Requested by Patreon Supporter: Daniel Fung Please don't request in the comment, please request on my website Make a Request/Vote for Requests: randomk.me Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
Gaeul still has the least lines, but we must admit that she still shine in this comeback, I love the amount of screen time she has in the music video!!!!
@@sangwondaniel5843 well she's the unofficial main vocalist and deserves more lines than the 4 members above her so stop replying to every single fucking comment and go get a life
I don't blame Starship, I mean, I think it's somewhat complicated to distribute lines, why does it have to be with the voice as well, and although it could have been a little fairer, it must also be somewhat complicated Or he specified, I say if it will be my turn to distribute lines if they will hate me for not distributing well
this type of distribution where Gaeul would be the last would probably be more often since she only has a rap position while the others have a vocal position which is more prominent since their recent title tracks have little to no raps and possibly also their future tts, but it's pretty fair if we would base it on their positions and abilities
I’m glad rei got alot of lines but so sad for Gaeul but she did slay the bside track and I’m glad they made a new comeback is literally stuck in my head 😭🥹🥰💕
@@sangwondaniel5843 I do I’m happy i never said I’m not but in there eleven song rei was in the second last so more she in this song she in the second highest which I’m proud I’m just talking about Gaeul 8 seconds line she deserve more and she did in the b side am also happy that Yujin was in the center of the dance break and wonyoung my bias and she deserve those line pls dnt think of what you think I’m saying Oki
Gaeul and Wonyoung voices actually very catchy for me and also in my opinion Gaeul should have like atleast more lines because her voice really suits the song
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
I feel Gaeul should sing at least this part at 2:06. I mean if on the first verse Rei sang it between Liz, then why on this second verse Rei sings it all by herself?
Liz voice so addicted and i hope next comeback Gaeul get more line and the dance break Gaeul get a center cuz why not she is the main dancer and so good)
even though she's the best in the group there's no confirmation she's the main vocal , plus there's absolutely no reason for a main vocal to always be on top and she got a lot in royal .
Yeah, but it doesn't matter, they always keep giving her almost no lines in their title tracks. That's not fair. I'm glad that she has more in Royal, but it's not relevant since they're not gonna promote it. Also, at least they could have given her the dance break, cuz don't get me wrong, I'm a fan, but they're giving way too much spotlight to the members who are already famous.
@@leenakim925 we actually don’t know if the main vocalist is liz or yujin, or even both. but yujin has done both high notes in their songs now so it seems like it’s Yujin
@@florallyclover during their debut showcase, only Liz was introduce as the vocalist thus the group doesn’t have clear position but I guess both of them could be main vocalists. They are impressive in their own ways.
@@user-kt4lp but you’re forgetting even if her vocals aren’t bad she isn’t a vocalist she’s a rapper so we just have to wait until their comeback has some proper raps to see her shine more, in a group with really good vocalist it’s just not weird that their rapper isn’t getting a lot of vocal lines
@@RiniNicole i agree but 18secs different is quite big imo. They can easily give her one of the "sumchago love dive" part. That part wasn't even hard for a rapper to do.
@@user-kt4lp it’s not just about being hard or not, but the company has to see who suits it best, who will deliver it best, positions of the members, and sadly popularity for those killer parts, they already gave her more than in eleven and has a lot more in Royal which to me means next comeback she will shine even more, also she got a lot of video screen time which also makes up for the bit lack of lines
I'm surprised Liz didn't get that many but nevertheless i'm glad Rei got to shine and sing the chorus this time! Can't wait for more Gaeul rap break next times
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
@@sangwondaniel5843 that seems as if you are implying that IVE is only popular because of wonyoung and yujin and liz gaeul leoseo and rei depend on them and so many people think that way even their company thinks so giving yujin and wonyoung more promotions ,line and screen time it is so frustrating
@@elva961 that is not what i imply and it makes sense company do that even if not fair. wonyoung yujin are reason for popularity and screentime is fair this era
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
I think it would be better if in this part 2:03 it was Gaeul and Rei, as it was in the first verse it was Liz and Rei, because I think it matches Gaeul's voice and so she would have more lines. If so, it would be perfect in my opinion.
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
im gonna pretend whoever produced this song was like " Gaeul and Liz YOU GUYS ARE WAYYYY ToO POWERFUL FOR THIS CONCEPT and you might outshine the group so youre gonna have to take the backseat this comeback and have less lines ok. for the next comeback youll be the main characters though dont worry." - just to make myself feel better because liz barely got good parts and gaul barely had parts
Rei!! She is a goddess! I'm so glad to see her getting more lines! I'm also glad to see they let her show her face with the bags pulled back for part of the video. She looks so good both ways! I love this girl!! 🥰
0:43 is the best part of the song ( my opinion ) no hate. Although I like the chrous & pre-chorus and dance break( technically the full song ) but this part is iconic 🖤💖💜
"LOVE DIVE TO ROYAL" for me royal has the best vocals and love dive has a best dance especially the dance break and we all know that were not expecting dance break cuz love dive vocals are so chill i like it and royal the high note and the rap is on fire its so good i love it,
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit. Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
@@silverain You can search who is the main vocalist than liz, Yujin position,lead vocalist,lead dancer,leader Gaeul position, main dancer lead rapper Liz position, main vocalist visual Wonyoung position, Center,face of the group,lead dancer, vocalist, visual Rei position, main rapper, vocalist, Lesseo position, Maknae, vocalist, visual
It’s ok gaeul!!! Everyone is giving her so much more attention now they have to give her more lines soon. Even if they don’t, they need to give her a center dance break bc she could literally also be the main dancer. Cant wait to see her shine!!!
Rei really stood out in this comeback. Her voice is really beautiful. I loved all her parts. All the members looked really pretty. Rei really shot us with that arrow because I'm obsessed.
IVE's Yujin and ex-IZ*ONE's Yujin look alike IVE's Wonyoung and ex-IZ*ONE's Wonyoung are very similar too I hope one day they will announce that they are twins PS: This was a joke, real DIVE and WIZONEs already understood my joke
Gaeul’s second pre chorus makes me so emotional. It literally touched my soul, top tier. I never realized Gaeul had such a short part, because she’s so impactful
honestly i think that the lines could've been distributed much better, it didn't make sense for wonyoung to sing in the pre-chorus then in the chorus right after. it would've made sense if yujin sang there. gaeul should've definitely gotten more lines despite her getting "a lot of screentime" in the m/v. in live shows she definitely won't get much chance to shine. also in the second chorus, i think that gaeul should've gotten the "lalala" bit instead of wonyoung. but that's just my opinion, unlucky gaeul :( the song overall is amazing but starship should rly stop picking favourites and distribute the parts properly lol
Strategically it could be a losing moment if Starsh1p not equally make all the members time to shine. Imagine if Gaeul had more lines and getting wider recognition (which she already got even with smallest portion of lines). It directly benefitted the company even more. Even for marketing purpose they aren't doing it well and both fans and non-fans already noticed it. This pattern also reflect their job outsides performances, the way more they pushed some members behind the less external job the members get. Other downside for the group is unspecified positions which makes bigger gap for them to create unequal lines. When it comes to favored members, some people said it was okay bcz they have considered 'position' by majority fans and when it comes to the least members they (some fans) said "there aren't any official position yet, so IT IS OKAY" conclusion : They equally deserved lines for showing their talents and it is the company job to do it well. sorry for the long paragraph
I think its all of them era, Gaeul = because of her line instead saying "oh my oh my god" for several times Yujin = because of her dance break Rei = because of her hairstyle Wonyoung = because of charisma Liz = because of her calming voice (as always) Leeseo = because of her facial expression so, its IVE era ;)
![[K-POP CHALLENGE] IF YOU SING OR DANCE, YOU WIN (with lyrics)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eGyICIvbbsk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[K-POP CHALLENGE] IF YOU SING OR DANCE, YOU WIN (with lyrics)](/img/tr.png)
Requested by Patreon Supporter: Daniel Fung
Please don't request in the comment, please request on my website
Make a Request/Vote for Requests: randomk.me
Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/random_k
At this point, daniel fung is the best k-pop fan everrr
Ive royal pleace 🙏
@@skyentertainment5710 it's already requested, Let's just wait a little bit
Its not clear
Many adlibs but u don't count it
READ. THEIR. COMMENT. stop requesting in the comments, they literally said not to in their comment, but i guess yall cant read
Gaeul’s second pre chorus is honestly my favorite part of the song, her voice is soooo good there
dude! ikr!
Same here
is it just me or when she said mangseoril siganeun, she kinda sound like mia for a sec
ikr 😭 idk when the company will give her more lines
@@lesserawrrr oh now that you've said it i kinda hear it! i personally heard somi, especially with the vocal fry(?)
Gaeul still has the least lines, but we must admit that she still shine in this comeback, I love the amount of screen time she has in the music video!!!!
thisss!! I didn't even realize her line was short since her screen time wasn't any less than the others
so why you complaining about lines,
@@sangwondaniel5843 am i complaining? I'm just stating what I observe.
@@sangwondaniel5843 because it's a line distribution video? What are you expecting?
I love love love her second prechorus. She sounds so smooth. She shines no matter what
I can see liz even better in this comeback she's voice really perfect but I can't understand why starship gave her Lil part
'))))
she has nearly 20 seconds calm down
she didn't get the "oh perfect sacrifice" it fits her so much! nevertheless this cb is a bop!
@@sangwondaniel5843 well she's the unofficial main vocalist and deserves more lines than the 4 members above her so stop replying to every single fucking comment and go get a life
@@sangwondaniel5843 I'm sad because of that😔💔
To be honest, I really like Rei's tone of voice. Her voice is unique, charismatic, stable and very addicted. rei is my favorite vocalist in ive
Yes. It’s quite distinctive compared to the vocal tone of the rest of the group. It gives IVE’s songs more color and character.
SAME THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING
Me too
Yes!!!🍥
I lovee Reii!🍡
Whistle stop 🛑🛑🛑
Everyone don’t worry about Gaeul’s amount of lines, she said “3 seconds is enough” 😌
Starship took that WAY TOO seriously😔
@@neo.ttaemune.simjangi.mongmala HELP THEY DID GAEUL DIRTY😭😭
At least she got double of that 3 seconds
this is what happens when you're optimistic
OMG GAEUL ARE U OK?!?! IM CRYING NOW HELP 😭😭
I don't blame Starship, I mean, I think it's somewhat complicated to distribute lines, why does it have to be with the voice as well, and although it could have been a little fairer, it must also be somewhat complicated Or he specified, I say if it will be my turn to distribute lines if they will hate me for not distributing well
I wish Gaeul got more lines but the song overall is amazing, it topped Eleven for me. Every member shined this comeback!
Same
Royal >>> Love Dive imo. Royal showcases Gaeuls lines and how she raps.
@@angelic4mimi I personally like Love Dive more than Royal as a song, but I agree that the rap in it was iconic and it was finally fair for Gaeul!
@@zimzalablink oh i meant Royal showcases Gaeul talent more. Not about the whole song.
@@angelic4mimi Oh well then I definitely agree, sorry about that 😅
Wished gaeul had more lines song is a bop though
Gaeul has rap lines in royal. try to check it out! it slaps
also she is slaying with her haircut!
at least she has no repetitive lines like eleven u,u
@@welike9319 oh I know she slayed that rap
this type of distribution where Gaeul would be the last would probably be more often since she only has a rap position while the others have a vocal position which is more prominent since their recent title tracks have little to no raps and possibly also their future tts, but it's pretty fair if we would base it on their positions and abilities
I’m glad rei got alot of lines but so sad for Gaeul but she did slay the bside track and I’m glad they made a new comeback is literally stuck in my head 😭🥹🥰💕
so you not glad wonyoung yujin got a lot of lines??
@sangwon daniel they will always get the most lines and screen time, it's obvious at this point but not for the other members
@@sangwondaniel5843 I do I’m happy i never said I’m not but in there eleven song rei was in the second last so more she in this song she in the second highest which I’m proud I’m just talking about Gaeul 8 seconds line she deserve more and she did in the b side am also happy that Yujin was in the center of the dance break and wonyoung my bias and she deserve those line pls dnt think of what you think I’m saying Oki
@@sangwondaniel5843 And your not glad that although ur a failure, others aren't?
@@pinkvenom5553 rei did not have that much difference in lines from wonyoung
Gaeul and Wonyoung voices actually very catchy for me and also in my opinion Gaeul should have like atleast more lines because her voice really suits the song
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
I feel Gaeul should sing at least this part at 2:06. I mean if on the first verse Rei sang it between Liz, then why on this second verse Rei sings it all by herself?
@@byeol_mmd idk why asking me? jk I don't know, it's just that we don't hold the decision
@@Lovely_Mochi is a hypothetical question. It doesn't mean is directed towards you nor is mean to be answered by anyone tbh.
@@byeol_mmdno they should add a 3rd chorus with the narccistic part
1:56 leeseo sounds so good
Liz voice so addicted and i hope next comeback Gaeul get more line and the dance break Gaeul get a center cuz why not she is the main dancer and so good)
They did her dirty😭
gaeul isnt the main dancer though, they have no positions
Actually Ive don't have fixed position the only position we know is yujin is the leader
@@penguins4058 cuz in kprofiles Gaeul position is main dancer and rapper
@@loveli7716 It's so sad
rei may not be apart of the vocal line but her tone is my favorite in ive. her part before the second chorus is my favorite in the song.
I think she is vocalist and rapper in the group. that's why she has lots of lines. there not much Rap in the song.
i think she is a vocalist idk why everyone lists her as just a rapper
@@wedidntdoanythingwrong yes, she's both vocalist and rapper, this was known since her introduction
@@SicaRun yh that’s what i said
Same. I love her voice colour
Liz who is main vocalist is in second last place. But so glad she gets a chance to show her potential of vocal with her high note in 'Royal'
Since when is she Main vocalist?
love i’ve!
even though she's the best in the group there's no confirmation she's the main vocal , plus there's absolutely no reason for a main vocal to always be on top and she got a lot in royal .
@@justlia6863 she has called herself the main vocalist as well as other members have referred to liz as the main vocal along with yujin
@@lillcutie6189 Ooh okay thank u !
Guys, Gaeul actually has a lot of lines in Royal, check that song out, its so good!!
YESS
ok but we want her to has more lines in actual comeback :/
Yeah, but it doesn't matter, they always keep giving her almost no lines in their title tracks. That's not fair. I'm glad that she has more in Royal, but it's not relevant since they're not gonna promote it. Also, at least they could have given her the dance break, cuz don't get me wrong, I'm a fan, but they're giving way too much spotlight to the members who are already famous.
yeah but it's not their comeback title track and the probability for them to promote Royal is low but I hope they do
@@ST-ll2qq + even their dance teacher admit that Gaeul is the second best dancer in Ive. So why not give her the chance to show that right?
all the members slayed but Rei really stood out to me this Era
wished Liz has more lines. her voice is so suited on this kind of song
Ikr she is a main vocalist!
yes im surprised she didn't have more lines
fr she would slay if she got part like NARCISSISTIC and OH PERFECT SACRIFICE
@@leenakim925 we actually don’t know if the main vocalist is liz or yujin, or even both. but yujin has done both high notes in their songs now so it seems like it’s Yujin
@@florallyclover during their debut showcase, only Liz was introduce as the vocalist thus the group doesn’t have clear position but I guess both of them could be main vocalists. They are impressive in their own ways.
Sad that Gaeul didn't get lines again, happy for Rei though
in royal she gets more lines
your not happy for wonyoung?
@@sangwondaniel5843 wonyoung had lines in eleven
@@wooseok5688 so did rei
@@sangwondaniel5843 true but rei is in 5th place
I was expecting them to give more lines to gaeul. Her vocals is so good
She has a lot of lines in royal :))
@@fnxykei yeah but it's not their comeback title track and they probably wouldn't promote Royal in music show
@@user-kt4lp but you’re forgetting even if her vocals aren’t bad she isn’t a vocalist she’s a rapper so we just have to wait until their comeback has some proper raps to see her shine more, in a group with really good vocalist it’s just not weird that their rapper isn’t getting a lot of vocal lines
@@RiniNicole i agree but 18secs different is quite big imo. They can easily give her one of the "sumchago love dive" part. That part wasn't even hard for a rapper to do.
@@user-kt4lp it’s not just about being hard or not, but the company has to see who suits it best, who will deliver it best, positions of the members, and sadly popularity for those killer parts, they already gave her more than in eleven and has a lot more in Royal which to me means next comeback she will shine even more, also she got a lot of video screen time which also makes up for the bit lack of lines
I'm happy Rei has more lines this first comeback
But hoping that Gaeul has decent lines in Royal
I'm surprised Liz didn't get that many but nevertheless i'm glad Rei got to shine and sing the chorus this time!
Can't wait for more Gaeul rap break next times
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
Gaeul's amount of lines is so suprising. She shined so much in the mv and had a similar screen time distribution to other members
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
뭐가 비슷해 ㅋㅋ 징원영이랑 20초나 차이나는데
I really thought Liz had more lines she shined so much. Very sad Gaeul got a little lines
Yeahh same too
she has nearly 20 seconds calm down
Samee
@@sangwondaniel5843 you literally replied to every comment abt Gaeul lines, go get a job
@@ursimpfrr and this is about liz not gaeul, fix your reading comprehension
IVE never disappoints ever, with a comeback so great, i as a wiz*one really really look forward to their many activities in the future.
IVE is lucky to have wonyoung yujin
@@sangwondaniel5843 that seems as if you are implying that IVE is only popular because of wonyoung and yujin and liz gaeul leoseo and rei depend on them and so many people think that way even their company thinks so giving yujin and wonyoung more promotions ,line and screen time it is so frustrating
@@elva961 that is not what i imply and it makes sense company do that even if not fair. wonyoung yujin are reason for popularity and screentime is fair this era
@El va It is true tho. No hate. IVE wouldn't get the hype if it wasn't for the 2 former member of izone especially wonyoung.
@@rielalto3547 I agree.
Wonyoung's voice really suited this song💗
I agree
Omg ur PROFILE so cuteee
*I want Liz to have more lines . Her vocals are perfect*
gaul only has 8 seconds? she shone so much in this mv that it felt like she had more
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/shojqXhuD-c/w-d-xo.htmlsi=H90GSJPEtKFSB1KB
that “narcissistic my god i love it” is soo adorable
This band is sooo good
Wonyoung looks amazing
I'm so mad about Gaeul's lines! Her voice is so strong and emotional in this comeback. I want to hear it more than 8 sec😭😭😭
I want Gaeul to have more lines!!!
But I’m glad that Rei has a lot Of lines
LEESEO definitely need more praise! her VOICE omg 😩
Ya like people never praise her talent.she's my bias and sometimes they forget about her existence
@@up-ww5dg ikr !!!? like its so sad :((
fr tho she's much better than what wonyoung was during her debut .
@@Kat-y_L bruh why do you need to bring down wonyoung to praise her groupmate? Leave the poor girl alone for god's sake
@@syafirahasnaa her stage presence and voice caught my attention
screentime distribution was really good cause based on the MV i couldn’t tell wonyoung had the most lines.
Am I the only one addicted to Yujin's first verse? Like it's such a seductive whisper with a passive-aggressive message.
Gaeul deserves more lines :c , she have a lot of talent she can`t show because of the lines , she deserves more
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
REI GETTING THESE LINES? Love it :). She is my bias since Eleven.
same I can't stop looking at her and hearing her voice
That's funny stupid Rei getting vocal line
@@claude6818 couldn't control your hands?Kindly keep them to yourself
@@claude6818 its funny how you say that not knowing that rei is the 3rd best vocalist in ive
Even tho Rei isnt my bias i respect Rei and
YOU dissapoint Rei that she said "HOLD THIS SHIT"
0:27😅
even though gaeul has the least amount of lines, she stood out so much to me!
Gaeul just needed like 1 more line (about 3-4 seconds) to get her to a good spot for distribution
or at least put her in the center for the dance break since she’s their main dancer after all 😭
@@mads12345 exactly bruh
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
At least give her wooyoung sumchago love dive after dance break but starship said nope
I think it would be better if in this part 2:03 it was Gaeul and Rei, as it was in the first verse it was Liz and Rei, because I think it matches Gaeul's voice and so she would have more lines. If so, it would be perfect in my opinion.
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
I WAS JUST SAYING THIS!!! it was rei voice back to back. they should have given that to gaeul
Woooww I really love Wonyoung's and Rei's voice here 😍😍
im gonna pretend whoever produced this song was like " Gaeul and Liz YOU GUYS ARE WAYYYY ToO POWERFUL FOR THIS CONCEPT and you might outshine the group so youre gonna have to take the backseat this comeback and have less lines ok. for the next comeback youll be the main characters though dont worry."
- just to make myself feel better because liz barely got good parts and gaul barely had parts
i thought liz is gonna get so much lines and now im sad :( main vocalist and is second least…
@@amelka7269 in Royal she has lots of line and high notes!
@@amelka7269 she's not main vocal
@@mateokoceku5742 she's the unofficial main vocalist.
@@mateokoceku5742 She is the main vocal, they have updated their official positions
Wonyoung: sum chamgo love dive
Yujin: sum chamgo love dive
Leeseo: sum chamgo love dive
Liz: sum chamgo love dive
Rei: sum chamgo love dive
Gaeul: a-
Liz deserves more Lines, her voice matches the group's concept a lot and it's amazing
Rei!! She is a goddess! I'm so glad to see her getting more lines! I'm also glad to see they let her show her face with the bags pulled back for part of the video. She looks so good both ways! I love this girl!! 🥰
I'M SO HAPPY FOR REI, but still sad our queen Gauel didn't so many lines but even so she always slays
1:48 "Gaeul has left the chat"
damn that was quick 😬😬😬😬😬😬
i feel like yujin own this era together with gaeul even tho she has the least line they both shine the most for me !!
Yeah especially in Dance Break.
The chorus hits so hard and I love the prechoruses as well, something about it sounds so ethereal
Gaeul and Liz deserved a hit more lines but everyone shines and the song is so good like whoa
this era rei era for sure. hopefully gaeul can get many lines in next era, she is so shining even get least line😭
THANK YOU DANIEL FUNG FOR REQUESTING THIS
You forgot Yujin’s adlibs on Wonyoung’s verse at 1:30 - 1:33
@@themayasaur nah, that is clearly yujin
@@themayasaur def not gaeul
@@themayasaur Yujin has very distinguished vocal tone, and I can tell it’s 100% Yujin
@@jean-thomato no, is yujin
@@vinnyalv3s never said it wasn't yujin
Gaeul Looks so good in short hair
“Gaeul has left the chat” GOT ME ROLLING
The fact that Gaeul got the lines she deserved at Royal
1:26 - 1:27 Yujin was singing with Wonyoung
1:29 - 1:32 Still yujin harmonizing
0:43 is the best part of the song ( my opinion ) no hate. Although I like the chrous & pre-chorus and dance break( technically the full song ) but this part is iconic 🖤💖💜
Omg Rei Shines Out on 2nd Of The Most Lines im so proud of her i wish gaeul have most next comeback
I don't even Stan this group but I was obsessed with the prechorus. The pain of seeing "Gaeul has left the chat" when her part was my favorite
Gaeul singing:
"THREE SECONDS IS ENOUGH "
STARSHIP = ANd I tOoK tHaT pERsoNalLY.....
rei and gaeul really stood out for me!
Starship is so biased. If you’re not going to give someone lines at least give them a lead dance break or something.
Wonyoung's voice in Narcissistic my god I love ittt💀💜
If Gaeul got those dance break lines it would've been fair in my opinion
"LOVE DIVE TO ROYAL" for me royal has the best vocals and love dive has a best dance especially the dance break and we all know that were not expecting dance break cuz love dive vocals are so chill i like it and royal the high note and the rap is on fire its so good i love it,
this song could be an hour long that i would never get tired of it.
I'm addicted to wonyoung's lines , her voice is so addictive 😭
Ya not bad
@@jojohey3929 hmm. She definitely improved alot,and I'm so proud as a dive 💜
Same 😭 she's perfect
Yupp, wooyoung and leeseo part in chorus is soo addicting
I‘m pretty sure it’s the autotune since wonyoung isn’t that good at singing
Nobody:
Wonyoung: Narcissistic, my god I love it.
Also Wonyoung: 👁0 👁
Gauel:
Gaeul look so good in short hair, i was waiting for more lines for her :/
that 2nd "neon naegero nan negero" part should have been gaeul line then it's good all members have 10secs above lmao starship
im so happy rei got more lines but i do wish gaeul had more
why is GAEUL STILL GETTING 3 LINESSSSSSSSSS WHEN WE COMPLAINED ABOUT IT LAST COMEBACK!!!!!!!!
Guys if you wanna see Gaeul get more lines check out my edit.
Mv version- th-cam.com/video/l1ZBbK5aq64/w-d-xo.html
Performance version- th-cam.com/video/LhA90sRbkxE/w-d-xo.html
Liz deserve more lines as main vocalist and best vocals at group
Yes absolutely
IVE members dont have official positions
@@silverain You can search who is the main vocalist than liz,
Yujin position,lead vocalist,lead dancer,leader
Gaeul position, main dancer lead rapper
Liz position, main vocalist visual
Wonyoung position, Center,face of the group,lead dancer, vocalist, visual
Rei position, main rapper, vocalist,
Lesseo position, Maknae, vocalist, visual
@@stantoallk-pop5066 that's fake
@@silverain but many people and the fandom treats her like she is the main vocal.
It’s ok gaeul!!! Everyone is giving her so much more attention now they have to give her more lines soon. Even if they don’t, they need to give her a center dance break bc she could literally also be the main dancer. Cant wait to see her shine!!!
Rei really stood out in this comeback. Her voice is really beautiful. I loved all her parts.
All the members looked really pretty. Rei really shot us with that arrow because I'm obsessed.
1:26 Yujin adlibs over wonyoung singing are missing
Wow, REI has a lot of lines here
I did not expect that dance break, and God it was awesome!
"3 seconds is enough"💀
song is a banger, they really made this song for a 5 member group
omg Rei got more than 20 seconds? ahh im so grateful for this, her voice is really perfect for this song 🥺
I'm happy that rei got so many lines. She really suits this concept and looks and sounds so good~
I'm a bit disappointed Gaeul got the least lines in two consecutive eras, but the song is amazing!!
It's Gaeul era, They will realize !
IVE's Yujin and ex-IZ*ONE's Yujin look alike
IVE's Wonyoung and ex-IZ*ONE's Wonyoung are very similar too
I hope one day they will announce that they are twins
PS: This was a joke, real DIVE and WIZONEs already understood my joke
Liz… the best vocalist in the group.
Damn this level of editing.
ikr
my jaw dropped and stayed for thousand years when i saw Gaeul's lines were over after the 2nd PRE CHORUS. she has less lines than eleven wtf?
Gaeul’s second pre chorus makes me so emotional. It literally touched my soul, top tier. I never realized Gaeul had such a short part, because she’s so impactful
Wow!!! Rei had lines, I'm happy 'bout that.
think this cb, some member shined in lines and others in screen time and visual ❤
In 1:30 I think Yujin did an adlib and in 1:53 Gaeul made an adlib too "its so bad" and "its good"
honestly i think that the lines could've been distributed much better, it didn't make sense for wonyoung to sing in the pre-chorus then in the chorus right after. it would've made sense if yujin sang there.
gaeul should've definitely gotten more lines despite her getting "a lot of screentime" in the m/v. in live shows she definitely won't get much chance to shine.
also in the second chorus, i think that gaeul should've gotten the "lalala" bit instead of wonyoung. but that's just my opinion, unlucky gaeul :(
the song overall is amazing but starship should rly stop picking favourites and distribute the parts properly lol
Strategically it could be a losing moment if Starsh1p not equally make all the members time to shine. Imagine if Gaeul had more lines and getting wider recognition (which she already got even with smallest portion of lines). It directly benefitted the company even more. Even for marketing purpose they aren't doing it well and both fans and non-fans already noticed it. This pattern also reflect their job outsides performances, the way more they pushed some members behind the less external job the members get.
Other downside for the group is unspecified positions which makes bigger gap for them to create unequal lines. When it comes to favored members, some people said it was okay bcz they have considered 'position' by majority fans and when it comes to the least members they (some fans) said "there aren't any official position yet, so IT IS OKAY"
conclusion : They equally deserved lines for showing their talents and it is the company job to do it well.
sorry for the long paragraph
@@najibanurisma I really hoping this group don't become like twice.
Gaeul is such a smooth voice and such a pretty face, she deserves more and this is coming from someone who’s bias got the most time😭
Even the kettle noise in the dance break beat Gauel with 14 seconds
Great job tho Gaeul, your lines were worth a song
Gaeul definitely deserved way better in this comeback
wtf she shined !! Iconic lines, screentime, her rap in royal, her stages outfit !!
Eleven: Liz and Yujin
Love Dive: Wooyoung and Rei ❤
Next cb: Gaeul and Lesseo
Gaeul left the chat LMAO SHE DESERVES MORE LINE AND SCREEN TIME!!!
This has to be my favorite IVE come beck that i have ever seen😍😮
i really like wonyoung narcissistic part. watching behind the scene recording makes me love them all. they're all talented.
I think its all of them era,
Gaeul = because of her line instead saying "oh my oh my god" for several times
Yujin = because of her dance break
Rei = because of her hairstyle
Wonyoung = because of charisma
Liz = because of her calming voice (as always)
Leeseo = because of her facial expression
so, its IVE era ;)