yes agree on that. tilapia fish itself cannot sustain an hydroponic vege economically. Normally it relies on additional A/B fertilisers (chemical) or dump more poop (organic) into the sump tank for bacteria to digest them. Additionally, with high concentration of fish in small SQFT fish tank, fish death rates are high and unhealthy for fish.
It depends usually for agriculture if you are involved in normal ministry or lembaga will assist you or you didn't get in touch. Of course every business there is a risk involved. Need to know n explore. I am from agriculture too but lot labour incentive. If can use automation then it is great
If follow the laws and regulation, no issue… but many want to take short cut… This is not bumi or non bumi issue… many non bumi plantation company also get a lot of land. Please Don’t relate everything with skin color…
@@chiawaixiang482 this is why gov play a big role, they need to promote and assist farmer how to setup and provide a low interest loa, else we will just backward
It is very high risk to make fertilizer, first you need sourcing from good quality petrochem. A high concentration fertilizer also can make bomb, so the risk of making fertiliser is very high.
if you go explore more on how holland do on agriculture, u will amaze, all is indoor and machinery, their tomata almost 1/3 export to worldwide. u only need people to monitor.
food is necesity, like pork, chicken, but we need to go for industrial automotion system, like china and sg. but all this thing really need gov to sponsor, low interest loan rate, and need them support, else very hard
Yeap agree. Govt need to play a role, and start it from a grassroot level. You can't apply a top-down approach and expect everything to flow smoothly. (Jin)
@@ZFounderClub i say just copy china pig farming system and if pork cannot sold out, can do can food, there is no waste. why not you do a crowdfunding and look for youngster which has this knowledge, and can look for investor and gov to support, is a very good market prospect
Very generate comment on the agriculture industry. Thank you for that. Love a lot of video from z founder. Good effort. However there is still a lot of hidden factor that didn't discuss. In conclusion with my 10 year experiences in this industry, agriculture in malaysia is not as good as this video think. For those that are interested to hoop in this industry. Please try to can get more data on the ground which justify more on your decision as there is a lot of hidden risk that you may not know.
Commenting as i listen to the podcast, so everything is base on the timeline vege cannot sell due to climate change. vege need to grow in cool weather otherwise will not grow properly. this is the inner detail why vege is declining. also grant is give base on stages. every stage need to be reported and verified to enable for the next disbursement. Hydroponics and Aquaponics also has its issue small / large scale. in small scale, hobby level ok, large scale, it still goes down to human maintenance and cost of fertilizer, equipment. After that, vege under hydroponic, aquaponic still require human to upkeep and maintain. In short introducing this tech is good idea, but it also invites additional expertise to maintain it. compared to natural sunlight, pesticide, and rain water. Mothernature has the upper cost advantage. Human labor wise, it is about currency exchange. Australia can have tech due to export and good curruency exchange. Malaysia labor is cheap. Urbanisation is one of the issue to the decline, capital, land and labour prices all are adjusted according how populated the area is. this leaves the cheapest areas are far away from urban areas. and this incurs transportation cost. unless this logistics is being solved, it will still be an issue to deliver from farm to fork supply chain.
I think agriculture graduates are not appreciated by gov and local council . They are not given any opportunity to use their knowledge to help in agriculture sector or mayb they juz aim to enter Felda . If this group of ppl involve in the food supply chain esp in private sectors , they can explore deeper on the core issue of M'sia agriculture and can give direct advice to the farmers as well as act as channel to talk with ministers. Plantation in large scale nit local council support, there are some states facing problems of difficulty on application on land. N bsides the land issue, there are issue of price control + how much profit margin does the middleman earn in the supply chain ? is there any governance? Aquaponic has problem of variation of vege offered + water pollution. I seriously doubt is it ok to consume too much of it.
should change the title to ' In Malaysia, fertilizer business can be very profitable' instead of growing vege in Malaysia. whole episode is non related to vege and malaysia food supply chain.
This episode's discussion is merely to highlight how much more market opportunity there is for food supply chain/ vegetables plantations. For a country with ample land, it's shocking that we are only meeting 30% of the food needed. Our plantations in 油棕/ 橡胶 are well recognised globally. Why can't we do the same with other commodities? Overall the episode is just to spark different discussion. If you're looking for a discussion heavily into the prices of veges, profit margin of veges etc., then we're so sorry that we didn't cover that part in the video.
@@ZFounderClub exactly… as the title of the video suggested… might as well change to fertilizer related, not growing vege… Just my opinion.. cause we spent 30min to go through the video but non related to vege when the title itself suggested vege and attracted us to click in. Anyway.. good sharing and hope to Hear more stuffs related to our country food security and agri related stories. Cheers
@@tansmurf Thank you for your comment and we will look into this matter for future content. Happy that you enjoyed the sharing albeit wasn't really what you were really looking forward to.
look at the veg price, you think you can really profit from it? The real profit folks are the middle man! I can tell you, a lot of rice farmers don't earn a lot.
We understand and we agree. But that can only mean that industry practices in the agriculture scene is still up for improvements. Agriculture itself is profitable, what's not profitable is the undercut practices by middlemen and other players within the supply chain.
Land price is an issue, infra cost is too high for any agri R&D to propagate. As long as Indonesia land is still cheap, no way Malaysia agri can be self sustain. You guys need to look beyond easy money topics.
原来那么多人喜欢看关于农业的课题！谢谢大家！但是这里我们也在事后发现到了一个小小的错误。7:59 那里应该是 63.65 billion 和 75.71 billion.
不好意思！
aquaponic就只是一個噱頭，單單靠魚的糞便不可能養活這些菜，肯定還需要添加a-b肥，魚菜共生理想很美好，現實難管理，一批蔬菜30天種完要清理青苔，一批魚要養8-10個月，添加ab肥料池中長滿的青苔如何處理。道不如把hydroponic和養魚分開做好
原来如此！谢谢分享，学到了！
yes agree on that. tilapia fish itself cannot sustain an hydroponic vege economically.
Normally it relies on additional A/B fertilisers (chemical) or dump more poop (organic) into the sump tank for bacteria to digest them.
Additionally, with high concentration of fish in small SQFT fish tank, fish death rates are high and unhealthy for fish.
我本身有在设计aquaponics系统，摸索了好几年，给与我对鱼菜共生的看法：
1. 鱼菜共生鱼，菜和系统，三者之间的关系是紧密的，养多少条鱼，种多少颗菜，比例都需要经过计算，系统的设计也很多需要非常多的考量，设施设备方面如何选择，出水量排水量，水位高度等等还有很多。
2. 鱼菜共生初期投入很大，如果一开始就要做大商业化，除了资金是其中一个问题，也必须拥有了一组优秀的技术团队维持系统运作，观察水,鱼和菜的状况。
3. 再来就是如何销售种出来的菜，要跟本地农药市场竞争已是不可能的，售价的考量很重要，太贵没人买，太低难回本。
还有很多我就不细说了
哇！谢谢分享！你的系统有 test run 过吗？是否能成事？
@@ZFounderClub 有，没有问题
@@mr.modeller6173 哇，弄到我也想去看看
谢谢你们做了这集视频，本人是做农业种植的。。。经历种植失败亏了很多，公司也遇到财务危机，农业真的是很多未知风险。。。想好好规划好好再进场
对。。所以在视频后面也有说了句公道话，门槛真的不低。虽然利润，如果没有中间商，是很客观的。
It depends usually for agriculture if you are involved in normal ministry or lembaga will assist you or you didn't get in touch. Of course every business there is a risk involved. Need to know n explore. I am from agriculture too but lot labour incentive. If can use automation then it is great
Aquaponics 其实这个东西已经很多很多很多年前也是很多人大流行去玩，后来老一辈的人不玩后就新一代没人接手。
如果要产生新生小孩多接触大自然，比如蔬菜之类，我脑海现在有一个想法，就是Educated 那些新的project Property 里, 让 Resident 推动回馈农业，了解农业，然后在Lanscape 里种植这些农业，从小开始Training ,到他毕业后，自然有更好的天赋去做更新。
Agriculture 里有一个很大的问题就是，回本太慢，没人要做，而且很多地都是卖的太贵，已经不是那种能买的起的价钱，加上政府各种限制性（比如在多少年后必须把这块地给回政府之类）等。
我之前有想到种辣椒和tomota 之类，或是种植比较短的，后者就是收入太小了，花费时间一开始比较大，除非真的拿来娱乐玩，还可以，但是以企业家来做，完全100%，不要求多，够吃就好，别说赚钱，至少3个月才有成果。而且是solo，不请人。
所以，很多这些都是比较上游的东西，如果不是经过三代，都不敢玩，Test and Error 这个动作，除非后台说，敢敢去，那么就不怕。(怕晒，怕下雨的人大部分人都不怕，只是怕穷而已）
现在陆陆续续更多玩家啦。以后会更好！
油棕行业提到的人工问题，其实如果有仔细了解的话，一直以来我国的几个巨头的一直在尝试技术创新在割油棕果上，期间有研发出不少的机器企图来代替人工收割，但是效果都不如人工收割快及没。其实割油棕也是一种技巧 把果割下来后 还需要修油棕树叶 这些都是机器暂时代替不了的😂
现在技术突破，如果让现在的工人配备眼镜录下来，然后用海量的data去给喂AI，配上适合的大模型，很快就有取代人类，就差在把整个行业的生态圈结合起来。
原来如此。那就只能说科技不够发达吧，需要多点时间。(Jin)
小时候割过，挺累的😂
赚錢的永远是肥料商,虧錢的永远是农民,气候的变化以及價格的不稳定都是农民要面对的。
感觉可能因为农名 to 市场 ( 中间太多中间商 ) ? 所以苦的是他们，赚的都是转了一手的人。Personal POV ( Jin )
Aquaponic 和 Hydroponic 比较的话，还是相对有很多控制不到的元素。如果要降低冒险性，Hydroponic 是比较好的选择。
原来如此！学到了，谢谢分享！
跟政府租地没有保障，而且太多人需要settle, 没有办法。我们还是把投资重心放到其它地方，例如泰国和越南。农业产业一旦投入金钱，就必须获得相应保障，要不然真的是怎样赔了都不知道，尤其栽在马来西亚政府手里。我觉得如果要创业可以试一下，如果要投入资金就一定要绕过马来西亚，这是2024的肺腑之言
谢谢观看
原因是貪污问题 non bumi can't get land. 租地而且分分鐘收回所以不下重本投资。貪污在每个行业变成投资者不願投资。
这个我就不知道了，有故事？
Hard to own land, but still can rent either directly from them or other owner.
If follow the laws and regulation, no issue… but many want to take short cut…
This is not bumi or non bumi issue… many non bumi plantation company also get a lot of land.
Please Don’t relate everything with skin color…
我不知道阁下说的是否完全正确，不过，我自己本身也是对马来西亚没有什么信心...所以我就把重心放在泰国那里...不过我也比较幸运，因为家母是泰国华裔...同时也从我外家祖上那里继承了一些土地与橡胶园...在经过我的再三考虑过后决定把钱投资在家母的那些土地更为保险...现在在考虑种榴莲...至少在泰国这里并没有几等公民之分...属实比马来西亚稳定的多...
@@ZFounderClub 很多故事。政府口头说支持food security 都只是客套话，一直以来对农业政策都不友善哪来得到argitech的进步，你要有黑白想通，白的是负责通过你的liscense 他们抽油水给atas的人，中间人抽油水。黑- 黑社会妳不给他们搞妳农作物下毒毒妳鱼池， 还有邻国某个大亨垄断了东南亚市场，你要是对他们有竞争威胁 他们会dump price 或者控制原材料来搞死你，
a very informative channel, keep up the good work
Much appreciated! Thank you for such kind comment!
農業是知本家的遊戲，菜有價農民還可以活，菜沒有價採收的工錢都不夠，黃瓜批發價可以從rm0.3-rm3都有，天氣不好大家沒有產量價錢就高，天氣好菜價低有時算一算棚架錢肥料錢工錢零零總總加起來賺沒有多少 。做農業還要面對全軍覆沒風險
非常赞同你的说法 种到辛辛苦苦去到中间人手中又是以烂价收购 分分钟钟都是亏本 农材料也是疯狂起价但是农民卖出去的价钱没有改变 辛苦的永远是农民
所以市面上有很多水耕种。但这类种植，可以的话还是不要鼓励。
所以中间商最开心？哈哈
中间商不至于亏到无路。农夫还要给工钱，买肥料。
@@ZFounderClub风险最低
我目前正从事农业，也是农科毕业的。农业也不见得那么好赚。很多赚钱的是卖农药，肥料，设备的，种植的农民可不一定。农民的收成需要看天吃饭，病虫害问题，天气都会影响收成。马来西亚政府也没花什么心思给农民教育，或者在科研上，所以马来西亚的农业技术往往都比外国输了一大截。最近可见越来越多的进口蔬菜水果，很多其实不是本地无法栽种，而是外国他们的成本相对低，如中国他们一来就很大面积的栽种，政府也给农民很多的支持，他们有本事把价钱压得很低。马来西亚没有这条件，政府也没什么管控进口蔬菜价钱，本地农民对进口菜没竞争力，自然就少人去做，也就难发展起来。
谢谢你分享这些 insider info 给我们知道。那你认为这个问题应该从哪里开始处理呢？
@@ZFounderClub 小农民应该很难，主应该需要农民公会，团体（但应该很多农民也不活跃）反应给政府，政府再进一步协助。但年轻人越来越不要做农业是真的。台湾也一样，他们有农业险（稳赚不赔，发生天灾病虫害造成损失，可以claim保险），但依然没有人做。
其实马来西亚农业是绝对够供应给本地市场的，除了某些种植不了的菜就需要靠进口，然后政府并没有帮助本地农民全部是靠自己经验，你可以注意市场的价格每年都会上好几次新闻 金马伦蔬菜过剩拿去丢，而且本地还有能力出口蔬菜到国外Singapore ,香港，台湾，泰国，文莱，dubai ，可能这点你不大了解
对于无人机技术使用并不广泛，大多数只能用在稻米，水果而已，蔬菜根本不行
还有对于菜园为什么不使用机械化，主要原因是地理环境不允许很多菜园里面没有电话线，也没有电力，甚至有些地是山区或则租地不稳定，再来就是投资设备本钱太大
原来如此。学到了，谢谢分享。
@@chiawaixiang482 this is why gov play a big role, they need to promote and assist farmer how to setup and provide a low interest loa, else we will just backward
@chiawaixiang482 还有这个设备一旦买了，还要增加security的cost. 整个东西做起来是另外一个level的，所以普通农民搞不了。
要开始绝对没有那么容易， aquaponic 还是hydroponic 都好， 要scale up 赚到钱 绝对需要很大笔启动资金， 有多少这个专业的·大学毕业生有那么笔钱去开始， disease control 分分钟·让你颗粒无收。 虽然想法很好，可是执行上绝对没有那么容易
当然当然。还是需要 meticulous planning and proper execution.
Kementerian Ekonomi 的 IPR INTAN 是一个很好的例子。现代农业不须要很大的土地，可是科技很重要。
可以在每年70 billion 的进口市场分一杯羹。加油👏
谢谢分享！ 我们会去看看！感恩！
感恩分享🎉又是收获满满 🎉 好怕以后会有粮食问题
谢谢观看！
其实说比做容易，这就是为什么人人都有一个口但不是人人都富有
当然当然，这里只是讨论讨论这个话题。
@@ZFounderClub 我指的是说哦，你是讨论就不相干了，行行出状元，但有多少人失败而造就了今天的王者？1+1等于2，很多人认为是应该这样，但你去上网找1+1会是多少，你会发现另外一个世界
It is very high risk to make fertilizer, first you need sourcing from good quality petrochem. A high concentration fertilizer also can make bomb, so the risk of making fertiliser is very high.
I see, thanks for sharing!
You need good r n d department to assist
个人觉得，有很多是教育文化问题。。
第一，在老马年代提倡商业与科技开始，农业就被忽略了，同时农民也被看不起，成为不受注重的一群。。
第二，农业部经常都有很好的计划，到最后还是泡汤多过种菜，原因就是皮肤问题和没人执行任务。
第三。机器化问题，怎么那么多的科技大学都不能处理传统农业的基本结构问题。一就是大学知识问题二就是执行问题。
粮食安全是国家战略，大部分国家的领袖都不会忽略，除了那位在位超久的马爷爷，硬是把稻米变成油棕。农民不被尊重最重要的还是因为工业改革。马爷爷看不起西方世界，但他还是导向工业改革，但没有学习到不管是西方国家，还是日本等东亚国家除了发展工业外都不曾放弃农业。
2）他们把大部分的 agriculture budget都放在felda，都进了油棕的领域。除了你说的，还有他们不愿意重视非法土地问题，农民都上新闻表达了困境，政府方面静静的。是有听到政府说要重视粮食安全问题，但还没说中央愿意和州政府斡旋。
3）已经听说政府要买drone施肥，但是针对什么农作物就不清楚了。比起农民，感觉大学生更不被政府重视。之前看到中国的新闻，农民可以找地方政府寻找农地产量不佳的解决方案，地方政府会委派大学的研究生（们）到该农地做研究，这些都是不需要农民给任何费用。对双方都是win win situation
赞成赞成！
if you go explore more on how holland do on agriculture, u will amaze, all is indoor and machinery, their tomata almost 1/3 export to worldwide. u only need people to monitor.
food is necesity, like pork, chicken, but we need to go for industrial automotion system, like china and sg. but all this thing really need gov to sponsor, low interest loan rate, and need them support, else very hard
Yeap agree. Govt need to play a role, and start it from a grassroot level. You can't apply a top-down approach and expect everything to flow smoothly. (Jin)
@@ZFounderClub i say just copy china pig farming system and if pork cannot sold out, can do can food, there is no waste. why not you do a crowdfunding and look for youngster which has this knowledge, and can look for investor and gov to support, is a very good market prospect
Will do in the future haha. For now focusing on building ZFounderclub first
Very generate comment on the agriculture industry. Thank you for that. Love a lot of video from z founder. Good effort. However there is still a lot of hidden factor that didn't discuss. In conclusion with my 10 year experiences in this industry, agriculture in malaysia is not as good as this video think. For those that are interested to hoop in this industry. Please try to can get more data on the ground which justify more on your decision as there is a lot of hidden risk that you may not know.
Thank you Haw Siang for your kind comments. We will strive to improve our videos in the future both in depth and quality.
Commenting as i listen to the podcast, so everything is base on the timeline
vege cannot sell due to climate change. vege need to grow in cool weather otherwise will not grow properly. this is the inner detail why vege is declining.
also grant is give base on stages. every stage need to be reported and verified to enable for the next disbursement.
Hydroponics and Aquaponics also has its issue small / large scale.
in small scale, hobby level ok, large scale, it still goes down to human maintenance and cost of fertilizer, equipment.
After that, vege under hydroponic, aquaponic still require human to upkeep and maintain.
In short introducing this tech is good idea, but it also invites additional expertise to maintain it. compared to natural sunlight, pesticide, and rain water. Mothernature has the upper cost advantage.
Human labor wise, it is about currency exchange. Australia can have tech due to export and good curruency exchange. Malaysia labor is cheap.
Urbanisation is one of the issue to the decline, capital, land and labour prices all are adjusted according how populated the area is. this leaves the cheapest areas are far away from urban areas. and this incurs transportation cost. unless this logistics is being solved, it will still be an issue to deliver from farm to fork supply chain.
I think agriculture graduates are not appreciated by gov and local council . They are not given any opportunity to use their knowledge to help in agriculture sector or mayb they juz aim to enter Felda .
If this group of ppl involve in the food supply chain esp in private sectors , they can explore deeper on the core issue of M'sia agriculture and can give direct advice to the farmers as well as act as channel to talk with ministers.
Plantation in large scale nit local council support, there are some states facing problems of difficulty on application on land. N bsides the land issue, there are issue of price control + how much profit margin does the middleman earn in the supply chain ? is there any governance?
Aquaponic has problem of variation of vege offered + water pollution. I seriously doubt is it ok to consume too much of it.
Thank you for your commentaries! I'm pretty sure lots of other viewers will find it useful!
没有接触过的人没办法想象农业的风险多大...... 天坑你地坑你肥料商和批发商也坑你........到处都是坑
明白。只能说很多 undertable risk 吧。
我也要做肥料.但沒有这方面的知識.工地.工人.我都有.但要先做什麼？.買機械.進原料.目前有一點榴槤芭
虽然好赚，但是后面也提到门槛没有想象的低。可能可以先研发自己的肥料，出了点成绩后，再 approach 其他园主 (Jin)
看看法国不给农民津贴开拖拉车抗议😅
50年前馬來西亞學生很多都去台灣業這這一科
还蛮好奇为什么有这个现象。
要做农业之前要好好问一问前辈，其实市场上没有几个种菜种瓜的赚到钱，很多都亏到😭到没有泪。
靠天吃饭的行业，别轻易相信网上说的，也不要听政府说太多😂
农业是好赚的。问题在中间商。
很不错的分享
感谢观看!!
Majority VC in Malaysia don't even want to touch agro stuff . In Malaysia history we got no VC that have made a huge hit with agro company/ startup .
We will be having a VC on the show soon haha, maybe I can ask him about this.
@@ZFounderClub during that time Kl20 event I met many agro tech people , they are the one who told me about this .
There are vc investing in agro.at least I know 2.
@@mygoldpublishing That's cool! What's the name of the VC if you don't mind sharing.
人家成功了就说人家好赚！人家开始打拼那时打半死又不说！亏了钱又不说！
后面说了啊？我们有说 to be fair, agriculture 门槛也不低。
全部地拿去种榴莲，棕油，哪里会有够食物
其实也不只是地的问题，人才也是问题，人么对于这行的刻板印象尤为重要
要学会生态循环方式才去搞农业成功几率更高...
Hydroponic 对吧？看到很多小伙伴分享了这个方法
@@ZFounderClub Hydroponic 商业模式需要整个配套智能化管理/太阳能与大规模才能够赚钱..个人比较看好的是小型战法比如1 arce 地的生态玩法-比如种玉米🌽养面包虫养鸡法..养出来的鸡有鸡味也卖得到价钱
615million的sales （肥料）和 80million 的进口食物， 你不觉得数据有问题吗？
只能说明了油棕/橡胶比种菜更好赚，开发商/政府宁愿进口食物，也不浪费土地在 consumables plantations。 但是这是其他国家还肯出口给你的情况，以后有什么样的变动我们应该怎样？
靠自己最实际吧。
not only fertilizer, pesticide should be a big portion in sales, look deeply so you would not show the wrong picture to your audiences
我一个朋友种tomato,能赚多少钱我不知道。但是只是收回来的tomato的分类厂就3个ekar.有多大的地种我就不知道了
谢谢分享！
你朋友应该是批发商吧。
should change the title to ' In Malaysia, fertilizer business can be very profitable' instead of growing vege in Malaysia. whole episode is non related to vege and malaysia food supply chain.
This episode's discussion is merely to highlight how much more market opportunity there is for food supply chain/ vegetables plantations. For a country with ample land, it's shocking that we are only meeting 30% of the food needed.
Our plantations in 油棕/ 橡胶 are well recognised globally. Why can't we do the same with other commodities? Overall the episode is just to spark different discussion. If you're looking for a discussion heavily into the prices of veges, profit margin of veges etc., then we're so sorry that we didn't cover that part in the video.
@@ZFounderClub exactly… as the title of the video suggested… might as well change to fertilizer related, not growing vege…
Just my opinion.. cause we spent 30min to go through the video but non related to vege when the title itself suggested vege and attracted us to click in.
Anyway.. good sharing and hope to Hear more stuffs related to our country food security and agri related stories. Cheers
@@tansmurf Thank you for your comment and we will look into this matter for future content.
Happy that you enjoyed the sharing albeit wasn't really what you were really looking forward to.
@@ZFounderClub Because for the same land area, Rubber and Palm Oil is much more profitable. And much more resiliant to climate change.
@@moodswingcafeYeap yeap
aquaponic 真的就是一个坑 😮💨
Hydroponic 比较适合哈哈哈。
请问华人买得到农业地吗？
大部分农业地都是租的 农业地租金大部分也不会贵 一些1年才几千块
买农业土地与种植生产出售农产品基本上有很多法律法规要跟,光是这个前期成本就好吓人的
这个不清楚呢。
look at the veg price, you think you can really profit from it? The real profit folks are the middle man! I can tell you, a lot of rice farmers don't earn a lot.
We understand and we agree. But that can only mean that industry practices in the agriculture scene is still up for improvements.
Agriculture itself is profitable, what's not profitable is the undercut practices by middlemen and other players within the supply chain.
可以加字幕吗
字幕+1
字幕+1
好的好的，不好意思过后会处理！
卖肥料真的很好赚，我家乡一个卖肥料的有两个老婆，财力可以养两个家lol
哇靠。。。
稻米统制零售价格上限在 RM26 / 10Kg，更不要讲厂商收购批发价，基本上都算亏本卖了，赔钱生意没人做，更何况还要投入更多成本来研发创新，根本就痴人说梦。
那为什么有些卖辣椒，卖凤梨还是那么赚钱？哈哈哈
我就是挺青睐种植股的小投资者😂
目前前景 ok 吗？
新加坡也没农业 但是人民吃得饱饱的
这里也吃的饱饱啦。只是想说，明明可以自足，何必 import.
好笑的是供应不购满足内需，
政府还要干扰农民，
不是辅助农民成长。
这个我们真的不懂。。。有故事？
@@ZFounderClub 金马伦那里不是是有农民土地纷争？
彭亨猫山王也是。
种菜不好赚的。除非你是大卡。小农夫还不如grab rider赚的多，你说年轻人要做吗？
我有马来朋友和华人朋友是农夫，都劝我不要进农业。农业不得政府重视，把农民当傻瓜。批grant给你种指定的农产品，但又不拉电，拉水，叫你自己搞定。最可恶的，Grant给你非常不合理的条件。搞得你进退两难。
马来朋友是种橡胶的，但政府给的树苗是烂货，胶水少。种得他叫苦连天。
政府真的想要新农民吗？或只是做给选民看而已。
可能那些大型 big scale 的比较辛苦吧。我是有听过朋友种辣椒，pineapple 这些其实还可以。但我只是听说。
@@ZFounderClub 辣椒也是面对自己的问题，当辣椒价钱升高时，政府开放进口辣椒降低价钱，搞得农民只高兴几天。除非，农夫本人懂销售，不然也是被中间人压着。
黄梨，我不清楚。
我突然间想到。。。如果本地辣椒也能培育成文冬姜的 level。那就有自己的定位了，分分钟外国的餐厅还来给你订单。
我觉得种ketum有前途
谢谢分享！学到了!
Hope you could do a more complete research before doing such podcast.
Will do (:
还有农业没有tech那么sexy。return没那么快。年轻人谁要做。
是需要时间，个人认为不一定要亲自下田去种等收成，做agriculture-related 的industry 也可以啊（Marcus）
在台灣唸養殖業回馬發展的表示現在根本沒有年輕人想做這個行業，不能吃苦💦
我國的農業困境，論生產成本全輸泰國等鄰國，苦力全靠外勞，年輕人或當地人就只想當個農耕地老闆或主管。相比城市的生活壓力，好多人羡慕吉蘭丹這類鄉下慢活，當然還有金馬倫的仙境，但就無法接受在鄉下的農耕業上做苦力。
据我所了解的是老一代的人都是以劳力占据了市场，然后用资本控制着市场的价格和运输管道。
如果是新的玩家进场，家里的长辈不见得会支持改变（比如：台湾的排水／换水系统，实验室的需求等），长辈比较要求的是孩子复制他们的事业。
更不用说如果你是没有背景的新玩家，除非是土著，不然要租那片地（海），都很难。
也不能完全怪他们啦。当中的困难也蛮多的。(Jin)
@@Tia9752說得沒毛病，就是你也要有資本入場
@@kongshanlieren 某些地方是需要颜色力量。
fertilizer已经读错了
Ok
这个影片有很大的bias. 看不到真实的一面
好的 👍
你發地我去種，沒錢買地
2024 了大哥，很多其他方法的。网上都时常传 small scale farming, 可以看看。
这样讲会害死很多马来西亚农民， 马来西亚的农民这两年几乎都在亏钱，请不要误导民众
我们只是根据财报分享了真实的盈亏情况。马来西亚的农业还有很多发展空间，这个毋庸置疑。
如果你看了，会自己衡量风险，进一步分析。这才是对的。而不是看了影片，就随便加入农业。
如果这样不负责任的经商思维，失败后还要怪罪于我们的话，说的过去吗？
美女啊地理环境不一样啊热带雨林难啊。。。。。。吊牌公司忽悠赚股票钱啦。。。。！！！
你的看法是什么呢？
讲到那么容易？ 来做做看，看你会亏多少，看你有多少钱来亏
你都会说只是讲，我们只是属实报了几家公司的盈亏状况。后面也说了门槛其实没有想象的低。
1 area land rm250000.
sell it turn it usd 5.5%
???
@@ZFounderClub 1 area land now rm350000 Turn into USD fixed deposit 5.5%
@@ZFounderClub one acre lah
Land price is an issue, infra cost is too high for any agri R&D to propagate. As long as Indonesia land is still cheap, no way Malaysia agri can be self sustain. You guys need to look beyond easy money topics.