Dark S3E8-Claudia tells Adam the real Origin | Part 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- Watch Dark, Only on Netflix: www.netflix.co...
Dark on IMDB: www.imdb.com/t...
In 2019, Jonas emerges from the cave into a different but not unfamiliar world: The town of Winden
reeling from the recent disappearance of a young boy
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976,
allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment,
news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use
permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor
of fair use.
#dark #darkseason3 #darknetflix
Claudia taking control of her own fate , seeing the bigger picture and knowing the origin was amazing.
Claudia didn't outplayed fate , fate outplayed Claudia just like it outplays everything in this universe, nothing escapes the cycle of cause and effect, free will is an illusion
That "Hello Jonas" though..Most badass moment..Always sends chills down my spine!! Shows how Adam and Eva are nothing in front of Clauda!!!
Just imagine how Jonas must have felt in all of the versions where Claudia didn't arrived. He just suffered the most by far and had the most worst fate. He spent his entire life to fix all of this, is responsible for the tradegy and death of his father, death of his best friend who was killed by his own son, killed his mother and the love of his life three times and is one of the reasons why everybody suffered. After 33 years of living in the apocalypse he slowly turned into the very thing he sworn to destroy. The last 33 years he was so determined that everything will end for good. His suffering and the suffering of everybody else. Than after he killed Martha and the origin he just stands there alone, no one else around him just to realize in frustration and pain that everything he did fixed nothing at all and was always the reason why everything happened.
Jonas is such a tragic character. It's hard to imagine how he felt during his entire life. I feel so sorry for him. But I actually don't believe that there is an infinite amount of versions of him. For me it makes more sense that everything happens only once. Because all the events in the cycle lead to Claudia breaking it. This would be the case in every cycle. But she can break it only once. If everything is happening as always, then how can she even make a difference and find/use the solution in the first place, without ever having done it before? My theory is that after Tannhaus creates both worlds they run through the cycle once before destroying themselves.
I know that this is still not a perfect explanation but it's fun to think about.
@@jakobkerman1247 Agreed! The infinite amounts of version of Jonas still doesn't make sense. Everything should have happened exactly before. How could've Claudia noticed that detail about Regina? It effected the hole outcome. In the whole series there was not one sign of the possibilty that something like that could have happened. Sure, we were given the information many times. But with the belief that the changes the most people tried were part of the knot. There was always someone who knowed or effected the changes of the cycle and used them. Claudia was the only person that noticed this little detail about Regina and she wasn't proven wrong. She just found it by no one but herself, you could say by accident. But how was it possible to let this accident happen in a repeating cycle?
@@addy2429 Exactly! If everything is repeating, Claudia must find a way to break the cycle as a result of all the unchangeble events. This means the fact that she finds the loophole is determined through the cycle itself. It's her fate that can't be changed. So there has never been another way for her than finding the loophole and destroying the cycle. I don't know why, but this "plothole" feels intentional. I love how this show always leaves room for interpretations.
@@jakobkerman1247 I would say that this plothole just want us to say that the story of Dark is just a "dream" or just a story. Not everything has to make sense even though Dark seems to be perfect. I'm just glad what a huge experience Dark was for me. It has a very special place in my heart. Also because I'm from germany and I'm very happy that Dark got so much international attention. The most of the german series are crap. Dark gave a huge different view on the german tv production. Sadly, I just know a few people who've seen Dark and it isn't that popular here. But I'm really looking forward for "1899"
@@addy2429 I'm german too and I have been really surprised when I realized how few people actually seem to know it here. I would really love to see more shows like Dark in the future and I also hope that this type of tv show gets more popular.
Both worlds are referred to as cancers. In both alternate worlds, Regina gets cancer. But in the origin world, she doesn't. Holy moly.
But honestly, how come it that Regina happens to get cancer in both worlds but not in the original? That was never explained unless i’ve missed something.
@@eagleman5138 I have no idea, but it seems symbolic of the worlds being "wrong" and metaphorically cancerous.
Marcell2aG Yeah it is. I guess you could say symbolism is the cure for cancer. Lol.
@@eagleman5138
Maybe it has something to do with the night she was tied to the tree. Remember the sound from the cave? It may have been the night where the "accident" in the nuclear power plant happened.
In the Origin world she was never tied to a tree because Ulrich doesn't exist. Also there is no nuclear power plant anyway so she was never exposed to the accident/radiation.
That’s exactly it. The night she was tied down right next to the cave she got an a Ute dose of radiation from the plant disaster that ironically covered up by her birth father Bernd.
Claudia is the real game changer
"Sic Mundus creatus est"
I love the look on Adam's face lol the new "surprised pikachu face"
🤣😂
For those who thinks Eva was more smarter then Adam and she was winning, in my thought Eva was more foolish then any one else. Adam was just misinformed and misguided by Claudia. When Claudia told Adam everything he stopped the cycle like it was just peanuts for him. Evas greatest strength is that Claudia from Evas world was with her. Claudia is the best. 😍😍😍😍
Tannhaus and Claudia are the two most important people in the series. Yeah everyone plays their own part. Nothing impacted the story more than Tannhaus in Origin world, and Tannhaus even in the other world's was just as impactful. Claudia's realization is the most important thing in the entire series imo, besides Tannhaus literally creating 2 separate universes
@@daltonvann9876 Tannhaus was the idiot of the entire show. For him the entire charade started. Claudia was the best of course. But I liked Adam. But still their are no explaination how Claudia realised their is another origin exist.
@@ty814 Claudia literally had infinite amounts of loops to find out about the origin world. You have to keep that in mind. It's not like the one specific Claudia at the end of the series was solely responsible for finding out. It was a collective effort of all her former selves. When I mentioned HG Tannhaus bring the smartest, I'm mainly just talking about raw intellectual ability. He's literally the most intelligent person in the show. I'm talking about Origin world Tannhaus. He figured out time travel by himself. The other Tannhaus was I'm assuming just as intelligent due to him being a replica of the original.
@@daltonvann9876 For me both Tannhaus was psycho and idiot. Being intelligent doesn’t make you smart.
@@readbyname Bro delusioned Claudia from Evas world was fooling the Claudia from Adam's world to manipulate Adam in wrong track. Adam was misguided.
Most powerful moment.
@@emiliorodriguez8104 That's her opinion, you have a different one, deal with it and don't argue.
Claudia is the brain of the series.
Claudia is by far my most favorite grandma in all media.
"Hello Jonas" gave me chills...
"Du hast immer noch keine Ahnung wie dieses Spiel gespielt wird" - Mann, er ist nicht der einzige!
Claudia is the coolest character in the whole series.
0:55 - 1:05
When you win in Gulag (Warzone) and run into the guy who killed you in the first place
0:00 when I wake up every morning realizing I didn't die in my sleep
Underrated comment
0:00 when i wake up every morning realizing I shidded my pants
Claudia is like a wise person or least remained of it.
she is the one who still has "insight",all the other gets lots in madness or corruption for the plan.
Claudia is the best
Claudia had a genius intellect as a child; Jonas and Martha did not.
To be fair, they were also smart. Alt-Martha seemed to be very motivated about learning, and Jonas was very depressed in the beginning of the first season, so we don't know what he studied and what he liked, but there were lots of books in his room, so I think he was also curious about learning. J&M also managed to stabilise the God particle in their worlds while not even havi ng finished high school. Claudia at least had a proper education. There are different types of intelligence, and genius is relative. But it's true that Claudia was gifted in the physics and maths area. She was, indeed, the only one who truly understood time-travel.
Adam was right all the time, that his and Evas world was just wrong, and if there is dark and light side, then Adam side is the Light one. Because Eva wanted to leave everything same, like in darkness. In same sorrow all the time, but he didn't. He did bad things, he knew that his world wasn't right/real, and yet he was right. And with Claudia (neutral Claudia) , they manage to make it to right one. epic show ever created
nah, they were both psychotic. Adam did horrofic things in his attempt to wipe them all from existence, too.
this scene literally scared me and got me thinking if there are 2 other worlds in this dimension where i don't exist in both of those 2 worlds
Thats the thing though isn't it? Old Tannhaus created the machine that split everything into two worlds to save his son. And in the end it worked, Jonas and Alt-Martha saved them and then simply disappeared. His son came back to the younger Tannhaus and lived. And the freakiest part is, younger tannhaus will never know about what he did cause he officially changed the timeline. And this all happened without anyone knowing.
I remember watching this the first time and almost jumping out of my seat! I was stunned that I hadn’t realized the possibility of a third world despite seeing the triquetra all the way back in season 1!! The writers did a fantastic job. Best written TV show of all time, IMO.
I love Adams face that it goes from preparing to die or to cease existing maybe is better to utter not shocked but utterly confused. He really didn't expect for nothing to happen
Adam is like me , assumes the wrong data to solve a physics problem.
I have to say this.. Claudia scares the shit out of me
I still don’t understand that this is the first time that Claudia tells Adam how to break the knot. After this scene, Adam asks Claudia how many times this conversation happened. Claudia said that him breaking the knot (that obviously resulted in nothing) happened endless amounts of times and that this conversation never happened before. Can somebody explain this to me?
Maybe Adam finally lost faith in his own work, then went to kill Eva. Maybe Martha killed Adam when she found Eva’s corpse. And maybe Claudia is only here now because during the endless times before she had not learned yet
The series follows the "present" of the story. So, from the very first chapter in S1 we are witnessing the start of the ending. That's it. That is why everything ended right there.
I guess that the story of the series works in this was, that the whole story is stucked in a loop. But through every loop the older versions influence their younger versions, so there is a very minor change. Claudia takes advantage of that, collecting more and more information through the loops, giving them to her younger selfs, who also gain more information to pass on their younger selfs. Until Claudia finally figures out, what is actually going on.
Proof of this is a scene where its not sure if its a continuity error, or a very little hint: The scene where old and young Claudia meet for the first time in Claudias office. This is shown in episode 2x2 and 3x7. But their is a difference how this both scenes start.
Claudia used the fraction of a second during which time stands still to be able to reach him there. Cause and effect isn't in play during that fraction of a second, so she was able to send herself a different way, as Eva apparently does.
In all other iterations, after his plan fails, Adam travels to Eva's world and kills her, which is part of what drives Martha into becoming Eva. It's only in this one that he first speaks with Claudia and then goes to send Jonas after Alt-Martha.
Hope that helps.
2:13 jonas realizes he kills martha for nothing....
That must have hurt.
Not for nothing. It all had to end. He just didn't know exactly how.
@@RaptorJesus but the knot not was broken even if he kills the origin and the love of his life (again), for this reason he was on the verge of tears.
@@Rickil96trollencio He was on the verge of tears for multiple reasons. The largest of which, I would argue, is that he was finally getting the oblivion he so desperately desired. The other two worlds are finally going to end. Their pain will cease.
@@RaptorJesus yes, but i think kill martha again and that not works would so hurt to him, he still loves her and it's suppose this was the end of all and fail again.
He promise martha that he do all are okey, and destroy the two worlds and end with all the suffer it's a way of comply it.
@@Rickil96trollencio Of course he loves her. I just think that, by this point, it's not loss he's feeling. He knows loss. He knows regret. Better, arguably, than any other man to have ever lived. And he knows them so well that cannot *hurt* him anymore. His tears here I would say are not from pain. They're relief. Someone has finally, *finally* told him "your journey has reached its end", and there are no more beautiful words that could be spoken to him.
at this moment he knew, he f'd up
Adam, I've come to bargain...
" Nothing is complete without the third dimension " woah woah This was the same statement, Which That Time machine guy made 😮 Does it mean there was already a hint back then
Bloody hell he must of been exhausted, what he must of been thinking when he got told their is a third world lmao
I wonder what originally happens to Adam here before Claudia splintered herself to recruit him
!!!! SPOİLER !!!!
Claudia solved everything with Regina's death. Regina was never be a part of the knot. So she must not die. But in two worlds both Adam's and Eva's she is dead. At the end of the season 3 those who must not be dead (because they are not a part of the knot ) are all gonna die in Adam's and Eva's world.
i still didn't understand why Regina hd to be killed..she was dying from cancer already . And how old Cloudia knows about the origin world ?
@@maxim196 Katharina, Hannah, Regina, Peter, Torben and Bernadette are died in these two worlds. Their parents are out of the knot so they must be alive. But Adam's and Eva's worlds are a mistake. They shouldn't exist. Everything is go wrong in these worlds.
@@maxim196 the most probable reason of Regina's cancer is the nuclear power plant. If there's no knot, there's no Martha's son, so no one extorted the Winden's 1954 Mayor to approve the nuclear power plant.
@@maxim196 I'm sorry, I've just realized that I didn't answer your question. Claudia sent Tronte to kill Regina to create that painful memory that moved young Claudia to try to find a way for Regina to live.
Wow, brilliant perspective
It is said that the inner desires of Adam and Eva made them do things that maintained the knot, the cycle। Can someone tell me what exactly were the desires??
Adam maintains the knot to get to kill alt-Martha and her unborn child.
Eva or Eve maintains the knot to keep her son alive.
@@uchihakiri8062 Oh!! Thanks buddy. I thought that it was their younger versions being together.
Adam wants to destroy everything but he knows how things must happen as they always have so that he can destroy the origin.
Adam wants to destroy everything but he knows how things must happen as they always have so that he can destroy the origin.
Hi
But how did Claudia find out the way to escape the loop, what did she do different from other past Claudia's of the loop? How can it be different if it is already a loop?
The old Claudia always gave informations to the younger one so she already knew what the old one did and she was able to get further without doing what the old ones already did so she eventually found an escape
Idk if I was understandable 😅 but yes it’s that
@@Davd015 So Claudia was already out of the loop but in order to gain enough info to end the knot she had to make the loop continue becouse her length of life isn't enough to gain all the required information. Maybe she had to make the loop continue for maybe like a thousand time?
The show runners earned all the money they have to and keep us the auditions "get all going" through this
Claudia replaced her alt self and was able to spy on Eva, and From there, I think she learned about the quantum thing, where the Loop stop (aka when the Apocalypse happens) and creates two different points (One where Jonas accidentally leads Martha 2 into becoming Eva and one where Jonas becomes Adam).
How did Claudia know that she was going to be killed and how does she know that Adam thinks that, by this time, she's dead?
Middle age claudia saw the newspaper story in the library( remember that scene, she struggled with computers) therefore she knew all facts that caused her death
Because neither one survives, one is killed by Adam and the other is killed by herself
Manager of a complex Atomkraft is indeed a genius.
I wish there are spinn off series about Claudia Journey
Where did Martha even disappear, surely she wasn't killed because this has happened like all the times before and Eva lives
The eva that lives was the Martha that is with eva. ( I know this sounds confusing) but there were 2 Martha's living in parallel realities, the one that brings Jonas to other world (killed by Adam in this scene) and other that bartosz stops from going in to bring Jonas.
The question wasn't "where?", "when?" Or "in what world?"... It's "why?"
"I'm not supposed to be here, Marty"
I need to rewatch this series
A very beautiful series and a story like no other👍👍👍🔥🔥🔥
She probably figured it out from the question- who created the design for the machine? The doc never figured it out in these timelines and nobody except him could create one so it must be him who created the knot but not the 2 from these dimensions
It’s a time loop, he created it from the blueprints, the blueprints were created from his creation, it repeats
@@mranima748 yes but the original must come from somewhere. That's why the characters created by the loop simply vanished but the originals remained in the original timeline/reality
this is how borderline feels when breakup😭
I felt the 3rd season switched the rug under me, there was no time to develop the second time line and much of the character development was so incredibly rushed by the last season limitation, plus I liked it before way more because Adam was the antagonist since part of the fun was the mystery of how Jonas came to be this person. Like I get it, but I don't plan on re-watching.
That's fine, however a lot of the things that happen in the second world happen in the first, some are different sure, like Ulrich dying instead of being imprisoned. Jonas also doesn't exist in that world and Mikkel never gets lost, that's a LOT of time shaved. I did like the mystery of how Jonas became Adam but this season slowly showed us how Jonas/The Stranger became him in the end. Just lines of dialogue show his demeaner switch...
According to me this is the best season
Yah rewatching is kindda boring but s3 is so much suspense breaking
Thanks for let us know. Now we can happily fade away.
@@andres.alegre LOL!
@Gabriel Orville I liked season 3, and the more I think about it, the more it grows on me. But I see where you are coming from. To me, seasons 1 and 2 are the pinnacle of Dark, with season 2 being a solid 10/10. I'd actually even say s1 is a 10/10 with s3 being a respectable 8.75/10.
How did claudia survive ?
She didn't after this we see her prepare to meet Noah and get shot by him again.
Sven Kampen its not possible because her death is part of the loop . Since the loop as destroyed that means she never died . I just dont get from what time is this claudia comming from
Yes, this is her before she gets shot by Adam, you literally see her prepare to get killed for the last time after this, whoch she has to, because the loop needs to happen or Adam would not be here in the room to hear about the original world and the loophole he needs to sent Jonas to break the loop at the moment of the apocalypse..
Sven Kampen yeah before she gets shoot but from wich time or before wich events I mean did she uses realities but before witch time especially did this claudia meet eagon?
Ergi Dedja no this is a different version of claudia. Claudia used the same thing which eva used where time stopped for a second during the apocalypse to create two version of herself: one to get killed by noah, the other to come here to adam
Please explain to me how Jonas and Martha came to exist following the destruction of the origin world. Thank you.
They don't exist after avoiding the creation of the origin word.
(I know this is late, but hear me out )All their origins are connected to Egon and Hannah. They were part of the knot which has no observable origin cuz of the bootstrap paradox. The continuous loop causes them to have no explainable origin as their older selves are the reason their younger selves are born in the first place. Technically, they are born becuz of their older selves' influence.
Why manipulate jonas? Tell him from the beggining? Stop killing children?
the loop must continue
I wonder how adam dies everytime in the end of every cycle
When is all complete
maybe a younger Martha is supposed to kill him after finding him standing over Eva's body.
Yeah, everybody have died many times, and their many versions too
@@ZOMBIETH44 Or he goes to another place and kill himself, since Eva said that she found only her older self dead at that moment...
Can pls anybody explain me how did claudia survive ?
just like how jonas survived , the Schrödinger cat
things happend differently at the same time , she got killed in scenario 1 but survived in scenario 2
@@yamatokosanyaku7898 no she just come to Adam before she was killed by Noah, she died after this conversation with Jonas when Noah killed her
Nico LG i dont think thats possible if she talked to adam and all the events that occured after she would never get to noah because he would be erased .
Yamato Kosanyaku thanks this makes sense but the only problem is that with jonas we see a very detailed joureny meaning we see all the events that lead to his death and in turning adam in second scenario while with claudia we never get to see a clear or chronological path of her journey. Like okay she grows up has regina survives does all the time travel etc but I really couldnt fully explain her traveling as I did to jonas. I checked the dark netflix io and it still wasnt very clear
@@nicogameravie she said that the conversation with adam has just happend for the first time , so it couldn't have happend before that she told him and then went to get killed by adam
🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺 Hallo Jonas
I had many expectations from this show like they'll save both the worlds and happy ending kind of thing but it's all screwed up
They actually saved the both worlds, if you paid attention. By destroying these worlds.
@@KADETUL9 man but it would be better if they got not destroyed
@@pradyumn2453 Theoretically they still exist because everything repets itself by an infinite number of times. But they have to destroy the worlds in order to stop the circle and time to be linear. They are a "glitch in the matrix", as Jonas said. But their love still exists somewhere in universe. They also existed in the origin world, by meeting Marek and his wife. I know that it sounds strange what I am saying to you, but this is what happened. The ending is in the same time sad and happy. Sad = they disappear; Happy = Tannhaus saves his family, Claudia saves Regina and Jonas and Martha had a beautiful love story.
@@KADETUL9 yah man it sounded a lot strange and tbh I didnt got that don't have brains like u lol but they need to be existed man they were great and it ended
@@pradyumn2453 It's not possible in the origin world because if time travel was not invented, they also weren't born in this world. Both Jonas and Martha are born by persons who time travelled. But as I said, they still exist because everything repeats itself. Jonas becomes Adam and Martha becomes Eva (older version of themselves). So they have lived. Everything has an end, but also a beginning. I know that you expected better, but this is life and love.