Sunni hadiths in a prior reply in this thread, read through them and then it becomes clear why she should be condemned, the only respect that can be given was that she was the wife of the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, but that is due to the respect given to the Prophet, not because of her own status.

    • @HadithOfThaqlain
      @HadithOfThaqlain 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@8heavyhchamp8 "Fall"? Brother, the Sunni hadiths are confirming the state of Aisha, the state which Shias mention against her, we are using Sunni hadiths to counter the claims of Aishas superiority over other wives since it is the Sunnis themselves holding her to such a high regard, when their own books say otherwise.
      No need to discuss any further, I have given you solid evidence, you can believe whatever you want.
      My apologies if I have offended you in any way, may Allah guide and bless the both of us.

  • @trailblazer7108
    @trailblazer7108 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    What is the reference in sahih Muslim for the story about Juray?

  • @nikoutoajaisai6310
    @nikoutoajaisai6310 2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Subhanallah waw

  • @ahmedtijanitanko2534
    @ahmedtijanitanko2534 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    How true is this about Maria this is the first time I am hearing this

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  5 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      Sadly, a lot of the things mentioned with Sunni books are hidden in order to exonerate some other personalities.

  • @tameemansari707
    @tameemansari707 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Best analysis, Sunni Aalims claim this verse about sanctity of Aisha, it was not so, sir clarified the truth.

  • @fazlulhaque3057
    @fazlulhaque3057 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    When ifk happened it was previous position. After that incidence the Quranic verse revealed. Obviously, this law should be applicable next time. So that, prophet ( pbuh ) didn't punished . I think so.
    Allah knows best.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      This can be a very logical argument. Allah warned through this incident of severe punishment if such an accusation is repeated.

    • @fazlulhaque3057
      @fazlulhaque3057 2 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      @@Thaqlain
      Assalamualikum
      I am from Bangladesh. English is not my first language. I am sunni backgrounded. After knowing about bag e fadak and some companions dishonored prophet pbuh at the time of his deathbed I became to learn about ahlal byte ( A.S ) . Now I want to follow them. But, I don't know any shia brother. Once I went Mohammadpur mosque in Dhaka. They don't give permission me to enter.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Alaykum Salaam. There is a reasonable Shia population in Dhaka. We will suggest you to reach out to a scholar instead of a mosque :)

    • @fazlulhaque3057
      @fazlulhaque3057 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@Thaqlain
      I don't know any scholar. I follow urdu and English lecture in you tube

  • @ibm630
    @ibm630 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Sir, Wasn't Hassan ibn Thabit, who was accused of spreading false rumors about Aisha bint Abu Bakr, the spouse of Sirin who was the sister of Maria al-Qibtiyyah?

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Please share the reference so we can discuss this version with Sayed.

    • @ibm630
      @ibm630 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​In ep 190 sir mentioned it at 9 min 39 sec

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      The entire Ifq story, as we have examined is this episode, has several loopholes. However, yes Hassan was the husband of Maria's sister.

  • @habibanathani3747
    @habibanathani3747 ปีที่แล้ว

    When was bibi Fatima Zehra S.A born before Ibrahim or after

  • @matloobhayat468
    @matloobhayat468 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Why didn't the Prophet marry Maria?

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  5 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Maria was very much a wife :)
      We have covered this topic in detail in another episode.

    • @mustafahusayn6104
      @mustafahusayn6104 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Narrated by Abdullah al zubairi : noble prophet married maria daughter of shamun , this is the same maria sent by mauqaqis ruler of alexendria to prophet ( sahih al mustadrak al hakim vol 4 pg 36 ) , those who made efforts by fabrications to show her as a concubine were so jealous of her bcz she was non arab and only wife who bore Prophets child after sayeda khadija ( s . a ) however most of sunni historians like ibn arabi , al nahwavi , ibn kathir did accepted that she was wife

  • @saidkhan5086
    @saidkhan5086 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Sunni inconsistencies made me Shi'a follower

  • @abdirahmaanmohamed1582
    @abdirahmaanmohamed1582 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Allah declared the innocence of Aisha R.A in Surah Nur but The Hypocrites of Ahlul bayt Slander her May the wrath of Allah be upon the Hater of Aisha R.A Mother of the Believers.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  ปีที่แล้ว

      And where is the slander here?

    • @abdirahmaanmohamed1582
      @abdirahmaanmohamed1582 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Thaqlain The Rafidah Curse her and Slander her Because she didn't agree with Ali one's upon time.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      May Allah protect us from slandering someone.
      By the way, Surah Nur was revealed in honour of Mariya al-Qibtiyya. We have covered it in detail in this series 🙂

    • @abdirahmaanmohamed1582
      @abdirahmaanmohamed1582 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@Thaqlain Absolutely not It Was Aisha R.A.
      Bring your Evidence from the Sunnah.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  ปีที่แล้ว

      We have explored it here:
      th-cam.com/video/axkNXMUd2zM/w-d-xo.html

  • @qasimabukar7488
    @qasimabukar7488 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Shia they so obsessed with Aisha (RA)

  • @Cade-Cade
    @Cade-Cade 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Subhana Allah people who put down Aisha and knowing she was the prophet wife are literally playing with fire. For the heresy they speak about will be asked at judgment day.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

      And what about those who put down the Prophet's wife Mariya?

    • @zaraibragim2690
      @zaraibragim2690 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      So what about the wife of Lut as ? Quran what saying about her? Also what Quran saying about aisha and hafsa ?

    • @user-eh2pv4sc7h
      @user-eh2pv4sc7h 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      WELL ALLAH PUTS HER DOWN IN THE QURAN. SHE IS THE WIFE MENTIONED IN THE SURAH OF THE DISOBEDIENT HOUSEWIVES.

    • @saidkhan5086
      @saidkhan5086 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Defend her academically not base on your feelings

  • @samyhannah9563
    @samyhannah9563 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    we really need microphones for the audience questions.

    • @Al-Madhloom
      @Al-Madhloom 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Definitely agree, I've been saying this since day one...either a microphone for the classroom or Sayyed should repeat their questions so that we know what is going on, inshaAllah.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  2 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      We have shared this concern with Sayed. InshaAllah the later recorded sessions will have this covered :)

    • @Al-Madhloom
      @Al-Madhloom 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@Thaqlain 🙌🏽 💚

  • @rehanalvi4009
    @rehanalvi4009 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Didn't Hazrat Muhammad SAW know about this? You are trying to prove that He SAW didn't know about whats to happen and still kept her as her wife???? STOP SPREADING HATE U FOLLOWER OF SHAYTAAN

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      We have discussed this already in detail in Episode 205

    • @user-eh2pv4sc7h
      @user-eh2pv4sc7h 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ISN'T THAT YOU FOLLOWER OF SHAITAAN.

  • @wissamalhashemi5548
    @wissamalhashemi5548 ปีที่แล้ว

    If Aisha was an unbeliever, how could the Prophet marry her when marrying Kafirs is haram?

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  ปีที่แล้ว

      Where did we say Ayesha was an unbeliever?

    • @wissamalhashemi5548
      @wissamalhashemi5548 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Thaqlain I'll preface this by saying that I'm neither a sunni or shia, I'm just trying to learn more about both perspectives. Whilst doing so, I came across a handful of your videos which I thought were interesting. The logic used in your presentation and arguments were sound, but it left me with the above question. In your earlier videos that I watched, you never explicitly called Ayesha an unbeliever, but it was implied so by bringing up multiple examples of instances where the Prophet SAW dismissed Ayesha. Such as when you brought the example of how when Umar visitted the Prophet, the Prophet asked Ayesha to bring them food repeatedly, and she swore in the end that they had no food to serve. Umar then told thr Prophet that a believing woman wouldn't swear by Allah and lie, and in response the Prophet smiled and said "Who told you she's a believing woman?" - this is one of the examples you've brought up in past videos of instances where it's implied that Ayesha was an unbeliever. I recall 2-3 more out of the 4 videos I watched, but I think my response so far is enough.
      Again, I'm not sunni nor shia, I'm not trying to critisize you, but I'm trying to understand and learn. With the logic you've used in the past of how the Prophet can't do anything that goes against the Quran, how then can you bring up examples of instances where the state of Ayesha's belief was lowered to the point where she's made out to be a kafir by implication, if the Quran says marrying a kafir is haram and the prophet can't do anything against the Quran?

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      There are two stages of belief: Islam and Iman. The one who announces Tawheed and Prophethood has accepted Islam and hence is a Muslim. In most circumstances, when the term unbeliever is presented, it means in the sense of Iman. The only person for whom Takfir is allowed is Nasibi, the one who explicitly displays hatred for Ahlulbayt of the Prophet. Because Ayesha never explicitly showed enmity to Ahlulbayt during the Prophet's life, she remained a Muslim and, hence, in the Nikah of the Prophet. After the Prophet, however, we have narrations that the Prophet gave the fate of his wives to Imam Ali, and Imam Ali did make some decisions in this regard. Sayed has discussed that in episode 197 (th-cam.com/video/2Iw2bls6ReE/w-d-xo.html)
      Having said that, the purpose of this entire discussion, as mentioned by Sayed, is to present whether Ayesha is a credible source of Sunnah.

    • @user-eh2pv4sc7h
      @user-eh2pv4sc7h 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      WAKE UP! SHE WAS A TEST FOR RASOOLLLAH.

    • @user-eh2pv4sc7h
      @user-eh2pv4sc7h 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@Thaqlainwell explained.

  • @AKIB1991LASKAR
    @AKIB1991LASKAR 2 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    It's clearly Aisha (RA) brother....we don't understand why you people have this rage against Aisha(RA)....our beloved prophet expressed great love for her so many times....surely prophet is not fool that he expresses love to some vengeful women....surely we don't hate Ali (RA) contrary to that we love him so much....so please stop this divide it's harmful for ummah.

    • @ulrikeburha4626
      @ulrikeburha4626 2 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Please read "all" your own Hadith about and from Aisha and you understand

    • @AKIB1991LASKAR
      @AKIB1991LASKAR 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@ulrikeburha4626 I do understand and read most of the hadiths....please we don't divide or hate progeny of our beloved prophet..and yes Aisha (RA) never taught to hate ...nor we Sunnis hate Shias ...so please don't hate each other for petty reasons which clearly was a political power struggle..we both beleive in same Allah and his rasool and same deen...stop hating each other... Prophet SAS said in his lifetime that this would happen and warned us about new inventions in religion and taught us to be steadfast in our deen and not to divide the Ummah..Peace

    • @mimimiraj7351
      @mimimiraj7351 2 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Salaam.
      First, it is a tremendous blessing that you are exploring a more inclusive understanding by listening.
      Think about this...our Prophet,swas, expressed great Love for Mankind, as He,swas, is the Mercy to Mankind. Thus, His,swas, expression of love for his wives, is within the parameters of to be expected.

    • @Thaqlain
      @Thaqlain  2 ปีที่แล้ว +13

      Salaam Alaykum. Thanks for dropping by. Won't we be dividing the Ummah if we give an honour given by Allah to Maria al-Qibtiyya to some other wife just because she claims that it is in her honour? We have nothing against Ayesha but as Muslims we cannot be unjust to other "Mothers of the Believers" 🙂

    • @ulrikeburha4626
      @ulrikeburha4626 2 ปีที่แล้ว +8

      @@AKIB1991LASKAR The shia dont hate the sunnis, they only explain the mistakes from some companions or wifes, so you can understand the truth.

  • @qasimabukar7488
    @qasimabukar7488 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    this man he's so obsessed with Aisha (RA).

  • @SwordofAllah1234
    @SwordofAllah1234 ปีที่แล้ว

    The way you say thing like you are prophet of Allah😁

    • @ahmedalwakil6696
      @ahmedalwakil6696 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ​@Rafida Shia Muslim lineage doesn't matter Islam came to destroy notions like that