The song is perfect, the video is outstanding, and I love how each clip was chosen to showcase Sofie and Ben's special "connection." Despite others objections, this was expertly done. The video was (and still is) a wonder to behold.
I' d forgotten how much I loved this show and just how crushed I was when I realised the second season I'd just purchased was also the LAST season. I really thought I was over it until I came across this video and it broke my heart all over again.
Thank you so much for making this video and what a perfect song to go with those clips !I am so sad that this show did not get more seasons but this video helps a little bit to fill the void🎶💕👍
It's been about a year since I watched them and for a second I forgot. Carnivale isn't a show you watch casually in re-runs. You have to be emotionally prepared to journey through it all.
Carnivale was cancelled after 2 seasons (12 eps each). The tragedy is that the creator, Daniel Knauf, had planned out six seasons. So the fans will never see the final 2/3 of the story.
Thank you. :) I make my videos for myself and am always thrilled when someone else connects with them in the same way I did or even just enjoys them. You can't please everyone, but I appreciate your kind words very much.
Nick Stahl, you are one of my favorite actors, but just stay away from the Porno shops around Hollywood. You still have a good career ahead of you, just try to stay sober. I'll pray for you.
Ben was tracking down his father Henry Scudder for half the show, did you miss that part? :P Fantastic show, leaves an empty feeling inside me knowing it wasn't completed.
Well, #1, HBO offered Dan Knauf a "wrap up" movie option, but he turned it down. He said that there was no way he could "wrap up" 48 hours of story in a 2-hour movie and felt it was better to leave the show unfinished than to finish it poorly. Most fans agreed. #2, HBO owns ALL creative rights to the story which means Dan cannot continue the story in any form on his own. It's truly a sad and frustrating situation.
Well, they don't share either a mother or father, so it's kinda hard to be brother and sister that way. But I definitely agree - cancelling this show was one of many big mistakes HBO made.
even more tragic, HBO owns the rights to Carnivale, preventing Knauf to do anything with his brainchild, not even write a book about his characters, effectively saying: you can't write your own story, which is just messed up.
I'm sorry I can't get in to the "romance" part of this clip. They're brother and sister. Even though they don't know it. When they cancelled Carnivale and Six Feet Under, HBO jumped the shark.
It seems that today's programing is aimed at the video game mentality. Fast, good special effects, some sex, and minimal plot. This program required thinking, and thus its downfall.
Sofie and Ben Hawkins from CARNIVALE
are the biological parents of Sheriff Lucas Buck and the grandparents of young Caleb Temple in AMERICAN GOTHIC.
The song is perfect, the video is outstanding, and I love how each clip was chosen to showcase Sofie and Ben's special "connection."
Despite others objections, this was expertly done. The video was (and still is) a wonder to behold.
I' d forgotten how much I loved this show and just how crushed I was when I realised the second season I'd just purchased was also the LAST season. I really thought I was over it until I came across this video and it broke my heart all over again.
BENOFIE this is absolutely beautiful! Thanks for sharing.
muy buen video...ho como extraño esta serie...ojala la volvieran a retomar xq verdaderamente vale la pena
Thank you so much for making this video and what a perfect song to go with those clips !I am so sad that this show did not get more seasons but this video helps a little bit to fill the void🎶💕👍
Indeed. I really like this video..it's a lovely tribute to my favorite pairing on Carnivale and the song fits very well.
I really liked this video, you put the clips in exactly the right places with the song. You did a really good job.
This was AWESOME
WOW really really really great job this video was awesome! Thanks
It's been about a year since I watched them and for a second I forgot. Carnivale isn't a show you watch casually in re-runs. You have to be emotionally prepared to journey through it all.
This is lovely!!!
Omg 2 of the HOTTEST and UNDERRATED actors ever .. I freaked wen I seen they were both in the same show lol . Good Video :)
You did an excellent job with this video!! not to mention I love Alison Krauss
This series is one of the best sad that wide audience couldnt see it Nick Stahl Is very underrated actor with so much talent Not fair sometimes !
Adorei.maravilhoso
Imposible love? Or the best love?
Goodness against evil.
Carnivale was cancelled after 2 seasons (12 eps each). The tragedy is that the creator, Daniel Knauf, had planned out six seasons. So the fans will never see the final 2/3 of the story.
Thank you. :) I make my videos for myself and am always thrilled when someone else connects with them in the same way I did or even just enjoys them. You can't please everyone, but I appreciate your kind words very much.
Nick Stahl, you are one of my favorite actors, but just stay away from the Porno shops around Hollywood. You still have a good career ahead of you, just try to stay sober. I'll pray for you.
It was called the Dust Bowl for a reason.
I agree. I'm worried about him. :(
Oh, you're right. I got a little confused. For a second I thought they both had the same father, Sofie's.
Ben was tracking down his father Henry Scudder for half the show, did you miss that part? :P
Fantastic show, leaves an empty feeling inside me knowing it wasn't completed.
Well, #1, HBO offered Dan Knauf a "wrap up" movie option, but he turned it down. He said that there was no way he could "wrap up" 48 hours of story in a 2-hour movie and felt it was better to leave the show unfinished than to finish it poorly. Most fans agreed. #2, HBO owns ALL creative rights to the story which means Dan cannot continue the story in any form on his own. It's truly a sad and frustrating situation.
Well, they don't share either a mother or father, so it's kinda hard to be brother and sister that way. But I definitely agree - cancelling this show was one of many big mistakes HBO made.
even more tragic, HBO owns the rights to Carnivale, preventing Knauf to do anything with his brainchild, not even write a book about his characters, effectively saying: you can't write your own story, which is just messed up.
Cute video. Perfect song for them. I hate hate HATE that this show was cancelled HBO are first class fools.
Too bad, it was AWESOME.
Still prefer Ronan Keating version of the song. Great show!
I'm sorry I can't get in to the "romance" part of this clip. They're brother and sister. Even though they don't know it.
When they cancelled Carnivale and Six Feet Under, HBO jumped the shark.
OMG😳😳😳😳😳 was the minister their father?
Henry Scudder is Ben’s father. Brother Justin is Sofie’s father. It was shown near the end of the 2nd season. Very easy to miss.
It seems that today's programing is aimed at the video game mentality. Fast, good special effects, some sex, and minimal plot.
This program required thinking, and thus its downfall.
Fuck you. It's people who feel the need to post shitty, pointless comments to vids they don't like who have no life. Go screw yourself.
awesome series, this song however doesnt fit in it at all.