ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2024
- [뮤비 코멘터리] 몬스타엑스 - 걸어
[MV Commentary] MONSTA X - ALL IN
Hello, K-POP Followers !!
M/V MONSTA X "ALL IN" Commentary and MONSTA X's M/V behind story~ !!!!
오늘의 MV 코멘터리 주인공은 '몬스타엑스'
몬스타엑스가 직접 나와 말해주는 뮤직비디오 비하인드 스토리!!!
코멘터리 최초!! 들었는데 더 모르겠는, 분명 들었는데 더 어려운 코멘터리
몬스타엑스 ALL IN 의 미궁속으로 빠지게 될끄얏 ㅋㅋ
#2.5부작이니 다음편 꼭 꼭 기다려 달래요
#뮤비코멘터리 #MVCommentary
More from #M2? :D
Facebook: / mnetm2
Twitter: / m2mpd
Instagram: / m2mpd
![Idol Weekly Interview with MONSTA X [KBS World Idol Show K-rush2 / 2017.11.24]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/noWbEYhNBqc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol Weekly Interview with MONSTA X [KBS World Idol Show K-rush2 / 2017.11.24]](/img/tr.png)
![[Today′s Room] (ENG) MONSTA X Challenge to 'Aegyo' Show! 150916 EP.7](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CMRMdvhx1yk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[몬채널][B] EP18. THE CLAN PART.1 LOST 걸어 (ALL IN) MV](/img/n.gif)
When Hyungwon is the main character in the MV alongside with Minhyuk but he didn't understand a thing about it 😂
yes hahahaha
@Bryant Maverick ok you're most likely a bot but that's so messed up. you're invading her privacy :/
hyungwon : I really don't understand anything
ME TOO. hyungwon representing all munbebes
555555555555
*Monbebe
But his story/his and minhyuk's is one of the main stories in the mv lol and he doesn't understand 😂😂😂
I swear Hyungwon is us tbh, we are confused as him 😂
when did he say that???
Reasons why you're here:
1. It's monsta x
2. HyungWonho at the thumbnail
3. You need someone to explain the mystery in the music video
all
tru😂
Yasss!! Especially 2.
Accurate lmao
number 2 is the main reason. that otp is literally my soul.
05:41 Kihyun said "nyam nyam" when the scene showed Hyungwon eat the flower oml i'm died laughing on the floor😂😂😂😂😂
the cutest part
7:15
Wonho: *All I can see are Hyungwon’s lips*
Me: Oh really now...😏😏😏😏
Same. 😂
Hyungwonho shipper mode on
kh : if im monbebe i'll get more confused watching this
wh : if im monbebe i want to hit us one by one
lol
vannya imbie they're right
vannya imbie
Wonho was so right
These are accurate representations 😂
He is the one who isnt giving information. The song and m/v is released and if the "colors" and closing of the eyes had meaning. It wouldnt matter cause the fans you made it for dont know whats going on :/ Wonho got me FRUSTRATED MAN LOL
클랜시리즈 세계관 넘 좋았어요 뮤비에서 애들 연기도 솔직히 데뷔한지 2년차라고 하기엔 정말 자연스러웠구요ㅠㅠㅠ 형원이 눈빛이 모든걸 다했죠..... ㅜㅠ 히어로에서 걸어랑 파이터로 이어지는거 ㅜㅠㅠㅠ 엘게 이후부터 비주얼강조하면서 영상화보급인 뮤비도 진짜진짜 황송하고 감동이지만 드라마타이즈 소취합니다ㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠ 더 커넥트 뮤직필름도 진짜.... ㅜㅠ
NO ONE TALKED ABOUT CHANGKI SCENE IM LEAVING
Changki scene is my fav 💓
i feel u
Same it's my fav
totally agree!
ikr.
lol they said they wounldn't explain everything but it's the first time a group explained this much
ferial l
The explain everything in circles probably mostly because they want you to come up with your own conclusion
Is no one going to talk about Hyungwon almost falling @ 6:12 and Wonho supporting him. Wah~ HyungWonho is real! And @ 15:06 Kihyun surprises Jooheon. HAHAHAHAHAHA
OMGG I KNOW RIGHTTT!!! EVEN WHILE HES TALKING OMGGGGG!
wonho has a hyungwon radar ahaha
I was looking for this kinda comment 👌👌
Wonho look like a mom with her amigas and then there is her son hyungwon playing
Wonho is always there to catch hyungwon. My ship sailing since no mercy. Hwh forever peace ♥️
when the subs abandon you half way....
it's here noooow
Hahahahahaa yup I can relate
HYUNGWONHO IS ALIVE AND KICKING LIKE YASS BLESS MY SOUL WITH HYUNGWONHO.
It's still sailing
Wonho looks so scandalized seeing Minhyuk and Hyungwon in the tub hahahaha
Jealousy 😂
A LiTTLe jEaLOUsYYYYYY
진짜 볼때마다 느끼지만 석이 되게 세계관 잘 이해하고있어서 매 무대마다 컨셉되게 잘 나타내주는거같다 소화가 완벽하다고 해야하나 무대에서 표출하는게 ㄹㅈㄷ 사랑한다 몬스타엑스❤️
6:13 when hyungwon was about to but he wasn't, and wonho was trying to catch him but late lol, these cuties
I'm crying because I can't understand anything.
I'm smiling because I can't understand anything.
I'm lost because I can't understand anything.
I'm laughing my ass out because I can't understand anything.
I'm dying because I can't understand anything.
I JUST CAN'T UNDERSTAND ANYTHING...
sameeee hahaha
You have english subtitles here
www.dailymotion.com/video/x4fxzba_eng-sub-mv-commentary-monsta-x-all-in_fun
Marina Mandek I've already watch it. ^^ Thanks!
same same.......
pffttt😂😂😂 yeah me too😂😂😂
First of all, there were a few hints given by MX about the MV itself. Wonho mentioned that the members who had their eyes open (I.M Wonho Jooheon and Kihyun) and the members who hadn't (Hyungwon Minhyuk and Hyungwon) are a clue. I guess that for the next 1.5 parts, those members who had their eyes open will have a bigger story/part. Minhyuk said that his hand didn't move, but Hyungwon's did when they were in the bathtub. This might mean that Minhyuk died sacrificing his life for Hyungwon (Wonho also said in this video that Minhyuk's character really cared a lot for Hyungwon), but, because of that heart(?) in the end, all members are there (looking better or actually got cured) so all of them lives and become a (super hot) CLAN. I just love them so much and I'm looking forward for their next MVs.
tq so much
thnaks dear for d explanation
thnaks dear for d explanation
thank u so much for u expalnation
now, i get it what they say
looking at their MV views i know our fandom quite small, but seeing other monbebe comments here and there make me realize that we are concrete family
*precious family
Amen!
all Monbebe is a family..😍😍
i think i'm not a monbebe... but i'm monnoona... i'm older than them but love them so much. how can 27th noona be their baby. they're my babies. love you monsta x
this comment is so sweet. i've never met a kinder fandom tbh
They're all sitting in their ships
1. Hyungwonho
2. Showhyuk
3.Jookyun
4.Kihyun x MCing
How cute. Can't wait for subs!
cutiehoops Kihyun is sitting alone because he's mine
My Hyungwonho heart is happy ♥️
@@musabunny I don't like this comment. Kihyun is not from you. I hope you can tell him it's MONBEBE. I think other MonBebes will feel bad about this comment.
@@민서-u3s IT WAS A PURE JOKE OMG i would never think that way about any of the members that's weird
@@musabunny Yes! Thank you for your kind reply.
봐도 모르게쒀요....이와중에 짱규니 돼멍이시절 진짜 졸귀턍ㅠㅠ
Until I read the full eng subs, the only thing I learned from this is that Wonho has a lot of things to say haha!
HAHAHA so true
there's an english sub?
+andrea tiopianco they usually upload the subbed version later
where's eng sub?
+Kitana T. You can find the eng sub on Monsta X Subs channel
Hyungwon x Minhyuk in MVs but Hyungwon x Wonho in rea life xD Hyungwon getting all them boys
when will jooheon ever learn to keep his hands off i.m lmaoo
lol hopefully never tbh
Ikr, it's so cute how they always stick together, especially knowing their History, it makes it just even more precious 🙈 We all know how thankful our Maknae is thowards Jooheon, it's adorable to see how much Jooheon treasures out Maknae 😊
Never, you know you likey
6:12 ..hyungwon-ah
i keep replaying^^
the way jooheon said "this is gun" 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 lmao i cri
진짜 걸어 뮤비가 퀄리티 최고였어.. 진짜 영화같구ㅜ
근데 해석은 전문해석채널 보고 이해했어ㅎ
HYUNGWONHO, SHOWHYUK, JOOKYUN!!!! ALL MY SHIP ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Siti Nur Alia Norli LOL ikr!! Mnet knows the perfect pairs in MX
When Hyungwon said he doesn’t understand the story I’m like « that’s literally me right now with Fantasia X »
i can't stop staring at that kylie lips :D
hyungwon?
Camila Musa
yup
😂😂😂
Kylie wishes
Tias Dwi Kurnia kylie lips lmao😭😂😂
kihyun did such a good job mc-ing~~~~~
항상느끼는건데 몬엑 7명다 예능감진짜좋은듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ별말안하는데도 웃김ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그니까요 ㅋㅋ 다 넘 매력있고 멋지고 귀엽고 몬엑 때메 미치겠어욬 ㅋㅋ♡♡
천재 작곡가 작사가 워노짱균
9:35 헤메기껏했더니~ 한다는게 복면컷~
헐 대박ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱ형원이 손이 움직이는것이였다니 마지막 멤버 각자사진소름...
The fact that they managed to act and portray the emotions of the characters so well without even knowing what the hell is going on....
Strangely impressive
I WANNA POKE JOOHEONS DIMPLES
ikr
Nina Ahgase i’ve done it
On my poster of him
And hey fellow ahgase”or u aren’t”
Moooooddd
1:50 Minhyuk's "omonanananana" is the cutest thing ever 😍
일단 욕조씬에서 형원이의 손이 움직였다는건 민혁이 자신의 생명(파란물)을 형원이한테 대신 주고 형원이 살아나는 씬 같아요! 근데 클로즈업할때는 형원이 왜 눈을 감고있는지 ㅠㅠ 마지막에 죽는게 아닐까 싶네요! 셔누는 더이상 잃을게 없으니 죽는거 같고 민혁은 형원이를 대신해 죽고 나머지 멤버들은 친구들을 대신해서 싸우는?? 대충 어떤느낌인지는 알겠는데 다음 파트 뮤비를 봐야지 알거같은 느낌이네요ㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋ
6:12 how cute it is when wonho holding hyungwon as he was about to fall omggg I’m soft..❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
파란꽃이 뭔가 고통을 덜 느끼게 해주는? 아니면 생명과 관련된 뭔가 같은데… 욕조에 떨어뜨린건 그 꽃으로 만든거구 형원이가 욕조에서 거의 죽음에 가까운 상태로 누워있는데 거기에 민혁이가 파란액체 부으고 자기도 형원이랑 같이 죽는..? 셔누는 엄마? 할머니를 살리려고 기껏 돈 구해왔는데 집에 돌아와보니 이미 죽은..? 그래서 자기도 같이 죽은…?
9:19 are they all fanboying over Minhyuk?? Because honestly, fucking s a m e I replayed that part of the video so many goddamn times. He looked so hot with all that swagger o m g
5:40 THE WAY KIHYUN SAID "nyum nyum" MAKES ME WANT TO SCREAM HE IS SO CUTE OMG
[AGGRESSIVELY PRETENDS TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY'RE SAYING]
원호가 컨셉을 제일 잘 이해하고 있네.. 좀 더 설명해주지ㅠ
각도 진짜 극악이다..
6분 13초 쯤에 신호석 형원이 넘어질려고 하니까 잡아주는 거 봐 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
Lol the translator must having a hard time translating because of this talkative kids 😂
이 노래 진짜 내 갠취 1등임.. 뭔가 아련아련해짐 ㅠㅠ 뮤비도 되게 의미있고
i'm such a hyungwonhoe 😏
+miracle M whout?
huhu i need subs, i just laugh when they laugh
life of a non korean fangirl hehe
+Mina preach
same...
same lol
i'm planning on subbing this :-)
I LITERALLY SCREAMED SEEING CHANGKYUN AND JOOHEON IN THE SAME SQUARE
all of them look so fine 👌👌👌
다들 풋풋하구 귀욥땅 시간을 되돌릴 수 있다면 이때로 돌아가 입덕하고 싶....😭
걸어 컴백 축하해요 몬베베는 이날만
기달렸죠
뭐야...... 나 괜히 소름돋고 난리 났어. 누가 나와서 이거 다 해석해줘.. 제발 책이라도 내줘.. 내가 읽을게
12:20 kihyun just called himself handsome ajshagsgs that was 100% sagittarius mood y'all
am i the only one who keeps on replaying 6:12 bc damn that was adorable
Hyungwon is me while I was watching the mv. 14:01 🤔
형원 ㅠㅠ 넘 귀엽나너ㅠ
First of all, there were a few hints given by MX about the MV itself. Wonho mentioned that the members who had their eyes open (I.M Wonho Jooheon and Kihyun) and the members who hadn't (Hyungwon Minhyuk and Hyungwon) are a clue. I guess that for the next 1.5 parts, those members who had their eyes open will have a bigger story/part. Minhyuk said that his hand didn't move, but Hyungwon's did when they were in the bathtub. This might mean that Minhyuk died sacrificing his life for Hyungwon (Wonho also said in this video that Minhyuk's character really cared a lot for Hyungwon), but, because of that heart(?) in the end, all members are there (looking better or actually got cured) so all of them lives and become a (super hot) CLAN. I just love them so much and I'm looking forward for their next MVs.
what does it mean their eyes were open ?
means they are still alive
oh, HI **Jin 진**
nice theory though
+Bar 9898 at the last part when they were just about to find the heart
+Josie Dela Cruz thank you (:
Hyungwon is such a pretty boy 😍😍
오빠들 덕분에 더 헷갈려졌어 그치만 난 괜찮아...
Generally! The storyline they're trying to say is that in this album "Lost", each member has like a weakness of some sort (or more accurately a sort of life test/trial)
For Shownu, it's poverty (ie lack of money to cure his father??)
For MINHYUK, it's his affection and love for hyungwon
For Hyungwon, it's family abuse
For kihyun, it's his disability.
(Wonho and I.M's part they said should be later on)
And they said each and every scene has meaning but they won't explain it all to us Monbebes cos it's up to us to figure it out but they'll just drop little hints here and there!
Hope this helped!
Hyungwon looks so clueless, just like me.
I can't stop laughing when Hyungwon was about to fall out of his chair at 6:13 while Wonho is talking and Wonho is just like holding him back
Hyungwon is so cute ❤️
KIHYUN'S "NyAM NyAM" AT 5:42 IM SOFT
월컴 투 동막골ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아 겁나 똑같넼
that awkward moment when you stan monsta x af but don't even understand any word at all...
7:13 wonho:all i can see are hyungwon's lips
me:That's what a boyfriend can see on his girlfriend :P
몬스타엑스 이런영상들많아서 너무좋아요 ㅜㅜㅠ
I hope they'll grant Jooheon's wish to do other MVs with a storyline
im sorry. I'm suffering from "International fan who cant understand korean" syndrome
개나리 민혁이..ㅎㅎ너무귀엽다ㅠㅠㅜ♡♡
그니까요ㅠㅠ 민혁이 넘 기여버요♡
뮤비 진짜 시각적으로 멋지고 스토리적으로 난해한데 뭔가 알거같기도 하고 그르네...
근데 진짜 멋있다 애덜...
뮤비코멘터리가 이렇게 잼난 거였다니ㅋㅋ몬엑 최고
I actually did learn one thing from this thanks to Wonho, that the members' closed or opened eyes at the end was significant.
Wonho was so engaged here while Hyungwon next to him would gladly have taken a nap lol
SO CUTE WHEN HYUNGWON WAS ABOUT TO FALL BUT WONHO QUICKLY HELD HIM SO HE WOULDN'T. (MY HEART:( #HYUNGWONHO
Minhyuk my love
와 대존잘 ㅠㅜ💕💜💙몬스타엑스 꽃길만걸어요!!💙💜💙
THE WAY JOOHEON WAS FALLING ASLEEP GOT ME WHEEZING AS SOON KIHYUN STARTLED HIM
8:47 I definitely heard everyone unanimously say "it's a gun..." Or "you got us a gun..." As if it was a "well no shit sherlock" moment. Paired with Kihyun's face, that's all that went through my mind.
DID ANYONE ELSE NOTICE KIHYUN CRACKING HIS KNUCKLE LIKE KANEKI AT 10:57
HAHA!! YESSSS!!!
MY MOOD EVERY DAY:
I just wanted to say "Hello, I'm Hyungwon". and finish like that.
9:00 The moment he realized but then they didn't stop 10:26 Just Why???? That's scene got me everytime.
WHEN JOOHEON AND I.M IS TOGETHER... AAAAH. WHATS THEIR SHIP NAME GUYS?
jookyun
Pick Me Squad
Maknae Team I.M.J.H lawl
jookyun is the main, but sometimes you'll see rapline or maknae line
they sometime refer to themselves as 꿀꿍
6:13 미쳤다 형원이 넘어질 뻔 하니까 바로 잡아주는거
Who is still here in 2021 and now knowing what happened in the mv ? :)
Here iam ending up more confused 😂
Petition for Monsta X to do drama-like MV again because All in is a masterpiece
14:00 HW: I didn't even get the story..
Well, same here..
Hyungwon is such a mood,,, I CANT-
기요미 몬스타엑스 오빠들 ♡ 몬베베는 항상 응원합니땨 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
아휴 기현오빠 너무 기여우어ㅠㅠ 원호오빠도 잘생기구
Ok so I've gathered some info, and just so you know, I am not going to tell my personal interpretation, just some stuff the members gave hints about (lol sorry for my bad english, this is not my first language)
Things that are important to notice and think about to understand the mv:
- Minhyuk said that in the bathtub scene, it is important the fact that Hyungwon's hand is moving and not his
- Wonho said that the "kinda" purple "THE CLAN" in the beginning has a hidden meaning. He added that their logo burning also has a hidden meaning.
- Kihyun commented on the scene where it looks like they are in a weird sect, he said that they drink something and that it brings them closer together
- Wonho said that the timeline isn't in order, it comes back and forth a lot. He also said that every scene is important and that you should ask yourself "What is this?" all the time
- About the scene where they zoom on their faces in the cave, Wonho said that it is important the fact that some members have their eyes opened (Kihyun, I.M, Jooheon and Wonho), and some are closed (Hyungwon, Minhyuk and Shownu)
- The scene at the end with the big purple thing moving is supposedly a heart and Minhyuk said "This scene, with our clothes, is non-realistic". He probably said that for a reason, but I personally have no idea why
- Wonho said that some little details, like color or shapes can give big hints about the meaning (so you can search the meaning/symbolism of purple, blue, fire, white, snow, x, whatever you notice in the mv)
Things that the members have explained:
- They talked a lot about pain. Wonho said that everyone lost something and that sadness was definitely very present in the mv. Minhyuk really cared about Hyungwon and he bets on something to protect him, that is his pain, Shownu's pain is poverty (his mother is sick and he wants to pay for some medical intervention, so he takes the gun that jooheon gave him, but when he returns, his mother is not there anymore, he lost her. So he burns the money(I know it's not well explained, but I can't say too much info, because I'm not sure about it, it's mostly my interpretation)), Hyungwon is abused by his father (the scene where he's being hit by a man and when we see his beaten face) and Kihyun's pain was related to his body (the scene where he runs in the snow, clearly suffering) Wonho didn't talk about the other members' pain, but I think the other characters were less important for the story. (Maybe that is why they talked about their eyes being closed or opened, because Jooheon, I.M, Kihyun and Wonho had their eyes opened and their characters weren't really important in this mv)
- The thing inside the bag that Jooheon gave to Shown was a gun (Jooehon and Shownu didn't even know what was in the bag before filming the scene, this was their real reaction)
- The scene where the building is on fire, Wonho believes the building was burned and that the father got arrested (Hyungwon's father, I think)(and I think it's Minhyuk, Wonho and IM who did it, probably to avenge Hyungwon)
For the completed subs, I went to dailymotion where a kind monbebe subbed it from beginning to end. here is the link: www.dailymotion.com/video/x4fxzba
Mariane oh my god thank you for this
Mariane thank you 💖
My aesthetic is Monsta X calling themselves handsome.
맞아요, 때리고싶당 오빠들 ㅠㅠ
kihyun is so handsome here 😍😍
hYUNGWONHO STILL ALIVE THO
8:08 I HAVE NEVER HEARD “AK47” SAID WITH SUCH AN AMAZING VOICE B4 OMG IM NEVER THINKING THE AK47 THE SAME AGAIN
I also want to add a few things that I’ve noticed and that others don’t really touch on.
1. The ‘timeline’ where everyone is in white clothing, I believe this to be after they have all taken in the blue flower. Whether it be liquid form, or as the flower(Larkspur, I believe) itself.
a. I quoted timeline because I’m not quiet sure that they are in a different timeline but more suspended. Purgatory if you will.
b. The real timeline is everything else, them in regular clothes.
2. The member clearly state that every has pain.
Ex.
-Minhyuks’ pain is Hyungwon getting hurt, feeling guilty for not being able to help.
a. I believe him and Hyungwon to be in a relationship but the religious group doesn’t wouldn’t agree with it so they try to hide it.
-Hyungwons’ pain is his abusive father.
a. Some people have mentioned that he was forced to participate in the religious activity. I’m not 100% sure on this but I believe it to be true.
-Kihyuns’ pain is physical. His body is deteriorating, almost like he has a disability.
a. You can see throughout the video he’s always limping or holding on to someone or something, I believe a cane.
-Shownus’ pain is being unable to help the person in the hospital.
a. I’m not sure the relationship between him and the person but many have guessed. I wont specify.
-Wonhos’ pain is emotional. He is the optimist of the group. Trying to keep hope and not start fights.
a. This is a personal guess but when Wonho in the commentary states that he’s always smiling in the mv. I can only assume that’s his role in the mc.
-Jooheons’ pain is family issue, the opposite of Shownus’. He has money but he doesn’t like it for an unknown reason.
a. I believe this to be true because of a few things.
1. His clothes, throughout the real timeline they are different than the others. They’re more fitted, has accessories (his hat), while everyone else has baggy clothes like they were passed down from family or bought as a necessity.
2. He had a gun. As Minhyuk mentioned in the commentary, it would be weird if Shownu had the money to buy the gun but not help the person in the hospital. But this doesn’t exactly mean that Jooheon got it by fair means. He could have stolen.
3. He was the one who brought the Blue Flower. Now i’m not 100% sure of this but he was the one performing the ritual and when I think about people want to show something off they usually prepare ahead of time. Doing researching, trying/testing it out or having experience with it. This leads me to believe that this is how his parents are making money (by selling the Larkspur).
4. When he pulls the gun up to his head. That’s a classic ‘What are you going to do about it’ kind of position. They members state that in the commentary. The main character of shows often do that and they’re usually the rich kid that knows they have power over other people. If they make a bad situation they have enough money to take care of it.
5. I also believe he’s the unofficial leader of the Clan (the members in the mv). He’s often leading them somewhere or the one giving advice.
6. In the MV Kihyun starts off with a stick to help him walk, later he’s seen throwing crutches, which can be very expensive. Jooheon maybe the answer for him optioning them.
b. I know I made some good reasonings for him being rich but going through all this, it also makes me feel like he might be a drug user or a criminal. The bad kid always getting in trouble and turned to the streets for attention. I’m not sure but he was one of the hard characters to understand.
-I.M.s’ pain is naiveté. He barely shows up and I believe that’s the whole point to his character development. He knows what’s happening but hasn’t fully grasp his own opinion on it. He’s made friends and wants to keep them, protect them.
a. I.M. is often seen with Wonho, almost Wonho is looking out for his younger brother; keeping him near.
b. He is mainly in the back of the group, following behind the members.
3. The giant heart in the sky during ‘Purgatory’ ‘Timeline’. I want to say that it’s a real heart. I say this because the CGI is really good (as Minhyuk says in the commentary), too good. Like there’s a reason they made is so good.
a. The heart is blue, I’m sure this is an easy connection but it’s blue because of the Flower. They all consume it or are covered in it (during the ritual) and it has reached their hearts.
b.I believe that they had to find this heart to return from ‘Purgatory’, either to the previous timeline or to a new one.
4. Clothing color in the Real Timeline. I highly suspect that this is a very important to the MV. So the main colors range from pitch black to pure white, I don’t believe anyone changes clothes for the whole MV. Also, Wonho in the Commentary mentions how the clothing, makeup and imagery are very well made. Feels like a clue.
a. White is innocence, pure of heart, good intentions. Black is evil, bad intentions, doing wrong and thinking bad. Also why I believe the beginning if the MV is Monotone.
b. Every character , even the background one ( store keeps, guards and religious affiliates) are wear colors in that range. The store owners and wear white, the guards black and the religious affiliates dark blue. Now, nonblack n white color should just be thought of in a monotone spectrum.
c. I’m not sure if hair color, and shoes color matters or the exact position of the clothes matter.
1. The store owners and all white, innocent not a culprit in the crime; bystanders. Guards, all black. They do bad, are bad and know it, but the religious group is a bit different. They wear dark blue, which would be a charcoal; almost black. Their intentions seem just but are deep down are bad.
2. Each of the clan members are wearing a variety of colors.
Ex.
-Hyungwon, pitch black. Does bad things, is related to the religious group and believes he’s nothing
-Minhyuk, grey hoodie, khaki vest and black shorts. He feels guilty for hiding and not helping Hyungwon sooner, giving him a grey torso. He then does something bad and that gives way to the black shorts.
a. I’m not sure if the fact that he has shorts instead of pants means any thing but you can figure that out.
b. He does change clothes and is the only one to do so. In the very beginning he is wearing a large, all white hoodie, almost like a cloak and no vest. I’m not sure if this is on purpose or not.
-Jooheon, pitch black shirt and camo pants with a dark blue hat. He is a ‘bad guy’ in terms of he does bad things, know that it’s a bad thing and considers himself bad. However, his actions are not the exact same actions as the guards or religious group. They are however on the same scale and he knows it but doesn’t believe he himself is as bad as those people, hence the ‘grey hat’.
-Kihyun, medium grey sleeveless shirt, black pants and a black undershirt. He is injured, maybe sick. He feels like this causes him to be a burden, someone who they have to look out for and slow down for. He wants to be better but doesn’t know how how. Greyed with doubt and black with guilt.
- I.M., he has a large white t-shirt, a medium grey long sleeve undershirt and black pants. He is the character with the most to figure out. He wants to be good, the white shirt, he just isn’t sure he is, they grey undershirt. He also knows that he has done a bad thing but for what he hopes is a good reason.
- Wonho, wear a large, light grey shirt, a medium grey undershirt and khaki pants; which would also be grey. He is the most in between person. He knows that they aren’t going about this the best was and tries to help them stay with good intentions but he knows that he wants to protect everyone as well. His intentions are always for the best and he tries to go about it the best way.
- Shown, also a large, white shirt and light blue jeans. Every few scene changes you also notice he wears a black tank. Outside he tries to keep up and do good by everyone but that drags him down and fills him with guilt. Leads him to do bad things to try to protect the right people.
d. The ritual scenes also have them wearing all black, solid black. Doing something wrong, know that it’s wrong and not caring. Bad intentions.
e. There are monotone moments in the ‘Purgatory’ ‘Timeline’ which could mean they have meaning but I’m not too sure. These scenes have them wear all white with cream accessories. This I can not 100% explain but I think if it as them wanting to start over, start pure but with the knowledge of what they did wrong.
f. The mask. The represent good intention, hiding behind a bad deed.
1. Four people have them, Shownu, Wonho, I.M. and Hyungwon. Shownu considers wearing his but decides to face his actions head on. Wonho wears his to show his good intentions. I.M. does the same but in a more powerful sense. He is deciding which side he is on. Hyungwon wears his to literally cover his pain. He wants to be good, do good but can’t seem to get there(especially in his ‘fathers’ eyes).
2. Minhyuk doesn’t wear one while going to burn down the building for the same reason as Shownu. He knows what he’s doing and wants the people who did wrong to know he did it.
5. I don’t believe the Fake Snow to represent snow, but ash. This is a popular opinion but I wanted to mention it again as it would mean a lot more. Furthermore Minhyuk in the beginning of them playing the MV mentions not recording in the winter, which was an answer to Monbebes concerns but I feel like he had a second meaning towards it. Although Kihyun refers to is as fake snow and not ash or anything else. I’m not sure but I think of it as ash.
6. During the ritual everyone partakes in using the liquid, which we can assume is the Flower turned into liquid. I think this is where their bodies become connected. Kihyun mentions them becoming connected and affectionate with each other during this moment. I believe it’s just them become inseparable, combing hearts if you will.
There are something that were mentioned and/or that I thought of that I wanted to also write down.
1. The Monsta X symbol fading away at the end of the video. Wonho mentioned in the Commentary that the symbols had meaning, is this one included.
2. The video ends with them in ‘Purgatory’. Is that the correct time frame?
3. The scars/injuries on their face towards the end of the video. How did they get there, do they represent something?
4. The fog/gas/mist they walk through in ‘Purgatory’. Is it tied in with the fires they set, does it help explain the ash in the air?
5. The colours of the paint on their faces. Some have a lot more paint then others. Not every has the same colors. Does it have anything to do with their eyes being open? Do the colors have a meaning themselves?
6. Does Minhyuk give his life in exchange for Hyungwons? He’s the last person seen in the real timeline alive, is there a purpose?
7. Hyungwons hand moved but they all are in ‘Purgatory’ together, is this event not in that order? Also, why are there so many plants in that bathroom.
8. Did Hyungwons’ father drown him?There are something that were mentioned and/or that I thought of that I wanted to also write down.
9. They all end up in different place in ‘Purgatory’, does that mean they arrived at different times and does that have to do with them ingesting the Blue Flower?
10. Why does Wonho and Minhyuk switch places while watching the building burn?
11. Kihyun’s stumbling in the real timeline but ends up running into the ash. Are they physically entering purgatory, or is this a representation on Kihyun character catching up?
12. That’s Hyungwon stumbling out the building right? Why didn’t anyone tell him to get out before they set it on fire? Or was he the one to set the fire while others gassed it?
13. Does the shape of the paint on their face mean anything? I noticed that they have ‘X’ of the sort on them, do they all have it and what does it mean?
14. We can clearly see the letters ‘SEAR’ on I.M.s sleeve, should we know what they means? ‘No Signal Searching’ ‘ CHING DBYG [L1R] No’
15. When does the ritual take place? Before the death of Hyungwon? Before the Shownu burns the money? Before the beginning of the MV?
16. Does Wonho actually drink the liquid, or is he just pouring it in himself?
17. Is the mask Shownu had previously wrapped around his gun?
18. Did the trio actually set fire to the building or did some else do it? Are we sure that’s gasoline in the jug?
19. Where exactly and How did Jooheon get this gun.
20. Shownu and Hyungwon have ‘family’ outside the group, does anyone else?
21. Jooheon the badass and Hyungwon the flowerboy. Why are they the only three to show up in this scene?
22. Why does Hyungwon have the flower? Where did he get it from and why is he giving it away. Does this happen before the ritual?
23. Why is the Monsta x symbol burning and why did Wonho say its important? Also, the background is blue, same as the Title. Is the blue burning important? Also, the fire is black n white.
24. Why does Minhyuk have different clothes in the beginning than in the rest if the video?
25. Why are they dressed like they are in a war? What are they running from? Who?
26. Hyungwon is ‘alive’ since he moved his mouth, but does that mean that he was gravely injured for Minhyuk to give him the flower? How was he injured? Where did the flower come from?
27. Where exactly are they, placement wise in the their army wear? Location, physically.
28. There are exactly scene in the beginning of the video and at the end along with the Monsta x symbol disappearing.
29. Were they in ‘Purgatory’ first by chance and then in real timeline? Is ‘Purgatory’ part if the real timeline?
30. Why is everyone having 2.5 parts important, and what does that mean?
I didn’t take a look at the lyrics and can’t understand Korean for the life of me so if you want to do more research, I’d say start there.
Thank you for reading through this and sorry if you cant get through all of this but thank you for skimming through!
!!!!Moving on to the next mv!!!!
Hyungwon still being hyungwon: *I'M STILL DON'T KNOW WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT* awwww my baby is too cute!!!
Hyungwon actually represents his monbebes reactions 😂😂😂😂😂 & when will it have eng sub 😭😭😭😒😒😒