They really were friends please stop saying Seolhyun bullied her she wouldn't do that to Mina I can see it they were truly close😭💔🥺 my poor babies I'm tearing up
yeah. they only have one vid of seolhyun pointing mina and she said its juast because mina makes many mistakes but not like how jimin points at mina. other than that no more. mina won't hold seolhyuns legs if she does not like her. maybe seolhyun was forced by jimin to be her bestfriend because seolhyun is the most popular AOA. that would make sense. we saw a lot of jimin mina not being good at each other becausejimin is a bully it would be hard to pretend you like someone really. i they dont like each other it will show. maybe jimin is using seoulhyun to gain more attention and more subscribers in her yt
@@treinandoparaobalepotter7384 yeah it really makes me sad to that seolhyun is now being targetteed 😭 sish people stop hatin and just prayin' thing would kinda workout
Both of you don't know how Jimin really is. Only the ones close enough could say. There was only one side of the story so far due to contractual and comotion reasons. Give love to Mina, don't say bs of Jimin.
Stop hate seolhyun in her insta account please Because if she didn't nothing wrong It can hurt her heart She is best friend with mina I think Jimin just want to have more popularity so she get close with seolhyun I think that jimin jelaous to mina because she close with seolhyun
Is it just only me think that Jimin is attention seeker? i think it make sense bcus seolhyun is the most famous member and maybe Jimin didn't want seolhyun to get close with mina. And maybe she will beat seolhyun or body shaming seolhyun if she didn't be her bestfriends. *this is just my speculation based on my research and what i see. I can't say this is the truth unless i became the 8th member of AOA and debut with them lol..
Maybe somewhat unexpectedly, Mina kinda has the male energy between these two. And yet is obviously the wife with Hyejeong. Still somehow, Seolhyun is hubby with Hyejeong.....very interesting.
I guess jimin were jealous for seolhyun n mina relationship, plus both were famous around men. Mybe seolhyun also been threats by jimin, so she forcely be friend with jimin.
i think so toobecause seolhyun is themost popular so jimin is using her. if mina was able to say jimin bullied her then she could say that to any AOA members too if she wants to. no vids shows seolhyun being bad to mina. even tzuyu says seoulhyun is a very kindblike older sister during their practice and collaboration. people saying seolhyun is a bully too should think about it. they could all been bullied by jimin
@@pandasoftT I can feel seolhyun may also hurt inside seeing her beloved unnie(mina) bullied by jimin but yet cannot do anything for help, or mybe she doesn't knowjimin doing bad to mina when she's so busy with her drama and stuff, but jimin acting good when they being together. Who knows right.
A Personal Note: As a kid I practiced to look good Photographically. The one (1) trait that goes with God Given good looks is...to be able to express your "genuine feelings"..."to be sincere".
I loved it. I had photographs with friends, animals, tuxedos, stop action performances, etcetera. Point: The one thing that made me "real & attractive", to the viewer, was that I was able to express my "genuine feelings". I was "Sincere" in a "Fun Loving way"! Love "Authenticity (God given) & Thankfulness"!
A Key characteristic that I developed from this experience & Botany (at a young age) was..."Objective Empathy"... with... "Awareness & Consciousness"! Love "Authenticity & Thankfulness". Good job, Mina Chan.
I really thought Jimin was the one to blame, but what Mina said is what makes me rethink everything. She said "you are all the same". Don't know about u, but that says a lot to me, but I also understand that the reason why she wrote that was because she felt betrayed by the other members, and they kinda did. Not saying anything and not defending her makes u think that they all sided Jimin in this. I want with all my heart to think they are not like her, but I know they weren't right either. Seeing this kind of videos makes me realize that they could have genuinely cared about her. Anyway, we don't know what were they facing/thinking at the moment. I hope Mina feel loved and supported and that everyone is okay and reflecting on their actions.
@@theextremelycrucialcaterpi6988 What has come out is why I was surprised. On camera everything seems great and everybody seems to be so close, but off camera people aren't getting along so well. This is exactly what happens with groups in the west. They look like they love each other on camera, but off they are at each other's throat. No matter where you go people are still the same.
Paul Dillingham Yeah it depends on their personalities really! Little Mix are all genuinely really close but I guess it’s hard when so many personalities are thrown together like in Fifth Harmony, you have to be lucky to get along with every single member
The one question I have about Mina's accusation toward Jimin is that she claimed that Jimin had been picking on her for 10 years before she left the group. At the time Mina left, the group had been in existence for only 7 years. That would have meant that Jimin would have to have been picking on Mina for 3 years before the group even started. So, when the group was just starting, why didn't Mina refuse to join the group if it meant being in a group with someone she didn't get along with? Why put up with the bully for another 7 years when she had the opportunity not to even join? This makes me suspicious of her accusation.
She wanted to be an Idol, she was not going to refuse just because someone didn't liked her. The bullying was probably less worst back then because Jimin could've have been kicked out of the compagny if Mina reported her actions before their debut. They denied what Jimin did after their debut because Jimin was one of the most popular members and they couldn't afford to lost another member.
![“Old Man? Guess Again- I’m an Idol” l KANG MIN KYUNG&aespa NINGNING [SELF-ON KODE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9irjIz6Clpc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Twins’ House - Hot tub date with AOA girls [The Return of Superman / 2017.01.01]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hDnaDIzQk6I/mqdefault.jpg)
They really were friends please stop saying Seolhyun bullied her she wouldn't do that to Mina I can see it they were truly close😭💔🥺 my poor babies I'm tearing up
yeah. they only have one vid of seolhyun pointing mina and she said its juast because mina makes many mistakes but not like how jimin points at mina. other than that no more. mina won't hold seolhyuns legs if she does not like her. maybe seolhyun was forced by jimin to be her bestfriend because seolhyun is the most popular AOA. that would make sense. we saw a lot of jimin mina not being good at each other becausejimin is a bully it would be hard to pretend you like someone really. i they dont like each other it will show. maybe jimin is using seoulhyun to gain more attention and more subscribers in her yt
@@pandasoftT What a horrible thing, we see that Seolhyun and mine are good for each other, Jimin is really bad😫😭
@@treinandoparaobalepotter7384 yeah it really makes me sad to that seolhyun is now being targetteed 😭 sish people stop hatin and just prayin' thing would kinda workout
take care mina, we love you
❤❤❤
my babies
Yes❤️❤️
See seolhyun have kind heart she is not like Jimin
I worried that Jimin was a bad influence on Seolhyun. Maybe that's going to turn out to be true.
Both of you don't know how Jimin really is. Only the ones close enough could say. There was only one side of the story so far due to contractual and comotion reasons.
Give love to Mina, don't say bs of Jimin.
Stop hate seolhyun in her insta account please
Because if she didn't nothing wrong
It can hurt her heart
She is best friend with mina
I think Jimin just want to have more popularity so she get close with seolhyun
I think that jimin jelaous to mina because she close with seolhyun
Is it just only me think that Jimin is attention seeker? i think it make sense bcus seolhyun is the most famous member and maybe Jimin didn't want seolhyun to get close with mina. And maybe she will beat seolhyun or body shaming seolhyun if she didn't be her bestfriends.
*this is just my speculation based on my research and what i see. I can't say this is the truth unless i became the 8th member of AOA and debut with them lol..
Thanks so much :) its beautiful
Try to do more duo like this pls..in AOA i mean more or any cut etc anything
Maybe somewhat unexpectedly, Mina kinda has the male energy between these two. And yet is obviously the wife with Hyejeong. Still somehow, Seolhyun is hubby with Hyejeong.....very interesting.
They are both women
Subtlety is confusing huh?
what?
The streak continues.
u are dumb ass loser get life from shipping
3:59 she was Hypnotized by the tension HoLy FuCk
Jimin was just a bad influence on Seolhyun, seolhyun doesn't naturally have a bad nature. Manipulative people can influence others alot
Jimin disliked this with her multiple accounts
they looks in love
The best legend couple to stay forever👍👍👍👍👍
3 dislikes from Hyejeong, Jimin & Zico . HAHAHA
De Soul Lynn HAAHAHAHAHA😂😂😂👌🏻
💔💔
:(
Lmao😭😂😂
why
여신 둘이 너무 보기 좋네요 ❤️
mina and seolhyun bestfriend
Two beautiful women for sure!
2:27 mina what do u touch? 7u7
I guess jimin were jealous for seolhyun n mina relationship, plus both were famous around men. Mybe seolhyun also been threats by jimin, so she forcely be friend with jimin.
Yes that's what i think too
But people think seolhyun bullied mina too
@@samueltristan6699 hope seolhyun will say something soon😢
@@aishahsharif9671 me too
i think so toobecause seolhyun is themost popular so jimin is using her. if mina was able to say jimin bullied her then she could say that to any AOA members too if she wants to. no vids shows seolhyun being bad to mina. even tzuyu says seoulhyun is a very kindblike older sister during their practice and collaboration. people saying seolhyun is a bully too should think about it. they could all been bullied by jimin
@@pandasoftT I can feel seolhyun may also hurt inside seeing her beloved unnie(mina) bullied by jimin but yet cannot do anything for help, or mybe she doesn't knowjimin doing bad to mina when she's so busy with her drama and stuff, but jimin acting good when they being together. Who knows right.
A Personal Note: As a kid I practiced to look good Photographically. The one (1) trait that goes with God Given good looks is...to be able to express your "genuine feelings"..."to be sincere".
I loved it. I had photographs with friends, animals, tuxedos, stop action performances, etcetera. Point: The one thing that made me "real & attractive", to the viewer, was that I was able to express my "genuine feelings". I was "Sincere" in a "Fun Loving way"! Love "Authenticity (God given) & Thankfulness"!
A Key characteristic that I developed from this experience & Botany (at a young age) was..."Objective Empathy"... with... "Awareness & Consciousness"! Love "Authenticity & Thankfulness". Good job, Mina Chan.
Mina Chan has a great Trait & Style! It's called, "Photogenic"! (Look at me.)
Photogenic is essential...in acting...for Advertising & Product Recognition & identification!
"Mina Chan" can hold her own with "Seolhyun & Hyejeong"! And that's saying a lot. Great Team for "ROI & Ticket Sales"! PS: 24 years old, 9/17!
I really thought Jimin was the one to blame, but what Mina said is what makes me rethink everything. She said "you are all the same". Don't know about u, but that says a lot to me, but I also understand that the reason why she wrote that was because she felt betrayed by the other members, and they kinda did. Not saying anything and not defending her makes u think that they all sided Jimin in this.
I want with all my heart to think they are not like her, but I know they weren't right either.
Seeing this kind of videos makes me realize that they could have genuinely cared about her. Anyway, we don't know what were they facing/thinking at the moment.
I hope Mina feel loved and supported and that everyone is okay and reflecting on their actions.
Mina didnt say you all the same... Its Youkyung, ex member.
@@bbudimanalqodriyou are absolutely right, I read it wrong...
Thanks for correcting me :)
We love you mina ❤❤❤❤❤ stay strong
It's amazing to me how well these girls get along with each other. If this was an American group they would be at each other's throats.
Paul Dillingham This comment didn’t age well 😆
This aged like milk
@@theextremelycrucialcaterpi6988 What has come out is why I was surprised. On camera everything seems great and everybody seems to be so close, but off camera people aren't getting along so well. This is exactly what happens with groups in the west. They look like they love each other on camera, but off they are at each other's throat. No matter where you go people are still the same.
Paul Dillingham Yeah it depends on their personalities really! Little Mix are all genuinely really close but I guess it’s hard when so many personalities are thrown together like in Fifth Harmony, you have to be lucky to get along with every single member
@@pauldillingham6316 hey mina is lying for the whole bullying thing it has been disproved now~
The one question I have about Mina's accusation toward Jimin is that she claimed that Jimin had been picking on her for 10 years before she left the group. At the time Mina left, the group had been in existence for only 7 years. That would have meant that Jimin would have to have been picking on Mina for 3 years before the group even started. So, when the group was just starting, why didn't Mina refuse to join the group if it meant being in a group with someone she didn't get along with? Why put up with the bully for another 7 years when she had the opportunity not to even join? This makes me suspicious of her accusation.
Paul Dillingham Probably to pursue her dream as an idol and taking the chance just in case she doesn’t have another.
Andd sheee had to helps her parents cz they weren't financially goodd
She wanted to be an Idol, she was not going to refuse just because someone didn't liked her. The bullying was probably less worst back then because Jimin could've have been kicked out of the compagny if Mina reported her actions before their debut. They denied what Jimin did after their debut because Jimin was one of the most popular members and they couldn't afford to lost another member.
Actually she explained that, her parents weren't that well off financially and endured everything for them.
mds que tristeza
sim vey
Vemos que a Seolhyun tem um coração, diferente da Jimin 😭❤️
What's this song
Attracted Woman - Monsta X
GAYOA.
세상에나 이영성 뭐냐 우린 널 방관자 가식덩어리라 부른다 이젠 안속아
10년을 함께 해왔고 관계는 늘 바뀌는 거니깐..... 좋았던 때도 있고 어느 순간 민아를 아프게 하기도 했을 테고 그런게지
Uhhh that didn’t age well
Robert Sch ye