Well, I did think it was someone from the family and nailed it. Just never thought of Jay, even tho it now makes so much sense, they target Rusty, Barbara and even the son, but never Jay, because it was her. Its always the one that has the less posibility. I think this ending is sadder than Rusty being guilty, because of his cheating, his daughter became the murderer of his love, destroying their family in the process. Carolyns death will likely never find true justice, Rusty, even tho its not the killer, its the one to blame, for cheating, for covering up the scene and now the truth. Its all his fault, yet, I still feel happy they won. Amazing show, truly amazing.
Excellent Q’s, here’s what I think: 1. Jaden’s curly silhouette was caught on video at the scene night of by Michael; 2. Rusty considered Carolyn cruel for dispatching him with a kiss but felt she had deep feelings for him too and wanted to mend the relationship; 3. Barbara wasn’t a suspect rightfully so, need probable cause and Rusty fit the bill perfectly; 4. Bunny Davis copycat murder theme would keep the hounds at bay and his set up of Reynolds as an alternative theory for burden of proof purposes was roll of the dice. This was a fun ride!!!
Questions I had: 1. How did she know that her dad was there? Was she following him as well? 2. Why did Rusty decide to go back? Was there stuff still left unsaid and he went back to clear it up? 3. Why didn’t the prosecutor ever search and process the wife’s car? 4. I still need clarity on why rusty decided to go the bunny davis route of tying her up? Did he think Liam Reynold would be his out automatically? 5. Mya better be is season 2!
It was a theory that was not one of my top 3 that’s for sure! Especially the Rusty/Jaden combo??? But Carolyn was such a bitch for rubbing salt in the wound, “I’ll stay away from him but we will be intertwined for a while…I’m pregnant…with his child.” Like why tf would you say that to an already wounded and hurting child!? That’s def not what she needed to hear, nor was it appropriate for her to say to her before even telling Rusty?? Carolyn was cruel and ultimately it was her undoing. I don’t approve of murder but…go Jaden 😤
Holy moly I didn’t see that coming!
Hey guys!!!!!! I can’t believe I missed that ye were doing reviews of this!!!! Loved loved loved this show ❤
Well, I did think it was someone from the family and nailed it. Just never thought of Jay, even tho it now makes so much sense, they target Rusty, Barbara and even the son, but never Jay, because it was her. Its always the one that has the less posibility. I think this ending is sadder than Rusty being guilty, because of his cheating, his daughter became the murderer of his love, destroying their family in the process. Carolyns death will likely never find true justice, Rusty, even tho its not the killer, its the one to blame, for cheating, for covering up the scene and now the truth. Its all his fault, yet, I still feel happy they won. Amazing show, truly amazing.
Excellent Q’s, here’s what I think: 1. Jaden’s curly silhouette was caught on video at the scene night of by Michael; 2. Rusty considered Carolyn cruel for dispatching him with a kiss but felt she had deep feelings for him too and wanted to mend the relationship; 3. Barbara wasn’t a suspect rightfully so, need probable cause and Rusty fit the bill perfectly; 4. Bunny Davis copycat murder theme would keep the hounds at bay and his set up of Reynolds as an alternative theory for burden of proof purposes was roll of the dice. This was a fun ride!!!
Questions I had: 1. How did she know that her dad was there? Was she following him as well? 2. Why did Rusty decide to go back? Was there stuff still left unsaid and he went back to clear it up? 3. Why didn’t the prosecutor ever search and process the wife’s car? 4. I still need clarity on why rusty decided to go the bunny davis route of tying her up? Did he think Liam Reynold would be his out automatically? 5. Mya better be is season 2!
I think it’s the forensic corner and Tommy…Here goes I so excited to watch this right now….
Jayden and Rusty are responsible for Carolyn's death
It was a theory that was not one of my top 3 that’s for sure! Especially the Rusty/Jaden combo???
But Carolyn was such a bitch for rubbing salt in the wound, “I’ll stay away from him but we will be intertwined for a while…I’m pregnant…with his child.” Like why tf would you say that to an already wounded and hurting child!? That’s def not what she needed to hear, nor was it appropriate for her to say to her before even telling Rusty?? Carolyn was cruel and ultimately it was her undoing.
I don’t approve of murder but…go Jaden 😤
I said it was the daughter
Pam says Tommy did it!
Kyle - & either Barbara or maybe michael & both. It’s Leslie from SF!
It’s Carolyn’s son and ex husband
It’s Tommy
Definitely Tommy or the ex husband
Different from the movie ending?
Ex husband
The Daughter did it. Apple really botched this version but the book and movie are both REALLY Great and worth checking out.