Waltz in B minor (Original Composition, 17edo)

This is my first original composition! As 17edo was voted Tuning of the Month for June 2024 on the XA (Xenharmonic Alliance) Discord server, I decided to compose a waltz in this tuning. Please share your feedback in the comment section. Thanks for listening!
Also, shoutout to ‪@Starshine777‬ for their amazing feedback, which I will implement in my Op. 1, No. 2 composition!
Sheet Music: drive.google.com/file/d/16sfY...
#waltz #microtonal #piano

[@YoVariable]

Sheet Music: drive.google.com/file/d/16sfY8faquF3KlD6hRZ0NxFi51JJXIdut/view?usp=sharing

[@unkn0wn._.acc0unt65]

The dissonance gives an interesting sound, keep Up the good work!

[@YoVariable]

Thank you! There are times when 17edo can sound consonant :)

[@DorothyOzmaLover]

Very expressive with interesting color and rhythms that catch the ear, cheers!

[@YoVariable]

Thanks!

[@bexiexz]

perfection

[@stephenweigel]

Neat composition! I wonder if one could play it on a 12-out-of-17 per octave keyboard.

[@YoVariable]

Probably not the neutral section but for the rest it’s possible!

[@stephenweigel]

@@YoVariable Ah yes I see what you mean

[@originalname7176]

Verry fancy and beautifull !
And like, im curios, how does your perfect pitch work exactly with microtonal tunings ?

[@YoVariable]

Good question! 17edo is a great example for this. When I hear a G in 17edo, I immediately recognize that it’s a flatter G than in 12edo, getting into subminor territory (paired with an E as the root note). When I hear an Ab, the 3rd cannot decide whether it’s major or minor; it just sounds like a train horn, which indicates to me that it’s a neutral 3rd. When I hear a G#, I hear it as a strained major 3rd, but it doesn’t feel as consonant as a 9/7 supermajor 3rd, but it’s still a supermajor 3rd nonetheless, closer to 14/11.

[@originalname7176]

@@YoVariable dude for me G in 17edo is sharper than the G in 12 because I use a fixed C sistem, I tune all my tunings to C=261.6255653005986 Hz I think you are using a fixed A sistem at 440 and tune 17 around that note.
for me I feel the G is sharper than 12 because superpythagorean. for you is flatter because if A is 440hz the major second is ~212 and thus G being ~12 cents flatter .
I feel kinda insecure about my perfect pitch because it's not (perfect). assuming 12edo A440
I can tell the name of a pitch relatively quickly, without thinking ,but on G and F im a bit slower. and I can't do chords 3 or more notes. I simply can't unless its C major. or it just takes me way too long .
And I also can't recognise notes if they go too fast like in a melody or in a song. But I can tell you car honks and other straight tones easely and also theyr aproximate cent deviations .
Im verry annoyed when I hear chords in a song I like and don't know what they are, it ruins my listening experience.

[@YoVariable]

@@originalname7176 you’re right, I tune mostly to A440 so the G does sound flatter. But if I tuned to C = ~261.626 Hz, then the G would sound sharper because of superpyth.

[@YoVariable]

@@originalname7176 for me, at least, I can immediately tell the key of a song and if I actively listen, then I can identify the chords being played (I’m working on identifying more complex chords like 11th and 13th chords). In microtonality, harmonic 7th chords are very easy for me to identify; I just listen to the prevalent harmonic 7th (7/4) in the chord.

[@originalname7176]

@@YoVariable I'm happy for you ! (jelous)
But I'm really confused. Do I even have perfect pitch if I can't tell the key of songs like you ? I think I have true pitch, like when I was little I had theese silly musical toys, like a tiny electric piano and a xilophone. I think I developed 50% of perfect pitch and just stoped, it wasn't enough for me to have actual perfect pitch.
But in my teenage years, I think I started learning true pitch (quasi-perfect pitch) and I completez the rest 50% with that ? Soo I want to beleve I have an even mix of perfect pitch and true pitch, this is a thing that really bothers me. I technacly have perfect pitch but I feel like I have a dissability when comparing myself with people with actual perfect pitch, sorry for telling you this, it's been on my mind for a while and I didn't know where else to say it
If you could give me some advice I would really like it but you don't need to really . Please have a nice day sorry to bother you ♡