Dude this was super entertaining. The commentary and montages for top 3 was fantastic. This is definitely some of your best work yet. Great way to wrap up the year!!
(Not referring to the rankings themselves) Easily the best disc-ranking video ever. You take things from both an objective and subjective perspective, analyzing exactly why you like or dislike each disc, you account for each disc's context (thank you for not trashing on the horror discs just because they're not music), and it all comes together for my favorite video of the month (aside from AvA11, sorry, Alan has you beat).
Thank you for introducing me to the beauty of the Minecraft music discs! I’ve never really listed to them but just by hearing bits of some of them in this video I fell in love. I didn’t even know some of these were from Minecraft
Thanks for watching! Like I said in the video, I'm pretty proud of this one. This will be the last long form video of the year. Speaking of which, Thank you all for making this a great year. I started this year with around 200 subscribers, and look at me now! I really appreciate all of you. Here's to 2025 being another great year.
Finally someone who appreciates Ward. It is my favorite C418 disc (probably cause I barely listened to Cat when I was younger so it never grew on me) it’s ominous start (especially with the funeral march surprisingly) grew on me so much throughout the years that in my most recent survival server with some of my friends I made that disc my theme song basically and made my whole base based around it. Even after the ominous bits it still manages to be one of the best discs C418 made in my opinion. If I were to put it on a list it would be either third or second just because of how much it has grown on me over the years.
It might be a bit too much, but you should do the whole minecraft album! Like i said that would probably be too much, but maybe you could do every album independently!
Fantastic list! Totally agree with your logic for the bottom three, and my only personal change would be switching Creator and Precipice. Tricky Trials really brought out the best in all the composers!
The Minecraft Minigame ost is also REALLY good, the exhilarating yet playful strides of Glide, the frantic and bouncy nature of Tumble, and Battle... Which I haven't listened to it yet... Maybe I should...
Maybe I’m a little silly but I really like creator music box. Something about it winding up and then slowing down so much at the end, the mechanical chirping and clicking, and how it starts off creepy and off putting but then feels hopeful at the end just really gets to me.
That's fair. I might have been a little too harsh on it. In the video I said by its self it would be higher, because it looses a lot of points for having a total upgrade directly in the soundtrack.
Ward is the best to me because it's me and my siblings childhood and is one of the last things I have to remind me of them and my dad. How I miss burning villages and building rollercoasters and sealantern houses with them and plugging up dads tunnels with jackolamterns. Those were the days
Please do a ranking on the new music (1.16+) all of music ranking i find is about the old ones and i would love to hear opinions on the new tracks, like if they fit Minecraft etc, or if they are just good...
Creator and Pigstep being second and first, i couldn't agree more! Lena composed them amazingly god damn i love them, as a musician myself they earn extra respect for how well done they were produced along with just sounding superb
Fun Fact: A man named Smag put Pigstep in F Tier because he thought it didn’t fit in Minecraft and that he can’t see Zombie pigmen playing this (he clearly did not know about The Nether Update) while putting 13 and 11 in A Tier and 5 in C Tier as well as Cat on the highest S Tier Imagine if he found the Warden
i feel like creator does not fit the game, we gotta remember that we aren’t playing doom, celeste or some other game, we are playing minecraft, a survival game with building elements that also happens to have crazy structures and precipice does its job well as it’s extremely unhinged but still remains in the bounds of not using string instruments like guitar but creator doesn’t really fit for a silly box that plays music
Yeah, I came at from the perspective that it fits the trail chamber, not Minecraft as a whole. I agree it is very different, I just think it is so good that I don't really care.
@The_Dandalorian i honestly dont get how people think its a good track, its slow and like a creepy disk at the start and transitions into some goofy music that doesnt fit mc then a guitar solo lol, i get precipice fitting as it is fast like wind
Hot take Minecraft Story Mode soundtrack is more nostalgic than normal Minecraft, Antimo and Welles composed a magnificent soundtrack that suited the game flawlessly and I love everything about it. Especially “Order Of The Stone” song
For some reason, I really don't like Precipice. It's loud and feels like it doesn't fit to be a disc, but rather a background music to some event or some sort, I kinda get a similar vibe to a Terraria Event Music. but, for me Wait, Creator, Pigstep and Stal are my top 4
Yeah, of all of the minecraft songs, I think precipice fits the least. But, if you think of it as a disc for the trail chamber, and not a disc for minecraft, I think it works a lot better.
Dude this was super entertaining. The commentary and montages for top 3 was fantastic. This is definitely some of your best work yet. Great way to wrap up the year!!
Thanks! I'm glad you liked it!
(Not referring to the rankings themselves)
Easily the best disc-ranking video ever. You take things from both an objective and subjective perspective, analyzing exactly why you like or dislike each disc, you account for each disc's context (thank you for not trashing on the horror discs just because they're not music), and it all comes together for my favorite video of the month (aside from AvA11, sorry, Alan has you beat).
Wow, that's some really high praise, thank you! I will gladly take second place! There is no way I could ever make something as good as Alan's stuff.
Mitsi😭
Thank you for introducing me to the beauty of the Minecraft music discs! I’ve never really listed to them but just by hearing bits of some of them in this video I fell in love. I didn’t even know some of these were from Minecraft
Your welcome! The whole Minecraft soundtrack is really great, I recommend listening to it in its entirety.
Great ranking! Keep 'em coming!!
Thanks!
Thanks for watching! Like I said in the video, I'm pretty proud of this one. This will be the last long form video of the year. Speaking of which, Thank you all for making this a great year. I started this year with around 200 subscribers, and look at me now! I really appreciate all of you. Here's to 2025 being another great year.
So I have to tell you something. I wish the iceologer could be added in Minecraft.
@@AtticusSanchez-xm4xk That would be awesome
I personally thought of creator music box
as being something you might hear in a baby's nursery
Finally someone who appreciates Ward. It is my favorite C418 disc (probably cause I barely listened to Cat when I was younger so it never grew on me) it’s ominous start (especially with the funeral march surprisingly) grew on me so much throughout the years that in my most recent survival server with some of my friends I made that disc my theme song basically and made my whole base based around it. Even after the ominous bits it still manages to be one of the best discs C418 made in my opinion. If I were to put it on a list it would be either third or second just because of how much it has grown on me over the years.
I think Ward is maybe the most underrated song in the whole game. I'm glad you also like it!
It might be a bit too much, but you should do the whole minecraft album! Like i said that would probably be too much, but maybe you could do every album independently!
I'd love to do that, if this video does well, you can look forward to those videos in the future.
Beautiful Matpat reference execution
But that's just a theory...
Fantastic list! Totally agree with your logic for the bottom three, and my only personal change would be switching Creator and Precipice. Tricky Trials really brought out the best in all the composers!
Thanks!
The Minecraft Minigame ost is also REALLY good, the exhilarating yet playful strides of Glide, the frantic and bouncy nature of Tumble, and Battle... Which I haven't listened to it yet... Maybe I should...
Yeah, Garth Coker did a really good job with them.
Awesome! My favorite video so far.
Thank you!
Maybe I’m a little silly but I really like creator music box. Something about it winding up and then slowing down so much at the end, the mechanical chirping and clicking, and how it starts off creepy and off putting but then feels hopeful at the end just really gets to me.
That's fair. I might have been a little too harsh on it. In the video I said by its self it would be higher, because it looses a lot of points for having a total upgrade directly in the soundtrack.
Why do i feel like all of the the old music dics would fit perfectly in an anolog horror series.
That would be cool!
Best tierlist. I agree with you pigstep. But best version of pigstep is from Scott Buckley.
Thank you!
Ward is the best to me because it's me and my siblings childhood and is one of the last things I have to remind me of them and my dad. How I miss burning villages and building rollercoasters and sealantern houses with them and plugging up dads tunnels with jackolamterns. Those were the days
Yeah, it is a very nostalgic disc, I'm glad it means so much to you.
Those top 3 man… goated
Yeah, They are the best, IMO
Please do a ranking on the new music (1.16+) all of music ranking i find is about the old ones and i would love to hear opinions on the new tracks, like if they fit Minecraft etc, or if they are just good...
I talk about the new ones in this one, the top two are from 1.21 and 1.16
@The_Dandalorian oh sorry i mean the background ones not the disc
@@ncsr9675 oh, that makes more sense. That would be a cool video!
Good video
Thank you!
Creator and Pigstep being second and first, i couldn't agree more! Lena composed them amazingly god damn i love them, as a musician myself they earn extra respect for how well done they were produced along with just sounding superb
Yeah, they are both amazing.
JAKE??
Fun Fact:
A man named Smag put Pigstep in F Tier because he thought it didn’t fit in Minecraft and that he can’t see Zombie pigmen playing this (he clearly did not know about The Nether Update) while putting 13 and 11 in A Tier and 5 in C Tier as well as Cat on the highest S Tier
Imagine if he found the Warden
Okay...?
That's pretty funny.
Any type of villagers pleaseeeeeeeee🙏
FIRST!!❤
I am brazilian and I Love your videos😂❤
Thank you!
"What my monkey brain thinks sounds good" lowkey real
yep
i feel like creator does not fit the game, we gotta remember that we aren’t playing doom, celeste or some other game, we are playing minecraft, a survival game with building elements that also happens to have crazy structures and precipice does its job well as it’s extremely unhinged but still remains in the bounds of not using string instruments like guitar but creator doesn’t really fit for a silly box that plays music
Yeah, I came at from the perspective that it fits the trail chamber, not Minecraft as a whole. I agree it is very different, I just think it is so good that I don't really care.
@The_Dandalorian i honestly dont get how people think its a good track, its slow and like a creepy disk at the start and transitions into some goofy music that doesnt fit mc then a guitar solo lol, i get precipice fitting as it is fast like wind
I love Relic except for the fact that when it starts it always sounds to me like a Creeper's about to blow
Yeah, it takes a little too long to start.
Bruh why u hate creator music box
Creator is better, that's really my only reason.
LENA RAINE IS MY GOATTTTT
She's pretty great
Hot take Minecraft Story Mode soundtrack is more nostalgic than normal Minecraft,
Antimo and Welles composed a magnificent soundtrack that suited the game flawlessly and I love everything about it. Especially “Order Of The Stone” song
I would say it depends on if played story mode or not. I really like story modes sound track, my personal favorite is the wither storm theme.
For some reason, I really don't like Precipice.
It's loud and feels like it doesn't fit to be a disc, but rather a background music to some event or some sort, I kinda get a similar vibe to a Terraria Event Music.
but, for me Wait, Creator, Pigstep and Stal are my top 4
Yeah, of all of the minecraft songs, I think precipice fits the least. But, if you think of it as a disc for the trail chamber, and not a disc for minecraft, I think it works a lot better.
@The_Dandalorian Awesome minecraft Ranking music download video 😊❤
Thank you!
@The_Dandalorian thats ok buddy 😀