thanks for this very well made video about the subject, very well explained. your english is easly understandable and you dont speak too fast, that's a nice point for non english natives.
Love the Pood...18 pd gun with the reload of a 12 pdr and the punch of a 24 pdr...my favorite cannon. But rare now, I hope during the holidays the gift more. You answered so many questions in my mind that I now can arm a ship properly now.
This was really excellent. Thank you for taking the time to do this so thoroughly. It answered lot of questions I'd wanted properly answered for quite a long time and also gave me food for thought on loadout experimentation. Cannon weight (and cargo weight) don't factor in to speed anymore in the current version of NA. I just double checked on an Indiaman and different cannon loadouts showed the same speed. So Congreves don't even have that going for them anymore. I wonder what it is about the wimpy Obusiers that's supposed to make them create more deadly splinters? Wikipedia says they could fire explosive shot and canister rounds, so maybe that's being modeled. Interesting that you went for the sabicu (s) planking rather than the white oak (s) on the teak (s) build. Sabicu gives you 4% more hit points but 2% less thickness than WO. That seems to me like a wise decision, but some actually prefer the WO thickness--opinions vary just like play styles. Again, thanks for doing a great job on clearly explaining the complex relationships among the damage model variables in this awesome sim.
yeah I am glad you checked on the Congreves situation. I was not sure if that was going to be the case which just means they are even more useless now then before. as for the sabicu, its all about if that extra HP will help you survive a few more shots. if close in combat the extra thickness will not save you. but its all player preference.
From memory in the Napoleonic wars Congreves were British rockets. I think this is a rocket battery, possibly with fire damage? The Edinorog was a rare Russian carriage cannon. A pood is a Russian agricultural unit of measurement, and describes the weight. 1/2 pood or 1 pood. A pood is about 35 pounds. It's an 18pdr so likely really a 1/2 pood in the game. It's 1780s technology.
be understanding that these are the names of the cannons in the game. of course in real life it was Medium to short cannon, long guns and Carronade cannons. a long with some small varients of iron or brass. but in the game the developers made congreves, navys, bloomfields, longs, mediums and carros, and yes poods. none that do what they really did in real life.
@@RommelsAsparagus um it is. only because they game will reset soon. exact date is unkown. but it will be wiped. players dont lose any XP. due to everyone waiting the game does not have a lot of players at the moment but still lots of content going around.
That was a really nice presentation, however, it would be nice to see the diversity of the guns as well. Which guns can do double shot, chain, and grape. Not all guns have the capability to shoot all ball types.
It looks like blomefield is an upgraded medium and navy gun is an upgraded long. If thats true the navy gun and blomefield tests at the end maybe mistakenly swapped.
for 1st rates (Santi, vic, Ocean) on the top deck it always going to be preferred that you put Carronades, the longs just dont do the same dmg and neither will pen at long distances. but yes on the top deck you should only ever put carronades or long guns. the bottom deck you can switch out for meds if you want.
definitely depends on the type of cannon, mods, books. without anything even i can see the difference in reload time from 42pd long to 42pd med. also make sure you have enough crew on ship.
@@Rook2299 Sorry. I mean the ship's speed. So lighter guns don't make a difference in ship speed anymore, I think, since the devs made the last speed change (cargo weight doesn't matter, etc.)
Hey guys since a TH-camr won't tell how to like put the sailers on the ship .or like put the guns in the slot or getting ammo you know . Before you make damn money or experience . Hell I'm not sure but I think you must be able to sail out in the water . Just saying
It could have been but i wanted to explain a lot of things and not need to make like 5 different videos. I was longer then I planned and I dont want any of my videos to be this long again haha.
I was really interested in this game but looking at it it looks worse than empire. the ships aren't crewed at all and all the effects look like a game made 15 years ago
@@felixarbable this is a online game as first. Other is a solo game so everything Can be tuned up, where people in pvp wants performance. Second this game is made by a indie dev team. Have some respect. Do you know the budget of Empire ? Good now hush.
@@boomcat1337 i guess you have to shill for them for whatever reason but I never played empire solo. If this game was like super fun or something id overlook it but games like this are supposed to be thematic and engaging in a convincing way
@@felixarbable im not no. But your argument is like why does this Toyota not goes as fast as the McLaren in F1 they look the same. Naval action is a pure sail combat game where Empire is RTS. There is no other game out there who offer this gameplay. So dont compare two diffrent genres.
![[UNCUT] บอสพอล แผลงฤทธิ์ บอสพระ-นักร้อง ก. โดนแฉยับ! I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 21 ต.ค. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XKf6HeftoPI/mqdefault.jpg)
The most comprehensive cannon guide out there that I'm aware of. Probably your best video to date. Cheers.
Need a refund this damn game sucks ass
The 32pdr longs, especially on the ingrammanland, are absolutely devastating!
thanks for this very well made video about the subject, very well explained. your english is easly understandable and you dont speak too fast, that's a nice point for non english natives.
Love the Pood...18 pd gun with the reload of a 12 pdr and the punch of a 24 pdr...my favorite cannon.
But rare now,
I hope during the holidays the gift more.
You answered so many questions in my mind that I now can arm a ship properly now.
Cool, new to the game, and happy to learn
Ngl I knew nothing about cannons and now I feel like a expert
So far my logic on cannons has been
Boom boom Harder, boom boom better, boom boom faster makes boom stronger.
Make boom bigger, pull the trigger.
Hey Rook what's up .what you think about weight does it matter much? Thank you
not any more. unless they changed something recently the weight of cannons does not matter anymore.
This was really excellent. Thank you for taking the time to do this so thoroughly. It answered lot of questions I'd wanted properly answered for quite a long time and also gave me food for thought on loadout experimentation.
Cannon weight (and cargo weight) don't factor in to speed anymore in the current version of NA. I just double checked on an Indiaman and different cannon loadouts showed the same speed. So Congreves don't even have that going for them anymore.
I wonder what it is about the wimpy Obusiers that's supposed to make them create more deadly splinters? Wikipedia says they could fire explosive shot and canister rounds, so maybe that's being modeled.
Interesting that you went for the sabicu (s) planking rather than the white oak (s) on the teak (s) build. Sabicu gives you 4% more hit points but 2% less thickness than WO. That seems to me like a wise decision, but some actually prefer the WO thickness--opinions vary just like play styles.
Again, thanks for doing a great job on clearly explaining the complex relationships among the damage model variables in this awesome sim.
yeah I am glad you checked on the Congreves situation. I was not sure if that was going to be the case which just means they are even more useless now then before. as for the sabicu, its all about if that extra HP will help you survive a few more shots. if close in combat the extra thickness will not save you. but its all player preference.
Could not read the Website! What site are you on please? Thank you for your video.
its called netlify. or just type in naval action map
Awsome work mate 👍keep it up.
i got the Hercules triny to figer out what canons to do with it i got Naval a few days ago and engjoying it
From memory in the Napoleonic wars Congreves were British rockets. I think this is a rocket battery, possibly with fire damage? The Edinorog was a rare Russian carriage cannon. A pood is a Russian agricultural unit of measurement, and describes the weight. 1/2 pood or 1 pood. A pood is about 35 pounds. It's an 18pdr so likely really a 1/2 pood in the game. It's 1780s technology.
be understanding that these are the names of the cannons in the game. of course in real life it was Medium to short cannon, long guns and Carronade cannons. a long with some small varients of iron or brass. but in the game the developers made congreves, navys, bloomfields, longs, mediums and carros, and yes poods. none that do what they really did in real life.
@Rook2299 Got it. Thanks for the detailed video. Given the state of the game, in your opinion, is it worthwhile for new players?
@@RommelsAsparagus um it is. only because they game will reset soon. exact date is unkown. but it will be wiped. players dont lose any XP. due to everyone waiting the game does not have a lot of players at the moment but still lots of content going around.
Thumbed and subbed thanks brother!
That was a really nice presentation, however, it would be nice to see the diversity of the guns as well. Which guns can do double shot, chain, and grape. Not all guns have the capability to shoot all ball types.
all cannons can shoot all types. except for carros. carros cant shoot double anything. so not much diversity
@@Rook2299 ty for reply, nice work :D
It looks like blomefield is an upgraded medium and navy gun is an upgraded long. If thats true the navy gun and blomefield tests at the end maybe mistakenly swapped.
Blomefield is long gun with shorter reload.
Isnt it better when you put only longguns abd caronnades on the top on 1rates ?
for 1st rates (Santi, vic, Ocean) on the top deck it always going to be preferred that you put Carronades, the longs just dont do the same dmg and neither will pen at long distances. but yes on the top deck you should only ever put carronades or long guns. the bottom deck you can switch out for meds if you want.
@@Rook2299 okey thank you mate
I bought the Hercules 5th rate ship and medium cannons when I click and drag to cannon slots they won't stay in the slot please advise?
make sure they are the right size of mediums and the correct amount.
I tries switching various guns onto the same ship. The speed didn't change at all, no matter what gun??
definitely depends on the type of cannon, mods, books. without anything even i can see the difference in reload time from 42pd long to 42pd med. also make sure you have enough crew on ship.
@@Rook2299 Sorry. I mean the ship's speed. So lighter guns don't make a difference in ship speed anymore, I think, since the devs made the last speed change (cargo weight doesn't matter, etc.)
@@cubsfan910 yes that is correct. the weight of cannons no longer matter. that was error on my part.
@@Rook2299 No worries. Just wanted to make sure I wasn;t missing something. Still an awesome video. Great job!
Why not put Portugal in the game?
That's what I have been saying this whole time. Put them in and take China out
thank you
be aware that video is a bit old the information is not 100% correct anymore.
Is this still relevant or too many changes to game now?
its kinda relevant. the main changes now are that the cannon does dmg based on the size of cannon. longs are still better than mediums.
Hey guys since a TH-camr won't tell how to like put the sailers on the ship .or like put the guns in the slot or getting ammo you know .
Before you make damn money or experience . Hell I'm not sure but I think you must be able to sail out in the water . Just saying
I definitely explained how to put cannons on the ship. The crew is kinda self explained. Put ill remake a video that can help
This video should be 25 minutes long.
It could have been but i wanted to explain a lot of things and not need to make like 5 different videos. I was longer then I planned and I dont want any of my videos to be this long again haha.
@@Rook2299 It's not what I meant. In a video you go over same topic several times.
Brevity is the soul of wit.
@@yuriyi2859 I can agree to that. I do go over some stuff more than once.
Thanks for the video. But you repeat yourself so much.
it helped thax bro
This video is actually outdated. The cannons work much differently in the game at this time
@@Rook2299 to let anyone know i use 9 pound longs on all my ships ,,,,, im one of those watch and learn types he did good job
I got 42ib navy guns off elite Wasa
That's a good find 👌
yo dude this an hr long...
The cannons don't even recoil when fired, how lazy is the coding in this game?
I was really interested in this game but looking at it it looks worse than empire. the ships aren't crewed at all and all the effects look like a game made 15 years ago
I’ve asked the devs the same question about the recoil and I was told it would affect the games performance negatively
@@felixarbable this is a online game as first. Other is a solo game so everything Can be tuned up, where people in pvp wants performance. Second this game is made by a indie dev team. Have some respect. Do you know the budget of Empire ? Good now hush.
@@boomcat1337 i guess you have to shill for them for whatever reason but I never played empire solo. If this game was like super fun or something id overlook it but games like this are supposed to be thematic and engaging in a convincing way
@@felixarbable im not no. But your argument is like why does this Toyota not goes as fast as the McLaren in F1 they look the same. Naval action is a pure sail combat game where Empire is RTS. There is no other game out there who offer this gameplay. So dont compare two diffrent genres.