Sir some scholars are saying that his claims are not true. And have asked to have a debate with the Indian scholars. Please convey this message to the claimer. (Invitation for debate is from Andra Vidwat Parishad under the guidance of HH Sri Sri Govindanand Saraswatiji). Please have a debate with them.
Sad that he had to go to cambridge and work this thesis instead of dping this at home. Shows how much we lack the infrastructure and funding of researches in India to fuel the bright untapped minds of Indians. Extremely proud of him no doubt.
Scholars have confirmed that there was no 'puzzle' to begin with and nothing has actually been solved. Rishi's solution can best be thought of as an alternative model/view of the Ashtadhayayi. This is because the right-hand rule that he is proposing would have to make use of the original sutra that he is contesting in the first place, thereby negating the point of this new 'discovery'.
Peer reviewer already said he misunderstands old rules and his rules only working in few words so i think it's nonsense to do this type of publicity and also some sanskrit scholar says there is no puzzle he just creates his own rules understand better likes others did in past ..
His thesis has lot of flaws and ill conceived interpretations pointed out by many experts,why this student going overboard claiming fake 2500 year old puzzle solved claim everywhere?.
At Cambridge ?? I would love to know what the esteemed teachers of ashtadhyayi in India feel about it.. Still better a joint interview of them so students of Sanskrit can learn from the discussion
India's oldest language in north india is bhojpuri, which is an inheritor of brahmi, pali of Asoka. And Tamil is original language of south India. Gond language is roots of several languages in India. Sanskrit apoears only after second century BC. Sanskrit was a code language of male priest class. You cannot call it language as such, it's a chants for invoking veda gods. Hence its use was limited to very small group of people. "Sanskritization" is adaption of diction of Sanskrit into colloquial languages.Example, sanskritised version of original Asoka is ashoka. The Buddhist king of Japan names his city osaka (Japanese pronounciation of Asoka ) by Asoka s name. There is no sho its so. River does not flow from ocean to mountain top, it flows from mountain top to the ocean Please stop giving godly status to Sanskrit. Language evolves from ordinary people. Not from top of the pyramid. Top of the pyramid appropriate s, steal and claim ownership
No, it was from 1200 BCE and 1700 BCE. The rigveda dates to that time. Tamil inscriptions were first found in the 2nd century BCE. I don't know about bhojpuri. And sanskrit was spoken amongst the ordinary people in both north and south India, since the discovery of the mittani kingdom scriptures in syria and India. Learn history of languages before saying some nonsense. Sanskrit is after all the mother of all languages
Maybe Sanskrit is India's one of the oldest Languages alongside Pali, Old Tamil or other scripts, but it by no chance defines modern India. U cherish a culture, it's heritage and it's antiquity by other methods, not by pushing it to mainstream which will make People feel that they are being enforced to feel proud of Sanskritam. U never push or force traditional culture. It comes naturally for a person to feel to preserve and showcase it. Never push traditionalism...
No one expects Xtain like you to learn and speak Sanskrit. It's an internal matter of Hindus. Sanskrit literature has came from all over India unlike other present languages.
Sir some scholars are saying that his claims are not true. And have asked to have a debate with the Indian scholars. Please convey this message to the claimer. (Invitation for debate is from Andra Vidwat Parishad under the guidance of HH Sri Sri Govindanand Saraswatiji). Please have a debate with them.
Sad that he had to go to cambridge and work this thesis instead of dping this at home. Shows how much we lack the infrastructure and funding of researches in India to fuel the bright untapped minds of Indians. Extremely proud of him no doubt.
Hey Pakistani...Indian is far better than Pakistan....
@@soumyadipdey6531 and who said otherwise?? Are you even understanding what i've written?
Scholars have confirmed that there was no 'puzzle' to begin with and nothing has actually been solved. Rishi's solution can best be thought of as an alternative model/view of the Ashtadhayayi. This is because the right-hand rule that he is proposing would have to make use of the original sutra that he is contesting in the first place, thereby negating the point of this new 'discovery'.
Exactly my thoughts...
His paper is still not peer reviewed.. how can such claims be made
Peer reviewer already said he misunderstands old rules and his rules only working in few words so i think it's nonsense to do this type of publicity and also some sanskrit scholar says there is no puzzle he just creates his own rules understand better likes others did in past ..
Still his paper should be verified under scholars , not done yet .
Thank you for moving humanity one more step forward 👍
Great explanation Rishi. Best wishes for your future projects 😊👍🏼
Inspirational.
His thesis has lot of flaws and ill conceived interpretations pointed out by many experts,why this student going overboard claiming fake 2500 year old puzzle solved claim everywhere?.
Where did you read his thesis??
Where did you read his thesis??
At Cambridge ??
I would love to know what the esteemed teachers of ashtadhyayi in India feel about it..
Still better a joint interview of them so students of Sanskrit can learn from the discussion
The quint❤️Thank you for creating this lovely content । Lv ur vdo । Lv the way u represent this vdo❤️❤️❤️
Excellent 👌👌👌🙏🙏🙏🙏
You have to come India and do shashtrarth with aadaraniya pushpa ji dixit. Atul raj popat
What was the answer?
India's oldest language in north india is bhojpuri, which is an inheritor of brahmi, pali of Asoka. And Tamil is original language of south India. Gond language is roots of several languages in India.
Sanskrit apoears only after second century BC. Sanskrit was a code language of male priest class. You cannot call it language as such, it's a chants for invoking veda gods. Hence its use was limited to very small group of people. "Sanskritization" is adaption of diction of Sanskrit into colloquial languages.Example, sanskritised version of original Asoka is ashoka. The Buddhist king of Japan names his city osaka (Japanese pronounciation of Asoka ) by Asoka s name. There is no sho its so. River does not flow from ocean to mountain top, it flows from mountain top to the ocean
Please stop giving godly status to Sanskrit. Language evolves from ordinary people. Not from top of the pyramid. Top of the pyramid appropriate s, steal and claim ownership
Typical dravidian nonsensé
No, it was from 1200 BCE and 1700 BCE. The rigveda dates to that time. Tamil inscriptions were first found in the 2nd century BCE. I don't know about bhojpuri. And sanskrit was spoken amongst the ordinary people in both north and south India, since the discovery of the mittani kingdom scriptures in syria and India. Learn history of languages before saying some nonsense. Sanskrit is after all the mother of all languages
Exactly....
Pushing this Sanskrit language and promoting it is practically of no use...
We Hindus will give importance to it, the way muslim give importance to Arabic. You non-hindus can do whatever you want.
@@jonathanalvinrays..7070 For you it's no use, for others it is
What's the need for this now??
Maybe Sanskrit is India's one of the oldest Languages alongside Pali, Old Tamil or other scripts, but it by no chance defines modern India. U cherish a culture, it's heritage and it's antiquity by other methods, not by pushing it to mainstream which will make People feel that they are being enforced to feel proud of Sanskritam.
U never push or force traditional culture. It comes naturally for a person to feel to preserve and showcase it.
Never push traditionalism...
No one expects Xtain like you to learn and speak Sanskrit. It's an internal matter of Hindus. Sanskrit literature has came from all over India unlike other present languages.
Typical rice bag