Man nothing hits differently like old kpop music. Listening to old bap, bts, vixx, beast, exo and bigbang still make me feel things no other music ever can
Yup. This gen doesn't have the emotional storyline like it needs to. The music is decent but everyones having fanwars and insulting the gals for not having perfect bodies, and its SO OVERRATED istg
I agree with this. Probably the reason why I'm sticking to OGs like VIXX and not finding other groups. I like a good concept, and a unique story with the albums. Not much of these in today's groups.
When first time hongbin sing was at 0.44 .. His voice being so rough... But at 2.46 his voice being so soft... He very talented... I like him and Hyuk...
Lokyee Yan Yes! I also kept switching between the GR8U and Error videos because I love how he can go from being all cute and playful to sexy and mysterious. *sigh*
+Subin Ma-Hee No...isn't it the prequel to Hyde, and if not that, apparently falls in the same category. We all know how well Hyde went in terms of relationships ._.
Wow, the lyrics are really powerful. Add their amazing vocal abilities and emotional musicality and it is magic. Seriously though, whenever I've been hurt by a guy I totally feel like this song. Tell them I don't care and they can go shove it but secretly cry in my room while watching He's Just Not That Into You. LOL!
I almost did. And I never cry. But you know what's worse? I felt all breathless and painful and THAT only happens in the worst of situations to me. It goes beyond crying. It's like drowning basically. That's what this song and MV did to me. Idk why I'm even spilling all this out in a youtube comment section lol.
this song makes me feel so emotional. Like, the lyrics help, but it's really the harmonies and the music. It's so beautiful and painful at the same time. Like, I like a lot of kpop, but songs that actually affect me emotionally are pretty few and far in between. And it's not like this song is just bittersweet and makes me nostalgic - it makes me feel something bigger, something deeper. It reminds me of how I feel when I listen to the Hebrew Slave's Chorus from Nabucco or Mahler's Second Symphony (yes, you read right - i did compare kpop to classical music, and I meant it). It's hard to pinpoint, but it's like a mix of sadness and compassion in the face of someone expressing so much pain, but doing it so beautifully. I really wish this song were longer - 4 min is such a short time to go through such deep emotions and when it's done I am always like "wuh? it can't be over yet"
Never before has a song made me sob so hard (; ;) I've never even had my heart broken like this before and yet I can feel it through this song. It's so amazing, and so is the MV. Too many feels for a simple fangirl
Vixx always puts so much meaning in their songs.. I think that's why I love them more than other bands, even American bands.. I can't believe Hongbin's voice can get that low! Wow! My bias was always Ravi but as time went on I've found that I can't like one member more than the other they're all so kind and I love how Hongbin and Leo are polar opposites. Hongbin always smiles while Leo doesn't. I think I'm totally hooked.
+Amanda Flynn Leo does smile and laugh quite easily (specifically when he's flustered) but he hides his face or bows his head. I agree with you so much omg. American singers these days sing mostly about the same things over and over (bad break up, sex, alcohol, drugs, being in love, not getting the person you love to love you back, etc.) and when there _is_ a song with a different, unique meaning it's always obvious in the lyrics. I think what I like about VIXX's songs is that they not only have unique and heartbreaking/dark meanings to their songs, but it's kind of like a riddle that you have to interpret. The quotes are beautiful and meaningful as well, and their MVs and choreography are just amazing
+peppermint5509 i gotta watch that drama....but im afraid that ill get addicted like i do with all kdrams, and cant handle waiting for new episodes each week...
Wow...I started listening to Kpop like 11 years ago or so and the older I got I stopped updating on every group. I actually got to like VIXX they have great songs but this one...now that I'm kinda in a situation like this it touches me so deeply I almost started to cry...actually I said I wouldn't cry anymore and it's not just about a simple relationship I think it's about something even deeper...a special connection between 2. idk how to describe it but hands down to VIXX for this wonderful song
I saw you again, I cried Something went terribly wrong My heart is still remembering (let me free) Everything was the same (let me breathe) There’s nowhere to run from you ^ Kills me! Love this song so much!
After getting out of a 3 year relationship of false hope, Vixx were promoting this song and it was exactly how I felt. This permanently got me back into kpop after 8 years, and I can't thank this group enough.
I'm having a VIXX marathon and I miss my boys.. Concept kings and they all are catchy af.. Throwback to our younger years y'all ㅠㅠ miss my 2nd gen groups
omg this song makes me cry every time.....reading the Hangul.....this song just is so depressing but beautiful at the same time. Great job with the Hangul! Good job spelling it correctly! I am now so happy. ^3^
This is one of the most powerful songs I've ever had the pleasure to listen to...It takes my breath away at how perfect it is. VIXX is absolutely amazing and I'm so proud to be a fan of theirs.
I remember I once said aloud "Stan VIXX." and someone heard me. He said something like, "VIXX is super talented." When he asked which song was my favorite, I said Fantasy and Error. He then said "Error reminds me of Detroit:Become Human." We've been friends ever since 😂
So the music video already makes me cry, but the lyrics hurt even more. Because they don't need to apply to just romance. It can apply to school (I'm often forget in school because I'm slightly slower than everyone else) so here I am bawling my eyes out because I relate!!!
This song always makes me feel some type of way. idk how to say it, but it is always the start of the song that makes me feel some kind of dejavu. it is I C O N I C
in my opinion one of the BEsT kpop songs.and ive heard of so many songs .the catchy lines and oh my god those lyrics really made it impossible for me to STOP singing it in my head.also from one point when i first heard it while seeing the lyrics i cried.this never happened to me for a kpop song
They deserve more fame seriously this is my first K-pop band that I have listened to and they are amazing...i love all of them so much...I'm gonna meet these guys someday and tell them on their faces "YOU ROCK" 😁
I have so much love for this song. My friend showed it to me over a year ago and it was the first Video I'd seen with VIXX. I came back to listening to this album this exact time last year: During exam week. Ever since I've fallen in love with all 6 of them and I can't express how much this one song means to me. I will remember it years from now because it's that type of song :) Starlight Fighting! VIXX Fighting!
they're talking about how they want to breathe, and here i am, only just now getting into vixx and i can't breathe because of their amazing vocals and beautiful faces omg
oh i remember that error era it was the time i knew vixx and fell in love with them but i refused to admit i love as much as to officially join the fandom till fantasy era
Crazy how I never really looked up the lyrics of older songs because I was already used to companies never putting up english subtitles. Now that I've seen them I love the song even more 😭
![VIXX - Eternity (기적) [Hangul/Romanization/English] Color & Picture Coded HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/phIn8yddjZU/mqdefault.jpg)
![VIXX - Eternity (기적) [Hangul/Romanization/English] Color & Picture Coded HD](/img/tr.png)
legit one of the best kpop songs ive ever heard.GAME.CHANGER.
back again because Jesus it's so good
Maci Johnson couldn't agree more
agreeee
Nd i m here in 2018 luv this so much
Ikr
"i saw you again, i cried. something went terribly wrong"
omg this part 😭
Are you ok?
Still one of the best and most underrated kpop songs of ALL time.
fucking yesss
YEEES !!
Suga sold Jimin's jams for 3 dollars True and your username gives me life XD
Your username though! ARMY!
Hyuk's voice is so damn beautiful he deserves more lines tbh
Lena Layth yes he does he is amazing
Error is the best kpop song so far
Theres a reason this comment has no dislikes
Agree
Definitely one of the best👌
Well said. So true
Maura N that youtube doesnt show dislikes on comments
Man nothing hits differently like old kpop music. Listening to old bap, bts, vixx, beast, exo and bigbang still make me feel things no other music ever can
Yup. This gen doesn't have the emotional storyline like it needs to. The music is decent but everyones having fanwars and insulting the gals for not having perfect bodies, and its SO OVERRATED istg
@@jaepark4124 yea. like bro nobody's perfect lmao. People have really changed over the years. Their getting more disrespectful. T°T
I agree with this. Probably the reason why I'm sticking to OGs like VIXX and not finding other groups. I like a good concept, and a unique story with the albums. Not much of these in today's groups.
When first time hongbin sing was at 0.44 .. His voice being so rough... But at 2.46 his voice being so soft... He very talented... I like him and Hyuk...
can i know u?
I still cannot believe at 0.40, is it really hongbin? It sounds like ravi, srsly good job hongbin
same!😊
D.O kyungsoo namiA hongbin and hyuk are pretty cool but I prefer Leo
@eunicorn eunice N is the oldest
this title represents my existence
Haha same :,u
jamless kookie I was supposed to cry bc of the song but you make my emotion error.
I love your profile pic btw
😂
Replaying Hongbin's part over and over...
Yas his voice is amazing he needs more parts
Lokyee Yan Yes! I also kept switching between the GR8U and Error videos because I love how he can go from being all cute and playful to sexy and mysterious. *sigh*
Luanne Lewis legend says you’re still replaying hongbin’s part
mood
his voice is legend
Here is the question... will they ever have a title song/comeback song that is about a *healthy* relationship?
+Subin Ma-Hee No...isn't it the prequel to Hyde, and if not that, apparently falls in the same category. We all know how well Hyde went in terms of relationships ._.
+Subin Ma-Hee hyde is the sequel to g.r.8.u, so nope.
I kept thinking and was like what about their new song Dynamite... Nope, guess not!
I was about to say chained up...nope it's just my crazy dirty mind
Levi's Height Infires my Jams Definitely not Dynamite that's for sure.
My grades are lower than Hongbin's voice.
same
+Amelia Oprean LOL
cyberNyan He has quite a bit in Dynamite. Have you listened to that song?
hongbins voice is my life
he kinda has a lot of lines in super hero but after that i did not hear him sings more than 2 lines
then there's hongbin with his deep voice😂😂❤
Ravi's rap parts in this song go so hard I feel like punching a wall omg!!!
+Bonsquisha Samoa I feel that with Vodoo Doll and On and On lol
Ravioli always has the best parts
his hat tho
@@brem4204 WTF??
Joy 2605 Ravioli
.. when i saw the mv.. i want to cry
You wanted to cry?? I DID cry lol. It was so sad, but it was also really beautiful.
I cried 🙊 It's sad 💔 but beautiful 😍
It was SOOOOO sadddddd 😭😭😭😭
You know what? I like the red - headed one♥!
Ehem, not to interrupt you but all of them has red hair.......
Eiman Danial i mean that I like the all~!!
Hahahahahhahahahhaa faiiiiil +Eiman Danial
Yasa Ebady not really, just saying u know?
LMAO
This song is so sad 😔 and the MV even more 😭
ikr
Wow, the lyrics are really powerful. Add their amazing vocal abilities and emotional musicality and it is magic.
Seriously though, whenever I've been hurt by a guy I totally feel like this song. Tell them I don't care and they can go shove it but secretly cry in my room while watching He's Just Not That Into You. LOL!
i was crying the first time i watched the MV T_T
This song is the anthem of unrequited love
when u tryin to read the lyrics then just forgot about it and just kept singing because its so catchy and addicting
same😊😊😂😂💗💖💖
Aebee Alcaraz I RELATE
Lol me
Same 😂😂😂
Me everytime
Can't stop listening to this song
Same here ❤
Press "pause" buton.
xDDDDDDDDDD
Same😍
My favorite song ^^
+ChimChim Swag it's mine too
I felt bad when Hyuk said LET ME FREE...LET ME BREATHE
😢
me too. 😢😢
It's sad he had to beg for more lines. 😢
Steadystrike Lol i dont know whether to laugh or kick you. 😂😂😂
he's literally me when I get suffocated into fandoms
I remeber the first time I saw this I teared up and I RARELY tear up
same
I almost did. And I never cry. But you know what's worse? I felt all breathless and painful and THAT only happens in the worst of situations to me. It goes beyond crying. It's like drowning basically. That's what this song and MV did to me. Idk why I'm even spilling all this out in a youtube comment section lol.
potaeto थे
omg same
i never cry for stuff like this!!
this song makes me feel so emotional. Like, the lyrics help, but it's really the harmonies and the music. It's so beautiful and painful at the same time. Like, I like a lot of kpop, but songs that actually affect me emotionally are pretty few and far in between. And it's not like this song is just bittersweet and makes me nostalgic - it makes me feel something bigger, something deeper. It reminds me of how I feel when I listen to the Hebrew Slave's Chorus from Nabucco or Mahler's Second Symphony (yes, you read right - i did compare kpop to classical music, and I meant it). It's hard to pinpoint, but it's like a mix of sadness and compassion in the face of someone expressing so much pain, but doing it so beautifully. I really wish this song were longer - 4 min is such a short time to go through such deep emotions and when it's done I am always like "wuh? it can't be over yet"
Hongbin is just so perfect.
Never before has a song made me sob so hard (; ;) I've never even had my heart broken like this before and yet I can feel it through this song. It's so amazing, and so is the MV. Too many feels for a simple fangirl
Vixx always puts so much meaning in their songs.. I think that's why I love them more than other bands, even American bands.. I can't believe Hongbin's voice can get that low! Wow! My bias was always Ravi but as time went on I've found that I can't like one member more than the other they're all so kind and I love how Hongbin and Leo are polar opposites. Hongbin always smiles while Leo doesn't. I think I'm totally hooked.
+Amanda Flynn I wish they did more songs with Hongbins low voice. @_@ Dear lord it's amazing.
+Amanda Flynn Leo does smile and laugh quite easily (specifically when he's flustered) but he hides his face or bows his head. I agree with you so much omg. American singers these days sing mostly about the same things over and over (bad break up, sex, alcohol, drugs, being in love, not getting the person you love to love you back, etc.) and when there _is_ a song with a different, unique meaning it's always obvious in the lyrics. I think what I like about VIXX's songs is that they not only have unique and heartbreaking/dark meanings to their songs, but it's kind of like a riddle that you have to interpret. The quotes are beautiful and meaningful as well, and their MVs and choreography are just amazing
+I Am The Almighty Duck
I completely agree with you. I've seen Leo smile but it's not usually willingly is what I meant.
I don't know anything about this band, but I think I'm in love with Leo. Whoops.
+Frank Oreo Leo is everyone's secret crush xp
+Frank Oreo update: I'm officially a Starlight, and while my crush on Leo remains, I think my bias is N. We'll see, I'm still new.
Frank Oreo u'll have a hard time bcuz I myself not sure who's my bias xp I gave up for Leo sin-set ;^;
Lol before I watched moorim school, me bias was Leo, and slightly N, now It's hongbin 😽
+peppermint5509 i gotta watch that drama....but im afraid that ill get addicted like i do with all kdrams, and cant handle waiting for new episodes each week...
2:35 this part is so emotional... i could feel the sadness in his voice
Wow...I started listening to Kpop like 11 years ago or so and the older I got I stopped updating on every group. I actually got to like VIXX they have great songs but this one...now that I'm kinda in a situation like this it touches me so deeply I almost started to cry...actually I said I wouldn't cry anymore and it's not just about a simple relationship I think it's about something even deeper...a special connection between 2. idk how to describe it but hands down to VIXX for this wonderful song
I saw you again, I cried
Something went terribly wrong
My heart is still remembering (let me free)
Everything was the same (let me breathe)
There’s nowhere to run from you
^ Kills me! Love this song so much!
After getting out of a 3 year relationship of false hope, Vixx were promoting this song and it was exactly how I felt. This permanently got me back into kpop after 8 years, and I can't thank this group enough.
ToTALlY NOT CRYInG
Ikr
+Brianna Jerralds i know just sound so sad that you want to cry
Okay cool girl don't cry then
FINALLY I FOUND SOME ONE
WHO HAS STRONG HEART THAN MINE..
years ago when i found this song, i also cried
This is is so amazing. Can't understand why my sister doesn't like it.
+Binti SimpsonMahoneHoranSykesLadaoVaughns Probably not her taste?
+Corstarkk yeah maybe
+Binti SimpsonMahoneHoranSykesLadaoVaughns I have a legitimate questionWhy is your name so long?
It is a combination of all my favorite american singer before I was in to K-POP.
OLI
Why is this song more eventful than my life?
I'm having a VIXX marathon and I miss my boys.. Concept kings and they all are catchy af.. Throwback to our younger years y'all ㅠㅠ miss my 2nd gen groups
WHAT YES THIS IS EXACTLY ME
"I don't want to let go of myself, I don't want to ruin myself anymore" LEO BBY
"Love, in the end, is a lie to one person" STA A HP
Leo‘s voice is the best in the world. Does anybody else apart from me agree to this statement?
I agree
palash maji totally agree. I live and die by his voice.
I remember crying the 1st time I watched its mv. It seriously threw me in depression. The concept was NO JOKE.
same i did that too.. i didn't watch the mv for 4 years now, finally i watched it again and i cried again.. it's so sad.. even the lyrics is.
I watched the MV and cried, then i came here to see the lyrics. I was doing fine without cry until 2:37, but with these lyrics i just lost my shit T.T
omg this song makes me cry every time.....reading the Hangul.....this song just is so depressing but beautiful at the same time. Great job with the Hangul! Good job spelling it correctly! I am now so happy. ^3^
I like Vixx now, I'm saying this and I ain't taking in back. This song is literally what I was searching for in my life
I want Hyuk to sing more lines!!
Blue Bird me too
Leo
This is one of the most powerful songs I've ever had the pleasure to listen to...It takes my breath away at how perfect it is.
VIXX is absolutely amazing and I'm so proud to be a fan of theirs.
I can relate so much to the lyrics omg 😭
this song sealed the deal for me with Vixx❤😍😍
This song was my first VIXX song, and I cried. Now, VIXX is my bias band and I still cry everytime it's beautiful
I'm not into K-pop, But I just LOVE this song!
Be careful, VIXX could be the one who'll get you into Kpop xD
And yes! This song is A-awesome!
just an advice be carefull cause they will ruin you're life like they did to me *in good way*
Judela Biare true true true true! They play it like 100000000000 times on One Channel... AND REALLY THIS IS ONE OF MY FAV SONGS!
Judela Biare That was the case with me. Vixx and Exo made me love everything Kpop. Kpop is now my life haha :)
I guess there's no Exit for Kpop life xD
Let's just enjoy this kind of "prison-freedom".
Ok am I the only one who thinks Ken looks like a taller/older brother version of D.O. from EXO??
I can't be the only one here O_O
I think the same too.
i think it too
that eyebrow game too strong ~~
it's so great that i'm not the only one who think that TvT ~
P/s: my English... :P
hahahahaha we were just the same! :)
Totally love this song! Their voices blend well with one and another..
Vixx is so underrated. ⚘⚘⚘
The lyrics are so powerful and the video itself is so sad, to be part of such a love only to end up broken in the end 💔
Thats one of the most beautiful songs in kpop. So deep, so meaningful...
I remember I once said aloud "Stan VIXX." and someone heard me. He said something like, "VIXX is super talented."
When he asked which song was my favorite, I said Fantasy and Error.
He then said "Error reminds me of Detroit:Become Human."
We've been friends ever since 😂
This song really hits you in the heart, it"s rare to find song that can do that to you........
I officially got to vixx and I think I'm so late to the party but who cares and I think error is my favorite song by them
same
Hyuks 'Let me free' and 'Let me breath' lines give me LIFE.
This is my absolute favourite song of the whole K-Pop world.
VIXX is one of the only groups out there to have so many iconic songs
VIXX deserves more love.
Okay, first song I hear by VIXX and I have to say... I AM LOVING THIS! Oh my days, the feels are strong with this one
Who's in 2020??
Ok it's just me ok....
Me 💚🖐
Me
..
Me too😁❤️
🤚
i think i fell in love with Leo!! His voice!!! i want to cry😭😭
I’ll never forget ever
hongbin's solo..
This song is so nostalgic. I've become addicted since I first heard it.
Tbh, this song breaks my heart.
Every time I hear Hongbin's part(0:45-0:53) it gives me goosebumps, EVERY TIME!!! It's legit my FAVORITE part of the song!!! A1 vocal tone!!!👌👍👏
I was just missing vixx so much rn and I ended up here
4 years later still having those feels
So the music video already makes me cry, but the lyrics hurt even more. Because they don't need to apply to just romance. It can apply to school (I'm often forget in school because I'm slightly slower than everyone else) so here I am bawling my eyes out because I relate!!!
Omg I really love VIXX.. I saw for the first time some days ago now I am totally obsessed
I missed vixx and this song!!!! Their vocals. ❤️❤️❤️
This is a sad, but a really good song. The mv in my opinion is really sad to the point where I teared up. And I rarely tear up watching a mv...
Have you watched T-ARA Day by Day/Sexy Love MVs one after another? The story made me cry more than error.
No and did you really?
Animefan2016 Titania Erza Yeah. The members all act out a sad story set in a post apocalyptic world
No V No Life I'll check it out
Animefan2016 Titania Erza they are quite lengthy though
This song hurts even more now that Hongbin's gone...
2012 groups really have the best anime ost anthem.....FRICKING LOVE IT OMGGGGGGGG
Wow this lyric is so good T.T
This song always makes me feel some type of way. idk how to say it, but it is always the start of the song that makes me feel some kind of dejavu.
it is I C O N I C
This is actually a great song!
This song always has a place in my heart
2019 and this still incredible
in my opinion one of the BEsT kpop songs.and ive heard of so many songs .the catchy lines and oh my god those lyrics really made it impossible for me to STOP singing it in my head.also from one point when i first heard it while seeing the lyrics i cried.this never happened to me for a kpop song
This song gives me chills and makes me cry everytime I hear it ;-; I’m in love 💗
It’s already 2021 and this never gets any less powerful!!
lmao I've already fallen for hongbin and ravi.. Ravi and I share birthdays, back the fuck up
you soo lucky
Ken's birthday is a day before mine so that kind of counts right? hahaha
pyorite My friend and her bias (N) share the same birthday :^
They are staring into my soul, and I'm loving it
Such an addictive song this is!! 😍
They deserve more fame seriously this is my first K-pop band that I have listened to and they are amazing...i love all of them so much...I'm gonna meet these guys someday and tell them on their faces "YOU ROCK" 😁
It's 2019 and this is still a bop
I have so much love for this song. My friend showed it to me over a year ago and it was the first Video I'd seen with VIXX. I came back to listening to this album this exact time last year: During exam week. Ever since I've fallen in love with all 6 of them and I can't express how much this one song means to me. I will remember it years from now because it's that type of song :) Starlight Fighting! VIXX Fighting!
1:42 for some reason, that part makes my heart sink
김이나 작가님은 천재가 분명하다... 어떻게 가사를 이렇게 잘 쓰실 수 있지?
This song make me cry and I can't stop listening this :(
they're talking about how they want to breathe, and here i am, only just now getting into vixx and i can't breathe because of their amazing vocals and beautiful faces omg
oh i remember that error era it was the time i knew vixx and fell in love with them but i refused to admit i love as much as to officially join the fandom till fantasy era
this song just hits differently man.... ugh my heart ;;
God i never read the lyrics even tho I've been singing along to it for years why does it hit so hard
Crazy how I never really looked up the lyrics of older songs because I was already used to companies never putting up english subtitles. Now that I've seen them I love the song even more 😭
Holy shit!! 0:46 THAT WAS HONGBIN???? All this time I thought it was Ravi
whenever I listen to it, it breaks my heart. it has so many meaning to me. their tone of voice is so good that it makes me cry
I really need to learn VIXX.. And THIS SONG
I was really addicted to this song and listened to 10 times a day! I'm not a k-pop fan and for me it was the most favorite of Korean songs :D
Leo gets me eveytime