Did you eat? Have you eaten? (What's the difference?!)

[@Yousef-qf9qh]

Summary :
Did you : used when speaking about a fully ended action and can't affect the present
Have you : used when speaking about an action that happend recently and can affect the present
Thanks for the clear explanation 🙂

[@suhsinku9011]

I got it ! ❤️

[@yenglao2792]

You're my favorite english teacher 🙏 I always wait to get your newest video 🙏 I love your style to teach english 🙏 so marvelous.. So clear to be listened

[@obaid9791]

Great lovely teacher

[@anenyashamusonza8336]

Well explained

[@Wowlentina]

Yes, I agree. Very clear explanation. And very clear pronunciation. Thank you. I love learning such things in the English language.

[@liavang7673]

Thank you for sharing this video.

[@natnaelanssa8121]

I googled their deference and it was hard to understand. I wanna say Simply you are the best teacher on TH-cam because you know how to make us understand easily

[@khublalriahi-zf5yi]

0Iggy by

[@Sapito-nd4df]

Yes, you're so right. Mike is the best.😊

[@evelynquinonez1667]

I ate tea, sweet potato and tea for breakfast this morning. Have you already eaten dinner, Evelyn? No, I haven't yet. Thanks, Mike.

[@thelthel2885]

Thank you..very good teacher...God bless

[@Afghanvoice1]

Thank you sir

[@janakp2252]

Excellent tutorial

[@christenatawfeek911]

It’s so nice that you are talking nicely and I can understand well

[@belalmhijjawe6477]

Easy and understandable explanation, thank you very much

[@plusdelamusique7486]

Great it helpful 👍

[@hninsatt9152]

I like your video.Your teaching skill is really good.

[@Magmava]

Your explanation is so thoughtful and easy to digest! I subscribed!

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thanks!

[@rhea3234]

Very well said.❤️👍

[@LuuLy-cu1or]

I’m still enjoying this interesting lesson. The present perfect tense always amuses me. Thank you, Mike.

[@saizhinimaeva6653]

Hello Mike! You explain always very clearly . Thank you so much!

[@nayanapriya7330]

Thanks a lot.. Good explanation..

[@samitharajaguru3938]

You explained it very clearly.thank you

[@josemello649]

Excellent examples, thanks...

[@PiotrHoppe-x6t]

Thank you for explaining this to me .

[@mohamedamezoug7482]

You explain always very clearly
Thank you teacher Mike

[@RajinderSingh-si4wc]

Superb. Thank you so much for makng this video.

[@Akram_Al-Omari]

Great 🌷

[@jehanhussien2555]

You are great at explaining lessons 👏

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thanks!

[@salmaannich577]

Thank you so much teacher Mike

[@jordanondosanchez9999]

You are the best teacher ❤🎉😊

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thanks a lot!

[@Princess._1990]

Thank you sir.

[@muralikrishna9835]

well said Sir, I searched for the difference, and got the clarification more on that. Thank you very much. I am new to this channel. now I am subscribing your channel

[@NesSuMaA-f7u]

Thank you so much teacher mike.

[@affys_world]

Amazing explanation👏👏

[@learnenglishwithshivani]

Very well explained 👍

[@IramHameedRather1]

Dear Mike, you are making life easy, with great explanation. thanks.

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Glad to hear that!😀

[@dilshadahmed4838]

you always make the subject easy thats why i love the way you are teaching us english and you are my favorite english teacher and the best one all around the world

[@jocelynbond3645]

wow. your explanation is clear!

[@guermahfatiha8050]

Very clear?Thanks!🎉🎉🎉❤

[@Vadimka3]

Thank you, Mike!!!
This is the best explaination I’ve seen about difference between two times. You are a perfect teacher!

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thank you!🙏

[@keketube4012]

Thank you teacher Mike. Good explication

[@lalitabiswas4971]

Thanks a lot. Very helpful 👍.

[@laf7907]

Thank you teacher mike. Very clear❤

[@maryamshammo5706]

Best teacher ever ❤ thanks for your time and efforts

[@faizal3381]

Thanks a million!

[@qhamkiletobo6235]

Thanks teacher I had problem with using present perfect tense now that you have given me explanation I understand, you are my great teacher

[@imeldawijaya4989]

Thank you teacher. It's an incredible explanation where you explain very detail and clear the different between the 2 tenses

[@seokariya4722]

You are a good teacher

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thanks!

[@mohamadshami6817]

Great teacher

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thank you! 😃

[@phucanhao7208]

Thanks a lot, very useful

[@shamsalgroob72]

Thank you ♥️

[@Eldjay-q8z]

We appreciate you sir 🙏 much love

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

🙏

[@Eldjay-q8z]

@@TeacherMikeEnglish thanks again sir

[@husseinmohammed6852]

Many thanks

[@DmitriyBlokhin]

thx

[@stanleybrown5656]

Which form is correct if I want to ask about the past in general: Have you managed to ship this order yet? or Did You shipped this order yet?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

The first one.
But some people would also ask "Did you ship it yet?" It's less correct, but VERY common.

[@mareamm118]

Oh now I understand it, thank you so much.

[@meenaba5995]

Thé clearest video that I watched in my life.

[@Vlad-Kyiv]

Thank you a lot! Now, I understand a bit

[@Xiom-92]

Thank you you cleared my biggest doubt.... 👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Glad you found this one.

[@OppoSmart-qy7lg]

Teacher, If a friend asks me if I have eaten dinner? Could I answer "I have had mine? " or " I already had dinner? "...which one is correct? Or both incorrect?

[@rabikhemrom139]

Thanks Mike.

[@maria-zl4cf]

Oh, thank you very much. Actually, I was confused about this question

[@hooyoaamaguul3673]

Thank you Brother

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

You're welcome!

[@Alexhusen4607]

The best teacher 👨‍🏫
I love you.

[@DivyaSss-tp7vb]

Thank u for clear explanation. Then what about ...had ur breakfast??? Pls explain.

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Have you had breakfast? = Have you eaten breakfast?
Did you have breakfast? = Did you eat breakfast?

[@begbeg8038]

Really I understand thank you so much 👏🏻 Please get this kind of video

[@mohamedmifras8274]

Sir,
This one also correct right
Did you have your dinner?

[@japontv1158]

So, when we use "Did" means the action is 100% impossible to do in this moment because is 100% past?
In sentence with "Did" we can not use "have" but in sentence with "have" we can use "did"?
Imagine is the morning, we don´t have breakfast yet, we can ask "Have you had breakfast?" (because still is possible to do it) but we can ask in the same context "did you have breakfast" if still is possible to it?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Many native speakers would use "did you" but "have you" is grammatically a better choice.

[@chuchorrichi]

very clear

[@ديابمحمد-ب3ق]

Thank you very much ‏‪

[@user-friendly-kind]

Thank you Mike. It wasn't easy for me to understand.

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Does it make sense now?

[@user-friendly-kind]

Yes, thank you for the good explanation.

[@raghdesam5311]

Thanks 🙏 teacher 👨‍🏫 mike

[@matheusfreire2420]

tnx teacher

[@pooklook888]

Thank you.

[@jaymont8469]

Woow I really like his explanation
Great!!
I'll subscribe

[@لؤلؤة-ق4ب]

Thank you ❤

[@daroonahmed7808]

Thanks 😊

[@GhostSnow7]

Tha bst xplaation ever😃🥰

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Thanks!

[@Sapito-nd4df]

Did you eat a delicious breakfast this morning? I hope so.😊

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

I did not because I had to fast before my doctor's appointment.

[@Sapito-nd4df]

Oh, no. I hope that you don't have anything serious, Mike. Take care! 😊

[@mohammadmuhtadi6928]

thanks for sharing sir,,, now i know the differences, but may i ask you how if i am wrong, i mean this evening i said did you eat dinner,, is it understable ?

[@manueldimas4073]

Helpful.. but how can I use them in other situations?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Those questions or those tenses? Just apply the same idea. Is it something that you think should be 100% in the past, or is it something that you think might still happen.

[@htupannbwi505]

Hi Tr.Mike
A: Did you have breakfast at home yesterday?
B: Yes, I did.
Or
Yes, I had.
Which response is grammatically correct?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

The question was "Did you...?" so the answer should be "Yes, I did."

[@omerbolatfc]

My English is a little but I understand to you , thank you very much ,

[@setterkim4050]

And that’s why English is best! Much more simpler! 😊

[@zynabelchref-ef8vv]

❤thank you 🙏

[@حسن-ش2خ4ث]

Thanks .
If i want to speak a bout historical events or story which tense is sutible ?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

You will probably use past tense more often if you are simply telling a story about the past. However, if you are relating things to the present, then you will also use present perfect.

[@haronli5575]

How about "are you" and "were you".. can u explain

[@NeerajKashyap-uk6hj]

Thanks a lot sir
I am having my hair cut
I am going to shop to have my hair cut
I am going to shop to have my mobile prepared
Are these sentences correct ?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

I am going to the barber shop to have my hair cut.

[@Blueberry_GSD]

👍👍👍👍👍😊

[@FayziyevFirdavs]

What's the difference between supper and dinner?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

I think I have a video about that.

[@FayziyevFirdavs]

@@TeacherMikeEnglish Thanks! 👍

[@ruatbawihibawitlung239]

💜💜💜

[@akfmast100master2]

Je te le jure ton anglais est tellement compréhensif très clair et très simple mer I mark thanks

[@user-rx3ku4qq8i]

thank you❤❤🍜🍛🍲💖💗💌💜💜💜💜

[@chathutharanga2196]

Yes i had dinner

[@jehanhussien2555]

🌟🌟🌟

[@hiuhasrie4164]

👍👍👍

[@Sapito-nd4df]

Have you had lunch, Mike? 😊

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Yes, I have.😀

[@Sapito-nd4df]

😊😊😁

[@Yosemite-George-61]

How about "Have you ever been in love?" This formula is not wrong is it? Then while at the Police station thay ask: "Did you point the gun at him?" "Have you ever pointed the gun at someone?" More: "Did you close the door?" "No I didn't" "Then go back and close it!" "Did you remember to call Mary?" "No I forgot" "Well.. I'll call her right now"

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

You've got it.✅

[@muselhassnaoui9633]

What about if i want to ask someone for example ;
*have you been before in (name of country)*
normally is on the past, so i need to us did you ..!
is that true ?

[@starwar2474]

Have you ever been to Canada?
Why "to Canada" ? I don't now but I found out about it today dont
use "in Canada"

[@loganwilcox4037]

Hate to do this to you, but what about "ate"?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

You wouldn't use it in a question because it is the past tense form of the verb "eat", and when we make questions in past tense, we don't use the past tense form of the verb. You would only use it in an answer.

[@loganwilcox4037]

@@TeacherMikeEnglish Thanks!

[@TV-og5en]

Mr are you american? or Are you English?

[@TeacherMikeEnglish]

Hi. I'm American.