Well everybody make mistakes but not everyone apologize for their mistake, AK deserve to be educated for all his mistakes and I know he is the sweetest when he see yu yang perform. People do change and learned from their mistakes sometimes. I believe there must be a reason to why he does those mistakes +My guy debuted +Ak hella talented this man can sing, rap and make his own music +just keep hating on him or whatever its not like he will *UNDEBUT* kbye
I love his smile and everytime he watch other trainees you'll know he adores them. He always looks like a proud dad when the other trainees show their talents
"Many people cannot accept your Letter of Apology. How do you respond to this?" AK: "I think it's normal there are people who cannot accept my apology. If I were so easily forgiven, the price of making mistakes would be too low. All I can do is to keep going and show that I'm doing my best with my deeds. The Letter of Apology is only a beginning". We may say people will never change. "If he was a jerk back then, he must be a jerk now too". But are we being honest when we say that? Do we really believe people never change? Ultimately, people do change. For the better or the worse. Idk AK personally so whether he truly changes for the better, I will never truly know. But I personally feel the boy's sincerity and I hope the people who have been hurt can eventually forgive him. And I hope he forgives himself, too. His apology was courageous. He IS courageous.
[sorry if this is too lengthy, i have no one to talk to abt this] i totally agree with you, but then another mistake happen, causing me to stop for a while... if yall didnt know, he said the r slur in the werewolf episode. i was so shocked when i saw that on twitter.. shocked, sad and disappointed since i dont condone ppl who just use that word freely bc i was taught to never say that word if you are to downgrade someone for their intellectual capacity. just dont use that word at all unless ofc if the context is diff.. (like for fire retardant.. etc) i liked him so much, he is one of my top picks. i loved his courageous act in this apology letter performance. i cant really say so much abt his past doings bc i am new in the cpop scene, but i still liked him, bc he owned his mistakes, he let himself eat his own words on the big stage with knowing that he could reach new fans of the show... he is literally exposing himself to them, but still went on bc he knew he went wrong before and wanted to do a public apology. but after the next said incident, my heart broke and it pains lol fjkhdk i stopped posting abt him and stopped liking contents that has his face or name, many are hating him... but honestly... deep inside, i cant really hate him so much bc it made me think of my first impression to him and all those good comments from the trainees to him. he is a good team mate and a friend, he is someone that can be depended on. he is bold at times but humble too... also he has undeniably good talent. so i thought, with that mistake, we cant really say that he is a bad person, we dont know him personally just like any other trainees on the show. it was also said that the r slur in chinese is not really dealt srsly by their ppl but still being used to describe a person who is mentally atypical. im not saying this to say that i support what he did or that i forgave him. no. he used an ableist language but doesnt really mean that he is one... those who hates him to the guts should also reflect to themselves if they too used similar words before or now, even tho they are already familiar with ableism... i am too reflecting on myself bc i probably said similar words on the internet but since many people are also using those words (not really just the r slur, but other similar ones too like dumb, lame, crazy, insane etc.) it tends to be overlooked.... its sad but thats whats happening... i dont think i can post my opinions like this on twt since my mutuals are already hating him so much and cancelling him, i dont think i can face that much negativity if i did share... and also some of them are my friends too, so im very sorry if this was vvv lengthy.. right now, im still torned honestly. he has high ranks atm, so if he actually make it to the finals or even make it to the group, i'll still support them as a whole, including him... as long as he is going to be a good team mate, thats all that matters ig djksdks i also hope that one day he will see and realize this mistake of his and slowly change for the better.... im also saying this to everyone, including myself :)) lets be more cautious than we are today.. have a nice day and pls stan hu yetao and boyuan hehe
@@yujinpeach Hi, since you're a fan of nine percent, can you please tell me the title of the song? I'm sorry if it makess you re-open an old wound, but on twitter I read that people are the angriest because "Justin was still a minor and it was disgusting of him to say those things to a minor". AK is like 3 years older than Justin, right? So, when he was 18, Justin was 15 (when the problematic song came out). Yes, in terms of age, AK was an adult, while Justin was still a minor, but I was wondering how much difference people expected his thinking to be? I'm just trying to understand a little bit more of the situation, because I refuse to believe that AK is through and thorugh a manipulator (and I'm willingly manipulated). I feel if I can hear the song and rea the English Translation, I can approach it differently based on my intelligence amd belief (rather than because of what people say on twitter). Thank you 🙏🙏
@@ai-tn5wd Hi, Kimchi (is it ok if I address you so?) You can call me Nature/ Nat. There's NOTHING to be sorry about. I really do APPRECIATE you spending your time and energy to write such a genuine respond, so I really do THANK YOU. Biggest tightest cuddliest hugs from the other side of the globe, I hope they can help you feel better and less sad about the whole situation, even only a little bit 🤗🤗🤗 I reckon what you say here is true to yourself, to what you believe about AK (the positives and negatives), and to your feelings about the fact that some irl people you care about are hating on a musician you're fond of. Please, brace yourself, this' gonna be lengthy😅🙏🙏 I believe it's a matter of cultural difference. Without undermining the weight of ableism, of using disability slurs, it's an unfortunate fact there are many cultures whose people still utter such words on regular basis, including China. There is a GAP of knowledge, of understanding, of ways of thinking&doing things. - I grew up in a culture where saying "Stupid girl, silly boy, are you a moron?" is NOTHING that is SUPPOSED to be regarded as hurtful. It doesn't mean it IS NOT hurtful. We just have to accept it and move on with our daily lives. It's a regular occurance (I never live in any country where English is spoken, so Idk whether the equivalence happens, too, there). So, some of us can take a purposeful step AWAY from ableism ONLY BECAUSE we HAVE LEARNED and have a certain level of understanding about it. - I dont speak Chinese, but you remember in Santa's vlog, he asked AK, "What is the Chinese word for 'stupid'?" And AK answered, "Ben dan", and Santa said, "AK shi ben dan". They just laughed it off. There are also interviews of the J-trainees and everyone told the story when Yuu was stuck in locker, everyone's like, "Baka janai no? Isn't Yuu such a fool??" and laughed it off. When Yuu was eliminated and everyone said, "Ganbatte!" Yuu answered, "You guys are the ones who should ganbatte, aren't you guys stupid??" and said goodbye happily. It's such a regular thing in Japanese conversation, too, among close friends/family (I dont speak Japanese but have watched enough anime&J-drama to recognize it😅). Another situations of insensitivity and ignorance. Reflections of GAP of knowledge, of understanding, of ways of thinking&doing things: - Fu Shichao said, "Nine has gained weight again" (reminding your friend to maintain their weight is ok among close friends), but after Nine said something, Shichao furthered, "Hey, look, the fatboy is talking to you🤣🤣" When it came to this point, it was NOT OK; -Liu Yu says his standard of beauty is white/fair skin. While I believe it's ok for people to have preferences, I dont think it's ok for someone (who is on a platform where young audience pay attn to him, LOOK UP to him) to make a statement that implies 'things other than white/fair skin is not beautiful' (or not beautiful ENOUGH); - Some Thai BL actors dont actually support PRIDE/LGBTQ++ community (the irony, the hypocrisy); - Some relative told his gay nephew, "I know everyone is equal before God and only HE has the right to punish sinful people 'like you', but I wish to break your neck so you could get punished quicker!"; - Some KPOP male idol say misoginic/sexist statement, "If I have a son one day, I'll give him everything so he'll grow well, if I have a daughter I'll beat her and lock her at home"; - My parents suggested that I prayed more&be closer to God rather than going to a psychiatry to treat my adhd&depression, "Why seek help from fellow mortal(s) when the Mighty Immortal can give you everything you need?" they asked... Well, there's just so much of what's been fought for in western countries that have not even started here in eastern countries. There's too much of what people see are judged based on western standards. When I say 'western standards', I dont mean they are bad, I mean they are still difficult to understand, let alone implement. I dont mean we shouldn't follow through, I mean it will take a while (the fight has not even ended in the western, too), so please judge us in a manner fitting our particular circumstances. My cousin is doing a PhD on the level of happiness/life satisfaction of an Asian family. Idk the details but basically Asians are told to grow up well, study well at a good uni, find a good company to work at, marry well, have kids, spend your day working, your evening preparing for work tomorrow, your night resting, and your weekend for your family/friends. Generally, Asians live up to this 'advice of life' well. Like, there is a fixed definiton of live well, die well, and Asians are OK with it. But is that all enough to be happy/satisfied? In the west, you've got self-actualization, etc etc. Studying in a higher edu institution is an option. Working in a company is such one tiny option (out of so various many). Marrying is an option. Having kids is an option, etc etc etc. Honestly, for people whose lives have been simple, and thus, who have learned to think simply, such a life is already meaningful enough. Everything is not an option, everything is such a natural to do, just like breathing, but everything is happy/satisfying enough. It's only when we're faced with the standards of others that we may have a change of heart, a change of ways of thinking. Again, I'm not saying it's a bad or a good thing, but there is A GAP. Of course a gap is something we can gradually close but it won't happen overnight. There is a poet I used to admire, Atticus, in one interview he mentioned how he was sad/upset because people were starting to write poems for the sake of profit/fame because the (online)poetry industry was growing & looking promising. He complained about the low quality writing. On the one hand, he is a professional so I understand he said it based on his skills, experience, professionalism AND genuine love towards poetry. Some times it's easy to tell, even for amateurs, when a singing voice is bad, a song is lacking, an acting skill is non-existent. So such lacks must be easy to get spotted by professionals. There will be people whose JOB is to say the HARSH things in a STRICT way, in order to produce quality works. On the other hand, I was heartbroken when I read the interview because I liked writing poetry, too (still do). Tho I dont make a business out of it, I know my writing sucks and I felt I was among those who had been disappointing poem writers. - Nevertheless, just because his skills are Ferrari-level, does it mean it's ok to discourage people whose skills are Mitsubishi Mirage-level? To tell them to stop writing? (Idk about cars, but I googled and found that Ferrari can be the best car and Mirage has got negative reviews😅🙏🙏) What I'm trying to say is, without undermining the importance of EDUCATION (so people dont stay ignorance), I do believe OFTEN TIMES everyone is judged TOO HARSHLY by everyone else. In this case, AK is judged harshly. People can say I'm biased because I like AK's type of music. Well, they can think whatever they want to think. I know I do my best to be objective.
his rapping is really good but i got goosebumps when he started to sing, was really good! also very good that he apologized like this, its difficult as it takes a lot of courage to do so!
soooo much respect for him! for everyone who still hates him because of his irresponsible actions when he was younger, i'm not excusing this at all, but he's matured and become a better person since then. i think it's also really evident that he's extremely talented so let's not hate on him and appreciate who he is now!!
also the way he apologized is very honest, smart and courageous ! he made his apology on such a big stage, in front of those he once dissed while trying to become an idol. he made a diss track against idols when he was young and now he made another track to say sorry. if people aren't still forgiving him, i bet they never made a mistake and never had the need and the courage (and the skills) to apologize in front of millions but also directly to those he once direspected
Y'all I'm going to be honest I don't like him at first since my friend is a fan of the group that he dissed and she really hate him and told me his issue and I see most of twitter stans hate him. But when I fully watched all the episodes of Chuang, I didn't know that he apologized already until I saw this part. Let's just say not all, will accept his apology but do you really have to stay with hatred ?? He has a lot of friends inside the camp and that really shows that he changed. People change. Give him a chance. He's talented and cute too. I really regret saying that he didn't deserved to be forgiven bcs of what he did when I didn't know the truth :(( pls vote for AK!
Idc what ppl say cus AK deserves the spot on the top 11. He apologized for his actions in such a sincere way and he worked so hard these past few months to improve himself. AK JIAYOU! DONT LISTEN TO THE HATERS AND DONT LET THEM DRAG YOU DOWN!
Nothing to do with admitting his mistakes, but this performance was lit. I love his flow and the sudden burst made me excited.Definitely a very talented rapper and the lyrics are 🔥🔥.
Back than he were young and naive. Since he seems to be sincere when he apologizing, i forgive him. Beside he is cute and can write his own song. Definitely want him to make it to top 11.
@@rebeccaloo06 but I think u should know that he diss them because fans of npc diss one the rapper name 法老 at first and caused his song couldn't being uploaded in any platform. Imagine how did u feel when ur idol song couldn't even release because of the other critical comments
I respect people who admit their own mistakes and apologize openly without asking for forgiveness. We all learn from our past mistakes and there is no single human being on this earth who is perfect. I understand if you don't accept his apology but please stop making up false accusations and spread fake rumours just because you dislike him. If you really hate him, then don't look at his news or listen to his songs. Stop being a malicious keyboard warriors and focus on improving yourself as an individual in real life. Peace & love!
I honestly think he has become a much better and mature person. Why else would he participate to be part of a program that is aiming to debut a boy group that he personally dissed few years back? In his lyrics, he stated he chose the biggest stage to come forward and admit his mistakes and take responsibility for his actions that hurt others. It would be contradicting if he decided to participate in this show and a huge hypocrite if he didn't do this to prove his thoughts and views has changed. This shouldn't be a reason to bury his talent after how big of a person he is to come forward and apologize. Freaken explosive and emotional rapper. He was a victim to his own hatred towards bullies and didn't know any better and became one himself. He's had time to reflect. It's probably why he's on that stage now to dedicate this apology nationwide. We are all guilty of writing and saying hate speech online but it never occurs to us how much it can hurt a person who reads them. Can you do what he did? Doubt it.
all I know is he dissed a boy group can I know what the name of this group ...... I'm clueless....... But if is very sensitive to say the name of a group .... Then I understand.......
@@unprettysquad5846 I don't know which boy group he dissed. From the way they describe it on the show, he dissed boy groups in general or at least the concept of boy groups and the way they function/work.
@@cii-d5j yeahh I already know it's 9 percent but I thought lil ghost is the one he really want to diss....... But I'm wrong? Btw did kun and the group respond about that?
Sooo cute, this just made him more charming. Everyone makes mistakes and certainly have written mean comments online at least once. He regrets it, apologized and it's time to move on! Jiayou ❤❤❤
I don't know the details of his mistake... aside from what's mentioned in the show, but... people should take it in mind that apologizing on a big stage like on a show like this is a double-edged sword. If the viewer(me included) sees and feels his sincerity and are open to forgiving others for their mistakes because of being young and immature then... that's what you will see, but if the viewer does not think they are sincere and is just using it to gain votes (or whatever negative thoughts that come to mind) then that is how the viewer sees it. Respect to him for taking the courage to apologize and if he knew what it meant to apologize that there will be those that believe it and those that won't. He has already done what he has set out to do and that's to apologize. Good for him and may he continue to become a better version of himself.
This rap legitimately almost made me cry... especially when you understand the lyrics and you can just feel the regret and sorrow and apology for what he did in the past 😭😭😭 he is definitely one of my pick for this season with the Japanese trainees
i like his rap performance and i think he deserves better, its not easy to smile in front of everyone like this, he is so strong that's why i wanna cheer him up and vote for him to debut
I know about his mistake, know it was too severe. But he has the courage to say it here. It's very credible. And he's just 21 on all of that. I respect him for that. And I hope he's really meant this apology and changed to be a better person.
Everyone makes mistakes. He was young, and it happens. Not everyone has the balls to stand up on stage - in front of the whole world, recorded for posterity, no less - and apologise, even dissing himself in the process. That aside, this guy can rap AND sing! He'll prob have haters haunting him for his whole career, but that's also a testament to his ability. After all, if he were a nobody, who would waste time hating on him?
The special thing about him is that he actually really regrets his mistake. Some people don’t even feel sorry for what they did but he does. The fact that he had the courage to come out here even tho he knows about everyone knowing about his rumors. He came out really great and admitted his mistake. A lot of people still hate him after this but it’s all on them. He s one of the special contestants because he’s willing to come out and admit to his mistake so he can start over. Stan this kid!
I can actually hear every word, i'm surprised. It's what I like best in a rapper, to be able to understand what they say, because lyrics is important, their message is what they are trying to convey afterall
The phrase is shocking I was bullied at school and i move this hate through internet Everyone who diss him , just watch the surface of the icerberg , he made a mistake but you have to ssee all . He is really supporting and empathy please vote for him 🤩🤩
When HanJiang kept on observing AK's action in his position 😂😂😂. I laughed at his expression. That line he said that AK is way different as to what people said on weibo.
It makes me laugh that this moment is used by the antis to spread their hatred of ak, saying that hanjiang hates him but they seem not to know that they are good friends hahaha.
my fav performance of ep1 🥰 very moving story and he is brave enough to face his past mistakes. there's soul and personality to AK, wish to see more from him!
There was no denying that what he had done in the past caused hurt to other people. However, he brings his apology to a big stage so that everyone can see it, can see he now can bear the responsibility for what he did. What a man! I like him!
kinda sad when i see some ppl (or many) in twt still can't accept his apology, but i respect whatever they said but still, i respect AK more, i'll always support him, not everyone can apologize from their mistake. Everyone can change , we can give him a chance, jiayou AK!
Idc if you still hate AK or cannot accept his apology but the fact that he bravely admit his mistakes and tries to get better is way much more than the one who never admits their mistakes well leave out the apology tho
本来不听rap这种音乐，但他唱得也太好听了吧 词写得好好，太帅了
他不止一次道歉耶
我覺得很有誠意
有看過別的訪問他也有很認真的提過
而且如果有看創造營的其他節目
他是個連玩遊戲犯了錯都會誠摯的跟伙伴道歉的人
每个人都做过错，可是不是每个人都会为自己的错误道歉。我原谅你了✨
AK的rap吐字很清晰 歌詞也寫得很感性 真的感覺得出他在吐露整個心路歷程
0:41 聽到這真的嚇到我了 副歌切的很完美 情緒都刻在歌聲上了..
很少聽到rap能讓人聽到想哭 只能說這首原創已經是頂配了 只差還沒有發行
Well everybody make mistakes but not everyone apologize for their mistake, AK deserve to be educated for all his mistakes and I know he is the sweetest when he see yu yang perform. People do change and learned from their mistakes sometimes. I believe there must be a reason to why he does those mistakes
+My guy debuted
+Ak hella talented this man can sing, rap and make his own music
+just keep hating on him or whatever its not like he will *UNDEBUT* kbye
+ his kind that he support his friends 😻
@@simpingfornene9821 OMG YESSS, +the way he just hyping and smile brightly while other trainee performing is just cute too
♥ω♥
@@__urlocalearthling Yesss his smile really cute😻🙈
I love his smile and everytime he watch other trainees you'll know he adores them. He always looks like a proud dad when the other trainees show their talents
he deserves to debut, a boyband group needs a member like him who good at singing , dancing and rapping
他rap 吐字很清楚， 超好听，听了无数次。
错了就改，每个人都会有犯错的，我相信你刘漳AK一定会成功的
Song by LiuZhang
Lyrics by LiuZhang
Music/ Rhythm by LiuZhang
LiuZhang 100% Genius Artist
"Many people cannot accept your Letter of Apology. How do you respond to this?"
AK: "I think it's normal there are people who cannot accept my apology. If I were so easily forgiven, the price of making mistakes would be too low. All I can do is to keep going and show that I'm doing my best with my deeds. The Letter of Apology is only a beginning".
We may say people will never change. "If he was a jerk back then, he must be a jerk now too". But are we being honest when we say that? Do we really believe people never change? Ultimately, people do change. For the better or the worse.
Idk AK personally so whether he truly changes for the better, I will never truly know. But I personally feel the boy's sincerity and I hope the people who have been hurt can eventually forgive him. And I hope he forgives himself, too. His apology was courageous. He IS courageous.
👍👍👍
I am a nine percent fan, I hate him so much back then and now what the duck he's one of my pick
[sorry if this is too lengthy, i have no one to talk to abt this]
i totally agree with you, but then another mistake happen, causing me to stop for a while... if yall didnt know, he said the r slur in the werewolf episode. i was so shocked when i saw that on twitter.. shocked, sad and disappointed since i dont condone ppl who just use that word freely bc i was taught to never say that word if you are to downgrade someone for their intellectual capacity. just dont use that word at all unless ofc if the context is diff.. (like for fire retardant.. etc)
i liked him so much, he is one of my top picks. i loved his courageous act in this apology letter performance. i cant really say so much abt his past doings bc i am new in the cpop scene, but i still liked him, bc he owned his mistakes, he let himself eat his own words on the big stage with knowing that he could reach new fans of the show... he is literally exposing himself to them, but still went on bc he knew he went wrong before and wanted to do a public apology.
but after the next said incident, my heart broke and it pains lol fjkhdk i stopped posting abt him and stopped liking contents that has his face or name, many are hating him... but honestly... deep inside, i cant really hate him so much bc it made me think of my first impression to him and all those good comments from the trainees to him. he is a good team mate and a friend, he is someone that can be depended on. he is bold at times but humble too... also he has undeniably good talent.
so i thought, with that mistake, we cant really say that he is a bad person, we dont know him personally just like any other trainees on the show. it was also said that the r slur in chinese is not really dealt srsly by their ppl but still being used to describe a person who is mentally atypical.
im not saying this to say that i support what he did or that i forgave him. no. he used an ableist language but doesnt really mean that he is one... those who hates him to the guts should also reflect to themselves if they too used similar words before or now, even tho they are already familiar with ableism...
i am too reflecting on myself bc i probably said similar words on the internet but since many people are also using those words (not really just the r slur, but other similar ones too like dumb, lame, crazy, insane etc.) it tends to be overlooked.... its sad but thats whats happening...
i dont think i can post my opinions like this on twt since my mutuals are already hating him so much and cancelling him, i dont think i can face that much negativity if i did share... and also some of them are my friends too, so im very sorry if this was vvv lengthy.. right now, im still torned honestly. he has high ranks atm, so if he actually make it to the finals or even make it to the group, i'll still support them as a whole, including him... as long as he is going to be a good team mate, thats all that matters ig djksdks
i also hope that one day he will see and realize this mistake of his and slowly change for the better.... im also saying this to everyone, including myself :)) lets be more cautious than we are today..
have a nice day and pls stan hu yetao and boyuan hehe
@@yujinpeach Hi, since you're a fan of nine percent, can you please tell me the title of the song? I'm sorry if it makess you re-open an old wound, but on twitter I read that people are the angriest because "Justin was still a minor and it was disgusting of him to say those things to a minor". AK is like 3 years older than Justin, right? So, when he was 18, Justin was 15 (when the problematic song came out). Yes, in terms of age, AK was an adult, while Justin was still a minor, but I was wondering how much difference people expected his thinking to be? I'm just trying to understand a little bit more of the situation, because I refuse to believe that AK is through and thorugh a manipulator (and I'm willingly manipulated). I feel if I can hear the song and rea the English Translation, I can approach it differently based on my intelligence amd belief (rather than because of what people say on twitter). Thank you 🙏🙏
@@ai-tn5wd Hi, Kimchi (is it ok if I address you so?) You can call me Nature/ Nat. There's NOTHING to be sorry about. I really do APPRECIATE you spending your time and energy to write such a genuine respond, so I really do THANK YOU. Biggest tightest cuddliest hugs from the other side of the globe, I hope they can help you feel better and less sad about the whole situation, even only a little bit 🤗🤗🤗
I reckon what you say here is true to yourself, to what you believe about AK (the positives and negatives), and to your feelings about the fact that some irl people you care about are hating on a musician you're fond of.
Please, brace yourself, this' gonna be lengthy😅🙏🙏
I believe it's a matter of cultural difference. Without undermining the weight of ableism, of using disability slurs, it's an unfortunate fact there are many cultures whose people still utter such words on regular basis, including China. There is a GAP of knowledge, of understanding, of ways of thinking&doing things.
- I grew up in a culture where saying "Stupid girl, silly boy, are you a moron?" is NOTHING that is SUPPOSED to be regarded as hurtful. It doesn't mean it IS NOT hurtful. We just have to accept it and move on with our daily lives. It's a regular occurance (I never live in any country where English is spoken, so Idk whether the equivalence happens, too, there). So, some of us can take a purposeful step AWAY from ableism ONLY BECAUSE we HAVE LEARNED and have a certain level of understanding about it.
- I dont speak Chinese, but you remember in Santa's vlog, he asked AK, "What is the Chinese word for 'stupid'?" And AK answered, "Ben dan", and Santa said, "AK shi ben dan". They just laughed it off. There are also interviews of the J-trainees and everyone told the story when Yuu was stuck in locker, everyone's like, "Baka janai no? Isn't Yuu such a fool??" and laughed it off. When Yuu was eliminated and everyone said, "Ganbatte!" Yuu answered, "You guys are the ones who should ganbatte, aren't you guys stupid??" and said goodbye happily. It's such a regular thing in Japanese conversation, too, among close friends/family (I dont speak Japanese but have watched enough anime&J-drama to recognize it😅).
Another situations of insensitivity and ignorance. Reflections of GAP of knowledge, of understanding, of ways of thinking&doing things:
- Fu Shichao said, "Nine has gained weight again" (reminding your friend to maintain their weight is ok among close friends), but after Nine said something, Shichao furthered,
"Hey, look, the fatboy is talking to you🤣🤣" When it came to this point, it was NOT OK;
-Liu Yu says his standard of beauty is white/fair skin. While I believe it's ok for people to have preferences, I dont think it's ok for someone (who is on a platform where young audience pay attn to him, LOOK UP to him) to make a statement that implies 'things other than white/fair skin is not beautiful' (or not beautiful ENOUGH);
- Some Thai BL actors dont actually support PRIDE/LGBTQ++ community (the irony, the hypocrisy);
- Some relative told his gay nephew, "I know everyone is equal before God and only HE has the right to punish sinful people 'like you', but I wish to break your neck so you could get punished quicker!";
- Some KPOP male idol say misoginic/sexist statement, "If I have a son one day, I'll give him everything so he'll grow well, if I have a daughter I'll beat her and lock her at home";
- My parents suggested that I prayed more&be closer to God rather than going to a psychiatry to treat my adhd&depression, "Why seek help from fellow mortal(s) when the Mighty Immortal can give you everything you need?" they asked...
Well, there's just so much of what's been fought for in western countries that have not even started here in eastern countries. There's too much of what people see are judged based on western standards. When I say 'western standards', I dont mean they are bad, I mean they are still difficult to understand, let alone implement. I dont mean we shouldn't follow through, I mean it will take a while (the fight has not even ended in the western, too), so please judge us in a manner fitting our particular circumstances.
My cousin is doing a PhD on the level of happiness/life satisfaction of an Asian family. Idk the details but basically Asians are told to grow up well, study well at a good uni, find a good company to work at, marry well, have kids, spend your day working, your evening preparing for work tomorrow, your night resting, and your weekend for your family/friends. Generally, Asians live up to this 'advice of life' well. Like, there is a fixed definiton of live well, die well, and Asians are OK with it. But is that all enough to be happy/satisfied? In the west, you've got self-actualization, etc etc. Studying in a higher edu institution is an option. Working in a company is such one tiny option (out of so various many). Marrying is an option. Having kids is an option, etc etc etc.
Honestly, for people whose lives have been simple, and thus, who have learned to think simply, such a life is already meaningful enough. Everything is not an option, everything is such a natural to do, just like breathing, but everything is happy/satisfying enough.
It's only when we're faced with the standards of others that we may have a change of heart, a change of ways of thinking. Again, I'm not saying it's a bad or a good thing, but there is A GAP.
Of course a gap is something we can gradually close but it won't happen overnight.
There is a poet I used to admire, Atticus, in one interview he mentioned how he was sad/upset because people were starting to write poems for the sake of profit/fame because the (online)poetry industry was growing & looking promising. He complained about the low quality writing.
On the one hand, he is a professional so I understand he said it based on his skills, experience, professionalism AND genuine love towards poetry. Some times it's easy to tell, even for amateurs, when a singing voice is bad, a song is lacking, an acting skill is non-existent. So such lacks must be easy to get spotted by professionals. There will be people whose JOB is to say the HARSH things in a STRICT way, in order to produce quality works.
On the other hand, I was heartbroken when I read the interview because I liked writing poetry, too (still do). Tho I dont make a business out of it, I know my writing sucks and I felt I was among those who had been disappointing poem writers.
- Nevertheless, just because his skills are Ferrari-level, does it mean it's ok to discourage people whose skills are Mitsubishi Mirage-level? To tell them to stop writing?
(Idk about cars, but I googled and found that Ferrari can be the best car and Mirage has got negative reviews😅🙏🙏)
What I'm trying to say is, without undermining the importance of EDUCATION (so people dont stay ignorance), I do believe
OFTEN TIMES
everyone is judged
TOO HARSHLY
by everyone else.
In this case, AK is judged harshly.
People can say I'm biased because I like AK's type of music. Well, they can think whatever they want to think. I know I do my best to be objective.
He can't only rap but also sing very well!! I loved this performance! In my opinion he deserves to be A-ranked
Agree
Yass! 💗
+1
I agree!! I want to hear his singing voice more!
+1
his rapping is really good but i got goosebumps when he started to sing, was really good! also very good that he apologized like this, its difficult as it takes a lot of courage to do so!
Got goosebumps the same time 😂😱
Same!!
love his rapping, rhyme so much
没人吹这首原创也很好听吗！
超好听！！！
对！很好听，他的rap一直都很好听，旋律很好。
副歌很好很好很好
好好听🥰
比奧斯卡好好多
太棒了！！吐字太清楚了。
會道歉嘅男仔真係好型
soooo much respect for him! for everyone who still hates him because of his irresponsible actions when he was younger, i'm not excusing this at all, but he's matured and become a better person since then. i think it's also really evident that he's extremely talented so let's not hate on him and appreciate who he is now!!
also the way he apologized is very honest, smart and courageous ! he made his apology on such a big stage, in front of those he once dissed while trying to become an idol. he made a diss track against idols when he was young and now he made another track to say sorry.
if people aren't still forgiving him, i bet they never made a mistake and never had the need and the courage (and the skills) to apologize in front of millions but also directly to those he once direspected
@@saltedfish2192 who did he diss?
@@pinkeubit1019 It is said that he actually used to diss the idol boy group and now, he's apologizing for that behaviour as he realized his mistake...
@@pinkeubit1019 nine percent
What did he do
他是少有的rapper里面吐字最清楚的
army~
@@namnis1831 yesss
对对对对! 唯一一个我不用一直读着字幕的选手
真的，其他人的rap都含糊不清
而且断句不会断的很懒
@@a_lee8324 对吧 我每次听别人唱rap都不知道他们在说什么
刘彰真的很棒，我觉得以后不论做什么他一定会成功的！
其实ak私底下跟其他学员相处的时候真的很可爱
❣❣❣liu zhang fanclub from 🇹🇭🇹🇭
先不管之前發生什麼事
憑他敢做敢當
在舞台上的實力，才華，魅力
我支持他
No matter what haters say AK deserved his place in INTO1 ✊🏻
初舞台一聽到就路轉粉了 太好聽了 鴨鴨衝吖
他長得不帥,但很有特色,
我因為別的視頻而去看了創4,
前面不管表演好的不好的,我就驚訝無言一下
直到看到他的道歉信,我居然哭了???(我尼瑪我根本不認識他誰)
那個迷霧開始,我沒看到它發光,但是我看到了救贖
不知道他未來發展好不好,至少現在這時刻的他讓人難以忘記
我粉上他的時候也沒有想到他現在長這麼帥了🤣
長得蠻帥的 我覺得哈哈哈哈哈
Ak現在蠻帥的
第一次看到覺得他並不起眼，但不知道是不是他的內涵還有特色，越看越覺得他很耐看也蠻喜歡他的
雖然不知道他之前發生過了什麼，也沒有特別喜歡rap，但是不得不說，他每次的原創副歌都很觸動到我，很厲害。
Y'all I'm going to be honest I don't like him at first since my friend is a fan of the group that he dissed and she really hate him and told me his issue and I see most of twitter stans hate him. But when I fully watched all the episodes of Chuang, I didn't know that he apologized already until I saw this part. Let's just say not all, will accept his apology but do you really have to stay with hatred ?? He has a lot of friends inside the camp and that really shows that he changed. People change. Give him a chance. He's talented and cute too. I really regret saying that he didn't deserved to be forgiven bcs of what he did when I didn't know the truth :(( pls vote for AK!
Thank you for saying this! I hope more people can have their own thinking after they really understand the story.. instead of being a hater.
Idc what ppl say cus AK deserves the spot on the top 11. He apologized for his actions in such a sincere way and he worked so hard these past few months to improve himself. AK JIAYOU! DONT LISTEN TO THE HATERS AND DONT LET THEM DRAG YOU DOWN!
Nothing to do with admitting his mistakes, but this performance was lit. I love his flow and the sudden burst made me excited.Definitely a very talented rapper and the lyrics are 🔥🔥.
首秀最精彩就是这个rap了，咬字清晰，flow好，词真诚，而且表现迎刃有余，完全effortless。
Back than he were young and naive. Since he seems to be sincere when he apologizing, i forgive him. Beside he is cute and can write his own song. Definitely want him to make it to top 11.
What mistake did he make? Sorry just curious..
@@rebeccaloo06 he dissed boygroup but idk who
@@Erika-sf7gp ohh noted ty!
@Nicole Chen ohh noted, ty!
@@rebeccaloo06 but I think u should know that he diss them because fans of npc diss one the rapper name 法老 at first and caused his song couldn't being uploaded in any platform. Imagine how did u feel when ur idol song couldn't even release because of the other critical comments
能够道歉知道自己的错误是一个非常好的事情
超级帅
他应该出道偶像。因为他的rap最棒了
先聽到他的流言蜚語挺討厭他的，但是第一次看他的舞台我愛上了🥺現在只想給他一人撐腰
还有一票给赞多或者力丸吧，两个都是实力派，重点是他们两个都是AK的好兄弟
@@eagleeyeseeu 我不會投他們兩個 他們兩個不缺我的票啦哈哈哈 我投給了胡燁韜 我覺得他有實力 不需要定義男團 🥺 我覺得他很棒 說起劉彰兄弟我當初也是投給了于洋😢他淘汰了🥲太難過
我喜欢这个rap呢
I respect people who admit their own mistakes and apologize openly without asking for forgiveness. We all learn from our past mistakes and there is no single human being on this earth who is perfect. I understand if you don't accept his apology but please stop making up false accusations and spread fake rumours just because you dislike him. If you really hate him, then don't look at his news or listen to his songs. Stop being a malicious keyboard warriors and focus on improving yourself as an individual in real life. Peace & love!
會道歉的男生很帥
真的!!!
................
rapper不能说对不起
@@zewenyang1661 靠 戳到我笑點😂
（小太陽又出來照耀人間了嗎😂）
@@zewenyang1661 rapper不能说对不起但可以写道歉信XD
第一次看到AK觉得他可能只是为了红来的节目, 但是AK的道歉信真的有惊艳到我, 后面的加试, 二创也很棒. AK的谈吐里也可以看出他其实是一个会想很多的人, 有点自卑但是努力做好自己的事情. 虽然不知道AK会不会成团, 但是希望他能一直坚持创作. 加油~
他的rap是我听过所有rapper里面让我最爽的。我很喜欢他歌曲里的内容，他的词都很好，尤其是这首歌还有《你笑起来真好看》，曲也很好听
I honestly think he has become a much better and mature person. Why else would he participate to be part of a program that is aiming to debut a boy group that he personally dissed few years back? In his lyrics, he stated he chose the biggest stage to come forward and admit his mistakes and take responsibility for his actions that hurt others. It would be contradicting if he decided to participate in this show and a huge hypocrite if he didn't do this to prove his thoughts and views has changed. This shouldn't be a reason to bury his talent after how big of a person he is to come forward and apologize. Freaken explosive and emotional rapper. He was a victim to his own hatred towards bullies and didn't know any better and became one himself. He's had time to reflect. It's probably why he's on that stage now to dedicate this apology nationwide. We are all guilty of writing and saying hate speech online but it never occurs to us how much it can hurt a person who reads them. Can you do what he did? Doubt it.
all I know is he dissed a boy group can I know what the name of this group ...... I'm clueless....... But if is very sensitive to say the name of a group .... Then I understand.......
@@unprettysquad5846 I don't know which boy group he dissed. From the way they describe it on the show, he dissed boy groups in general or at least the concept of boy groups and the way they function/work.
@@diaryanjo ahhh okkk.....
@@unprettysquad5846 nine percent, specifically cai xu kun
@@cii-d5j yeahh I already know it's 9 percent but I thought lil ghost is the one he really want to diss....... But I'm wrong? Btw did kun and the group respond about that?
Way too good. Responsible for his behaviour. Even gave his buddy a chance to perform. Perfect example.
天ㄚ 副歌超好聽
副歌部分我真的一直在无限循环！
00:41 cry 😭😭😭
IKR
Yee
你真的很有勇氣，雖然不知道你們經歷了什麼，也沒有資格說人們應該原諒你，但AK你做的真棒
Sooo cute, this just made him more charming. Everyone makes mistakes and certainly have written mean comments online at least once. He regrets it, apologized and it's time to move on!
Jiayou ❤❤❤
整个创造营2021我最爱的歌就是道歉信，从这一刻我一直在期待刘彰成团！
总决赛还唱一首，虽然和这个不太一样，但同样精彩，赞👍🏻
Please vote for him at tencent...he is ranked 11 now:( he deserves better...
i. vote him everyday at wetv
@@sunyutongyvette4574 do you use the international or china version of the app?
@@sunyutongyvette4574 install wetv, find chuang, click the result, you’ll see where to vote and click
@@sunyutongyvette4574 the first voting round has ended. the second voting round will start this weekend (maybe)
International fans can vote??
他在舞台上的时候整个人都在发光！ak前途无限！！！
Ak Liu Zhang is my favourite contestant in Chuang2021. He can rap and sing really well.
I don't know the details of his mistake... aside from what's mentioned in the show, but... people should take it in mind that apologizing on a big stage like on a show like this is a double-edged sword. If the viewer(me included) sees and feels his sincerity and are open to forgiving others for their mistakes because of being young and immature then... that's what you will see, but if the viewer does not think they are sincere and is just using it to gain votes (or whatever negative thoughts that come to mind) then that is how the viewer sees it.
Respect to him for taking the courage to apologize and if he knew what it meant to apologize that there will be those that believe it and those that won't. He has already done what he has set out to do and that's to apologize. Good for him and may he continue to become a better version of himself.
This rap legitimately almost made me cry... especially when you understand the lyrics and you can just feel the regret and sorrow and apology for what he did in the past 😭😭😭 he is definitely one of my pick for this season with the Japanese trainees
his rap, strong and stable voice with that smile oh dear he deserves the best
真的喜欢上他的rap 和他的勇敢
My favorite performance from the 1st episode
AK小太阳🌞，我的pick!
Stan Ak Liu Zhang! Someone who knows how to own up to his past mistakes and learn from it.
これを見た時めっちゃびっくりした凄い圧倒された！！WeTVのVIPに入ってAKの可愛さに気が付いた
Well, because of AK, I fell in love with rap. I stan you, dude. I felt your music too.
i like his rap performance and i think he deserves better, its not easy to smile in front of everyone like this, he is so strong that's why i wanna cheer him up and vote for him to debut
他真的很有才華，看完整個創造營2021後更喜歡這位選手，不但講義氣做人又直率，希望以前罵過他的人也好，能夠看到他真正的模樣，永遠支持你！👍👍👍
I know about his mistake, know it was too severe. But he has the courage to say it here. It's very credible. And he's just 21 on all of that. I respect him for that. And I hope he's really meant this apology and changed to be a better person.
我可能會關注他，很好!
對不認識的陌生人攻擊
早就自責想公開道歉
我惡毒的話帶來的衝擊
超越我想像沒有資格抱怨
我承認 那些批評
我承認 我的錯誤
我承認曾經想法畸形
我會讓這些都落幕
自稱厭惡暴力但我從來都沒有想過
在校園裡面經歷我把它又帶進網絡
幼稚的憤怒和所謂真實
演變成不尊重
別裝可憐了 AK
Diss他人自己也該承受
但不夠力氣掙脫我身上的線
收到的要求裡面 寫著
噓 閉嘴 我好討厭
歉意都不能表現
不想用所謂的公關技巧
來幫我擋子彈
責任由自己背負
做敢彎腰的男子漢
讓我扒開那層霧
讓全世界都看清楚
那些我說過的話所有的錯誤
我並不打算逃避或找藉口
與過去擁抱邂逅
所有的過錯就由今天的我自己接手
由diss 開始 請讓我diss me來結束
一直等待
因為不想把道歉信放在別處
我不渴求原諒
但我至少不想把歉意堵埋
說我沒擔當冷處理
就把道歉信帶上最大的舞台
Everyone makes mistakes. He was young, and it happens. Not everyone has the balls to stand up on stage - in front of the whole world, recorded for posterity, no less - and apologise, even dissing himself in the process. That aside, this guy can rap AND sing! He'll prob have haters haunting him for his whole career, but that's also a testament to his ability. After all, if he were a nobody, who would waste time hating on him?
我超喜欢他的，AK加油💪🏻
The special thing about him is that he actually really regrets his mistake. Some people don’t even feel sorry for what they did but he does. The fact that he had the courage to come out here even tho he knows about everyone knowing about his rumors. He came out really great and admitted his mistake. A lot of people still hate him after this but it’s all on them. He s one of the special contestants because he’s willing to come out and admit to his mistake so he can start over. Stan this kid!
I haven't paid any attention to him since I focus only on my picks during the show but now I watch his video he's the best rapper in Chuang💯💯
I think is the first time I fall in love at first sight
I can actually hear every word, i'm surprised. It's what I like best in a rapper, to be able to understand what they say, because lyrics is important, their message is what they are trying to convey afterall
音乐替他说话
AK刘彰加油
The phrase is shocking
I was bullied at school and i move this hate through internet
Everyone who diss him , just watch the surface of the icerberg , he made a mistake but you have to ssee all .
He is really supporting and empathy please vote for him 🤩🤩
His smile is so cute.
When HanJiang kept on observing AK's action in his position 😂😂😂. I laughed at his expression. That line he said that AK is way different as to what people said on weibo.
It makes me laugh that this moment is used by the antis to spread their hatred of ak, saying that hanjiang hates him but they seem not to know that they are good friends hahaha.
AK sorry to get to know you so late: ') you are wonderful AK 💕
聽當時人唱完，作為藝人，已盡了自己能力去表達同釋放積壓數年的包袱。
真的好🙂 ，有幸見到 有承擔的、面對及接納自己少年！🌻🌱 愛您🙆🏻♀️🙆🏻♀️🙆🏻♀️
期待將來的表演，加油哦！
He is so talented.. Wish you can make it to the final 11, AK. Fighting!!!
my fav performance of ep1 🥰 very moving story and he is brave enough to face his past mistakes. there's soul and personality to AK, wish to see more from him!
其實仔細看一下0:02 AK自己也是痛苦的
身為多年的飯圈女孩 剛開始固然生氣
但是AK真的很真誠 我也覺得可以原諒
可能這是很多人心中過不去的結吧 也不強求原諒
只希望網暴停在這裡就好 不要再更多了拜託
And that's how he stole my heart😊
He's the best
Please vote for him on WeTV🥺🙏🏻✨ He has ability&idol materials enough to debut🔥🔥🔥
I have so much respect for this yes boys so everyone to do a proper apology
There was no denying that what he had done in the past caused hurt to other people. However, he brings his apology to a big stage so that everyone can see it, can see he now can bear the responsibility for what he did. What a man! I like him!
Almost 1 yr.. but Im still obsessed with AK 🖤
kinda sad when i see some ppl (or many) in twt still can't accept his apology, but i respect whatever they said
but still, i respect AK more, i'll always support him, not everyone can apologize from their mistake. Everyone can change , we can give him a chance, jiayou AK!
Idc if you still hate AK or cannot accept his apology but the fact that he bravely admit his mistakes and tries to get better is way much more than the one who never admits their mistakes well leave out the apology tho
What did he do wrong?
He looks like Tablo of EpikHigh. Born to rap and perform, also he's talented even in singing. hope he made it to the group, standout one
he reminds me of b.i, especially with his goofy smile
When he switched from rap to singing I knew this guy would go places cus WOW
他為了這個［道歉信］，才來這個舞台吧，我覺得夠誠意了！雖然查就知道他做錯了什麼，但何必查，我要瞭解是現在的他，是我現在遇到的他......
ak小天使
@@yt-fr4dp wow在哪裡都能看到你在黑AK耶 導演邀他來的 不是他硬來的好嗎 看他在節目裡的一些片段 就能看出他根本是來玩、享受而不是來出道的 導演利用AK蹭個熱度 AK利用這個機會重新來過 人家都道歉了 你還像個惡犬咬著人家不放也是很厲害 說到底還不是NPC讓法老歌曲被下架 身為法老粉絲的AK 不高興就diss了 雖然他錯了 但換作是你們 難道你們偶像歌曲被下架你們不會狂噴大罵嗎 AK只不過是出歌diss而已 但跟你們的行為是一樣的 差在他是出歌罵 你們是在網絡上狂罵 自以為清高啊 呵呵 一開始叫人道歉 人家道了 現在又說人家在蹭熱度 你們的邏輯可真好呢 若換作是別的地下rapper根本沒人會鳥所謂的道歉
@@yt-fr4dp 是導演邀請他來的好嗎 罵人之前先理解實情 別盲目跟著罵 然後他順便在舞台上發表道歉信 這首歌他在很早就準備好了 裡面很多人怕他 但他在別的rapper眼裡還只是個小綿羊 他不是地下rapper 他是山上的rapper
姐妹们你们太厉害了 都让我想不到还有什么可以来怼那位yiting了
@@ting131 啊这 不可以吗 而且我也不是NPC粉丝mmd
I’m respect him very very much✊🏻. Not everyone dare to apologise and say about the mistakes that has did before. Support and 很尊重 💘
有责任有担当，respect～瑞思拜！
道歉信一周年快樂 一年了我還是好喜歡這首歌 AK劉彰繼續加油!!!
He deserves a better ranking. Plz support him
Really love his attitude! Love this song, too. He is not afraid of haters, me neither.
听了整整10遍太好听
👇
AK的歉意真的很感人。我希望大家真的可以撇开过去、原谅他、给他一个机会。不要继续吐他了 ~~~~(>_
His smile is too cute..and his abilities wowwwww
我以前不喜歡rap，但是AK的這首歌，讓我重新認識rap原來可以那麼美好
超喜欢AK的rap。他写的词很棒。我几乎只看AK的rap
相信他一定会成功的。加油(ง •_•)ง
I have to be honest, he's a genius and gifted!
AK AMAZING
恭喜Ak成功出道❤️