Just by facial appearance, it is definitely hard for foreigners to tell Taiwanese from other Asians. I remember that I dropped by Best Buy 25 years ago and the clerk greeted me with "おはようございます”. On the other hand, it is also absolutely difficult for Taiwanese to distinguish Americans from other western people, isn't it?
For the taiwanese that are ethnically han chinese, there is no difference for appearance, but of course there will be slight cultural and language differences just based on environment
Hi, my Taiwanese friend, I am Sichuanese , my brother-in-law is Hubeier, my friend is Jilinese, and my teacher is Xinjianger. Good luck to u alllll.have a good day
I loved the video and I could not imagine that the last guy is from Barcelona (Spain) like me 😂because people in Spain have a wide range of facial features, eyes and hair colours and skin tones but I guess is the same in the different asian countries 😊
yes... they are far nicer than Hong Kong people, Mainlanders, Koreans (intense and never smile and only work with their own group), Japanese (reserved), etc
hi, can you also please make a video from taiwanese people that how they think and how its like for them to talk or make friendship with foreigner , it will be fun to watch
This is not a judgment. You definitely should not walk around America with a video camera and a microphone asking people if they could tell a person is of a particular race / ethnicity just by looking at him/her! LMAO! That would be a HUGE no-no! That said, this type of discussion does take place often in private conversations in America. The fact that this person, Jay, felt okay to ask this question of foreigners on the streets of Taipei might suggest that guessing other people's race / ethnicity isn't a crime. What you do once you've guessed determines your intent, good or bad. p.s. Jay said "order", but the caption read "older".
I think this one I have is more difficult than trying to tell the difference between a chinese and the others - korean and japanese (all 3 main east asian regions) that have dna and cultural mixes through the centuries, being so near. Here's the challenge: Without speaking with any of them (and I think this is harder), how do you differentiate a taiwanese from a singaporean, mainland chinese, hongkonger, and say american (and all are ethnic han chinese)? I say han chinese because these regions or nationalities also contain other ethnicities (and let not throw these other ethnicities from each region into the mix which will be actually easier to distinguish). I mean you can definitely tell the difference between a han chinese and a tajik or uyghur from China, or a malay and a han chinese from Singapore just by appearance.
Its hard, unless they’re Indian or Bangladesh. But Nepal & Myanmar look alike as well, they’re look very South - Asian with strong features, almost anyone ppl can recognize. There are some Nepali, Bangladesh,Indian look more like East Asian than South Asian but generally mostly look South Asian. While Taiwan is East Asian, so their features similar to others East Asian people, its hard. Same for Southeast Asian, Laos Cam Thai Malaysian Punoys,etc.. is similar (except some muslim Malay because their religion head cover so) Its same for blak from Afrika or Blak in Western country & white ppl, cant say where they from. Nothing racist here, this is facts
Anyone who say they can distinguish ethnicities from just looks alone is setting themselves up for failure. The number of times locals think I am Taiwanese is almost 100%, but I'm not but they will insist that I am as if I am lying to them.
This is a difficult question. Did he mean Taiwanese who are originally from Taiwan? Or Chinese Han or Halka people in Taiwan or Chinese Han who came after the Nationalist invasion. They each have their own look, manners and mannerisms, style and way of speaking. But I am not sure which one he is asking about.
看了很多你的影片，很用心內容也不錯，但是… “大陸人”跟臺灣人？？？ 中國跟臺灣是兩個互不隸屬的國家，大陸是哪個國家？請稱呼他們中國）中國人好嗎？ 英文也是，we are Taiwan/Taiwanese, they are China/Chinese. Please don't use that "mainland/mailander"...這種容易混淆誤解的字。
![F.HERO Ft. JSPKK x ลำไย ไหทองคำ x M-PEE - ไม่สนิทบิดหมด (Thai Riders Anthem) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kPJZ0UihBfk/mqdefault.jpg)
街訪越做越好了！Jay可以針對不同的受訪者延伸提問觀眾可能好奇的問題，也會給出一些觀點讓他們產生回答的靈感，真的很棒～
謝謝你的鼓勵跟支持😊
@@JayChenTaiwan不建議做這種題材訪問，容易構成自我保護以及歧視三觀。
that flight attendant can literally start a podcast and i'll listen to it every single day.
令人印象深刻的街訪，感覺受訪者都能暢所欲言，不會覺得很尷尬！
感謝你的支持 😉
這主題有點危險，很容易造成爭議，建議不要特意去強調單靠外表 (膚色)、甚至 fashion 程度，這很容易造成歧視爭議。幸好大部分的外國人都盡量朝個性、行為去回答，真是捏把冷汗啊！
Just by facial appearance, it is definitely hard for foreigners to tell Taiwanese from other Asians. I remember that I dropped by Best Buy 25 years ago and the clerk greeted me with "おはようございます”. On the other hand, it is also absolutely difficult for Taiwanese to distinguish Americans from other western people, isn't it?
我跟臺灣同學在國外晴天拿傘跟穿長袖防曬，應該很好認😂
😂😂
😅😅😅
Keep it up man, really enjoyable stuff
I love the cultural understandings your videos give us!
Thank you 😎
Jay的街訪很有水準 讚
謝謝支持
Today's topic is really interesting , thanks for making great video, happy new year 😊
Happry New Year 😊
Great talk with the air attendant !
Thanks ! I like his vibe too
For the taiwanese that are ethnically han chinese, there is no difference for appearance, but of course there will be slight cultural and language differences just based on environment
感謝Jay的街訪~感謝Phil先生喜歡台灣人的溫暖~
不過這些溫暖其實有點.."區分"，
因為你不太會看到那些人對東南亞的朋友有這樣的"溫暖"!!
謝謝你的留言 很快就可以看到東南友朋友的專訪
Hi, my Taiwanese friend, I am Sichuanese , my brother-in-law is Hubeier, my friend is Jilinese, and my teacher is Xinjianger. Good luck to u alllll.have a good day
I loved the video and I could not imagine that the last guy is from Barcelona (Spain) like me 😂because people in Spain have a wide range of facial features, eyes and hair colours and skin tones but I guess is the same in the different asian countries 😊
🤔🤔🤔I wish I was brave enough to do interviews like how you do! Keep it up
yes... they are far nicer than Hong Kong people, Mainlanders, Koreans (intense and never smile and only work with their own group), Japanese (reserved), etc
hi, can you also please make a video from taiwanese people that how they think and how its like for them to talk or make friendship with foreigner , it will be fun to watch
That would be an interesting topic to talk 😀
Great idea.
東亞最好認，日本和南韓都有獨特的衣品還有氣質和臉部特徵
日本出社會的女生比較傾向穿套裝，幾乎都會化妝
哈 終於來了
哈 希望你喜歡😆
@@JayChenTaiwan 很棒的訪問呀👍可惜有點短 本來以為會有個五六組的😅
很讚的街訪
謝謝😀
學過一點西班牙文，最後一位西班牙人有提到台灣食物好吃之類的
只看外表的話當然看不出來啊。
我拿馬來西亞華僑，新加坡華僑香港人，台灣人和中國人放在一排，你看的出來誰是誰嗎？
當然無法呀，因為每個人都是華人啊。
看這個學英文不錯 都日常用語
謝謝
This is not a judgment. You definitely should not walk around America with a video camera and a microphone asking people if they could tell a person is of a particular race / ethnicity just by looking at him/her! LMAO! That would be a HUGE no-no! That said, this type of discussion does take place often in private conversations in America.
The fact that this person, Jay, felt okay to ask this question of foreigners on the streets of Taipei might suggest that guessing other people's race / ethnicity isn't a crime. What you do once you've guessed determines your intent, good or bad.
p.s. Jay said "order", but the caption read "older".
Agreed!
That is something I have never thought of.
我們分得出外國人跟亞洲人的不同
亞洲人台灣，日本韓國，臉型跟穿著和氣質其實不太通
墨西哥人，美國白人，歐洲人也不同，說話方式跟長相。
其實仔細觀察會分辨出來
墨西哥人跟其他有什麼不同？
採訪開頭可以講thanks for joining us比較好，thank you so much for your time 感覺好像要結束對話用的
I think this one I have is more difficult than trying to tell the difference between a chinese and the others - korean and japanese (all 3 main east asian regions) that have dna and cultural mixes through the centuries, being so near. Here's the challenge: Without speaking with any of them (and I think this is harder), how do you differentiate a taiwanese from a singaporean, mainland chinese, hongkonger, and say american (and all are ethnic han chinese)? I say han chinese because these regions or nationalities also contain other ethnicities (and let not throw these other ethnicities from each region into the mix which will be actually easier to distinguish). I mean you can definitely tell the difference between a han chinese and a tajik or uyghur from China, or a malay and a han chinese from Singapore just by appearance.
Its hard, unless they’re Indian or Bangladesh. But Nepal & Myanmar look alike as well, they’re look very South - Asian with strong features, almost anyone ppl can recognize.
There are some Nepali, Bangladesh,Indian look more like East Asian than South Asian but generally mostly look South Asian.
While Taiwan is East Asian, so their features similar to others East Asian people, its hard.
Same for Southeast Asian, Laos Cam Thai Malaysian Punoys,etc.. is similar (except some muslim Malay because their religion head cover so)
Its same for blak from Afrika or Blak in Western country & white ppl, cant say where they from.
Nothing racist here, this is facts
Phil 好強！可分辨出來
I'm Filipino and I can say I absolutely can!
Anyone who say they can distinguish ethnicities from just looks alone is setting themselves up for failure. The number of times locals think I am Taiwanese is almost 100%, but I'm not but they will insist that I am as if I am lying to them.
這個主題很有趣
謝謝
好有趣的主題！
我給他的提議 哈
😊
This is good. Thanks for sharing
😎
好友善的美國人
If they wear two masks or go to the seaside with a mask, they are 100% taiwanese 😅
😆😆😆
❤
😍
建議：往後以英文Taiwanian 稱呼「台灣人（台灣郎）」，似乎較以Taiwanese更貼近現實發音一些 些，大家覺得如何！
Another great video! But I have to ask: I'm in Taiwan now and how do I make Taiwanese friends?
Welcom to Taiwan ! Maybe this video can give you some ideas :
th-cam.com/video/9AD7jhs6HGw/w-d-xo.html
台灣人很奇怪 .. 走在路上過馬路都跟烏龜一樣慢，搭捷運什麼的都會乖乖排隊
但是在馬路上就不一樣了，各種衝各種鑽樣樣來 ...
到底 ...
觀察入微😂
有嗎？
我有走路的話
都走很快的！
Jay 你可以把雙語字幕拿掉嗎，身為英語學習者的我一直有在看你的影片來練習聽力，但是雙語字幕讓我覺得效果沒這麼好，覺得可以讓我們自由選擇是否開啟cc字幕是一個不錯的方式。
Hey Wesson , 感謝你的建議. 我一直有在思考這個問題 ~ 我在練習英文也是喜歡自由開啟cc字幕,選擇性更多, 只是我唯一擔心的是, 還是有一些觀眾不太會使用cc字幕去開啟,會造成觀看體驗的下降. 我開個投票看看結果好了 ~
Hello. What month is in the video? I thought Taiwan is hot all year round
It's January. Actually we have winter season 😎
@@JayChenTaiwan uuu... cool. dream to visit taiwan
👍
💪
原來Phil是空服員
This is a difficult question. Did he mean Taiwanese who are originally from Taiwan? Or Chinese Han or Halka people in Taiwan or Chinese Han who came after the Nationalist invasion. They each have their own look, manners and mannerisms, style and way of speaking. But I am not sure which one he is asking about.
👍👍👍👍👍👍😊
老哥訪問好像有進步欸 尬聊減少了
建議當一些訪問到的路人剛好比較尷尬的時候
剪輯可以勤一點把那些嗚嗚阿阿全剪掉 即使實際情況很尬還是可以剪到看不出來的
btw我覺得訪問要問的主題前可以先跟受訪者small talk一下下 不一定要剪進去 這樣一來雙方的心理距離會比較近 你的反應跟問的問題也比較不會像複製貼上
我不尷尬, 尷尬的就是別人😀 每次訪問前我們都小聊天,幕後花絮也許之後會推出.
我倒持不同意見。這集影片覺得沒什麼你講的嗚嗚阿阿，而且若是微少的烏啊 我覺得留著，我覺得真實！我喜歡真實
學英文的好頻道謝謝
謝謝
0:44 One of the routes, not roots.
Thanks 🙏
0:45 字幕有誤，是 routes 不是 roots
感謝🙏 字幕上到眼花了😵💫
認真講中國人不說話的話我除非很明顯的北方臉不然我80%沒信心分的出來
你問大陸人和台灣人?可能老外會會混淆聽不懂吧？最好問中國人與台灣人比較好!
第一个大叔不是说了么？中国大陆
你可以試著用兩台錄影機再剪輯
我一台就很忙了 😆
都不說話之前，我不相信可以分辨出，越南、廣西或台灣人。尤其是早餐店老闆娘。
早餐店老闆娘是什麼概念 😆
@@JayChenTaiwan 很多開早餐店的本地或外配媽媽，不說話前，不知道是不是本地人
原來這樣～
看了很多你的影片，很用心內容也不錯，但是…
“大陸人”跟臺灣人？？？
中國跟臺灣是兩個互不隸屬的國家，大陸是哪個國家？請稱呼他們中國）中國人好嗎？
英文也是，we are Taiwan/Taiwanese, they are China/Chinese. Please don't use that "mainland/mailander"...這種容易混淆誤解的字。
感謝你的建議,之後會注意的 ! 謝謝💪
@@JayChenTaiwan 謝謝你的回應🙏🙏🙏
真的要这么较劲的话，你们的英文名应该也是Republic of CHINA吧？看看你护照上面是不是有写？
@@JayChenTaiwan 中華民國憲法增修條文很明確地寫了中華民國分為大陸地區跟台灣地區😂，有觀眾愛自慰我們不必跟他一起！法盲觀眾在丟台灣人的臉
@@Aaron-wb6kl現在的Republic of China執政黨-民進黨，他們的黨章第一條，就是更改國名，變成台灣共和國，只是因為現實面目前做不到。
世界上絕大多數國家說到了China國都是指中華人民共和國，你們才是國際認可的真正中國人，我們不是。
👍🏻