A Universe From Nothing, Therefore God Exists!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2016
- Join us at: www.inspiringphilosophy.org
To help support this ministry click here: www.patreon.com/inspiringphil...
Have you ever heard the claim Quantum Mechanics demonstrates the universe can come into existence from absolutely nothing? Well this is not entirely true and it in no way replaces the need for a designer.
Sources:
Lawrence Krauss - A Universe from Nothing
www.npr.org/2012/01/13/1451752...
blogs.scientificamerican.com/c...
www.nytimes.com/2012/03/25/boo...
www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/1...
William Lane Craig - • Quantum Physics Proves...
www.amazon.com/review/R20NRSZ6...
• A Thin Sheet of Realit...
• Rebooting The Cosmos: ...
• SSE Talks - Quantum Me...
• Seth Lloyd on "Quantum...
• From Einstein To Quant...
Max Planck - The Observer (January 25, 1931)
• Prof Anton Zeilinger s...
• Video
Robert Jastrow - God and the Astronomers, 1978 - Page 116
*If you are caught excessively commenting, insulting, or derailing then your comments will be removed. If you do not like it you can watch this video:
• For the Censorship Whi...
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D2 | Summer | ร่วมส่งแรงใจ เชียร์ไทยไปพร้อมกัน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dN2gLsCJ0T0/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you. My roommate was a PHD in physics at UCLA. We had this argument when I was in law school. I told him nothing literally means nothing. In fact, we can't really contemplate nothing.
It's a pickle, that's for sure. Use any word or idea to describe what nothing is, and you've failed at your objective, because that's something.
@@colinchesbrough5772 Easy, nothing is not anything, it is nonexistence. A absolute definition or if you want to get poetic about it; Nothing is what sleeping rocks dream of.
If something exists now then something has always existed. If at any time there was nothing nowhere there would still be nothing, only an Infinite timeless Being must exist.
@@MountainFisher I love how philosophically and logically sound that argument is.
Nothing doesn't exist. There is nothing.
@@MountainFisher writing this down
Aristotle's definition of nothing: That which rocks dream about when they are asleep.
They dream about those rocks in that desert that move wishing that they chould also
The pioneers used to ride those for miles
Perfect
Rocks Have No Soul Therefore They Cannot Dream. Only Souls Can Dream.
@@Dark_Force_Of_Wishes Then you will have to quibble with Aristotle about it.
"Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools".
Romans 1:22
@@PlakyI didn't make an argument.
the proof of God is everything you see now, the 3 dimensional observable universe is the proof of God existence, that there is the most powerful being who created this universe, God created the universe, so the universe is the witness of God's creation. Since we know logically using consciousness, since human have consciousness or awareness of its reality, our mind is connected to the nature, or we humans have ability, able to observe the universe and have access of the reality. Of course we have right to reason Things, and we know that the building cant be built without a builder, it's like our universe needs a creator to exist. Because it is more logical and reasonable that a builder who built the building rather than a tornadoes and hurricanes built the building like that.
Bible doesn't contradict science, the bible explain why the universe exists, science explain how,
Science doesn't disprove God existence, let's be honest here, for real, science actually don't know, what is outside of the 3 dimensional observable universes. Even sciencetist claims that it is still mystery to them,if you ask them what is the origin of the universe. honestly they don't know.
Noah's ark happened a thousands of years ago and there is archeological evidence that you can learn, go do some research of your own.
And God created the universe in six days and how do you know? The universe is not created in six days?
You know God is all powerful so he can do all he want to do.
And what else?
To support my claim that science doesn't disprove God.
www.google.com/amp/s/time.com/77676/why-science-does-not-disprove-god/%3famp=true
@@JuanEttermontaut everything you said makes no sense. I am not attacking you, nor am I attacking anything you might stand for, but hear me out: In Christianity you believe that some all powerful "God" created the universe, and you say the Bible tells us why, but not once does it actually say why this God created the universe, nor can any science or religion. The only logical conclusion I have to this question is that this celestial being created existence and the universe itself as some form of entertainment because it was bored, but even the thought that some celestial, all powerful being would bother to do this in the first place makes no sense whatsoever, why would this God make beings that would refute its own existence, and why would it create this allure of a "heaven" that we all have to follow its rules in order to go to, otherwise it's eternal damnation... For what purpose other than some sick form of entertainment would that ever be sought to create? Not to mention why this being single handedly created evil, yet swore that it is the enemy of itself, meanwhile it was this very same being that creates/created the evil in the first place. If you think about it, the Bible never specifically even says that the "devil" is inherently bad, only that it punishes those who are deserving of it, so with that in mind, God, who created all evil that exists, is less worthy of worship than the devil who punishes those who embrace it, not that I worship either. (I am not Christian nor anything else) In my humble opinion, the fact that the only reason people could be good to each other is purely based on a selfish desire to reach this fantastic "heaven" and we can't just be good because it's the right thing to do, means we have failed as a species. That would also entail that this God specifically made us selfish beings with no willingness to do anything without some sort of reward, and all of this is just for Its entertainment, and I will be the first to be good for the appeal of heaven, I will just be the best person I can because it's the right thing to do, and when I die one day, you Christians happen to be the correct ones, and I am offered entrance through the pearly gates, I will refuse in spite of this evil being that created us all just to cause suffering and pain for one another because of our selfishness. If you managed to read all of that, bravo sir, and this is just how I feel, so do with this information what you wish, I doubt I will get any notifications of any responses to this, so I most likely will not respond to anything further. Also anyone who claims to "know" or be right about how the universe was created, is extremely arrogant and undoubtedly wrong to me, since we are an incomprehensible amount of "time" after that and it is impossible for us to even begin to comprehend such things as mortals, and we shouldn't bother trying to explain things we cannot ourselves understand nor comprehend.
@@mr_wright_official_ can you please make a question clearly, that I will answer it, I am confused about your question. I am waiting for your response.
@@mr_wright_official_ Why God makes being that would refute of its own existence?
Well there is no being disprove God existence.
And first, your question is like, why would God, allow richard dawkins to exist, if he knows dawkins would be an atheist. Why God make people, if he knows they would rebel against him?. Well God didn't make people an atheist, God just know they would be an atheist , because they choose to be an atheist. And actually there is no being is good no one is good only God alone, we are all sinners. Even if you think that person is a good person, but actually its just like us, commit sins and have a mistakes too. Even If this world created only for good person, well still, there is no one is good, even if that is they still make a mistakes or a sin because we are only humans.
God can change their hearts and turn their stone heart to a flesh of heart again, that's why God give us a time, a chance to change to repent our sin and give your heart to God, soon christ will come to the world and defeat the evil and judge people of what they have done. God did not force us to do Good it's our choice whether if we obey him or not, The scriptures actually warn us that if we still keep sinning and disobeying God, someday in afterlife there will be something bad happen to us all.
But why? If you think why I already explain it, and you would be arguing in a circles.
And why would it create this allure of a "heaven" that we all have to follow of its rules, in order to go to? Otherwise it's eternal damnation.
God created heaven, his dwelling place, and place for his people who choose him and obey him. Because God is all good, he wanted his people to do good to obey him. God give us a law, The Ten Commandments. God gave us these laws as a guide for the good living of His people and as a check against evil, and it's up to you whether you obey it or not,
God did not send people to hell, because hell is the place for the people who wanted to be there. And it's your choice, it's our choice whether we choose God or not.
Why God create evil?
First what is evil? Well evil is an absence of Good, it's like darkness is the absence of lightness.
Well God did not create evil for evil, God created evil for good, God allowed for the possibility of so that we can genuinely have free will and choose whether or not we wanted to serve him. adam and eve created as innocent but they have ability whether they obey God or not but they don't have desire or purpose to do disobey God, but the serpent deceives them. That's why we know what is Good and evil. And why God create the tree of the knowledge? Well God wanted adam and eve to choose him and obey him.
God allowed the possibility of evil, but God did not create sin, if he had not allowed evil, we would worshipping him out is obligation, not by a choice by our own will. If God dont allowed possibility of evil, we are just a robot or a mechanism, that only do what is Good and without will or we can't do anything because we just programmed to do only right. God give angels free will to choose him or not, we have free will to choose whether to choose God or not,
God did not create sin.
"God created the possibility of evil by giving us free will."
Is God the Cause of the Evil and suffering?
Problem of evil?
God is not the cause of evil and suffering, since sin=death? The more humanity do sin, the more suffering and death happen. We know millions of children being rape, that is the work of man, Not the work of God, because Man sinned thats why children suffered, being rape and murdered.
Million of children died of cancer? Well let's define what is cancer?
is a disease that Cell have error, instead of destroying itself but turn into cancer cells and dividing faster than a normal cell and also destroy something that cause death. God allow suffering because of sin humans do. It's like this, Man sinned or mans work causing people to suffer like millions of polish, killed executed in germany on ww2, and that is the work of man,
Not the work of God. So God is not the cause of evil and suffering, humans is the cause of evil and suffering because of sin.
@@JuanEttermontaut Before God created the physical universe, there was a spirit universe. If you ignore the existence of the spirit universe, you take things out of context and obviously go wrong.
I ran into you for a reason from God. I was having the worst of times dealing with doubt and my faith in Jesus Christ. You have saved me, understanding that God is here with us all, may God continue to bless you with more wisdom❤️
i can tell you being enlightened, once enlightened you hit a realisation,, that there is NOTHING and GOD IS NOTHING.. but it isnt actually nothing.. for example GOD is love, love is nothing right,, but GOd is EVERYTHING.. in meditation once enlightneded and you go into the space to connect with \god source... it is in the spaceof nothingness without thinking in a state of nothingness and you connect wiht the source.. sounds mad to those that understand, but music without empty space it would just be noise it would not be music... the so called NOTHING we perceive in our REALITY, i.e the space... THERE IS SOOOOOO MUCH GOING ON, and it is ACTUALLY EVERYTHING and needed... but because we dont see it, we think its nothing like actually nothing... someone enlightened like buddha jesus ect... reconnected and myself, reconnects with the source which is GOD.... and the only real way i can esplain in words to non spoiritual people is.. the space like the space around us the nothing, has become something. so its as ifwe are all connected and EVERYTHHIGN IS ONE.. my body is j oined to the desk infront of me through this nothingness.... so the WHOLE UNIVERSE IS LIKE A HUGE CaNVAS painting, and the space is merely just a space in the painting but EVERYTHING and everyone is on this canvas together....
i know so much more, buy the book once released LOL you will seee it too i will open the whole worlds mind.. soon
SAGE TAN
@@GreatTaoSage
In the origin of all...
The Void, Maker of the Gods...
The Gods, Designer of Creation...
Creation, Evolution of Mortality...
Mortality, Chosen of Fate...
Fate, Harbinger of the End...
End, onto the Void...
Nothing in this reality was real to begin with, but only, for a time because everything rarely exists long enough to reach the World's End.
But being myself... I find clarity from what this video has shown. However, it only states what I already knew about. Being serious... I'm afraid mankind are not the ones to reach me.
In the end, my decision will be the fate of all. Once it is done, the Void will no longer exist, and all will have to exist without the origin. Even if it means that the Dead World arrives... A world which can no longer create itself.
Speaking honestly... I can never understand why you humans exist, and all of me never was a part of creation. My humanity stays on Earth as an equal to my true existence. Upon my mortal death, the key will return to me. Until then, this reality has all the time it can manifest.
Only in truth... I feel like an outsider observing the state of creation. Then again, I created the Book of Fate in my mind. May the Gods hold back the inevitable, and I hope this time around... Things will end differently.
"Free will", only until one can quantify the manifestations of reality and time, in order to predict the machinations of Fate, move by move. Thus, defying the tyranny of stars. Until then, will anyone understand the true meaning of "free will".
I personally believe in God but not in Jesus, a god becoming a man is just too pagan of a belief in all honestly.
@@Rotisiv jesus wasnt God.. Jesus was son of god..
🤷🏻♂️
@@Rotisiv God the Son(Jesus) has to become human so that he could physically be with us. Otherwise, God’s presence would have destroyed us because of our sin. The only way for humans to be saved was that Jesus had to die for us. He didn’t have to but He did it out of love. It’s almost the same concept as dying for your children.
Nothing is Nothing. It's not Something. If there is anything in the vacuum, then that is NOT NOTHING!
Dude is a delusional liar and multiverses are unobserved untestable blind Faith as well!
@@5tonyvvvv athiesm IS A RELIGION AND THEY ARE DELUSIONAL..
Darin Walker How do you know what nothing is?
WARNING: This nothing more than conman silliness looking for lifetime donations, an absolute nothingness creator will alway exist as an absolute nothingness creator, unless he has a magic ingredient in his form. But, a magic ingredient in his form eliminates him from a true form of absolute nothingness. So, this is Nothing More than conman begging tricks on nothingness words. Get A Job At Wal-Marts and stop conning the public!!!!
i agree, so a creator is absolute nothingness and a creator cannot exist except to steal your money. Amen
As an atheist/skeptic, this has been the best argument for the existence of a divine creator I have ever considered. However, there is a large distance from accepting the possibility of a creator-mind to accepting all dogmas of christianity.
Thank you, if you are interested, I have a sequel: th-cam.com/video/iFEBOGLjuq4/w-d-xo.html
@@InspiringPhilosophy Thank you for the reply. I've moved from being a christian, to an atheist, to a panpsychist and perhaps pantheist in that sense that I wouldn't say that everything is God, but rather that our consciousness comes from God, and is a part of God in us. I believe that we might have an immortal "soul" in that sense that the "soul" is our consciousness that will survive after our bodies die as it is a part of the divine (and then return to merge with the divine or possibly be reincarnated, while our ego/self/selfawareness will not (survive death). Is there a word for that?
@@informator5018 It sounds very similar to stoicism, which is something I was actually reading today. Also, Plato advocated for a form of reincarnation and the stoic philosophers built on Plato in a lot of ways. I would recommend reading Plato and the stoics. You might find something you like. Seneca is great, and I admit there is a lot of agreement they had with the early Christian thinkers.
@@InspiringPhilosophy Thank you! Great advice!
@@InspiringPhilosophy If you have a chance.. do you have a video or an answer to this observation... If the corollaries of the Cosmological Argument are that the first cause must be timeless, non-material, all powerful, etc.... How does one avoid the conclusion that we are all somehow a piece of God, like say the eastern religions teach?
One of the first things that led me back into Christianity was seeing other fellow atheists discussing the simulation theory as a possibility while dismissing the idea of God with utmost ferocity. This struck me as odd and hypocritical, so I went back into reading all the arguments for theism I avoided back when I became an Atheist, like reading "There Is a God" from Antony Flew, then C. S. Lewis and Chesterton books.
Praised be Our Lord Jesus Christ, for being so patient with people like me and taking me back.
When science becomes as mystical as religion....
Religion is truth , repent from your sins jesus is coming back,you don't get saved by works
@@Christine-og4ni two things
1.) Jesus*(forgot to capitalize)
2.) Yes, you are saved by faith alone, but faith with no works is dead
@@Christine-og4ni what if Hinduism Is the True relegion
@@inspirex1831 it's not
@@Christine-og4ni lmao
SO... These girls are accusing Krauss of harassment, but he says he did "Nothing"
Lol. "I did nothing --- but nothing is unstable and will always produce harassments and lawsuits."
Oh man this is funny irony. Haha
Lol
@Paul Schultz he just fluctuated, unstably with his ding a ling around females, in a situation just prior to his "big bang". Before anyone could be there to witness it
It's science, you can't take science to court. Cause........science bruh.
Multiverses would need an absolute beginning and a calibrated universe generating mechanism which would need a mechanism which would need a mechanism.. it's an infinite regress answers nothing!
After my girlfriend and father passed away while studying in Uni, I spent a lot of time thinking about life and the nature of reality - how can something come from nothing, is it really nothing, what is nothing? From whatever we have popped into our thought existence from, thank you. Hot wings and a garlic/blue cheese dipping sauce still taste pretty awesome!
No body says something came out of nothing
I wonder why christian theologians put words in athiest mouth and come up with an argument
To debunk it
Realistically nothing is close to impossible to archive
We dont know what was before the universe
All scientists are saying is that it may have come from nothing at least the reachable nothingness
hm mate and father huh? rip both of them i will conclude that i wont ask you if you loved her although if you did that be quantum physics good!
THANK YOU! This is one of my biggest pet peeves about the "nothingness is unstable" theory, and nobody seems to challenge it. I think it's a conceptual problem that prevents most people (physicists and cosmologists included) from understanding what "nothingness" is. It's actually impossible to truly conceptualize nothing without turning it into a "something" in your mind. If you ask most people (and I've asked a few) to imagine nothingness, they'll usually conjure up a vast, empty space. But that's not nothing. There's space and dimension there.... That's two things already. And where there's space, there has to be time as well... So now there's THREE "somethings" there. NOT nothing. It's impossible to visualize nothingness. There's nothing to see, and no vantage point from which to see it. And nothing can happen, because there's nothing there to get perturbed, or in an excited state, nor is there the requisite space and time for any action to take place. I sometimes find myself wishing to run into Lawrence Krause some day, so I can have a word with him about this.... and a couple of other things.
What did God do before the big bang?
The Big Bang was mot the beginning of the Universe...this Theists doesn't understand Ancient History or Cosmologyth-cam.com/video/pGKe6YzHiME/w-d-xo.html
@@rationalsceptic7634 no
@@rationalsceptic7634 well how do you not understand basic scientific consensus?
@@matthoward598
Maybe you should ask the absence of time itself!
Scientists: "The physical universe is just a hologram or projection of a larger reality."
Yes, the bible actually says that is the case. The larger reality is God.
Also scientists: "Nothing created everything, but these were the things that created it."
Scientists: -＞ a few scientists among millions of scientists presumed:
That’s only a few fools a lot of scientists are theists like us
You do realize that the only reason you believe that is because you’re considering every scientist in the world one single entity? Each scientist has their own beliefs and answers but you’re the one that is mixing them all up.
I don't know if God exists, but how did the primitive ape-men discover God and assume that he exists?
@@gerardocamachoacosta6413 human nature, we evolved with social instincts that led us to religion, when people feel like their prayers are answered it’s the same feeling as a mothers love. People mentally associate certain aspects of religious figures with things that make sense to them in order to make them more believable. That’s why god thought just like the people he was made by.
28 years ago I was reading a book by Stephen Hawkin. I was halfway the book where I read about how all that is in the universe is constructed from something science calls quarks which essence can best be described as "vibration". And then I came to Christ, and started to read the gospel of John "In the beginning was the WORD", can you imagine this really got my attention?
If God said be, I would not be surprised it the vibration of His voice created what "is". .......:)
@@aaliyahfurqan9445 Check out ZPE Plasma Cosmology by Barry Setterfield, in his model Barry actually attibutes a very profound development to God speaking
@@aaliyahfurqan9445 , even if one doesn't believe in the personal God of Christianiry or Judaism, what is nature? what are the laws of physics? "There is only one substance in the universe; it is God; and everything else that is, is in God", Spinoza. It is very naturalistic way of conceiving God for me as a Christian, I always think about Spinoza when I listen to people negating God but talking about "mother nature".
@@aidagalvez7883 But... Do not think of "everything being IN God" as everything being a PART of God.
The Bible is very clear that the universe is CREATED by God, and that God MAINTAINS creation every single micro second, therefore allegorically it is IN God in the sense that it only exists because of God.
But creation in itself is very distinct from God!
As a non religious person, i.e. I do not practice any religion, but I strongly agree that scientist do not know what God is or who God is, they want us to present the evidence of God when the fact is God himself is the Almighty pure form of Energy that created all the matter in the universe , in other words he is the master source of Energy, we can only give scientist proof of Energy, as long as we say God is energy, they cannot dismiss existence of God then if we say God = Energy + Consciousness. God and Energy are the same two sides of the same coin, God is the consciousness part of that coin as energy is the other side of that same coin, Energy and God (Consciousness) are related in such a way that as our science becomes more advanced, we have learned that some particles behave differently when being observed, so does that not point to a fact that particles created out of energy possess intelligence, (Consciousness) since they can see if they are being observed, so there is a connection between God who is the "Thought" or "Consciousness" and influenced the energy by his mere thought,
Surely God's word caused a small fluctuation in the sea of his Energy's quantum field, and process of creation started, it is time we Religious people updated our holy books to reflect our newly acquired knowledge now that we understand what quantum field is and how atoms behave, we would not have know this 2000 years ago, like a child of say 5, would he know that his penis is also important in reproduction as his only knowledge is limited to that is for pee pee, but as he grows older he self learns that it has other functions too, quite so important in terms of future of mankind,
So God created this universe from his energy, by his thought or word, (consciousness) that influenced the energy. His word doesn't have to be spoken, you can think of the word in your mind, that is what our conscious does, it does not have to be spoken, if we want to do anything before we do it, we think about what we want to do, we don't have to say it aloud, then we spring into action, using what we have at our disposal, we achieve our task, God thinks of a creation, he creates or forms materials and tools and laws of physics with his energy, and his thought or word is transformed into matter and creation of universe.
So say you only have energy, and want to make a house, you need ground, sand and cement and bricks, and glass windows and wooden doors, so the first thing you would need to do is to create a ground, on which you will build your house, then you will need the tools, so you will make iron that we can then form into tools, we will then dig the foundations, with our tool, then create sand and cement, and aggregates , and water, we mix all these ingredients and lat the concrete foundations, then we will need to create bricks from the soil from the ground, and make furnace and bake our bricks, yes we would also need the fuel for our furnace that cam come from trees, so we must have grown some trees and waited for them to mature for us to use its wood for making doors and fuel for the furnace, so whatever we need we have the main component and that is Energy, and this infinite energy of God is responsible for the entire creation, today scientist are actually doing us a favour because now we can better understand in more depth how God created atoms, and what goes on inside atoms, what are quarks and what not inside the protons, how higgs field effect mass of objects or matter, all these factors are indeed properties of Energy, who is God himself, his conscious commands his own energy to form universe and all things and life inside, so for us believers, science is not our enemy but our friend as we now better understand God and his complex universe, 2000 years ago, his messengers he sent could not have possibly explained to us what Higgs field is why it is there what it is responsible for, what are electrons, 2000 years ago we were not ready for this information, but today we are hungry for this knowledge and want to know God even better that we ever did.
APART FORM technical knowledge God sent his messengers to teach us how to live a life of a good human, what we should do and what we shouldn't and what is good for us and what isn't, so he laid rules for a moral honest living , He wanted to create life that could commune with God as he was all alone before, she wanted to create man so that he could talk to God, and God can hear us without ushering a word, such is the science behind our thought, like the tangled pair, we can communicate with God faster than speed of light from anywhere in the universe. As the time went by our understanding deepened, we can now see how it is all possible and although universe is gigantic, it is still small compared to our thought. and our thought can be mighty too, at a press of a red button we can now destroy this earth should we so desire. we can unleash vast amounts of deadly energy all at once and destroy earth and all life on it, that is why it is important we use our thought wisely.
You can never scientifically eliminate the possibility of a creator. It is just not possible.
LordKellthe1st
The proof of God is our existence. This universe nor life can exist without a creator.
What proof do you require LordKellthe1st...
LordKellthe1st
Ok. So you don't accept anything without scientific proof?
Without scientific proof, you cannot prove anything, always was that.
Strange, science never were pointy with evidence needed, just simple evidence
Yet no religious was ever able to give it for their god
Universe and life are evidence of universe and life only, nothing point to an intelligent need for those
We are here. How much more proof do you need?Sometimes we just choose to ignore what is right in front of us. For me, I have no doubt that there is a creator (God or otherwise). I am a scientist and as such I realize that we will NEVER know all the wonders that exist or will ever exist. For you, that is not the case and I am okay with that. I used to think the same way, but I came to realize that some things are just above our capacity to fully understand. There's room for all.
Sometimes these self proclaimed geniuses are so smart that they are crazy.
Crazy because normal people are unable to perceive such abstract ideas.
Atheists are self-proclaimed geniuses.
Philosophers actually are intelligent.
@@briancooley8777No they aren't. Most atheist's are no better than most religious fanatics they don't even understand themselves, what they believe in. That is clearly a sign of low intelligence. If your neither , well congrats. You are clearly awake and understand the world around you, not the world in some story or myth. "Geniuses are mostly the ones who go un-noticed" simply because their brain tries do things the easy way, so they don't try too hard, but not because they give up easy, it's purely because they know giving up is easy.
well, let's don't jump ahead here. There are 3 types of self proclaimed geniuses. 1)The ones who are really genius, they know the facts and did the math and they are sure they're intelligent. 2) The one's who want to be a genius, so pretend to be one. Smartness is self made, not born with like intelligence even though it may infleunce intellect, it's not the same thing and will never be close to the real deal. 3) Those who believe they are due to mental issues , like narcissism. They are just lying to themselves.
@@stevendiaz6590 i dont think it's a sign of low intelligence tbh
I’ve said this many times before but it’s always worth repeating.I know it’s not intentional but GOD is driving atheists nuts! With much love and peace, John.
they only think of god when they hear such crap you wrote.
The Big Bang was not the beginning of the Universe...this Theists doesn't understand Ancient History or Cosmologyth-cam.com/video/pGKe6YzHiME/w-d-xo.html
@@rationalsceptic7634
Cosmology is pseudo-science.
If a real scientist heared you , he would think that you are joking.
🤦
@Lorenzo Smit he's driving you to watch and reply. Why is that?
*"However despite this achievement in creativity...."*
LooooooL that was so well put together
Jason R Stanton you clearly have no comprehension of the Bible. But good on you for being creative with your auxesis
Bible says satan is the god of this world Jesus called him the ruler of this world and that he doesn't accuse you moses acuses you Jesus said no man has seen or heard from God before even went contrary to ot verses that weren't in love in acts 7 it says moses got the law from Angel's an angel who claimed to be God satan is an angel supposedly moses saw and spoke with God. Jesus says differently
R L what
@@rod8989
But Jesus is quoting the law of Moses as being true several times...
Moses even prophecied Jesus' coming...
And Jesus talked to Moses while He was on earth...
@@Ben-br1bu
Essentially it's all God's plan anyways for our betterment
Isaiah 45:7 I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things.
Isaiah 46:10 Declaring the end from the beginning, and from ancient times the things that are not yet done, saying, My counsel shall stand, and I will do all my pleasure:
Nothing can create nothing...but a creator can create something....Great video!
The universe is not created. We now know how galaxies form and it doesn't involve magic.
@@fraser_mr2009 What does how the galaxies form have to do with anything?
If we need a creator, then a creator would need one. That's an infinite regress. Supernovae forged the elements in our body.
@@mr.jazzbodkelsey58 That would be true if he wasn't God. God is not human. He goes by no rules as we do. He's outside the universe. He's everlasting. He's the Alpha and Omega. There are some things that humans will never understand. But God was never created.
@@RC-73 Well, that's a convenient description. The bible also said we were made in his image, did it not? We can't know everything I agree. But we know enough in 2023, to know the biblical account of the universe wasn't even close.
KJV Psalms 33
8 Let all the earth fear the LORD: let all the inhabitants of the world stand in awe of him.
9 For he spake, and it was done; he commanded, and it stood fast.
KJV psalms 83:18
He's talking about Steve Jobs.
IP as a man of science and religion you have helped me so much because I have always been on the edge of my seat in life.
I have always wanted proof for the soul and god , you have also have shown light upon evolution and its grand purpose in the universe
not to mention you have taught me so much about quantum mechanics and the need for consciousness in the universe.
I now see the purpose of the universe and how we fit in
its not that were just a bunch of mindless atoms that think there real
the real truth is that we are highly complex quantum computers with free will and a soul
as a person who struggles with faith at times , I've finally been able to put it to rest
I cannot thank you enough
~Papa Bless~ V N
0:18
Deep time is a construct of secularism in order to come up with an incomprehensible time so that authority could be taken from God.
Deep time has become an idol. 'Given enough time, we can produce anything.'
If we as the mighty humans we are cant figure God out....he must not exist damm it.....they are so silly and really need to accept Jesus. God bless them and i will be praying for them
It’s just straight up absurd. It’s like saying if given enough time and chance; a hurricane would fully assemble a Boeing 747 multi engine aircraft...
Like no. You could have infinite time and chances that shit won’t just happen coincidentally
Sounds like a slimy serpent to me. People need to realise that our lives are like smoke.
The other absurdity is thinking about what 13 billion years actually looks like.... I don't think people quite grasp the absurdity for example of what 65 million years would do onto the earth... you're telling me 65 million years will preserve me pristine fossils? That sedimentary layers will go hundreds of millions of years undisturbed to preserve organic material as well as minerals.. it's an unfathomable amount of time.. only serving the purpose to try and explain a world without the need of a creator.. it is lunacy.
We can't even properly preserve the fucking pyramids for a couple millenia.. we have no trace of anthropology past maybe 10,000 years... trying to explain complexity through an absurd amount of time is worthy of mockery in my opinion..
There is a scientific law that states the impossibility of a purely natural origin of the universe.. An actual scientific LAW.. the second of thermodynamics... how can you call yourself a scientists and believe in nothing creating shit and making it complex over billions of years.
It's mental gymnastics.. it's asinine.. it's clear anti science.
This one still gives me goosebumps man.
I love your videos! They are a great way for me to destress and be reminded of How Great Our God Is!
Thank you, and thanks for signing up to be a member!
@@InspiringPhilosophy Do you have a nothing to show that something can come from it?!
@@bonzaibrownie2853yes.
Life.
We a high percentage of people with cameras in their pockets, and no ones ever recorded it happening😊
God is fictional. He isn't real. Grow up
@@sexydudeuk2172 explain your premise. You have a burden of proof to meet.
Either everything came from nothing which is illogical
Or
Finite matter exists eternally which is also a contradiction.
Nothing comes from Nothing,
Nothing ever could......(Sound of Music)
Lawrence Krauss ~ "Nothing is unstable" haha I had to listen to that 3 times to be sure I heard it correctly.
WARNING: This nothing more than conman silliness looking for lifetime donations, an absolute nothingness creator will alway exist as an absolute nothingness creator, unless he has a magic ingredient in his form. But, a magic ingredient in his form eliminates him from a true form of absolute nothingness. So, this is Nothing More than conman begging tricks on nothingness words. Get A Job At Wal-Marts and stop conning the public!!!!
@@beammeupscotty3074 Calm... down...
@@KlaustheViking
Matter Transporter Department
Public Relation:
Unfortunately Scotty was beamed up , during a Solar Flare.
While the transporter procedure was a success, further investigation revealed chronic instability.
Scoty is under supervention, but at times he escapes custody and comments erratically on the Interned / Itranet
We apologies for the inconvenience.
If you do want to press charges please contact the Nearest Federation Office.
Yours Sincerely
Krix P.
Troll sub-manager !
krix pop Hero
@@beammeupscotty3074 Stop copy & pasting your trite, foolish, unintelligent, rants. No one cares.
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." - John 1:1
Dude whhat an hell only fool will believe creator becomes creation and comes to earth as jesus amd pooped peed like you and cry after running out of tissue paper ..christianity itself destroy jesus .creator can not he creation and creation can not be creator it means christianity got destroyed by this simple reality ...but jesus was a creation his some teaching is good not he jhon
Something creating itself is an absurdity. Never happened, never will.
Thank you for this, it was great. Philosophy is actually something I have only just begun reading and it's completely solidified my belief of a Creator. It's not that I didn't accept the existence of a Creator previously I'd say my belief in G-d wasn't as strong as it is now 😊
The Big Bang was mot the beginning of the Universe...this Theists doesn't understand Ancient History or Cosmologyth-cam.com/video/pGKe6YzHiME/w-d-xo.html
I, as well as many others, greatly appreciate you for making these videos... I believe God will bless you abundantly because you have touched many lives in the process. You're in my prayers brother. Thanks again!
Thank you! Heaven is the world of demons. Repent from your need to be religious.
You have to prove gods existence
PrimalScience Prove his inexistence
@@averygibson See I can say with the lack of evidence and errors within the religious books that I can confirm if a god does exist it's not there god. But a gods chance of existence is highly unlikely, why we'll cos with all the evidence we have, god is out of the picture. Science explains very well how the universe can and will come from a lack of something. If you believe in god then that's ok but to me, it's a lazy way of pretending to know how the universe was created. Religion has no bearing on truth whatsoever if it did it would have proved something by now they've been here for thousands of years and still not made correct assumptions. Thank science for this wonderful chat we are having right now that is possible by scientific studying and be able to crack technology for all us to use.
@@nylehaywood2471 "See I can say with the lack of evidence"
A lack of evidence doesn't prove somethings inexistence, it just means we lack evidence. You have to give evidence for somethings inexistence in order for it to be proven it doesn't exist.
"and errors within the religious books"
Errors are also an unreliable way to prove soemthing doesn't exist. Translation errors just mean something was translated poorly, or can't be translated properly with our modern language. If you are talking about inconsistencies, or contradictions, you'd have to name something specific from the bible.
"But a gods chance of existence is highly unlikely, why we'll cos with all the evidence we have, god is out of the picture."
What evidence?
"Science explains very well how the universe can and will come from a lack of something."
No, it doesn't. Science actually proves the exact opposite. It is scientifically impossible for something to come from nothing (a lack of something is nothing).
"If you believe in god then that's ok but to me, it's a lazy way of pretending to know how the universe was created."
This is a grand assumption. If someone has sound and logical reasoning to believe that something that begins to exist must be created, then there isn't anything lazy about it.
"Religion has no bearing on truth whatsoever if it did it would have proved something by now they've been here for thousands of years and still not made correct assumptions."
But if it were true that religion has no bearing on truth "whatsoever", religion would cease to exist. Every world view holds something true within it. Sedondly, how can you say they have not made any correct assumptions when the bible is leading the way scientists not only think about the world, but also test the world? The bible stated before it was proven that the earth floats in space, during this time, it was believed the earth was sitting on the back of a large animal or some sort of giant. It also tells us that the earth is round, during a time when many others believed it to be flat. The bible spoke about "paths in the sea", which inspired Matthew Maury to find these paths, which he did. He discovered that ships could travel faster using both ocean winds as well as currents, and it was all thanks to his curiosity and inspiration sprouted from his bible. But sure, religion has no truth to it, nor has it made any correct assumptions.
"Thank science for this wonderful chat we are having right now that is possible by scientific studying and be able to crack technology for all us to use."
We should also be thanking the divine being that gave us consciousness and logic to use during this discussion. Something science still has yet to explain the nature of its origin.
Something from nothing violates causality
Nope. We know from quantum mechanics that nothingness is unstable. If you were to remove all of the positive energy from a space, you have still have negative energy;moreover, quantum particles are popping in and out of existence all of the time, coming from nowhere. When you have nothing, you will still have something, because of the instability of nothingness. Nothingness produces. It sounds counter-intuitive, but that's what happens on the quantum scale.
Charles I'm not arguing with that theory, but as has been pointed out, the absolute nothing in philosophical terms describes nothing as no thing. Its not the same question in science since the two refer to two very different states, or non states respectively.
Which still makes me question why there are still videos like this comparing proverbial apples to non sequiturs.
hahaha "nothingness". NO, NO THING the absence of "any"THING.
This might seem like an absurd question but I generally want to know-how can "nothingness" be unstable if it is nothing... am I missing something? Does nothing have qualities ?
finding consciousness
Because nothingness is pseudo-science wrapped as science.
Psalms 33:9
"For He spoke, and it was; He commanded, and it stood."
Hu amar v'ayehy hu tsivah v'ayaamod-הוא אמר ויהי הוא ציווה ויעמוד.(Tehilim 33;9)
(תהילים 33;9-Lamed Gimel,Tet-ל"ג;ט)
Awww yes, the almighty man god
Who was running the universe, when God decided to become a baby?
Baby God? Oh
Very well put together! Insightful and direct! Oh, I also subscribed.
So true, in Sikhi it is also said "with one word all came into existence and expended, from there many streems started to flow". Yes, it is the information that created reality.
Are u a Sikhi?
@@Ivann1005I think he is a sikh
Pretty abvious the athiest commenting didn't watch the video
Gotta love how atheists posture like they’re these intellectuals when really they’re the least intelligent people we meet. They deliberately limit their worldview and reject all knowledge of God and the Bible, and don’t bother educating themselves much on the science they base their faith on, then have the gall to mock Christians. Jesus take the wheel 🙄
@@Triumvirate3 Prove it.
TZeusMusic Official
🙄
@@GameMaster-dt2ef man, do you expect him to send screenshots of everytime he saw an atheist being this way?
@@Triumvirate3 How is the Bible knowledge but to be fair to the Bible it allows you to beat your slave as much as you want as long as you kill the slave.
"Do they think they came from nothing? Or they think they created themselves?"
God asking Athiests in Quran 1400 years ago and this verse is absolutely valid in this time.
This beautiful, complex, dark and powerful universe has definitely a designer to sustain it otherwise we wouldn't be alive today on this planet Earth!
Hmmm proof?
@@ghassenboulares1479 Sorry, this is a theist space, and therefore a proof-free zone.
Sohan Dsouza You are so edgy!
MR. Ghv8en The proof? Just look around you and how perfect this universe is, and just think about consciousness.
Assalamuali kum brother ypu can watch hamza tzortiz video on youtube ' hey does God exist'
The close nothing we could get is the quantum vacuum, absolute nothingness does not exist and never happened, a state of absolute nothingness is an impossibility. Thats how simple it is
That means death cannot be absolute nothing either.
jeric jaime
Yeah, it’s not too crazy that “nothing” doesn’t exist, and that “nothing” doesn’t happen.
The only absolute nothingness is QUITE LITERALLY also absolute nothingness
this is great and on point. well done sir. PERFECT BREAKDOWN. in 100% agreement with you over here.
Oh! I remember a discussion between Prager und Shermer, where Shermer was hinting at this quantum fluctuation argument! At that time I thought he had the better argument, but man now I see the deceptive play on semantics! Man your channel is so eyeopening :D
These videos are awesome man. Time to rewatch and gather my thoughts
I'm a Muslim, and this was so interesting. I love learning more about the universe. The more I learn, the stronger my faith gets.
Same bro..i'm muslim n IP is one of the best yt channels for me..Guy is intellectually and epistemologically too based.
@@ademjrad9994 I’m happy you Muslims actually like a Christian scholar 😂
@@mattias640 Well in matters like these I don't really look at a person's religion. We are both theists at the end of the day so we both can present several arguments in favour of God. I've heard many good arguments from both, Muslims and Christians. :)
@Terre Schill Ah I've heard of that channel. I'll look into it and thank you for being respectful. Glad to hear that you've appreciated Muslim scholars too! :D
Also doubts are quite normal don't worry, and yeah science is a great way to appreciate God’s creation, but honestly sometimes it can all get a little too overwhelming. Sometimes you just need to step back, take a deep breath and ponder over the world around you and look into yourself as well. There's a great order in the way our world works. It's as if everything has perfectly been put together to support life, like how plants use inorganic substances to make food, which in turn benefits animals. These animals further benefit other animals in a food chain, and so on. Everything just screams purpose. It certainly couldn't have risen from blind natural forces.
God bless.
@@eepyru Well said. 🙂
YOUNG SCIENTISTS 🌱GODBLESS YOU ALL 🐟
Juan I believe many can relate to how you feel about this and it’s understandable. But I think your hatred is misplaced, you should at least try to understand the doctrine of hell first, I think getting that straight is best for you. m.th-cam.com/video/tiYf6ITgWbk/w-d-xo.html
Hell is not a place of fire. That's not in the bible.
Corey Davis (Luke 16:19-31)
@@ThetennisDr I don't know your life but unharden your heart,repent and reach out to Jesus I did and I found peace I didn't realize how much my hatred,lusts,etc had weighed me down don't let pride or your bad thoughts keep you from salvation God bless.❤❤
@@ThetennisDr what the heck dude
That ending was on point. Awesome video!
Amazing video. Very inspirational to see your point well illustrated and well substantiated by your various sources.
Excellent job! Great job breaking down a difficult topic.
"Pop out of nothing by the laws of quantum mechanics" What?? quantum Mechanics isn't nothing, its something, How do people believe their own lunacy, Its a Law, and their had to be something before a law can describe the constant, and Laws don't create anything its abstract like numbers, its already been proven that the universe Had a cause. (the expansion of the universe)
1) Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
2) The Universe began to exist.
3)Therefore, the Universe had a cause.
True for an example if you were to visit that realm outside the universe (the multiverse) you cant create anything in the universe with your mind because the laws of physics keep everything in it solid or set in stone but you could probably create a universe or anything you want outside the universe not only because of quantum mechanics but also because the laws of physics of our universe don't exist there so therefore nothing to prevent you from being god or creating or deleting anything as you wish even entire universes but it's all hypothetical I don't necessarily belive it but if it is true then to me it makes sense but that's just my opinion
So in other words it had to be quantum particles outside the universe or something, anything and no laws of physics in that realm.
@@matthewtuckman5827 but what made the multi verse exist? It will go back to infinite time
@@arijrauf3069 No proof of a multiverse, and that too also has to have find tuning.
@@airokun4551 exactly bro.
I love how scientist say...but our nothing means something🤣. I think they need to revisit the definition
I'm sick of hearing about quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics is something.
Agree. I surprised Krauss is not embarrassed for being so stupid. Then again, Krauss is all about deceit. It is clear to any thinking person who sees his ways. He's only convincing to those who want to be easily convinced that science backs up the universe could have started naturally.
Krauss actually took, space, matter, and time, called it nothing, and by some miracle, that was a natural miracle, it created more space, matter, and time. It clearly defies the laws of physics. Anyway, he's a dumbass leading dumbasses who fall for such nonsense.
www.nytimes.com/2012/03/25/books/review/a-universe-from-nothing-by-lawrence-m-krauss.html?_r=0
Cool vid. I will conclude that those people, who are humble in their understanding, whether they be faithful or skeptics are absolutely to be held in a higher regard, than those who think they know everything, or something with 100 percent certainty.
I actually deal in realist phenomenology(St. Edith Stein, Husserl) so I find the implications of consciousness on physics fascinating.
The fruit of knowledge of good and evil
How can nothing produce something if nothing doesn’t have anything to produce with because it’s nothing
"nothing" is a word that describes something, for which there is no space, time, etc.
its "nothing" just as a word, but in reality, its something.
they say nothing and make it sound retarded, if you ask me.
its not truly absolutely nothing, there is something. its deliberately misleading!
@@tanko.reactions176 no
@@tanko.reactions176 clearly didn't watch the video lol
They play semantics and redefine the definition of "nothing". That's what William Lane Craig is talking about in the video. It's a deception that allows them to fit their square peg into a round hole.
@@tanko.reactions176 then where did the something in the nothing came from?
I also use science when my bill collectors call me and ask for money. I say it's paid, therefore it's paid. They say "where the money coming from?" I say nothing..
I should have you know, good sir, that very rarely when I watch a video that I like do I thumb it up. I have to REALLY like it to do that. But after you brought up equivocation (my personal favorite of the logical fallacies), I had no choice. Here's a *like* for you sir.
Everything is so oviously designed, it amazes me that this isn't obvious to every scientist in the world
Why would God create blackholes?
It is because they have a philosophical presupposition that God and miracles don't exist. Therefore, every time evidence for intelligent design is discovered, they attribute it to something like random chance. I would argue that is an extremely obstinate position. Hopefully, they will come to Jesus soon.
"Professing to be wise, they became fools" - Romans 1:22 KJV
@@LilKevvYou heard of fine tuned universe? I don’t think that is just some random chance. It’s definitely perfected by an intelligent mind
@@deejaythedeejay I completely agree with you! This is all thanks to God!!
I thought Samuel Jackson made the strongest case.
“Atheism drops to 0%”
If there ever was "nothing" there was no god either, that isn't "nothing" but "something"
Great video, the best argument for something beyond the physical universe and something I've thought about a lot. Although as time is likely just a concept we made up it'd be better to leave that bit out of the argument.
Just caught your latest video love this one .Great work ...God Bless.
Lol
Lel it's not the same God he talks about in his video. It's not a bible god, not a Jesus. Jesus it's a imaginational character in jewish tales.
@@laniakeas92 noone is referring to a skydaddy god
Second Corinthians 4:17-18 “For this light momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison, as we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen. For the things that are seen are transient, but the things that are unseen are eternal.”
Im an atheist and my reasoning why the universe exists is this:
The universe was born because it died, and it died because it was born. Its and inifinite loop.
And to think that the Lord who created all of this made himself at home in the body of a man. The creator of the heavens became the most humble of men simply because he loves us. Praise the good Lord, in the name of the Father Son and Holy Spirit.
after i have started to look, what is more plausible, ihave really seen, that this simulation theory actually answers all the physical problems, which are threshold for materialism. There MUST be immaterial cause and the only immaterial cause, that can process information, is mind. as John.1:1 says :)
Spot on.
Lol
What about a computer? I mean we don't have any proven examples of immaterial minds either so why not?
Nucularburrito2 now you’re sounding like Lewis Wolpert
@@Nuclearburrit0 Hmm.. Its seems to me that if you postulate computer, you simply dont avoid the same problem. Computers are based on material which then processes information through electricity. Alexander Pruss comments in his article concerning cosmological argument and the infinite regress issue: "The solutions to the Glendower and Regress Problems tend to go hand in hand, and probably the best way to classify cosmological arguments is by how they address them. There are then three basic kinds of cosmological arguments: Kalaam, Thomistic and Leibnizian. The Kalaam and Thomistic arguments posit an intuitively plausible Causal Principle (CP) that says that every item of some sort, e.g., event, contingent being, instance of coming-into-existence, or movement, has a cause. The arguments then split depending on how they handle the Regress Problem. The Kalaam argument proceeds by arguing, on a priori or a posteriorigrounds, that the past is finite, and hence in fact no infinite regress occurred. The Thomistic argument, exemplified by Aquinas’ first three ways, does not rule out the possibility of an infinite past, but uses a variety of methods to argue against the hypothesis that there is an infinite regress of causes with no first cause. The most distinctive of these methods is an attempt to show that there is an intrinsic distinction between intermediate and non-intermediate causes, where an intermediate cause of E is an item C that is itself caused by something else to cause E, and that this distinction is such that intermediate causes are, of necessity, dependent for their causal activity on non-intermediate causes, which then end the regress.
Leibnizian arguments, on the other hand, invoke a very general explanatory principle, such as the PSR, which is then applied to the cosmos or to some vast cosmic state of affairs, or else a non-local CP that can be applied to an infinite chain or the universe as a whole. In the PSR-based versions, the Regress Problem is typically handled by showing that an infinite chain of causes with no first cause fails to explain why the whole chain is there. The main challenge for Leibnizian arguments here is to argue for an explanatory principle or CP that is (a) plausible, (b) applicable to the cosmic state of affairs in question, and (c) not so strong as to lead to implausible conclusions such as the denial of contingency or of free will. In this chapter, I shall defend several Leibnizian arguments.
The basic Leibnizian argument has the following steps:
(1) Every contingent fact has an explanation.
(2) There is a contingent fact that includes all other contingent facts.
(3) Therefore, there is an explanation of this fact.
(4) This explanation must involve a necessary being.
(5) This necessary being is God."
alexanderpruss.com/papers/LCA.html
I will concede that this stuff is WAY over my head lol
Prob the most intelligent comment in this section
@@jeffsingleton88 word!
Absolutely.
@@jeffsingleton88 I agree, the comments are full of delusional atheists
Spend an hour a day listening or reading and in a few years it won't be.
For the universe to begin . Someone outside hast to start it . Something can't be made from nothing . I present to you god .
How did god get there??
@@leogets2006 Psalm 90:2
That's the whole point.. God is timeless, spaceless, immaterial.. the source of all existence. Your argument depends on God being of the same essence as creation itself.. that's not the case.
@@sejason56 sounds like you have facts to back that claim buddy. Wanna share?
Yes, we are limited by our existing in this space time continuum or construct so it's
difficult to even express what I "saw" from the corner of my mind's eye for just an instant, but the implication remains clear.
Hey IP, I agree with your video, well done. Although I have a question, do you think space-time had a beggining as well ? Some now say that singularity theorems are false because they are only explained in classical physics and quantum mechanics proved them false .
Classical physics still implies a big bang, yes. That really doesn't change the fact since space-time is not in the quantum world and that had to begin.
Very interesting video. I've always thought that God or some power must exist, if nothing else for the logical impossibility that everything naturally came from nothing. This video really fleshes out that idea, and I feel like I'm going to have to watch this video a lot more to understand everything in it.
MoeTheMonk doesn't any God also have to deal with that same problem?
And if you are going to say he's exempt because he is eternal then let me remind you that energy is also eternal as per the first law of thermodynamics
@@Nuclearburrit0 So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
@@2fast2block na. It's a rebuttal to the idea that God doesn't need an explanation.
Notice how your explanation assumes that the creator is supernatural, that is to say it can't be explained by science.
But since science is just the study of the rules of reality, those rules must allow for everything that is possible. If God exists then the rules of reality must allow for a God to exist.
Keep in mind, the rules are derived from reality and not the other way around, so I'm not going to say something like "The rules of reality don't allow for beings able to create the universe thus God is false" the real implication would be "If there is a being able to create the universe than the rules of reality as we understand them are wrong or incomplete"
Anyways back on track.
Unlike physical laws which could have been different in a different universe.
The axioms of logic don't describe a particular universe but instead describe the rules of language. The reason why we can't say "Nothing Creates X" is because that statement is gibberish. However, when saying X created Y we can have recursion. The idea behind things like this video is to keep going back until the big bang and then arrive at God as the thing that eventually indirectly created everything else. However, that isn't the most logical explanation, since we can stop sooner at energy which ALSO wasn't created for the exact same reason.
Energy+Spacetime actually has all of the properties needed to create the universe as we know it.
For example Energy is omnipresent and eternal, everything action that can be done uses energy giving it a form of omnipotence and all data storage and information processing is done through physical means and since matter is energy that means all data exists in the form of energy making it omniscient in a sense.
Spacetime meanwhile is immaterial and capable of creating things spontaneously at random (look up virtual particles) ect ect ect
Both of these things were there at the time of the big bang and we have no proof that there weren't there before it.
@@Nuclearburrit0 energy is enternal?????? Uhhh excuse me have you ever heard of thermodynamic entropy!!!
@@domersgay28647 yes. The 2nd law of thermodynamics states that energy transformations always produce unusable heat energy as a byproduct.
That doesn't change the fact that the energy is still eternal as per the 1st law of thermodynamics which states that energy can neither be created nor destroyed, only altered.
Mankind had a difficult time understanding a Being (God) who has no beginning or end because we humans (our flesh) have a beginning and an end. Thank you for all of your amazing, much needed videos ❤
I found it helpful to look backward instead of forward and that was when I realised ... if indeed there always was nothing then nothing is what there would be now and always would be.
This, at last, helped me "see" - only peripherally and fleetingly - with my mind's eye what absolute nothing would be and would imply!
Not really. We tend to think that nothingness is the default state of reality, unless something happens to it -but this is fundamentally false. The thing is, if nothing has no logical laws to define or constrain it(and it shouldn't have, or else it wouldn't be nothing) then there is literally nothing to keep it from spontaneously turning into something. The nature of nothingness is inherently paradoxical. It's true that according to the laws of logic everything must have a cause, and something can't arise out of nothing. But remove these laws, and anything is possible. If laws of logic only work on things that already exist, and that once something exists it's bound by logical laws, you can't prove that nothingness itself is bound by any such laws. Actually, by definition, it's not.
The laws of quantum mechanics by which the Universe came into existence is NOT nothing.
where'd the laws come from?
gustavo pena the laws aren't a thing. That's like asking 'what is the speed of love?'
nunya bisnass so your telling me there nothing?
gustavo pena where is nothing? I don't understand your question?
Nobody says the laws are material, and yet they had to exist at least ontologically prior to the Universe being formed.
Yeah I came to the same conclusion in my own study of physics. And the arrow always points back to a concious creator even if, in my opinion this conciousness would fragment itself and in doing so create another perspective. This in effect would continue exponentially, until which a point that a majority of the fragments understood what they were and are. Science, religion, philisophy, and math are the 4 fundamental concious pursuits to rediscovering your own creationist nature. namaste brethren
Whoa. That’s really cool! Were you majoring for a degree in physics? Or just studying?
It's great that you do physics, but like many physicists I'm afraid you are lacking a solid founding in philosophy and theology. God is ultimately simple, fully unified, all is one in God. Something that is ultimately simple cannot break into parts. We are not a part of God, because God has no parts. We stand as a dependent creation that only exists within God's Intellect. All of creation is indeed made in the image of God and everything is just a fragment of His wholeness, however it's more like you thinking of yourself in parts than actual parts.
No-thing implies Some-thing, they’re inseparable, like Positive and Negative; you cannot have the one without the other. It’s energy on the wave up (something) vs the wave down (nothing), this now looks like a wave, vibration- sound (the word) of “God”.
I have heard atheists dismiss this argument by stating ‘there’s no such thing as nothing’.
1st: that is a statement of philosophical belief, not scientific fact, because the scientific method could never search for ‘nothingness’.
2nd: that raises more questions about matter, because if matter has ‘always existed’ then there must be self creating matter, otherwise there is no reason for it to exist. It’s like asking a child where his toys came from and the child responding ‘they were always here, otherwise I couldn’t have played with them - they just existed and must have always done’. It answers nothing about true origins, it’s just another way of saying ‘the universe is god’.
Let's not be too hard on krauss, just imagine being in his shoes, that's a difficult situation for him.
He hasn't thought this thru.
In support of what Krauss said about Nothing....well, uhm,....sorry, I got Nothing.
I 100% agree with you that quantum fluctuations require a vacuum and the vacuum requires space. If the fluctuations are physical phenomena in the vacuum then they have to exist in space, or else they would have to be space less, and if they are space less, then they would have to be immaterial since material things require space to exist.
Just because we can’t explain something doesn’t mean we can insert god into the picture. Furthermore the stretch from a conscious creator to the Christian god is such a large leap.
Makes perfect sense. Thoughts are things
I have made some short notes through the videos as it is very well put-together. Keep up the good work!
-- Your Muslim Brother
I love Muslims but you gotta know that Jesus is Lord!!!!! He is the only way! You gotta KNOW. peace brother
@@briancooley8777 dont get offended your religion IS *YOUR**RELIGION*
*MY**RELIGION*IS* *ME*
@@briancooley8777 so you is you me is me choose what you want and same as iam
@@briancooley8777 because i choose islam and you are different and that is the nature of our reality
@@briancooley8777 also did you know that jesus was actually Allah messenger which is An actual One And only God That Actually Exists
And that is islam my dude get outta here before ww3 happens
God bless y’all... Seriously. I was going through some doubt and suddenly, y’all appeared.
That was really good. I have just started learning about quantum physics and reality itself. This strengthens your faith more than anything- the complicated life we live.
Jonathan S. Do you have a nothing to show that something can come from it?!
@@bonzaibrownie2853 do you have an argument that is not illogical?! No! You pop atheists, y’all really think you’re cute 😪
@@jonathans.219 Saying that the universe came from nothing which is saying that it's something is a very poor argument. Again, do you have a nothing to show that something can come from it?! My argument is about thinking rational. Your argument is illogical because you still didn't answer my question.
@@jonathans.219 Y'all?! You must be from the south because I live in the south, too.
@@bonzaibrownie2853 you are stating that nothing (no space, time, matter, physical laws, energy, etc.) can create an explosion? And, to go further, can create vastly complex structures? Also, your question is actually helping me 💀, because you proved my point- you can’t do it either. You can’t do it because it is impossible. If it were true that something began to exist without a cause, then why don’t we see that happening all of the time!? Lol, I don’t live in the South, just like using slang haha. I’m in the heartland.
The bigger question would be "what is the engine that is driving the dynamics."
Even as a Muslim who believes in God too, I was happy this video came out to kill the confusions that so-called scientist caused the young generation of believers in their hearts. Thanks bro for the explanations. Certainly, Nothing(the real nothing) can't and will never create nor produce anything. May God bless us all
I know,after talking to atheist online for a while,they can be some of the most hard hearted people and will continue to deny the overwhelming evidence for God. Though is it okay we have a friendly debate?
I am curious on which god you think fills that gap 😂😂 i want you 2 to agree on it
@@Alejandro-tm8eq overwhelming evidence
you do realise this whole video is pointless the whole universe out of nothing argument is made by very few scientists and non of them consider it factual
His definition of nothing is impossible to even reach the evidence we have never say before the big bang there was nothing no scientist is even saying that
The big bang is what sparked the universe as we know it
The evidence state at no time was there ever nothing quantum physics doesnt go by the rules of natural physics quantum energy doesnt deteriorate that on its on says it doesn't need to be caused or pushed into existence
Muslims are funny they are super excited when they see videos like these , bro they are not talking about your god who is sitting above a throne with eight angeles holding him .
@@toucheyes9248 The creator of this video is Christian lmao
I once watched a video (I don’t remember what it was about) claiming that before the big bang was another universe that collapsed on itself, and that universe was created by a big bang, and so on and so forth, and I just wondered how anyone could claim that
"...despite this achievement in creativity..." what an epic line, a quiet but powerful slam against their argument. How can Nothing be unstable if there is nothing there to be unstable?? Instability (as it at least seems to me) implies the presence of something unstable; without the presence of Something, how could Nothing be unstable? But then Nothing would not be Nothing, if Something was there. You can't really apply such a physical description relating to physical matter as "unstable" to the literal and resolute Absence of Anything, there is nothing within Nothing that can be unstable
It seems evident to me that Mr. Krauss don't know nothing!
He is just another speculator.
Thank you so much for all your work. I am trying to witness to a pretty hard core atheist and this has helped me immensely. May God bless you for everything you do
Give up, they'll be clever than you and will statistically know more about your religion than you do.
Oh ffs, leave that poor person alone.
@@Yamyatos but I love them!!!
@@SE-kd5lo Pretty sure you are just annoying them. Imagine you had a muslim friend and he was constantly just trying to talk you into converting. Imagine this friend instead tried to wittness you into believing in the tooth fairy. To you these sound ridiculous. To me, and your atheist (presumably) friend, it's the same.
@@Yamyatosoh I don't constantly rag on them every time I see them. It's like an 85/15 split. I know that ultimately it's up to God to change their heart, but I definitely want to be able to logically answer their comments when they say something invalid about the reality of our world or the bible. Why would I let them be misinformed? That just seems mean. It's nice you care about their mental well-being though. I appreciate that.
'Word' coud be vibration; fluctuation. (A word IS vibration, sound is vibration. Sound breaks glass, for instance)
a 'Word' is modulated sound, modulated for specific causes. Effects follow.
Everything is Energy: thought an Feeling! Thought is focus and Feeling is the Energy! This is one of many dimensions..
God Bless you. please stay revealing this kind of information. you are saving souls. HalleluYAH no one can toss our God man!!! HE IS EVERYTHING. WITHOUT HIM WAS NOT ANYTHING MADE THAT WAS MADE. AMEN
In the beginning, was the word ( information) and the word ( information) was GOD.
Edit: haha I wrote this 8 mins in, it just makes so much sense! God actually revealed this to me a few years ago,glad to see educated people confirming it to me. 😌
I've been thinking about this for a while. I've had phases of doubts and stuff and I just realized that no matter what physics or science phenomenon you think happened, nothing makes nothing. Something coming out of absolutely nothing sounds crazy to me.
Wow!! This is likely among the top 5 videos I have ever seen!!
To explain how the Universe works it would be similar to teach a stone how computers work, for instance, even though computer's chips are made from stone's material....
So let's not forget about other dimensions where energy flows guided by Infinite Intelligence, where "where" is not that important, time is only illusion, and "the game" starts and ends in a mystery...
Adonai
The game 😧
It's kinda inspirational...that even Nothing can make something of Itself
With every one of your videos that I watch, I am more amazed. Thank you, IP. Thank you.
When is your book coming out?
Thanks a lot guys, I love you
Good video. I may have to re watch it....a lot to unpack.
if “nothing” is unstable and will produce “something”, then its not “nothing”, we just dont understand it yet.
This was so amazing and like even though I didn't really understand!
Nothing is a lack of variation at every scale.
The universe, like life, exists in a stream of energy.
Where did the energy come from?