I always hope that peoples wounds heal but this wound seems to be really deep. All happened in July 2010 and also she mentioned him in 2011 on some thanks note to the first fx album.
@@emilywu5033 on her thanks in this song too, she say J who pass away when Amber 18 and J is Julian because Amber mention Julian on f(x) Pinnochio Album, Julian is Amber and Henry closest friends when they're trainee in SM but Julian doesn't debut.
For those who may not know, what Amber is doing is a mourning practice called dumb suppers (dumb in this case stands for silent). You pretend you're having dinner with someone you lost or miss, and give your final thoughts to them
I don't why, I started remembering Jonghyun listening to this.. Even though it's been quite some years, it takes back to good old days and sudden thought of missing one's presence. Damn, this music just shares the emotions which people usually hide deep inside themselves... 🥺
I had a little hard time last month, some nights i just literally walking around without any destination and crying to this song in my ear. Thank you Amber for the healing songs that always walk me through hard times.
I showed this to a friend who has no idea who Amber, f(x) or even what kpop is, and her first comment was 'god that is one of the most beautiful and touching voices I've heard in a while' amd it just made me so proud of Amber 🥺
I love everything about this. The honest lyrics, the depth and vulnerability in your voice, the intimate way it's been recorded and mixed, and this video which paints the picture of what it's like to continue on yourself with someone who is always on your mind but whom you will never see again. It's hard. But I'm glad you were able to share, and create beautiful art in the process.
My sister hate korean music (cause apperantly all korean songs are kpop) and used to make fun of me for liking something so stupid, but amber changed her idea completely. After accidentally seeing other people mv she started getting interested in amber and after watching her songs and fun mvs now my sister become her fan too and she even stopped talking bad about korean songs. Ambers music is indeed helpful for others, she can even make miracles like this
Maybe wanna consider B-sides from Dreamcatcher? They are K-pop girl group that offer other genre song in their latest full album beside their track title a rock/metal one with deep meaning. I really like their 'Always' and previous album 'Dear'... legit Korean songs that actually bring out my tears every single time I listen to the songs for no reason...
So many idols and general people take their lives, its so sad. I'll try to remember this message when I'm in a dark place again. I love you amber, please don't feel sad anymore.
Amber, thanks for this visualizer because I didn't think you would make this after knowing it took you so long to finish this song alone. Previously, the feeling of this song still didn't reach me even though I like the arrangement and know the story behind this song. But, after seeing this visualizer I came to moreeee understand how much this song means to you. Love you Amber!
I wasn't prepared for the message at the very beginning. Instantly brought tears to my eyes. I think many of us still aren't over it. I don't think there ever will be an "over it", we just learn to adapt and move on with the pain. Some days are better than others but on those 'other' days, it hits like a fresh wave all over again. This video was incredibly deep. The simplicity, the vulnerability, the enormous meaning of that empty chair and full glass. It hit hard. As always, your voice is incredible. I won't be dramatic and say it's the voice of an angel... 'cause if we're being honest, those are apparently terrifying given descriptions. I will say that it is soft, elegant, soothing. One of my many favorite 'sounds'. Thank you for continuing to share your music, for growing and overcoming all obstacles. You're an incredible human being. Thank you for being authentically you.
Often we have a smell or a song that triggers a memory of someone that is no longer here. This song is beautifully done and a great way to remind us that we all grieve in different ways and it's o.k. to remember people who no longer are with us, and honor them by remembering them. Beautiful job Amber. 💕💕💕
Maybe you wanna listen to 'Dear' and 'Always' by Dreamcatcher as well, in the remembrance of your best friend as well. Best regards and R.I.P. for your friend.
This came at the right time for everyone to hear and feel. We can never get over our love ones who left us physically and not spiritually. Amber you are an awesome woman of God! Keep bringing the songs you are given by God's grace! I'm so blessed to have come across all your songs from f(x) days to now. I am looking forward to many more!!! Stay strong and keep moving forward!!! Your songs have always touched my heart and many others!
I missed this voice 😭😭. I love you Amber ma'am . 🤍✨ We hope you get the closure and heal gradually. This voice comforted and encouraged us multi times. Have a good one hooman. Smile/laugh/eat more today.😚✨
When I first heard this song, I cried. This video is exactly what I envisioned it to be. Love it! I can't wait to see the MV for Paradise and Bad Decisions :)
Beautiful song. ❤️ And…..Oooohhh, girl! I wasn’t prepared to cry while checking out your new video. 🥺 I could feel your love & grief for this person. And I couldn’t help but think of my person who I’m still grieving.
i relate to this song even more now lately, things have been a lil harder and im struggling, but i know im gonna get through and im glad i can listen to this song and hear your voice
Amber, this song is beautiful! A loved one of mine took his own life when he was 18 years old. It’s been 11 years now and it still hurts so much.🥲 sending healing thoughts your way🙏🏻
RIP Julian and Jay, My hearts breaks for them too. Julian, you're so loved I hope that you are in a better place both mentally and wellbeingly. I love you and I hope that you and your brother is in peace. RIP my boys. I'm so sorry for you Amber.
❤️ this is truly an amazing song. Thank you Amber, I recently lost my mom and wish daily that I could talk to her one more time. This is a beautiful tribute.
This song is stating our unsaid words for the ones who left us. I'm bawling my eyes rn coz i have been preparing myself for my father's "not here anymore" 1st anniversary and this hits so hard. This song exactly explain my feelings. Writing and singing this song was definitely hard for Amber too and i can sense that from her voice. Thanks Amber for being our voice. Lately its all hard on me.
Wow it’s Great to see Amber making music I missed her. she’s Super talented and has a Amazing sprit. I really liked the song and video. It gives off super honest good vibes !
Dude, got me chills when u were setting the table, and that empty chair remind me of linkin parks - one more light " In the kitchen, one more chair than you need" I can't imagine how much this song and mv means to you. Thank you Amber
![Spring snow-10cm 1hour/loops [Lovely runner OST part8]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vg6_Qu8yNx4/mqdefault.jpg)
This song is dedicated to Julian, a late SM trainee that took his own life when Amber was 18. He was very close with Amber and Henry.💔
I wasn't sure if it was him or Jonghyun 🥺
I always hope that peoples wounds heal but this wound seems to be really deep. All happened in July 2010 and also she mentioned him in 2011 on some thanks note to the first fx album.
@@meuinsider9253 where ? I can’t find the tweet
i thought it was dedicated to jinri at first :"
@@emilywu5033 on her thanks in this song too, she say J who pass away when Amber 18 and J is Julian because Amber mention Julian on f(x) Pinnochio Album, Julian is Amber and Henry closest friends when they're trainee in SM but Julian doesn't debut.
For those who may not know, what Amber is doing is a mourning practice called dumb suppers (dumb in this case stands for silent). You pretend you're having dinner with someone you lost or miss, and give your final thoughts to them
ouch my heart
That’s amazing - didn’t know that was a thing
Wahhh thanks for explaining..
Its prob for sulley
❤❤❤❤
I don't why, I started remembering Jonghyun listening to this.. Even though it's been quite some years, it takes back to good old days and sudden thought of missing one's presence. Damn, this music just shares the emotions which people usually hide deep inside themselves... 🥺
I had a little hard time last month, some nights i just literally walking around without any destination and crying to this song in my ear. Thank you Amber for the healing songs that always walk me through hard times.
fyaza
So beautiful 🥺
I showed this to a friend who has no idea who Amber, f(x) or even what kpop is, and her first comment was 'god that is one of the most beautiful and touching voices I've heard in a while' amd it just made me so proud of Amber 🥺
I love everything about this. The honest lyrics, the depth and vulnerability in your voice, the intimate way it's been recorded and mixed, and this video which paints the picture of what it's like to continue on yourself with someone who is always on your mind but whom you will never see again. It's hard. But I'm glad you were able to share, and create beautiful art in the process.
엠버 목소리가 꼭 잔잔한 파도같다... 보컬일때 어쩐지 슬픈 느낌이지만 그래도 노래가 끝나면 늘 내일은 오늘보다 괜찮아질거란 생각이 들어.
My sister hate korean music (cause apperantly all korean songs are kpop) and used to make fun of me for liking something so stupid, but amber changed her idea completely. After accidentally seeing other people mv she started getting interested in amber and after watching her songs and fun mvs now my sister become her fan too and she even stopped talking bad about korean songs. Ambers music is indeed helpful for others, she can even make miracles like this
Little funny is her soloist mostly mandarin pop or English songs not truly Koop so ur sister still not K-pop fun just more into her I think 🥰🥰🥰
@@PP-js1qx yeah but she knew her from my fx poster and I don't want to break it for her since now she's less against my music taste 😅
Maybe wanna consider B-sides from Dreamcatcher?
They are K-pop girl group that offer other genre song in their latest full album beside their track title a rock/metal one with deep meaning.
I really like their 'Always' and previous album 'Dear'... legit Korean songs that actually bring out my tears every single time I listen to the songs for no reason...
Nothing wrong with pop music. Amber's just not that good at music. I feel like she really has no training and probably never mastered an instrument
She is beautiful in every way, and has so many heartwarming songs , even if some are sad songs. They are all very beautiful
fyaza
So many idols and general people take their lives, its so sad. I'll try to remember this message when I'm in a dark place again.
I love you amber, please don't feel sad anymore.
Her voice is heavenly.
Amber, thanks for this visualizer because I didn't think you would make this after knowing it took you so long to finish this song alone. Previously, the feeling of this song still didn't reach me even though I like the arrangement and know the story behind this song. But, after seeing this visualizer I came to moreeee understand how much this song means to you. Love you Amber!
I loved it, full of emotions
My eyes were watery for the message at the beginning, so I hope u are fine too Amber
I wasn't prepared for the message at the very beginning. Instantly brought tears to my eyes. I think many of us still aren't over it. I don't think there ever will be an "over it", we just learn to adapt and move on with the pain. Some days are better than others but on those 'other' days, it hits like a fresh wave all over again. This video was incredibly deep. The simplicity, the vulnerability, the enormous meaning of that empty chair and full glass. It hit hard. As always, your voice is incredible. I won't be dramatic and say it's the voice of an angel... 'cause if we're being honest, those are apparently terrifying given descriptions. I will say that it is soft, elegant, soothing. One of my many favorite 'sounds'. Thank you for continuing to share your music, for growing and overcoming all obstacles. You're an incredible human being. Thank you for being authentically you.
Often we have a smell or a song that triggers a memory of someone that is no longer here. This song is beautifully done and a great way to remind us that we all grieve in different ways and it's o.k. to remember people who no longer are with us, and honor them by remembering them. Beautiful job Amber. 💕💕💕
I’m so glad that amber still make a very good music… really miss ur voice 💛💛💛
She’s a song writer’s
Ahhh her voice is always calming me down
I lost my best friend like a year ago from cancer and this song made me in tears.😞😢😭
I think your friend would be happy just cus you keep them in your thoughts
Maybe you wanna listen to 'Dear' and 'Always' by Dreamcatcher as well, in the remembrance of your best friend as well.
Best regards and R.I.P. for your friend.
유튜브 알고리즘 첫사랑니 보고 찾아왓서요ㅜㅜ 하 진짜 언니 진짜 좋아해요 어릴때 언니
만나고 싶다고 아이돌 된다고 햇었는데ㅋㅋ 좋은 노래 내주셔서 감사해요!
This came at the right time for everyone to hear and feel. We can never get over our love ones who left us physically and not spiritually. Amber you are an awesome woman of God! Keep bringing the songs you are given by God's grace! I'm so blessed to have come across all your songs from f(x) days to now. I am looking forward to many more!!! Stay strong and keep moving forward!!! Your songs have always touched my heart and many others!
랩도 잘하고 예쁘고 멋지고 잘생기고 춤도 잘 추고 성격도 좋고 노래도 잘하고 채고 b
I love her voice so much she deserve the whole world 🥺
this song immediately goes into my playlist of the night in a corner in my room
I know exactly what you mean!
Amber with another masterpiece
fyaza
I love her voice so much..... its so soothing and peaceful. Her talent is incredible and her personality is beautiful. My fav singer. 💓 from Australia
The voice of an angel!!! Thank you for such a beautiful song!! Love you and I support you always.
Thank you Amber!!! 💜
fyaza
I missed this voice 😭😭. I love you Amber ma'am . 🤍✨
We hope you get the closure and heal gradually. This voice comforted and encouraged us multi times. Have a good one hooman. Smile/laugh/eat more today.😚✨
Amber always speaks from a deep place. This song is beautiful. I appreciate her honesty and hard work. Hwaiting.
Your voice is my therapy for my hard times in life. Thank you Amber Liu for existing!
앰버님 좋은 하루 보내시길 바라요! :) 종종 노래 듣고싶어서 찾아오는데 너무 좋아용
Amber!!!!!!! Lately I've been missing you!!!!!
오랜만에 앰버 구경왔어요. 좋아요.
Love this MV so much. You look so beautiful here.The love will last forever even though you were separated
I love this already 😭😭🥺🥺
When I first heard this song, I cried. This video is exactly what I envisioned it to be. Love it! I can't wait to see the MV for Paradise and Bad Decisions :)
I'm sure they are extremely proud of you, I am, you are an inspiration and I will always support you, I love you 💜
Beautiful song. ❤️
And…..Oooohhh, girl! I wasn’t prepared to cry while checking out your new video. 🥺 I could feel your love & grief for this person. And I couldn’t help but think of my person who I’m still grieving.
Amber is such a talented artist. I'm in love with her music.
the sad part of our life most accept and move forward to see the bright day ahead 😊 愛你 Amber ❤
Success always for you Amber❤️🔥
You really are a mix of an infinite talents, thanks for this song
We love you!
Wahhhhh
Amber's voice is so amazing😻❤️
My babe you know I'm so proud of you.
i relate to this song even more now lately, things have been a lil harder and im struggling, but i know im gonna get through and im glad i can listen to this song and hear your voice
You will get through. You are stronger than you know. Hang in there.
so simple and im crying, thanks babe for being this sensitive artist
This sad but beautiful song hit me in my feels.
Coming up on 6 years without my best friend. I know she’s at peace though. This realy hits. I love you amber.
I hope she's resting well, and i hope you're well now
Such a beautiful song. Thank you Amber! 💜🔥
Everytime I listen to LATELY, I can't help but think about Taeyeon singing with Amber.
love you, amber ! ♡
我喜欢这首歌的治愈感，让我很放松，amber还在继续做音乐真的让我很开心，加油！
Amber, this song is beautiful! A loved one of mine took his own life when he was 18 years old. It’s been 11 years now and it still hurts so much.🥲 sending healing thoughts your way🙏🏻
Amber is so talented!! I'm so excited to listen this new song, makes me cry.
Love you Amber ur da best ❤❤
so in love with ur voice Amber!
I'm sorry for your lost
Amber liu, I like your voice, ur voice is so beautiful, and sounds like an angel❤️❤️
I already know this will be my new comfort song. Thank You !!!!
Thank you 💜🧡💚
啊啊啊been waiting for this! Amber, we love you!!! Please stay safe!💜🔥💜🔥💜🔥
RIP Julian and Jay, My hearts breaks for them too. Julian, you're so loved I hope that you are in a better place both mentally and wellbeingly. I love you and I hope that you and your brother is in peace. RIP my boys.
I'm so sorry for you Amber.
Another brilliant song by the great amber Liu.
Lately, slowly, I started to found peace at eveything I do and went through.
Amber gracias por todo tu esfuerzo, eres mi modelo a seguir y me siento feliz de verte hacer cada uno de tus proyectos.
💞
Amber supremacía 🛐🛐🛐
We love you Amber ❤️
You made me cry 😔 such a sad but beautiful song. Love you always, Amber. Take care of yourself
Amber your songs always are healing
"Numb" really healed me that time
Aww im proud of you Amber this song is so lovely
A beautiful song written by a beautiful soul💜💜💜
엠버가 랩만 하는게 아니었어
보이스가 너무 좋아
앞으로의 엠버를 응원해🎉
I want to give strength to Amber. More strength and fortitude to you! Live warmly and peacefully. 💜🌿
I LOVE YOUUUUU AMBER
Thank you forcthe song Amber. It hits right smack through the heart. Lovely 💙💙💙
nice song & tradition...
Beautiful!
Love it ♥️ GREAT JOB AMBER 🌺
We all went through tough times lately. Hope we will get positive energy to look forward to a better future😇
I’m so burnt out at the moment
I happened to watch this, it feels you are reading my minds 😂
Thank you so much Amber for sharing it with me ♥️
約10年前にf(x)を知り、毎日のように聴いていました。日本から応援しています。
Thank you Amber love you soo much 😭😭😭😭😭😭♥️♥️♥️
Amber Liu is a huge inspiration to me and I WILL produce a song for her one day.
Don't give up and you will!
I am always grateful to you for giving me strength with your soft voice in my bad times. My hero
Amber :'( i missed you 🖤
❤️ this is truly an amazing song. Thank you Amber, I recently lost my mom and wish daily that I could talk to her one more time. This is a beautiful tribute.
Thank you for uploading this on my birthday. Best birthday gift 🥳
Amber’s voice is really beautiful🤍💕
Amber's voice will always be my favorite
This song is stating our unsaid words for the ones who left us. I'm bawling my eyes rn coz i have been preparing myself for my father's "not here anymore" 1st anniversary and this hits so hard. This song exactly explain my feelings. Writing and singing this song was definitely hard for Amber too and i can sense that from her voice. Thanks Amber for being our voice. Lately its all hard on me.
Wow it’s Great to see Amber making music I missed her.
she’s Super talented and has a Amazing sprit.
I really liked the song and video.
It gives off super honest good vibes !
This is beautiful
I love this
Love song of amber Liu
So beautiful
I really love this song🥺🥺 thank you so much for sharing your music🧡💜
you voice is beautiful, is my inspiration , thank you Amber 💖💖💖💥 eres el mundo en el yo quiero estar. you are the world in when I will want to be.
fyaza
Always love you .🥰
Lovely!
Dude, got me chills when u were setting the table, and that empty chair remind me of linkin parks - one more light
" In the kitchen, one more chair than you need"
I can't imagine how much this song and mv means to you.
Thank you Amber
Such a gorgeous song Amber! Just love it!
Beautiful 😍
es tan hermosa la voz de Amber Liu