I loved this. I didn't find it boring, cause it was kind of what I expected. We all knew what it would be about beforehand amd that they would still end up together. It was just a bit more details about their happily ever after ish
I’m so glad you said you weren’t Team Atlas in the first book. I wasn’t sure if I was the only one but I didn’t connect with him AT ALL in the first book. Was completely indifferent about him and so I’m glad this book brings lots more of him!! I’m starting it tomorrow!
I LOVED the refrence to the book title. Like it really packed a punch to me when that happened in It Ends With Us. And it was SO cute how this title was included in the story.
I don't know how people re read any books.. I can not do that! Lol I get so excited when I finish any book and get excited even more to start a new book right away. That's just me! Love your vlogs by the way!! 😊
I personally gave the book 5/5 but I feel like it hits me on such a personal level and reminds me of my mom and with the beautiful writing, I knew it cannot be any other way. And Atlas of course. I understand your POV, the only thing I would maybe fault it, it was a bit too short for me, I could've read more 😄 Love this video !
I just finished reading it! But it was so cute I agree ryle needs more than therapy for sure. But I loved seeing more about Atlas & his past! Also loved how they finally got a happy ending I was tearing up!!
It was 5 stars for me! I've always loved Atlas. A sweet thought I had - what if Atlas is partly based on Colleen's stepdad since she based Lily & Ryle on her mom and bio dad? Don't know but I love that idea. I think she did well with showing this post-divorce situation and how a man like Ryle would react; people needed to see the real him. I love the found family aspect, Atlas's letters, all of it!
I just bought the book yesterday and I’m already 124 pages in, I’m enjoying it so far but there are some cringy moments in it. It’s definitely not better than it ends with us but I’m liking it so far. Honestly, I was just expecting a bit more from it.
I literally have the book on my shelf and decided I needed to watch ur vid before picking it up lol i agree w ur thoughts about atlas on the first book so I’m glad there’s much more of him. love that u still filmed this without ur camera #true dedication love u sara❤
@@SaraCarrolli exactlyyyyy!!!!!!! I’ve been putting off reading IEWU for that reason alone! Just ordered my copies today! Can’t wait! Love your content!
Sara u should try brittainy c cherry's book, they are so so good fr. Also I'm not into this book although I loved it ends with us but I'm not into this. Also love your videos sara 💖
loved this book wish the ending was longer. Lily and Atlas deserve the world . And Ryle needs therapy and Jail time because NO. whoever was team Ryle needs therapy .
I didn’t bond with atlas in the first book and also I hated the Journal pages but it is the complete opposite with the second book! I wish more ppl would be like atlas and I also didn’t mind the journal entries maybe because there weren’t as many as in „it ends with us“ but it was a great book especially when you were in a manipulative relationship yourself
So I finished it after I watched this. I just kinda wanted someone to say it was a good book. But I was wondering what made you cry? I read the book and it didn't make me cry.
Love this book I just got mines and I literally am almost done I have been reading it all day your so retry I am your number one fan I don’t see much reading channels so I love this channel!
@@SaraCarrolli i literally bought it as an hardback yesterday, gave it back and then ordered the paperback instead, and now my friend is holding it for me😭 I want to read it so bad
See now I’m like, I don’t know like if a book makes you cry or at least tear up then it’s like it’s worth reading but if not or like it’s good but with no actual action there’s no Point like there has to be a huge plot twist for me to actually enjoy it
2 ปีที่แล้ว
AH I just posted my vlog of this too! I know what you mean about the journal entries, I read the books back to back so it was very repetitive for me. It Ends With Us left me feeling really traumatized and I was very upset with most of Lily's decisions in the first book, but the second book was a breath of fresh air and it actually became a romance!
I love this book Ryles is just disgusting honestly, like he’s just horrible anyways love the book love atlas love Lily and their love. I think it ends with us obviously still better, but this was a really great book for me. It was like a long, happy epilogue.
I think the video of reading this book is really good. I'm also uploading a video of reading a book, I think it helps me focus on the book~ I hope we can continue to read books together. thanks for the good video have a good day😄
I really want to read this book 🙁 it's not available in here.. Will have to wait for the PDF version in a few months 😍😍 meanwhile I'll thrive on these reviews 💕💕💕
well I am glad with the video. bcause I was really not interested but I did read it ends with us but mister colleen made this book 20 euros like ?? it ends with us was 11,50 and this one??miss girl knew. so yeh,
Tbh I loved it ends with us because of Lily. Just the fact that this book involves Ryle is such a turn off. I hated him in the first book and I was one of those people who hated him from the very beginning because of all the red flags. Just to know that he interferes with Atlas and Lily's relationship is so jarring. I don't think I'm going to pick this one up
You can say it girl it’s boring. Ryle’s sister and her husband are actually quite toxic. If that was my brother I’d throw him to the dogs. A lot of excuses are made for him because he killed his brother! He’s an awful person. I skipped all the diary entries I hate them and dear Ellen I never want to read that again.
can we all agree that we need a book about theo and joshs friendship and like highschool years ect
“ryle.. needs more than therapy”😂 i love that
I loved this. I didn't find it boring, cause it was kind of what I expected. We all knew what it would be about beforehand amd that they would still end up together. It was just a bit more details about their happily ever after ish
No other book tuber compares to your content Sara! I work from home and look forward to your new videos!!!
Omg thank you so much
I’m so glad you said you weren’t Team Atlas in the first book. I wasn’t sure if I was the only one but I didn’t connect with him AT ALL in the first book. Was completely indifferent about him and so I’m glad this book brings lots more of him!! I’m starting it tomorrow!
I didn't love Atlas but Ryle made it pretty hard for us to like him...
I loved Atlas, i also loved ryle at first but he’s abusive so Atlas>>
Omg I loved atlas I hated ryle
yes same here ! i didn't like atlas too much at first but it starts with us made me fall
@@makeuprudie6540 definitely! I’m total team atlas after ISWU 😍
I LOVED the refrence to the book title. Like it really packed a punch to me when that happened in It Ends With Us. And it was SO cute how this title was included in the story.
I don't know how people re read any books.. I can not do that! Lol I get so excited when I finish any book and get excited even more to start a new book right away. That's just me! Love your vlogs by the way!! 😊
Now we need a Marshall and Allysa book
Wishing your Dad a wonderful birthday. Hope you all enjoyed your time.
Thank you so much!!
Aw yes!
screaming crying FREAKING OUT!!! ahhhh I cannot wait to watch this 🥲
For the FIRST TIME ✨ I'm actually buddy reading a book with Queen Sara 🙌❤️😭
I personally gave the book 5/5 but I feel like it hits me on such a personal level and reminds me of my mom and with the beautiful writing, I knew it cannot be any other way. And Atlas of course.
I understand your POV, the only thing I would maybe fault it, it was a bit too short for me, I could've read more 😄
Love this video !
I totally agree
I just finished reading it! But it was so cute I agree ryle needs more than therapy for sure. But I loved seeing more about Atlas & his past! Also loved how they finally got a happy ending I was tearing up!!
"He's too good to be true. Ryle needs more than teraphy. 😂😂
Yes and Atlas don't have any negative sides no fights with Lilly like not just a one.
you and destiny pulling through with the coho content >>>
It was 5 stars for me! I've always loved Atlas. A sweet thought I had - what if Atlas is partly based on Colleen's stepdad since she based Lily & Ryle on her mom and bio dad? Don't know but I love that idea. I think she did well with showing this post-divorce situation and how a man like Ryle would react; people needed to see the real him. I love the found family aspect, Atlas's letters, all of it!
Your videos are the best thing on this app 😌❤
Just picked mine up from Walmart! I was shocked they had it. So excited, gonna be my next read.
I just bought the book yesterday and I’m already 124 pages in, I’m enjoying it so far but there are some cringy moments in it. It’s definitely not better than it ends with us but I’m liking it so far. Honestly, I was just expecting a bit more from it.
is ryle is present in this book?
@@alicha2646 ya Ryle is in the book
@@alicha2646 yes unfortunately and he’s more annoying in this book
the way that i agree with EVERYTHING you said about this book!!
I literally have the book on my shelf and decided I needed to watch ur vid before picking it up lol i agree w ur thoughts about atlas on the first book so I’m glad there’s much more of him. love that u still filmed this without ur camera #true dedication love u sara❤
SCREAMING!!!!! coming back and watching this on saturday when i get my book :)
I liked the vidéo before watching it. That’s how you know i love every vidéo she posts
Yesss I just got the book today at Walmart ❤️💐🌸
Hi Sara you just make my day better every day
I justtt placedd an order for this book! Can'ttttt waitttt to readdd itttt!😭
Hey! Sara my day is incomplete without your vlogs so so much you inspired me so so much and I wish you reach 200K Subscribers very very soon!✨💞☺️
loved this so so much
I enjoyed the video Sara this was fun to watch
yeah the 200 page mark really makes the book picks up fr
Yayyy I was just think about you.. wanted you to do this vlog!!! 😊👐🏼
I need to get back into reading. Seriously. Good job motivating me.
fav notification of the day!!! love u
🫶🏼
i need to make a coho reading vlog to catch up on all her books 😂
Love the vid ❤ can you do more reading vlogs?
Yes!
Starting to read it today! I’m so excited :)
I was so excited for this video ! 💕
I just wanted to say i love your videos i think your amazing ❤️
Thank u! ☺️
I haven’t read any CoHo books yet! I’m gonna read IEWU and ISWU back to back! Just have to go get a copy of each! 😂
Omg back to back is gonna be good!!!
@@SaraCarrolli exactlyyyyy!!!!!!! I’ve been putting off reading IEWU for that reason alone! Just ordered my copies today! Can’t wait! Love your content!
Sara u should try brittainy c cherry's book, they are so so good fr. Also I'm not into this book although I loved it ends with us but I'm not into this. Also love your videos sara 💖
Omg new video after just 22 hours😭😭
And guess what 🤭 I have another one coming either tmrw or Saturday
sooo excited to read this one!!!
best part of my day😽
I am so excited to read it!!
IM READING THIS NOW
I’m in the same place with this book. Page 100 and I’m like ok… something needs to happen or this book is about nothing lol.
Haven’t read it yet but already have a feeling I won’t enjoy it as much as It Ends With Us but I am very excited to read Atlas’s POV.
currently doing a reading vlog for this one but I am reading it so fast that it might be 5 minutes lol but my thoughts exactly about the book so far!!
Just finished it and was hoping someone had some thoughts to share with me!! Thank you 🎉
The fact that everyone has this book but i’m one of the few that still doesn’t have this book😩
I don’t have it yet either 😔
I preordered mine and it’s delayed istg I’m so mad
loved this book wish the ending was longer. Lily and Atlas deserve the world . And Ryle needs therapy and Jail time because NO. whoever was team Ryle needs therapy .
Im not mad about the recycled journal entries. I read It Ends With Us a while back. Not even that long ago, but my memory is shit. So I'm glad😹
I'm excited to read this (:
running to the bookstore to buy it
I didn’t bond with atlas in the first book and also I hated the Journal pages but it is the complete opposite with the second book! I wish more ppl would be like atlas and I also didn’t mind the journal entries maybe because there weren’t as many as in „it ends with us“ but it was a great book especially when you were in a manipulative relationship yourself
I have this book on my list of books to get! Your videos are so fun & help me get out of my reading slumps! 🤍
🤍🤍
i’ve watched three vids today about this book today and none of them LOVED Atlas in the first book lol
curious. what music or sound do you listen to on the AirPodsMax while reading ??? Thanks!
I look up playlists for the books im reading! If i cant find one then it’s usually just harry or taylor swift lol
8:23 ryleeee ... needs more than therapy lol 😂😂😂
I just got my package today and I’m so excited to read it!
I’m so excited for this book!
omg idk if I'm ready
So I finished it after I watched this. I just kinda wanted someone to say it was a good book. But I was wondering what made you cry? I read the book and it didn't make me cry.
The letter he wrote her! I think it was towards the end
"they ar for context u need to read that" u sounded like ariana grande
Love this book I just got mines and I literally am almost done I have been reading it all day your so retry I am your number one fan I don’t see much reading channels so I love this channel!
Mine just arrived at home, but I’m on vaccation 😭
That was me
@@SaraCarrolli i literally bought it as an hardback yesterday, gave it back and then ordered the paperback instead, and now my friend is holding it for me😭 I want to read it so bad
Shocked there’s a buy 1 get 1 50% sticker on a brand new release??
The way Colleen Hoover added TikTok made me mad😃It was so random
See now I’m like, I don’t know like if a book makes you cry or at least tear up then it’s like it’s worth reading but if not or like it’s good but with no actual action there’s no Point like there has to be a huge plot twist for me to actually enjoy it
AH I just posted my vlog of this too! I know what you mean about the journal entries, I read the books back to back so it was very repetitive for me. It Ends With Us left me feeling really traumatized and I was very upset with most of Lily's decisions in the first book, but the second book was a breath of fresh air and it actually became a romance!
I can’t believe they rushed into their wedding 😭😭😭😭
Hi, Sara. Did you read the recent NYT article on Colleen Hoover? If not, you’d like it❗️
I haven’t yet!
I feel like the only person on the planet that didn’t enjoy It Ends with Us
Honestly if I read it now rather than a few years ago my opinion would definitely be different
I love this book Ryles is just disgusting honestly, like he’s just horrible anyways love the book love atlas love Lily and their love. I think it ends with us obviously still better, but this was a really great book for me. It was like a long, happy epilogue.
I’m almost done it and thoroughly enjoying it. CoHo is a great story teller.
I think the video of reading this book is really good.
I'm also uploading a video of reading a book, I think it helps me focus on the book~
I hope we can continue to read books together.
thanks for the good video
have a good day😄
Book Recommendation: Virus Outbreak by Matt Doeden 🎃
I really want to read this book 🙁 it's not available in here.. Will have to wait for the PDF version in a few months 😍😍 meanwhile I'll thrive on these reviews 💕💕💕
well I am glad with the video. bcause I was really not interested but I did read it ends with us but mister colleen made this book 20 euros like ?? it ends with us was 11,50 and this one??miss girl knew. so yeh,
Who would you cast for it ends with us???
❤❤❤❤ ily
❤️😍❤️
Is it just me but is the height of it starts with us bigger than it ends with us?
IM EARLYYY 🎉
Tbh I loved it ends with us because of Lily. Just the fact that this book involves Ryle is such a turn off. I hated him in the first book and I was one of those people who hated him from the very beginning because of all the red flags. Just to know that he interferes with Atlas and Lily's relationship is so jarring. I don't think I'm going to pick this one up
This book made me just hate ryle more and more that's the only reason of publishing this book (didn't finish it yet)
omg ngl the book was a little disappointing 😩
it was good but idk i was expecting more.
Agreed!
Hi!
Hope your doing well (:
You can say it girl it’s boring. Ryle’s sister and her husband are actually quite toxic. If that was my brother I’d throw him to the dogs. A lot of excuses are made for him because he killed his brother! He’s an awful person.
I skipped all the diary entries I hate them and dear Ellen I never want to read that again.