I can offer no higher recommendation that my refernce to this series in my response to a question on Quora: "It's a bit of a slog but does not involve any arguments beyond about a year 11 grasp of Greek geometry - espcially conics a la Apollonius - and, IMHO as a physics major and long-term and possibly physics nerd, it stands out as the best and least hand-waving explanation of Newton's derivation that I've found. It also wonderfully highlights how Greek mathematical thinking worked so beautifully using only ratios and concordances, with no relience on irrational quantities or algebraic analysis. Highly recommended!"
This is amazing work of enlightenment for next generations! I'm interested in taking this massage to Brazilian kids. Would you mind sharing the tool you used for the animation of your video series?
That's pretty much all I know about the Principia. You should get that book I mention in the videos if you want to learn more about it. I'm glad you like the videos, it took months to make this series so I'm happy that some people are learning from it.
@4.39 & @4.45 a small but big point , A planet can't be in 2 places at once.One other thing form a triangle. in the period of time around the sun and the opposiite side at 180 deg should be the same , taking into account the speed of the planet.Which is the case above.
@@nymathteacher Dear Gary, thks 4 sharing the resource. Once again, I referred to the book you mentioned and I understand and appreciate the effort you have put in to bring this to us.
Sir i have a question 1 : in 1800 which book for physics did people studied at that time . 2: from which books did Einstein and other physicist studied physics (all major books)
I'm not sure. There is a great biography about Einstein by Walter Isaacson, it has a little about Einstein's influences, but I don't know much about the history of physics, I'm more of a math person and wanted to understand this geometric proof of this famous theorem from physics.
I can see you want to begin your study from those books up and in doing so hope to uncover the greatest mysteries the world has ever heard or seen😅😅. Good luck in advance! Do tell me when you have identified those books from 1800. Me too curious. #Tobi
Even though I may appear pedantic, please note that first name of the Italian scientist is Galileo and the surname is Galilei. So as you don't refer to the English scientist as ISAAC but as NEWTON you should refere to the Italian scientist as Galilei and not as Galileo.
Thank you so much Mr. Rubinstein. This was extremely helpful.
I can offer no higher recommendation that my refernce to this series in my response to a question on Quora: "It's a bit of a slog but does not involve any arguments beyond about a year 11 grasp of Greek geometry - espcially conics a la Apollonius - and, IMHO as a physics major and long-term and possibly physics nerd, it stands out as the best and least hand-waving explanation of Newton's derivation that I've found. It also wonderfully highlights how Greek mathematical thinking worked so beautifully using only ratios and concordances, with no relience on irrational quantities or algebraic analysis. Highly recommended!"
I'm thinking of putting together a hypothesis (web notation) tour through this and Galileo's dialogue.
Thank you very much for your work. Very well made. 👌🏽
What is the name of the website/app you used in the video?
This is amazing work of enlightenment for next generations! I'm interested in taking this massage to Brazilian kids. Would you mind sharing the tool you used for the animation of your video series?
The Geometer's Sketchpad version 5
Wow, Mr. Rubinstein. So sophisticated.
that was so cool bro tbh its easier to make sense of things when you see it as a graph
thank you, was very enlightening.
Best lesson ever! Thanks Mr. Rubinstein! -sea burger
good explanation
Thank you! Good job.
One thing missing...SOURCE: andyborne.com/math/library-storage/philosophiae-naturalis-principia-mathematica.pdf
You won't be able to go straight to the file btw. Navigate through the site.
sir can u please tell me which software did you use for geometry drawings and their analysis
Sure. I used The Geometer's Sketchpad version 5
Sir there are only 8 tutorials on principia? Plz plz upload more vedios you are great
That's pretty much all I know about the Principia. You should get that book I mention in the videos if you want to learn more about it. I'm glad you like the videos, it took months to make this series so I'm happy that some people are learning from it.
@@nymathteacher sir thank you very much you are genius
Thanks for breaking it down. Not an easy read.
Awesome, thank you so much
@4.39 & @4.45 a small but big point , A planet can't be in 2 places at once.One other thing
form a triangle. in the period of time around the sun and the opposiite side at 180 deg should be the same , taking into account the speed of the planet.Which is the case above.
Thanks! I really appreciated this.
Dear Sir, the videos are grt. Thks
I had a query ....... how did u create the animations ..... power point or something else ?
I used Geometer's Sketchpad
@@nymathteacher Dear Gary, thks 4 sharing the resource. Once again, I referred to the book you mentioned and I understand and appreciate the effort you have put in to bring this to us.
If you’re explaining calculus, I’m subscribing!!! 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Thanks! I have enough math to keep me busy before Calc so I don' t think I'll be opening that box up anytime soon.
thanks for the explanation :D
Thank u
Don't we have literal English translations of the book?
en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Mathematical_Principles_of_Natural_Philosophy
yea, latin only has a hard "c" sound
Sir i have a question
1 : in 1800 which book for physics did people studied at that time .
2: from which books did Einstein and other physicist studied physics (all major books)
I'm not sure. There is a great biography about Einstein by Walter Isaacson, it has a little about Einstein's influences, but I don't know much about the history of physics, I'm more of a math person and wanted to understand this geometric proof of this famous theorem from physics.
I can see you want to begin your study from those books up and in doing so hope to uncover the greatest mysteries the world has ever heard or seen😅😅.
Good luck in advance!
Do tell me when you have identified those books from 1800. Me too curious. #Tobi
tnk you very much
guraski: Italians pronounce the latin C as chi, but they are wrong, of course :)
I wondered the pronunciation of Principia
prinkipiah
Even though I may appear pedantic, please note that first name of the Italian scientist is Galileo and the surname is Galilei. So as you don't refer to the English scientist as ISAAC but as NEWTON you should refere to the Italian scientist as Galilei and not as Galileo.
Thanks for the education .
some dodgy editing going on in there yo
He used the ecclesiastical pronunciation (princhipia) instead of the classical pronunciation (prinkipia) no biggie
I.Newton was a genius
i think it is pronounced 'prinkipia'? not prinshipia
s s" s'' s'''
just fyi: proportional is ∝